They appeared only once, this performance. Maybe they did not get good viewer ratings, they were not invited back. I wish they will be given another chance.
Yeah, I know and aware of that. Same thing happen to other kpop groups like Miss A, Vixx, Sunny Hill etc. But I hope Spica would get another chance because all of them got good vocal.
OMG! Spica us a vocal group. Their vocals are unmatched by any in Kpop. You talk about enthusiasm, what about vocal performance. Many people think vocals are about belting out high notes, and Spica has that. But holding a soft tone and controlling that tone shows more vocal skills. All of Spica has that, cant say the same for any other Kpop group. Its not about short skirts and cute outfits, its about the music, always has been. Bohyung takes all of this to the highest level. Bohyung is the best!!!
I feel like the only difference in them and mamamoo is that their company manages them wrong... or else they should have been a permanent cast on immortal songs 2 and/or all of them should have been on masked singer... they're really talented and beautiful... it bugs me that they aren't that famous... well I can still be a new fan I guess.. 😋
Wow I don't know Spica but they're voices have so much depth, I love it! Too bad they don't get more attention, I regret not knowing owing about them earlier
SPikachu Sings really well. TO much Idols in south korea, if they were in china or some else east asia, they should be the top singers! So many idols sing fabulous, but a whole group who sings altogether is really rare. I like Spica
Best K-pop girl group that can really sing!!! They should be more popular that snsd or fx or any other girl group with just their talent!!! But on top of that they can dance and sing and they all look so gorgeous, they are the whole package. To bad they are very underrated, but u cant deny their talent and they always sing live!
You're so right!! I started to like K-POP because of Spica... I already knew some groups like Snsd, but Spica showed me the real meaning of talent and charisma!!! i Love them
indeed I like them both. I am a sone (fan of SNSD) for 4 years, each member have their own talent and their teamwork is no joke. for Spica, this group have the strongest vocal line I have ever seen. the members are their own characteristics too. but I must say SNSD and SPICA belong to different styles - SNSD is kpop-idol group while SPICA is more like Westernized vocal group, it's hard to compare ....so I think why not like them both :) just my opinion
As read everyone comments etc.. I makes myself to evaluate both performance mamamoo and spica.. Srsly spica voice is soo perfect when live soo good. But somehow their singing looks like a doll. I means ofcs they put emotion but what ppl listen and see like me i cannot really enjoy the whole song. Ofcs arrangement of is diff and i hope the company did justice to this group but yeah as i said they singing quite a doll.. Holding awkward and straight hand when holding mics 😅 but still killing slay peefect vocal 😍😍 also harmonies looks struggle and thy seems forced to not enjoying (the expression i means) overall i can said they done great job 😍 hoping fr all members performing but nvm this trio is still beautiful slaying performance 👍🏻👍🏻
Ha, I feel like I had immersed myself too much into Mamamoo's awesomeness! Going back to the good old Spica feels so good ** I love those groups so much! I was kinda trying to compare the 3 versions of the song to see which interpretation was the closest to the original but then I realised that it makes no sense haha ^^; I mean, Mamamoo has this awesome feel and groove with strong vocal, but they can't go into perfect harmonies like Spica, not yet ;) And Spica can't own the stage like Mamamoo does, because they have such a unique way to do it! I think those two collaborating would just kill every single other group out there, definitely :D
+Alysse Kim Hm.. if I'm just basing on this specific spica's performance, i would say mamamoo did a better job harmonizing. the harmony here sounded very forced. personally feel the girl in blue here doesn't have that stable a voice either. Boa is definitely the best here..
+Alysse Kim i feel like you don't know what good harmonization is. Both are good but spica is more rough with their harmonies than mamamoo is. I love both, but spica features more individual voices than mamamoo does.
+sabs really everyone in mamamoo has a different sound they are just able to blend them together better than spica. I used to follow spica really well until their songs became to mainstream, didn't really fit their voices, and to be honest kind of boring. Mamamoo has everything spica doesn't really have. Stage presence, variety talent, and better lives while dancing.
+Kyana Takafuji i agree that spica has less stage presence compared to mamamoo, but i think their two recent sonngs have different feelings with ^mainstream songs^. i am talking about tonight and you don't love me of course. ghost sounds decent too. but yeah, i agree they need to work on their confidence on stage. they have the talent. they need to know to use it well. i'm a fan of both btw. :)
Realtalk: both MAMAMOO and SPICA are great vocal group. They're way so much better compare to other girl groups who just lip sync in their every performances.
