Julia SHOULD BE IN TOP FIVE! Not Russell, who is hoping that saying she is granddaughter to Loretta Lynn will win her the 2024 American Idol. SHE SHOULD NOT BE IN TOP 5!!!
Abi Carter is phenomenal!! I hope she wins but I also love Jack. Emmy is good but to me she sounds the same in every single song. Wish there could be a female and a male winner every season. Good luck to all!!
If Abi doesn’t win, there’s something wrong with the voting community- she DESERVES this- she actually reminds me of Adele in so many ways- but she Abi- she could be as huge as Adele though
Emmy doesn’t need the power vocals because she’s got such a unique sound and sweet presence. Her voice is very different from Loretta amd Crystal. She is a star in her own right. She’s the whole package - not a belter but a very lyrical and beautiful sound. She’s an original. Whether or not she wins, she should be on the world stage singing to the masses.
Beautifully played and sung by McKenna, the "To make you feel my love" is an original Bob Dylan song that he wrote in 1997 for the album "Time Out Of Mind".. Kind of sad that neither 'Talent Rewind' nor Lionel Richie knows that; Lionel being old enought to have listened to BD for years, like me...
She has a good voice, but she should NOT be in Top Five! She is only there because she is granddaughter to Loretta Lynn! If that had not been vocalised each time, she would NOT BE IN TOP FIVE. THAT IS THE TRUTH!
When they got to the top 7, I'm like there's your winner 🏆. McKenna I Love and want her to win, but Abi Emmy Julia Will Jack Triston, they're all winners in my mind and all will be going on even after.. so🎉 and EDIT: Gawdam Julia has a huge powerful beautiful voice. I'm Still in LOVE with the SULTRY voice MCKENNA. But I still think it's Abi's season
I'm 75 years old and have been watching it since the beginning. I used to watch bits and pieces of it. Now I can't turn it off. The judges have one hell of a job now. Trying t choose a number one is absolutely impossible because there are now dozens of number one performer.
She is a good singer Emmy she deserves it not because she's Loretta Lynn's great granddaughter she can stand alone with or with out saying who she is related too if my grandma was Loretta lynn I sure as hell would tell the world. She's not boasting she loves her grandma and just lost her. I love you Emmy
Julia was Robbed , if Emmy wanted to be known for herself she should not had said she was Loretta’s granddaughter , the other two was Better . Julia should have Won
like you wouldn't use it or every thing possible to come out on top. good on her for using everything God gave her. she can say she did it now because look at all her haters come out crying about it
People have different choices. Some may have the same choice as you have or they may dislike someone that you like very much. It is about preference. And you cannot blame other people for disliking those you really like. And in this case it is not the fault of those contestants who were voted in nor of those who were voted out. Let us say it was their fate.
She (Julia) was great! But, she wasn't the total "Hollywood" package. Which is sad but true, unfortunately. But a cutie and a beautiful voice for sure!!! ❤❤❤
At this point it wouldn't hurt my feelings. If any of these top 10 would win American idol. They're all more than capable of winning this thing. My favorite I have to admit is Emmy Russell but rest assured the rest of the contestants are isometrically on the same level. I just think any Russell is adorable. I've always been a Loretta Lynn fan. I know I know she wants to be separate from her me ma and all that to make her separation to confirm her final separation. She has to win American idol 30:35 mom
I think McKenna has a great voice. I like the outside the box. That's why I like emme. There are so many who sound like Julia and abi. Give me Emme,Jack, and McKenna. I like the young man from Alabama but he, in my opinion needs a couple more years. Give me the outside the so called what a singer should look and sing like and ill love it everytime.
@Goya1216 not everyone has to sing like an angel to be good. Emme has a completely diffrent voice. I think she's awsome but I also believe that the other young lady is better than the 15yr old on this particular night.
Abi Carter is my winner, she has been since Week 2, and Julia and Jack aren't close to her and that goes for the rest of the contestents in the competition
You are absolutely right! Yes, Emmy is good, but she made Top 5 because of constantly tying her in with the name of her grandma. Otherwise she WOULD NOT have made Top Five!
Emmy Russell has the entire Loretta Lynn community voting for her ONLY because she is Loretta’s granddaughter. If she had never mentioned it, they would never have known &would NOT have voted for her en masse.
