RDR2- Why I think Gavin is Nigel's horse

[@werifestxriia]

I think your correct

[@BurryJoe]

Whose?

[@livewire2759]

Interesting theory... but if you tie him up and loot him you'll find a note that explains who Gavin really is.

[@natek5579]

I agree the letter is supposed to explain things, but that letter doesn't seem to do a good job of explaining much.
The letter from Gavin that apparently says nothing at all, what if Nigel's mate is as crazy as Nigel and also thinks horses are people?
I know it sounds crazy and it probably is

[@livewire2759]

@@natek5579 What the letter explains is that Nigel IS Gavin. He suffers from a multiple personality disorder.

[@Caydugger]

Makes sense

[@danny8254]

possible