They have once again outdone themselves! The tiny scale-detail is a triumph - very gratifying to see it on the theropods as we had seen it achieved on the hadrosaurs. That detail on the belly you point out is staggering! What I find most compelling and real-animal-convincing is the columnar mass of the legs; the breadth of the shins seems like a first at this scale, conveying the muscle and tendons wrapped across the bones (for me it recalls the Irritator by Dino Hazard). The pose is a fantastic achievement in itself. You can really see this animal as a living thing moving through space. Also the silhouette from above seems just right! The breadth flows through the neck to the tail base without shrinking back. The paint scheme, as complicated as it is, could use some subtle washes in the lighter areas to just slightly bring out the texture. Thanks for another superb review!
Excellent observations Arnoldiepin! I wish I'd talked about that breadth of the shins, quite underappreciated but we have to consider what a real animal would really be like. Being able to imbue a model with a sense of life and living is a special thing, and many models utterly fail in this area. The washes will certainly do much towards putting this ahead of the GR Toys version. But I often wonder how much more PNSO could do without putting up the price 😅
Thanks Austin, starting to feel better. And yes this will look good next to the EoFauan Giga. In terms of shape and scientific accuracy, they will go well together! Start to build out the carcharodontid family!
What an amazing review, you're so thorough! But I must say the GR TOYS charchar looks better to me. The paint apps are far better and the sculpt is easier to appreciate, the addition of lips also makes me happy. Have a good day :)
i get your point with lips, like are chat on Instagram the other day but i have to say one thing.... we still don't know for sure if any theropod had lips because just like modern day crocodiles and birds like cranes, they could have hunted in rivers seasonally. So all im saying is that just cause of updated research, that doesn't necessary mean they had lips, im all in for lips but again.... you never know
Well Paleodude, if you're lucky, your GR Toys one if you buy it, might actually not have that problem. A couple of collectors have stated theirs closes perfectly, which would be super to showcase lips!
@Paleostories_ It really boils down to personal preference or for some, emotional investment. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, so there is plenty of room for interpretation. Which is one of the reasons dinosaurs are so appealing, it allows imagination and speculation!
This sure is one exciting review on the amazing African Carcharodontosaur from PNSO,also this video is just so awesome. Also hope your having amazing Monday.
Thank you I am! Been recovering from flu, hence the delay in these reviews. This is truly a magnificent offering from PNSO. And it's really distinctive from the typical theropod too! You have a great week ahead too!
It was literally impossible for me to choose so I just bought both the GR toys and PNSO models, was not disappointed lol. Both are a mated pair on my shelf now! Also great review, mate! Always love watching your older vids :)
Thank you! With a name like that, you would be a much better judge of this dinosaur than anybody else! 🤣👍👍 I definitely like both and they are excellent in their own ways. While the colour is really the talk of the town for the GR, there is something about the soothing earth tones and that bit of green that actually makes the PNSO Carcharodontosaurus one of my favourite paint apps for their theropods!
Just ordered this figure (it's difficult to catch up with PNSO's speed LOL) and I'm really excited to get it. Your comparison shot between the Eofauna Giga and PNSO Carchar really shows how much improvement has gone into the quality of PNSO's sculpts over the years. The Eofauna Giga was, and still is, an amazingly accurate work of art, but when I compare it's forelimb claws to the Carchar, I see the vast difference in their quality. It almost seems like the Giga had a severe allergic reaction resulting to edematous, sausage-like fingers LOL
There are still many people who prefer EoFauna, simply because very strictly speaking, at 1:35 you might not actually be able to see so much detail. My only dislike of EoFauna is the very boring colours it has, and the Yoshi's Trike, while amazing, had the more atrocious colours. I am looking forward to seeing their Diplodocus though!
@@DinosDragons yeah, eofauna too has dramatically improved the fineness of their sculpts, the sculpt details in their atlasaurus is vastly superior to their giga and their tendency to stick to 1/35 or 1/40 (for atlasaurus) is a big plus.. unfortunately, as you mentioned, the paintwork on their trike is not the best out there.. and in my opinion, not very lifelike. they were already on the right track with their paintwork on the atlasaurus so i was a bit surprised with their decision on the paintjob on their trike.
Great review as always. PNSO is on fire at the moment. They seem to get better with each release. Like yourself, they are my preferred company now. You just can`t get this quality for the price anywhere else.