Emmy Russell is trying to make a name for herself in the music business. And she definitely deserves to go through no matter what anybody says. So back off
Katy Perry--Put some clothes on for Pete's sake. We all have those but we don't need to have them popping out. Disgusting. I thought this was a FAMILY show!
The cowboy is actually one of the best in my opinion but everybody has their own opinion but I agree with the person who Said if Loretta lynn granddaughter wanted known for herself she shouldnt have out it out there for everyone to know she is riding on gmas shirt tail
I think Emmy is sliding in on her family name. She's not that good. I agree with others - Julia is much better. Emmy is just....blah...., in my opinion. Totally understand people like her, but i can't help but feel she's got some favoritism playing into her choice -
I just finished watching this and I'm seriously upset and kinda mad at the same time because I Honestly and Truthfully believe that America should've Voted McKenna🤔 to be in the Top 5 instead of Emmy Russell 🤨! I mean don't get me wrong Emmy Russell is a pretty good Singer, but in all Honesty McKenna was so much better, Ugh!! To be Totally Honest with everyone, I honestly think 🤔 that 1 of the Only reasons that Emmy Russell has continued to be able to Keep Moving forward in this Season's American Idol is because she's the Granddaughter! But she shouldn't of gotten made it into American Idol's Top 5🤔😕😠!
Watching this from Sydney, Australia. If any of the contestants are watching this - Emma, I love your tone and voice on the piano, you didn't need to get up and dance, but what would have made the song you was if you "sexed it up" by singing it slower and more seductively. It sounded rushed at the piano. If you had of got up, it would have been ok, but at the piano, when singing songs tike that try singing seductively. Keep up the great work, you are not lost in the world and have started to shine. Well done.
I just came here to say that these top 5 results SUCK!!!! No McKenna, No Good. I didn't watch tonights episode yet, but i swear to God if Abi isnt in this finale, AI can go F*** O**!!!
Abi Carter….Amazing! Love listening to her. She’s gotta win.
Abi Carter is the winner; she has a voice like no other
Abi Carter is taking this win🎉 No doubt then runner up Jack.... just my opinion. Favorites
Julia!! Wish you were in top 5!
Julia SHOULD BE IN TOP FIVE! Not Russell, who is hoping that saying she is granddaughter to Loretta Lynn will win her the 2024 American Idol. SHE SHOULD NOT BE IN TOP 5!!!
We all do, Julia
@@Goya1216 like you wouldn't play that card if you were in her place.
@@Goya1216 truth is Julia was ok at best but ok will not win this show. miss Russell won't win it's ok they're just cleaning out the pack
@@dennisfitch7791 - I would not, but It’s obvious YOU would.
Abi Carter is my favorite!
Abi Carter is phenomenal!! I hope she wins but I also love Jack. Emmy is good but to me she sounds the same in every single song. Wish there could be a female and a male winner every season. Good luck to all!!
Abi has been my favorite since her audition! Good luck girl.
I'd choose Julia over Emmy.
If Abi doesn’t win, there’s something wrong with the voting community- she DESERVES this- she actually reminds me of Adele in so many ways- but she Abi- she could be as huge as Adele though
Emmy doesn’t need the power vocals because she’s got such a unique sound and sweet presence. Her voice is very different from Loretta amd Crystal. She is a star in her own right. She’s the whole package - not a belter but a very lyrical and beautiful sound. She’s an original. Whether or not she wins, she should be on the world stage singing to the masses.
Jack.is REALLY a Great Entertainer and Vocalist 🎉
Love Emmy!!!
I wanted the see Julia go forward 😢. Abi and Jack will most likely face off at the end. ❤🎉😊
Julia one of the best voices over there wow
gotta love Abi.... but Jack is also awesome.
Julia should be there. I feel she got robbed.
I AGREE! She got robbed royally!
She didn't get robbed it was America's choice don't be hating on Emmy.
American Idol is rigged.
Beautifully played and sung by McKenna, the "To make you feel my love" is an original Bob Dylan song that he wrote in 1997 for the album "Time Out Of Mind"..
Kind of sad that neither 'Talent Rewind' nor Lionel Richie knows that; Lionel being old enought to have listened to BD for years, like me...
That's all songs a lot older than Bob Dylan 1997
Love Jack❤
I love Emmy Russel you can’t help who you are related too!
McKenna is mine
Why? She just sounds like someone who lost their voice?
