Another Election Show: What’s the pulse of Bengal’s youth? On Modi, corruption, development
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 май 2024
- #loksabhaelection2024
In West Bengal’s Hooghly, the BJP’s Locket Chatterjee and Trinamool Congress candidate Rachna Banerjee are locking horns in a fierce poll battle. The constituency is one of the seven Lok Sabha seats in the state that are set to vote on May 20.
In this episode of Another Election Show, Newslaundry reached Hooghly’s Chandernagore Government College to understand the pulse of the state’s youth and the issues that matter to them. The students spoke about triple talaq, women’s safety, Manipur violence and the Sandeshkhali controversy.
The students said development has taken place under Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government but corruption has also increased. Some others said both inequality and GDP have increased.
Watch.
Avail our press freedom offer: pages.razorpay.com/press-free...
Subscribe to Newslaundry: www.newslaundry.com/subscript...
Download the all-new Newslaundry app: www.newslaundry.com/download-app
Join us on WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va61...
Follow and engage with us on social media:
Facebook: / newslaundry
Twitter: / newslaundry
Instagram: / newslaundry
Avail our press freedom offer: pages.razorpay.com/press-freedom-offer
Subscribe to Newslaundry: www.newslaundry.com/subscription?ref=social
Download the all-new Newslaundry app: www.newslaundry.com/download-app
Join us on WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va61PEo0QeacOqU9vr2k
If you do biased information why we should fund you?
Being a Bengali I'm disappointed with this generation of students. This is a shame. They're not just ill-informed, they're irresponsible too.
rightly said.
Utterly sad. They have access to all sources yet choose to believe in the shit of irrationality.
When Locket, Indranil and Rachana are your candidates, what do you expect
It is disheartening to witness the demotion of our students; I never anticipated such a disappointing and irresponsible response. It is crucial to investigate whether they are being funded by a specific party cadre. Newslaundry is disseminating biased information in Bengal, as they are exclusively engaging with individuals affiliated with a particular party cadre, rather than seeking input from neutral sources or ordinary students.
Mostly they are Instagram users or youtubers. What else can be expected from them.useless youth
Very badly informed. Only students of WhatsApp university.
If this is how the present students are, then I feel sorry for my country. Very poorly informed.
It must have been embarrassing for the teachers and librarian of Chandannagar College listening to the students. My sympathy are with the young generation.
These students are not very aware of socio political situation of India.
true
Bilkul bhai if anyone is saying something right for bjp tb woh andhbhakt hai, pagal hai, whatsapp university ka graduate hai aur anpadh aur un aware hai to pls apna comment ki banao batti aur dal lo piche wali jeb me 😂😂😂
Sports... I think the girl is unaware of the Sakshi Malik case, the stand taken by our government, and the Manipur case.
yeah i almost laughed when the girl and the boy said 'nari shakti'. are you kidding me? do these kids ever read the newspaper?! whatsapp university is where they actually study
After all the colleges/universities in Bengal, you chose to visit a college, which nobody even bothers to look at, except for its aesthetic beauty!!!
Glad they did that.. this is the unfortunate reality and a generation that has only known modi
@@attudapatusHaha .... care about Bengal...whole education system was destroyed by TMC ....look at job corruption rampant .... No industrialization only 1000 rupee scheme...... 3rd most densely populated State , once highest GDP per capita State to now 21st per capita State with 1900 usd way below than national average ....23th in Human development index ,,, 19th in crime index ... Highest level of bureaucrat scams .....once contribute to 20 % of Industrial output of the nation to now less than 3% ....all thanks to TMC and CPIM ....and we bengali care about West Bengal 😂
No ground reality. Just WHATSAPP GYAN
There's some Pressure on them do BHAKTI.
I guess you either enter the wrong place to talk to student or it shows how this university is giving education to their students. Sad to see how the young youth of our country marching towards wrong path 😭
What a disappointing bunch of students
I am worried about next generation
We are doomed. This generation is a
Disgrace.
Haha .... care about Bengal...whole education system was destroyed by TMC ....look at job corruption rampant .... No industrialization only 1000 rupee scheme...... 3rd most densely populated State , once highest GDP per capita State to now 21st per capita State with 1900 usd way below than national average ....23th in Human development index ,,, 19th in crime index ... Highest level of bureaucrat scams .....once contribute to 20 % of Industrial output of the nation to now less than 3% ....all thanks to TMC and CPIM ....and we bengali care about West Bengal 😂
It pains to see that a huge section of the youth has lost the ability of critical thinking.
This is Bengal's Galgotiya University .... you will find at least one in every state ......
