This school Of thought is the essence of the true worship of god, the Quran is the authority in our religion and the hadeeth is taken as historical refference as opposed to having hadeeth as the foundation for our religion. It was never meant to be like that and I’m so happy that there has been a shift in the thinking of Muslims :)
I’m happy too but what confuses me is when someone asks me if I’m a hadith rejector and Quranist, as if following the Quran is some shirk. There is still so much resistance but I don’t blame people, we have been brainwashed for so long I see it in my own family. While I don’t reject all hadith, I am not afraid of anyone thinking that I might be a Quranist. It comes from Allah how can anyone be afraid of that, the fact that we have to think twice to even mention it amongst Muslims makes me wonder why we complain so much about the west when we bully our own so much.
The hadith are important because it records the traditions and doings of the prophet of islam Muhammad saws. The man we claim to follow in this religion. These cannot be washed away as simply historical references or whatever. It is taken as a major source of religious law and moral guidance. For example the holy Quran does not exactly teach you how to pray even though prayer is obliged on the muslim. Furthermore, we believe we need the sunnah and hadith to contextualize the holy Quran. For some to say that we have been “brainwashed” is as shallow as to say that somebody is a hadeeth rejector without really knowing anything about the person. Allah says in the holy quran: “O believers! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you truly believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution.” Surah An-Nisa Verse 59 No doubt he had to convey the divine message, but it was also his duty to act upon it and to explain it to the people. His actions and explanations are a source of guidance forever. His sayings, actions, practices, and explanations are a source of light for every Muslim in every age. And the only way for us to get to know about the prophets sayings, actions, practices and explanations are through Quran AND HADITH (Sunnah). So not quran OR hadith! So be careful to what we disregard and what we take from the the religion because verily allah said in the holy quran: “And whoever defies the Messenger after guidance has become clear to them and follows a path other than that of the believers, We will let them pursue what they have chosen, then burn them in Hell-what an evil end!” Surah An-Nisa verse 115 Also, we never really rejected hadith unless they were fabricated until the 19th century we started seeing people who were. Why is that? Are we suddenly “more intelligent” or are we understanding things that 1200 years of muslims did not understand? May allah Azzawajal guide us all and make us believers in allah swt and followers of his prophet without error. Sami’na wa ata’na.
The first hadis sounds more like a pagan practice surely nothing that our Prophet peace be upon him would do. I am learning so much here thanks a lot Dr Shabir Ally and let Quran speak team
I disagree. Disregarding a Hadith entirely simply because it does not make sense to YOU from a logical standpoint is a practice which should not be done. However, I think it is entirely appropriate to temporarily ignore certain Hadith that do not make sense to YOU personally and do not have a good scholarly explanation, or seem to contradict the Quran (which the Hadith mentioned does not as Islam has many rituals in it). Perhaps at some point all of these issues will be cleared up by the Mahdi or Isa AS when he descends Insha Allah, but we don’t know when that will happen so we need to be careful not to start completely denouncing portions of our religion. The prophet SAW warned people against doing this as it is a major sin and changing of the deen.
Confusing explanation by Dr Ally, Please explain in detail why the Hadith relating to magic or evil eye are not dependable Ahadith, More and clear explanation required!
Yes he is not clear. What is he trying to substantiate? The reality of magic, Jinns and evil eye. Or the reality of superstition, magic tricks, and false or Daif hadiths? Because based of Knowledge from the Holy Quran and hadith the two topics he is addresing does exist. However, one does not cancel the other. He has a problem with logic and what is concrete thinking .
A lot of Muslims come from cultures that are full of parents that forgot to tell their kids that the magical beings from their childhood bedtime stories are not real 🤣
@Aqeel mahmood the prophet said the eye is true. By saying believing in the evil eye is shirk you’re accusing the prophet peace be upon him of shirk he too believed in it
I am a fan of Dr Shabbir. However, I have to point out that I find it is uncharacteristic of him to dismiss something without giving a good argument. In this video he did not provide a good argument for dismissing the evil eye. It is from an authentic hadith so he should give a strong argument if he is to claim the hadith 'problematic'.
As I listened to The discussion I recalled the opening lines of Al Baqarah where it speaks of those who "believe in the Unseen". I wonder if this refers to people who are aware of situations and outcomes they cannot explain rationally and immediately their anxiety goes out of control. As painful as it may be, bad things happen to good people and whatever the cause, nothing happens that is not the Will of God, who is the best planner for our affairs.
@@ableskill Yes, but I agree with the post above. Perhaps these are things that could be explained in a demystified sense if you possessed the same level of understanding as Allah regarding their physics, biology, creation, etc. But alas human beings are limited in our technical and scientific knowledge and therefore we cannot grasp these things without a more mystified explanation due to our limited understanding. We still believe in them, but we do not fully comprehend them lol
glad people are respecting this person's words.Came here after Nouman Ali Khan's controversy on this topic.Truly people do not want to let go of their traditional thinking and open their eyes and hearts to what is actual Islam
So we should reject authentic hadith because according to our own logic it seems weird and strange?? He didn't even mention any weakness in the chain of narration. He needs to stay in his field of comparative religion and not talk about things he is not qualified to speak about.
عَنْ أَبِي مُوسَى أَنَّ النَّبِيَّ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ قَالَ ثَلَاثَةٌ لَا يَدْخُلُونَ الْجَنَّةَ مُدْمِنُ خَمْرٍ ما وَقاطِع رَحِم وَمُصَدِّق بالسحر Three will not enter Paradise: one who is addicted to alcohol, one who cuts ties of kinship, and one who believes in (the power of) magic,”
No Magics, No Evil eyes, Jinns cannot posses people. You can show me 1000s of hadiths (I know there aren't), but too bad prophet didn't tell me and they are not in the Quran so I don't accept them. If you believe Prophet was sick because of Magic, then you would be questioning the revelation at that time. That would be a huge problem, you will be digging for what time he was afflicted. And Allah didn't protect his messenger as he promised. It's best bet just to leave those "hadiths" away. If Magic was real i am sure All the terrorists would be using it lol. If you believe in evil eyes, then you are denying the words of Allah. Surah 35:2 As for Jinns or Ghost possession. Its not real, it would make a good horror movie. No One Can see jinns or Control them. Its Kuffr! even to believe in Magics, Just like believing in Idols (gods created by men) as gods.
真実Yaasir He also told you about the people during the time of Sulayman (As) its definitely real and not a joke but what most people see be mere parlor tricks but Sihr is very real brother. Remember Sulayman (As) Had power and Kingdom like no one before or after him giving to him by Allah (Swt). As for Ahadith I'm not Sure where I stand on it I don't want to lean to far one way or the other rather Sirat almustaqeem. I want to follow the Message of the Rusul (Saw) as any Muslim should and his character and conduct ect. We have to find a middle ground any thing that goes against Quran or what you know about your Prophet's (Saw) behavior get rid of it Khaalas. We never put negative connotations next to any Nabi (Peace be upon them) so we have to do the work for sirat almustaqeem that's not bias by any means nor leaning one way or the other but the straight path. That's why The Fatihah is so important and in these moments we have to refer back to it. I hoped I helped brother May Allah guide us all to Sirat Almustaqeem. Ameen
Magic doesn't have to be like supernatural, someone could put something in someone's drink and make them go crazy. I have seen this happen to a love one, the person went insane for a few years , then one of people admitted what they did because he thought he was going to die so he wanted to repent. The loved one stay sick for a few years but read Quran everyday plus he was given medication from a doctor and was healed.
The idea of evil eye emerged in ancient times from the belief in extramission theory of vision, where rays emanating from the eyes were thought to cause vision and influence the human body. However, this theory was debunked by Ibn Al Haytham, a famous medieval physicist and mathematician, who established the modern intromission theory of vision in his book Kitab Al Manazir, upon which the medical sciences of Optometry & Ophthalmology are based. It's likely that the idea of evil eye is a metaphor for envy or a misattributed and inauthentic hadith, as it has no basis in the Quran and if it were significant, it would have been mentioned. Today, the current understanding is that light rays entering the eye are responsible for vision, and the concept of evil eye is considered bogus.
I have been watching imam shabir for years now. I really like the way that imam shabir approche the Hadith and the Quran. One suggestion that I have is that the imam should mention some positive ideas on the subject of Hadith. Otherwise many people who listing to him will be confused. Thank you..
Hadith 4:259 Narrated Abu Huraira: Allah's Apostle sent us in a mission (i.e. am army-unit) and said, "If you find so-and-so and so-and-so, burn both of them with fire." When we intended to depart, Allah's Apostle said, "I have ordered you to burn so-and-so and so-and-so, and it is none but Allah Who punishes with fire, so, if you find them, kill them." Hadith 4:260 Narrated Ikrima: Ali burnt some people and this news reached Ibn 'Abbas, who said, "Had I been in his place I would not have burnt them, as the Prophet said, 'Don't punish (anybody) with Allah's Punishment.' No doubt, I would have killed them, for the Prophet said, 'If somebody (a Muslim) discards his religion, kill him.' " Hadith 4:261
Salaam,in reference to Hadith,all Muslims should remember that Allah gave prophet Muhammad One Book -The Qur'an ,which he in turn delivered to mankind.All over The Qur'an Prophet Muhammad clearly states that he only followed what was delivered to him,nothing more.My question to those who believe and follow Hadith,why didn't Prophet Muhammad leave a book of Hadith?The Caliphs after Prophet Muhammad died ,they all burnt Hadiths,even Prophet Muhammad in his lifetime forbid the writing of Hadiths.The Hadiths contain a lot of contradictions and nonsense,take for example that the Prophet was bewitched,when the Qur'an clearly states in many verses that the Prophet was not mad or bewitched,I even encountered Muslims who believed the Hadith putting it ahead of the Qur'an.Hadiths have caused a lot of misunderstanding and confusion among Muslims,we all need to go to the Book Of Allah ,the Book of sure guidance wherein is no doubt and contradictions-The Qur'an.
I think we need to keep some perspective here. God does not judge anyone but Dr. Shabir Ally for what Dr Shabir Ally says.Speaking for myself, I listen to this teacher because he is a finger pointing in a particular direction and his guidance may help me. In the end, though, all guidance and protection comes from God and I am ac mountable to God for how I use what events come my way. FWIW.
Dr.Shabir you are as ignorant as I have been but I tell you sincerely that your version is totally wrong because I have gone through this. I had been a great critic of Jin Sahar and evil eye but what I experienced is very hard to believe... I request you sir to give a second thought to your belief about this issue.
Bibi Cardona Humans and the Jinn can surely harm you with the permission of Allah AWJ. That is a test for them if they oppress you and a test for you to see how you will respond; for the life of this world is a test to see who's best in deeds. But surely if Allah wishes to protect someone and keep them from harm nothing can harm that individual. Asalamu'alaikum.
