Jinnah was a strong nationalist and ambassador of hindu muslim unity in the beginning, but in a later stage,after Lahore resolution was passed,the sole purpose of his life was to partition of India and creation of Pakistan. Dr.Istiaq Ahmad has established this fact in his book,while Ayesha Jalal argued that till the end Jinna did not want partition. But Dr.Istiaq Ahmed defeated her argument beyond doubt.
It is misconception that Jinah was nationalist and ambassador of Hindu Muslim unity he was selfish opportunist and greedy of power. Jinnah was the founder of split the Indian nation on the basis of religious hate . The whole politics of Mr. Jinnah was based on religious hate against Hindu and Sikh peoples. Peoples. Thanks.
1916 se 1945 tak Sir Chhotu Ram bhi bahut bade role mai thai, lekin unke chapter ko jaan bhuj kar nikal diya gya, but unke kamo ko mitaya nahi ja payega. #sirchhoturam
Very nice video. Really appreciate Zeeshan Ali’s point of view. Partition is a fact of history and while we can only now only discuss and imagine ‘what if’ India remained united, ‘we can’ still improve relations between the two nations. Like Zeeshan expressed in a another video, it is tragic today, that the British who divided the subcontinent can still move freely across countries, while we the inheritors of a shared heritage can only struggle to see the ‘other side’.
@@AKumar-co7oeThey are just presenting what they have read they are not eye witnesses and neither are you if you read different sources and believe them to be true you can disagree with them. No need to call them duffers.
@@LoneWolf.1990 he is presenting a twisted narrative from ayesha jalal and ignoring facts that are mainstream at this point. if he wants to be fair he can call professor ishtiaq
@ Bro first u called them duffers and now ur calling them dishonest by accusing them that they are twisting “mainstream facts”. It feels like ur listening to podcast with predetermined beliefs only to get assurances on ur existing “facts”. Ayesha jalal is a Author and she did her research and presented her view. She doesn’t work for government and if u know her work she was never in a good books of power corridors in Pakistan, what do u think she can achieve by “twisting mainstream facts”. She’s of view that partition of India was a big Blunder.Her views could be problematic for you and opinions shared on this podcast could be unpopular or totally wrong but thats whole point of listening to podcasts we learn about views/opinions/research contrary to our mainstream beliefs.
Kyon teri tatti nahin nikalti masha allah ke pichwaade mein ghuse bagair? Har baat mein Ahamdullilah, Masha Allah. Lo fir gadh gaya pakistan ke pichwaade mein killa.
Lord Mount Batton had put forward the offer of primeministership to Jinnah Sahib. Mr Jinnah replied , "Oh, it must be the cunning Gandhi." It was obvious that he could be thrown out by Hindu majority at any time.
No all wrong, fake narrative. False equivalence. Jinnah was a dirt bag. India is a secular nation. India mein 1000s muslim ladkiyon ka forcible conversion nahin hota. Do not compare India with a disease called Pakistan.
No they did not clear your concepts, they completely distorted the facts. This long haired id-io-t from Lahore is not a historian. He is speaking out of his a-s-s. False equivalence. Read books, don't listen to Paki fake youtubers.
Lord Wavel complained to Sir Sikandar Hayat Khan Tiwana C.M. ABOUT Sir Chhotu Ram's fiery speech in Panipat inviting JATs to burn crops keep Wheat only enough for their families if they don't get a adequate price. CM said: He would do that if he said so. MATTER CAME TO A COMPLETE HALT. Barrister M.S.Dahiya Bhatgamia Garhwale, Canada.