Thanks Rik! 😁 Of course, there's no pleasing anyone. Quite a few people actually don't like this and complained about the paint job, same with the Allosaurus. I wonder what they are expecting at the price range. Though to be fair, I understand some are paying much higher prices, e.g. in the EU they have new taxes to add to the mix 😔
The GR toys definitely stands out! I would never have expecte the level of improvement over the first figure, the Spinosaurus, not just in sculpt but paintwork. Just look at the hands alone, and you will see what GR toys has accomplished.
Something to also consider ; The GR Toys version retails for more than double the cost of the PNSO figure so do take that into account when deciding . I will say PNSO’s colours are in need of re-imagining . Even using the same hues one can use a different pattern to differentiate between figures or , reverse the primary and secondary hues to create something unique . Pleased that you’re on the mend . Do take care of yourself .
Thanks you @ArawnsFire, I'm slowly recovering but this was most convenient, causing the delay of reviewing not just one but two amazing models from PNSO! I know a few people have feedback to PNSO about the colours now, so hopefully they'll do a rethink on this. They hit the mark in so many areas it would be unfortunate if this little thing caused them to lose their fanbase. Perhaps if you, and more, started writing in also, they would incorporate this into future presentations!
I adore this finger the body proportions, the pose, musculature, and fine scale detailing. They all hit the that sweet spot for, me personally along the how, accurately portrayed one of, my favorite theropods. The only thing, I wish that was a tiny bit better was the paint 🎨 job. PS the only other finger, I’m more excited to see is the SAVAGE-LIZARD
I definitely agree! The only one I have is the CollectA, and I'd be keen to see what PNSO can do with it. That, and Saurophaganax, would start to flesh out other families of theropods. Of course, Mapusaurus would be a worthy candidate too.
@@DinosDragons I’d love to see a Saurophaganax or Lord-Of-The-Lizard-Eaters but since the, animal has incomplete fossil remains. I’m genuinely curious how, PNSO will go about making there own. For example the size estimates for Saurophaganax is 12-13meters and 5-6+ tons. So in theory it could be a, basal carcharodontosaurid. And being mega-theropod it should generally have, a larger head and smaller arms. Kinda similar to Battle At Big Rock “Adult Allo”/Saurophaganax. Or will PNSO just make it an over-sized Allosaurus? Only time will tell and, as for a. Mapusaurus finger that be, amazing along side a Tyrannotitan! as well.
I'm sure it will be around for a long time, but hopefully the paint application wouldn't have lost quality till then. There's something about the muted earth colours on this I really like.
Great comparison between PNSO and GR Toys. I like PNSO chunky design, but I cannot resist against GR Toys blue colour scheme. I'll purchase GR Toys one!
The GR Toys one is truly spectacular, and will definitely stand out in any collection. You wil truly appreciate the amount of detail in that verions. I didn't expect it, but it's not the main attention getting features that really sell it. It's the often overlooked parts, such as the texture on the underbelly and the hands. You will know what I mean when you have it in hand!
Definitely. I hope that more fossil finds come to light, and help us flesh things out a lot better than we already have. PNSO certainly has done a great job!
Scant fossil material is the thing. I asked Dr Scott Hartman why he hadn't done a reconstruction yet, and that's the reason he gave me. There is just too much fill-in work done if you really want only fairly complete fossils. I suppose you won't be buying Mecuriceratops anytime soon! 🤣
He's definitely unusual and stands out from the usual theropod crowd! PNSO has done a marvellous job with him! The head and belly are selling points for me 🤣
You've really put me on the spot! The GR of course has those vivid colours, which really highlight the insane detail. Plus also a skull that is more accurate to Sereno's reconstruciton. The PNSO has a slightly more elongated skull, a distortion I can live with however, and the caudofemoralis muscle looks thicker. And there is just something so incredibly soothing about those colours. I would rather not choose, but if you pointed a gun at my head, I would go with the PNSO. What about _you_ ? 😁
@@DinosDragons it's definitely a unique contrast between the two. I prefer different aspects of them. It all comes down to personal preference at that point! Say, have you had any noteable morphing issues with the legs of the PNSO and GRtoys carcharodontosaurus so far?
I was telling friend that we need more dark theropods, the colorscheme on the allosaurus is really similar to this carcha, i would prefer uf they applied some dark tones over some predators, something like the allosaurus jimmadseni painted by andrey atuchin.
