@FreyalovesJR Again thanks for your comments to answer your points 1)I know at least one competitor who used the video sites to comment for themselves2) I was/am not nasty to the competitors/viewers I just comment on what is clear.3) These comments were originally made months ago.
@FreyalovesJR Thanks for your comments I notice you are a particular fan of Jessica So I'll just say in competitions which this was you should be impartial. This does involve pointing out flaws as well and praising talent. As my interest in the winner of this competion was solely based on talent(I had no favourite) I had/have no problem or regrets with doing so.
Okay I think its mean to make these girls sing from Evita, but it is a good range to determin who will be Dorothy because Evita is one of the hardest scores to sing but like I said one of the hardest not many professional singers can sing the notes correctly
@goggz .... because it's one of his! :D @TheHughLundy I think, though Jessica moves heavily, she can act and sing better than Danielle and many others, though she's definately not the best...
@FreyalovesJR It was Jessica herself that was using the site(under a different name which by the way I have not problem with shows she is an intelligent lady))You comment about constructive criticism well this is a competition to appear in the West end not a local school production. Flaws should be corrected to give the public the best performance.Should the truth hurt either a) inprove,b)get a thicker skin or c) get out and take up something else
@futtiaddict Thanks for the reply certainly Sophie does have a very good and what I would describe as beautiful voice. Lauren would possibly have the bewst voice. Stephanie was very sadly overlooked and does have a very good voice as you point out.
@livzter At least Emilie putting in hard work and attempting to improve, she should be applauded for that. We are now a few years into the competion and what do we get from Jessica everyweek week the same overblown dramatics and vocals. Good luck to Jessica as a person but she simply does not have the natural talent of the other competitors to be a top musicial performance. We all have goals we dream about but somethimes it's best to wake up.
WAYO SOPHIE :) however. it has to be said. Jessie and Rachel did this so much better two years ago.. then again they had much more training seeing as it was the semi finals.. but yes.
@futtiaddict I wouldn't pay that much atention to what Charlotte Church says or thinks. Shouty is the perfect descrition for her so called singing, just my opinion but I'd rather listen to Danielle, Sophie or Lauren. Also could Ms Church have done as good a version of Cry Me A River than Danielle the answer is no.
Emile, Stephanie, Sophie, Jessica and Jenny havent been in the bottom2 yet so I think it cudb one of them thisweek lol hope not tho well wouldent care if it was Emile lol
Please watch this video very very closely then expain to me purely on talent how Danielle one of the two best dancers & one of the closest to acting a true Dorothy can be in the bottom two. Then how someone like Jessica who moves with heaviness and acts by making faces isn't. Again can the explaination be backed by evidence of talent.
@TheHughLundy I agree with your Danielle comments. Jessica I don't like.. I've gave my reasons on many videos... I've also noticed she ALWAYS sings AT the judges... so annoying.
@FreyalovesJR Not that I need to defend myself in anyway. By closely I mean carefully not the way most people were acting in their voting Ie I Like Jessica & don't care that she isn't up to standard which is clear when watched closely . I have nothing against her just see better actresses, singers & dancers.
@mckitty2008 It really cracks me up you can't even get my gender right.That's the first thing you've got wrong. Second I neither like or dislike anyone I don't know but base my judgement on the issue in hand. In this case talent has this is supposed to be a talent competition.Look at the evidence and then make a judgement on who has the most & least talent. Leave favourism for children's schoolplays.
@xxweexstarxx Thanks for putting me straight I will apply to you in future on questions of talent if that is allowed.Good luck with taking over the world and forcing everyboby to think your way. I will say what I want when I want as you are entitled to do as well. Now That is all- Thanks
I couldnt have put it better myself. Overblown dramatics and forced vocals. Did anybody see the acting Dorothy challenged when Jessica to a said, "Im a good actress, and I would like to show it today" I burst out laughing. She has taken musical theatre acting to a level which is clearly fake, everything is forced. Time to go I think. !!
what a load of crap.someone needs to tell andrew l webber to get back under his bridge to stop goats passing over. And why the hell are the beeb promoting his shows? I thought the bbc was an ad free zone. This is just one long weekly commercial.
Is it just my opinion that quality of group performance is falling every day? Girls, You can be as greedy and shiny as you want at your solo performance but group is group! You should make the harmony and concord! You are going to perform a musical theathre, not just a song. This is WORST group performance personaly. Finale was terrible, theres no adjective better!
I love the dancer with Steph always makes me laugh for some reason.
i love this song and i love evita
This performance is ACE!!!! :D JESSS
Great job ladies
brilliant
@FreyalovesJR Again thanks for your comments to answer your points 1)I know at least one competitor who used the video sites to comment for themselves2) I was/am not nasty to the competitors/viewers I just comment on what is clear.3) These comments were originally made months ago.
Steph fearon she is a great singer Says say goodbye to our Dorothy's
She sing
Over the Rainbow
@FreyalovesJR Thanks for your comments I notice you are a particular fan of Jessica So I'll just say in competitions which this was you should be impartial. This does involve pointing out flaws as well and praising talent. As my interest in the winner of this competion was solely based on talent(I had no favourite) I had/have no problem or regrets with doing so.