This is one of the best heritage colleges of West Bengal.
3rd class students from an aristocratic town, I am amazed.
Noo😭😭😭 This is not the true Bengal! How disappointing!
Strange to see kids like this. Kids from my university are terrifyingly well informed and active. Even about rights of the gaurds, andworkers employed by the university.
It's very sad to see the students are unaware of the reality.
Most of these students didn't answer the questions asked by the reporter but they gave a general reply instead of actually answering the question. This way,their answers seemed to be all made up in advance. For example, they didn't answer the questions related to Manipur and Revanna.They spoke well only about Bengal related issues.
We are bengali so obviously we care for Bengal more than the rest of India.
Scripted answer s
Haha .... care about Bengal...whole education system was destroyed by TMC ....look at job corruption rampant .... No industrialization only 1000 rupee scheme...... 3rd most densely populated State , once highest GDP per capita State to now 21st per capita State with 1900 usd way below than national average ....23th in Human development index ,,, 19th in crime index ... Highest level of bureaucrat scams .....once contribute to 20 % of Industrial output of the nation to now less than 3% ....all thanks to TMC and CPIM ....and we bengali care about West Bengal 😂.😂@@viiru9683
@@atulanabhattacharya8191yes it is ...they hate bjp coz they are highly leftist ..in this process they forgot problems of Bengal .... bengal is in very pathetic situation all thanks to TMC
Giving me headache,listening to such guy especially 2nd boy at top from left..he is using WHATSAPP as source of info....r we heading towards catastrophe??? How will opposition deal with such nonsense and fake news???
So sad to see the shift in the thought process of Bengal. It looks like the state has lost its intellect. The sensibility and rationality that the youth of Bengal carried in the 70s have now become the story of the past. It's sad to see jobless youth but most unfortunate is to see the misguided and ill-informed youth. Modi is sensible for women is the greatest farce and those who believe this without even questioning are the abyss of hopelessness.
Students need to do homework regularly... Chandannagar college students forgot this basic rule 😂
am frm Northeast Nagaland n people considered us backwards too,bt i knw what is going around special this days but seeing this students interview i can assure you 💯% guys that they are frm Watsapp University... 😂
Bengali here. I present to you the WhatsApp generation of Bengal, i.e. the generation born between 1996-2006. This is the generation whose political awareness started to develop on or after the deceptive India against Corruption movement, the fall of TV journalism quality, the rise of media control to propagate hate politics and Modi-Bhakti, and the emergence of industrial grade social media fake news.
Haha .... care about Bengal...whole education system was destroyed by TMC ....look at job corruption rampant .... No industrialization only 1000 rupee scheme...... 3rd most densely populated State , once highest GDP per capita State to now 21st per capita State with 1900 usd way below than national average ....23th in Human development index ,,, 19th in crime index ... Highest level of bureaucrat scams .....once contribute to 20 % of Industrial output of the nation to now less than 3% ....all thanks to TMC and CPIM ....and we bengali care about West Bengal 😂
मोदी सरकार में समानता की बात करना सबसे बड़ी बेमूर्खता होगी। लोकतंत्र धर्म के लिए ज्यादा से ज्यादा मतदान करे व करवाए। जय-जय जागरूक जनता-जनार्दन जय जय इंडिया गठबन्धन सरकार जय जय पत्रकार बन्धुजन जय जय गांधी परिवार
Am a bengali and am very sad to see the very limited gyan todays generation have. No homework no fact check nothing no deep thoughts. Shocked on student's reply on Manipur issue.
they does not represent Bengal..only aware of PR news
These students are like kinder garden kids, they are having Only what's app knowledge,
how sad situation they are in. they don't even know what they are talking about I think students of AIIMs dharbhanga are more knowledgable than them.
How frustrating this would be for the camera man and the reporter to take their interview🤣 they must be thinking, why on earth we had to face these childrends
Sad and disappointing to hear.
I am from Bhubaneswar Here lot of students from Bengal come to study I have seen them closely - smart intelligent & culturally rich
Jahan bhi BJP ka sarkar bani thi, wahan pe kuch be development nahi hua, na siksha, na hospital, na kisi ko , naukri mila,
Ye University k students hain ya WhatsApp University k students hain?? Kahan se laaye hain aap aise students interview k liye 😂😂😂
I couldn't finish seeing this video. These opinions are formed thru Whatsapp, none of the students (whether with or against the BJP) had in depth knowledge of any topic! Sad to see this in a College...
same! very disappointing video
@@Juss169indeed
Coz of mamata the biiiitccccch ....he destroys the whole bengal....
