बहुत बहुत सुन्दर प्रस्तुति अच्छी तरह से तैयार किया गया कार्य अच्छा लगा कमल शर्मा जी के सवाल गम्भीर आवाज़ में मन्ना डे के जवाब सुरेली मधुर स्वर में पहले रेडियो पर प्रसारित होता था तब सुनता था टेप रिकार्ड में रिकार्ड करता था अब मोबाइल फोन पर करता रहा आज कल तो you tube video bhi देख लेते हैं मन्ना डे महेंद्र कपूर किशोर कुमार गांगुली महान इंसान सिंगर गायक मेरे मनपसंद गायक है कमल शर्मा जी सादर नमस्ते 🙏🙏
Manna Da Amar rahe. My unka ek bhakt hoon. Manna Da ka Gaya human Madhushaala ke partisan roj sunta hoon aur gungunata bhi. Jai ho Manna Da aap ka Charan spars.
A great singer having his own style of singing. A singer capable of singing romantic, comedy and a master of classical song having his own unique style.
ज़िन्दगी में पहली बार एक बेहतरीन कलाकार का ऐसा साक्षात्कार सुना जो गीतों के बग़ैर नीरस है। दुःखद है। इस क्लिप को गानों के साथ फिर से प्रकाशित करना चाहिए। इसके ऑडियो में भी कई जगह त्रुटियाँ हैं।
Great manna dey. G aor royalty mehanat ka hota Hai aap log mehanat ka hi paisa lete the aaj Kal sab kuch fast ho gya Hai. Rahi award uska kya bahut sare singer aise hain jinhe nominate Kiya gya but Mila nahi but jo Kam kiye Hai aap log wahi bahut bada award hai
दुख इस बात का है की इस इंटरव्यूमें मधुशाला के लिए मन्ना डे जी ने डॉक्टर साहब का जिक्र किया लेकिन वह हरिवंश राय जी के नहीं बल्कि लोग जयदेव जी के लिए उनको सुनते हैं l
Not agreed. He was the most prepared singer among all his contemporaries. Whatever songs he sang, he sang with perfection. According to me after Rafi Sahab and Lata Mangeshkar he was the only one who was truly a playback singer.
@@Duaakhan570 History is there to see. He never was main hero's voice. By the way playback singing is not about perfection. It is for the classical singers. Playback singing is about making the character alive. Here Kishore Mukesh Rafi and even Talat were way ahead.
@@vinodreeta Your criteria to consider someone how great he was, is based upon the popularity. No wonder by using this same criteria many Kishore Da fans say that he was better than Rafi Sahab. The criteria to know who is what should never be the popularity meter because if it is so then today Yo Yo & Badshah are more popular than Sonu Nigam. So correct your criteria first. If you look closely without any prior prejudices in your mind then you will find that Rafi Sahab is undoubtedly the superstar of playback singing. No singer could touch his genius. No one. After Rafi sahab it was only Lata Mangeshkar who understood the difference between singing and playback singing. After LM it was only MANNA Dey sir who worked on this thing and thats why I put him on high place. I know many Kishore da fans, Mukesh ji fans and Asha Bhonsle fans and other singers fans may get angry with me on this statement but what I am saying should be understood sincerely. No doubt Kishore da was genius, Mukesh ji touched hearts and AB was so much prepared in all the songs but still when we listen to Kishore da song it was Kishore da who sang and not that hero or that character who was singing. Same happened for other singers. And that's the difference. When you listen to any Rafi Sahab's song you can easily identify just by listening the song who is the hero. Even watching any Rafi Sahab's song on screen you never remind Rafi sahab and just bound to believe that song is being sung by that hero only. That's the beauty and genius of Rafi sahab which upto some extent LM and Manna Dey did too.
@@Duaakhan570 It's the other way around. Kishore Kumar was an actor and knew exactly what sort of voice modulation was required to suit an actor's voice, which none of the other great singers even had a clue about. To me all Rafi songs sound like Rafi not that of the voice of an actor. One glaring example is when Rafi was made to sing for Kishore Kumar and the voice is jarring as Rafi makes absolutely no attempt to modulate his voice to suit Kishore Kumar's. Other singers such as Manna Dey, Mahendra Kapoor who also sang a few songs for Kishore Kumar at least tried to sound like him and therefore they didn't sound that incongruous. Rafi sounded like Rafi in every song he sang irrespective of the actor who enacted the song. The similarity of Rafi's voice to voices of actors is only in your imagination.
