The reason the courts shut it down before wasn’t because of the contents of the laws, it was the jurisdiction of the people enforcing them. The courts just ruled that the states didn’t have the right to ban it, and that a tiktok ban wasn’t within the prerogative of the president. Stuff like this has happened before, like with Grindr, where social media platforms have to get their assets out of China. The federal legislative branch definitely has the power to create this ban, so it likely won’t be shot down by the courts.
Did you watch the video? Carter says stuff and adds no proof. he calls it unconsttutional for no particular reason. I am not gonna focus on any of the stuff the federalists wrote but I will focus on the amendments. 1st amendment; This is what most people have a problem with and think tik tok is breaking. The 1st amendment grants the freedom of the press, speech, religion, assembly, and right to petition against the government. Tiktok is not the press, tiktok is not being banned soley because of its content and content and opionions like it can be found on other platforms such as youtube, Tiktok is not a religion, Tiktok is not the only place you can assemble, but one of many, Tiktok isn't being banned because of petitions. Tiktok isn't a miltia so the 2nd amendment does not apply. I don't think banning tiktok will cause soldiers to sleep in your house, but maybe ig. The 4th ammendment is also know as "no search and seizure." Banning tikok doesn't take anything from you, so I think the ban is good with that one. I could go through all the constitutions and how the tiktok ban is fine with all ok them but every argument I've seen is about banning it violating the 1st amendment. Below is a full list of the fallacies Carterpcs made: Ad miserorem(towards Misery): Carterpcs uses an unqualified appeal to miesery at the end by saying banning tiktok would be bad for him Apriorism(Hasty Generalization): Carterpcs uses a past occurence with a different set aof situations. An executive order is much different than the entire legislative branch. Circular reasoning(assuming the conclusion in its premise):"Why wont it get passed, because its unconstitutional""Why is it unconstitutional, because it wasn't passed" Ipse Dixit(He said Himself): He said a lot of statements that he gave no evidence for, e.g. "They are using it to -hopfully- scare people off the app". also the og constitution gives the president very little power, and that is still partially true. While the common public view is that the president is very powerful, that is not(at least not supposed) to be true. This is why a judge said it was unconstitutional for the president to create an executive order. In truth, a single congressman has around the same power to pass laws as the president.
@@6256mateus Tiktok is owned by a chinese company. In China every single company has to give data to the Chinese government, so does tiktok. Also, Tiktok locked down their api requests and other stuff, so it is practically impossible to see what data Tiktok collects
the reason why Trump's attempt to shut down tiktok failed, was because of a executive order, AND the reason why Montana's attempt to shut the platform down ALSO failed is because a state cannot afford legal state fairs to shut down the platform that's the reason why tiktok will never shut down in the past, s, everyone tiktok is never shutting down because byte dance will most likely succeed in finding a company in the US that can buy the platform, so, if you hate tiktok everyone, I advise you to just ignore tiktok and move on (for tiktok haters) ALSO THIS is not a rude message, it's just a advice do you do agree???😀😀😀😄😄 Everyone who likes RUclips down here:👇 I love you all RUclips users........🤩🤩🤩😘😘😘😘😘😘🤩😍😍😍😍
I mean, technically it's not unconstitutional. It only applies for within the US, censorship of content from outside the US to the US and vice versa is legal
I think that includes most countries in the western hemisphere as well considering that the US is actually involved in most of its social media information and such so sensorship is likely to take effect in countries other than the US as well.
Even if the bill gets 100% Passed, it wouldn’t even be an immediate ban. The Bill would force Bytedance (the Chinese company that owns tiktok/douyin) to sell it within 6 months. Only after those 6 months can they vote to fully ban it, and only then if bytedance didnt sell it.
Fortunately if TikTok gets shut down it could possibly be temporary but I’m not a expert at this kind of stuff but there is a chance that the ban can pass unless they try to ban it in 2025-2026
Those terrible things will just happen on other platforms and possibly ones you're using. It's not about the actual platform but the users who exist on it. Keeping TikTok is somewhat of a necessary evil since their users are contained within the app and aren't infiltrating other places.
Even if I don’t use it, why would they ban it? It asks for information most apps ask for anyways. I get America’s mad cause its a Chinese company but it’s not like it’s going to get all the information stolen by the Chinese government or smth like that
i mean, it has the ability to feed information that influences opinions, it can learn what you're interested in, and if you want to get conspiracy theorist, it makes americans waste their time
Tiktok had it's pros as it helped many people wuth businesses etc. But there's more cons that are in depth neurologically and psychologically. If it does get banned, I'd like to see the impact because (based opinion) I know it may be a better change.