End here while searching for Mamamoo's version and I have to say they are REALLY good. I thought I wouldn't like it but end up being totally wrong. Congrats to the, it was a beautiful performance
I'm sad to say this because I thought I'd like spica's performance, but it's just lacking that enthusiasm. I feel like I'm watching a performance, whereas I want to see them feel the song and be a part of the song. The mood of the performance was almost scripted and "go through the motions". The only part I really felt engaged was when the three people harmonized and sang counter melodies. SPICA members all have great voices, but there's just something missing :/ I really wanted to like them too...
This is the wrong type of song for them. Their greatness can't be seen here besides the fact that 2 members are missing. Mamamoo is versatile and create their own choreography and are among the best entertainers in Kpop. Spica can sing anything also but sometimes a song just doesn't fit them and that's the case here.
at 3:07 they were struggling to do harmonies.... Spica's members are amazing singers by themselves but when they are all together they just don't blend in a group, they don't have that "team" feeling Mamamoo has.
+Heya 혜야 their management seems to suck. I only learned of them through Mamamoo, and that is sad. They should get much more spotlight. I hope they get some killer, catchy comebacks and better management to get the word out.
i really really hope that their next performance (if there will be one) is a ballad, they don't need to dance! Boa's and Bohyung's voices need a better song!
I wish they wouldn't have tried to make the song and image cute skier. I really wanted them to have straight brooding stage filled with their powerful vocals
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Mamamoo and Spica should Collab! they both have amazing vocals!
SPICA and MAMAMOO both sang this...I feel like it's a sign. Collaborate soon pretty please?
Spica should appear on Immortal Songs more often. they definitely got the voice.
They appeared only once, this performance. Maybe they did not get good viewer ratings, they were not invited back. I wish they will be given another chance.
Yeah, I know and aware of that. Same thing happen to other kpop groups like Miss A, Vixx, Sunny Hill etc. But I hope Spica would get another chance because all of them got good vocal.
this is what idol performances should be like. still looking like idols wearing cute outfits and nice dances with AMAZING vocals
OMG! Spica us a vocal group. Their vocals are unmatched by any in Kpop. You talk about enthusiasm, what about vocal performance. Many people think vocals are about belting out high notes, and Spica has that. But holding a soft tone and controlling that tone shows more vocal skills. All of Spica has that, cant say the same for any other Kpop group. Its not about short skirts and cute outfits, its about the music, always has been. Bohyung takes all of this to the highest level. Bohyung is the best!!!
one of the most talented girl group in kpop and most underrated girl group.hope they will get lots of attention and love ...spica
I miss spica :(
I feel like the only difference in them and mamamoo is that their company manages them wrong... or else they should have been a permanent cast on immortal songs 2 and/or all of them should have been on masked singer... they're really talented and beautiful... it bugs me that they aren't that famous... well I can still be a new fan I guess.. 😋
They're so underrated.
Wow I don't know Spica but they're voices have so much depth, I love it! Too bad they don't get more attention, I regret not knowing owing about them earlier
I think of the same thing too
Narae's voice during that blending/harmony part!
wow i love spica i love 5pica Please bring them back to immortal song :(
I love their voices! Please bring them back to immortal song!!
Amazing performance! Amazing voices!!
SPICA
For me this is the best among flying into the deep night covers out there
so beautiful, so flawless, so perfection, so SPICA!
I need Spica again in Imortal song!!! PLEASE!!!
SPikachu Sings really well. TO much Idols in south korea, if they were in china or some else east asia, they should be the top singers! So many idols sing fabulous,
but a whole group who sings altogether is really rare.
I like Spica
proud be Mercury, spica hwaiting! ♥
This song, their voice and their performance is totally addicted!! I'll look for spica from now :D
Best K-pop girl group that can really sing!!! They should be more popular that snsd or fx or any other girl group with just their talent!!! But on top of that they can dance and sing and they all look so gorgeous, they are the whole package. To bad they are very underrated, but u cant deny their talent and they always sing live!
Make that Spica AND Mamamoo
+Vly Sato can't more agree XD
Fantastic performance! I'd love to see the whole group on this show next time!
