The "scientific" claim is unfounded. Many intelligent parents' children outright dumb, and vice versa is true too. If a child wants to pursue his parent's occupation, then there is no need for a "system" for it, he can anyways do it. We need to accept our mistakes and correct it, not try to justify everything in our past as divinely ordained, supreme stuff.
This video was not about justifying any oppression or discrimination. It was to explore the system and thought behind why it was created for that time and context. The same system was later misused for exploitation. None can argue with that.
I completely disagree with you trying to justify this terrible system. Human beings are not rats. Their genetics have the flexibility to shift occupation. This was a discriminatory, horrible practice.
@@adhvaitha The "scientific" claim is unfounded. Many intelligent parents' children outright dumb, and vice versa is true too. If a child wants to pursue his parent's occupation, then there is no need for a "system" for it, he can anyways do it. We need to accept our mistakes and correct it, not try to justify everything in our past was divinely ordained, supreme stuff.
Before jumping on any conclusion and following the idea of west world without proper research. Read varna system den west interpretation of it. I knw whenever any white say something u believe it blindly
Sorry but I disagree here, the things that was passed on was fear which is essential for survival, if the study isolated some rats who were let's say great at completing a maze and then isolated them and passed on to next gen and so an soo forth then this makes sense, otherwise your basis of this video doesn't make much sense to me (not trying to hate, I love your videos otherwise)
Genes are not only limited to 'fear' based emotions, although I agree that 'survival' is an important factor for the species. The most common example is the tone of the skin.
There is no purpose nothing is good or bad everything is alright. Its like a game the end is decided. Wheather you fulfill purpose in 1 lifetome or a billion lifetime doesnot matter if the purpose defies the logic of time
@@youAbajajTube awakening is not the purpose i believe. Lately i find everything going around even if it crime or good things i think they are ok and well calculated we dont need to worry wheather we are doing our work or not. This is made by you in your pure conscious state everything is happening because you made it dont worry
Hello, Mr. From what you are talking, it is crystal clear that you don't know anything, even abc of the system. It is unfortunate that such people are trying to lecture about it. Very pathetic.
@adhvaitha subject is very delicate, sensitive and can be easily misunderstood. It is unfortunate that both those speaking for and against, actually don't have clear understanding. If you are serious in knowing, pls contact me.
So you know how you said that the karma from previous lives is thousands and thousands of births, if the solar is eternal, doesn’t that mean that it has infinite amount of births both in the past present and in the future?
Yes, humans have genetic memory, we will be having different interests or genetic memory from our many ancestors , and we have our own interests too, simple eg is Im a tea lover same as my grandparents 😁
Very subjective opinion.. As krishna said sometime we need change the thigs as the time passes. I agree and understand what you are saying is more of a scientific POV. But i feel this topic had more negtive points than positive giveaways to the socity . People compelty mis used it .. I come from a brahmin family background and i can say and as u mentioned Seekers should not be stopped And no one should. Judge other person based on their oarents background. Since thats how socity changed later..
I understand that the system was later misused. But the point of the video was that the original structure was not oppressive in nature rather it was scientific.
This video was not about justifying any oppression or discrimination. It was to explore the system and thought behind why it was created for that time and context. The same system was later misused for exploitation. None can argue with that.
Suppose an artisian has 5 sons, not all will be as skilled he is, everyone of his sons will have different abilities be it intellectual or physical. So keeping them stuck in religious structure, and not allowing them to explore their abilities given to them by God is a sin, rather than turning them into structured animals. This is the reasons why we Indians haven't done any new scientific inventions that change the course of Human society. All modern advancements on which we thrive anre mostly done by NON INDIANS, and we are just stuck in our religious dogmatic thinking. And this is not only about India, any country or society which is struck in religious hegemony is shattered down to pieces by its own weight, a live examples is in our neighborhood Pakistan, look at the society degrading itself. And we Indians in the new world who explore our abilities are scientists, intellectuals and who ever we want to be are inventing new inventions, you can see most of scientists in the US and Europe are indians and that has nothing to do with their varna. Rather when you allow a human mind to evolve itself it enlightens.
This video was not about justifying any oppression or discrimination. It was to explore the system and thought behind why it was created for that time and context. The same system was later misused for exploitation. None can argue with that.
Join Adhvaitha Conscious Society: video.adhvaitha.com/vuaxQIFhqQIBKp92I
The "scientific" claim is unfounded. Many intelligent parents' children outright dumb, and vice versa is true too. If a child wants to pursue his parent's occupation, then there is no need for a "system" for it, he can anyways do it. We need to accept our mistakes and correct it, not try to justify everything in our past as divinely ordained, supreme stuff.
This video was not about justifying any oppression or discrimination. It was to explore the system and thought behind why it was created for that time and context. The same system was later misused for exploitation. None can argue with that.