Or may be they were forbidden by their parents to unveil their minds....
Newslaundry be like we will wash and clean every party but not BJP 😂
not news laundry but bjp is one wich clean every party by taking there corrupt party politicians
puts them in washing machine and produces clean politicians from
coal scammer to adarashscammer all in bjp
even corrupt tmc politicians purified by bjp
🤣🤣
Godi media is doing it for bjp, so it's balanced.
😂
Ashamed being a Bengali seeing this students, they are so so ill informed and they are not aware of the source of information pivoted to them.. …digging own grave..
Thank you for this information
Even there're some Andh Bhakts. Wah Wasooliwala Modaniji Wah, Ache din? 🤬
So, it proves that education level is in the same level of WULU (WhatsApp Uncle Logic University), Wah!
What kind of college this is...very poor quality of student. c grade college ?
Sorry to say... Hum (aam janta) ni sudhrenge sir.
Hume wo saare kaam achche lagte h jo feel good karaye for example 370 ya UN me humara jalwa ho gaya h... Bass itna kafi h
Hume rozgar mile na mile... Humare as pas aag lag jaye bhale hi... But feel good factor hona chahiye...
Bass gdp badh rahi h bhale hi per capita income kamm ho jaye ( illogical baate) ye graduate ho ke job mile na mile but shayd ek party ke bheed banne me jaroor kaam aynge❤
As a Bengali NRI, I'd vote for NDA as long as I hold my Indian citizenship. India needs capitalism, hardcore capitalism.
Surprise to know their opinion 🫣
So Atul found another Galgotia University in Bengal???
Subhendu Adhikari ko bhul gaye Atul...this college was known for revolution...but some of them broke my heart...
It must be said, that people are very less aware of any socio-political-economic realities of their land... And people will complain about poor governments, but ironically not even be aware of their basic responsibilities and the causalities of all the nuisance...
"We want to be apolitical!!!"
Bengal, the mukhia of the country once (pehle), but seems, now (ab) padhna likhna chhor diya hai.
many achievers from bengal we have but looking at these students i could say, they have zero knowledge and serious followers of godi media. Someone said once, 4th pillar of democracy has become 3rd leg of XXXX. All studnets are graducated from whatsapp university. All the best.
These students are fooled by......
Bengal was known for its critical thinking, intellectualism and revolutionary ideas. What has happened to that intellectual temper and spirit? Seems most universities these days have been taken over by WhatsApp University.
Bengal's critical thinking is in coma under ventilator support in the Critical Care Unit.CCU
Blame TMC Govt governance 😂
Coz of TMC ..... All college students try to lick mamata's sandal and want to become a youth leader ... easy way to earn money
Corruption hua development bhi hua..ye kya bat hey.
Great work! Thank you. Sad to see so many young minds disillusioned and that too in Bengal! WhatsApp seems to be doing its job well!
Manipur Hathras prajwal ravana yeh sab tou hua hi nhi india mei ji
Serampore - Danish Chandannagar - French Chinsurah - Dutch Saptagram - Portuguese
We have a long way to go. Everyone has a right to opinion. The disappointment is because they are so ill-informed. If they read sufficient enough with diverse perspectives and reasoned arguments, how will they know what are the ground realities!!! Amazed at the level of and extent of being ill-informed. I also feel that NL needs to probe at least on certain thematic, use the opportunity to let them know how women's safety has gone for a toss... There were several responses on women's safety improved. Using probes to elicit focused views will help. Opportunity to provide them space to revisit their views...
Very sad to hear these students. The quality of politics in Bengal and the quality of leaders of the current regime shows it's impact on education also. All 3rd class and bogus students. The students seem to have very little knowledge of socio political environment of Bengal.
I expect better from these students but I was kidding myself.
Ashamed to see these goborvakts in Bengal
At 25th minute a student boasts about gdp growth the gdp growth doesnt benefit anyone sitting there or listening to rallies the gdp gorwth is distributed very unequally and also a huge portion of the gdp growth showcased is due to government spending in infrastructure development not because our manufacturing in the country has grown and make in india is kinda more like assemble in india just imagine if all make in india and gdp is growth is all huge why is the unemployment rising at all time high because we have a lot of growth in paper not really in a ground level
Is this in Bengal, I wonder
This interview reaffirms the fact that student politics is extremely crucial in college. Atleast students will be more aware of what's going on in the country.
What is INDIA's place in world hunger index 111 the GOVT both state & central are not working for education health employment etc not performing upto date but very poor government are not for all types of religion
wow, very nice intro music, can you give name of it.