JUST cry children, you are not getting tiktok back!!!!!!!!!!😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂📢📢📢📢 😭😭😭😭😭😂😂😂😂😂😭😭😭😂😂😂😂 I bet all of the tiktok children who are watching the platform is now grounded forever, and there's no way for them to get there ipad back.....😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😘😘😘 I love you as always!!😘😘😘😘😘
Both tiktok and RUclips are the best platform ever even after all these years........................... i think THAT this dude is actually having nightmares about tiktok actually getting banned 😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I can almost guarantee myself the app will get banned, and I really hope it does because he's getting worse bro, I literally had a violation came up on one of my videos one of my most popular videos the audio was removed for being too long, bro it's been on there for a year and a half😂
tik tok is the single worst piece of software ever. it is a pathetic embarrassment to humanity. you kids will figure it out in a few years when you grow up and understand how life works.
Tiktok wont get banned if carter does the thug shake
As the president of the United States’ secret second account, I approve this message
YAAAAAA
@@k_Bones fake, ur sentence structure makes too much sense
@@pomato12321 this the new him didn't you see his latest speech 😂
Not in front of Diddy…. Plz
if Tiktok gets deleted maybe Carter will look at his youtube comments for once
hes bigger on tiktok than on youtube
THUG SHAKE
@@lostives exactly
@@lostivesthen he could make one final video to tell his tiktok audience to move to youtube
@@cleaner900playzno we don’t want his TikTok user base. Cringe
Bro is coping at this point
The reason the courts shut it down before wasn’t because of the contents of the laws, it was the jurisdiction of the people enforcing them. The courts just ruled that the states didn’t have the right to ban it, and that a tiktok ban wasn’t within the prerogative of the president. Stuff like this has happened before, like with Grindr, where social media platforms have to get their assets out of China. The federal legislative branch definitely has the power to create this ban, so it likely won’t be shot down by the courts.
Yes
I like this. Just no nonsense video that gets to the point and properly explains what we want to know.
Except hes grasping. Also wrong
Did you watch the video? Carter says stuff and adds no proof. he calls it unconsttutional for no particular reason. I am not gonna focus on any of the stuff the federalists wrote but I will focus on the amendments. 1st amendment; This is what most people have a problem with and think tik tok is breaking. The 1st amendment grants the freedom of the press, speech, religion, assembly, and right to petition against the government. Tiktok is not the press, tiktok is not being banned soley because of its content and content and opionions like it can be found on other platforms such as youtube, Tiktok is not a religion, Tiktok is not the only place you can assemble, but one of many, Tiktok isn't being banned because of petitions. Tiktok isn't a miltia so the 2nd amendment does not apply. I don't think banning tiktok will cause soldiers to sleep in your house, but maybe ig. The 4th ammendment is also know as "no search and seizure." Banning tikok doesn't take anything from you, so I think the ban is good with that one. I could go through all the constitutions and how the tiktok ban is fine with all ok them but every argument I've seen is about banning it violating the 1st amendment. Below is a full list of the fallacies Carterpcs made:
Ad miserorem(towards Misery): Carterpcs uses an unqualified appeal to miesery at the end by saying banning tiktok would be bad for him
Apriorism(Hasty Generalization): Carterpcs uses a past occurence with a different set aof situations. An executive order is much different than the entire legislative branch.
Circular reasoning(assuming the conclusion in its premise):"Why wont it get passed, because its unconstitutional""Why is it unconstitutional, because it wasn't passed"
Ipse Dixit(He said Himself): He said a lot of statements that he gave no evidence for, e.g. "They are using it to -hopfully- scare people off the app".
also the og constitution gives the president very little power, and that is still partially true. While the common public view is that the president is very powerful, that is not(at least not supposed) to be true. This is why a judge said it was unconstitutional for the president to create an executive order. In truth, a single congressman has around the same power to pass laws as the president.
he is VERY biased on this topic
Heavily agreed
And this my friends, is denial, aka the first stage of grief.
i'm sorry for your coming loss, carter.
They don tryna get the ban its second season 😭😭
Bros meatriding TikTok cuz it’s his only source of income 💀
Bro what's the problem with Tiktok?