I completely disagree with you trying to justify this terrible system. Human beings are not rats. Their genetics have the flexibility to shift occupation. This was a discriminatory, horrible practice.
The system later became 'Terrible'.
@@adhvaitha The "scientific" claim is unfounded. Many intelligent parents' children outright dumb, and vice versa is true too. If a child wants to pursue his parent's occupation, then there is no need for a "system" for it, he can anyways do it. We need to accept our mistakes and correct it, not try to justify everything in our past was divinely ordained, supreme stuff.
Before jumping on any conclusion and following the idea of west world without proper research. Read varna system den west interpretation of it. I knw whenever any white say something u believe it blindly
Oh hey, don't mind me. I'm just here for the comments, I just got my popcorn.
Sorry but I disagree here, the things that was passed on was fear which is essential for survival, if the study isolated some rats who were let's say great at completing a maze and then isolated them and passed on to next gen and so an soo forth then this makes sense, otherwise your basis of this video doesn't make much sense to me (not trying to hate, I love your videos otherwise)
this is pretty much hinduism hes teaching
Genes are not only limited to 'fear' based emotions, although I agree that 'survival' is an important factor for the species. The most common example is the tone of the skin.
Great explanation bro...
Thank you 🙂
There is no purpose nothing is good or bad everything is alright. Its like a game the end is decided. Wheather you fulfill purpose in 1 lifetome or a billion lifetime doesnot matter if the purpose defies the logic of time
The more I think of my purpose, the more I think of myself as a separate being, the further I am away from awakening.
Ultimately, yes.
@@youAbajajTube awakening is not the purpose i believe. Lately i find everything going around even if it crime or good things i think they are ok and well calculated we dont need to worry wheather we are doing our work or not. This is made by you in your pure conscious state everything is happening because you made it dont worry
@@adhvaitha so maybe best not to worry about my purpose. Just best to be, and accept things as they are?
What do you think?
@@youAbajajTube It depends on the particular person and the particular case.
Hello, Mr.
From what you are talking, it is crystal clear that you don't know anything, even abc of the system. It is unfortunate that such people are trying to lecture about it. Very pathetic.
So enlighten us.
@adhvaitha subject is very delicate, sensitive and can be easily misunderstood.
It is unfortunate that both those speaking for and against, actually don't have clear understanding.
If you are serious in knowing, pls contact me.
So you know how you said that the karma from previous lives is thousands and thousands of births, if the solar is eternal, doesn’t that mean that it has infinite amount of births both in the past present and in the future?
I didn't get the question.
Sanaatana dharma ki jai
Satyameva jayathe 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
🙂🙏
💩
Yes, humans have genetic memory, we will be having different interests or genetic memory from our many ancestors , and we have our own interests too, simple eg is Im a tea lover same as my grandparents 😁
🙂🙏
Very subjective opinion..
As krishna said sometime we need change the thigs as the time passes.
I agree and understand what you are saying is more of a scientific POV. But i feel this topic had more negtive points than positive giveaways to the socity .
People compelty mis used it ..
I come from a brahmin family background and i can say and as u mentioned
Seekers should not be stopped
And no one should. Judge other person based on their oarents background.
Since thats how socity changed later..
I understand that the system was later misused. But the point of the video was that the original structure was not oppressive in nature rather it was scientific.
It's just one more way to prove or claim supermacy in this system by a class . Totally disagree.
This video was not about justifying any oppression or discrimination. It was to explore the system and thought behind why it was created for that time and context. The same system was later misused for exploitation. None can argue with that.
@adhvaitha this system was biased from the very beginning
@@rumoum How do you know this?
@@adhvaitha read veda
Sure, mention which part/verse of the 'Vedas' specifically talks about 'discrimination'.
Suppose an artisian has 5 sons, not all will be as skilled he is, everyone of his sons will have different abilities be it intellectual or physical. So keeping them stuck in religious structure, and not allowing them to explore their abilities given to them by God is a sin, rather than turning them into structured animals. This is the reasons why we Indians haven't done any new scientific inventions that change the course of Human society. All modern advancements on which we thrive anre mostly done by NON INDIANS, and we are just stuck in our religious dogmatic thinking. And this is not only about India, any country or society which is struck in religious hegemony is shattered down to pieces by its own weight, a live examples is in our neighborhood Pakistan, look at the society degrading itself.
And we Indians in the new world who explore our abilities are scientists, intellectuals and who ever we want to be are inventing new inventions, you can see most of scientists in the US and Europe are indians and that has nothing to do with their varna.
Rather when you allow a human mind to evolve itself it enlightens.
This video was not about justifying any oppression or discrimination. It was to explore the system and thought behind why it was created for that time and context. The same system was later misused for exploitation. None can argue with that.
Beautiful
🙂🙏