Yes that is a concern if too similar paint apps start to lose PNSO fandom. But I have reason to believe that PNSO is starting to receive this message, so let's see what future offerings come up. Paint app is something that differentiates companies, and given their quality of application, it would be unfortunate if choice of colour disappoints.
@@DinosDragons absolutely, its kinda their symbol now, but seeing how good they got on correcting the scale detail I think they have the potential to improve their color schemes
Carcharodontosaurus is probably the only mega theropod I actually really love (Im more of an Abelisaurid kinda guy) so I’m beyond happy it’s finally getting more love as of late. It’s such an interesting looking theropod but it feels like it’s often overshadowed by its South American cousin all the time. Also yea it’s no way this is in scale with the T. rex figure but whatever
Unfortunately, it's so poorly known, that fame will always go to better understood figures. I'm also an abelisaurid camper, though I've been learning more about Allosauroidea and developing a greater appreciation of the clade. Hopefully we'll get another decent abelisaurid soon!
@@DinosDragons do you prefer the PNSO one or the GR toys one, also would ali express be trustworthy to buy the GR toys one from? Link: www.aliexpress.com/item/1005002004820982.html?spm=a2g0o.placeorder.0.0.567a321eu9W73l&mp=1
This is a beautiful model no doubt..and your review is fantastic...only issue I have with this model is they should some Grey or black wash to highlight the texture and skin folds especially in the belly region...second thing is it is really small compared to Wilson T.rex...if t.rex represents 12 meters individual as it is 1/35 scale this model should be little bit higher on the hip region even if it's considered to be 11 or 10 meter individual...the height difference is quite significant between the two model..we know that height around the hips is almost similar in these gaint therapods (Giganotosaurus, Mapusaurus, charcharodontosaurus and T.rex)
Thank you! The issue with Carcharodontosaurus is how fragmentary it is. For example, Dr Larramendi did an estimate of over 12m based off a Giganotosaurus femur that was _itself an estimate_ of 143cm. Then that got revised down to 136.5cm, and the estimate of Carcharodontosaurus based on that estimate was again revised down in length and height. The femur is such a key bone and yet we're missing it for Carcharodontosaurus. We really need more evidence. Meanwhile, I just try to enjoy the models as they are 😁
@@DinosDragons yes..I hope a new fossil discovery of this animal will give us a better picture....by the way i recently bought the Eofauna tric (cryptic version.. because they opted for striking color scheme based on modern birds)...and let me tell you pictures don't do justice to this model...it is very beautiful...you will definitely appreciate it in your hand...if you ever decide to buy it..😊
eofauna seem to be the best currently for reconstructions ..the older dinosaur books mention carcharodontosaurus as 8m based on the first partial specimen,must likely a sub adult in my view....
I am a little picky with my dinosaur models, I usually like all of mine to follow roughly 1:35 scale and be as scientifically accurate as possible! Would you be able to give me any advice on which one to pick up out of PNSO and GR ones, I really cannot decide!
@@DinosDragons sorry if I was a little vague in my comment, I was just refering to the GR toys and PNSO carchara, I ended up ordering the GR toys one just because of the scaling you spoke about later in the video. Can I just say I've gone through and watched nearly all of your reviews now; You truly are amazing man, well done. I am currently studying geology at university to later take my PhD in vertebrate paleontology and the amount of scientific detail you go into really makes you stand out from other channels, I would be interested to know some of your favourite scientifically accurate 1:35 figures of all time from any brand! I am wanting to build a big collection of my own.
Unfortunately, I think consistency in scaling just isn't going to be a reality. Firstly, sculptors would prefer to work without that restrictiong. Secondly it's what size can bring out what features they want to elaborate on. And finally, depending on which actual size estimate you use, you won't ever satisfy fervent fans who have their own concept. For example I know people who firmly believe Carcharodontosaurus is only 11m or even less, and won't entertain any other estimate.
id prefer if they do what collecta has,have regular size figures and deluxe figures which would be larger...i dont mind bigger figures at all in fact i wish more companies made the figures in a larger scale...
Hi, off the top of my head, I can only think of Spinosaurus. Other contemporaneous dinosaurs like Rugpops PNSO might have made in their little dinosaurs line, but I'm not familiar with that. I'm kind of hoping PNSO will tackle Ouranosaurus and of course, a Paralititan in 1:35 but that's probably just going to be a fantasy.