Dr. Shabir i have to kindly disagree with you on this topic. Magic is no joking matter heck i was just one of those who didn't really believe until.. anyway
I had a question for some time in my mind. How do athletes perform at such a high level ? Certainly there are millions of people who envy them, want bad of them. And even in the case they do lose or perform bad, we can find the root cause of their failure, like bad diet, lack of discipline or simply just the other guy is better than them at that day. How is that an average man on the streets falls prey of evil eye of one or two or few people, but not those who are probably under the evil eyes of who knows millions or people ?🤔 Please answer this.
No athlete perform best all the time.Even those who are disciplined and best in their game like Babar Azam, etc. I watched him very closely. So there are not visible reasons for failure everything.Evil eye can take away wealth, health , peace of mind, etc. Allah has completed and perfected Islam centuries ago . Try to perfect perfected makes it imperfect.
Magic: to trick the eye or the senses and make the person believe something that isn't there. 1-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, God wouldn't have said the magicians of Pharaoh tricked the eyes of the people and intimidated them: He said, “You throw!” And when they threw, they beguiled the eyes of the people, and intimidated them, and produced a mighty magic.7.116 So will you not reason? 2-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, why did the magicians of Pharaoh use ropes and sticks instead of other objects that didn't not look like snakes? were they weak magicians or did they need the items to look like snakes to trick the eyes of the people? So will you not reason? 3-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, why didn't the magicians bind Moses and cast spells on him and made him under their control? Didn't they outnumber him? Wasn't spelling him a better demonstration of their power and knowledge than playing with sticks? Were they weak magicians? or is magic just a trick of the eye? So will you not reason? 4-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, the magicians of Pharaoh wouldn't have admitted Moses's prophethood and would have simply said instead that he is indeed a more knowledgably magician than them, after all magic is a mysterious force and they got outplayed by him, wasn't that better for them than getting butchered and crucified? Or is magic just a trick of the eye and they witnessed a real miracle? If they had even an atom of doubt that magic is a mysterious force and you can change a stick to a snake that eat others with that force, they wouldn't have accepted the horrible punishment. So will you not reason? 5-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, God wouldn't have destroyed Thamud for killing the she-camel, because bringing a she-camel out of a rock is exactly what you would expect from a dark and mighty and knowledgeable magician, so did God wrong them? or is magic just a trick of the eye and they knew this fact and yet denied the truth? So will you not reason? 6-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, the people of the prophet would have been totally justified in saying he is a magician, wasn't he bringing thousands of people into his new religion? doesn't that look exactly like a spoken spell? or is magic just a trick of the eye and they knew this fact and yet denied the truth? So will you not reason? 7-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, the radical-Jews would have been totally justified in crucifying Jesus, because walking on water and bringing the dead and breathing life into clay and telling people what they store in their homes is exactly what you would expect from a dark and mighty and knowledgeable magician. So will you not reason? 8-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, all the deniers of truth would have been justified in denying it, if indeed there were people out there controlling dark and mysterious forces, because how can one recognize a miracle from a dark and mysterious act? So will you not reason? The Truth has been made clear to you! Now you know now you know! So tell others! It's time to stop using the light of God to lead people into Darkness. It's time for the Islamic world to go back to its golden age. It's time to leave the age of magic and enter the age of reason.
its rather confusing video. what is Dr Shabir saying. We should ignore the hadith? Were the hadith sahih ,Hassan, or taif he was talking about. Dr Shabir was sitting on the fence in this video. How should one distinguish the veracity of the hadith. Simply by thinking whether it matches science then? If that is the case then the idea of parting the sea could be questioned. Jesus pbuh bringing the dead back to life should be questioned. What is the sive that you are using to determine the truth. I'm Muslim forever insha Allah,but that was a sitting on the fence video by Dr Shabir. Sorry if I offended anyone. jzk.
What you should do is come to the true form of Islam and cast away your other scriptures. The Quran is the only true scripture. Our guidance should only come from it and not other source. It's good to have a historical perspective on the life of prophet Muhammad but we shouldn't use it in our everyday lives. Cast off all of your associations and abandon shirk.
Dhynasah Çakir The Quran is the final scripture, not the only book of Allah. There are even a few verses in the Quran that confirm the veracity of the books before it and the accounts of the prophets of the previous generations.There is still plenty of knowledge a Muslim can learn from reading the Torah and Gospel, after reading and understanding the Quran.
Do you really wanna know why I don't like this video? Ok, here we go. Dr. Ally is your "source" for everything. You display a blind belief in his "scholarship". You are guilty of taqleed. Your presentation of this topic rested entirely on his "opinion", whereas what he should have done is address the authenticity of the hadith on the basis of the solidity of the chain of narrators. You take a hadith -> you evaluate its apparent linguistic meaning in comparison to the Qur'an -> if there is no obvious contradiction, you evaluate the strength of the chain of narration -> if it is solid, you study the application of the hadith in our daily practice of Islam. But Dr. Shabbir did nothing of that sort.
Matthew 6:23 But if your eyes are unhealthy, your whole body will be full of darkness. If then the light within you is darkness, how great is that darkness!
Mustafa R have you ever read the quran completely yourself? or have you blindly believed PEOPLE all your life? don’t listen to people when you have your creators words at hand.
Aisha Khaja, I think after watching this Shabir Ally I think I will no long be watching any of his lecture. To Dr Shabir you are at the boundary. Just an fyi, we can also assume just like how what you have said as purely your assumptions based on your understanding and knowledge that if Prophet Mohammed PBUH did not go through the evil eye or the magic then a muslim today would never believe in these. Lot more to say but wish you well... I ask Allah SWT to guide you and grant you with more knowledge since you need it and you are representing alot of Muslims!
Usually Dr Shabir is quite clear in explanations and I am a total fan of his. However, in this instance I found him surprisingly lacking and confusing.
Speaking from personal experience as a medical doctor and a Muslim. I have personally experienced the ill effects of magic between few hours to 24hrs on two separate occasions- my experiences could not be explained by psychiatry ailment. It did not fit any specified diagnostic pattern nor am I in need of any antipsychotics then or now. In fact I saw first hand the work of the medical doctor and some of quacks who claim to provide spiritual healing some of whom were practising magic. May Allah forgive me and them. For me personally I found healing in reciting the Quran as the scholar has already mentioned Surah Falq moreover I found comfort in understanding that our dear Prophet SAW too was affected. Believing in Islamic concept of magic does not mean that ones intelligence or the ahadeeth should be refuted. Magic is a knowledge that can harm mankind only by Allah's Will. But by experience really brought me in awe of Allah's Book and His Messenger
Moreover I think at times too much emphasis is placed on the power of magic by certain people and communities. Allah is the All Powerful - fear Him - No one can harm us unless by Allah's permission
When you see and experience the healing of Quraan then your Imaan just soars.If I could share my experience here but this is not the platform for it. once you start doing ruqya on yourself and others, Allah shows you things which you were sceptical about before. Absolutely amazing. Dr Shabir Ally knows nothing about jinn possession. I have studied this topic for years now and know for a fact that drug abuse open gateways for such addicts to be possessed by jinn. No wonder alcohol is also called Spirits. Delirium Tremens is not illusions...these people see jinns in scary forms. As Muslims who believe in the effects of jinn possession and magic and evil eye, we are so blessed not to fall for the tricks of popular magicians like Dynamo etc. Also mentalists like Darren Brown. They are seeking the assistance of Jinn and it shows in their eyes for they themselves are possessed and can therefore communicate with jinn. May Allah SWT guide Dr Ally as he thinks in terms of science and philosophy. The Quraan is above all these and the healing and mercy is in the Quraan. Some of us feel and see the presence of jinn. They are fond to manifest themselves in the form of dogs and cats. Once you understand that this is Real you will make a conscious Wudhu for Ablution is definitely a shield against Shaytaan and always try and be in wudhu. I speak from experience as I deal with possessed people daily. I don't have to ask any questions anymore as the symptoms are so apparent and these victims are pumped with anti depressants and all kinds of chemicals that cause more harm to their bodies. Please Dr Ally educate yourself and visit Raqis like Mohammed Tim Humble whose knowledge can benefit you. Through your ignorance you are advising people that their suffering is their imagination or that they must accept that they have a medical condition. I have found that people who study philosophy always seem to have doubt in the Unseen world. So disappointed in Dr Ally. Also need to add that a person who commits a crime in a possessed state will remember very little or nothing after the act. The one who remembers is responsible because he listened to the whispering of the devil. You will find that the one one who could not recall the crime is often diagnosed with some mental disorder and end up in a mental institution and not in jail. Question for you Dr Ally, Why was this "mentally ill" criminal born sane and suffered this disorder later in his /her life? Test them with Ruqya and you will have no doubt Inshaa Allah.
sir,how can we cherry pick ?as if you are doing the same thing ,you and we muslims do with bible....i think one has got 2 option ,either accepting or totaly disregard( solely my opinion)...but this causes some problems too because they are the source from which we extract our prophet's(pbuh) life and many other things...i am currently studying 'The study Quran'..it is also causing some problems...i really want you to help me ..because i m going astray.
focus on the quran it is complete and use it to strengthen your deen after move on to hadiths but always compare them to the quran the ones you follow should never contradict the quran
Allah knows best! Sir, your are very pious Muslim whom I like very much. Regarding this topic it is very clear that the evil eye, black magic etc are not logically fitting to this day science we know. But sir, there are so many things which were not digestible at each time in history. It is became common now that most of our great scholars are trying to explain each and everything logically and with the science we know today. I believe Islam is 100% logical and there would be always something in life which cannot be explained with the knowledge available at the time. If we started rejecting things based on our present logic, I think it is a very dangerous approach. What logically not fitting a 100 years ago is absolutely logical now.
But most of the story in quran is about 2 to 5000 years ago so its also difficult to interpret with our present knowledge.quran have some secret guidance which only some intelligent can crack but its all in god hands as the requirement of knowledge of religion needed god revealed it. Our scholars says nobody can understand quran except what the scholar has translated but i don't think so guidance never ends as allah will be forever. In religion young children or teenagers they learned fast and they think that the world are going fast so they are not so interested now in the religion and quran have some aayat which our ulama has translated its doesn't sound nice to them and most of the cases are from hadith 1000 of it are fabricated.thats why i think allah is revealing some very useful and secret information through his good preacher of the quran and its nice that most of them are quran lovers. So follow quran and sunnah not every hadith and not every scholar.
All due respect but the Sheikh's interpretations are solely on his personal opinion and complete logic, however we cannot even begin to claim to be believers without faith_which is not logical.
I agree with Dr Shabir regarding the authenticity of some(numerous?) hadiths, eg. the Prophet(pbuh) could be harmed by magic as the quran speaks otherwise. I believe the primary guide of muslims is the quran. Islamic scholars should sift through all hadiths to verify them. Those considered authentic and not against the teaching of the quran should only be used. Salam to everyone.
Yes he is not clear. What is he trying to substantiate? The reality of magic, Jinns and evil eye. Or the reality of superstition, magic tricks, and false or Daif hadiths? Because based of Knowledge from the Holy Quran and hadith the two topics he is addresing does exist. However, one does not cancel the other. He has a problem with logic and what is concrete thinking .
