I’m going through all albums as stated but for some reason I just hit action to answer before all to action…no worries I will do that one as well. I think I just got the order mixed up 😅 Also I stated that I would be doing live performances in the video so don’t forget to leave links to performances you want me to watch. Otherwise I’ll just pick whatever I find and watch that instead. Thank you!
EDITED: I made a playlist of “ALL TO ACTION” lyrics videos which the members lines are more accurate!!! Here’s the link: ruclips.net/p/PLqr0sSMck-MC3FjLMGymM0rWL5Or6EuLy --------------------- Here’re the links for the performances: ^^ Treasure EP.3 live stages Wave : ruclips.net/video/3mHbMzBE8Ls/видео.html Illusion : ruclips.net/video/rqT0jWdElc0/видео.html Utopia : ruclips.net/video/ivpkMLWL-rE/видео.html Aurora : ruclips.net/video/4_hycuJAA34/видео.html Dancing like butterfly wings : ruclips.net/video/AcmJ3a4PenU/видео.html Action To Answer live stages : Answer : ruclips.net/video/aE-rUO6BWks/видео.html Horizon : ruclips.net/video/dJl8tbVmxK8/видео.html Star 1117 : ruclips.net/video/UeLkI1yxs2Q/видео.html Precious live : ruclips.net/video/bEXbpAOpbjM/видео.html start @ 4:06 - Other legendary performances: (must watch) MAMA 2019 : ruclips.net/video/0R6tRuVFVrQ/видео.html MAMA 2020 : ruclips.net/video/tQJIszK1EOo/видео.html TMA 2021 : ruclips.net/video/YBhKb2Bv2YQ/видео.html GDA 2020 : ruclips.net/video/__mCL1kdZMk/видео.html KCON 2019 : ruclips.net/video/nCxoi-i1Zrc/видео.html Wonderland Halloween Stage : ruclips.net/video/AFP6QLw0ClY/видео.html IMMORTAL SONG PERFORMANCES: Immortal song “BLACK CAT NERO” ruclips.net/video/lnhGb-MO4vc/видео.html Immortal song “ANYHOW SONG” ruclips.net/video/3fiFK89RFhY/видео.html Immortal song “ITS RAINING” ruclips.net/video/6pH4QRQObKY/видео.html Immortal song “RIGHT NOW” ruclips.net/video/lBqV4I4_0Tc/видео.html Immortal song “FANTASTIC BABY & NILLILI MAMBO” ruclips.net/video/OP1aCSufqJg/видео.html KQ Fellaz Performances: ATEEZ(KQ Fellaz) Performance Video 1 ruclips.net/video/5A9EMLrURS8/видео.html ATEEZ(KQ Fellaz) Performance Video 2 ruclips.net/video/Eh9LI9EpK2E/видео.html ATEEZ(KQ Fellaz) Performance Video 3 ruclips.net/video/H7flzjxjQNc/видео.html
also for star 1117 yes! that actually was seonghwa and hongjoong respectively hehe and the transition from treasure to precious live on stage is absolutely chilling holy crap especially when hongjoong gets possessed and he falls to the ground and then carves the word "ATEEZ" on thr floor..... God it's really life changing i want to see it in concert so bad
THIS!!! the transition from treasure to precious brought chills on my arms when I saw it live. if you ever get the opportunity, I genuinely hope the perform both songs back to back as they did for my show.
@@hiitsdes7325 i really hope they keep it on the set list for future tours i need them to come to southeast asia T__T hongjoong is insane live all of them are it's incredible they sound better live and their energy can be felt so strongly even as i was keeping tabs on every tour stop through twitter like Wow.... so happy you got to see them live 🥺
This is why Treasure series will be one of the most seamless and exquisite discographies that came from a kpop artist, Ateez will be branded as the pirates of kpop, they have a story to tell and you're definitely in it for a wild ride. Being Atiny is the best part of it too.
Precious is literally my favorite Ateez song and I love how it connects to Treasure. First time I heard it, the ending got me so hyped. When they perform it live, they actually do Treasure and Precious back to back and it's so good. I love it so much. I really do love when they do callbacks to their old songs.
The Horizon choreogrpahy is probably one of their most iconic and it's extra awesome because Yeosang takes the spotlight during the chorus and he absolutely bodies it. San and Yunho do some aerial work in the prechorus and the bridge too and it's stunning, there's a dance practice for you to check out as well as multiple live stages, watching the song be performed live definitely does make it even better imo
They did perform Star 1117 on tour! I had gone to the NJ show and let me tell you... when they did this song, Atiny had sung back and it had Hongjoong in tears and it was emotional as heck. Its so dang special
I was there too. I'm glad I read your comment, or I would've written the same thing. He totally lost it because he thought he'd never be in front of Atiny again...and to see 20k people must have been so overwhelming. So glad I got to be a part of it.
30:18 WHEN I TELL YOU I HAD THE SAME EXACT REACTION 😭 Them bringing back some of the melodies/portions of some of their other songs will never fail to make me tear up
I'm so glad you were just as blown away by precious as we all now. You HAVE TO see their stage where they perform Treasure and then seamlessly transition into Precious 😭😭😭 it gives me goosebumps every single time! Great reaction as always Caitlin 💕🌼
At 4:13 during Horizon, Yeosang was actually singing, not Seonghwa. At 4:28 it was Yunho singing instead of Jongho. Also, at 5:41 it was Seonghwa’s voice again, and not Yunho’s.
you should really watch horizon performance cause yeosang ROCKED. and precious UGHH you should watch the one from their concert at korea where they performed precious and continue with treasure!! HONGJOONG KILLED IT!!
