The Broken Promise That Doomed The World To War | Impossible Peace | Timeline
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 авг 2020
- When WW2 became inevitable. While all of Czechoslovakia is annexed, the curtain goes up on what will become the world's first truly global and total war.
It's like Netflix for history... Sign up to History Hit, the world's best history documentary service, at a huge discount using the code 'TIMELINE' ---ᐳ bit.ly/3a7ambu
You can find more from us on:
/ timelinewh
/ timelinewh
This channel is part of the History Hit Network. Any queries, please contact owned-enquiries@littledotstudios.com
After re-watching WWI and WII documentaries these last few days, the similarities that lead up to the wars are eerily similar to what we're experiencing today.
Agreed. Do we ever learn?
@@metamorphicme9378 nope
Why is it that Europe gave us two world wars and now it seems we are on the verge of a third one, also given to us by Europe...?
@@metamorphicme9378 We became complacent and our adversaries know Biden is feckless and ineffectual. They watched the disaster that was the Afghanistan exit.
I’ve been experiencing this is exact same thing, watched a few days worth of WW2 documentaries and history is definitely repeating itself
"The blind leading the blindfolded" is a beautiful synthesis - even though it expresses a evil that happens way too often.
Two hours eventualities be lenient in nine days -:- dont name investments lent before-:- elodies half time investments
ernest becker has a clarifying explanation of humanity's evil
I think "in the devils dance" would have been a better ending for that quote, so that is how I am going to remember it.
The reason why Hilter thought Brittian would sue for peace was Chamberlain's desperation for appeasement.
3:07 The tragedy of decent men is to expect that others are also decent. The tragedy for the world is that authoritarians regard decent individuals as an opportunity for personal power.
Decent men should not be so naive.
@@fkjl4717 Yup. Decent men (and women) should be educated about the selfish, potentially-violent egotism of too large a portion of males.
@Min Tin Nope, never for no reason. Personal power and dynastic ambitions provide reasons aplenty for greedy authoritarians.
The GREAT decent men who recognize that authoritarians are EVIL will fight for decency.
The only problem there is that in order to vanquish the evil, decent people need to be capable of otherwise nasty behavior.
As Victor Davis Hanson points out, we can't win playing Marcus of queensbury rules.
@@jaydouglas8170 Agreed. “Beware that, when fighting monsters, you yourself do not become a monster... for when you gaze long into the abyss. The abyss gazes also into you.”
― Friedrich W. Nietzsche
Happily, although first conceived to protect the powerful, laws and equitable law enforcement can be used to disempower malfeasants by isolating them from society. In other words, lock tRUMP and his cadre of thieves up.
This has been one of the best documentary series I have seen on RUclips. Great stuff and so glad I found this channel. Too many history docs rely on poor reenactments and hyperbolic pro-wrestling style narration. Glad to see someone making documentaries for curious, thinking people.
You need to also check out the "People's Century" documentaries on here, very interesting.
@@VincentRE79 - Thank you for the recommendation. Wow, the "People's Century" is a great series as is this channel.
@@CadillacFleetwood68 No problem. People's Century is superb, don't know how I missed it at the time.
0l
Oh that’s a nice 👍🏿 p
I love documentaries that give me more than just the military facts.
This was a good one.
+Henrich Schmidt They dont mention that the infratructure improvment and how the organized crime families were destroyed in Germany?
@@strikerorwell9232 You always have to omit something.
And why do you call me 'Heinrich'? You have only seen my name in writing?
@@henrikschmidt3964Oh? Sorry I didnt notice that? Anyway? They always exaggerate how "horrible" it was living under Napoleon, Stalin, Pinochet etc. Some good stuff and I mean wonderful stuff is always neglected to be mentioned by the historians even if it was tough for some people? You learn to appreciate the small things in life even under the French revolution and so on! I mean, they could perhaps enjoy some good cinnamon buns in the trenches in WW2? Its to much gloom and doom in these documentaries. Its called THE GOOD OLD DAYS for a reason.
@@strikerorwell9232 it’s not that the government were all bad. If literally everything they did was bad they wouldn’t be power very long. It’s just the fact you know... they were Nazis...
@@strikerorwell9232 He Made The Trains Run On Time
This is one of the best documentaries I have ever witnessed regarding MUNICH. And believe you me, I have seen them all. This is a wonderful, enlightening exposé of the times. Thank you for posting.
I have seen countless works on the subject but this is truly brilliant. Footage I have yet to see somehow, quotes I've yet to hear and the quips from the narrator are just perfect.