Why don't people appreciate spica the way people go crazy for snsd? :( it saddens me
Snsd is Funny And talented . I Love SPICA TOO :( BUT SORRY , I More Like SNSD
Thanks, I was very interested in who you like because I care
:) SPICA HAVE a POWERFUL VOICE
You're so right!! I started to like K-POP because of Spica... I already knew some groups like Snsd, but Spica showed me the real meaning of talent and charisma!!! i Love them
indeed I like them both. I am a sone (fan of SNSD) for 4 years, each member have their own talent and their teamwork is no joke. for Spica, this group have the strongest vocal line I have ever seen. the members are their own characteristics too. but I must say SNSD and SPICA belong to different styles - SNSD is kpop-idol group while SPICA is more like Westernized vocal group, it's hard to compare ....so I think why not like them both :) just my opinion
really love them, going to support them always...
Everytime i listen to boa, i got eargasm... Dunno why but her voice is really something
Spica,Mamamoo and Kyuhyun version. I like them all. They nailed it by their own colour. Not to forget the original Lee Moon Sae. 😊❤️
park narae was among the top 10 of superstar k 1st season, enough said.
오랜만에 소름 쫘악~~~~
Bohyung looks so cute when she smiles :)
they r so good, my lovely ladies ;P
잘한다....!!!!^^
노래 참 잘해요.. 흥했으면 합니다.. ^^
노래다잘부른다..
이그룹은 그룹전체가 잘합니다
진짜노래잘불러요
와ㅏ.좋다
SPICAAAAA
우와 대박..
As read everyone comments etc.. I makes myself to evaluate both performance mamamoo and spica.. Srsly spica voice is soo perfect when live soo good. But somehow their singing looks like a doll. I means ofcs they put emotion but what ppl listen and see like me i cannot really enjoy the whole song. Ofcs arrangement of is diff and i hope the company did justice to this group but yeah as i said they singing quite a doll.. Holding awkward and straight hand when holding mics 😅 but still killing slay peefect vocal 😍😍 also harmonies looks struggle and thy seems forced to not enjoying (the expression i means) overall i can said they done great job 😍 hoping fr all members performing but nvm this trio is still beautiful slaying performance 👍🏻👍🏻
I just know this song from Miss Korea , this is an old and awesome song, SPICA sang it well \m/
Awesome
As moomoo i see Spica is the hardest contender for girl groups, sadly they re not lucky enough for the management
노래진짜 잘해 ㄷㄷ
Oh my God, when they did that harmony near the end, I flipped my shit
Ha, I feel like I had immersed myself too much into Mamamoo's awesomeness! Going back to the good old Spica feels so good ** I love those groups so much! I was kinda trying to compare the 3 versions of the song to see which interpretation was the closest to the original but then I realised that it makes no sense haha ^^; I mean, Mamamoo has this awesome feel and groove with strong vocal, but they can't go into perfect harmonies like Spica, not yet ;) And Spica can't own the stage like Mamamoo does, because they have such a unique way to do it! I think those two collaborating would just kill every single other group out there, definitely :D
YAASS I CAME HERE CAUSE I WAS SEARCHING SPICAN AND MAMAMOO I LOVE THEM OMG
+Alysse Kim Hm.. if I'm just basing on this specific spica's performance, i would say mamamoo did a better job harmonizing. the harmony here sounded very forced. personally feel the girl in blue here doesn't have that stable a voice either. Boa is definitely the best here..
+Alysse Kim i feel like you don't know what good harmonization is. Both are good but spica is more rough with their harmonies than mamamoo is. I love both, but spica features more individual voices than mamamoo does.
+sabs really everyone in mamamoo has a different sound they are just able to blend them together better than spica. I used to follow spica really well until their songs became to mainstream, didn't really fit their voices, and to be honest kind of boring. Mamamoo has everything spica doesn't really have. Stage presence, variety talent, and better lives while dancing.
+Kyana Takafuji i agree that spica has less stage presence compared to mamamoo, but i think their two recent sonngs have different feelings with ^mainstream songs^. i am talking about tonight and you don't love me of course. ghost sounds decent too. but yeah, i agree they need to work on their confidence on stage. they have the talent. they need to know to use it well. i'm a fan of both btw. :)
SPICA~
Bohyung is amazing!
SPICA tienen unas voces asombrosas
Realtalk: both MAMAMOO and SPICA are great vocal group. They're way so much better compare to other girl groups who just lip sync in their every performances.
THEY'RE AWAY TO AMAZING FROM ANY OTHER IDOL GROUP!!
End here while searching for Mamamoo's version and I have to say they are REALLY good. I thought I wouldn't like it but end up being totally wrong. Congrats to the, it was a beautiful performance
They 're so amezing, They're singer, isn't idol
진짜 실력
Bohyung ♥♥
Aw man, wished they chose another song that fits them better! But I do like the quiet, slow little part in the middle where they harmonise :)
2020 guys? Anyone?
i like spica and mamamoo
but this song i choose mamamoo
they did better
바로 떨어져서 아쉽다...
