Jennie and Giselle, the main rapper, should match, while Lisa and Karina, the main dancers, should match. Rosé - Ningning (main vocalist) Jisoo - Winter (visual, lead vocalist) Jennie - Giselle (main rapper) Lisa - Karina (main dancer, lead rapper)
i think only jisoo stans are saying that it is a good line distribution... *As for me* it's not based on the abilities of members, but simply on how the voice fits. (I'm not saying that they are talentless)
*line distributions are based on who can sing that part the best (assuming). in this case, jisoo's vocal colour would have gone well if this were truly a bp song*
@@shemawarsini10-g6this comment is not about their position thou, and No Offense but Rosé is the only member who can do that HN & maybe that long HN since she has the highest vocal range among all of them. I know Jisoo can do a HN but she strain when hitting a HN and doesn't have good support (watch the CLARITY) and these HN's is not her range. I love Jisoo so much she's my Bias Wrecker, but let's be real she can't do that HN.. sorry for my bad english btw....
@@Mikha_My_Bae Jisoo for easy can do hn, just watch her encore cam from lovesick girls and in clarity she did really well with notes. It’s so annoying to read she is bias and etc and after that reading that she did smth bad
@@s1tal1k she really can’t. The high notes she did in clarity were easy, even I can do them. And plus, her voice cracked when performing clarity. Those ningning high notes would be too hard for her and she would probably strain it a lot. Rosé is the one who is most likely to pull of those notes.
This distribution is so biased towards jisoo lmao 0:33 to 0:45 jisoo 0:46 to 0:58 rosé 2:08 jisoo 2:14 rosé 2:55 jisoo 3:02 rosé *based on their skills,vocal range not just in position*🤦♀️😬
In my opinion, Rose would be NingNing and Jisoo is winter. I'm not trying to discredit jisoo by saying she cant hit NingNings high notes it just seems better. Rosè isn't in NingNings really high notes range but she can hit them better with her vocals... I'm not saying Jisoo cant even hit her high notes but Rosè is a main vocalist after all so I dont think it would be thrown in garbage. Plus Winter has high notes too so I'm not really discrediting Jisoo. Just my opinion
I love this cover but karina is the main dancer and lisa ,so whay you give karina to jennie and gizelle for lisa gizelle is the main rapper so is jennie
Jisoo...And that many lines...And raps...Are you joking...Yg will never gonna do that...Probably they will give her more line...But she really did not fit in this type of line distribution...Just my opinion...
Jisoo can't hit this high notes.....she so talented, but she sings worse than Jennie.I would put almost everything between Rosé and Jisoo the other way around
Blackpink is beautiful in every songs 💖
If only YG had done such line distribution for blackpink.....Jisoo always gets justice in other songs!!
If only YG had done such line distribution for blakpink........Jisoo always gets justice in other songs!!
Jisoo is Ning ning
Jennie is Karina
Rosé is Winter
Lisa is Giselle
Incorrect
Jennie and Giselle, the main rapper, should match, while Lisa and Karina, the main dancers, should match.
Rosé - Ningning (main vocalist)
Jisoo - Winter (visual, lead vocalist)
Jennie - Giselle (main rapper)
Lisa - Karina (main dancer, lead rapper)
Yes
@@queenlalisa7666 it’s not about position matching, it’s about voices
It's should be Jennie - Giselle
Jisoo - Winter.
Rosé - Ning ning
Lisa - Karina
Rose - winter
Jisoo - ningning
Lisa - Karina/giselle
Jennie - Giselle /karina
Rosé is Karina and Winter cause she got a Karina line here at 2:07 and at Jisoo is giselle and ningning cause she even got giselle rap at 1:48
Aespa Bias: Ningning And Giselle
Blackpink Bias: Jisoo And Rosé
I love rose and winter😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
3:42 Jisoo’s timer is bugged
verdade,pq na hora que ela cantou,o cronômetro parou
I like this song 🖤💜💕
0:39 them parts Rose and Jisoo switch
Rosé and winter 💙💙
They are both my biases
i think only jisoo stans are saying that it is a good line distribution... *As for me* it's not based on the abilities of members, but simply on how the voice fits. (I'm not saying that they are talentless)
Jisoo as Ningning
Rose as Winter
Jennie as Giselle
Lisa as Karina
LISA
perfect line distribution YG should let the girls have sometimes
Amazing 🔥🔥🔥🔥🦋
I think you forgot that Jennie is a lead vocal !! And this part 2:08 IS for Jennie !!
vddd
3:44 Jisoo timer have a bug
At 0:33 rose said nom Jom and when rose said it together it spells namjoonie
Why are you making Jisoo seem more of the main vocalist by giving her the harder parts then Rosé?
aaaaa,toda as partes que a jisso cantou,combinaram com a voz dela
*line distributions are based on who can sing that part the best (assuming). in this case, jisoo's vocal colour would have gone well if this were truly a bp song*
You just have to be careful in some parts as they are more high and Jisoo can do them but not as well as Rosé
Jisoo could be a Main Vocalist, but not in Blackpink, maybe in Le Sserafim or Momoland
Bruh do you even know what this video is about?
0: 36 is like roseì voice wow
0: 36 is like roses voice wow 💜💜💜
Giselle and Lisa
Jisoo and winter 😍
Winter is rose
I love this song 🎵
jennie kim , winter , karina , giselle, lalisa manoban , park chaeyoung , ningning , kim jisoo❤❤
Lmaoo why you gave high notes to jisoo when those are for rosé no hate but it's true, jisoo should have gotten lots of lines but not those high notes
Girl even jisoo can sing those high notes
Not all the high notes are supposed for main vocalist
Btw I'm ot4 sorry If I sounded rude
@@shemawarsini10-g6this comment is not about their position thou, and No Offense but Rosé is the only member who can do that HN & maybe that long HN since she has the highest vocal range among all of them. I know Jisoo can do a HN but she strain when hitting a HN and doesn't have good support (watch the CLARITY) and these HN's is not her range.