Excellent with a lot of bonus, often ignored information and intersting
arguements. Thank you for making this available to everyone.
“The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.”― Edmund Burke.
Sigh~
I say this every time someone tells me they don’t or won’t vote.
"A quote everyone can agree on regardless of what ideology they have" - Human.
@@AFGuidesHD biast quote so far
@@ryrify "if voting changed anything, they wouldn't let us do it." -Twain
Wake up, these problems are too big to be solved by voting
Twain was a satirist.
The best series you ever uploaded!
It is unbelievably good!
History is repeating itself as we speak
This has to be one of the best documentaries I have seen on RUclips. Well-researched with insightful opinions.
There's 2 versions of what happened in World War 2 : "The Official History" and "The Secret History". Which version do you like?
People, you are truly making the best and most quality documentaries! You were talking about real things and important things and you reveal things we didnt know previously. While many bog broadcasting companies should truly be ashamed of so called documentaries they are making which neither consist of historical truths nor the written and video material which can back it up and alike. You are the only documentary makers I trust, honestly. Thank you for all this you brought to us and keep up the good work!
It "started" quite innocently, way before WW2.
*With a London policy.*
I'm sure the British population and the inhabitants of Empire would have been happy if their toffs hadn't made Germany the enemy as a default setting.
The best way to avoid going to war altogether, is to have leaders who don't make others "the enemy" as a default setting...
[britannica(com)com/topic/balance-of-power]
*According to London's own policy:*
"Within the European balance of power, Great Britain played the role of the “balancer,” or “holder of the balance.” It was not permanently identified with the policies of any European nation, *and it would throw its weight at one time on one side, at another time on another side,* guided largely by one consideration-the maintenance of the balance itself."
*The Germans, became "the enemy" because of where they lived and what they had (economy/power).*
They took over this "role" from France, after 1871.
They dared unite, and industrialize, and raise their own standard of living away from a purely agrarian society.
Note: nothing personal.
The policy didn't mention any names.
It was simply "policy".
*A few London lords made entire nations the "enemies" as a matter of policy.*
It came first before all other considerations.
It practically dictated how London acted (commissions as well as omissions) regarding
1) alliances
2) treaties (or no treaties)
3) non-aggression pacts (or no non-aggression per accord)
4) neutrality in a dispute (or when to jump in and meddle)
5) whose "side" to chose in crises (irrelevant of "right" or "wrong" from an objective standpoint)
6) when to engage in arms races
7) whom to "diss" and whom to "snuggle up" to at international conferences/peace conferences
*Go over your history, and see its handwriting all around...*
Enjoy.
@@ralphbernhard1757 b Jr? Ĺ
All the amazing people we lost in the fight against evil.
Their souls are were they want to be
One of the best if not the best history series I've seen in a very long time!
Not many lessons seem to have been learnt from this period of history in today's world !
Watched all of the 'shows' leading to this one. Will probably go back and watch them again. Thought provoking. Will have to look into some of this more closely.
Thanks!
Thank you for uploading these!
Really excellent documentary series, one of the best. Full of interesting facts, new photos and videos. Highly recommend
What chamberlain and the Munich agreement teaches us is that people are outcome determinative. When chamberlain came waving the Munich agreement the people cheered en masse. When war later came about, people criticize.
No one knows the future and I was not alive at the time. Maybe it was more obvious that appeasement was not the way to go.
In almost every foreign policy issue, we are presented with both basic sides. Peace or war. How far one will bend and “appease” to avoid war or be inflexible is the question historically presented to leaders and the people.
Yet people only judge on the outcome and then decide whether the choice was correct.
Those last few minutes of narration are chilling. Great stuff
It must be remembered that when Chamberlain returned to England saying "I believe this is peace in our time," he was acting as anyone would, from the small lens through which he could see the world in his day.
This was an excellent series to watch, there was so much footage I had never seen before and very balanced attention to detail. Thank you!
Incredibly amazing !!
I have watched and saved all this episodes for future reference.Well done.👍
Thank you so much for uploading this video. It is helping me get through the pandemic!
This "impossible peace" series really was incredible. I learned so much about a decade that is glossed over with the bullet points usually. If only France, and Britain to some extent would have been a lot kinder to Germany after ww1, ww2 could have been avoided.
