I think the lesson hear is that we should never discredit any idol for lipsyncing. Almost all idols do lipsync which is a sad reality for this gen of kpop especially when the past generation really worked hard to maintain a stable voice completely live while dancing
Well, the whole idol thing has become more hectic, so packed schedules and demanding dances is more than likely to decrease your will to sing live. It's nice when they sing live but it's also okay when they lip-sync.
this channel is great! whenever i try to tell someone that a group is lip-synching cause they have identical sounding performances, they just stamp the hater label on me. Thanks for the upload
Ryan Ryan we all know twice is not good at live singing... I did hear their mr removed and pre recorded removed video.. still not that good... they used a lot of prerecorded audio for their live during this comeback
All these comments on twice's vocal, MR etc. while me, a devoted-yet-too-lazy-to-give-a-shit-Once is just enjoying Twice's performance. honestly, everybody knows Twice aren't *perfect* singers but they are improving a lot so imma save my energy from reacting to Thrice's comments and just enjoy their stages lol
I wonder why people care about lipsync.. What is wrong with lipsyncing? Aren't idols human too? Do you guys expect them to sing live every performances? TWICE have a very tight schedule what do you still expect? I saw many comments asking them whether they are lipsyncing. Guys jus enjoy what TWICE performs!! I know it's sad that TWICE don't show their real ability in performances but in the future, i hope they will! Sorry for my bad english.. Don't judge
It’s fine but I feel like the reason why other people hates them for lipsynching is because they got popular like so much fast compared to the other group but their abilities are not the best. They think it’s kinda unfair.
Why would you compare this when you could rather compare the mr removed from both stages. Of course it’s going to sound the same with Mr still there like seriously 😂
Because I'm not 100% familiar with the process to make MR-removed, and I was not permitted to use MR-removed audios from other channels. You, however, are free to do so if you're not convinced enough.
it is normal when they lipsync during dance...it is impossible to sing perfectly when u r dancing...that is why when they perform on radio they can sing perfectly because at that time there is no dance...
As a blink, ive seen once attacking blackpink for having bad mr removed vids just because there bias group, twice, started to have good mr removed videos. I wont deny that twice has had a fair amount, if not more, of hate towards them regarding there mr removed videos especially at the start of their career. The lesson here is to never degrade or compare a group to another. I hope that all stans of a group who continuously degrade another group just because there bias group has better mr removed videos would actually see these types of videos of their bias groups so that they may be able to open their eyes and stop spreading hate on other groups. :)
because in MR removed, you can still hear the pre recorded and I think that's what makes them think their idol is singing live. My girl group were being praised for singing live during their stage. and i always watch their mr removed videos and yes, they were really singing live. you can actually hear their real voice during their performance because the back track isn't loud. But with their latest comebacks, they were now using the pre recorded. Some fans think they sang live on that performance but actually they were not. You can differentiate actually if an idol is singing live or not, if their using pre recorded or not. You just not be bias.
Duhhh they use pre recorded vocals here so you hear the sound are identical all kpop uses pre recorded for some reasons like: Rest their vocals, Tiredness,and etcc.
It's not about the back tracks. I made another video comparing two live performances of Like Ooh-ahh and there are a lot audible differences, even though it's not MR-removed.
LMAO firstly to all the people talking about this, this is not MR removed. Of course it’s gonna sound the same😂 And the fact that they took two specific concerts is not fishy at all? They probably lip sync sometimes and don’t other times. They have had 5, close to 6 (candy pop in Jan) comebacks. They are literally the MOST POPULAR girl group right now. Just the truth. Why would you think that for music performances, they don’t need MR? EVERYONE wants them on their music shows. To fit them like sardines in the schedule, they have to give their voice a break sometimes. SIMPLE.
Uhm, what's fishy about it? They use the exact same live MR track for most of their performances during their promotion period, and it'd be a drag to make a comparison for every lip-synced performance. I agree, tho: they don't always have to sing live, and I really hope they can get a rest.
dallak93 erm what I was saying that it makes sense that when they use live MR, it’s the same track so they don’t have to do it over and over again. I was saying that this is only the comparison of two performances, so people shouldn’t use this as a reference to say “ twice ALWAYS lipsyncs and stuff like that.
![TWICE - Strategy (With.이영지) [더 시즌즈-이영지의 레인보우] | KBS 241206 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/f4VCRBWNvms/mqdefault.jpg)
![[DRAGON BALL LEGENDS REVEALS ＆ STUFF] LEGENDS FESTIVAL 2024 Special Edition Part 2](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/af0phKxitX8/mqdefault.jpg)
![A 15-Year Friendship Turns into a Threat Strategy 🤬 | Nayeon VS Jeongyeon [TrickKODE]](/img/1.gif)
I think the lesson hear is that we should never discredit any idol for lipsyncing. Almost all idols do lipsync which is a sad reality for this gen of kpop especially when the past generation really worked hard to maintain a stable voice completely live while dancing
Well, the whole idol thing has become more hectic, so packed schedules and demanding dances is more than likely to decrease your will to sing live. It's nice when they sing live but it's also okay when they lip-sync.
this channel is great! whenever i try to tell someone that a group is lip-synching cause they have identical sounding performances, they just stamp the hater label on me. Thanks for the upload
Ryan Ryan we all know twice is not good at live singing... I did hear their mr removed and pre recorded removed video.. still not that good... they used a lot of prerecorded audio for their live during this comeback
Maksim Li why are you replying to me??? Did you think that I would agree with you? Cause I don’t 😕
I'm glad you found this video helpful! Thanks for watching.
