The Battle of Jamal | Shia View | Prof. Liyakat Takim | CIMS Islamic History (2 of 3)

Please Like 👍🏼, Share ↪️ & Subscribe👆🏿
CIMS Presentation on the Shia perspective by Prof. Liyakat Takim on the Battle of Jamal. Professor Takim briefly recapped the historical narrative, outlined by Qari Zahiruddin, confirming that these details were largely agreed upon by both Shia and Sunni. He then went on to mention certain points raised by Shia scholars such Lady Aisha’s attack on Basra, which resulted in many lives being lost, despite the killers of Uthman being in Medina and not in Basra. Furthermore, he mentioned the incident of the dogs barking at a place called Hawab, at which point Lady Aisha wanted to turn back as she remembered the Prophet warning his wives of the barking dogs of Hawab. However, members from her army came together and bore witness that the place they were at was not Hawab, to which some Shia scholars point out that this was a mass false testimony if not the first one in the Muslim history. The battle of Jamal was a dark time for the Muslim community and it is at this point in history according to Prof. Takim that a concretised notion of identity formed in the community where the label of either a follower of Ali or a follower of Uthman came into existence. (Part 2 of 3)
What is CIMS?
Since its inception in 2015, as a joint initiative of a network of Sunni and Shia scholars, The Centre for Intra-Muslim Studies (CIMS) has been at the forefront of providing a platform for honest, open and critical engagement on issues of historical and theological tension amongst Sunni and Shi’i thought.
www.cims.almahdi.edu/
Follow us on
Facebook: / almahdionline
Instagram: / amioutreach
Twitter: / amioutreach
Website: www.almahdi.edu/
Podcast: anchor.fm/almahdiinstitute
Al-Mahdi Institute
Access Islamic studies and Arabic anytime, anywhere: www.hawzaondemand.com/
Apply for the exciting & flexible AMI Islamic Studies programme: ami.is/apply
If you'd like to donate to this or other AMI programmes click here: ami.is/donate
#ImamAli #BattleofJamal #IslamicHistory

[@Ali19391]

So was it uthman or mauwiyah that started the war?