The main problem was France. Bismark deliberately misused France in 1870 to unify Germany (after the victory) in 1871 and by the way took Alsace-Lorraine from the French. This has upset the French politics so much that they were not thinking rationally when preparing the "Peace Treaties" with Germany, Austria and Hungary. It was this revenge spirit that lead Maréchal Foch, French General of WW I, to make the statement "this is not a peace. It is an armistice for 20 years".
Versailles insured another war? It was a bad peace deal.
Different accolades untie different isolations. On this site I’ll repeat a catastrophic formidable formulation payout in guarantees to less arrears. On this or that it’s the untie in its untold indices.
Thats what we are living now, thats why Macron said we do sanctions but we should not humiliate Russia.
@@constantinioan5425Well, maybe, not everybody had nuclear weapons back then, so restraints were less serious.
Excellent and informative all around. Diolch yn fawr!
This is great! Well-done, and thank you :)
I made it almost 4 years without catching covid.
I found your page about a week before. For 3 days now I've loved all the videos.
Thank you!!!
This is a really good series as far as regular TV productions go.
4sure... Between Netflix, a free movie app & RUclips, I dont even have/miss cable tv!
These types of comments do make me laugh. Who even watches regular TV anymore, other than over 50's? Regular TV is stuck in the past in terms of production.. all that fake drama and silly "celebrity" stuff that just appeals to an audience of the past.
It out does anything I've ever seen by far. On any channel in any era. 90's even which is a quote I think I've said maybe for the first time in my life. 90's owns every title, except a very very very small few, this being one of them. This channel is simply, and I mean so awestrikingly "THE BEST!!!!!!!!"
Just finished watching this for the second time all the way through. Fantastic production.
My lord! the footage is really amazing stuff!
Excellent documentary. Thank you
Excellent, with great depth, and analysis, and at the same time keeping in line with that well spoken english.
It "started" quite innocently, way before WW2.
*With a London policy.*
I'm sure the British population and the inhabitants of Empire would have been happy if their toffs hadn't made Germany the enemy as a default setting.
The best way to avoid going to war altogether, is to have leaders who don't make others "the enemy" as a default setting...
[britannica(com)com/topic/balance-of-power]
*According to London's own policy:*
"Within the European balance of power, Great Britain played the role of the “balancer,” or “holder of the balance.” It was not permanently identified with the policies of any European nation, *and it would throw its weight at one time on one side, at another time on another side,* guided largely by one consideration-the maintenance of the balance itself."
*The Germans, became "the enemy" because of where they lived and what they had (economy/power).*
They took over this "role" from France, after 1871.
They dared unite, and industrialize, and raise their own standard of living away from a purely agrarian society.
Note: nothing personal.
The policy didn't mention any names.
It was simply "policy".
*A few London lords made entire nations the "enemies" as a matter of policy.*
It came first before all other considerations.
It practically dictated how London acted (commissions as well as omissions) regarding
1) alliances
2) treaties (or no treaties)
3) non-aggression pacts (or no non-aggression per accord)
4) neutrality in a dispute (or when to jump in and meddle)
5) whose "side" to chose in crises (irrelevant of "right" or "wrong" from an objective standpoint)
6) when to engage in arms races
7) whom to "diss" and whom to "snuggle up" to at international conferences/peace conferences
*Go over your history, and see its handwriting all around...*
Enjoy.
But what is wrong with this policy? It largely kept the peace in Europe for the 19th century, and each European nation knew about it. 'The balance of power' included Britain itself, and its function was to maintain a peace, not to dominate another nation or keep them subservient. Germany invaded France three times in 70 years. Germany was a militant state and an active aggressor. If he wasn't, then he may well not have been the 'enemy' to keep the balance.
Excellent and informative all around. Diolch yn fawr!. An excellent documentary. It would be even better if you provide subtitles.
Very well done. Thank you.
Loved this series
Dude the quality of thus channel , muah!
TIMELINE BRILLIANT GREAT WORK THANK YOU ❤
Excellent writing & narration!
This is series is good. I've seen some episodes and have found some inaccuracies but it's overall well documented using historic images, masterfully narrated by Charlton Heston and beautifully adorned by quotations from great personalities who lived those years. I think it's a good source for anyone who want's to know more about the period but I should remind that using more than one source and looking for different points of view is always the best road - with this and any other source in any media.
I love this series !! My friends laugh & say I should be knitting !!
It is not Charlton Heston narrating; it is a British/Australian man., called Rod Mullinar.
@@marthae9338 regardless he sounds like an old British Tom hanks
An excellent documentary. It would be even better if you provide subtitles
Fantastic reportage 👌
This made me aware of something I haven't thought of. The Munich agreement was very much the same as the Soviet german nonaggression pact.