Partition was an excellent Idea by Zinnah and Mountbatten, Only blunder was done by Gandi and Nehru, they didn't implemented it in totality and complete transfer of population couldn't realised. The result of which Hindus in Pakistan and Bangladesh are still facing religious hatred and atrocities because of being non muslims and on the other hand remaining muslims are flourishing in India and dreaming of Islamisation of the country. ACTUALLY, MOULANA AZAD WAS MORE VISIONARY AND CUNNING THAN ZINNAH, HE WAS THINKING OF USURPING OF WHOLE SUB CONTINENT AND WAS NOT HAPPY WITH ZINNAH THAT HE AGREED WITH MERE TWO PIECES OF THE LAND. SO HE DELIBERATELY STOPPED MUSLIMS IN INDIA FOR ANOTHER PARTITION OR COMPLETE TAKE OVER, WHICH THEY ARE TRYING THEIR BEST.
Karl Marx has also written some articles about India where he has exposed Indian kings and analysed British exploitation along with figures and budgets for india.
It is true that Jinnah didn't want partition in 1920s but when he saw chances of becoming PM of India quite less since Patel was the most suitable candidate but Gandhi backed Nehru...Jinnah then became power hungry despite knowing he was suffering from lung cancer and had 2-3 years left during 1946
He even accepted cabinet mission plan in 46 but congress was not ready to give free hand to Muslim majority provinces but main cause of partition was hindu congress who showed his true colour in 1937 government. Jinnah dont had lung cancer he had T.B .
😯😯😯... 🤔🤔🤔... 😢😢😢... 🌹🌹🌹... Very sad very goood and very informative GUPPP SHUPPP... Lekin aik baaat aaap bataaana bhoool gaye k baqol Jinaaah Saaab Pakistaaan mainay aor meray Type writer na banaaaya hay aor may Moslim aksariat par Hindostaaan k mosalmanooon ko qurbaaan kar rahaaa hooon ??? A kaaash aisaaa na hotaaa ???
Jinnah is the culpit of partition ... sidh ka kya huya... jinnah ki call par bangal aur punjab mein roits huye jis k wajh se nehru aur patel partition k leye raji huye ...
Jinnah is not the reason of partition, it's the religion that Jinnah follows is the reason of partition...... Take UK as example. UK gives all the rights, welfare to all citizens. Peaceful community enjoys it all but now are also asking for " Shariah for UK", why??? Qki ye log kissi ke saath nahi reh sakte. Agar gair mazhab ke saath rahenge to unse jhagadenge, agar shia Sunni rahenge to unse ladenge, inko sirf apna mazhub aur usme se apna maslak se hi pyaar hai....
Sar aap lagta hai aapane cabinet mission ke bare mein Puri jankari nahin liye. Teen tarah ke state banae gaye the unmen se 10 varsh pakshat alag hone ka Adhikar Diya gaya tha jiski vajah se Muslim bahul ilake Pakistan ki taraf ho sakte the yah Jawaharlal Nehru ko aashram ka thi akaalee mishan yojana mein bhaarat ko teen samudaayon mein vibhaajit karane kee baat thee: grup e (hindoo bahul kshetr) grup bee (muslim bahul pashchimee kshetr) grup see (muslim bahul poorvee kshetr) neharoo ko yah dar tha ki is desh kee ekata aur akhandata mein khatara paida ho sakata hai, kyonki muslim leeg kee is yojana ka upayog karake deshon ko vibhaajit kiya ja sakata hai.
Jinha alli sabh ashe thhe alli sabh ne Pakistan bana kar shi kya india mein ajj sikh logo ki kya halat h kitna julam hota 1984 mein darvar shib par hamal kya cun chun kar sikho ko mara gya
@@shubhammittal9003East India Company k sath bohot indian bhi kaam krty thy aur British rule main bhi indian job krty thy is se kya prove hota hai k British government theek thi?
not agree with your point of view......zinna changed his view 180 degree after he joins muslim league....aur britishers ne kaunsa constitution ko maan kar koi kaam kiya....so its a bogus argument
Jinnah was a strong nationalist and ambassador of hindu muslim unity in the beginning, but in a later stage,after Lahore resolution was passed,the sole purpose of his life was to partition of India and creation of Pakistan. Dr.Istiaq Ahmad has established this fact in his book,while Ayesha Jalal argued that till the end Jinna did not want partition. But Dr.Istiaq Ahmed defeated her argument beyond doubt.