There are actually a few and nothing definitive and generally accepted by all. I'm hoping for more complete material... well I guess I've been waiting for fifteen years, what's a few more!
Hello I'm an amateur paleontologist, I love to read books on the skeleton and. Wonder what these top level predators life was like? my theropod leg bone,it has this tooth mark,that is on the back located to the left side, i wonder if it was a carcharodontosaurus that could have done damage from it's bitting teeth strength? And may I ask you do you have any used Books that I could have, I want to gain more knowledge to further my understanding of these creatures?
Apologies for my late reply as I have been ill. For a start, what books are you currently using? Then I might be able to see what level of reading you're at, and then make some recommendations 🙂
@@DinosDragons I've read the introduction to paleontology and biology textbook by wiley Blackwell. J david Archibald, Dinosaur extinction and the end of an era ,what the fossils say,
The GR is definitely more complex, something I would never have believed possible on a mass produced model. However it _is_ more fantastical while this one is more natural. Another thing is that the paint on that is pretty sticky, something to consider if it's likely to irritate you.
I can't choose between this one and the GR Toys model. This one has a better sculpt, but, other than the eyes, the paint doesn't even come close to the GR Toys model. It's also lacking in lips. I've heard that there's still discussion relating to dinosaurs having lips or not, but I prefer them having them. It looks more natural to me, and makes more sense, conskdering that modern reptiles do.
Seems like you're inclining toward the GR Toys model. Would having the eyes repainted elevate it a bit more and help you make a decision? Also keep in mind that if you like lips, is it important that the model shows it? I can't speak for others, but both of my GR Toys versions don't close fully, and so are unable to fully showoff the lipped interpretation of this dinosaur 😥
@@DinosDragons I'll admit, I'm leaning to the GR Toys model. The eyes are for sure the thing I hate most about the model, though, I'm planning on learning to paint at some point in the near future. I've heard several complaints about the articulation on the GR Toys model. It is one reason I'm considering the PNSO model, as I prefer the mouths of the models being closed. I'm not sure if it's common for the figures to not be able to close their mouths or not, but, I'd rather not take the chance. I've never had good luck in cases like these.
It definitely is, Maddy! Something about it, perhaps the head shape combined with the belly area. I am glad we have more distinct theropods; after a while they are in danger of becoming a blur!
Mine hasn't broken but then I haven't dropped it. I have dropped my old PNSO Spinosaurus (large one) before, but except for some looseness in the articulated jaw after that, it seemed fine. I won't tempt fate though. Everything is on a secure shelf with sufficient space to avoid jostling.
They have once again outdone themselves! The tiny scale-detail is a triumph - very gratifying to see it on the theropods as we had seen it achieved on the hadrosaurs. That detail on the belly you point out is staggering! What I find most compelling and real-animal-convincing is the columnar mass of the legs; the breadth of the shins seems like a first at this scale, conveying the muscle and tendons wrapped across the bones (for me it recalls the Irritator by Dino Hazard). The pose is a fantastic achievement in itself. You can really see this animal as a living thing moving through space. Also the silhouette from above seems just right! The breadth flows through the neck to the tail base without shrinking back.
The paint scheme, as complicated as it is, could use some subtle washes in the lighter areas to just slightly bring out the texture. Thanks for another superb review!
Excellent observations Arnoldiepin! I wish I'd talked about that breadth of the shins, quite underappreciated but we have to consider what a real animal would really be like. Being able to imbue a model with a sense of life and living is a special thing, and many models utterly fail in this area.
The washes will certainly do much towards putting this ahead of the GR Toys version. But I often wonder how much more PNSO could do without putting up the price 😅
I’m glad you are feeling better DD, excellent review! I feel like this figure will look great next to my Eofauna Giga!
Thanks Austin, starting to feel better. And yes this will look good next to the EoFauan Giga. In terms of shape and scientific accuracy, they will go well together! Start to build out the carcharodontid family!
Another excellent review. Thanks for taking the time to do it.
Thank youfor taking the time to watch it, David! 😁
What an amazing review, you're so thorough! But I must say the GR TOYS charchar looks better to me. The paint apps are far better and the sculpt is easier to appreciate, the addition of lips also makes me happy. Have a good day :)
i get your point with lips, like are chat on Instagram the other day but i have to say one thing.... we still don't know for sure if any theropod had lips because just like modern day crocodiles and birds like cranes, they could have hunted in rivers seasonally. So all im saying is that just cause of updated research, that doesn't necessary mean they had lips, im all in for lips but again.... you never know
Well Paleodude, if you're lucky, your GR Toys one if you buy it, might actually not have that problem. A couple of collectors have stated theirs closes perfectly, which would be super to showcase lips!