I love Jisoo so much she's my Bias Wrecker, but let's be real she can't do that HN.. sorry for my bad english btw....
@@Mikha_My_Bae Jisoo for easy can do hn, just watch her encore cam from lovesick girls and in clarity she did really well with notes. It’s so annoying to read she is bias and etc and after that reading that she did smth bad
I don't think Rosé can do the ningning high notes.
@@s1tal1k she really can’t. The high notes she did in clarity were easy, even I can do them. And plus, her voice cracked when performing clarity. Those ningning high notes would be too hard for her and she would probably strain it a lot. Rosé is the one who is most likely to pull of those notes.
Help- i read the title as SAUSAGE 😩✋
My bias : Rosé and Winter 😍
My bias :Rose and Winter 😍
This distribution is so biased towards jisoo lmao
0:33 to 0:45 jisoo
0:46 to 0:58 rosé
2:08 jisoo 2:14 rosé
2:55 jisoo
3:02 rosé
*based on their skills,vocal range not just in position*🤦♀️😬
Yeah the 2nd one would go to rosé because she has better vocals than jisoo
@@rosiexyt4640 not better just squeeaky
@@ΜουσικήΙδιοφυΐα better
@@rosiexyt4640 evrn jennie is better than rose
@@ΜουσικήΙδιοφυΐα Jennie is good but not better so you can stop being biased now
I love this song😗♥️
I love this song😗♥
Jisoo🥰🥰🥰
Que orgulhonJisoo com 60s na line
jisso is ningning
rose is winter and she sang one part of kanira
lisa is gilselle
jennie is karine
jennie is also lead vocal where is your vocal part? Jisoo is a not rapper and she have one rap?
Aurel💜Novi💚😍Zafira💖😍Anggita💗
LISA
ROSE
JISOO
JENNIE
LISA ROSE JISOO JENNE 💜💜💜
Jennie never gets raps
Its so unreal, my gosh
in my opinion I think Jennie should go with Giselle
Same
in my opinion l think Jennie should go with Giselle 💜💜💜💜
Plz make 🙏 Savage aspea sing by bts and blackpink
LISA AND ROSE
LISA AND ROSE 😍😍😍😍
I am first
don't forget Jennie is a vocalist just like Jisoo
My opinion jennie =karina jisoo=Giselle Lisa=NingNing Rose=Winter
But ningning is the main vocal on aespa, and lisa is only vocalist...lisa is a good singer, but ningning is rosé or jisoo for me
@@freddy585 Creo que se refiere a "voces similares".
Lisa is human she needs respect 😒
True
Wdym
Lisa is human she needs respect 😍
Jisoo (winter)
In my opinion, Rose would be NingNing and Jisoo is winter. I'm not trying to discredit jisoo by saying she cant hit NingNings high notes it just seems better. Rosè isn't in NingNings really high notes range but she can hit them better with her vocals... I'm not saying Jisoo cant even hit her high notes but Rosè is a main vocalist after all so I dont think it would be thrown in garbage. Plus Winter has high notes too so I'm not really discrediting Jisoo. Just my opinion
I love this cover but karina is the main dancer and lisa ,so whay you give karina to jennie and gizelle for lisa gizelle is the main rapper so is jennie
I must say jisso and jeenie rośe and Lisa is not the same voice
Jisoo...And that many lines...And raps...Are you joking...Yg will never gonna do that...Probably they will give her more line...But she really did not fit in this type of line distribution...Just my opinion...
Thank you rosé rap
Jennie (gizelle)
Jennie for karina part
Lisa (karina)
Lisa fit more Karina
This line distribution is not fitting for Jisso‘s voice
Rosé (nignig)
And ningning is the maine vocaliste and rose to so why jisoo in nigning
I don't think Jisoo can hit those high notes
@MLR ENTERTAINMENT jisoo high note in lsg is extremely lower than this high note
@MLR ENTERTAINMENT jisoo is talent but her vocal range is not enough to do the high notes. Sorry for my bad english
@@nguyenhaphuong7117 Agree, it's not her range
@MLR ENTERTAINMENT Lol We all know Jisoo is a Talented Queen, but we are talking about the HN,it's too high for her and those HN is out of her range.
@@Mikha_My_Bae she did really good hn in lg (watch encore cam) and in clarity
0:03 Lisa
0:06 Lisa
0:20 Jennie
Pre-chorus: Rose only
0:45 Lisa and Rose
No, Jisoo will also sing the pre-chorus lmao.
@@Lucas-jw4fy Oh wow, I am looking back at my comment and I realized how unfair it is-
2
2 💜💜💜😍😍😍
Idk why this feel weird
Jisoo can't hit this high notes.....she so talented, but she sings worse than Jennie.I would put almost everything between Rosé and Jisoo the other way around
So in my opinyun (no hate)
Jennie=karina
Lisa=giselle
Rosè=ningning
Jisoo=winter
Like song
Like song 💜💜💜💜
No
Tf Jennie shouldn't have gotten most of the rappers, she's the main rapper
lmao dont mad this is not real but i think jennie is suit to sing
Jennie is lead vocal to
is a edid is a aespa song .😬😠😒😭😰😤😣😬😠😡
so bad :(