@@caitlinbensonn 😂😂 i’ve a strange love for incongruence in music… the weirder the better! Good thing Ateez has a song for each and every human in this planet lol
Precious is one of my favorite bside tracks, they sang it in their concert, medley with treasure and it really sick. They eating cds and they are good in live. I cannot
Precious is one of my all time favorite songs, the drop is just divine! im a sucker for the panflute sound👌its supposed to be a sequel to treasure, they always perform those 2 together and its so cool 😭 also the lines in horizon were very wrong... not just a line or 2, almost a third of the song was wrong lol, just so you know
Phew your reaction just reminded me how HARD Precious goes, loved it! Also agree with everyone else in the comments, live stage performances for some of these songs are wilddd, and Horizon choreo is one of my faves!
You do not know how beyond excited I was when I found out that an extended version of Precious was gonna be on this album!!! I absolutely loveeee Precious and it’s one of my favorite Ateez b-sides!!! Star 1117 is such a precious and comforting song for me and I’m so glad to have been following these incredible 8 guys since the very beginning.
The dance practice for Horizon is what sold me on that song, it is a whole different experience and I'm so excited for when you get the chance to see it!! I love your reactions, thank you for reacting!!!
I'm so happy that you finally reacted to this EP. (also Horizon is in my top 5 song list from their songs😍) This is one of my favourite album from them. Also sorry if I ask this question, probably you already told us, and I was just forgetful, but did you already reacted to the All To Action album? Cause I can't find it in your channel.
Star 1117 was absolutely beautiful live! Especially the part where we sing back to them (San's part in the last chorus). If you have time later one, I'd recommend you watch clips of it live during their latest tour. (The longest and clearest videos I've seen of it are from the last two days of the tour, which was LA.)
All to Action was actually before this album. Action to Answer is the epilogue for the treasure series and then we go back in time before all the treasure era happened and enter the fever series which is before they became pirates. Now since the fever series is the prequel to treasure series, after fever epilogue is Say My Name/Hala Hala and then pirate king until Answer. That’s the timeline of their lore 🤍 everyone’s excited for the next era because no one knows what to expect next since fever and treasure series are over
yesssss another amazing reaction ! let me tell you Horizon and Precious have been on my top songs playlist on spotify for 3 years in a row and yet i have never read the lyrics to them ! i feel so ashamed right now 😩but glad i could go through the journey of falling more in love with these songs thanks to you. Also i had never paid that much attention to the outro and how that connects to the rest of the storyline! since Answer is the end of the Treasure series, and the Fever series is what happened before they became pirates, it makes me even more excited for what's to come in their universe !
i always really appreciate how you gush about how much meaning you get from ateez's music!! i'm 8 months late to this video but somehow, coincidentally, i quite literally JUST read a rolling stone interview with ateez where they talk about the effort that they put into writing lyrics and connecting to those who listen, as well as how atinys analyze their lyrics, and how much that means to ateez. watching your reaction and how you always take the time to try and analyze what's going on and how much their music reaches you immediately made me think of that article, and so i feel really grateful for atinys/reactors like you that show that kind of love so generously towards their efforts in their art, even when something isn't exactly your taste!
just to help u out cuz we knowhow these lyric videos go: HORIZON -the beginning, the back and forth is between Wooyoung and Seonghwa -the choruses is Yeosang not Seonghwa -the beginning of the 2nd verse is Yunho, not Jongho, then Seonghwa follows -the back n forth is still Wooyoung and Seonghwa -that drop that showed Jongho was actually Yunho. -YES THERE IS A LIVE STAGE!! CANT WAIT FOR U TO SE IT!!! STAR1117 -yes that is Seonghwa. -YES that is Hongjoong -that rift in the background during Jongho part is San. the one who harmonized with Jongho was Seonghwa. -yes they did! this tour was the first time they performed it in front of I-atinys 😭 PRECIOUS -pls ur expressions where literary us. -yes this is linked to Treasure! -Hong wrote this song pre-debut, along with Treasure, so just imagine how long they where sitting on this track!!! -u HAVE to see this tour stage performance!! they always perform this back to back with Treasure!!
Yay happy for another album reaction :) Yes in Star 1117 it was Seonghwa + Hongjoong. The lyric guide got it wrong in Horizon: the switch in the verses between Wooyoung + Yunho is actually Wooyoung + Seonghwa ^^ Looking forward to your live stage reaction, Yeosang gets center time in Horizon :3
They sang this on concert. In Korea they were all a crying mess during their first concert and in Prudential Center Hongjoong cried so much, I cried with him 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
what a welcome surprise thank you for starting march off so well caitlin 🥺 hope it'll be a better month to you 💗💗💗 also hongjoong actually wrote horizon predebut but it was saved for this album the epilogue album to tie of their treasure series and its perfect 🤍
OMG AM I REACHING BUT I JUST REALIZED NOW IN PRECIOUS There is a line "Is this place a dream or reality" And the album after this is the start of the Fever series which started with a dream (Inception) and ended with The Real 🤯🤯🤯
yeah you should react to their fellowship version of treasure+precious, they performed it together, its really crazy!!! you can see their desire towards treasure or somethin
I always look forward to your reactions and this was no exception! I love that you appreciate and talk about the lyricism and the instrumentals on top of the vocals/rap! Your genuine love for music shines so much and I love it To answer your question about if they did Star 1117 on tour, they did! I was ugly sobbing the entire time (I can't even watch my fancam LMAO it was a mess) and at my stop (Newark) Hongjoong broke down when we started singing our part of the song, so it made me cry harder 😭 ATEEZ love ATINY so much, I seriously love the bond we have with them ❤
I cannot put into words how much I love this EP. Probably this is my fav Ateez album. If this would be a jubilee type of an album in their career, I would probably say "oh they are leaving at the top so hats off!" but NO they just released it in their first year which is insane. This EP has just put the most delicious cream on Treasure era which makes this era so distinct for me.