I think RUclips shorts pays more than TikTok if I’m not mistaken it’s just that TikTok is the overall better app for short form content
He really is jamming tiktok up his ass in the hopes that he won't be unemployed 🥵
@@6256mateus Tiktok is owned by a chinese company. In China every single company has to give data to the Chinese government, so does tiktok. Also, Tiktok locked down their api requests and other stuff, so it is practically impossible to see what data Tiktok collects
@@6256mateusit’s a Chinese malware that steals users data same with Temu. when you download the app it has access to your phone without you knowing
I swear to god, tiktok will die out before it gets banned. bruh
no..
@@jaydenleckpa8381 yuh uh
the reason why Trump's attempt to shut down tiktok failed, was because of a executive order, AND the reason why Montana's attempt to shut the platform down ALSO failed is because a state cannot afford legal state fairs to shut down the platform that's the reason why tiktok will never shut down in the past, s, everyone tiktok is never shutting down because byte dance will most likely succeed in finding a company in the US that can buy the platform, so, if you hate tiktok everyone, I advise you to just ignore tiktok and move on (for tiktok haters)
ALSO THIS is not a rude message, it's just a advice do you do agree???😀😀😀😄😄
Everyone who likes RUclips down here:👇
I love you all RUclips users........🤩🤩🤩😘😘😘😘😘😘🤩😍😍😍😍
It's far from dead, it's still popular and it's the best app for short form content. Ahead of shorts by several miles
@@am8431 that is true but I was making a joke
It is absolutely constitutional under the Espionage Act, get your life together.
when TikTok gets banned!: sends spy balloons 💀
Bro is freaking out lol
Hopefully otherwise I’m really screwed last line is pretty hilarious 😊
petition to make carterpcs do the thug shake :
👇
wooah
yes
yes
No
He doesn't even see these comments 😭
Tiktok needs to be banned, FOREVER
He is just gas lighting himself into thinking it’s not getting banned
Bro did his homework lol 🤣
Nice vid
I mean, technically it's not unconstitutional. It only applies for within the US, censorship of content from outside the US to the US and vice versa is legal
I think that includes most countries in the western hemisphere as well considering that the US is actually involved in most of its social media information and such so sensorship is likely to take effect in countries other than the US as well.
No, its not, it is 100% illegal execpt in certain situations such as in WWII
just got scammed on amazon and now im running a intel core i5-6500 and 8 gigs of ram for $500
Owchiepoo
Bro doesnt want tik tok banned because then he will have to get a real job. 😂
Hey Carter just got my first first 😂
And on top of that, the company will probably sell it and even then if they don’t, everyone will just move to a different app so
"everyone" like americans aren't just 10% of the people using tiktok they will not sell it and tiktok will do just fine
carter has to do the thug shake
I think we need better quality control on Tiktok. The more eating Tidepods people see, the more eating Tidepods people will do
the tidepods thing died a long time ago
Hey you're not fully f’d you've got us shorts users
Like I said maybe we bring him over here
Carter's slow transition to a law student
no almost everything he said was false. source: THE F-CKING CONSTUTION
bro please do the thug shaker im begging you please just do the thug shaker
Even if the bill gets 100% Passed, it wouldn’t even be an immediate ban. The Bill would force Bytedance (the Chinese company that owns tiktok/douyin) to sell it within 6 months. Only after those 6 months can they vote to fully ban it, and only then if bytedance didnt sell it.
Carter you could have sped this up until it was a minute long so you could make this a short
Fortunately if TikTok gets shut down it could possibly be temporary but I’m not a expert at this kind of stuff but there is a chance that the ban can pass unless they try to ban it in 2025-2026
FAX PEOPLE KEEP SAYING IT GONNA GET BANNED WHILE ITS NOT
If tiktok got banned, the tiktok hair will be gone
THE COPE
besides from the app being chinese, tiktok is actually still a pretty horrible platform
gotta know the song
Macdonalds😂
Hopefully it does. Terrible things happen on that platform, and it should've gotten banned a long time ago.
Those terrible things will just happen on other platforms and possibly ones you're using. It's not about the actual platform but the users who exist on it. Keeping TikTok is somewhat of a necessary evil since their users are contained within the app and aren't infiltrating other places.
The terrible things in question = cringe that will exist anyways
@@Erons1528it isn't really that bad it's just idiots being idiots tiktok is still probably the Best short form content app
A few days ago they now have nine months to sell or it gets deleted so there selling and deleting it soooo and btw it did get by it got passed
So what? It's still a horrible app, regardless if they ban it or not.