Later Jinnah call for Direct Action Day which was one of the biggest massacre in the history of India.
Jinnah was a monster.
The moment he said Jinnah didn't want partition i stopped watching this 😅
Tere baap nein bataya thaa yeh tujhe? Suuar khane waala, anrezon ka pichwada chatne waala sick aadmi thaa Jinnah.
It is misconception that Jinah was nationalist and ambassador of Hindu Muslim unity he was selfish opportunist and greedy of power. Jinnah was the founder of split the Indian nation on the basis of religious hate . The whole politics of Mr. Jinnah was based on religious hate against Hindu and Sikh peoples. Peoples. Thanks.
@@civilmonk1166 Agree with your point of view. From Pakistan.
geez i wish this had subtitles i love gandhi mountbatten was a fool and jinnah i know little about i could have learned alittle here
1916 se 1945 tak Sir Chhotu Ram bhi bahut bade role mai thai, lekin unke chapter ko jaan bhuj kar nikal diya gya, but unke kamo ko mitaya nahi ja payega. #sirchhoturam
Very nice video. Really appreciate Zeeshan Ali’s point of view. Partition is a fact of history and while we can only now only discuss and imagine ‘what if’ India remained united, ‘we can’ still improve relations between the two nations. Like Zeeshan expressed in a another video, it is tragic today, that the British who divided the subcontinent can still move freely across countries, while we the inheritors of a shared heritage can only struggle to see the ‘other side’.
I love 💕 sweetheart my Leader Quaid e Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah
even ishtiaq ahmad ji proved lot of points....
which these duffers ignored
never expect Pakistanis to not lie
@@AKumar-co7oeThey are just presenting what they have read they are not eye witnesses and neither are you if you read different sources and believe them to be true you can disagree with them. No need to call them duffers.
@@LoneWolf.1990 he is presenting a twisted narrative from ayesha jalal and ignoring facts that are mainstream at this point. if he wants to be fair he can call professor ishtiaq
@ Bro first u called them duffers and now ur calling them dishonest by accusing them that they are twisting “mainstream facts”. It feels like ur listening to podcast with predetermined beliefs only to get assurances on ur existing “facts”. Ayesha jalal is a Author and she did her research and presented her view. She doesn’t work for government and if u know her work she was never in a good books of power corridors in Pakistan, what do u think she can achieve by “twisting mainstream facts”. She’s of view that partition of India was a big Blunder.Her views could be problematic for you and opinions shared on this podcast could be unpopular or totally wrong but thats whole point of listening to podcasts we learn about views/opinions/research contrary to our mainstream beliefs.
بہت خوب بہت ہی بہترین انفارمیشن دی ہے سر ذیشان نے ماشاءاللہ
Kyon teri tatti nahin nikalti masha allah ke pichwaade mein ghuse bagair? Har baat mein Ahamdullilah, Masha Allah. Lo fir gadh gaya pakistan ke pichwaade mein killa.
Lord Mount Batton had put forward the offer of primeministership to Jinnah Sahib. Mr Jinnah replied , "Oh, it must be the cunning Gandhi."
It was obvious that he could be thrown out by Hindu majority at any time.
بہت عمدہ ذیشان صاحب!
No all wrong, fake narrative. False equivalence. Jinnah was a dirt bag. India is a secular nation. India mein 1000s muslim ladkiyon ka forcible conversion nahin hota. Do not compare India with a disease called Pakistan.
Very good vedio
The book is well researched and well written don't comment on this. True History.❤😢
very informative video zeeshan bhai
Nice podcast ❤
Thank you clearing our Concepts
No they did not clear your concepts, they completely distorted the facts. This long haired id-io-t from Lahore is not a historian. He is speaking out of his a-s-s. False equivalence. Read books, don't listen to Paki fake youtubers.
