I appreciate the attention to detail given to Enver Pasha and his depiction in the video. He even has an Iron Cross which was given to him by Wilhelm II.
That’s actually an Armenian General Antranik who had many victories against ottomans and that cross is from Bulgarian war against Turks in which he participated!
it's crazy how west is fast to call russian invasion a genocide and cry about it but call isreal self defense for Killin 15k civilians in thier attempt to kill like 100 hamas people
@@ebonaparte3853 The Armenian rebellions and minor revolts in the Ottoman Eastern Anatolian territory throughout the 19th century, massaccres in ww1 and the Turkish independence war, ASALA, etc.
The countermeasures taken involve nothing less than the destruction or enforced Islamisation of a whole people. The destination of those exiled from Samsun is said to be Urfa. It is certain that no Christian Armenian will reach this destination. According to news from the interior, there are already reports on the disappearance of the deported population of entire towns.[12] German consul to the Ottoman Empire
The armenian genocide was done by a purely nationalist government using religion as a convenient pretext. I don't consider them ottomans because the ottomans were tolerant of other religions and enver pasha was a turkish nationalist trying to make his empire more turkish and less muslim.
One of the most interesting and tightly packed, yet most overlooked aspect of not just WWI, but the ENTIRETY of modern history. Would love a full length WWI from the Caucasian perspective or any kind of Caucasian front video. There's enough to analyze to fill an hour long video.
I think it would also be beneficial to learn why the Ottomans joined against the war with Russians, and also what caused the Ottomans to “commit genocide” on the orthodox people
Almost like he's called... THE ARMCHAIR HISTORIAN. You know, wouldn't that be crazy? If he was named THE ARMCHAIR HISTORIAN? But he couldn't possibly be named anything to do with armchairs, or historians. I am incapable of reading a RUclips channel name, as I am a Turkish bot that exists for the sole purpose of genocide denial.
Huuuuge mistakes. Armenians were constantly being supported by the Russians since the War of '93, Russians created the ARF which band of militias armed and trained by Russians started the ethnic violance between the Turks, Kurds and Armenians by attacking, massacaring and razing Kurdish and Turkish villages. Which that is why the hatred against the Armenians in the Eastern Anatolia begun meanwhile in the West there was many Armenians were working together with the Young Turks which during WW1 that also broke down because of the Russian influence on the Armenian politicians in Ottoman politics. Which ARF's constant attacks on villages even during WW1 caused the relocation plan of the Armenians to Syria, Iraq and Western Anatolia which people going to Western Anatolia managed to re-settle 'safely' before migrating out of Ottoman Empire meanwhile the ones going to Syria and Iraq under the small protection force (Again manpower issues) mostly attacked by the Kurdish Tribes who refused Armenians to settle in their lands because of the ethnic tensions caused by ARF and Russians. About the 'Massacare' in Ardahan, it is very unlikely as Ottomans didn't had time nor manpower to conduct proper 'massacare' on the civillian population as Russians were still close to the city.
@@rod9829 I don't believe they didn't occur because there is no historical document that proves they did it. There are only claims that don't even match with eachother. If you want to learn more things you can use your internet and reach to historical documents in archives of U.S, France, UK and Russia. Majority of them are free but you have to pay very little amount to see some of them.
Bro the genocide is fucking real my grandmothers grandfather was in a basement getting medicine when they slaughtered his family he had to march across the desert at the age of fucking 5. To fucking Syria
@@Trill-Is-Realduhhh, Armenians helped Tsar Russia, so Ottoman empire had to transfer those armenians. If you read history properly you would probably know what is truth or misinformation. I dont know what they teach in school and what are the paragraphs in your books 🤦🏻 May Jesus lighten you
@@stuart4341 1)armeninan violence started in 1890.2) Even the russian perspective and based on what russian officers wrote, how armenina gangs attached the civilians, massacred them and attempt ethnic cleansing. 3) you cant find any massacre that even attempted by Ottoman Army
As a Georgian we would have preferred to be under the ottoman empire rather than russian. Yes both are horrible but no empire comes close to horrible things that russia has done to our people (except the mongol empire)
What exactly... Did Rusaia do to us that compares to centuries of slave trade and assimilation into the Islamic sphere for good? It's 95% likely that Georgia wouldn't even HAVE sovereignty as a nation if it was ever capitulated by the Ottomans. Just look at what happened to Armenia! Historically it was much closer to the Persian and Ottoman influences, thus much more prone to attacks and they suffered dearly for it, losing 2/3 of their entire rightful territory.
(SPONSORED) We made this short with #opusclip, check them out here! www.opus.pro/?