Even if I don’t use it, why would they ban it? It asks for information most apps ask for anyways. I get America’s mad cause its a Chinese company but it’s not like it’s going to get all the information stolen by the Chinese government or smth like that
yea if they ban tiktok they would have to keep the same energy for other apps
i mean, it has the ability to feed information that influences opinions, it can learn what you're interested in, and if you want to get conspiracy theorist, it makes americans waste their time
I'm pretty sure the CCP can just ask for information from TikTok anytime they want
...so meta?@@KTibow
foreshadowing
My favorite poor Blackman
Yo let me 1v1 you in fortnite, im i switch player so im pretty bad. could i get a pc if it win
We gochu bro
Don’t warty carter you got us RUclips
Now do the thug shake 🔥
13 seconds?
this is like 3 videos after he said i dONt MaKe 1 MIn viDs GuYS
also do the thug shake
Tiktok had it's pros as it helped many people wuth businesses etc. But there's more cons that are in depth neurologically and psychologically. If it does get banned, I'd like to see the impact because (based opinion) I know it may be a better change.
Do the thug shaker
I think they wouldn't ban tiktok if there was a video of you doing the thug shake.
can we sign carter doing the thug shake into law?
True
Day one asking for an rx 6600
I want a PC
i don't think the thug shake will ever get banned either
He’s gonna be doing the thug shake for etirnity if TikTok gets banned for us on yt
Hopefully not!
I didn't believe it anyways cause they did the same thing in 2020
Do the freaking thug shake dude
Thug shaker post better come out before the bill gets passed :)
I know that the thug shake is legal
No what are the poor iPad kids gonna do
JUST cry children, you are not getting tiktok back!!!!!!!!!!😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂📢📢📢📢 😭😭😭😭😭😂😂😂😂😂😭😭😭😂😂😂😂
I bet all of the tiktok children who are watching the platform is now grounded forever, and there's no way for them to get there ipad back.....😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😘😘😘
I love you as always!!😘😘😘😘😘
Stay on RUclips shorts where they have always been
bro lookin goofy
Bros gonna have to get a job😂
i hope it gets banned so carter actually interacts with his youtube fanbase
Not first, im too good
SOmeone tell me what the Thug Shake is!!
First and can u make a video updating the Temu lawsuit?
No
They will send another child to give him pink eye if he talks about it again
@@SourDudeDude😂fr
Thug Shake
Thug shake
We got yt shorts
It sucks
@@fleimillo8497 stop watching
Save BLM or TIkTok ❌✅
IMPOSSIBLE CHALLENGE INFLUENCER EDITION
I believe you
This didn't age well, lol.
It’s still not banned tho😭what’s taking them so damn long
i don’t care if it gets banned or not i hate that fucking app
@@sonyadraughon9232i'm going to touch you
Based and redpilled
Both tiktok and RUclips are the best platform ever even after all these years...........................
i think THAT this dude is actually having nightmares about tiktok actually getting banned 😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I can almost guarantee myself the app will get banned, and I really hope it does because he's getting worse bro, I literally had a violation came up on one of my videos one of my most popular videos the audio was removed for being too long, bro it's been on there for a year and a half😂
orrrrrr theyre using it for that sweet sweet facebook money
We’re better anyway, we can get rid of ticktock
its only getting banned because its foreign
Rizz?
No rizz😢
@@VrIndieGamesShorts skibidi rizz😊😊😊😊😊
And im not a 4 years old
@@amrsanad7079 yeah for a second there I was thinking
tik tok is the single worst piece of software ever. it is a pathetic embarrassment to humanity. you kids will figure it out in a few years when you grow up and understand how life works.
Tiktok is probably the Best short form content app
if ticktock gets banned everyone of ur fans on tick tock will come to youtube
I think this is what youtube wants
We should ban you for not doing the thug shake
Day 11/Video 36 of asking Carter for a DJI drone
Day 1 of asking for a samsung galaxy S24 ultra
Day 3 of being annoyed when people say usb type c
Do the thug shake and they won’t ban TikTok
Day 1 of asking for a pc
I’ve been trying for one for 5 years but my family say it’s too expensive pls Carter 🙏
Hey guy I'm bored lol (the time is 3:33 for me rn)
fr bro
Pls biden do something for once and ban tiktok
I don’t really care, TikTok is an awful app.
Dammit
You doing the thug shake isnt banned so do it
Carter doesn’t know crap about politics lol!!
Yoooooo
that's becouse tiktok show the truth about the Israel the status of occupation
Yo