Emmy Russell sings awesome beautiful voice ❤ Her Grandma Loretta would be so proud of her ❤️ America vote for her on American Idol 2024😊👍
Como cuando pesa en la balanza tu abuela🙄
She has a good voice, but she should NOT be in Top Five! She is only there because she is granddaughter to Loretta Lynn! If that had not been vocalised each time, she would NOT BE IN TOP FIVE. THAT IS THE TRUTH!
@@Goya1216but no matter what you say she's there. there's no use crying about it to everyone who liked her. get over it
Ali is my favorite to win
I can't believe that Julia is not on the top 5 😢
Being over 55, I love Miss Brienhollz version of both sides now
When they got to the top 7, I'm like there's your winner 🏆.
McKenna I Love and want her to win, but Abi Emmy Julia Will Jack Triston, they're all winners in my mind and all will be going on even after.. so🎉 and
EDIT: Gawdam Julia has a huge powerful beautiful voice.
I'm Still in LOVE with the SULTRY voice MCKENNA.
But I still think it's Abi's season
Emmy didn't have to ride her coat tails. Talent wins out. When they narrow it down to 10 they are all winners
Love Emmy Russell performance, she was awesome!
I'm 75 years old and have been watching it since the beginning. I used to watch bits and pieces of it. Now I can't turn it off. The judges have one hell of a job now. Trying t choose a number one is absolutely impossible because there are now dozens of number one performer.
McKenna should have gone through. She sings amazing!
She is a good singer Emmy she deserves it not because she's Loretta Lynn's great granddaughter she can stand alone with or with out saying who she is related too if my grandma was Loretta lynn I sure as hell would tell the world. She's not boasting she loves her grandma and just lost her. I love you Emmy
have to love katy perry to bits... she's such a beautiful human being; she gives so much of herself to us
MaKenna should have made it to top 3!!! She has one of the best and unique voices out of a majority of the rest!
Its hard to pick just one..They are all good. ..no doubt someone will be after them with contracts.
The thing with a contract is signing your life away to someone else
Julia was Robbed , if Emmy wanted to be known for herself she should not had said she was Loretta’s granddaughter , the other two was Better . Julia should have Won
like you wouldn't use it or every thing possible to come out on top. good on her for using everything God gave her. she can say she did it now because look at all her haters come out crying about it
😂❤
People have different choices. Some may have the same choice as you have or they may dislike someone that you like very much. It is about preference. And you cannot blame other people for disliking those you really like. And in this case it is not the fault of those contestants who were voted in nor of those who were voted out. Let us say it was their fate.
That didn't do anything to help her! They would have found out anyway!
She (Julia) was great! But, she wasn't the total "Hollywood" package. Which is sad but true, unfortunately. But a cutie and a beautiful voice for sure!!! ❤❤❤
Idol is pushing Abi Carter but to me all her songs sound the same. To me there is some good talent this year.
At this point it wouldn't hurt my feelings. If any of these top 10 would win American idol. They're all more than capable of winning this thing. My favorite I have to admit is Emmy Russell but rest assured the rest of the contestants are isometrically on the same level. I just think any Russell is adorable. I've always been a Loretta Lynn fan. I know I know she wants to be separate from her me ma and all that to make her separation to confirm her final separation. She has to win American idol 30:35 mom
Abi just did a winning performance right there!!!
McKenna..... Just smooth, smokey honey.
I think McKenna has a great voice. I like the outside the box. That's why I like emme. There are so many who sound like Julia and abi.
Give me Emme,Jack, and McKenna. I like the young man from Alabama but he, in my opinion needs a couple more years.
Give me the outside the so called what a singer should look and sing like and ill love it everytime.
I really like her
ABI is one of my favourite she is Absolutely Amazing ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Jack looks like Pre Wee Herman
I don’t mind his voice… but he makes just the oddest expressions with his mouth as he sings.
Emmy reminds me of her grandma. She looks like her when she was young.
That’s the problem…constantly mentioning her grandmother! She IS NOT LORETTA LYNN! AND, she doesn’t belong on TOP 5 finals!
@Goya1216 not everyone has to sing like an angel to be good. Emme has a completely diffrent voice. I think she's awsome but I also believe that the other young lady is better than the 15yr old on this particular night.
@@carldavisjr7501 - Emmy DOES sing good, but NOT as good of the other two ladies.
My opinion Emmy is in a box. She doesn't dance or engaging with the audience
She’s too Taylor Swiftie for me and every song she sings sounds the same to me
Julia and jack are miles ahead of the rest.