Do we have permission to use, some of your videos on opus?
Me trying to find the Turkish comments
gotta love the random ass comments on a short like this
I do indeed love random asses
@@mamoon304 relatable
These Turks in the comments are just💀💀
Turks who voted for Erdogan*
Suckers? 😂 They are
Owner of the video deleted all the comments
Big talk from someone supporting neo n@zis. Please do tell how Ukraine isn't full of pro n@zis
@@elbibokoning7889That's good or bad?
One of several occasions when I'm not ashamed of my country (Russia) for preventing Armenians being wiped out.
Why should you be ashamed of your country?
@@phonkyman237russia genocided and ethnically cleansed a lot
@@phonkyman237maybe because they did same to many others,only reason they tried to stop it because Armenians were fighting for them like a puppet .
Most countries has done a cleansing once s it aint special
@@perniciousseizurehellio3438genocided who?
Turks in the comment section do be smoking a lot of copuim💀
I appreciate the attention to detail given to Enver Pasha and his depiction in the video. He even has an Iron Cross which was given to him by Wilhelm II.
That’s actually an Armenian General Antranik who had many victories against ottomans and that cross is from Bulgarian war against Turks in which he participated!
Good thing it was over by christmas. That could've gotten out of hand
yeah it probably would shatter most of the empires
These Turks bro 💀
ikr its insane how stupid some of them are.
They wild bru💀💀
@@Mentalhospital2000xabsolutely 💀
They destroy the world
Yeah this comment section is a mess
Turks will defend hamas but say that killing Armenians was self defense. They are crazy
it's crazy how west is fast to call russian invasion a genocide and cry about it but call isreal self defense for Killin 15k civilians in thier attempt to kill like 100 hamas people
Ww1 ottoman pov vid soon.
the only people who deny the genocide are those that committed it and their supporters 🇹🇷🇦🇿🇵🇰
So true the Turks don't have any proofs that it didn't happen
The Armenians also commited genocide(for about 130 years)
@@LibertardManSource?
@@ebonaparte3853trust me bro we are innocent
@@ebonaparte3853 The Armenian rebellions and minor revolts in the Ottoman Eastern Anatolian territory throughout the 19th century, massaccres in ww1 and the Turkish independence war, ASALA, etc.
The countermeasures taken involve nothing less than the destruction or enforced Islamisation of a whole people. The destination of those exiled from Samsun is said to be Urfa. It is certain that no Christian Armenian will reach this destination. According to news from the interior, there are already reports on the disappearance of the deported population of entire towns.[12]
German consul to the Ottoman Empire
The armenian genocide was done by a purely nationalist government using religion as a convenient pretext. I don't consider them ottomans because the ottomans were tolerant of other religions and enver pasha was a turkish nationalist trying to make his empire more turkish and less muslim.
As a Turkish person your spelling of Ardahan was perfect
Real name is Artaani, there are many medieval Georgian churches there.
@@shakochokheliarmenians are coming
@@AnatolianHittite no it was really Georgian, last time it was in jurisdiction of Georgia was 1921. Artaani not ardahan
The also genocided the Assyrians. A very much forgot Christian people of the middle east
and greeks
This is sad. Staying friendly would be insanely worhtful for both Armenians and Turks. I don't think there is a winner of this war.
“Defeat fire with fire!” Vibes
One of the most interesting and tightly packed, yet most overlooked aspect of not just WWI, but the ENTIRETY of modern history. Would love a full length WWI from the Caucasian perspective or any kind of Caucasian front video. There's enough to analyze to fill an hour long video.
Its 10 hr and only 1k likes let's fix it
I think it would also be beneficial to learn why the Ottomans joined against the war with Russians, and also what caused the Ottomans to “commit genocide” on the orthodox people
Wtf, why do you have "..." They killed a large percentage of a group. Theres no need for apisthrofes.
watch the whole video, and yes it was genocide. They literally aimed to wipe out the entire population.
Great video
My ancestors were murdered by the turks.
And my village was burnt down by the greeks
And my grandpa died in Stalin’s gulag
When and were@@AnatolianHittite
@@biljanakiric5111 During the Turkish War of liberation, the greeks burned our village.More recently, greek eoka terrorists murdered Turks in Cyprus.
THE COCKROACHES
Nobody asked you to put your name down.
How old are you
Another Taalat Pasha sympathiser.
why u type your nations name in here ?
Создовайновыеистории1😊
🇷🇺
It's clear you have armchair level knowledge on the topic, stop taking sides.
