Leading a Platoon Through Intense Combat at the Battle of Okinawa

Поделиться
HTML-код

Комментарии • 195

  • @americanveteranscenter
    @americanveteranscenter  Год назад +16

    Join our Patreon community to receive exclusive content and opportunities to meet these heroes in real life. This funding goes directly into helping us capture more incredible stories with our nation's veterans: patreon.com/americanveteranscenter

    • @user-fo2yr7yu2d
      @user-fo2yr7yu2d 8 месяцев назад +1

      My grandfather was in the Army Corp of Engineers in ww2. In the Indonesia and Philippines theater. I was mind blown by his intimate stories of what civilians don't calculate into the casualties of war.
      This fact staggered my mind.
      He said. " we lost a very significant amount of men on rope ladders and the panic within men not to time out their jump down to a boat! A high tide calls for leaping when the boat below you is rising! It's counter intuitive in a layman's mind. But by the time you drop 10 yards...the boat will be going down and you won't break your legs. That's if your aim is even proper and you are far less fortunate and go under the boat or get squeezed."
      To think of that, and how many people died before they even had the satisfaction of squeezing a trigger to the enemy and bring it back home... saddens my heart. To end before you start.

  • @abdullahiahmed7484
    @abdullahiahmed7484 7 месяцев назад +6

    Who would be stupid enough to give thumbs down, for this interview or the many like it….
    This is what I watch every night when I finish shift of driving and find a truck stop..

  • @reggierico
    @reggierico 2 года назад +78

    I want to know what Col. Riffe's secret is. By my calculations, he is well into his 90's and is as sharp as a tack and has the recall skills of a man in his 20's. Amazing stories by an incredibly amazing patriot!

    • @mikekrypel4771
      @mikekrypel4771 10 месяцев назад

      It amazes me how WW2 veterans call recall the dates and events, I love to listen to their stories. My grandfather was a Partisan in Poland during the occupation, I remember some stories but as a young child i didn’t pay attention, unfortunately he passed away before my teens and my fascination with history and WW2 started, I do have his medal tho my most prized possession

    • @redwatch1100
      @redwatch1100 9 месяцев назад +5

      Probably never took a lot of prescription meds. My grandma is now 95 born in 1928 and never took meds or trusted any doctors.

    • @kentuckybeararms2779
      @kentuckybeararms2779 13 дней назад

      Because he isn’t like the sissy soy boys today. He is a man. people today would have never defeated the Nazis or the Japanese they are to soft

  • @josephe.9869
    @josephe.9869 Год назад +11

    I cant believe this guy is almost 100 yrs old then. Hes in good shape and sounds young and remembers well. Thank you for your service Sir.

  • @COACHWARBLE
    @COACHWARBLE 2 года назад +33

    Think about the level of training this guy had. He still remembers specific orders.

  • @leeneale8776
    @leeneale8776 3 года назад +83

    all these men are so gentle natured. Utmost respect

    • @INdifrnve
      @INdifrnve 3 года назад +4

      So true. Amazing.

    • @prmayner
      @prmayner Год назад +6

      that's because they're 90+ years old, duh. I'm sure when they were young they were hell raiser's just like the rest of us.

    • @sec9788
      @sec9788 3 месяца назад

      @@prmaynerNah. These guys were mostly humble family men. Not this radical nonsense you see today.

    • @marcnelson2645
      @marcnelson2645 29 дней назад

      My grandfather was the kindest , loving man I've still ever been around. And fought like hell. Is what he said late in life.

  • @richardthornhill4630
    @richardthornhill4630 2 года назад +18

    Thanks to all our military veterans who proudly served this nation.

  • @HollisterMorgan
    @HollisterMorgan 4 года назад +121

    Thank you for your help of basically saving our world. I’m only 22 years old female and I can’t imagine losing my boyfriend, friends, younger brother to this and I and I can’t even begin to imagine the pain and suffering and horror that every man (&woman) had to go through. Truly a devastating time and I hope that you had an amazing life. Thank you isn’t enough.