Abi Carter is my winner, she has been since Week 2, and Julia and Jack aren't close to her and that goes for the rest of the contestents in the competition
Everyone is gifted and has put in the work, and their heart so kudos to all of them.
Emmy has a sweet little voice but she needs to mature in her performance.
Jake all the way
Emmy Russell shouldn't of gone through. She always plays it safe. She is getting votes on the coat tails of her grandma Loretta.
You are absolutely right! Yes, Emmy is good, but she made Top 5 because of constantly tying her in with the name of her grandma. Otherwise she WOULD NOT have made Top Five!
Emmy Russell has the entire Loretta Lynn community voting for her ONLY because she is Loretta’s granddaughter. If she had never mentioned it, they would never have known &would NOT have voted for her en masse.
Youre both dead wrong
Love Emmy!!! You’re wrong!!!!
Emmy Russell is trying to make a name for herself in the music business. And she definitely deserves to go through no matter what anybody says. So back off
I was embarrassed for Katie’s wardrobe- disgusting!!! She’s beautiful and doesn’t need to dress like that.
Jack’s awesome!!! They all are so good!
I like Emmy and she’s good but she was already singing with bands on stage soooo
She will be famous anyway
Based even just on this 1 song she should win!
Well Abbie, they said you were the winner after your first audition ,congrats ,well deserved
I love Jack the best!!
I feel like the judges always say - this was your best vocals.
Emma played it safe and didn't get up like she planned... sad
Mckenna was robbed. 😮
ABI CARTER
Mckenna have a awesome voice but less confident of herself 😔😔
Emmy all the way
Katy Perry--Put some clothes on for Pete's sake. We all have those but we don't need to have them popping out. Disgusting. I thought this was a FAMILY show!
What in the hell?? Common america. The cowboy is out of his leaugue. Hes good but he is no Loretta Lyn or Aby wth robbed 😂😂😂
The cowboy is actually one of the best in my opinion but everybody has their own opinion but I agree with the person who Said if Loretta lynn granddaughter wanted known for herself she shouldnt have out it out there for everyone to know she is riding on gmas shirt tail
I think Emmy is sliding in on her family name. She's not that good. I agree with others - Julia is much better. Emmy is just....blah...., in my opinion. Totally understand people like her, but i can't help but feel she's got some favoritism playing into her choice -
I agree she doesn't engage with the audience. She not ready. You have to be the whole package
She doesn't dance every other contests dance
Mckenna
I just finished watching this and I'm seriously upset and kinda mad at the same time because I Honestly and Truthfully believe that America should've Voted McKenna🤔 to be in the Top 5 instead of Emmy Russell 🤨! I mean don't get me wrong Emmy Russell is a pretty good Singer, but in all Honesty McKenna was so much better, Ugh!!
To be Totally Honest with everyone, I honestly think 🤔 that 1 of the Only reasons that Emmy Russell has continued to be able to Keep Moving forward in this Season's American Idol is because she's the Granddaughter! But she shouldn't of gotten made it into American Idol's Top 5🤔😕😠!
Watching this from Sydney, Australia. If any of the contestants are watching this - Emma, I love your tone and voice on the piano, you didn't need to get up and dance, but what would have made the song you was if you "sexed it up" by singing it slower and more seductively. It sounded rushed at the piano. If you had of got up, it would have been ok, but at the piano, when singing songs tike that try singing seductively. Keep up the great work, you are not lost in the world and have started to shine. Well done.
Remember not what you know but who you know these days
DITTO!
Emmy ? Its a show so what do you expect?
3 guys "ALL" Country "REALLY" WHAT BS is this FFS. TOP 5 AI contestants earnings = "four females"
Emmy is picked and not Julia...Nepotism!
Emme Russell does not have a strong voice! It's a little above average but it's not exceptional. She should not be in the top five!
I just came here to say that these top 5 results SUCK!!!! No McKenna, No Good. I didn't watch tonights episode yet, but i swear to God if Abi isnt in this finale, AI can go F*** O**!!!
🤮 Absolutely cannot stand Disney night! What a lame night and songs!!! 🤮
Truthfully, none of those are any of my favorites.
Hate Katys outfit ! What was she thinking ???
It’s all about looks pisses me off
I miss the days of having an honest judge that used constructive criticism.