A First Listen Of Heart Shaped Box by Nirvana (Analysis/Review)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 окт 2024

Комментарии • 86

  • @rizipt
    @rizipt 2 года назад +24

    Really enjoying the ride. Have patience my man. If you build it, they'll come.

    • @SyedRewinds
      @SyedRewinds  2 года назад +7

      haha well put mate. That's my whole ethos. I just want to make the best video possible, I think if you make content you believe in, people will be drawn to it. I will be diversifying what I create here, I have big plans for the channel, but music always held and holds a special place for me. Thanks for the kind words mate!

    • @2682shark
      @2682shark 2 года назад

      That’s the wrong quote, it’s “He will come”

  • @kathleensmith3555
    @kathleensmith3555 2 года назад +10

    Actually Kurt was a Pisces and their introspection can be seen as being weak -- Courtneys sign is Cancer and according to a biography about Kurt she gifted him a heart shaped box when they first met -- I know she says its referring to something else -- and perhaps its true

  • @agdgdgwngo
    @agdgdgwngo 2 года назад +13

    I love this song. I don't say it often but to me this track is perfect, the music, the production and the lyrics, Kurt really was a genius and the whole band sound awesome here. I love the subtle interlocking guitar in the verse and how menaching and heavy the bass it, Dave's drumming being subdued and then crashing into life. Probably the best song they ever did, though my favourite, and reccomendation (if you haven't already) is Serve the Servants. Great reaction too btw I will be subscribing.

  • @jonathanlocke6404
    @jonathanlocke6404 2 года назад +7

    I would recommend a look at the original music video created for this...Very surreal...

  • @The_W3st_Is_The_B3st
    @The_W3st_Is_The_B3st 2 года назад +4

    I love your reactions, very fresh, nothing like those fake ones that find everything amazing, with exaggerated expressions, starting on the first 2 seconds of each song. And you really pay attention to detail, and you discover new things that I didn’t notice by myself, in songs that I’ve been listening for over 20 years. Keep up the good work.

  • @markogden4587
    @markogden4587 2 года назад +8

    Been a nirvana fan since just before nevermind was released (yep I'm an old one) but it's really exciting to see someone hear them for the first time and their interpretation of both the lyrics and how it's played. I'm not a big fan of reaction videos but you actually put effort into why you like the song and Yr own take on what the lyrics could mean that I really enjoy listening to, sometimes breathing new life into songs I've listened to a million times already. Keep up the good work, you deserve a hell of a lot more subs and I'm sure you'll get them!!

  • @jamesrumsey
    @jamesrumsey 2 года назад +5

    Dude! I love that you take it that one step further and analyze the poetry of the lyrics. Sets you apart. I don't subscribe to any other reaction channel, and that's pretty much why.

  • @dynjarren8355
    @dynjarren8355 2 года назад +21

    A catchy love song lamenting regret and a feeling of dread with contradicting lyrics? Kurt was so good at that! Definitely one of his most powerful songs. He sounds trapped, unhappy and wistful about love. CL is responsible for this mess and it didn’t end well. But it’s a great song nonetheless!
    Good reaction!

    • @SyedRewinds
      @SyedRewinds  2 года назад +5

      So many different emotions in one song, so well done!

    • @winkweindel
      @winkweindel 2 года назад

      @@SyedRewinds hey maybe try For Squirrels - Mighty KC
      ruclips.net/video/IeY8tYAFrMw/видео.html
      Song was written in the wake of Kurt's suicide but has a second (unintentional) meaning because the band was in a terrible accident in their van coming home from a show. The singer, guitarist and road manager was killed two weeks before album came out. Please try this out you will be blown away ✌

  • @zackmano
    @zackmano 2 года назад

    You have great intuition. The original title actually was "Heart Shaped Coffin". Amazing you figured out that imagery without knowing that. 🙌🏼🤘🏼

  • @ThereAre2TypesOfPeople
    @ThereAre2TypesOfPeople Год назад

    Really love your breakdown of songs, everybody can take lyrics their own way. It means different things to different people, but usually you'll give me a new outlook on a song I thought I had nailed down for years. Bravo Sir.

  • @nickkleiber8636
    @nickkleiber8636 2 года назад +6

    Check out You Know your Right! Last recorded song they did!

  • @TechnicalHotDog
    @TechnicalHotDog 2 года назад +4

    I already liked this song but what sent it over the edge for me was hearing Ramin Djwadi's cover in Westworld. It really highlighted the beautiful melody.

  • @Sunshineandhydrangeas
    @Sunshineandhydrangeas Год назад +1

    There has always been a story that the line about priceless advice was something he used to say to CL in a sarcastic way. The umbilical noose was when she got pregnant with their daughter, so now he was irretrievably tied to her even if they broke up. They had a very volatile relationship. Heart shaped box was also,supposedly a double meaning. She gave him heart shaped boxes as gifts, but it also referred to a certain part of female anatomy. He supposedly locked himself in a room or closet to write this after a nasty fight with her.