  • @keithdavis9897
    @keithdavis9897 9 месяцев назад +15

    this guy is beyond incredible and his recollection is phenomanal. He got there after Saipan and there was a short time that a Marine General took over Army forces on Saipan. The Marine General said the Army was bogged and not making progress so he ( being senior ) took command from the Army General. My Dad ( 27th Infantry ) said that didn't go over well. The Army had been given the worst of the paths to the objective on Saipan. They were down in the valley where it was swampy and heavy with forestation. I didn't know the 10th Army on Okinawa was combined Marine/Army....interesting.

  • @TheirStoryVeterans
    @TheirStoryVeterans 4 года назад +46

    Colonel Riffe - thank you for sharing your story sir.

  • @chocolatefrenzieya
    @chocolatefrenzieya 11 месяцев назад +6

    The effort his men made to make sure he got his sword says a lot.

  • @NATAS-cr3ss
    @NATAS-cr3ss 3 года назад +12

    My grandfather Charles B GLOVER fought in Okinawa. 6TH MARINE. He survived 🙌

  • @tex346
    @tex346 4 года назад +56

    My Father was in the 27th which BTW was the first combat division deployed from the U.S. after the attack on Pearl Harbor. They fought two Pacific operations before Dad joined them in Hawaii. They would next remove the enemy from Saipan and then be taken off the line for a rest and training. On Okinawa, the 27th would be the first division to move against Kakazu Ridge aka. Hacksaw Ridge. On the first full day of battle the 27th had roughly 500 casualties. In the Hanks/Speilberg production PACIFIC there is a depiction of the relief of the 27th by the 1st Marine Division.

    • @JimD410
      @JimD410 10 месяцев назад +4

      It's amazing how many people don't know the Army was there fighting too. My Grandfather fault along side the marines he was with the americal div. These men were 100% the greatest generation.

    • @tex346
      @tex346 10 месяцев назад +1

      @@JimD410 I bet my father was so thankful that the 1st Marines came up the escarpment to relieve the 27th.

    • @WhichSideOfTheMasonDixonLine
      @WhichSideOfTheMasonDixonLine 10 месяцев назад +3

      Our son’s F-I-L’s late father was in the Army, I believe 27th and received the Bronze Star, Purple Heart and a Service Citation for his actions at Okinawa. I’m sorry, I can’t give you all more details about it, as he is long passed away and his GGrandchildren can’t learn first hand of his experiences there.
      My F-I-L was 9thAAF, 107thTRS, P47 Thunderbolts, ETO, Trinidad to the Ardennes 42-45. He passed in 1966 of a massive heart attack and so our kids never got to know him.

    • @JimD410
      @JimD410 10 месяцев назад

      @@WhichSideOfTheMasonDixonLine Sounds like you guys know a good bit though. They were with out a doubt the greatest generation.

    • @CrossOfBayonne
      @CrossOfBayonne 2 месяца назад

      Upmost respect, My VFW member Eugene Iconetti was with the Marine Corps on Saipan 4th Marine Division

  • @wessteele1058
    @wessteele1058 3 года назад +14

    This man was a bigger man at 23 than most men ever will be ,god bless

    • @juspete5527
      @juspete5527 5 месяцев назад

      Does signing up to fight a war to become a paid order follower by the government to extend their rule make someone a bigger man or a sheep? Sheep. Face it not one war was ever about helping people or protecting America it is always about money.

  • @jlo7770
    @jlo7770 4 года назад +51

    Im 10 minutes in and this guy is sharp as a tack. I can barely remember where I was 2 years ago let alone 70 something years ago. Blows my mind the stuff these men remember.
    Thanks again (I've commented other videos) keep doing these interviews so many amazing stories ive gotten to hear

    • @PLAZMOHD
      @PLAZMOHD 3 года назад +5

      Whether it be for good or bad, i personally feel like the utter rarity, violence and change in circumstances that war provides leaves a lasting impact on people that fight in them, which they'll never forget . Also i agree this man's memory is so sharp and he looks super healthy for his age

    • @guypierson5754
      @guypierson5754 2 года назад +1

      For better or worse the ultraviolence of combat stays with you.