These kids dont really follow news, not even mainstream media.
Pura dekhne k baad yaad aya, our teachers would do the same- to do and say things which might help boost the schools image. Minister log sayad ye sab answer sunkar khus ho jaye and kuch donations kar de college/University k liye.
This generation is so aloof about politics. Shame!
Notice the students who know Jack sht speak in hindi
It is also the duty of the journalist to share the truth with these brainwashed kids
As a Bengali I am really disappointed by the level of misinformation among the students of these generation. It is not their fault as they have spent 10 years of their formative years under this regime and have been fed this bull crap relentlessly through the social media.
I am from west Bengal. These are not true picture. These are WhatsApp university student
दहशत के माहौल को0 महसूस किया इन बच्चों में इस बात चीत के दौरान । समय की और संसाधनों की बरबादी मत करिए बच्चों में कोई समृद्ध विचार नहीं मिले।
Let me inform you that they all learn french and most of them migrate to France.There is an Alliance Française in Kolkata where the courses are very expensive.These Chandannagar students dominate there because they come after learning french from school level.They are the ones who go to France.In fact this Institution is totally controlled by Chandannagar and outsiders pay lakhs of rupees and don't learn a thing.All the Chandannagar people I've met till date..and there are many,are hindutwa agents and Modi bhakts.They even troll and threaten other learners if,during a discussion they criticise the Central Government.The French Government which is mostly Islamophobic also encourages immigration of these people.
This is what my friends say when I ask them what BJP has done. I ask them what about inequality, GDP PPP, etc. They act as if they are BJP party members.
So ill-informed and un-thinking students. Completely disconnected from reality. Eating out of the hands of the media who are completely bought. Compared to these students those in UP and Bihar are much more discerning and articulate. They may not be comfortable in Hindi, but that doesn't stop them from being more aware of their environment. What a shame!
Having some basic knowledge when you try to explain the history, is good.
From Serampore till Bandel, there were 5 different European settlements in different times. Serampore (Srirampur) was a Dennis settlement, the first printing press of India was set up here. Chandannagore was a French settlement. Chinsurah was a Dutch settlement. Bandel was a Portugese settlement.
All were lost to the British, except Chandannagore. While India got independene in 1947, Chandannagore and Pondichery were made independent and part of India in 1954.
Yai students ohh my God yai kya bol rahe h inhe khud ko pata nahi,sad
चंदन काॅलेज गलगोटिया युनिवर्सिटी के अंतर्गत आता हैं क्या?
विद्यार्थियों में ज्ञान और समझ करीब करीब एक जैसी हि लगती हैं।
Ask these students why BJP always Choosing the corrupted leaders like Suvendu adikari, and himanta biswas sharma as a party leaders,
These are university students... Shocking.... Talk like nursury students...
When you use WhatsApp forwards for study:
Sad to see the level of uninformed taint the young Bengal is doing. Disappointing.
This is embarrassing to listen to. Being a bangali I feel sorry to have given the audience a very poor representation of bangali youth.
Ill informed generation :(
Bengal is doomed.
As for as employment both the govt i.e central and state are failed to make any impact. Especially state govt has become a curse for the youth. Education system is totally collapsed.
Students are either instructed by college authorities or they might be under political pressure or be may be lack of self analytical point of view. This is not expected from Bengali’s failure to analyse lack courage to speak truth
@user-qs4ry9zp8x no, I do well come criticism against Mamata, so did they and You should analyse Every politician (including Modi) we are citizens we are mean to do so
@user-qs4ry9zp8x I don’t know much of Bengal local politics as I am from from Maharashtra, but I am not against students criticising Mamata my comment is regarding student’s poor basics understanding. I am not blind supporter of any politician like you and I am also not bound to make you understand anything cause you have basic understanding issues…analyse yourself your are turning into foolish political for canning politicians(includes every party)….
@@mairaateeb9459Haha .... care about Bengal...whole education system was destroyed by TMC ....look at job corruption rampant .... No industrialization only 1000 rupee scheme...... 3rd most densely populated State , once highest GDP per capita State to now 21st per capita State with 1900 usd way below than national average ....23th in Human development index ,,, 19th in crime index ... Highest level of bureaucrat scams .....once contribute to 20 % of Industrial output of the nation to now less than 3% ....all thanks to TMC and CPIM ....and we bengali care about West Bengal 😂
@@mairaateeb9459 you don't have any idea about Bengal .....it was destroyed by TMC and CPIM ..... weather you like it or not ..... Even they youth are useless everyone want be youth leader of TMC coz it is the easy way to earn money 🤑
@@WRATH19 yes definitely one can say so, I have idea abt violence in panchayat elections …. It’s strange but fact ..