@@artsandideas1895 HaHaHaHa what a joke😂👌. You objected on that quality in which only Rafi Sahab was famous i.e modulation of voice according to the actor on screen. This means you know nothing about Playback singing. You are not the first one who tried to belittle Rafi sahab but as the Sun doesn't get belittled when someone spits on it, same way the greatness and genius of Rafi Sahab never get affected when some ignorant like you tried to belittle him. The music industry knows, the music legends know and the world knows who was Rafi Sahab and what was Rafi Sahab. No Tom, Archana or Harry would ever succeed in this filthy game of spit and run. I give you one example by which you will be able to understand it better. You know in 70's Kishore da became the voice of Amitabh Bacchan. Though Rafi Sahab also sang for Amitabh but overall it was Kishore Da who sang more for Amitabh as his voice NATURALLY (mind the word please) suits on him. Now just watch any Amitabh movie in which he is with some other actor/hero. When it comes to the song in which two or more male singers were required and one hero is Amitabh then Kishore Da always sang for Amitabh and Rafi Sahab sang for the other actor. You will never find a song in which two or more actors were there and Amithabh was one them then Kishore Da would sing only for Amithabh and for no one else while Rafi Sahab Sahab would(could) sing for anybody. Why? You know why? I tell you the reason. Kishore Da was always chosen for Amitabh because his voice got fit on him naturally while Rafi Sahab could change his voice according to the actor on screen. Every MD knew this fact and that's why whenever Amitabh was singing on screen with any other hero then Kishore da was given only his song while Rafi sahab was given the other hero singing part as they all knew Rafi Sahab could easily do that. Now go and listen to more and more music legends to know what Rafi Sahab was so that in future you dont write such type of stupid comment.
बहुत बहुत सुन्दर प्रस्तुति अच्छी तरह से तैयार किया गया कार्य अच्छा लगा कमल शर्मा जी के सवाल गम्भीर आवाज़ में मन्ना डे के जवाब सुरेली मधुर स्वर में पहले रेडियो पर प्रसारित होता था तब सुनता था टेप रिकार्ड में रिकार्ड करता था अब मोबाइल फोन पर करता रहा आज कल तो you tube video bhi देख लेते हैं मन्ना डे महेंद्र कपूर किशोर कुमार गांगुली महान इंसान सिंगर गायक मेरे मनपसंद गायक है कमल शर्मा जी सादर नमस्ते 🙏🙏
The most versatile and the best playback singer ever.
मन्ना दा आप फिल्मी दुनिया में आए हमारी खुकिस्मती है। हमे इतने अच्छे गाने सुनने मिले। हम आपके आभारी हैं।
The Legend!
Lovely Intervwe .
Kitne mehnati aur sincere log the
Manna Da Amar rahe. My unka ek bhakt hoon. Manna Da ka Gaya human Madhushaala ke partisan roj sunta hoon aur gungunata bhi. Jai ho Manna Da aap ka Charan spars.
Even while he speaks ,manna da its almost like listening to his songs.. Wow.how lucky we are to be part of his journey as avid musical fans .
A great singer having his own style of singing. A singer capable of singing romantic, comedy and a master of classical song having his own unique style.
Superb interviewer
A Seven Gun Salute to Sri Mannada.Your Eternal Fan. To Sir with Love🎉. Ekalavya
Big Like wow
ज़िन्दगी में पहली बार एक बेहतरीन कलाकार का ऐसा साक्षात्कार सुना जो गीतों के बग़ैर नीरस है। दुःखद है। इस क्लिप को गानों के साथ फिर से प्रकाशित करना चाहिए। इसके ऑडियो में भी कई जगह त्रुटियाँ हैं।
Soothing to listen old singer interview!
Very nice
A versatile singer with modesty.Bharatratna awardee was not given the funeral with State Honours.
Too many advertises spoil the mood. Why can't Vividh bharati keep the videos free of ads?
A singer with golden voice - simply matchless.
Nice
You R Very Graet Manna Dey SaHaB
Pure bengalees. Aesehi. Hotehae. Great. Grand. And. Gratitude. Sabunmethe. Jo. AK. Bare. Banske. Aoulad. Hi. Jansaktehae. Karke. DikhaSaktehae.
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Those 5 dislikes have fallen to all time low disgraceful indeed
Rightly said.
Reminds me a Saying in my mother tongue Donkey will nit know broken rice taste.
🙏🙏🙏
Great manna dey. G aor royalty mehanat ka hota Hai aap log mehanat ka hi paisa lete the aaj Kal sab kuch fast ho gya Hai. Rahi award uska kya bahut sare singer aise hain jinhe nominate Kiya gya but Mila nahi but jo Kam kiye Hai aap log wahi bahut bada award hai
Sir Rishikesh mukharji k episodes upload kijiye
हम तो मन्ना डे गाना गुनगुनाते हे 365 डे हे मन्नाडे
दुख इस बात का है की इस इंटरव्यूमें मधुशाला के लिए मन्ना डे जी ने डॉक्टर साहब का जिक्र किया लेकिन वह हरिवंश राय जी के नहीं बल्कि लोग जयदेव जी के लिए उनको सुनते हैं l
unfortunately he never get what he deserved
No songs only discussion upto 15 minutes!