@Paleostories_
It really boils down to personal preference or for some, emotional investment. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, so there is plenty of room for interpretation. Which is one of the reasons dinosaurs are so appealing, it allows imagination and speculation!
This sure is one exciting review on the amazing African Carcharodontosaur from PNSO,also this video is just so awesome.
Also hope your having amazing Monday.
Thank you I am! Been recovering from flu, hence the delay in these reviews. This is truly a magnificent offering from PNSO. And it's really distinctive from the typical theropod too! You have a great week ahead too!
Thanks so much for this amazing review! I love your work! Thanks a lot!
Thank you Carlos! I'm delighted that people enjoy my reviews, and the way I choose to showcase these magnificent animals!
It was literally impossible for me to choose so I just bought both the GR toys and PNSO models, was not disappointed lol. Both are a mated pair on my shelf now! Also great review, mate! Always love watching your older vids :)
Thank you! With a name like that, you would be a much better judge of this dinosaur than anybody else! 🤣👍👍 I definitely like both and they are excellent in their own ways. While the colour is really the talk of the town for the GR, there is something about the soothing earth tones and that bit of green that actually makes the PNSO Carcharodontosaurus one of my favourite paint apps for their theropods!
Just picked this one up. I like the earthy paint scheme and it’s a lot cheaper than the GR Toys version, so it was an easy choice!
Yes the original GR Toys one has skyrocketed in price!
Excelente como siempre!! Te felicito por la figura! Saludos desde Chile
Muchísimas gracias! Lo me gusta mucho!
So many dinosaurs, so little time! Great review!
Thank you, I especially felt that this weekend laying sick in bed 😂
PNSO is really doing great to keep making such great figures one after another ! Excellent and detailed review !
Thank you! PNSO makes it a pleasure! 😁
Absolutely ! Could you let me know the source you buy from? And if the seller ships to India, could you let me know somehow?
Excellent review. Look forward to the next one.
Thank you Ivy! I was a little late but my PNSO Stegosaurus review is up!
Just ordered this figure (it's difficult to catch up with PNSO's speed LOL) and I'm really excited to get it. Your comparison shot between the Eofauna Giga and PNSO Carchar really shows how much improvement has gone into the quality of PNSO's sculpts over the years. The Eofauna Giga was, and still is, an amazingly accurate work of art, but when I compare it's forelimb claws to the Carchar, I see the vast difference in their quality. It almost seems like the Giga had a severe allergic reaction resulting to edematous, sausage-like fingers LOL
There are still many people who prefer EoFauna, simply because very strictly speaking, at 1:35 you might not actually be able to see so much detail. My only dislike of EoFauna is the very boring colours it has, and the Yoshi's Trike, while amazing, had the more atrocious colours. I am looking forward to seeing their Diplodocus though!
@@DinosDragons yeah, eofauna too has dramatically improved the fineness of their sculpts, the sculpt details in their atlasaurus is vastly superior to their giga and their tendency to stick to 1/35 or 1/40 (for atlasaurus) is a big plus.. unfortunately, as you mentioned, the paintwork on their trike is not the best out there.. and in my opinion, not very lifelike.
they were already on the right track with their paintwork on the atlasaurus so i was a bit surprised with their decision on the paintjob on their trike.
Oh, and hope you feel all better soon!
Thank you Michael! I took a couple days off to recover, and I think it's coming along nicely! Though I'm backlogged on reviews because of that 😉
Great review as always. PNSO is on fire at the moment. They seem to get better with each release. Like yourself, they are my preferred company now. You just can`t get this quality for the price anywhere else.
Thanks Rik! 😁
Of course, there's no pleasing anyone. Quite a few people actually don't like this and complained about the paint job, same with the Allosaurus. I wonder what they are expecting at the price range. Though to be fair, I understand some are paying much higher prices, e.g. in the EU they have new taxes to add to the mix 😔
Just ordered this guy on Amazon, so excited to get him!
He's special all right! Didn't think I'd like the eye colour, head and belly shape so much!
Another great review. PNSO looks nice but the GR Toys version is much more impressive to me. I love its unique, colourful look.