  • @johndavis8690
    @johndavis8690 3 года назад +204

    To the nine thumbs down on this interview:: You don't deserve the freedom these veterans fought for.

  • @rikijett310
    @rikijett310 Год назад +7

    Sir, thank you endlessly for your service and may God bless you always!!!!! ✝️🇺🇸

  • @dmaextraordinaire8205
    @dmaextraordinaire8205 3 года назад +15

    Extraordinary man telling an extraordinary story. Thank you Sir for your service to our country and for our freedom.

  • @roberfaubus3455
    @roberfaubus3455 3 года назад +9

    Thank you forever my friend without you I won’t enjoy my freedom my dad and grandpa was in World War One and two.

  • @toddavis8603
    @toddavis8603 3 года назад +8

    A Platoon leader is much responsibility, indeed.TY brave soldier, for your valor and meritorious conduct, in combat.We are thankful & grateful to you☆☆

  • @TommyStGeorge
    @TommyStGeorge 3 года назад +12

    Thank you for your service Col. Riffe. My father Lt. Col. Tom Doran (deceased 1998) also fought on Okinawa in the 7th Infantry. I an Arisaka Rifle and bayonet and a western style Japanese officer's saber that he left me.

    • @seanmarley3123
      @seanmarley3123 3 года назад +5

      Cool man have you any pictures of the items

  • @ronhaworth5471
    @ronhaworth5471 2 года назад +4

    Thank you for service.Your men first attitude puts you on top of my list!!

  • @user-fo2yr7yu2d
    @user-fo2yr7yu2d 8 месяцев назад +2

    Ok. Not even 3 minutes in and the fella states "i was a staff sesrgent in 4 months." That is amzingly commendable but in the same respect.
    Its a testament to how many before him have died and the need for men of quality. I say this in my humblest tones. To be honored to lead men to victory in such a desperate moment. No matter what. Hats off.

  • @BlueWaterSTAX
    @BlueWaterSTAX Год назад +2

    What a guy. A true American PATRIOT. God Bless America.

  • @tigertiger1699
    @tigertiger1699 Год назад +1

    These guys are so humble…., all that. & to Chief the 82nd.., yet so humble

  • @johndial3018
    @johndial3018 Месяц назад

    My great grandfather was in the 77th ID and took Ie shime and continued the fight on Okinawa. I’m retired From service now and Okinawa is my home. I’ll preserve this island against any that would take it. It’s home and a well of history and beauty.

  • @Steve7318
    @Steve7318 2 года назад +4

    Much respect and thank you for your service. He mentioned that he has two swords and only 3 grandsons. Perhaps consider donating them to a WWII museum so they can be viewed as relics of history for all to see.

  • @iancostigan5047
    @iancostigan5047 3 года назад +6

    What a mind this man has.

  • @PorchHonkey
    @PorchHonkey 8 месяцев назад +2

    Sir, I would like to thank you for your unselfish sacrifice and the part that you played in saving the world! I will never forget as long as I live. And I am truly and eternally grateful for you and all of your comrades. Fallen or otherwise. May God bless your souls! 🇺🇸💪

  • @davesmith5022
    @davesmith5022 3 года назад +9

    I love his West Virginia mannerisms.

  • @danielhughes5517
    @danielhughes5517 2 года назад +6

    Still so sharp!! Thank you for your service and sacrifice Col.!!!

  • @Joellikestobox
    @Joellikestobox 8 месяцев назад +1

    Thank you for your service

  • @JoeFootball55
    @JoeFootball55 3 года назад +8

    Much respect and thank you for your service. 🇺🇸

  • @gcrauwels941
    @gcrauwels941 4 года назад +13

    Thank you for your sacrifices and your service.