Whatever hadith is inconvenient is mentioned as weak hadith by shabbir ally, if that is the case why not junk the weak hadiths altogether, secondly if magic, evil eye are said ti exist who gives them the power, to know more on these issues viewers will be delighted to view you tube videos of learned scholars such as David Wood, Arabian prince, apostate prophet, sameer abdullah, Harris sultan, masked arab, sam shamoun ,
Dont try change the religion. its perfected surah(5:3) part of islam is believe in unseen without belive in useen your not muslim. chek surah bagara(2:3) We dont custom make islam to serve us We change ourseves to fit in islam
Excellent response to this illegocial talk. I am now going through the evil eye since now 3yrs and i don't agree to a lot of things that the sheikh talk. As long as a scholar of Islam i respect him but that does not mean i agree to whatever he says.
Jazak Allah brother! But sometimes I find your explanations leave me in a state of confusion, not able to draw a clear conclusion. May be you try to avoid sharing your explicit views to avoid any conflict. It would be tremendously helpful if you could please share your opinions explicitly because your invaluable opinions will shine a torch for many of us. I myself find difficulty believing in authenticity of such narrations. These things look against the ideology of Islam which is very pragmatic and away from anecdotes and confabulations. Islam teaches us to live our lives without any fears except being God conscious in our every deed. Please please share more videos on this topic with your explicit views. Jazakumullah kheir
If the cucumber is bitter and gives you a stomach ache, don’t eat it in the thin hope that there are some hidden benefits. The bitterness is warning that doesn’t lie. It is the same when your deepest untroubled heart struggles in accepting something. When it’s true, the heart knows. That’s why even the criminal is troubled when committing a murder - his heart knows it’s wrong. Anything that looks too complicated is corrupt. Truth is simple. Islam is about being a good person. Believing in fantastical tales is never more important than being a good gentle soul. Allah gave us consciousness so that it can guide us. When our consciousness rejects something as nonsense, that’s the truth.
I agree with you. I really admire dr ally because he is more logical than the mass of ulamas we currently have, but my issue is he is holding a lot back. I think it’s also because RUclips is full of bully scholars/muftis who will call anyone a deviant that questions a hadith. Dr ally while he is on the correct path, he is still very hesitant to fully embrace his views and make his position known because of these bullies. They have attacked him many times before and while he is too mature to engage those clowns, he still has a tendency to remain diplomatic and I think he should just get past all this and be more upfront for the sake of Islam.
@@fatimaxo4885, actually religion is a very sensitive topic. Of course we do want to be careful before forcing our opinions. I myself had always been very careful when it came about different issues in Islam, but lately after listening to scholars like dr Ally I realised that I had these thoughts in my mind for a long time but avoided to express them. Dr Ally is a breath of fresh air. We should be able to understand our Lord Almighty how He is.
@@lamson8349 No, this is a completely incorrect view of Islam. Every human being has a different conscience and sense of reality. Some people are more willing to accept things than others. For example, did you know some Muslims completely reject the existence of Jinn? Even though they are clearly mentioned as being a creation of Allah in the Quran separate from humans just like the angels are a separate creation, some people still reject them due to their “consciousness” or “sense of reality”. Operating on the same principles, some Muslim people reject the concept of playing games (video games, cards, selling cards or video games, etc) as being completely haram, while others do not. Some people are willing to call others kuffar or kill them over these issues, yet they’re relying entirely on statements from individuals in history who they’d never personally met. You can’t simply operate on your own consciousness, you have to do the best you can to adhere to Islam, but I think it’s acceptable to sideline or ignore Hadith that seem to contradict the Quran and the majority of the teachings in the Sunnah. For example, it is my personal opinion that Hadiths which demean or degrade women can be ignored, or hadiths stating that people cannot make jokes about one another that are personal even if they know each other well and are unbothered, or that anyone who leaves his faith should be killed even if they are peaceful, etc can be ignored because they tend to contradict the message and principles of Islam. This doesn’t mean the Hadith is wrong necessarily. Rather, in most cases, I believe some of these Hadith only make up a portion of what the prophet actually stated, similar to taking a verse or portion of the Quran out of context without historical knowledge, or ignoring the fact that many things in the Quran are written in a metaphorically representative fashion to paint a mental picture of a situation.
This channel is purely to broadcast Dr Ally's opinion on topics in Islam. There are other opinions out there you know. Might be interesting to invite someone else for a change.
I have high respect for the Sheikh. But unfortunately he got it wrong a few times. Interpretation of Quran and Hadith should be common amongst the scholars. One scholar can not have an isolated view based on his or interpretation. That scholar should check with others also.
Magic is real! The proof around me is just too obvious. I have had family members who have had a spell cast on them and the only people who could make these spells useless are people who have Knowledge of these things (obviously a religious and pious imam or mullah)
I agree with you. I really respect Dr Shabir ally. But i feel bad when he says magic, evil eyes... Are not real. Magic is real Wallahi. Maybe Dr Shabir, because he lives in canada, he feels embarassed to admit it.
Jiam jiao Isn't black magic just like when a human communicates with the shayateen (jinns) and they make deals, which include the Jinns harming people or performing services for them? Or does black magic have nothing to do with the Jinns in your opinion?
Mati khorasani Magic is real! Prove it! If we had magic, why would we need weapons of mass destruction or medicine? We could just cast spells on people we do not like or that we do, much cheaper. Magicians like mind readers can be easily disproved, one that purports to do it should be approached and punched. If he knew magic, he should have saw that coming or defended himself with his magic. Also, why is magic always lame. Why don't magicians walk around making heads explode or private parts fall off or go into children hospitals and cure the cancer or blindness? Instead they rather get people divorced or do some other equally lame thing. One can take over the world, feed the hungry, or heal kids, but they rather meddle in some random villager affairs in some third world, priorities.
@@cody7875 completely agree on logical grounds but it can still be proved from Quran and Sunnah that magic doesn't exist..for example some claim that the prophet was cast under the spell of magic which in itself is a blasphemous thing to say...
@@jiamjiao1187 No, I mean Dr Shabir could also simply be not convinced of it due to his scientifically oriented nature. However, I don’t think he’s entirely dismissing it, I just think he’s dismissing certain Hadith related to it, possibly because he lacks understanding of the topic. But the Quran and Hadith both clearly state that magic exists, and if you believe that magic exists and understand that evil eye has been a known form of magic throughout history even prior to Islam, it stands to reason that evil eye also exists. Some things have been widely known and carried out throughout history for centuries because they are clear and came from our forefathers closer to the time of Adam AS, and Islam confirms (some) of them.
I really admire and respect shabbir ally in many ways but i also disagree with him on many points 1. He always relies on scholarly opinions while rarely going go the actual quran or hadith.. i have noticed this in his debates (islam vs Christianity) infact. I saw him almost fairly losing out on arguements with nabeel.qureshi (christian apologist). 2. Using other scholarly opinion, shabbir refutes hadith that 'do not make sense' to him or his scholarly companions. But what about the whole science behind authenticating the hadith (last well known was sheikh albani). So if we are to take shabbir allys ideology, 90% of hadith of muslim, bukhari would be problematic 3. He cites dr israr ahmed (p.s he was from my country pakistan) as one of the authors who cites the importance of 'close door policy elimination'. While dr israr ahmeds works are incredible he too wasnt free from error. His support of wahda tul wujood ? Anyone ? He spoke in favour of it. FYi.wahdtul wujuud (the concept of one origin with many faces) is a clear contradiction to Quran, with nearly all main stream scholars fiercely rejection this ideology- again not due to those scholars opinion per se, but due to the nature of this belief I absolutely admire shabbir allys knowledge. Hes second to none. But i feel hes far off on certain topics due to his approach to scholarly methods. If i compare him to dr zakir nayak, ahmed deedat, theres a stark comparison between him and them.. while they gain their expertise in the knowledge of the scriptures and their comparison/contrasts/ contradictions, dr shabbir ally mostly utilises points raised by scholars and their interpretation of scripture (just like his debates with christians)
Yes he is not clear. What is he trying to substantiate? The reality of magic, Jinns and evil eye. Or the reality of superstition, magic tricks, and false or Daif hadiths? Because based of Knowledge from the Holy Quran and hadith the two topics he is addresing does exist. However, one does not cancel the other. He has a problem with logic and what is concrete thinking .
@@TheViperDawg I agree with u on hadith ..bt one thing I hv seen...many people are just quoting this is from Sahih bukhari ..without knowing the context...scholars identical Sahih bukhari as authentic..I agree.but we hv to admit that they r not infallible...not all hadith in Sahih bukhari is necessarily be true...one is the age of Aisha (RA)...which is questionable ..if the age of Aisha(RA) was 6 at the tym of marriage,then many of Islamic history has to be changed to fit her age.. Christian,jews scholar also give their life for studying the scriptures but r they correct ?....one book which is free of errors is the divine revelation of Allah-Quran...still amo ng hadith books,i trust Sahih bukhari but I don't consider it infallible....so what we do now....first and foremost ..is the 5 pillars of Islam....how do we perform. .use hadith(which the world know as authentic..if it is not,still u will not be held accountable bcoz Allah is just..He is the most merciful)..then we shall try to follow the Quran as much as possible....our arrogance,pride,anger should be zero....which are mentioned in the Quran ....and then live for the well being of humanity.... don't harm a human bcoz Allah is forgiving but not human...U can be held accountable for that on the day of judgement..feed the hungers,help the poors...it's not wise to debate and prove ur perception is the correct.....I hv seen many Muslims involve in debate and try to prove their percepyion is correct....One more thing..we don't even know 1 percent of Allah....His mercy has no limit....Remember Allah always and work good besides performing the mandatory like salat,fast,charity,hajj(if possible)..and Allah knows best
@@sportsflashback5335 whole ijma of muslim umma is on the 2 saheeh, infact Allah states that muslims will unify over whats right and divide on what is not. Infact there is no way to follow qurans directives without direction from sunnah How many raka in salah? How many sajda in sala ? We cannot deny that ahadith are not important
@@TheViperDawg please read my comments carefully...what I hv said...u must rely on hadith which the world consider authentic...from that u will know how many rakat ,how many sajdah....even if the hadiths r not authentic(u will not held accountable for that as Allah instructs us in the glorious Quran to use our reason ...to search for the truth...and beyond that u hv to follow Quran as much as possible..do good for the world..and not involve in unnecessary debate to prove u r correct ...we r accountable to Allah only..He will judge us...As per as my knowledge and facts,I trust Sahih bukhari the most among hadith books but I don't blv it is 100% authentic as no book on the face of the earth can be so correct except the glorious Quran...human error exists everywhere..