All these comments on twice's vocal, MR etc. while me, a devoted-yet-too-lazy-to-give-a-shit-Once is just enjoying Twice's performance.
honestly, everybody knows Twice aren't *perfect* singers but they are improving a lot so imma save my energy from reacting to Thrice's comments and just enjoy their stages lol
I'm so happy to find a comment like this…
Am i the only one who can hear the difference between these two?
Al Naza there are really small differences if you hear carefully it does not exactly sound the same
Yah timing.... -_-
Yep, there are parts that sounds different but the most of the song sound the same.
I wonder why people care about lipsync.. What is wrong with lipsyncing? Aren't idols human too? Do you guys expect them to sing live every performances? TWICE have a very tight schedule what do you still expect? I saw many comments asking them whether they are lipsyncing. Guys jus enjoy what TWICE performs!! I know it's sad that TWICE don't show their real ability in performances but in the future, i hope they will! Sorry for my bad english.. Don't judge
That's terrible :(
I think it is because they are idols. And also I think people never seen an idol sick as often as Sana
It’s fine but I feel like the reason why other people hates them for lipsynching is because they got popular like so much fast compared to the other group but their abilities are not the best. They think it’s kinda unfair.
Because theyre idols and their jobs to sing and dance but theyre failing at live singing (not all the time)
Why would you compare this when you could rather compare the mr removed from both stages. Of course it’s going to sound the same with Mr still there like seriously 😂
Because I'm not 100% familiar with the process to make MR-removed, and I was not permitted to use MR-removed audios from other channels. You, however, are free to do so if you're not convinced enough.
it is normal when they lipsync during dance...it is impossible to sing perfectly when u r dancing...that is why when they perform on radio they can sing perfectly because at that time there is no dance...
That's true!
2nd gen kpop: what? cant hear you
As a blink, ive seen once attacking blackpink for having bad mr removed vids just because there bias group, twice, started to have good mr removed videos. I wont deny that twice has had a fair amount, if not more, of hate towards them regarding there mr removed videos especially at the start of their career. The lesson here is to never degrade or compare a group to another. I hope that all stans of a group who continuously degrade another group just because there bias group has better mr removed videos would actually see these types of videos of their bias groups so that they may be able to open their eyes and stop spreading hate on other groups. :)
People fighting over MR-removed videos is old news. They're not even reliable, so don't get stressed over that. ;)
Thank you for watching btw!
because in MR removed, you can still hear the pre recorded and I think that's what makes them think their idol is singing live. My girl group were being praised for singing live during their stage. and i always watch their mr removed videos and yes, they were really singing live. you can actually hear their real voice during their performance because the back track isn't loud. But with their latest comebacks, they were now using the pre recorded. Some fans think they sang live on that performance but actually they were not. You can differentiate actually if an idol is singing live or not, if their using pre recorded or not. You just not be bias.
Duhhh they use pre recorded vocals here so you hear the sound are identical all kpop uses pre recorded for some reasons like: Rest their vocals, Tiredness,and etcc.
They lip-sync most of the time so it would be hard for those that don’t know how to differentiate between real and lip-sync
This is live AR :((
Thanks Ill slap this to my fellow Once who label me a "hater" for telling the truth 😒
jungyeon always wears long sleeves in likey
0:56
강민혜 Lol I tried doing the things they did with their mouths that looked like lip-syncing and I could still do it
I wish that this is mr removed but it is not... if they use back tracks it would literally sound the same.
It's not about the back tracks. I made another video comparing two live performances of Like Ooh-ahh and there are a lot audible differences, even though it's not MR-removed.
Please do Gfriend summer rain (music bank and mcountdown)
They lipsynced or not?
Lipsync😣😣
Andrei Estabillo nope
Zarif Wahid I hope so. In this performance. I can't hear their voice .
Zarif Wahid stulid fan open your eyes
xangelsedits I tried doing my mouth moments like them and I still did the notes perfectly.
Okay
0:50
1:09
LMAO firstly to all the people talking about this, this is not MR removed. Of course it’s gonna sound the same😂
And the fact that they took two specific concerts is not fishy at all? They probably lip sync sometimes and don’t other times. They have had 5, close to 6 (candy pop in Jan) comebacks. They are literally the MOST POPULAR girl group right now. Just the truth. Why would you think that for music performances, they don’t need MR? EVERYONE wants them on their music shows. To fit them like sardines in the schedule, they have to give their voice a break sometimes. SIMPLE.
Uhm, what's fishy about it? They use the exact same live MR track for most of their performances during their promotion period, and it'd be a drag to make a comparison for every lip-synced performance.
I agree, tho: they don't always have to sing live, and I really hope they can get a rest.
dallak93 1. Doesn’t really make sense for them to record different live MRs esp. since they’re so busy🤣
2. Glad you think so too😁
So if they're busy, doesn't it make sense that they use the same pre-recorded track?
dallak93 erm what I was saying that it makes sense that when they use live MR, it’s the same track so they don’t have to do it over and over again. I was saying that this is only the comparison of two performances, so people shouldn’t use this as a reference to say “ twice ALWAYS lipsyncs and stuff like that.
No, they should not. That's why I also made a video on them actually singing+dancing live, so people don't really get carried away.
They lipsync but they still cute
0:54
1:27
1:16