horizon felt like a little much for me too the first time i heard it but then it kept growing on me sm to the point where now its one of my favs b-sides, so i get what you mean
Fr precious is THAT good. Such a bop. My dad always ask me to blast that song on full volume whenever we drive lmaoo! Can't wait until you react to the live stage to this song omg
thank you so much for including info about Ukraine. there is no people who really wanted this to happen neither in Ukraine nor in Russia. I’m talking about civilians. all of us are suffering: people in Ukraine because of shelling, both Russian and Ukrainian army have already lost thousands of soliders, people are in captivity and Russians are under sanctions and a lot of pressure because someone REALLY THINKS that ALL CITIZENS wanted this war. are u serious? I hope that RUclips won’t be blocked here, because reactions is the only one thing that can prevent me from crying. please can we have a world without war and conflicts? stay healthy everyone💙
Horizon tends to be a grower for many people. In my opinion, I think the disorienting feeling of Horizon is intentional. Sort of the idea of being lost at sea, searching for something and kind of not sure where you're going? That's my take on it anyway. Plus, as you've guessed, the choreo enhances the music in a really cool way as well
i'm so excited for you to react to horizon's dance practice and/or live stage- its very much a performance song and really gives each member a time to shine. horizon is personally one of my favorite songs by them, but i wasn't in love until i saw the dance practice and live stage. as for precious, i absolutely LOVE how it's a clear refrain of treasure and i can't wait to possibly see you react to their joint stage of treasure + precious because of how well they go together. and until you pointed out that callback to utopia ("every day, every night") i didn't even notice, that's crazy! thank you for reacting to ateez!
always love your reactions and super excited for all to action! i haven't finished watching yet but just wanted to say Horizon's lyric video is actually mostly wrong, so if you get a chance definitely watch their live stages (either from SeoulCon like the Pirate King/Treasure stages you reacted to before or from M Countdown). Precious live stage is also amazing and I hope you can react to that one too!
Not me crying with you listening to Star 1117 😭 Ateez do deserve the world yess 🥺🥺🥺 Also, Hongjoong is really out there with those amazing vocals 🥲 If you ever get the chance, please check out his covers, they're so good, his take on the songs are just *chef's kiss* 😌👌
I just love your Ateez reactions they are always amazing 💕. You should definitely check out concert ver. of Treasure+Precious that performance really gives me chills Seoul concert version is available on youtube as well 😆
it doesn't matter how many times i listen 2 precious, live or studio, the segway into the treasure intro will forever give me fucking goosebumps. this album always gives me a intense feeling of euphoria, ugh
the bridge they created for the end of the Say My Name MV, Precious and then Treasure will always be one of the most surreal things Ateez has ever done
Awww my babiesss😍😍loved your reaction like always Caitlin! I defo recommend watching their live performances in your own time to get to know their voices better they can all sing and rap at this point 😂 so you might get confused😅
Yay another ateez reaction. Can’t wait for you to react to All to action cause my fav song Thank U is there. That song will emotionally wreck you hut in a happy way 😆. Also why did it only occur to me after watching your reaction that the ending of say my name could have been the teaser to precious instead of treasure.
Loved how they incorporated Psytrance into Horizon! Definitely one of my fav songs from them Precious is up there too tho,, i just love me some nice drops haha
Omg, SAME GIRL, I more confused 😅. Also, Precious is really really interesting, you will keep finding references to other songs, and is directly connected to Treasure!
Hey Caitlin, it's so nicee to see u react to ateez again! It's been a while 😭😭❤ I just want to tell u that i love ur reaction so much! Please always be happy and healthy, i'll always waiting for another reaction from u ❤
Actually as this album in chronological order is right before Fever part 1, it makes sense that Precious refers to Inception! I never paid attention to the lyrics of Precious after Inception was released but ye x) To me this album is my favorite (Answer being my fave title track too)!! Just what I usually need ~~ Horizon is a huge favorite of mine, also because of the choreo (and who gets the highlight hehe) so maybe it'll grow on you this way ~~
Honestly, for me it took me a few plays of horizon but now its up there with my favourites and is also a great gym song lol. but yes precious, desire, hala hala and promise are like my faves and i feel theyre all kinda the same vibe? lol you'll deffo love precious (overture) on all to action. but precious/treasure live perf is highly recommended!!