The GR toys definitely stands out! I would never have expecte the level of improvement over the first figure, the Spinosaurus, not just in sculpt but paintwork. Just look at the hands alone, and you will see what GR toys has accomplished.
Something to also consider ; The GR Toys version retails for more than double the cost of the PNSO figure so do take that into account when deciding . I will say PNSO’s colours are in need of re-imagining . Even using the same hues one can use a different pattern to differentiate between figures or , reverse the primary and secondary hues to create something unique . Pleased that you’re on the mend . Do take care of yourself .
Thanks you @ArawnsFire, I'm slowly recovering but this was most convenient, causing the delay of reviewing not just one but two amazing models from PNSO! I know a few people have feedback to PNSO about the colours now, so hopefully they'll do a rethink on this. They hit the mark in so many areas it would be unfortunate if this little thing caused them to lose their fanbase. Perhaps if you, and more, started writing in also, they would incorporate this into future presentations!
I adore this finger the body proportions, the pose, musculature, and fine scale detailing. They all hit the that sweet spot for, me personally along the how, accurately portrayed one of, my favorite theropods. The only thing, I wish that was a tiny bit better was the paint 🎨 job.
PS the only other finger, I’m more excited to see is the SAVAGE-LIZARD
I definitely agree! The only one I have is the CollectA, and I'd be keen to see what PNSO can do with it. That, and Saurophaganax, would start to flesh out other families of theropods. Of course, Mapusaurus would be a worthy candidate too.
@@DinosDragons
I’d love to see a Saurophaganax or Lord-Of-The-Lizard-Eaters but since the, animal has incomplete fossil remains. I’m genuinely curious how, PNSO will go about making there own. For example the size estimates for Saurophaganax is 12-13meters and 5-6+ tons. So in theory it could be a, basal carcharodontosaurid. And being mega-theropod it should generally have, a larger head and smaller arms. Kinda similar to Battle At Big Rock “Adult Allo”/Saurophaganax. Or will PNSO just make it an over-sized Allosaurus? Only time will tell and, as for a. Mapusaurus finger that be, amazing along side a Tyrannotitan! as well.
One of my favorite theropods I hope I can get this figure someday
I'm sure it will be around for a long time, but hopefully the paint application wouldn't have lost quality till then. There's something about the muted earth colours on this I really like.
Great comparison between PNSO and GR Toys. I like PNSO chunky design, but I cannot resist against GR Toys blue colour scheme. I'll purchase GR Toys one!
The GR Toys one is truly spectacular, and will definitely stand out in any collection. You wil truly appreciate the amount of detail in that verions. I didn't expect it, but it's not the main attention getting features that really sell it. It's the often overlooked parts, such as the texture on the underbelly and the hands. You will know what I mean when you have it in hand!
@@DinosDragons Thank you for your maniac advice. I have just ordered the GR Toy one. I cannot wait to see those details!!
Carcharo deserves lots of attention..
Definitely. I hope that more fossil finds come to light, and help us flesh things out a lot better than we already have. PNSO certainly has done a great job!
As always, a great review! No lips and such scant fossil material however will keep me from ordering this one.
Scant fossil material is the thing. I asked Dr Scott Hartman why he hadn't done a reconstruction yet, and that's the reason he gave me. There is just too much fill-in work done if you really want only fairly complete fossils. I suppose you won't be buying Mecuriceratops anytime soon! 🤣
Haha! True.
very nice pnso
PNSO really is a company to watch!
God I love him with those pink spots and with how chonky he looks.
He's definitely unusual and stands out from the usual theropod crowd! PNSO has done a marvellous job with him! The head and belly are selling points for me 🤣
Awesome review. If you were to choose ONE carcharodontosaurus figure to keep between the two, would it rather be the GR toys or PNSO's Gamba?
You've really put me on the spot! The GR of course has those vivid colours, which really highlight the insane detail. Plus also a skull that is more accurate to Sereno's reconstruciton. The PNSO has a slightly more elongated skull, a distortion I can live with however, and the caudofemoralis muscle looks thicker. And there is just something so incredibly soothing about those colours.
I would rather not choose, but if you pointed a gun at my head, I would go with the PNSO.
What about _you_ ? 😁
@@DinosDragons it's definitely a unique contrast between the two. I prefer different aspects of them. It all comes down to personal preference at that point! Say, have you had any noteable morphing issues with the legs of the PNSO and GRtoys carcharodontosaurus so far?