  • @timjenkins4065
    @timjenkins4065 2 года назад +1

    Love that u appreciate this band, one of, if not my favorite band

  • @Luminous_Beings_are_we
    @Luminous_Beings_are_we 2 года назад +2

    Excellent reaction! As Always :D The video that accompanies this single is also a very interesting work of art. Nirvana's beautiful melodies combined with thrashing choruses their formula that never ages or gets boring. Look forward to more reactions particularly from Led Zep and Nirvana

  • @menotyou9836
    @menotyou9836 2 года назад

    Support my man, sending you good vibes from California!

  • @jump_start
    @jump_start 2 года назад +2

    You have the best analyses on RUclips.

  • @grelch
    @grelch 11 месяцев назад

    “Forever in debt to your priceless advice” is meant in the most cynical, sarcastic way possible.

  • @dudermcdudeface3674
    @dudermcdudeface3674 2 года назад +2

    Tons of great stuff on In Utero, but the Unplugged album is also a must before one can start to appreciate this band's real depth and importance.

  • @damonhines8187
    @damonhines8187 2 года назад

    Potent, poisoned take on love. Always loved it. You MUST treat yourself to the official vid too. Always the interesting insightful take on the material, Syed. Cheers.

  • @jimbo9313
    @jimbo9313 2 года назад +3

    One thing about Kurt is he tended to write his songs at the last second. You can tell this and teen spirt are worked out. I love unplugged. R.I.P

    • @bassacoustic1549
      @bassacoustic1549 Год назад

      Yeah, wasn’t on a plain written literally in the studio as they were recording it? 😂 when you hear the lyrics back you can kind of tell

    • @tl4396
      @tl4396 Год назад

      Heart shaped box is not one of them. This is really personal to him, like pennyroyal terá and must In Útero lyrics.

  • @scribeadventures4696
    @scribeadventures4696 2 года назад +2

    Great analysis as always. Keep it up! Not sure if you ever plan on doing it, but it would be dope if you did Nirvana album reactions now that you’ve sampled stuff from Bleach, Nevermind and In Utero. So many good songs!
    Also, suggestion: Alice In Chains, Soundgarden, Pearl Jam. The Seattle scene was full of good tunes.

  • @nadyavishnyakova8297
    @nadyavishnyakova8297 2 года назад +2

    fun fact: the verses with Pisces/Cancer lines are a nod to their zodiac signs (Kurt & Courtney)

  • @Empathy_Test
    @Empathy_Test 2 года назад +4

    Grew up with Grunge and will never tire of it. Love Nirvana. I'd recommend checking out Pearl Jam's "Jeremy".

    • @waynetables6414
      @waynetables6414 2 года назад

      Early Pearl Jam kinda sucks. I feel like theres not much similarity with Nirvana and that era of Pearl Jam. Nirvana is more like Wipers, Dinosaur Jr, Hole, L7 sound. Early Pearl Jam is kind of bland . I liked Pearl Jam a lot more after Vitology..Spin the Black Circle, Do the Evolution and those type songs have a more punk vibe.. so much better than the shit on Ten imo. 1994-1998 Pearl Jam sounds a lot more like Nirvana.

    • @frank9367
      @frank9367 2 года назад

      @@waynetables6414 they don’t need similarities with nirvana to be good… they’re good in their own way

    • @waynetables6414
      @waynetables6414 2 года назад

      @@frank9367 I agree. The context of my comment was replying to someone basically saying "if you like nirvana, you'll also like Pearl Jam's Ten/Jeremy"
      All I was saying was that's not necessarily true, because as a big Nirvana fan myself, I despise the album Ten, but I really enjoy a lot of other Pearl Jam albums. Just giving my opinion is all. I agree that PJ is good in it's own way

  • @NBAHOTTAKEZ
    @NBAHOTTAKEZ 2 года назад +4

    You should do You Know You’re Right by Nirvana

  • @brayden.sandmann
    @brayden.sandmann 2 года назад

    Loving the content as always man! You should do Dumb, You Know You're Right, or About A Girl next. Keep up the great videos man!

  • @antonballard2212
    @antonballard2212 2 года назад

    Great job again! I love this song too! Bravo 👏👏

  • @torchmark66
    @torchmark66 2 года назад

    Great reactions, Syed, and 'analysis' too. I've noticed you have a thing for the quiet/loud dynamic, as well as lyrics that evoke even when they may seem somewhat nonsensical or obscure. Cobain was a master of those (as well as coming up with great melodies). You might want to check out some Pixies tracks for more of the same. Quiet/loud, weirdly charismatic front man (Black Francis), strange evocative lyrics. Came slightly before Nirvana and were influential.
    Keep it up!

  • @whataboutme7174
    @whataboutme7174 2 года назад

    You are gonna love the MTV Unplugged Version of these songs whenever u get to em

  • @fredrikottosson3427
    @fredrikottosson3427 2 года назад

    Great reaction and take on the lyrics

  • @cunningstunt69
    @cunningstunt69 2 года назад

    love this channel a lot!!!