Ek poora generation Godi media dekhke badi ho gayee. They base their opinions on lies peddled by lapdogs😢
China hindustan ka bahut Sara zameen gabsa karliya , arunachal pradesh ka Bahut sare jaga ka naam badal diya, Lekin yeh bachche log andh bakht jaise baat karte hai.
They have consumed BJP propaganda and regurgitated it in this session.
Muslim Dharam ke worship act me BJP Ne Bahut interfere Kiya Jo Kise ke bhe Dharam ke Workship Me KISI Ko bhe Haq Nahi Hai
@newslaundry with crowdfunding you have the obligation to serve the people better. More quality content and not such garbage content. I refuse to believe this is a mixed or aware crowd.
One way praise without critical thinking shows depravity of right winger thinking..
Does it take time to visit Manipur.
Yes Modi is inspirational but it is all lectures. Where are jobs, crime against women is worse than what it was, the inspirational leadership let's rape accused free...
Here also the students are not able to give concrete statements. Deep down they will boil down to religious hatemongering only.
They need some knowledge before speaking, india ki tulna un desho k saath hote hai jo list mai sabse niche hua karte hai, this things are really concerning the students of india can speak anything without any knowledge nobody cares but the prime minister of India ? What about him he must know what is he is speaking, million of peoples are watching him . BJP k dictionary mai religion, Pakistan and mandir hata de to utna hi sense bacha rahega jitna is duniya mai dinasaur bache hai . No doubt development hue hai lekin kya karoge development ka jab insaan hi insaan k khilaf hai
Are they blind 😂
@7:57.... मोदि का सबसे अच्छा काम "महिलाओं को आगे बढाना" "बेटी बचाओ बेटी पढाओ"
भाई चा..चु.. जर ये तो बताओ कि मोदि जी ने इस चुनाव में कितने महिलाओं को टिकट दिया हैं?
रही बात बेटी बचाओ बेटी पढाओ नारे कि तो मणिपुर के मामले में, महिला पहलवानों के मामले में, प्रज्वल रेवन्ना के मामले में, हाथरस के मामले में, उन्नाव के मामले में, मोदि ने ना बेटी को बचाया ना बेटी के साथ खड़े रहे, उलटा ब्रिजभुषण और प्रज्वल रेवन्ना को भाजपा से चुनाव तिकट दिया हैं ।
तो अगर भगवा ने थोडासा भी दि हो तो इस्तेमाल करो, रटेरटाए तोते कि तरह कुछ भी पोपटपंछी मत करो
Disillusioned with Didi I guess - they see hope as they are still part of India
Kon h ye log ......kaha se aate h....😢😢😢
Aaj ki padhi likhi new generation agar aisi h to ....🧐🤐🙏
I think that's what happens when you have access of cheap & easy access of internet, but don't know how to get proper information . Or maybe you are so disconnected with ground reality. Terribly lack of knowledge on concerned subjects. I think Atul-ji spare them from critical questions to save them from embarrassment. The Lucknow university one was much better.
My bengali friend talk about radical islamaisation and political violence.
I ask have u seen one bengali general caste got killed for marrying a obc /sc/st?
He said, " Wtf all those thing dont happen any more within hindus, these are muslim thing"
I ask him to write honor killings in up/bihar/Rajasthan/bengal/haryana/Andhrapradesh/Punjab etc all the states one by one and go to news section. He found and couldn't believe that only in bengal honor killings dont happen, bengal rank last in caste hatred.
I ask him that why in your society parents don't have at least one boy child?
He again said, " Wtf we aren't muslim, hindu treat son and daughter equally "
I showed him 2cr honor killings which happened in india, and still happening. In Uttrakhand in 132 villages no girl child born for 3months . Just search it .
Forget political party, whoever comes in power that doesn't matter much. But i just hope bengal knows that north is not hindu they only chant Sri ram name, ander se they castist racist fetus killer honor killer.
All the crime that happening happened in bengal are mostly done by politician such as shahjahan. But NO common people did any harm unlike north where common parents did wrong.
Bengali hindus name are laest found in rape in bengal itself, either its muslim or north indian. In other state they don't go for work and slut shame local women, unlike many other.
Only in bengal no farmer suicide happened.
I hope bengalis also see positive thing in their society.
Products of whatsapp univercity.
India ka naam Modi ka waja se badnaami hua, Modi videsh jaata hai sirf apna dost adani ka business keliye, desh keliye nahi.