I was telling friend that we need more dark theropods, the colorscheme on the allosaurus is really similar to this carcha, i would prefer uf they applied some dark tones over some predators, something like the allosaurus jimmadseni painted by andrey atuchin.
Yes that is a concern if too similar paint apps start to lose PNSO fandom. But I have reason to believe that PNSO is starting to receive this message, so let's see what future offerings come up. Paint app is something that differentiates companies, and given their quality of application, it would be unfortunate if choice of colour disappoints.
@@DinosDragons absolutely, its kinda their symbol now, but seeing how good they got on correcting the scale detail I think they have the potential to improve their color schemes
Carcharodontosaurus is probably the only mega theropod I actually really love (Im more of an Abelisaurid kinda guy) so I’m beyond happy it’s finally getting more love as of late. It’s such an interesting looking theropod but it feels like it’s often overshadowed by its South American cousin all the time.
Also yea it’s no way this is in scale with the T. rex figure but whatever
Unfortunately, it's so poorly known, that fame will always go to better understood figures. I'm also an abelisaurid camper, though I've been learning more about Allosauroidea and developing a greater appreciation of the clade. Hopefully we'll get another decent abelisaurid soon!
@@DinosDragons do you prefer the PNSO one or the GR toys one, also would ali express be trustworthy to buy the GR toys one from? Link: www.aliexpress.com/item/1005002004820982.html?spm=a2g0o.placeorder.0.0.567a321eu9W73l&mp=1
This is a beautiful model no doubt..and your review is fantastic...only issue I have with this model is they should some Grey or black wash to highlight the texture and skin folds especially in the belly region...second thing is it is really small compared to Wilson T.rex...if t.rex represents 12 meters individual as it is 1/35 scale this model should be little bit higher on the hip region even if it's considered to be 11 or 10 meter individual...the height difference is quite significant between the two model..we know that height around the hips is almost similar in these gaint therapods (Giganotosaurus, Mapusaurus, charcharodontosaurus and T.rex)
Thank you! The issue with Carcharodontosaurus is how fragmentary it is. For example, Dr Larramendi did an estimate of over 12m based off a Giganotosaurus femur that was _itself an estimate_ of 143cm. Then that got revised down to 136.5cm, and the estimate of Carcharodontosaurus based on that estimate was again revised down in length and height. The femur is such a key bone and yet we're missing it for Carcharodontosaurus. We really need more evidence. Meanwhile, I just try to enjoy the models as they are 😁
@@DinosDragons yes..I hope a new fossil discovery of this animal will give us a better picture....by the way i recently bought the Eofauna tric (cryptic version.. because they opted for striking color scheme based on modern birds)...and let me tell you pictures don't do justice to this model...it is very beautiful...you will definitely appreciate it in your hand...if you ever decide to buy it..😊
eofauna seem to be the best currently for reconstructions ..the older dinosaur books mention carcharodontosaurus as 8m based on the first partial specimen,must likely a sub adult in my view....
I am a little picky with my dinosaur models, I usually like all of mine to follow roughly 1:35 scale and be as scientifically accurate as possible! Would you be able to give me any advice on which one to pick up out of PNSO and GR ones, I really cannot decide!
Wow that is such a wide question it's impossible to answer. What are some specifics you're looking for?
@@DinosDragons sorry if I was a little vague in my comment, I was just refering to the GR toys and PNSO carchara, I ended up ordering the GR toys one just because of the scaling you spoke about later in the video. Can I just say I've gone through and watched nearly all of your reviews now; You truly are amazing man, well done. I am currently studying geology at university to later take my PhD in vertebrate paleontology and the amount of scientific detail you go into really makes you stand out from other channels, I would be interested to know some of your favourite scientifically accurate 1:35 figures of all time from any brand! I am wanting to build a big collection of my own.
The only problem I have with their 3 new dinosaurs Willson V3, Spino and this one.
Their new even smaller scaling than 1/35.
Unfortunately, I think consistency in scaling just isn't going to be a reality. Firstly, sculptors would prefer to work without that restrictiong. Secondly it's what size can bring out what features they want to elaborate on. And finally, depending on which actual size estimate you use, you won't ever satisfy fervent fans who have their own concept. For example I know people who firmly believe Carcharodontosaurus is only 11m or even less, and won't entertain any other estimate.
id prefer if they do what collecta has,have regular size figures and deluxe figures which would be larger...i dont mind bigger figures at all in fact i wish more companies made the figures in a larger scale...