불명 무대를 더 많이 봤으면 좋았을 텐데!
스피카 한번 더 불명 갑시당~!ㅎㅎㅎㅎ
ㅇㅈ~~~~!! 스피카는
셋시항곡 해야되는뎅
진심 김보형이랑 김보아는 불명에서 몇주 고정 했음 좋겠다 ㅠㅠ 인지도 쌓고 하면 충분히 대박칠 그룹인데 기획사가 너무 초짠가...
is this only Narae Boa and Bohyung?
원곡보다 조타 ㅠ
I love spica's version best!! Watched mamamoo's version too, but still prefer spica XD
I wonder if they won.
Hadir
Still extremely mad about their disbanding
spica and mamamoo should collab
lup
I'm sad to say this because I thought I'd like spica's performance, but it's just lacking that enthusiasm. I feel like I'm watching a performance, whereas I want to see them feel the song and be a part of the song. The mood of the performance was almost scripted and "go through the motions". The only part I really felt engaged was when the three people harmonized and sang counter melodies. SPICA members all have great voices, but there's just something missing :/ I really wanted to like them too...
This is the wrong type of song for them. Their greatness can't be seen here besides the fact that 2 members are missing. Mamamoo is versatile and create their own choreography and are among the best entertainers in Kpop. Spica can sing anything also but sometimes a song just doesn't fit them and that's the case here.
1:33 In the back, on the right, isn't that Hyori's boyfriend? I've watched this video quite a few times and didn't even notice.
Why the hell is this age-restricted?
jungsica maomao I dont know
at 3:07 they were struggling to do harmonies....
Spica's members are amazing singers by themselves but when they are all together they just don't blend in a group, they don't have that "team" feeling Mamamoo has.
Who's the blonde one? I love her voice ♡
she is kim boah the leader
thanks :) i really like her
Anyone know who they were up against and if they won? :)
mamamoo.. spica.. hmm.. i choose mamamoo cuz they put "latin parts?".. kekekeke
Love them but why are they wearing Dirndl lol
wheres jiwon?
Can someone tell me why they aren't known??? U_U
+Heya 혜야 their management seems to suck. I only learned of them through Mamamoo, and that is sad. They should get much more spotlight. I hope they get some killer, catchy comebacks and better management to get the word out.
양갈래 머리땋으신분 성함이 뭔가요? 걸크러쉬ㄷㄷ
이진 0:13 박나래
0:33 김보형
1:10 김보아
i really really hope that their next performance (if there will be one) is a ballad, they don't need to dance! Boa's and Bohyung's voices need a better song!
Who is the original singer of this song?
It's Lee Moon Sae. Original ver: /watch?v=Utke41C6xzU
t was not a good song choice... They couldnt really show the power in their voices. Too sad :/
좋은데 옷이 좀 별로 ㅠㅠ 다음엔 이런 핑크핑크 컨셉보다 보컬에 더욱 집중할수 있는 성곡을 하길^^
ㄹㅇ..솔직히 예스터데이때 했던 곡같이만 해도 ㅎㄷㄷ인데ㅜㅜ
did they win?
They lose:(
NARAE
como que se les perdieron dos chicas a SPICA hahaha
This cutesy shit is beneath them, because they can actually sing.
I wish they wouldn't have tried to make the song and image cute skier. I really wanted them to have straight brooding stage filled with their powerful vocals
정말잘하는데 한국엔 아이돌이나 가수들 너무많아 중국이나 다른나라에선 이만한실력이면 이미최상급
park narae also got significantly outdone by her own members throughout the performance, enough said.
마마무가 편곡한게 훨씬낫다......tvcast.naver.com/v/304315
제발 스피카 영상에서 마마무언급좀 안했으면 좋겠네요 마마무영상도 아니고
실력 비교하라는 영상도 아닙니다.
두 그룹대로 매력이 있는거지 누가 잘했냐가 아닌것 같은데요 댓글 삭제좀 부탁드려요
실력은 스피카가 훨씬 위임^^
스피카가 더 나음
@@제-p7c so..? 😂
could’ve easily ended taetiseo
노래 잘하는 여자아이돌은 많다 근데 그룹 전체가 잘하는건 브아걸 빼곤 못본거같다 진짜
What the hell man, your ears are what they suck.. XD
the blue dress cant sing