Thank you so much Caitlin!! I love your reactions so much!!❤️❤️ also, will u react to ATEEZ’s variety shows again? It’s been a long time🥺🥺 I hope u doing well
The outro kinda blew my mind up when i first heard it. My brain cannot handle this whole giant ateez lore. But my take on this one, Since they already got what they're finding when they started sailing, now they're facing another struggle and hindrances that maybe someone out there are hunting them down now. Let's not forget they're pirates so what is pirates without a villains who's after them right? And even after watching don't stop mv. I actually believe after they got their treasure someone stole it from them specially the ship and now they're actually sailing again to bring it all back together. Idk anymore hahahaa. The point is we can never actually grasp everything together. Ateez's story line is one hell of a journey and it's too hard for me to understand. But I'm trying tho haha. Btw, i miss this Caitlin. Thank you for always making time to react to our boys. You made my day. God bless you and your channel ☺️
ATEEZ albums are all no skip albums. But, for me personally, ALL TO ACTION IS TOP TIER :) That album is SUPERIOR. I'm really, really looking forward to your reaction to MIST, SUNRISE, and THANK U, because those songs literally blew my mind. Just thinking about the fact that you would finally react to ALL TO ACTION makes me so excited. 🤸
Yessss it is seonghwa and hongjoong there xdd and hightly recommend their live stage of star 1117 because you can clearly see how their emotion put in :)))) And highly recommend their live tour stage of Precious their choreo is crazyyyy!!! Treasure first and precious next as twins is link tgt when they perform usually and storyline too :))) Hongjoong mentioned in interview their storyline is not even in half so is question more lmao
I will be praying and continue to pray over Ukraine. I know the Lord is with them every step of the way those who are now deceased and those who are aren't. And I will also pray and continue to pray for you and your family Caitlin. I know that during your live stream you mentioned that week was not a good week for you and I don't want that to happen to you. I will put you in my prayers for your mind to be at ease, for you to be healthy and in good condition mentally and physically, to be able to not worry about anything. Only happiness! Well, in all honesty, you are one of the few people to bring me contentment. And I apologize if this is weird but I consider you family to me which I don't have. I remember watching one of your Stray Kids reactions which is another of the few people I consider family and I really enjoyed what was being brought to my eyes. So I want only and I mean only happiness for you, Caitlin!!!! Sorry for this being so lengthy. ☹️🤗
Actually the outro supposed to have the music on the last part of answer mv where the white masked guy appeared. Also that music is the latest hint we have for what is coming next if we follow their storyline since fever series is placed before the treasure series. I'm very looking forward for you to listen to all of the greatness in the EP. FIN: All to Action album, I actually can't wait for real😆😆
Horizon and Precious live stage are insane !!!! FOr STAR 1117 live stage, you will cry a lot esp there's part of tge song where atiny will sing back at ateez you should watch it
All the live performances of this whole album are the Best, you have to watch it, Is you are a Yunhopower I recommend you Horizon live stage 100% And star1117 concert versión 😭💖
![CHAEMURA [EUNCHAE - NI-KI] BEING SYNCHRONIZED](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vjzyF6ty3nE/mqdefault.jpg)
I’m going through all albums as stated but for some reason I just hit action to answer before all to action…no worries I will do that one as well. I think I just got the order mixed up 😅
Also I stated that I would be doing live performances in the video so don’t forget to leave links to performances you want me to watch. Otherwise I’ll just pick whatever I find and watch that instead. Thank you!
It's okaayy either way we're still grateful for your reaction!
EDITED: I made a playlist of “ALL TO ACTION” lyrics videos which the members lines are more accurate!!!
Here’s the link:
ruclips.net/p/PLqr0sSMck-MC3FjLMGymM0rWL5Or6EuLy
---------------------
Here’re the links for the performances: ^^
Treasure EP.3 live stages
Wave : ruclips.net/video/3mHbMzBE8Ls/видео.html
Illusion : ruclips.net/video/rqT0jWdElc0/видео.html
Utopia : ruclips.net/video/ivpkMLWL-rE/видео.html
Aurora : ruclips.net/video/4_hycuJAA34/видео.html
Dancing like butterfly wings : ruclips.net/video/AcmJ3a4PenU/видео.html
Action To Answer live stages :
Answer : ruclips.net/video/aE-rUO6BWks/видео.html
Horizon : ruclips.net/video/dJl8tbVmxK8/видео.html
Star 1117 : ruclips.net/video/UeLkI1yxs2Q/видео.html
Precious live : ruclips.net/video/bEXbpAOpbjM/видео.html start @ 4:06
-
Other legendary performances: (must watch)
MAMA 2019 : ruclips.net/video/0R6tRuVFVrQ/видео.html
MAMA 2020 : ruclips.net/video/tQJIszK1EOo/видео.html
TMA 2021 : ruclips.net/video/YBhKb2Bv2YQ/видео.html
GDA 2020 : ruclips.net/video/__mCL1kdZMk/видео.html
KCON 2019 : ruclips.net/video/nCxoi-i1Zrc/видео.html
Wonderland Halloween Stage : ruclips.net/video/AFP6QLw0ClY/видео.html
IMMORTAL SONG PERFORMANCES:
Immortal song “BLACK CAT NERO”
ruclips.net/video/lnhGb-MO4vc/видео.html
Immortal song “ANYHOW SONG”
ruclips.net/video/3fiFK89RFhY/видео.html
Immortal song “ITS RAINING”
ruclips.net/video/6pH4QRQObKY/видео.html
Immortal song “RIGHT NOW”
ruclips.net/video/lBqV4I4_0Tc/видео.html
Immortal song “FANTASTIC BABY & NILLILI
MAMBO”
ruclips.net/video/OP1aCSufqJg/видео.html
KQ Fellaz Performances:
ATEEZ(KQ Fellaz) Performance Video 1
ruclips.net/video/5A9EMLrURS8/видео.html
ATEEZ(KQ Fellaz) Performance Video 2
ruclips.net/video/Eh9LI9EpK2E/видео.html
ATEEZ(KQ Fellaz) Performance Video 3
ruclips.net/video/H7flzjxjQNc/видео.html
It's okay. I always mix up the order of the albums as well
i suggest you horizon performance theyre very GOOD, thanxx
reminder that Hongjoong wrote Star1117 as a birthday gift for us and the Seoul concert in 2020 was the first time they sung it for us to us
also for star 1117 yes! that actually was seonghwa and hongjoong respectively hehe
and the transition from treasure to precious live on stage is absolutely chilling holy crap especially when hongjoong gets possessed and he falls to the ground and then carves the word "ATEEZ" on thr floor..... God it's really life changing i want to see it in concert so bad
THIS!!! the transition from treasure to precious brought chills on my arms when I saw it live. if you ever get the opportunity, I genuinely hope the perform both songs back to back as they did for my show.