@@sportsflashback5335 yes brother i read your comments carefuly and replied. See the problem with this mentality ( i.e. its not 100% authentic or error free) leads to further problems. Problems such as you will see in the comments section. People are going to an extent to say they dont need hadith at all to be a muslim. My interpretation of this is close the door to such speculations. No one is talking about comparing it to quran thats no way a comparison. But at the same time we should not be (or perhaps people like shabir ally) cant come 1500 years later and claim that ahadith are problematic and that we should "reassess" the logic behind hadith. I agree with your comments abt accountability but my issue is with liberals like shabir ally, and many others who say that even proven saheeh hadith are wrong or problematic 🤣🤣 Tell you what ? Its like saying "salah has 3 sajdas not 2" and that the hadith with 2 sajdas is problematic. That was the main point in my issue that i mentioned. And Allah knows best..
By refering to soneof ther points before. I maynot be 100% correct about his views But.. His thought processes seemed to be based on the assumption of philosophical naturalism. He seems to be in partial-disagreement with spiritual realm (as he hisagrees with evil-eye), and only limited the cause effect criteria to emiprical one. While in Islam its clear that we have a spiritual reality which cannot be empirically observed, and hard to make sense with inductive methods. We have deduction based reasoning - which helps us to acquire ilm-ul-yaqeen, the knowledge certainty. (unlike the knowledge of science which is uncertain and susceptible to change) That's why we go back to Quran and Sunnah, without any bias towards philosophical assumptions of liberal, modernists and empiricist. And with the strong rules of inference we believe it can genuinely happen, behind our perception. Regardless of what empiricist and reductionist says about reality. We clearly know - science has a problem of induction, and so the empiricism has. Thus we cannot use this paradigms to judge and scrutinize the traditional narrations. The traditional scholars had a strong mechanism to uphold Islamic epistemology, so no point of orientalist-lenses to revisit those narrations. Otherwise one would hit the axe on their own feet. So please, better consider revisiting the thought peocess, asumptions or lenses of redutionist, empiricist and cursed-orientalists (as this is what their world-view is meant for, already to change), we cant use a world-view which uncertain within itself to counter the knowledge of certainty. Thank You.
Why is this so called doctor ignoring the fact that the two quls, al-falaq and al-nas were sent down to the prophet because of the magic that was done to him, may the peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and that magic is a pact made between a magician and a shaytaan and that none of them can harm you except with Allah's permission. Wallahi no saheeh hadith narrated from the prophet are problematic and may Allah guide you from the clear error that you are upon. This is definitely problematic that you think that you find the hadith about the sahaaba who was inflicted by evil eye to be untrue. May Allah save us from walking upon the wrong path and believing it to be true. For surely then are we truly lost like the nasaaris and yahuud who have earned the wrath of Allah.
I love Dr. Shabir but he has no knowledge of the jinn, sihr, and evil eye. I don’t blame him since I was just like him. Mashallah he hasn’t ever experienced that and I hope he never does. But I understand his approach to the Hadiths. For me it’s the other way around. I found the HDithhs that deal with magic to be more credible than the ones that deal with lies such as alcohol is haram, blasphemy against God’s prophet (Bukhari 323 for example) and so on. The Hadiths are BS (45:6-7) but the ones about magic are somewhat true. I have personal examples of magic, jinn possession, and evil eye. All are actually interlinked.
Evil eyes are real because few persons I knew if the said the plant looks good then the plant rots also one lady looked at me and admired my looks when I was baby I got diarrhoea of blood.
I don’t think the message is deciding which Hadiths to label right or wrong, the message is to fact check whatever you’re told. You should always check on authenticity and veracity of any Hadith, this should be second nature. The Quran doesn’t have a need for this since it is the actual holy scripture.
السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته I think Harut and marut are not angels because that is contradicting with that angels never do evil things , so i asked a relative arabic scholar about this ayah to make sure then we've found two things that the word ما is related to ما both of soliman and two angels that الله tells us they did not do it (soliman and the two messengers angels) , the second thing ببابل هاروت و ماروت thats called in arabic تقديم و تاخير means it is a new story here الله did not say هاروت و ماروت ببابل to link the two angels to this phrase in the end he knows best الله اعلى و اعلم hope the scholar shabbir make researches about it and tell me what he will find والسلام عليكم .
Ahmed Galal They did not teach it except that they told them this is a test from your Lord and not to learn from this . It was to clarify the difference between Sihr and a miracle giving to a Nabi (Peace be upon them). They didn't disobey Allah (Swt) nor was it malice or considered evil. Rather followed the command to test and show the people what Sihr really is all about and also freeing Sulayman (As) from the accusations of disbelief and being a magician due to the fact Allah (Swt) had giving him many Miracles and a Kingdom Like never before or after. I hope that helps brother May Allah guide us all to the sirat almustaqeem. Ameen
Muhammad Abdullah Ar Rahman Amin , but my opinion is because of arabic reading , read the whole ayah و لكن الشياطين كفرو يعلمون الناس السحر that means that the devils from human and jinn who were and are teaching magic (decieving) and as i mentioned in the comment above the word ما before the two angels is the same word ما before prophet sulaiman wich means they did not do that in arabic we say it عطف our lord mentioned also that no one will see the angels except when his death , he said also when he sent angels to help the prophet and the believers he said you do not see them , and in the end hope our lord guide us and forgive us if we were mistaken , peace
Ahmed Galal Ameen. That's where the middle ground comes in because we know Allah doesn't contradict himself so what is contradictory to Allah we must investigate. When it says they did not do it we have to know they mean magic (disbelieve). Automatically to practice Sihr is definitely Disbelief in Allah the Angels can't do things out of there on will especially disobey they clarify they didn't do it Meaning Sulayman (As) and Harut & Marut they are not responsible for the practice of sihr the people where initially doing this with the help of the shaytans. He stop them from doing this and the minute he took away there books it became a issue that he is the Magician because he has all these miracles how we know your not doing Magic. Only once all that has taken place did Allah step in to set the record straight for the people of Sulayman (As) And then sent Harut and Marut. Allah knows best
Muhammad Abdullah Ar Rahman You know brother harut and marut are not angels in my opinion because in arabic there is something called تقديم و تاخير i don't know the english name of it , anyway it is a grammer means that it is a new story seprated from the story before it like our lord said ببالبل هاروت و ماروت means at babel harut and marut and that is the تقديم و تاخير if it is not تقديم و تاخير it will be harut and marut at babel هاروت و ماروت ببابل so it is a new story here seprated from denying the accusation of sulaiman and the two angels who were reveal for him the words of our lord from disblieve because they accused them of disblieve , so allah begins a new story about harut and marut which they may be human and as you,ve said allah knows best الله اعلم
As much as I admire Dr Shabir for his knowledge and contributions, I have to say that I disagree with this video. The evil eye is real and so is black magic.
There were no clear answer at all. The only thing I understood from this clip is "It depends on how you translate". For Shabir we should faver new reverts and make them easy to understad and accept. That notion is not necessorily prijecting the reality. Havig said so, Dr Shabir is very intellegent and thus can easily sell his Idea. Thak you Dr.
If you denying this hadith it is denying the teaching of the Prophet SAW. therefore I think sheikh shabir has to check his new advisors because shaytaan lives within the people,stay firm and don't destroy what you have been building for years.
First of all the Heading is wrong "Problematic" Dr. Shabbir have to confirm that the Hadith which he narrated is Sahee, Hasan etc. And he simply says this hadith doesn't fit to our understanding so We have neglect them. Well Many thing and Hadiths doesn't come under our understanding Ex : Dajjal, Gog Magog, or born again on Judgement day. By saying it doesn't match to our today's world or today's understanding than you are becoming "Munkeer E Hadith" I remember Sir Syed Ahmed Khan the great personality and founding father of Aligarh University India also had same view in his book.
In the battle of Uhud didn’t the Prophet pbuh get hurt and his tooth got knocked out too ? I believe no doubt overall god protects his prophets but can there be a little damage (hardship) yes! It’s God’s book and he does protect it from error like it says in the Quran, but saying magic didn’t effect the prophet at all idk , I believe things happened to the prophet so we can learn from them and the last surahs came for that reason !!
Astaghfirulah. May Allah Subhanahuwata’ala guides all of us to the straight path and protect us from misinterpretating his book. May Allah Subhanahuwata’ala eradicates doubts in our minds about His book. And may Allah Subhanahuwata’ala protect us from worshiping our own intellect as god. With all due respect. You are wrong here Dr. Please take this video down because you are putting doubts into Muslims minds. Visit Morocco and spend a day or two with a roque and you will realize very quickly that black magic and evil eye is in fact a reality. To protect yourself from going down the wrong path and to protect Muslim Umah who respect you from leaving Islam due to the doubts you cause them to have, please take this video down ASAP. I love you for the sake of Allah and don’t want you to mislead Muslim ummah unintentionally. I was also a skeptic in black magic and evil eye until spent a year and a half in Morocco and had a chance to witness the effect of magic and evil eye in person. Magic and evil eye is as real as the fire is hot and the ice is cold. May Allah Subhanahuwata’ala guides us all. Assalamualiakum.
Yes... Brother.... I feel they are just taking Quraan only to understand things.. Then i believe they shud not eat Fishes 🐠 coz in the Holy Quraan it is written things which are dead by itself (without being halaal) shud not be eaten.. And Fishes are not halaal then....
Yes he is not clear. What is he trying to substantiate? The reality of magic, Jinns and evil eye. Or the reality of superstition, magic tricks, and false or Daif hadiths? Because based of Knowledge from the Holy Quran and hadith the two topics he is addresing does exist. However, one does not cancel the other. He has a problem with logic and what is concrete thinking .
Rizwan Pallickal Moidu There are no contradictions in the book of Allah, the Quran. If we are unable to comprehend a verse in the Quran, it doesn’t mean that what it says is not true. It just means the meaning of the verse is not meant to be clear or it was due to our lack of knowledge in the subject. As Allah says In Surah Al Imron verse number 7, “It is He who has sent down to you, [O Muhammad], the Book; in it are verses [that are] precise - they are the foundation of the Book - and others unspecific. As for those in whose hearts is deviation [from truth], they will follow that of it which is unspecific, seeking discord and seeking an interpretation [suitable to them]. And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allah . But those firm in knowledge say, "We believe in it. All [of it] is from our Lord." And no one will be reminded except those of understanding.” Islam means total submission to the will of God and total obedience to His law. If we want to claim that we are a true Muslim, what do we do? We submit and we obey Allah’s commands totally. With due all respect to Dr. Ally, his knowledge in this subject is lacking and he shouldn’t be doing what he is doing in this video. Please note brother, I’m not here trying to tarnish Dr. Ally reputation anyway. I believe he is sincere in trying to educate the ummah. But as human, we are prone to make mistakes. May Allah forgives, guide us to the right path and keep our hearts firm on the truth.
I dont think the angels need to telll the people how to cause rift between husband and wife, since this is with out anyone teaching is within us human nature, something has to far more then simply teaching them this. That has to be magic. Magic is not fake, people do al sort of black magic.