  • @jessietucker9342
    @jessietucker9342 Год назад

    This always reminds me of this autobiographical video of Kurt and Courtney shooting up and him nodding out while holding their young baby Frances in his lap while she is running around him babbling nonsense, the desolation of their brokenness was so disturbing.. Very brave of their now grown daughter to release that footage years later. The despair was palpable, an image so shocking and so very real.

  • @jaymcmullen6274
    @jaymcmullen6274 2 года назад +1

    Radio Friendly Unit Shifter, their joke radio friendly song off in Utero, great song that dives into fame, privacy and drug addiction.

  • @42Mrgreenman
    @42Mrgreenman 2 года назад

    Haven't seen anyone mention the double, but not only was Kurt a Pisces, it is also the sign of the fish. In a sense, he was "Hooked" on both Courtney and Heroin (Quite the emotional tangle, I'm sure)...I know how it is bro, Rest in Power!

  • @malenor4148
    @malenor4148 2 года назад

    Pisces. A fish eyes you from the side. Side-eying.

  • @axylve
    @axylve 2 года назад

    hey man great vid! i highly recommend serve the servants, its off the same album!

    • @axylve
      @axylve 2 года назад

      radio friendly unit shifter is also great lyrically!

  • @b1jou123
    @b1jou123 2 года назад +2

    You familiar with System of a Down? If not, you've gotta check them out. Songs to start with: Toxicity, Chop Suey, Sugar, BYOB, Question. Guarantee you'll be glad you listened!!

  • @mickidonahue4038
    @mickidonahue4038 Год назад

    Look up Courtney music during this time. Hole was her band, Doll Parts most known track.

  • @lesliedaubert1411
    @lesliedaubert1411 Год назад +1

    Courtney stalked Kurt with heart shaped boxes until he gave in. She's a Cancer and he was a Pisces. She dragged him down in different ways to his music, emotions, life, everything. It can be easy for a Pisces to be abused and then much later realize it. Trust me . Both my Sun and Moon are in Pisces. It's happened to me multiple times. It can be frustrating.

  • @nadyavishnyakova8297
    @nadyavishnyakova8297 2 года назад

    I’d really like for you to check out Serve the servants/R@pe me (In Utero) or Breed/Drain You/Something in the way (Nevermind). but I think you’ll eventually go through their entire catalog yourself 😂

  • @thesilverhawaiian5024
    @thesilverhawaiian5024 2 года назад

    SERVE THE SERVANTs is the second track off In Utero, its a banger

  • @emilybrooke3095
    @emilybrooke3095 2 года назад

    Great reaction of course! May I ask where you are from?

  • @ojs94bronco43
    @ojs94bronco43 2 года назад +1

    Drain you aneurysm live at paramount

  • @joshhawkins8394
    @joshhawkins8394 2 года назад

    You know your right by nirvana is pretty haunting, kurts last song

  • @BensSoZen
    @BensSoZen 2 года назад

    I subbed since you have a quick analysis on great songs, like MMA, did a reaction to Basketball (you ought to react to oldschool mixtapes like Jordan, Bird, Magic and you'll get more views than Lebron) and play Elden Ring, which i just started myself.

  • @Fuphyter
    @Fuphyter 2 месяца назад

    Great freakin song!

  • @goosefarm3602
    @goosefarm3602 Год назад

    Check out Hole- "Doll Parts".............Courtney Love was Kurt Cobain's wife...hole is her band

  • @ItzBadger.
    @ItzBadger. 2 года назад

    Should react to Serve The Servants Nirvana

  • @grahamthompson2594
    @grahamthompson2594 2 года назад

    The low E string is tuned down to C#

  • @mikefetterman6782
    @mikefetterman6782 2 года назад

    The death of the single Kurt. The birth of the married.

  • @jimbo9313
    @jimbo9313 2 года назад

    Cortneys only good deed in her whole life was giving him a heart shaped box. Then she help destroy him

  • @ojs94bronco43
    @ojs94bronco43 2 года назад +1

    Tool chili peppers Nirvana Zeppelin Alice in chains Soundgarden mother love bone smashing pumpkins

  • @yenlard6683
    @yenlard6683 2 года назад

    You need to hit up some Who. Big rabbit hole to go down. They were an amazing live band.

    • @SyedRewinds
      @SyedRewinds  2 года назад +1

      will do mate, that might just be up next actually!

  • @guinnesstrail6799
    @guinnesstrail6799 Год назад

    A paean to Courtney Love’s heart shaped box.

  • @lorcazola
    @lorcazola 2 года назад

    8:08. Here's what you're talking about looks like, ruclips.net/video/ditJB7Amxr4/видео.html

  • @dizzle7558
    @dizzle7558 2 года назад

    It sucks that Courtney had him killed..

  • @iainprendergast8311
    @iainprendergast8311 2 года назад

    This guy is going to far

  • @EttaKamenatios
    @EttaKamenatios 2 года назад

    по моему мнению это самый скучный трек с альбома “In Utero”

  • @hays9008
    @hays9008 2 года назад

    Sorry your meaning is completely wrong, look it up

  • @gregponder8332
    @gregponder8332 Год назад

    The heart shaped box? Obviously Courtney's vajayjay... umbilical cord and all... He can't escape it... and her... and it will/did not end well...