@@hiitsdes7325 i really hope they keep it on the set list for future tours i need them to come to southeast asia T__T hongjoong is insane live all of them are it's incredible they sound better live and their energy can be felt so strongly even as i was keeping tabs on every tour stop through twitter like Wow.... so happy you got to see them live 🥺
This is why Treasure series will be one of the most seamless and exquisite discographies that came from a kpop artist, Ateez will be branded as the pirates of kpop, they have a story to tell and you're definitely in it for a wild ride. Being Atiny is the best part of it too.
Precious is literally my favorite Ateez song and I love how it connects to Treasure. First time I heard it, the ending got me so hyped.
When they perform it live, they actually do Treasure and Precious back to back and it's so good. I love it so much. I really do love when they do callbacks to their old songs.
The Horizon choreogrpahy is probably one of their most iconic and it's extra awesome because Yeosang takes the spotlight during the chorus and he absolutely bodies it. San and Yunho do some aerial work in the prechorus and the bridge too and it's stunning, there's a dance practice for you to check out as well as multiple live stages, watching the song be performed live definitely does make it even better imo
Horizon became one of my favourite tracks as soon as I saw the performance for it, you should definitely check it out when you can!!
I will be checking out live performances ☺️
@@caitlinbensonn amazing! take your time though there’s no rush 💕💕
They did perform Star 1117 on tour! I had gone to the NJ show and let me tell you... when they did this song, Atiny had sung back and it had Hongjoong in tears and it was emotional as heck. Its so dang special
I was there too. I'm glad I read your comment, or I would've written the same thing. He totally lost it because he thought he'd never be in front of Atiny again...and to see 20k people must have been so overwhelming. So glad I got to be a part of it.
I went to LA day 1 ugh it was so heartwarming 😭
I was there too. I had to prepare my heart for that part . I always cry to this song . I’m person was so different .
I was there too! I killed me!!!
30:18 WHEN I TELL YOU I HAD THE SAME EXACT REACTION 😭 Them bringing back some of the melodies/portions of some of their other songs will never fail to make me tear up
Yayyy another Ateez album, I'm so excited 🥺✨
During a concert, right after hongjoong's part, atiny will sing back to them which I I find it so 😭
Ahhh during star 1117
I'm so glad you were just as blown away by precious as we all now. You HAVE TO see their stage where they perform Treasure and then seamlessly transition into Precious 😭😭😭 it gives me goosebumps every single time! Great reaction as always Caitlin 💕🌼
At 4:13 during Horizon, Yeosang was actually singing, not Seonghwa.
At 4:28 it was Yunho singing instead of Jongho.
Also, at 5:41 it was Seonghwa’s voice again, and not Yunho’s.
Horizon personally got me like jumping into rollercoaster ride..some parts make me hyping, some parts make me sentimental 😭
you should really watch horizon performance cause yeosang ROCKED. and precious UGHH you should watch the one from their concert at korea where they performed precious and continue with treasure!! HONGJOONG KILLED IT!!
Horizon is literally one of the best songs i’ve ever heard in my life
It’s a good song but i struggle with the verses…not sure about it yet.
@@caitlinbensonn 😂😂 i’ve a strange love for incongruence in music… the weirder the better! Good thing Ateez has a song for each and every human in this planet lol
same! I instantly love Horizon the first time I listenes to it even though it sounds weird but I love that about it
@@caitlinbensonn that was me on my first month listening to it, after that I can't go on a day without listening to it 😂
I never noticed it before but in “Precious” during the chorus that whisper of “Precious” behind everything gave me chills omg
Precious is one of my favorite bside tracks, they sang it in their concert, medley with treasure and it really sick. They eating cds and they are good in live. I cannot
Honestly when I heard star 1117, I promised to myself that I'm gonna always support the boys, no matter what !!
Precious is one of my all time favorite songs, the drop is just divine! im a sucker for the panflute sound👌its supposed to be a sequel to treasure, they always perform those 2 together and its so cool 😭
also the lines in horizon were very wrong... not just a line or 2, almost a third of the song was wrong lol, just so you know
finally u hear star 1117, aaa i love ur reaction caitlin 💗🌤😆
Finally someone reacted to Star 1117 and gave it the love it deserves
caitlin will never be free from the tears during an ateez album reaction haha! anyway, ateez discography is always so good.