  • @glockspecific7757
    @glockspecific7757 3 года назад +7

    In the Marine Corps you're a stud to make Sgt in 4 years, 4 months is insane!! Different times also part of it

  • @jharris0341
    @jharris0341 Год назад +2

    Respect.

  • @karencrowe3748
    @karencrowe3748 2 года назад +3

    Thank you so much for your nerves of of steel to defend our Country!!!
    God Bless you and your Soul. And REST IN PEACE. ❤️😎

  • @abcmedia2297
    @abcmedia2297 9 месяцев назад +1

    God blessed you...

  • @candicehanson2854
    @candicehanson2854 3 года назад +15

    My father fought in that battle.

  • @Chrisamos412
    @Chrisamos412 4 года назад +14

    Great interview thank you and thank you sir for your service and sacrifice to our Nation.

  • @telluride4017
    @telluride4017 7 месяцев назад +1

    This man can tell a story! Very well spoken! Seems like he lived a very good life

  • @rossthompson7956
    @rossthompson7956 6 месяцев назад

    Thank you sir.

  • @tnreprasentog7769
    @tnreprasentog7769 7 месяцев назад

    Man is incredibly sharp for his age... a true hero with a great memory!

  • @ThePponu
    @ThePponu 4 года назад +25

    Another excellent interview.
    Amazing how articulate Col. Riffe is.
    Thank you both for sharing.

  • @INdifrnve
    @INdifrnve 3 года назад +4

    An amazing man. Wow.

  • @benramirezguitar5927
    @benramirezguitar5927 2 года назад +2

    Thank you for your service sir, I am also a resident of southern WV

  • @Tolson2024
    @Tolson2024 Месяц назад

    Much respect sir thank u

  • @soldier4life_PR
    @soldier4life_PR 3 месяца назад

    Thank you Sir 🇺🇸🎖️

  • @haroldadkins770
    @haroldadkins770 Год назад

    Thank you sir you are my Hero God bless you sir I'm form west Virginia also thank you

  • @Hamel7777
    @Hamel7777 Год назад +4

    sharp guy, easy to see why he made officer

  • @tempemarine87
    @tempemarine87 9 месяцев назад +2

    I happen to think he saved that mans life....had he said no ..he would have went somewhere else and most likely died....I would say you saved his life...

  • @soldier4life_PR
    @soldier4life_PR 3 месяца назад +1

    He remembers everything like it was yesterday.

    • @SuperUAP
      @SuperUAP 7 дней назад

      Time to take your meds grampa 😂

  • @haroldmclean3755
    @haroldmclean3755 Год назад +1

    A Very Interesting and well articulated Account of His experiences and Service
    High Kudos 👍

  • @bobbyrayvictory6905
    @bobbyrayvictory6905 Год назад

    I'm sorry it's taken so long to find this channel. I've been binge watching these stories for the last 24hrs. Thanks for this

  • @tbm3fan913
    @tbm3fan913 5 месяцев назад +1

    The war ended for him on Okinawa while the war ended for my father in the Philippines where it was still going on. He also ended up in Japan assigned to Gen. Eichelberger's security detail. Ended up being discharged as a Staff Sergeant April 1946 at 20 years old. I now have a Japanese Type 99 rifle with bayonet and an officer's sword which impressed me when I was six in 1959.

  • @sgtpepper2469
    @sgtpepper2469 2 года назад +5

    And today they're taking down Lewis and Clark statues

  • @susanbrown5004
    @susanbrown5004 Год назад

    Thanks!

  • @Peter-gv2gn
    @Peter-gv2gn 2 месяца назад

    You were meant to be, what a life, what a service you gave to the Country of your birth and to your family, I see this is in 2024, you may have left this life by now Jim, I appreciate you from Great Britain , what a generation, God meant this,cheers.

  • @CRUSH71
    @CRUSH71 10 месяцев назад +1

    Amazing man❤ 🇺🇸

  • @miophx8283
    @miophx8283 3 года назад +1

    Watch anyone of these videos, and you'll know why they're called the Greatest Generation.