The Polish-German non-aggression pact of 1934 bounded both parties to resolve territorial disputes by peaceful means. Port of Danzig with 90% of Germans was under international supervision since 1918 but later occupied by Poland. The Danzig dispute started Polish- German war in 1939 and WW2.
The attack on Poland started after the Germans dressed as poles and made attacks on Germany, as a justification to attack Poland. The poles actually held their military quite distant from the border so to not appear aggressive towards Germany (which was also beneficial for Germany when they attacked because the polish military couldn't immediately defend)
@@tomlxyz Wrong, Poland declared war on Germany on the 31st, and Germany invaded the next day. Poland, assured of victory by the British and French promises to come help became arrogant and suddenly refused to negotiate with the Germans after keeping them on the line for five years. Then the Poles started to kill ethnic Germans, 58K of them missing by the time Germany invaded, the Gleiwitz incident probably never happened.
11:31 which one do you think set the pace there?
it looks pretty fierce...
and which one broke out in a sweat first?
Agreed. This turned out to be a good Doc. Pretty awesome in fact.
Its incredible how much conflict was going on, between countries, and inside the civil conflict of their own countries. In school we were taught basic stuff..but never this much info. I love history, and i enjoy teaching myself cause school didn't do justice by me.
The fact that you pronounce it "Duci" instead of "Duce" like the second "e" of "even" as it supposed to be pronounced, it makes that word so funny and with a cuddle/snuggle fx that right now I'm having a series of jokes and comedy sketches in my mind about Mussolini.
Just the thought that today we are Somewhat near to strange times like those ones makes the hair at the back of my neck straight.
Dumbing down society then Booom.. Look up Sheikh Nurjan mirhamdi
Don't the riots remind you of a poorly executed krystalnacht or what?
How are we near? What nation is currently planning world domination and destruction of neighboring peoples?
Not prelude to war, but the vibes of Weimar Republic can be seen in the west
We are living through *nothing near* those times. The *stock market* is priced for a Biden/Harris victory- and is _still_ within 90% of it's all time high. The *worst events* of the last 6 mos. would be at most a *page three* story in most newspapers if it wasn't an election year.
Nice work.
This is really great.
Well written and presented.
Look up ‘impossible peace’ for the episodes in proper order. The series comes as a playlist covering the interwar period (1919-1939)
Very good, thanks.
Anyone else getting an eerie sense of history repeating itself...
Very sad. But even today we are walking towards a situation of multiple crisis: the crisis of the two-parties-only US-democracy (leading nation in the 20th century but now in a clear decline), the crisis of the economy which is not willing to understand that the resources on the planet are limited and nature needs space for stability, the crisis of our natural environment that might lead easily to a worldwide total collapse of the eco-system (extinction of key-insects, poisoning of the oceans) with Apocalyptic dimensions, the man-made climate crisis, the crisis of human overpopulation.
Overpopulation is no longer a problem outside of Africa and the Muslim Middle East.
@Steve Duke 😅😂😅😞
What lessons for our world of today!
Such a cowardly nation today can't even leave the house without a face cloth
@@ItzAdam03 lol 12 months on and they’re back
It's also worth noting that the EE has 128-bit registers called MMI (Multimedia Instructions) which act on the quarks, working with them as vectors of 64-bit, 32-bit, 16-bit or 8-bit vectors.
You are great. Thank you
Politics is a difficult task that politicians who are greedy , incompetemt and immoral are not able to fulfill !
I know very little about what went on in Spain during this period when British focus was on the western front and their allies in France. I seem to know little about this chapter in general.
Spain is quite strangely disconnected during that time with its internal struggle, yet also a "training ground" for fighters
Wow amazing series!
Damn 20 years of peace would be unprecedented today.
the people who made this documentary seem to have a severe lack of knowledge on the USSR
I find the senator from Louisiana's statement to be quite odd in that the state had held on to several laws from its era of being a French colony. The most notable, in my opinion, was that the offspring of a free person and a slave was free. The outlandish part that everyone seems to have overlooked is that the freemen of New Orleans organized not for the Confederacy, but for defense of their city. Due to that the Confederacy was actually the first to have Blacks fighting for it, and the first to have integrated units.