Public Jo Votedetehae Sab. Apasanskritywale Hae indiame Shame!!!
कमल शर्मा जी कुछ जादा ही बोलते है
कमल शर्मा जी कुछ ज्यादा ही लंबा सवाल करते है, और अपना ज्ञान ज्यादा बताते हैं, हर इंटरव्यू में
His voice let him down. He could not rank along with Kishore Rafi Mukesh
Not agreed. He was the most prepared singer among all his contemporaries. Whatever songs he sang, he sang with perfection. According to me after Rafi Sahab and Lata Mangeshkar he was the only one who was truly a playback singer.
@@Duaakhan570 History is there to see. He never was main hero's voice. By the way playback singing is not about perfection. It is for the classical singers. Playback singing is about making the character alive. Here Kishore Mukesh Rafi and even Talat were way ahead.
@@vinodreeta Your criteria to consider someone how great he was, is based upon the popularity. No wonder by using this same criteria many Kishore Da fans say that he was better than Rafi Sahab. The criteria to know who is what should never be the popularity meter because if it is so then today Yo Yo & Badshah are more popular than Sonu Nigam. So correct your criteria first.
If you look closely without any prior prejudices in your mind then you will find that Rafi Sahab is undoubtedly the superstar of playback singing. No singer could touch his genius. No one.
After Rafi sahab it was only Lata Mangeshkar who understood the difference between singing and playback singing.
After LM it was only MANNA Dey sir who worked on this thing and thats why I put him on high place.
I know many Kishore da fans, Mukesh ji fans and Asha Bhonsle fans and other singers fans may get angry with me on this statement but what I am saying should be understood sincerely.
No doubt Kishore da was genius, Mukesh ji touched hearts and AB was so much prepared in all the songs but still when we listen to Kishore da song it was Kishore da who sang and not that hero or that character who was singing. Same happened for other singers. And that's the difference.
When you listen to any Rafi Sahab's song you can easily identify just by listening the song who is the hero. Even watching any Rafi Sahab's song on screen you never remind Rafi sahab and just bound to believe that song is being sung by that hero only. That's the beauty and genius of Rafi sahab which upto some extent LM and Manna Dey did too.
@@Duaakhan570 It's the other way around. Kishore Kumar was an actor and knew exactly what sort of voice modulation was required to suit an actor's voice, which none of the other great singers even had a clue about. To me all Rafi songs sound like Rafi not that of the voice of an actor. One glaring example is when Rafi was made to sing for Kishore Kumar and the voice is jarring as Rafi makes absolutely no attempt to modulate his voice to suit Kishore Kumar's. Other singers such as Manna Dey, Mahendra Kapoor who also sang a few songs for Kishore Kumar at least tried to sound like him and therefore they didn't sound that incongruous. Rafi sounded like Rafi in every song he sang irrespective of the actor who enacted the song. The similarity of Rafi's voice to voices of actors is only in your imagination.
@@artsandideas1895 HaHaHaHa what a joke😂👌. You objected on that quality in which only Rafi Sahab was famous i.e modulation of voice according to the actor on screen. This means you know nothing about Playback singing.
You are not the first one who tried to belittle Rafi sahab but as the Sun doesn't get belittled when someone spits on it, same way the greatness and genius of Rafi Sahab never get affected when some ignorant like you tried to belittle him.
The music industry knows, the music legends know and the world knows who was Rafi Sahab and what was Rafi Sahab. No Tom, Archana or Harry would ever succeed in this filthy game of spit and run.
I give you one example by which you will be able to understand it better.
You know in 70's Kishore da became the voice of Amitabh Bacchan. Though Rafi Sahab also sang for Amitabh but overall it was Kishore Da who sang more for Amitabh as his voice NATURALLY (mind the word please) suits on him. Now just watch any Amitabh movie in which he is with some other actor/hero. When it comes to the song in which two or more male singers were required and one hero is Amitabh then Kishore Da always sang for Amitabh and Rafi Sahab sang for the other actor. You will never find a song in which two or more actors were there and Amithabh was one them then Kishore Da would sing only for Amithabh and for no one else while Rafi Sahab Sahab would(could) sing for anybody.
Why? You know why? I tell you the reason.
Kishore Da was always chosen for Amitabh because his voice got fit on him naturally while Rafi Sahab could change his voice according to the actor on screen. Every MD knew this fact and that's why whenever Amitabh was singing on screen with any other hero then Kishore da was given only his song while Rafi sahab was given the other hero singing part as they all knew Rafi Sahab could easily do that.
Now go and listen to more and more music legends to know what Rafi Sahab was so that in future you dont write such type of stupid comment.
Ye kb record hua ..koi bta skta hai
Nice