AAAAAA ANOTHER ATEEZ REACTION! THANK YOU CAITLIN! ✨💖💖
Phew your reaction just reminded me how HARD Precious goes, loved it! Also agree with everyone else in the comments, live stage performances for some of these songs are wilddd, and Horizon choreo is one of my faves!
This warms my heart, thank you for appreciating ATEEZ
this is crazy im too early lol! hope you’re doing well Caitlin, and having a good week!! your reactions never disappoint!
Actually at first I was thinking like you said about Horizon as song. But Now I love this song so much and really like the changing in it!
Ahhh Caitlin, I really missed your ATEEZ reactions. So happy you're doing another one!
You do not know how beyond excited I was when I found out that an extended version of Precious was gonna be on this album!!! I absolutely loveeee Precious and it’s one of my favorite Ateez b-sides!!! Star 1117 is such a precious and comforting song for me and I’m so glad to have been following these incredible 8 guys since the very beginning.
The dance practice for Horizon is what sold me on that song, it is a whole different experience and I'm so excited for when you get the chance to see it!! I love your reactions, thank you for reacting!!!
I'm so happy that you finally reacted to this EP. (also Horizon is in my top 5 song list from their songs😍) This is one of my favourite album from them. Also sorry if I ask this question, probably you already told us, and I was just forgetful, but did you already reacted to the All To Action album? Cause I can't find it in your channel.
I got the order mixed up but yes I will do that one as well ☺️
and this is why i always say precious best bside
Star 1117 was absolutely beautiful live! Especially the part where we sing back to them (San's part in the last chorus). If you have time later one, I'd recommend you watch clips of it live during their latest tour. (The longest and clearest videos I've seen of it are from the last two days of the tour, which was LA.)
All to Action was actually before this album. Action to Answer is the epilogue for the treasure series and then we go back in time before all the treasure era happened and enter the fever series which is before they became pirates. Now since the fever series is the prequel to treasure series, after fever epilogue is Say My Name/Hala Hala and then pirate king until Answer. That’s the timeline of their lore 🤍 everyone’s excited for the next era because no one knows what to expect next since fever and treasure series are over
yesssss another amazing reaction ! let me tell you Horizon and Precious have been on my top songs playlist on spotify for 3 years in a row and yet i have never read the lyrics to them ! i feel so ashamed right now 😩but glad i could go through the journey of falling more in love with these songs thanks to you. Also i had never paid that much attention to the outro and how that connects to the rest of the storyline! since Answer is the end of the Treasure series, and the Fever series is what happened before they became pirates, it makes me even more excited for what's to come in their universe !
i always really appreciate how you gush about how much meaning you get from ateez's music!! i'm 8 months late to this video but somehow, coincidentally, i quite literally JUST read a rolling stone interview with ateez where they talk about the effort that they put into writing lyrics and connecting to those who listen, as well as how atinys analyze their lyrics, and how much that means to ateez.
watching your reaction and how you always take the time to try and analyze what's going on and how much their music reaches you immediately made me think of that article, and so i feel really grateful for atinys/reactors like you that show that kind of love so generously towards their efforts in their art, even when something isn't exactly your taste!
just to help u out cuz we knowhow these lyric videos go:
HORIZON
-the beginning, the back and forth is between Wooyoung and Seonghwa
-the choruses is Yeosang not Seonghwa
-the beginning of the 2nd verse is Yunho, not Jongho, then Seonghwa follows
-the back n forth is still Wooyoung and Seonghwa
-that drop that showed Jongho was actually Yunho.
-YES THERE IS A LIVE STAGE!! CANT WAIT FOR U TO SE IT!!!
STAR1117
-yes that is Seonghwa.
-YES that is Hongjoong
-that rift in the background during Jongho part is San. the one who harmonized with Jongho was Seonghwa.
-yes they did! this tour was the first time they performed it in front of I-atinys 😭
PRECIOUS
-pls ur expressions where literary us.
-yes this is linked to Treasure!
-Hong wrote this song pre-debut, along with Treasure, so just imagine how long they where sitting on this track!!!
-u HAVE to see this tour stage performance!! they always perform this back to back with Treasure!!
Precious is my top 5 ATEEZ songs!!!!!!! When I first heard it in All to action i was like I NEED THE FULL VERSION ASAP!!!!!!! Glad we got it
Yay happy for another album reaction :)
Yes in Star 1117 it was Seonghwa + Hongjoong.