All the videos of Dr. shabir have one thing in common... he encourages you to doubt Ahadees i.e. sayings of the Prophet SAW. He conveniently choose to draw his own conclusions on things just as the others he aims to correct. I do not agree with him on a lot of things. Wallah Ualam.
Those who put Quran( words of ALLAH) as primary source, will definitely find many contradiction in hadeeth( words of human saying that prophet Muhammad said this and that).
@@KenAiden It is in the Quran that Allah says that the Prophet SAW does and says nothing aside from the command of Allah himself. Quran and Ahadees and very much related.
Mutahir rasul you are right but not just hadith but also tha quran tha probalem is that there things that he can't deny there many muslims who get sick because of magic and evil eye this guy is keep twisting tha Quran and hadith
Yes he is not clear. What is he trying to substantiate? The reality of magic, Jinns and evil eye. Or the reality of superstition, magic tricks, and false or Daif hadiths? Because based of Knowledge from the Holy Quran and hadith the two topics he is addresing does exist. However, one does not cancel the other. He has a problem with logic and what is concrete thinking .
By approaching Islam through western framework, u r making "Islam" comfortable even for Bill Gates and George Bush! But let me clear that Islam is neither escapism nor dependent on your problematic interpretation. Islam has its own value system and some part of it even though appear problematic or embarassing to you, can't be compromised for the sake of western values.
Sorry - Islam has to make sense or it won’t be fit for purpose. Human consciousness expands with every generation. And you can’t expect Muslims living in modern Canada or USA to live according to the lifestyle and the understanding of a 7th Century desert Arab. For all generations, the core of Islam is that you should be a good person. You don’t need to believe in fantastical tales to do that. Love yourself and love others and do the right thing.
@@lamson8349 That means it is okay for us to modify the content of Quran and hadith than to modify our own selves!! I recall the hadith which states that to stand firm on the path of Islam would be as tough as to hold a burning coal in one's palm.
Than you never have seen or experienced someone who has done black magic on people, or people who had black magic and who were cured by the quran and ruqyah.. so what you are saying is not true.. im sorry
bigelowtech only God can judge what is the heart since He is the only One that knows the intentions of men. But once a man has spoken, he is at the mercy of his fellow brothers and sisters to support him if what he says is true and reprimand him if what he says is false. That’s why Allah says Surah Al Imron verse 110: to enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong...
I totally agree with his perspective which is absolutely correct. I can't believe that people believe one can harm anyone by sighting itself as though allah does. Isn't a shirk that believing one has one of the Allah's power. In quran allah says nothing is like him and anything happens when he orders happen..
In my old age, Satan has been my most faithful and useful Companion, not those calling themselves Muslims - those damn and damned creatures - not all of them, obviously! BAFS
He dont believe in magic. Why is it when people are possessed by jinn. The jinn speaks through that person and says that i was sent by a magician to possess this person. So he's talking rubbish. Just because you aint been inflicted with magic or evil deosnt mean it dont exist.
I know this video is old but I wanted to leave a comment and say I did not benefit and that your channel shouldn’t produce videos like this that are ambiguous and not clear. I don’t even feel like the host understood what this guest was saying. On matters that pertain to major parts of our faith you should be CLEAR not trying to satisfy this person and that person. If it is in a sahib Hadith I accept it. If it’s in Quran I accept it. Everyone knows Hadith goes into more detail that Quran. I feel like this served only to put doubts in the minds of Muslims. I would consider clarifying this content or taking it down. I’m being sincere in my advice. Salaam!
Brother I see you in every video on "let the Quran speak" and you don't sound happy 😊. Any ideas or issues feel free to discuss us. Assalaamu Alaikum Warahmatu LLahi Wabarakaatuh. Ramadan Karim 2019.
Fremaux : did u just say “insult to your intelligent” 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤪. That someone has revealed that your imaginary jinn (unseen) friend doesn’t exist 🤣. That’s what happens when you distance yourself from the Quran . (Basically you lost the plot) Surah ibrahim v22: shaytan has no Authority or control over us and can only give WasWassa (whisper) Surah An Nas: Allah confirms, shaytan can only give WasWassa (whisper). It’s the free will which Allah has given to you to act good or evil based on what u hear 👂.
@@ableskill You are another blind and damn fanatical preacher of what you do not know and do not understand! Get baptized, maybe then you will be given a PROPER name! Sadik FAST STRENGTH, my foot! BAFS
@@BAFREMAUXSOORMALLY 🤣🤣🤣🤪. Mate, atleast I know how to read, unlike you let alone understanding anything, you can’t even read 🤣! That’s why you blind follow and practice the like of your forefathers did. But it doesn’t bother me, coz people like u will die off along with your superstitious beliefs.😁 Allah clearly states this Quran been revealed plainly easy to read and understand.....😂 Go and ask your imaginary jinn (unseen) friend , how to read.. and why not even blame your jinn friend for all your problems, rather being a man and start taking responsibility for your own actions. Pathetic!🤯
This school
Of thought is the essence of the true worship of god, the Quran is the authority in our religion and the hadeeth is taken as historical refference as opposed to having hadeeth as the foundation for our religion. It was never meant to be like that and I’m so happy that there has been a shift in the thinking of Muslims :)
Yes me too. It's like Islam is having it's own "protestant" revolution.
I’m happy too but what confuses me is when someone asks me if I’m a hadith rejector and Quranist, as if following the Quran is some shirk. There is still so much resistance but I don’t blame people, we have been brainwashed for so long I see it in my own family. While I don’t reject all hadith, I am not afraid of anyone thinking that I might be a Quranist. It comes from Allah how can anyone be afraid of that, the fact that we have to think twice to even mention it amongst Muslims makes me wonder why we complain so much about the west when we bully our own so much.
The hadith are important because it records the traditions and doings of the prophet of islam Muhammad saws. The man we claim to follow in this religion. These cannot be washed away as simply historical references or whatever. It is taken as a major source of religious law and moral guidance. For example the holy Quran does not exactly teach you how to pray even though prayer is obliged on the muslim. Furthermore, we believe we need the sunnah and hadith to contextualize the holy Quran.
For some to say that we have been “brainwashed” is as shallow as to say that somebody is a hadeeth rejector without really knowing anything about the person.
Allah says in the holy quran:
“O believers! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you truly believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution.”
Surah An-Nisa Verse 59
No doubt he had to convey the divine message, but it was also his duty to act upon it and to explain it to the people. His actions and explanations are a source of guidance forever. His sayings, actions, practices, and explanations are a source of light for every Muslim in every age. And the only way for us to get to know about the prophets sayings, actions, practices and explanations are through Quran AND HADITH (Sunnah). So not quran OR hadith!
So be careful to what we disregard and what we take from the the religion because verily allah said in the holy quran:
“And whoever defies the Messenger after guidance has become clear to them and follows a path other than that of the believers, We will let them pursue what they have chosen, then burn them in Hell-what an evil end!”
Surah An-Nisa verse 115
Also, we never really rejected hadith unless they were fabricated until the 19th century we started seeing people who were. Why is that? Are we suddenly “more intelligent” or are we understanding things that 1200 years of muslims did not understand?
May allah Azzawajal guide us all and make us believers in allah swt and followers of his prophet without error. Sami’na wa ata’na.
@@bilaldenbosch7162 true!
✅
The first hadis sounds more like a pagan practice surely nothing that our Prophet peace be upon him would do.
I am learning so much here thanks a lot Dr Shabir Ally and let Quran speak team
ikr!! sounded so much like ,for instance, the concept of Baptism and surely nothing our Prophet(PBUH) would do.
maa theripper absolutely
I disagree. Disregarding a Hadith entirely simply because it does not make sense to YOU from a logical standpoint is a practice which should not be done. However, I think it is entirely appropriate to temporarily ignore certain Hadith that do not make sense to YOU personally and do not have a good scholarly explanation, or seem to contradict the Quran (which the Hadith mentioned does not as Islam has many rituals in it). Perhaps at some point all of these issues will be cleared up by the Mahdi or Isa AS when he descends Insha Allah, but we don’t know when that will happen so we need to be careful not to start completely denouncing portions of our religion. The prophet SAW warned people against doing this as it is a major sin and changing of the deen.
Totally agree with you, wish there were more people who could see things clearly.
My relative who is Muslim does agree with his black magic not being real comment.
After reading the comment section I can see what is wrong with the Muslims
What happened?
Confusing explanation by Dr Ally,
Please explain in detail why the Hadith relating to magic or evil eye are not dependable Ahadith,
More and clear explanation required!
He avoided addressing the authenticity of the hadith, mainly because he has no training on the subject.
Yes he is not clear. What is he trying to substantiate? The reality of magic, Jinns and evil eye. Or the reality of superstition, magic tricks, and false or Daif hadiths? Because based of Knowledge from the Holy Quran and hadith the two topics he is addresing does exist. However, one does not cancel the other. He has a problem with logic and what is concrete thinking .
🤣🤣🤣 too many of you guys are upset to find out your imaginary jinn (unseen) friend doesn’t exist. 🤪
A lot of Muslims come from cultures that are full of parents that forgot to tell their kids that the magical beings from their childhood bedtime stories are not real 🤣
@Aqeel mahmood the prophet said the eye is true. By saying believing in the evil eye is shirk you’re accusing the prophet peace be upon him of shirk he too believed in it
I am a fan of Dr Shabbir. However, I have to point out that I find it is uncharacteristic of him to dismiss something without giving a good argument. In this video he did not provide a good argument for dismissing the evil eye. It is from an authentic hadith so he should give a strong argument if he is to claim the hadith 'problematic'.
Not just Dr. Shabir but most scholars of Islam just ignore the subject and brush it under the carpet. They have never experienced it.
One the best scholars in current age. Please continue to address these issues. Thank you ❤
I didn't know that Dr. Ally is a muhadith who judges the authenticity of ahadeeth.
He believes in Ahadith, but not in all, which is called Sahih, he thinks logically, many are corrupted, but not all.
Salam
Tunahan Cantürk Salaam brother. Could you provide some details on which Hadiths can be considered authentic?
As I listened to The discussion I recalled the opening lines of Al Baqarah where it speaks of those who "believe in the Unseen". I wonder if this refers to people who are aware of situations and outcomes they cannot explain rationally and immediately their anxiety goes out of control. As painful as it may be, bad things happen to good people and whatever the cause, nothing happens that is not the Will of God, who is the best planner for our affairs.
“Those who Believe in the unseen”.
This refers to life after death, heaven, hell, jinn, angels, Allah... and we believe all these things exist.
@@ableskill Yes, but I agree with the post above. Perhaps these are things that could be explained in a demystified sense if you possessed the same level of understanding as Allah regarding their physics, biology, creation, etc. But alas human beings are limited in our technical and scientific knowledge and therefore we cannot grasp these things without a more mystified explanation due to our limited understanding. We still believe in them, but we do not fully comprehend them lol
Unseen means things our eyes cannot detect - that is clear.
his opinion makes an opposing view to that
We loved it actually
Thank you so much for your hard work !!!