Informative video
Is pure video me is khitte ki Janmajaat majority ki Ray ki Kisi ne Parwah nahi ki.. Bas yahi resion hai ki me partition ke favor me hu .. 👁️👁️😎
Nice discussion
Lord Wavel complained to Sir Sikandar Hayat Khan Tiwana C.M. ABOUT Sir Chhotu Ram's fiery speech in Panipat inviting JATs to burn crops keep Wheat only enough for their families if they don't get a adequate price. CM said: He would do that if he said so. MATTER CAME TO A COMPLETE HALT. Barrister M.S.Dahiya Bhatgamia Garhwale, Canada.
Kindly make a podcast of Neta ji Subash Chand Bose
Kar leya ❤
zabardast
History what a topic u hv chosen very nice and sensitive bt should not be biased
Brother you never talk about the killing of innocent Punjabis
Don't forget Mr. Kashmir that what goes around comes around
❤❤❤❤❤
Respected, Kindly study books of Mr Tariq Ali.
Reunification of India and Pakistan is need of the hour now to undo the blunder of partition committed by Jinnah and the British
Bhai.... Kyun poore India me dhamaka karwana chahte
@animeshkumar3121 india can counter china militarily very well with reunification of Pakistan
And you are an id-io-t. Iss gandagi ko fir se mila len? Paagal hai kya?
Nice topic badiya knoledge
Please addtimestamps
Partition was an excellent Idea by Zinnah and Mountbatten, Only blunder was done by Gandi and Nehru, they didn't implemented it in totality and complete transfer of population couldn't realised. The result of which Hindus in Pakistan and Bangladesh are still facing religious hatred and atrocities because of being non muslims and on the other hand remaining muslims are flourishing in India and dreaming of Islamisation of the country.
ACTUALLY, MOULANA AZAD WAS MORE VISIONARY AND CUNNING THAN ZINNAH, HE WAS THINKING OF USURPING OF WHOLE SUB CONTINENT AND WAS NOT HAPPY WITH ZINNAH THAT HE AGREED WITH MERE TWO PIECES OF THE LAND.
SO HE DELIBERATELY STOPPED MUSLIMS IN INDIA FOR ANOTHER PARTITION OR COMPLETE TAKE OVER, WHICH THEY ARE TRYING THEIR BEST.
Karl Marx has also written some articles about India where he has exposed Indian kings and analysed British exploitation along with figures and budgets for india.
Baalwala sir g ko bohat names yad hain itni yadasht Waly aksar bal k bagher hoty hain but he is with strong hairs
😂😂😂
Master Tara Singh communal nahi the, woh partition nahi chahte the
आप कहते हैं पर निश्चित रूप से निष्पक्ष नहीं हैं।सत्य बहुत कड़वा होता है।उसे पचाना मुश्किल है।
Jishan bhai Mount betten ki death 1979 me London ke samandar me ek boat me bethe ki kisi ne goli markar kar di thi os time me 10 th me padhta tha.
It is true that Jinnah didn't want partition in 1920s but when he saw chances of becoming PM of India quite less since Patel was the most suitable candidate but Gandhi backed Nehru...Jinnah then became power hungry despite knowing he was suffering from lung cancer and had 2-3 years left during 1946
He even accepted cabinet mission plan in 46 but congress was not ready to give free hand to Muslim majority provinces but main cause of partition was hindu congress who showed his true colour in 1937 government. Jinnah dont had lung cancer he had T.B .
Jhoot mat bholo
@@babarchatha8200 agreed
Sabse zyada zulam to Punjab per hi hua
😯😯😯...
🤔🤔🤔...
😢😢😢...
🌹🌹🌹...
Very sad very goood and very informative GUPPP SHUPPP...
Lekin
aik baaat aaap bataaana bhoool gaye k baqol Jinaaah Saaab Pakistaaan mainay aor meray Type writer na banaaaya hay aor may Moslim aksariat par Hindostaaan k mosalmanooon ko qurbaaan kar rahaaa hooon ???
A kaaash aisaaa na hotaaa ???