The lyric guide got it wrong in Horizon: the switch in the verses between Wooyoung + Yunho is actually Wooyoung + Seonghwa ^^
Looking forward to your live stage reaction, Yeosang gets center time in Horizon :3
They sang this on concert. In Korea they were all a crying mess during their first concert and in Prudential Center Hongjoong cried so much, I cried with him 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
what a welcome surprise thank you for starting march off so well caitlin 🥺 hope it'll be a better month to you 💗💗💗
also hongjoong actually wrote horizon predebut but it was saved for this album the epilogue album to tie of their treasure series and its perfect 🤍
ONCE AGAIN THERE IS NOT A BAD ATEEZ ALBUM, NOT EVEN ONE SKIP
OMG AM I REACHING BUT I JUST REALIZED NOW IN PRECIOUS
There is a line "Is this place a dream or reality"
And the album after this is the start of the Fever series which started with a dream (Inception) and ended with The Real 🤯🤯🤯
yeah you should react to their fellowship version of treasure+precious, they performed it together, its really crazy!!! you can see their desire towards treasure or somethin
I always look forward to your reactions and this was no exception! I love that you appreciate and talk about the lyricism and the instrumentals on top of the vocals/rap! Your genuine love for music shines so much and I love it
To answer your question about if they did Star 1117 on tour, they did! I was ugly sobbing the entire time (I can't even watch my fancam LMAO it was a mess) and at my stop (Newark) Hongjoong broke down when we started singing our part of the song, so it made me cry harder 😭 ATEEZ love ATINY so much, I seriously love the bond we have with them ❤
I've never dropped my homework as quick as I did when I saw this
I cannot put into words how much I love this EP. Probably this is my fav Ateez album. If this would be a jubilee type of an album in their career, I would probably say "oh they are leaving at the top so hats off!" but NO they just released it in their first year which is insane. This EP has just put the most delicious cream on Treasure era which makes this era so distinct for me.
Horizon is a Hongjoong' composition!!
Thank you so much for helping people from Ukraine, I really appreciate it🙏 and answer is my fav song from ateez, thanks for the reaction ^^
Yes I am so happy you’re back with ateez
Here is a link too (: ruclips.net/video/bEXbpAOpbjM/видео.html
horizon felt like a little much for me too the first time i heard it but then it kept growing on me sm to the point where now its one of my favs b-sides, so i get what you mean
Fr precious is THAT good. Such a bop. My dad always ask me to blast that song on full volume whenever we drive lmaoo! Can't wait until you react to the live stage to this song omg
I love your reaction!
What you said about Precious is exactly what's happening, you actually nailed it!
Ateez literally my favorite group, they are so special to me
Thank you for reaction 💜
Hello Caitlin! Love the reaction
horizon and precious are 2 of my favorite ateez songs, i love this mini album
Oh Caitlin ... you're gonna cry your eyes out when you watch ateez singing star1117 in their US tour & atiny singing the lyrics back to them
The live performance of Horizon is so much better and the dance practice oh my god it was amazing!! so please check them out 💜
I feel like the choreo makes Horizon make sense.
Star 1117 it's one of my top songs from ATEEZ 💯
thank you so much for including info about Ukraine. there is no people who really wanted this to happen neither in Ukraine nor in Russia. I’m talking about civilians. all of us are suffering: people in Ukraine because of shelling, both Russian and Ukrainian army have already lost thousands of soliders, people are in captivity and Russians are under sanctions and a lot of pressure because someone REALLY THINKS that ALL CITIZENS wanted this war. are u serious? I hope that RUclips won’t be blocked here, because reactions is the only one thing that can prevent me from crying. please can we have a world without war and conflicts? stay healthy everyone💙
i promise watching the dance performance while listening to the song horizon makes it 1000 x better!!!
Horizon tends to be a grower for many people. In my opinion, I think the disorienting feeling of Horizon is intentional. Sort of the idea of being lost at sea, searching for something and kind of not sure where you're going? That's my take on it anyway. Plus, as you've guessed, the choreo enhances the music in a really cool way as well
i'm so excited for you to react to horizon's dance practice and/or live stage- its very much a performance song and really gives each member a time to shine. horizon is personally one of my favorite songs by them, but i wasn't in love until i saw the dance practice and live stage. as for precious, i absolutely LOVE how it's a clear refrain of treasure and i can't wait to possibly see you react to their joint stage of treasure + precious because of how well they go together. and until you pointed out that callback to utopia ("every day, every night") i didn't even notice, that's crazy! thank you for reacting to ateez!
always love your reactions and super excited for all to action! i haven't finished watching yet but just wanted to say Horizon's lyric video is actually mostly wrong, so if you get a chance definitely watch their live stages (either from SeoulCon like the Pirate King/Treasure stages you reacted to before or from M Countdown). Precious live stage is also amazing and I hope you can react to that one too!
Not me crying with you listening to Star 1117 😭 Ateez do deserve the world yess 🥺🥺🥺 Also, Hongjoong is really out there with those amazing vocals 🥲 If you ever get the chance, please check out his covers, they're so good, his take on the songs are just *chef's kiss* 😌👌
I just love your Ateez reactions they are always amazing 💕. You should definitely check out concert ver. of Treasure+Precious that performance really gives me chills Seoul concert version is available on youtube as well 😆
it doesn't matter how many times i listen 2 precious, live or studio, the segway into the treasure intro will forever give me fucking goosebumps. this album always gives me a intense feeling of euphoria, ugh
Horizon is seriously a grower, I watched the live performance and it fell in love. It's amazing live, so it grew on me 😂
Inception and Precious are tied for my #1 ATEEZ song......both wreck me each and every time!!
the bridge they created for the end of the Say My Name MV, Precious and then Treasure will always be one of the most surreal things Ateez has ever done
Awww my babiesss😍😍loved your reaction like always Caitlin! I defo recommend watching their live performances in your own time to get to know their voices better they can all sing and rap at this point 😂 so you might get confused😅
Yay another ateez reaction. Can’t wait for you to react to All to action cause my fav song Thank U is there. That song will emotionally wreck you hut in a happy way 😆.