Bro what 💀
?💀
Almost like he's called... THE ARMCHAIR HISTORIAN. You know, wouldn't that be crazy? If he was named THE ARMCHAIR HISTORIAN? But he couldn't possibly be named anything to do with armchairs, or historians. I am incapable of reading a RUclips channel name, as I am a Turkish bot that exists for the sole purpose of genocide denial.
?Learn some history pal
Video is WW1 from the Russian perspective he's gonna tell it from the Russian perspective
Huuuuge mistakes.
Armenians were constantly being supported by the Russians since the War of '93, Russians created the ARF which band of militias armed and trained by Russians started the ethnic violance between the Turks, Kurds and Armenians by attacking, massacaring and razing Kurdish and Turkish villages.
Which that is why the hatred against the Armenians in the Eastern Anatolia begun meanwhile in the West there was many Armenians were working together with the Young Turks which during WW1 that also broke down because of the Russian influence on the Armenian politicians in Ottoman politics. Which ARF's constant attacks on villages even during WW1 caused the relocation plan of the Armenians to Syria, Iraq and Western Anatolia which people going to Western Anatolia managed to re-settle 'safely' before migrating out of Ottoman Empire meanwhile the ones going to Syria and Iraq under the small protection force (Again manpower issues) mostly attacked by the Kurdish Tribes who refused Armenians to settle in their lands because of the ethnic tensions caused by ARF and Russians.
About the 'Massacare' in Ardahan, it is very unlikely as Ottomans didn't had time nor manpower to conduct proper 'massacare' on the civillian population as Russians were still close to the city.
Spot the Turk…
the least fascist turk in the world:
Before you call out someone as 'Turk' go and read some history books rather than learning history from RUclips channels, you'll learn more things :)
@@mr.tobacco1708 your great grandparents commit crimes so heinous that you’d rather believe that they didn’t occur!
@@rod9829 I don't believe they didn't occur because there is no historical document that proves they did it.
There are only claims that don't even match with eachother. If you want to learn more things you can use your internet and reach to historical documents in archives of U.S, France, UK and Russia.
Majority of them are free but you have to pay very little amount to see some of them.
I love when I get that notification saying "Someone liked your comment!" Or "Someone has subscribed!" It really makes my day better!!!!!!☝🥺
🤖
💀💀🤖
Get help.
This guy explained this in the most basic and not researched way possible
Cope
@@Thess-wm8ke 😭
@@Fish_1914 😔
Well, it's a one minute short, really much more information doesn't fit in there
And how would he be able to squeeze an hour into a short?
why you must saying muslim community 😅 not Is this on purpose? or turkis community or something else
Because there were Turks and Kurds in the region as well as potentially other ethnic groups
Are Kurds and Georgians Turks? 🤦🏻♂️
What did you even say man
Cope
This video is far from historically accurate
Coping my friend?
Bro the genocide is fucking real my grandmothers grandfather was in a basement getting medicine when they slaughtered his family he had to march across the desert at the age of fucking 5. To fucking Syria
Why u denying genocide💀
@@Trill-Is-Realduhhh, Armenians helped Tsar Russia, so Ottoman empire had to transfer those armenians. If you read history properly you would probably know what is truth or misinformation. I dont know what they teach in school and what are the paragraphs in your books 🤦🏻 May Jesus lighten you
@@Cyberbully3 1.5 million people died.
title should be "how to lose credibility". talking like hunchak and dashnak not exist kind a stupid
did you miss the part taht says "from the russian perspective"
@@stuart4341 1)armeninan violence started in 1890.2) Even the russian perspective and based on what russian officers wrote, how armenina gangs attached the civilians, massacred them and attempt ethnic cleansing. 3) you cant find any massacre that even attempted by Ottoman Army
Your grammar speaks for itself, broken English is how you know somebody is spitting cold hard facts. Go back to kindergarten!
As a Georgian we would have preferred to be under the ottoman empire rather than russian. Yes both are horrible but no empire comes close to horrible things that russia has done to our people (except the mongol empire)
bruh if georgia was ottoman they would have been genocided like the armenians
What exactly... Did Rusaia do to us that compares to centuries of slave trade and assimilation into the Islamic sphere for good? It's 95% likely that Georgia wouldn't even HAVE sovereignty as a nation if it was ever capitulated by the Ottomans. Just look at what happened to Armenia! Historically it was much closer to the Persian and Ottoman influences, thus much more prone to attacks and they suffered dearly for it, losing 2/3 of their entire rightful territory.
This is probably fake
Cope Turkman
huh@@Thess-wm8ke
@@abubakaromer5860he means your trying to cope with the genocide by saying it didnt happen
@@JTEhistory oh
@@Thess-wm8ke stop lying