  • @seancronin4010
    @seancronin4010 11 месяцев назад +1

    Fortunately, we still have men and women of the caliber of James Rifle. Not many, but we have have them.

  • @fishbum55
    @fishbum55 День назад

    I Company of the 106th was originally recruited from Mohawk, New York. He transferred to K Company which originated from One,New York.

  • @jgstargazer
    @jgstargazer Год назад +1

    Okinawa even touched our little town by claiming a town son. He was killed on April 12, 1945. I can just imagine what he saw and went through, the massive invasion force and naval gunfire as he approached Okinawa.

  • @oustandingsitter6106
    @oustandingsitter6106 3 года назад +5

    What i wouldnt give to help these men on the battlefield back then...
    Semper fi.., my eldest brethren.

  • @brockbusa3912
    @brockbusa3912 4 года назад +8

    I may be related to this man. My great grandfather has the same last name Riff though it’s pronounced Like ryffe. My GG was also from eastern Kentucky. They look similar too!

    • @wongijen9167
      @wongijen9167 4 года назад +2

      If that actually turns out to be true, then you must be extremely proud to be able to have him as a great grandfather

    • @roberfaubus3455
      @roberfaubus3455 3 года назад +1

      My grandpa was in the first war we had the same drift number that was 40 during the Vietnam war. I never went.

  • @davidsdancepodcast2010
    @davidsdancepodcast2010 3 года назад +2

    Just a point of feedback, it would be great if you could remove the background noise. That can be done digitally using most audio software and only takes a couple minutes, but would improve the sound quality greatly. Great interview though and thank you for your service Mr. Riffe.

  • @AstroGremlinAmerican
    @AstroGremlinAmerican 4 года назад +7

    I don't like how James blames himself for the wounds of the second lieutenant artillery observer. He could have been killed later, especially with that desire to get combat experience.

  • @davide.b8027
    @davide.b8027 6 месяцев назад

    Panther, WV? I was born and raised in WV and i still live here. Ill admit, I have not heard of Panther. But either way, always proud to hear when a WV boy does something great!

  • @tcveatch
    @tcveatch Месяц назад

    As a boy I lived in a house on an upper slope of Kakazu Ridge on Okinawa, 1968-1971. Down the street was an empty lot, backing onto the edge of a steep gully, it was flat with tall grass all laid flat, with several unusual man-sized holes covered with long grass so it was fine to throw yourself down in the hole and we Army brat kids from the neighborhood would play War with each other in those holes, not realizing how they likely had been used for that very purpose, no play, by actual US Marines, so many who died crossing that slope and taking that ridge, the bloodiest part of the bloodiest battle in Okinawa, the bloodiest campaign of the whole war, so I’ve read. Thousands of Marines died taking this ridge. Once I found a large caliber bullet out in the tall pampas weeds in a field; Dad got pretty hot after he found it in my chest of drawers with my socks. Up the slope below the memorial lookout was a pillbox where you could crawl on your belly inside and imagine shooting down the slope, like they had done. It was a big concrete rounded thing, with lots of divots and big chunks shot out of it. Such an innocent youth I spent, but I came to appreciate the significance later. I read the book, The Battle of Okinawa cover to cover 3 years later, which started up my interest in reading history, grown up books. We are such innocent kids, all of us. It’s good to learn about what came before.

  • @robertjones8598
    @robertjones8598 10 месяцев назад +3

    The Japanese not only took an oath to an emperor but they believed their emperor was a god. There was a religious fervor to their combat mentality, much like modern day Islamic extremists. 2 nukes dropped is what it took for the emperor to come down from his palace and admit that he was just a man. And that was that and the Japanese people moved on.

  • @knarftrakiul3881
    @knarftrakiul3881 10 месяцев назад +1

    I live in west Virginia. Panther is in the middle of nowhere... Area time forgot lol

  • @jeremyperala839
    @jeremyperala839 2 года назад +12

    This guy is ten times more coherent than our current president.

  • @JohnThreeSixteen918
    @JohnThreeSixteen918 Месяц назад

    It is apparent that this man has a sharp intellect and that he was destined to become a leader and a most capable officer....why did he did not attain higher rank?