Also why did it only occur to me after watching your reaction that the ending of say my name could have been the teaser to precious instead of treasure.
Caitlin really gets it. I love this girl so much. T___T thank you always for your love for ATEEZ.
Watching you so exciting making theories about the storyline just make my day ILYSM 😭💕💖💀
Loved how they incorporated Psytrance into Horizon! Definitely one of my fav songs from them
Precious is up there too tho,, i just love me some nice drops haha
In the beginning or ending of precious in the coreography hongjoong spells ateez on the ground
i screamed when i saw this IVE BEEN WAITING FOR MORE ATEEZ😭
Omg, SAME GIRL, I more confused 😅. Also, Precious is really really interesting, you will keep finding references to other songs, and is directly connected to Treasure!
Hey Caitlin, it's so nicee to see u react to ateez again! It's been a while 😭😭❤
I just want to tell u that i love ur reaction so much! Please always be happy and healthy, i'll always waiting for another reaction from u ❤
Actually as this album in chronological order is right before Fever part 1, it makes sense that Precious refers to Inception! I never paid attention to the lyrics of Precious after Inception was released but ye x)
To me this album is my favorite (Answer being my fave title track too)!! Just what I usually need ~~
Horizon is a huge favorite of mine, also because of the choreo (and who gets the highlight hehe) so maybe it'll grow on you this way ~~
Horizon was named in the top 10 best b sides of 2020
PLS, I GOT SO EXCITED ON SEEING THE TITLE OF THIS VIDEO SKGGJDHS
yes, Star 1117 is the song for us fans
11:11 YES YOURE RIGHT OML I THINK THATS YEOSANGS PART,, ITS ADDICTING AFFF
Honestly, for me it took me a few plays of horizon but now its up there with my favourites and is also a great gym song lol. but yes precious, desire, hala hala and promise are like my faves and i feel theyre all kinda the same vibe? lol you'll deffo love precious (overture) on all to action. but precious/treasure live perf is highly recommended!!
Thank you so much Caitlin!! I love your reactions so much!!❤️❤️ also, will u react to ATEEZ’s variety shows again? It’s been a long time🥺🥺 I hope u doing well
The outro kinda blew my mind up when i first heard it. My brain cannot handle this whole giant ateez lore. But my take on this one, Since they already got what they're finding when they started sailing, now they're facing another struggle and hindrances that maybe someone out there are hunting them down now. Let's not forget they're pirates so what is pirates without a villains who's after them right? And even after watching don't stop mv. I actually believe after they got their treasure someone stole it from them specially the ship and now they're actually sailing again to bring it all back together. Idk anymore hahahaa. The point is we can never actually grasp everything together. Ateez's story line is one hell of a journey and it's too hard for me to understand. But I'm trying tho haha. Btw, i miss this Caitlin. Thank you for always making time to react to our boys. You made my day. God bless you and your channel ☺️
When I first heard Precious (overture) in All to Action, I'm not joking I don't remember any time of my life that I got so addicted to an overture...
ATEEZ albums are all no skip albums. But, for me personally, ALL TO ACTION IS TOP TIER :) That album is SUPERIOR. I'm really, really looking forward to your reaction to MIST, SUNRISE, and THANK U, because those songs literally blew my mind. Just thinking about the fact that you would finally react to ALL TO ACTION makes me so excited. 🤸
Yessss it is seonghwa and hongjoong there xdd and hightly recommend their live stage of star 1117 because you can clearly see how their emotion put in :))))
And highly recommend their live tour stage of Precious their choreo is crazyyyy!!! Treasure first and precious next as twins is link tgt when they perform usually and storyline too :)))
Hongjoong mentioned in interview their storyline is not even in half so is question more lmao
I will be praying and continue to pray over Ukraine. I know the Lord is with them every step of the way those who are now deceased and those who are aren't. And I will also pray and continue to pray for you and your family Caitlin. I know that during your live stream you mentioned that week was not a good week for you and I don't want that to happen to you. I will put you in my prayers for your mind to be at ease, for you to be healthy and in good condition mentally and physically, to be able to not worry about anything. Only happiness! Well, in all honesty, you are one of the few people to bring me contentment. And I apologize if this is weird but I consider you family to me which I don't have. I remember watching one of your Stray Kids reactions which is another of the few people I consider family and I really enjoyed what was being brought to my eyes. So I want only and I mean only happiness for you, Caitlin!!!! Sorry for this being so lengthy. ☹️🤗
Actually the outro supposed to have the music on the last part of answer mv where the white masked guy appeared. Also that music is the latest hint we have for what is coming next if we follow their storyline since fever series is placed before the treasure series. I'm very looking forward for you to listen to all of the greatness in the EP. FIN: All to Action album, I actually can't wait for real😆😆
loved this video!! ur energy is amazing
Horizon and Precious live stage are insane !!!!
FOr STAR 1117 live stage, you will cry a lot esp there's part of tge song where atiny will sing back at ateez you should watch it
I don't think i'm emotionally ready to see you react to All to Action album 😭 It's really special, you might need extra tissues girl
you should watch the live version of horizon in their seoul concert 2020 and listen to san&jongho harmonizing together🥺
YES YES ANOTHER ATEEZ REACTION!!! 😍
Was waiting so patiently for this omggg
All the live performances of this whole album are the Best, you have to watch it,
Is you are a Yunhopower I recommend you Horizon live stage 100%
And star1117 concert versión 😭💖