Loves from Afghanistan to all my brothers and sisters around the workd❤❤❤
6:00 actually the verse says that the pharaoh's magicians (tricked the peoples' eyes) .. so you're right Shabir.
uP
glad people are respecting this person's words.Came here after Nouman Ali Khan's controversy on this topic.Truly people do not want to let go of their traditional thinking and open their eyes and hearts to what is actual Islam
He is not a scholar of Hadith, Tafseer, and/or Fiqh. He therefore uses his own rationlism and presents as Islam.
So we should reject authentic hadith because according to our own logic it seems weird and strange?? He didn't even mention any weakness in the chain of narration. He needs to stay in his field of comparative religion and not talk about things he is not qualified to speak about.
Slow down my friend,
Cast off your pride and anger and open your heart. Humility and openness are the only paths to God. Not rigidity.
yes, hadith which were written after 300 years of the death of prophet should be examined if they contradict quran
@@suhelmallick thank you !! We all should have the same sense of
Sahih does not necessarily equal truth
Thanks. I heard in my language same details. Jazakallah khair Dr Sabir Ally and team
What is your language
Dr's stand is correct on false hadiths... Jazakallahu khairan.
عَنْ أَبِي مُوسَى أَنَّ النَّبِيَّ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ قَالَ ثَلَاثَةٌ لَا يَدْخُلُونَ الْجَنَّةَ مُدْمِنُ خَمْرٍ ما وَقاطِع رَحِم وَمُصَدِّق بالسحر
Three will not enter Paradise: one who is addicted to alcohol, one who cuts ties of kinship, and one who believes in (the power of) magic,”
No Magics, No Evil eyes, Jinns cannot posses people.
You can show me 1000s of hadiths (I know there aren't), but too bad prophet didn't tell me and they are not in the Quran so I don't accept them.
If you believe Prophet was sick because of Magic, then you would be questioning the revelation at that time. That would be a huge problem, you will be digging for what time he was afflicted. And Allah didn't protect his messenger as he promised. It's best bet just to leave those "hadiths" away.
If Magic was real i am sure All the terrorists would be using it lol.
If you believe in evil eyes, then you are denying the words of Allah. Surah 35:2
As for Jinns or Ghost possession. Its not real, it would make a good horror movie.
No One Can see jinns or Control them.
Its Kuffr! even to believe in Magics, Just like believing in Idols (gods created by men) as gods.
真実Yaasir He also told you about the people during the time of Sulayman (As) its definitely real and not a joke but what most people see be mere parlor tricks but Sihr is very real brother. Remember Sulayman (As) Had power and Kingdom like no one before or after him giving to him by Allah (Swt). As for Ahadith I'm not Sure where I stand on it I don't want to lean to far one way or the other rather Sirat almustaqeem. I want to follow the Message of the Rusul (Saw) as any Muslim should and his character and conduct ect. We have to find a middle ground any thing that goes against Quran or what you know about your Prophet's (Saw) behavior get rid of it Khaalas. We never put negative connotations next to any Nabi (Peace be upon them) so we have to do the work for sirat almustaqeem that's not bias by any means nor leaning one way or the other but the straight path. That's why The Fatihah is so important and in these moments we have to refer back to it. I hoped I helped brother May Allah guide us all to Sirat Almustaqeem.
Ameen
真実Yaasir i had a jinn in me :D
Magic doesn't have to be like supernatural, someone could put something in someone's drink and make them go crazy. I have seen this happen to a love one, the person went insane for a few years , then one of people admitted what they did because he thought he was going to die so he wanted to repent. The loved one stay sick for a few years but read Quran everyday plus he was given medication from a doctor and was healed.
Thnx.4.sharing.
That's not magic then. That's called poisoning.
The idea of evil eye emerged in ancient times from the belief in extramission theory of vision, where rays emanating from the eyes were thought to cause vision and influence the human body. However, this theory was debunked by Ibn Al Haytham, a famous medieval physicist and mathematician, who established the modern intromission theory of vision in his book Kitab Al Manazir, upon which the medical sciences of Optometry & Ophthalmology are based. It's likely that the idea of evil eye is a metaphor for envy or a misattributed and inauthentic hadith, as it has no basis in the Quran and if it were significant, it would have been mentioned. Today, the current understanding is that light rays entering the eye are responsible for vision, and the concept of evil eye is considered bogus.
Dr Shabir! Make a video on the trials in the grave pls, I want to know more about that
I have been watching imam shabir for years now. I really like the way that imam shabir approche the Hadith and the Quran. One suggestion that I have is that the imam should mention some positive ideas on the subject of Hadith. Otherwise many people who listing to him will be confused. Thank you..
Alkhassimou Doll,hadiths are not source of deen and as it is not in chronicled order one can't read as a historical information.
Hadith 4:259
Narrated Abu Huraira:
Allah's Apostle sent us in a mission (i.e. am army-unit) and said, "If you find so-and-so and so-and-so, burn both of them with fire." When we intended to depart, Allah's Apostle said, "I have ordered you to burn so-and-so and so-and-so, and it is none but Allah Who punishes with fire, so, if you find them, kill them."
Hadith 4:260
Narrated Ikrima:
Ali burnt some people and this news reached Ibn 'Abbas, who said, "Had I been in his place I would not have burnt them, as the Prophet said, 'Don't punish (anybody) with Allah's Punishment.' No doubt, I would have killed them, for the Prophet said, 'If somebody (a Muslim) discards his religion, kill him.' "
Hadith 4:261
Mashallah you are smart, great idea
@@abdulrashidkhan2196 poor person how did you get the Deen falling down from sky to your house, without hadith there's NO DEEN , GOT IT
Salaam,in reference to Hadith,all Muslims should remember that Allah gave prophet Muhammad One Book -The Qur'an ,which he in turn delivered to mankind.All over The Qur'an Prophet Muhammad clearly states that he only followed what was delivered to him,nothing more.My question to those who believe and follow Hadith,why didn't Prophet Muhammad leave a book of Hadith?The Caliphs after Prophet Muhammad died ,they all burnt Hadiths,even Prophet Muhammad in his lifetime forbid the writing of Hadiths.The Hadiths contain a lot of contradictions and nonsense,take for example that the Prophet was bewitched,when the Qur'an clearly states in many verses that the Prophet was not mad or bewitched,I even encountered Muslims who believed the Hadith putting it ahead of the Qur'an.Hadiths have caused a lot of misunderstanding and confusion among Muslims,we all need to go to the Book Of Allah ,the Book of sure guidance wherein is no doubt and contradictions-The Qur'an.
I think we need to keep some perspective here. God does not judge anyone but Dr. Shabir Ally for what Dr Shabir Ally says.Speaking for myself, I listen to this teacher because he is a finger pointing in a particular direction and his guidance may help me. In the end, though, all guidance and protection comes from God and I am ac mountable to God for how I use what events come my way. FWIW.
Just believe Allah is protecting you from all eliv
Dr.Shabir you are as ignorant as I have been but I tell you sincerely that your version is totally wrong because I have gone through this. I had been a great critic of Jin Sahar and evil eye but what I experienced is very hard to believe... I request you sir to give a second thought to your belief about this issue.
Tell me about your story
really difficult subject to clarify. my opinion only Allah swt has the power to do good or bad on you.
Bibi Cardona Humans and the Jinn can surely harm you with the permission of Allah AWJ. That is a test for them if they oppress you and a test for you to see how you will respond; for the life of this world is a test to see who's best in deeds. But surely if Allah wishes to protect someone and keep them from harm nothing can harm that individual. Asalamu'alaikum.
@@sheikhsensei9660 how in the hell can a jinn harm u when Allah clearly says they can only whisper. Read ur Qur'an more and quit being a follower.
Dr. Shabir i have to kindly disagree with you on this topic. Magic is no joking matter heck i was just one of those who didn't really believe until.. anyway
Safi Hameed magic is true
not beleive in magic is like not beleiving that the sea is salty.
Jinah ibrahim that was exactly my point.
Once you yourself go through the effect of the evil eyes you will Inshah Allah believe
I had a question for some time in my mind. How do athletes perform at such a high level ? Certainly there are millions of people who envy them, want bad of them. And even in the case they do lose or perform bad, we can find the root cause of their failure, like bad diet, lack of discipline or simply just the other guy is better than them at that day. How is that an average man on the streets falls prey of evil eye of one or two or few people, but not those who are probably under the evil eyes of who knows millions or people ?🤔
Please answer this.
No athlete perform best all the time.Even those who are disciplined and best in their game like Babar Azam, etc. I watched him very closely. So there are not visible reasons for failure everything.Evil eye can take away wealth, health , peace of mind, etc.
Allah has completed and perfected Islam centuries ago . Try to perfect perfected makes it imperfect.
I wish that this amazing videos would be translated to Arabic
Inshallah
Hello, I still didn't understand.. if magic real or not?
Magic: to trick the eye or the senses and make the person believe something that isn't there.
1-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, God wouldn't have said the magicians of Pharaoh tricked the eyes of the people and intimidated them:
He said, “You throw!” And when they threw, they beguiled the eyes of the people, and intimidated them, and produced a mighty magic.7.116
So will you not reason?
2-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, why did the magicians of Pharaoh use ropes and sticks instead of other objects that didn't not look like snakes? were they weak magicians or did they need the items to look like snakes to trick the eyes of the people?
So will you not reason?
3-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, why didn't the magicians bind Moses and cast spells on him and made him under their control? Didn't they outnumber him? Wasn't spelling him a better demonstration of their power and knowledge than playing with sticks? Were they weak magicians? or is magic just a trick of the eye?
So will you not reason?
4-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, the magicians of Pharaoh wouldn't have admitted Moses's prophethood and would have simply said instead that he is indeed a more knowledgably magician than them, after all magic is a mysterious force and they got outplayed by him, wasn't that better for them than getting butchered and crucified? Or is magic just a trick of the eye and they witnessed a real miracle? If they had even an atom of doubt that magic is a mysterious force and you can change a stick to a snake that eat others with that force, they wouldn't have accepted the horrible punishment.
So will you not reason?
5-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, God wouldn't have destroyed Thamud for killing the she-camel, because bringing a she-camel out of a rock is exactly what you would expect from a dark and mighty and knowledgeable magician, so did God wrong them? or is magic just a trick of the eye and they knew this fact and yet denied the truth?
So will you not reason?
6-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, the people of the prophet would have been totally justified in saying he is a magician, wasn't he bringing thousands of people into his new religion? doesn't that look exactly like a spoken spell? or is magic just a trick of the eye and they knew this fact and yet denied the truth?
So will you not reason?
7-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, the radical-Jews would have been totally justified in crucifying Jesus, because walking on water and bringing the dead and breathing life into clay and telling people what they store in their homes is exactly what you would expect from a dark and mighty and knowledgeable magician.
So will you not reason?
8-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, all the deniers of truth would have been justified in denying it, if indeed there were people out there controlling dark and mysterious forces, because how can one recognize a miracle from a dark and mysterious act?