Never realised how short Steph is lol
First time I have seen the lord smile iduring this performance haha.
ughhhh emilie kills my ears EVERY TIME
Okay I think its mean to make these girls sing from Evita, but it is a good range to determin who will be Dorothy because Evita is one of the hardest scores to sing but like I said one of the hardest not many professional singers can sing the notes correctly
@goggz .... because it's one of his! :D
@TheHughLundy I think, though Jessica moves heavily, she can act and sing better than Danielle and many others, though she's definately not the best...
@TheHughLundy she has the whole 'boro' voting for her!!
haha.. the thought of Emilie in the west end!! :S
Now she is!
Jenny Is just the best [Of all]
@FreyalovesJR It was Jessica herself that was using the site(under a different name which by the way I have not problem with shows she is an intelligent lady))You comment about constructive criticism well this is a competition to appear in the West end not a local school production. Flaws should be corrected to give the public the best performance.Should the truth hurt either a) inprove,b)get a thicker skin or c) get out and take up something else
@futtiaddict Thanks for the reply certainly Sophie does have a very good and what I would describe as beautiful voice. Lauren would possibly have the bewst voice. Stephanie was very sadly overlooked and does have a very good voice as you point out.
@blueace1000 Why because she is from there or simply because she has the most talent. This is a serious question
@futtiaddict So who from this competition do you consider a good singer. I ask this as I'm curious what your idea of good is.
@livzter At least Emilie putting in hard work and attempting to improve, she should be applauded for that. We are now a few years into the competion and what do we get from Jessica everyweek week the same overblown dramatics and vocals. Good luck to Jessica as a person but she simply does not have the natural talent of the other competitors to be a top musicial performance. We all have goals we dream about but somethimes it's best to wake up.
WAYO SOPHIE :)
however. it has to be said. Jessie and Rachel did this so much better two years ago.. then again they had much more training seeing as it was the semi finals.. but yes.
cnt believe Graham said that this was from West Side Story !!!!!
@TheHughLundy I agree with you there I don't think Jessica is very good either and how she gets good comments is confusing!
@IndieHardcoreBaby I think Dani or Steph.. but it doesn't matter to me what they look like (:
@futtiaddict I wouldn't pay that much atention to what Charlotte Church says or thinks. Shouty is the perfect descrition for her so called singing, just my opinion but I'd rather listen to Danielle, Sophie or Lauren. Also could Ms Church have done as good a version of Cry Me A River than Danielle the answer is no.
sophie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Emile, Stephanie, Sophie, Jessica and Jenny havent been in the bottom2 yet so I think it cudb one of them thisweek lol hope not tho well wouldent care if it was Emile lol
@maddimags Emilie???? Huh???
Please watch this video very very closely then expain to me purely on talent how Danielle one of the two best dancers & one of the closest to acting a true Dorothy can be in the bottom two. Then how someone like Jessica who moves with heaviness and acts by making faces isn't. Again can the explaination be backed by evidence of talent.
@TheHughLundy wellllll u know. they are a very loyal lot. dont care much about talent. just looking after their own I guess.
@TheHughLundy I agree with your Danielle comments. Jessica I don't like.. I've gave my reasons on many videos... I've also noticed she ALWAYS sings AT the judges... so annoying.
@FreyalovesJR Not that I need to defend myself in anyway. By closely I mean carefully not the way most people were acting in their voting Ie I Like Jessica & don't care that she isn't up to standard which is clear when watched closely . I have nothing against her just see better actresses, singers & dancers.
He
@mckitty2008 It really cracks me up you can't even get my gender right.That's the first thing you've got wrong. Second I neither like or dislike anyone I don't know but base my judgement on the issue in hand. In this case talent has this is supposed to be a talent competition.Look at the evidence and then make a judgement on who has the most & least talent. Leave favourism for children's schoolplays.
@xxweexstarxx Thanks for putting me straight I will apply to you in future on questions of talent if that is allowed.Good luck with taking over the world and forcing everyboby to think your way. I will say what I want when I want as you are entitled to do as well. Now That is all- Thanks
I couldnt have put it better myself. Overblown dramatics and forced vocals. Did anybody see the acting Dorothy challenged when Jessica to a said, "Im a good actress, and I would like to show it today" I burst out laughing. She has taken musical theatre acting to a level which is clearly fake, everything is forced. Time to go I think. !!
i cant stand jessica, she is so bad, wayyyy too much, i just want her out! SPAM forehead, and she is really up herself, its dire. LAUREN TO WIN!!
lauren exellent emille awful
this is bad, the solos are pretty good, but all together it's bad. Listen to Patti and you'll learn how to sing it.
what a load of crap.someone needs to tell andrew l webber to get back under his bridge to stop goats passing over. And why the hell are the beeb promoting his shows? I thought the bbc was an ad free zone. This is just one long weekly commercial.
Is it just my opinion that quality of group performance is falling every day? Girls, You can be as greedy and shiny as you want at your solo performance but group is group! You should make the harmony and concord! You are going to perform a musical theathre, not just a song. This is WORST group performance personaly. Finale was terrible, theres no adjective better!