Hi Dino. Do you know if PNSO have made any models that would have lived with the Carcha. ? Cheers
Rob
Hi, off the top of my head, I can only think of Spinosaurus. Other contemporaneous dinosaurs like Rugpops PNSO might have made in their little dinosaurs line, but I'm not familiar with that. I'm kind of hoping PNSO will tackle Ouranosaurus and of course, a Paralititan in 1:35 but that's probably just going to be a fantasy.
@@DinosDragons Yes I thought of Spinosaurus, hopefully someone makes make a one in 1:35 along with the ones you mentioned
Legal
Illegal
Compromise is often the best policy! 😁
the current estimates for C. saharicus are 1212cm long, 363cm tall and 6826kg at medium
There are actually a few and nothing definitive and generally accepted by all. I'm hoping for more complete material... well I guess I've been waiting for fifteen years, what's a few more!
@@DinosDragons true, i based my estimations on gunnar bivens's skeletal and franoys's weight estimates turned to the .95-.99 density
Hello I'm an amateur paleontologist, I love to read books on the skeleton and. Wonder what these top level predators life was like? my theropod leg bone,it has this tooth mark,that is on the back located to the left side, i wonder if it was a carcharodontosaurus that could have done damage from it's bitting teeth strength? And may I ask you do you have any used Books that I could have, I want to gain more knowledge to further my understanding of these creatures?
Apologies for my late reply as I have been ill.
For a start, what books are you currently using? Then I might be able to see what level of reading you're at, and then make some recommendations 🙂
@@DinosDragons I've read the introduction to paleontology and biology textbook by wiley Blackwell. J david Archibald, Dinosaur extinction and the end of an era ,what the fossils say,
This is the best carcharodontosaurus I have ever seen.
It's certainly one of them. The other is the GR Toys one, which is great because before this year, I can't think of a single decent one!
@@DinosDragons yep
Much prefer the paintwork on the GR
The GR is definitely more complex, something I would never have believed possible on a mass produced model. However it _is_ more fantastical while this one is more natural. Another thing is that the paint on that is pretty sticky, something to consider if it's likely to irritate you.
I can't choose between this one and the GR Toys model. This one has a better sculpt, but, other than the eyes, the paint doesn't even come close to the GR Toys model. It's also lacking in lips.
I've heard that there's still discussion relating to dinosaurs having lips or not, but I prefer them having them. It looks more natural to me, and makes more sense, conskdering that modern reptiles do.
Seems like you're inclining toward the GR Toys model. Would having the eyes repainted elevate it a bit more and help you make a decision?
Also keep in mind that if you like lips, is it important that the model shows it? I can't speak for others, but both of my GR Toys versions don't close fully, and so are unable to fully showoff the lipped interpretation of this dinosaur 😥
@@DinosDragons I'll admit, I'm leaning to the GR Toys model. The eyes are for sure the thing I hate most about the model, though, I'm planning on learning to paint at some point in the near future.
I've heard several complaints about the articulation on the GR Toys model. It is one reason I'm considering the PNSO model, as I prefer the mouths of the models being closed. I'm not sure if it's common for the figures to not be able to close their mouths or not, but, I'd rather not take the chance. I've never had good luck in cases like these.
I have the exact thing in mind, I really can't choose between this and GR toys as your explanation explains it all
this one is kind of cute and goofy
It definitely is, Maddy! Something about it, perhaps the head shape combined with the belly area. I am glad we have more distinct theropods; after a while they are in danger of becoming a blur!
bruh i got mine today and they forgot to paint the eyes rip
That sucks! Really?? The red colour is one thing that I really liked!
I suggest you buy from another seller
the plastic feels brittle
Mine hasn't broken but then I haven't dropped it. I have dropped my old PNSO Spinosaurus (large one) before, but except for some looseness in the articulated jaw after that, it seemed fine. I won't tempt fate though. Everything is on a secure shelf with sufficient space to avoid jostling.
The teeths are always exposed
Yes PNSO doesn't sculpt lips on their theropods.
조형은 훌륭한데 도색이 좀 성의 없다..
Actually, I see any dissatisfaction with the paint as a plus. If I don't like the paint, then I can save money on the model 😁
Did he eat chocolate like a baby?lol...the paint job is so awful 🙁