So will you not reason?
The Truth has been made clear to you!
Now you know now you know!
So tell others!
It's time to stop using the light of God to lead people into Darkness.
It's time for the Islamic world to go back to its golden age.
It's time to leave the age of magic and enter the age of reason.
Phew!!!well.said.
People keep a straight face while talking about the evil eye?
its rather confusing video. what is Dr Shabir saying. We should ignore the hadith? Were the hadith sahih ,Hassan, or taif he was talking about. Dr Shabir was sitting on the fence in this video. How should one distinguish the veracity of the hadith. Simply by thinking whether it matches science then? If that is the case then the idea of parting the sea could be questioned. Jesus pbuh bringing the dead back to life should be questioned. What is the sive that you are using to determine the truth. I'm Muslim forever insha Allah,but that was a sitting on the fence video by Dr Shabir. Sorry if I offended anyone. jzk.
What is he basically saying that you shouldn't treat Hadith the way you treat Quran.. didn't you LISTEN to what he said?
What you should do is come to the true form of Islam and cast away your other scriptures. The Quran is the only true scripture. Our guidance should only come from it and not other source. It's good to have a historical perspective on the life of prophet Muhammad but we shouldn't use it in our everyday lives. Cast off all of your associations and abandon shirk.
@@hyrunnisa997 so no ritual salath?
@J C if Hadith if just a historical record what would you call the teachings of the prophet?
Dhynasah Çakir The Quran is the final scripture, not the only book of Allah. There are even a few verses in the Quran that confirm the veracity of the books before it and the accounts of the prophets of the previous generations.There is still plenty of knowledge a Muslim can learn from reading the Torah and Gospel, after reading and understanding the Quran.
Do you really wanna know why I don't like this video? Ok, here we go.
Dr. Ally is your "source" for everything. You display a blind belief in his "scholarship". You are guilty of taqleed. Your presentation of this topic rested entirely on his "opinion", whereas what he should have done is address the authenticity of the hadith on the basis of the solidity of the chain of narrators.
You take a hadith -> you evaluate its apparent linguistic meaning in comparison to the Qur'an -> if there is no obvious contradiction, you evaluate the strength of the chain of narration -> if it is solid, you study the application of the hadith in our daily practice of Islam.
But Dr. Shabbir did nothing of that sort.
What if there is a big hole in the ''process of authenticating'' as you described? Your ''Process'' leaves out rational thought and science.
Matthew 6:23 But if your eyes are unhealthy, your whole body will be full of darkness. If then the light within you is darkness, how great is that darkness!
My problem with Ahadith is that it contains a lot of legendary stories.
ignorant people in this comment section. Dr shabir is allhamdulilah on the right path. so sit down and humble yourselves
What path is he on exactly? It sounds like he is skeptical of core concepts in Islam. Can you give evidence to the contrary?
Mustafa R have you ever read the quran completely yourself? or have you blindly believed PEOPLE all your life? don’t listen to people when you have your creators words at hand.
Which aya did the sheikh read
سبحان اللہ , can you improve sound quality
Superstition is strong in the comment section.
Sheikh Hassan Ali said if people dont beleive in magic and jinns they shud spend some time with a raqi (excorcist) by volunteering to help
Aisha Khaja, I think after watching this Shabir Ally I think I will no long be watching any of his lecture. To Dr Shabir you are at the boundary. Just an fyi, we can also assume just like how what you have said as purely your assumptions based on your understanding and knowledge that if Prophet Mohammed PBUH did not go through the evil eye or the magic then a muslim today would never believe in these. Lot more to say but wish you well... I ask Allah SWT to guide you and grant you with more knowledge since you need it and you are representing alot of Muslims!
Usually Dr Shabir is quite clear in explanations and I am a total fan of his. However, in this instance I found him surprisingly lacking and confusing.
Where can we ask questions of our own?
Next video should be "problematic quraniyuun"
If you are not seeking guidance, why you wasting your time by watching Islamic videos!
Well I suggest to make it more longer discussion for problematic issue !!!!!!!!!!!!
How about common sense 🤣🤣🤣
Speaking from personal experience as a medical doctor and a Muslim. I have personally experienced the ill effects of magic between few hours to 24hrs on two separate occasions- my experiences could not be explained by psychiatry ailment. It did not fit any specified diagnostic pattern nor am I in need of any antipsychotics then or now. In fact I saw first hand the work of the medical doctor and some of quacks who claim to provide spiritual healing some of whom were practising magic. May Allah forgive me and them.
For me personally I found healing in reciting the Quran as the scholar has already mentioned Surah Falq moreover I found comfort in understanding that our dear Prophet SAW too was affected.
Believing in Islamic concept of magic does not mean that ones intelligence or the ahadeeth should be refuted.
Magic is a knowledge that can harm mankind only by Allah's Will. But by experience really brought me in awe of Allah's Book and His Messenger
Moreover I think at times too much emphasis is placed on the power of magic by certain people and communities. Allah is the All Powerful - fear Him - No one can harm us unless by Allah's permission
When you see and experience the healing of Quraan then your Imaan just soars.If I could share my experience here but this is not the platform for it. once you start doing ruqya on yourself and others, Allah shows you things which you were sceptical about before. Absolutely amazing. Dr Shabir Ally knows nothing about jinn possession. I have studied this topic for years now and know for a fact that drug abuse open gateways for such addicts to be possessed by jinn. No wonder alcohol is also called Spirits. Delirium Tremens is not illusions...these people see jinns in scary forms. As Muslims who believe in the effects of jinn possession and magic and evil eye, we are so blessed not to fall for the tricks of popular magicians like Dynamo etc. Also mentalists like Darren Brown. They are seeking the assistance of Jinn and it shows in their eyes for they themselves are possessed and can therefore communicate with jinn. May Allah SWT guide Dr Ally as he thinks in terms of science and philosophy. The Quraan is above all these and the healing and mercy is in the Quraan. Some of us feel and see the presence of jinn. They are fond to manifest themselves in the form of dogs and cats. Once you understand that this is Real you will make a conscious Wudhu for Ablution is definitely a shield against Shaytaan and always try and be in wudhu. I speak from experience as I deal with possessed people daily. I don't have to ask any questions anymore as the symptoms are so apparent and these victims are pumped with anti depressants and all kinds of chemicals that cause more harm to their bodies. Please Dr Ally educate yourself and visit Raqis like Mohammed Tim Humble whose knowledge can benefit you. Through your ignorance you are advising people that their suffering is their imagination or that they must accept that they have a medical condition. I have found that people who study philosophy always seem to have doubt in the Unseen world. So disappointed in Dr Ally.
Also need to add that a person who commits a crime in a possessed state will remember very little or nothing after the act. The one who remembers is responsible because he listened to the whispering of the devil. You will find that the one one who could not recall the crime is often diagnosed with some mental disorder and end up in a mental institution and not in jail. Question for you Dr Ally, Why was this "mentally ill" criminal born sane and suffered this disorder later in his /her life? Test them with Ruqya and you will have no doubt Inshaa Allah.
@@muslim5067 can or cannot?
@@frontlineltdfrontlineltd4072 .I do not understand your question?
@@muslim5067 can someone perform Ruqya or not?
Was ever recorded about possession with Shabir?
sir,how can we cherry pick ?as if you are doing the same thing ,you and we muslims do with bible....i think one has got 2 option ,either accepting or totaly disregard( solely my opinion)...but this causes some problems too because they are the source from which we extract our prophet's(pbuh) life and many other things...i am currently studying 'The study Quran'..it is also causing some problems...i really want you to help me ..because i m going astray.
focus on the quran it is complete and use it to strengthen your deen after move on to hadiths but always compare them to the quran the ones you follow should never contradict the quran
Allah knows best!
Sir, your are very pious Muslim whom I like very much.
Regarding this topic it is very clear that the evil eye, black magic etc are not logically fitting to this day science we know. But sir, there are so many things which were not digestible at each time in history.
It is became common now that most of our great scholars are trying to explain each and everything logically and with the science we know today.
I believe Islam is 100% logical and there would be always something in life which cannot be explained with the knowledge available at the time.
If we started rejecting things based on our present logic, I think it is a very dangerous approach.
What logically not fitting a 100 years ago is absolutely logical now.
But most of the story in quran is about 2 to 5000 years ago so its also difficult to interpret with our present knowledge.quran have some secret guidance which only some intelligent can crack but its all in god hands as the requirement of knowledge of religion needed god revealed it. Our scholars says nobody can understand quran except what the scholar has translated but i don't think so guidance never ends as allah will be forever. In religion young children or teenagers they learned fast and they think that the world are going fast so they are not so interested now in the religion and quran have some aayat which our ulama has translated its doesn't sound nice to them and most of the cases are from hadith 1000 of it are fabricated.thats why i think allah is revealing some very useful and secret information through his good preacher of the quran and its nice that most of them are quran lovers.
So follow quran and sunnah not every hadith and not every scholar.
All due respect but the Sheikh's interpretations are solely on his personal opinion and complete logic, however we cannot even begin to claim to be believers without faith_which is not logical.
I agree with Dr Shabir regarding the authenticity of some(numerous?) hadiths, eg. the Prophet(pbuh) could be harmed by magic as the quran speaks otherwise. I believe the primary guide of muslims is the quran. Islamic scholars should sift through all hadiths to verify them. Those considered authentic and not against the teaching of the quran should only be used. Salam to everyone.
Quran Speaks? And you gossip about unreliable Ahadith?
Brother i couldn't have said it better. They should rename the show
Yes he is not clear. What is he trying to substantiate? The reality of magic, Jinns and evil eye. Or the reality of superstition, magic tricks, and false or Daif hadiths? Because based of Knowledge from the Holy Quran and hadith the two topics he is addresing does exist. However, one does not cancel the other. He has a problem with logic and what is concrete thinking .
Why didn't you let him finish the Jinn possession topic 😭
Whatever hadith is inconvenient is mentioned as weak hadith by shabbir ally, if that is the case why not junk the weak hadiths altogether, secondly if magic, evil eye are said ti exist who gives them the power, to know more on these issues viewers will be delighted to view you tube videos of learned scholars such as David Wood, Arabian prince, apostate prophet, sameer abdullah, Harris sultan, masked arab, sam shamoun ,
Dont try change the religion. its perfected surah(5:3)
part of islam is believe in unseen without belive in useen your not muslim. chek surah bagara(2:3)
We dont custom make islam to serve us We change ourseves to fit in islam
Excellent response to this illegocial talk. I am now going through the evil eye since now 3yrs and i don't agree to a lot of things that the sheikh talk. As long as a scholar of Islam i respect him but that does not mean i agree to whatever he says.
Allah-o-yasimuka min-an-naas
Don't include Sahar because Allah swt has created this phinominan and Allah swt does not change his Sunnah
Xc
In Tamilnadu likE Dr shabbir Ally some muslims nOt believe in evil Eye and black magic.
tntj ?