  • @keithfurr7224
    @keithfurr7224 2 года назад +1

    Your actions made it easier for our generation to lay our heads down at night without the fear of tyranny taking over the world

  • @reilleyluoma9675
    @reilleyluoma9675 4 года назад +3

    anywhere we can see the swords? great story

  • @marksummers463
    @marksummers463 Год назад

    God bless our troops!

  • @dotell3359
    @dotell3359 Год назад +1

    My dad was there at the same time and he landed on Okinawa April 1st 1945 . I wonder if he was my dad's commander.

  • @manlikebaz_
    @manlikebaz_ Месяц назад

    In hindsight, you probably ended up saving the life of the soldier who wanted to gain combat experience. Yes, he may of had 2 legs today, but if you told him no then he may have been killed in the following days.

  • @phanqd
    @phanqd 9 месяцев назад +1

    24:01 , he said "North Vietnam"?

  • @APerson-rc6vb
    @APerson-rc6vb 3 года назад +2

    any one got a link to the picture of his samurai sword?

  • @glockspecific7757
    @glockspecific7757 3 года назад +3

    Sharp as a tack still yet...

  • @phattyjoe887
    @phattyjoe887 2 месяца назад

    They left, BEFORE they were releived ! !

  • @susanbrown5004
    @susanbrown5004 Год назад +1

    🇺🇲THANKS!

  • @SeanNewhouse-mv9ez
    @SeanNewhouse-mv9ez 11 месяцев назад

    Pplz watch as many ww2 etc and connect with as many vets as you can as well as develop friendships
    eternal hugs from us ww2 vets, etc we know what we see and hear we'll always work to carry on your legacy

  • @majorwrinkles7906
    @majorwrinkles7906 4 года назад +3

    Question the embroidery medal on his cap is very similar to a British ww1 medal, except for the red middle ,is it coincidence?

    • @cultofgiovanni
      @cultofgiovanni 4 года назад +4

      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_Victory_Medal_(United_States)

  • @clydeblair9622
    @clydeblair9622 Год назад

    Truman on the atomic bomb "I don't want another Okinawa".

  • @susiedaniel8031
    @susiedaniel8031 Год назад

    Does anyone remember Charles Henry Smith, a Marine in the Pacific?

  • @NoneofyourBusiness-ce7qh
    @NoneofyourBusiness-ce7qh 4 месяца назад

    33:10 sad thing is is that the kids are probably going to sell it or lose it

  • @Rustsamurai1
    @Rustsamurai1 2 года назад

    Sounds like.a fun day out.

  • @jaime5711
    @jaime5711 11 месяцев назад +1

    4 months staff sgt. did I hear that correctly????

    • @SuperUAP
      @SuperUAP 7 дней назад

      During real war time all you need to qualify is to be breathing.

  • @Earth11111
    @Earth11111 2 года назад

    Thank you colonel sanders kFC wouldn’t be here without you🙏

  • @onlythewise1
    @onlythewise1 3 года назад +1

    you fought in how many battles

  • @bigbuzzhayes
    @bigbuzzhayes Год назад

    Is that an 82nd pin?

  • @bryanstaten5585
    @bryanstaten5585 Месяц назад

    So he said he eas born in 1921 so he was 98 at the time of this interview? Pretty dand sharp of mind still!

  • @jarrettwalker7845
    @jarrettwalker7845 2 года назад +1

    These are the men that are a cut above tha rest . All each and every one.black .white.green blue .yellow.purple.allcolors.and all. Of them .true .brave and loyalties remain two .our beloved America. The .best country under our heavenly father and our savior Jesus Christ 🙏 our Lord 🙏.these men are. Heros and we should and must never forget what each of them gave. So we càn walk free now .so thank you .my great americans.for your scarfice so we can. Be safe ❤️ and free .God bless you all.in Jesus Christ 🙏 our savior name amen andamen

  • @joefran619
    @joefran619 Год назад

    dying for an emperor? crazy

  • @luiscabrera7498
    @luiscabrera7498 8 месяцев назад

    12:59

  • @BrandonToy
    @BrandonToy 7 месяцев назад

    This guy is the exact opposite of me. I hate training.