He was a radical racist. They’re goal is always the same in the south. Return of Jim Crow, and to use blacks as slaves or cheap labour. And also as a scapegoat/distraction for the hatred of the whites who are losers in the system who feel a narcissistic/entitelment for supremesy based on genetics not merits or human rights
good work
This is very good. I particularly liked your defense of The League of Nations.
Great series. Mark Felton is also amazing
Thank you for an excellent documentary.
But, please , skip the background music when narrator or the interviewees are speaking.
In my mind it is either speach or music - but not in the same time.
Right! The easiest method would be to drop the music volume during speech. It might be too much to ask for a score built specifically for the doc.
this channel has the most articulate, well presented documentaries of the major conflicts of WW1 and 2, by far. Attention to detail, pacing, choice rare movie clips and even narrative tone express a concern over quality that seems unique
Phenomenal series. Thank you! I never liked Churchill, and now I even more understand why.
We find ourselves at the cusp again that 'world's gone wrong '
There's an interesting documentary that debates weather Hiroito, the Japanes emperor, was responsible for the Imperial Army actions. The interesting thing is why Japan decided to become an empire - it all started when Japanese leaders saw the Chinese subjugated by the British. China is the Greece of Asia - the most important source of culture and philosophy in the region - and seeing the Chinese under British rule made the Japanese so angry and in disbelief they decided to become the British of Asia.
Love and support from India 🙃🙃
Netflix for history huh? Favorite line. Riding that wave 🤣. Great docs tho.
After watching this very interesting series, you wonder what's crazy things went on between 1930-39. Yet today; with everything that's happened in 2020 including all the hotspots around the world etc, it would seem just one spark and the whole lot will go up, due to the complexities of many of these situations, there will be no backdoor diplomacy, nations will not be able to back down, with this the world population is again, through the roof. Best we tread very carefully.
Just seeing if any of this plays into todays issues. Or aligns with Albert Pikes plans for WWIII
Man is this good or what , History for everyone 🤩
Timeline is amazing
liked and now I'll start watching
What this documentary is wrong about is stating that the Munich agreement, as unjust and brutal as it was to the Czechs did not buy time. Britain was not prepared for war in 1938.
Britain did buy time... for themselves. The mistake was they did almost nothing to use that additional time to prepare for war whereas the bought time allowed Germany to continue to build up their forces even further. One of the very reasons Dunkirk became a disaster for Britain was because they procrastinated.
Imagine a student who was already granted an extension on an assignment still complaining they 'didn't have enough time' to finish it.
It's VERY expensive to prepare for a war. Especially when you are not certain that it will happen. And, especially, when you are an island protected by the world's largest navy and have no need to 'prepare for war' until a war has begun. You don't just spend countless billions preparing for something that might not happen when you don't need to. We were already defended, and we knew that we could build up an attack over-time.
this series is very interesting and the film footage is amazing. I pause the video, very often, and try to imagine living in these places. what must those huge rallies have been like?? Can you imagine planes flying over with Stalin's picture? Yikes.
Very interesting documentary
So Neville Chamberlain is forced out because of his disastrous campaign in Norway, and then replaced by the man who was behind the disastrous campaign in Norway "Winston Churchill" ? umm that makes sense doesn't it ?
Humans.. “ we come in peace “ . An advanced Alien civilisation, “ I think I will pass thank you “
Thank you
Wow, that is the best defense for the League of Nations that I have ever heard, pretty interesting.
As soon as I saw the notification,I was Fast and Fuhreous to click the video
So, England promises to never go to war with Germany again and then a few years later declares war against Germany and no one sees a problem with this picture?
They would've obviously invaded England anyway Dolphus
Peace is just the calm before a storm
Excellent.
Good point- democracy doesn't *die in the dark-* it dies without the *gold standard.* 47:38
that doesn't make sense, the gold standard was a terrible and outdated system. The subsequent obstinacy of the US to limit how much money they spend on the New Deal directly led to the WW2. They wanted to keep gov spending as low as possible, so while the new deal proved a solution it was not good enough. 10 years later, the US would spend 5x more for the war. If the US spent the money it did in the war on the New Deal, depression in Germany/across EU would have been alleviated, and very likely, WW2 would have been mitigated or averted entirely.
Britain was not ready for war. WW1 had bled Britain white and another war would tear their Empire apart. Chamberlain was in a difficult position.
Ive watched this over and over. The writing is superb. But can anyone tell me the order in which they are to be viewed? The titles dont give any sense of the proper sequence. For example 1 of 10, 2 of 10 etc.
Awesome reference to "The Lady Vanishes"!
It's even up here on the RUclips for those curious.