Jinnah is the culpit of partition ... sidh ka kya huya... jinnah ki call par bangal aur punjab mein roits huye jis k wajh se nehru aur patel partition k leye raji huye ...
Jinnah is not the reason of partition, it's the religion that Jinnah follows is the reason of partition......
Take UK as example. UK gives all the rights, welfare to all citizens. Peaceful community enjoys it all but now are also asking for " Shariah for UK", why???
Qki ye log kissi ke saath nahi reh sakte. Agar gair mazhab ke saath rahenge to unse jhagadenge, agar shia Sunni rahenge to unse ladenge, inko sirf apna mazhub aur usme se apna maslak se hi pyaar hai....
Angrej N bh Hindu Muslim K matter lkr fayda utya.batwara krw dya.Gurudware bhut kuch chut gya..Batwara Punjb k Hua..koi nh bhul skta..
Love Punjab or leave Punjab
Sar aap lagta hai aapane cabinet mission ke bare mein Puri jankari nahin liye. Teen tarah ke state banae gaye the unmen se 10 varsh pakshat alag hone ka Adhikar Diya gaya tha jiski vajah se Muslim bahul ilake Pakistan ki taraf ho sakte the yah Jawaharlal Nehru ko aashram ka thi
akaalee mishan yojana mein bhaarat ko teen samudaayon mein vibhaajit karane kee baat thee:
grup e (hindoo bahul kshetr)
grup bee (muslim bahul pashchimee kshetr)
grup see (muslim bahul poorvee kshetr)
neharoo ko yah dar tha ki is desh kee ekata aur akhandata mein khatara paida ho sakata hai, kyonki muslim leeg kee is yojana ka upayog karake deshon ko vibhaajit kiya ja sakata hai.
It was Nehro who was caused Pakistan
Oh, sir G baal waleya...
Mazy me aj b wohi hy jo jitna bara badmash begerat hy gareeb hamesha sy he rota marta r hy 🙂↕️
Ambedkar's comment on Gandhi and india's independent on BBC is available on RUclips.
ruclips.net/video/Wf3VJCpNMqI/видео.htmlsi=OEhwpR-aSNju00jv
Jinha alli sabh ashe thhe alli sabh ne Pakistan bana kar shi kya india mein ajj sikh logo ki kya halat h kitna julam hota 1984 mein darvar shib par hamal kya cun chun kar sikho ko mara gya
Aaj ek Sikh airforce chief hai india me aur kai cabinet ministery me bhi..lekin bhut julm hai sikho pe india me .😮😮
Le lo apna Khalistan 😂😂😂😂.
@@shubhammittal9003East India Company k sath bohot indian bhi kaam krty thy aur British rule main bhi indian job krty thy is se kya prove hota hai k British government theek thi?
ruclips.net/video/byRsgbhXg_8/видео.htmlsi=dFhEaKyPsQ8jiX8F
This video is totally different story.
not agree with your point of view......zinna changed his view 180 degree after he joins muslim league....aur britishers ne kaunsa constitution ko maan kar koi kaam kiya....so its a bogus argument
Zinna? We think Gaandii also changed his views
Yeh dono web series dekh k baithe h aur gyan de rhe h
Isse pehle bhi is topic pe inki podcast he ..zara check to kr lo
yea bhi kaha jata tha gandhi g ki sadgi show off krne per kafi paisae kharch hotay thy
Bhai ek ek line Freedom at midnight se bol rahe ho , Eiek hi kitab duniya ka sach nahi hota . Sorry aap logo ko aadat hai ek kitab ko sach manane ki 😂
100 janwaro ko punjnay sa to acha ha aik kitab e man lo or aik Khuda ko 😂
1937 me kya julm hua musalmano pe hinduo ke taraf se ya hindu congress ke taraf se please detail me bataiyega...
Jinna ek wahiad insan tha logo ka qatle aam uski hi vazah se hua acha hua azadi ke ek sal Baad hi chal basa
But u r Muslim, u have no right to say it
O dafa ho khabees