  • @NasirUddin-nk7tc
    @NasirUddin-nk7tc 3 года назад +3

    Jeeb 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

  • @unitedwestand5100
    @unitedwestand5100 3 года назад +3

    This guy was mistaken.
    The battle of Okinawa was under the 10th Army control.
    The 10th Army consisted of 7 plus Divisions. 4 Army Divisions, plus the 713th Tank Bn (flamethrower), and 3 Marine Divisions.
    The 82-day Battle of Okinawa lasted from early April until mid-June 1945 and U.S. (five Army, three Marine Corps Divisions and Navy personnel on ships) casualties were over 62,000 of whom over 12,000 were killed or missing.

    • @folland34
      @folland34 2 года назад

      No colonel sanders, you’re wrong

    • @ag358
      @ag358 2 года назад +1

      The tenth army was created, 7th,27th,77th,91st army divisions and 1st,2nd,and 6th marines. It was a joint army and marine command as was all the islands, my dad was at tarawa,tinian, saipan, Okinawa . Dad was a marine, he was at all the islands from the first day. There was trouble at saipan, the commander of the marines sent the commander of the army back to Hawaii because the marines were a mile ahead of the army on their assault which left the marines in more trouble. There was arguing, finger pointing and accusations but having heard first hand what happened i believe the army was in the middle with marine divisions on either side. The army was pinned down for much of the assault ,the fault was not army command or personnel, it was a bad place to be in. Unfortunately, it was reported in the media. This man was wrong about the statement of a marine was the first time in overall command on Okinawa, the marines were in command on saipan and other islands, that's why the marine commander was able to send home the army commander. One quote has the marine commander saying, " get off my island you son of a bitch,im sending you back to Hawaii"

    • @unitedwestand5100
      @unitedwestand5100 2 года назад +3

      @@ag358 ,.
      U.S. Navy Admirals Raymond Spruance and Richmond Turner wanted General Smith to command the Okinawa invasion forces. They were overruled by CinCPac, Admiral Nimitz because
      General Smith had sacked a U.S. Army general, Ralph Smith, during the Saipan campaign. And, justifiable animosity between senior U.S. Army staff existed towards General Smith due to his service chauvinism.
      U.S. Army general Simon Bolivar Buckner, Jr. was appointed to command the Okinawa invasion in his place.
      When Buckner was killed, USMC general Geiger temporarily replaced him. But, only temporarily until US Army General Stillwell could get to Okinawa.

    • @unitedwestand5100
      @unitedwestand5100 2 года назад +3

      @@ag358 , The Board that investigated the incident on Saipan, concluded that, while Holland Smith had the authority to fire Ralph Smith, he had not acquainted himself with the particular difficulties faced by the Army troops in the fight for Mt. Tapotchau and that the firing was "not justified by the facts.
      Never again would a USMC General command a combined Army/Marine force.
      Army leaders are molded, and educated in land warfare at West Point.
      USMC leaders, are either US Naval Academy Graduates, or Officer Candidate Corp's cadets.
      Both learn land warfare at a short training course at Quantico. (The Marine Corps, as a small land warfare division of the Navy, does not have a Leadership Academy of it's own)
      This fact, related to the Saipan incident, is why I chose the US Army Infantry over the Marines.
      I did not mind being asked to sacrifice my life for the country as long as I knew I was being lead by competent leadership.

    • @unitedwestand5100
      @unitedwestand5100 2 года назад +2

      @@folland34 ,. Of the 12,281 Americans reported killed in the Okinawa campaign, 4,907 were U.S. Navy personnel. (Kamikaze attacks)
      This figure outstrips the battle deaths suffered by both the U.S. Army (4,582) and Marines (2,792) who participated in the punishing ground offensive.