@@inzi5361 yes
@@mohamedalsaqaf2434 👍🏼
Jazak Allah brother! But sometimes I find your explanations leave me in a state of confusion, not able to draw a clear conclusion. May be you try to avoid sharing your explicit views to avoid any conflict. It would be tremendously helpful if you could please share your opinions explicitly because your invaluable opinions will shine a torch for many of us. I myself find difficulty believing in authenticity of such narrations. These things look against the ideology of Islam which is very pragmatic and away from anecdotes and confabulations. Islam teaches us to live our lives without any fears except being God conscious in our every deed. Please please share more videos on this topic with your explicit views. Jazakumullah kheir
If the cucumber is bitter and gives you a stomach ache, don’t eat it in the thin hope that there are some hidden benefits. The bitterness is warning that doesn’t lie. It is the same when your deepest untroubled heart struggles in accepting something. When it’s true, the heart knows. That’s why even the criminal is troubled when committing a murder - his heart knows it’s wrong. Anything that looks too complicated is corrupt. Truth is simple. Islam is about being a good person. Believing in fantastical tales is never more important than being a good gentle soul. Allah gave us consciousness so that it can guide us. When our consciousness rejects something as nonsense, that’s the truth.
I agree with you. I really admire dr ally because he is more logical than the mass of ulamas we currently have, but my issue is he is holding a lot back. I think it’s also because RUclips is full of bully scholars/muftis who will call anyone a deviant that questions a hadith. Dr ally while he is on the correct path, he is still very hesitant to fully embrace his views and make his position known because of these bullies. They have attacked him many times before and while he is too mature to engage those clowns, he still has a tendency to remain diplomatic and I think he should just get past all this and be more upfront for the sake of Islam.
@@fatimaxo4885, actually religion is a very sensitive topic. Of course we do want to be careful before forcing our opinions. I myself had always been very careful when it came about different issues in Islam, but lately after listening to scholars like dr Ally I realised that I had these thoughts in my mind for a long time but avoided to express them. Dr Ally is a breath of fresh air. We should be able to understand our Lord Almighty how He is.
@@lamson8349 No, this is a completely incorrect view of Islam. Every human being has a different conscience and sense of reality. Some people are more willing to accept things than others. For example, did you know some Muslims completely reject the existence of Jinn? Even though they are clearly mentioned as being a creation of Allah in the Quran separate from humans just like the angels are a separate creation, some people still reject them due to their “consciousness” or “sense of reality”. Operating on the same principles, some Muslim people reject the concept of playing games (video games, cards, selling cards or video games, etc) as being completely haram, while others do not. Some people are willing to call others kuffar or kill them over these issues, yet they’re relying entirely on statements from individuals in history who they’d never personally met. You can’t simply operate on your own consciousness, you have to do the best you can to adhere to Islam, but I think it’s acceptable to sideline or ignore Hadith that seem to contradict the Quran and the majority of the teachings in the Sunnah. For example, it is my personal opinion that Hadiths which demean or degrade women can be ignored, or hadiths stating that people cannot make jokes about one another that are personal even if they know each other well and are unbothered, or that anyone who leaves his faith should be killed even if they are peaceful, etc can be ignored because they tend to contradict the message and principles of Islam.
This doesn’t mean the Hadith is wrong necessarily. Rather, in most cases, I believe some of these Hadith only make up a portion of what the prophet actually stated, similar to taking a verse or portion of the Quran out of context without historical knowledge, or ignoring the fact that many things in the Quran are written in a metaphorically representative fashion to paint a mental picture of a situation.
Thanks!
Thank you!
This channel is purely to broadcast Dr Ally's opinion on topics in Islam. There are other opinions out there you know. Might be interesting to invite someone else for a change.
Yeah all it is is a platform for him to spew his unorthodox beliefs with extra steps (i.e. the talk show format)
I have high respect for the Sheikh. But unfortunately he got it wrong a few times. Interpretation of Quran and Hadith should be common amongst the scholars. One scholar can not have an isolated view based on his or interpretation. That scholar should check with others also.
Magic is real! The proof around me is just too obvious. I have had family members who have had a spell cast on them and the only people who could make these spells useless are people who have Knowledge of these things (obviously a religious and pious imam or mullah)
I agree with you. I really respect Dr Shabir ally. But i feel bad when he says magic, evil eyes... Are not real. Magic is real Wallahi. Maybe Dr Shabir, because he lives in canada, he feels embarassed to admit it.
Jiam jiao Isn't black magic just like when a human communicates with the shayateen (jinns) and they make deals, which include the Jinns harming people or performing services for them? Or does black magic have nothing to do with the Jinns in your opinion?
Mati khorasani Magic is real! Prove it! If we had magic, why would we need weapons of mass destruction or medicine? We could just cast spells on people we do not like or that we do, much cheaper. Magicians like mind readers can be easily disproved, one that purports to do it should be approached and punched. If he knew magic, he should have saw that coming or defended himself with his magic.
Also, why is magic always lame. Why don't magicians walk around making heads explode or private parts fall off or go into children hospitals and cure the cancer or blindness? Instead they rather get people divorced or do some other equally lame thing. One can take over the world, feed the hungry, or heal kids, but they rather meddle in some random villager affairs in some third world, priorities.
@@cody7875 completely agree on logical grounds but it can still be proved from Quran and Sunnah that magic doesn't exist..for example some claim that the prophet was cast under the spell of magic which in itself is a blasphemous thing to say...
@@jiamjiao1187 No, I mean Dr Shabir could also simply be not convinced of it due to his scientifically oriented nature. However, I don’t think he’s entirely dismissing it, I just think he’s dismissing certain Hadith related to it, possibly because he lacks understanding of the topic. But the Quran and Hadith both clearly state that magic exists, and if you believe that magic exists and understand that evil eye has been a known form of magic throughout history even prior to Islam, it stands to reason that evil eye also exists. Some things have been widely known and carried out throughout history for centuries because they are clear and came from our forefathers closer to the time of Adam AS, and Islam confirms (some) of them.
I really admire and respect shabbir ally in many ways but i also disagree with him on many points
1. He always relies on scholarly opinions while rarely going go the actual quran or hadith.. i have noticed this in his debates (islam vs Christianity) infact. I saw him almost fairly losing out on arguements with nabeel.qureshi (christian apologist).
2. Using other scholarly opinion, shabbir refutes hadith that 'do not make sense' to him or his scholarly companions. But what about the whole science behind authenticating the hadith (last well known was sheikh albani). So if we are to take shabbir allys ideology, 90% of hadith of muslim, bukhari would be problematic
3. He cites dr israr ahmed (p.s he was from my country pakistan) as one of the authors who cites the importance of 'close door policy elimination'. While dr israr ahmeds works are incredible he too wasnt free from error. His support of wahda tul wujood ? Anyone ? He spoke in favour of it. FYi.wahdtul wujuud (the concept of one origin with many faces) is a clear contradiction to Quran, with nearly all main stream scholars fiercely rejection this ideology- again not due to those scholars opinion per se, but due to the nature of this belief
I absolutely admire shabbir allys knowledge. Hes second to none. But i feel hes far off on certain topics due to his approach to scholarly methods. If i compare him to dr zakir nayak, ahmed deedat, theres a stark comparison between him and them.. while they gain their expertise in the knowledge of the scriptures and their comparison/contrasts/ contradictions, dr shabbir ally mostly utilises points raised by scholars and their interpretation of scripture (just like his debates with christians)
Yes he is not clear. What is he trying to substantiate? The reality of magic, Jinns and evil eye. Or the reality of superstition, magic tricks, and false or Daif hadiths? Because based of Knowledge from the Holy Quran and hadith the two topics he is addresing does exist. However, one does not cancel the other. He has a problem with logic and what is concrete thinking .
@@TheViperDawg I agree with u on hadith ..bt one thing I hv seen...many people are just quoting this is from Sahih bukhari ..without knowing the context...scholars identical Sahih bukhari as authentic..I agree.but we hv to admit that they r not infallible...not all hadith in Sahih bukhari is necessarily be true...one is the age of Aisha (RA)...which is questionable ..if the age of Aisha(RA) was 6 at the tym of marriage,then many of Islamic history has to be changed to fit her age.. Christian,jews scholar also give their life for studying the scriptures but r they correct ?....one book which is free of errors is the divine revelation of Allah-Quran...still amo ng hadith books,i trust Sahih bukhari but I don't consider it infallible....so what we do now....first and foremost ..is the 5 pillars of Islam....how do we perform.
.use hadith(which the world know as authentic..if it is not,still u will not be held accountable bcoz Allah is just..He is the most merciful)..then we shall try to follow the Quran as much as possible....our arrogance,pride,anger should be zero....which are mentioned in the Quran ....and then live for the well being of humanity.... don't harm a human bcoz Allah is forgiving but not human...U can be held accountable for that on the day of judgement..feed the hungers,help the poors...it's not wise to debate and prove ur perception is the correct.....I hv seen many Muslims involve in debate and try to prove their percepyion is correct....One more thing..we don't even know 1 percent of Allah....His mercy has no limit....Remember Allah always and work good besides performing the mandatory like salat,fast,charity,hajj(if possible)..and Allah knows best
@@sportsflashback5335 whole ijma of muslim umma is on the 2 saheeh, infact Allah states that muslims will unify over whats right and divide on what is not. Infact there is no way to follow qurans directives without direction from sunnah
How many raka in salah? How many sajda in sala ?
We cannot deny that ahadith are not important
@@TheViperDawg please read my comments carefully...what I hv said...u must rely on hadith which the world consider authentic...from that u will know how many rakat ,how many sajdah....even if the hadiths r not authentic(u will not held accountable for that as Allah instructs us in the glorious Quran to use our reason ...to search for the truth...and beyond that u hv to follow Quran as much as possible..do good for the world..and not involve in unnecessary debate to prove u r correct ...we r accountable to Allah only..He will judge us...As per as my knowledge and facts,I trust Sahih bukhari the most among hadith books but I don't blv it is 100% authentic as no book on the face of the earth can be so correct except the glorious Quran...human error exists everywhere..
@@sportsflashback5335 yes brother i read your comments carefuly and replied. See the problem with this mentality ( i.e. its not 100% authentic or error free) leads to further problems. Problems such as you will see in the comments section. People are going to an extent to say they dont need hadith at all to be a muslim.
My interpretation of this is close the door to such speculations. No one is talking about comparing it to quran thats no way a comparison. But at the same time we should not be (or perhaps people like shabir ally) cant come 1500 years later and claim that ahadith are problematic and that we should "reassess" the logic behind hadith.
I agree with your comments abt accountability but my issue is with liberals like shabir ally, and many others who say that even proven saheeh hadith are wrong or problematic 🤣🤣
Tell you what ? Its like saying "salah has 3 sajdas not 2" and that the hadith with 2 sajdas is problematic.
That was the main point in my issue that i mentioned. And Allah knows best..
There is no black magic
Please do a segment on tattoos
No issue as long as they dont have anything vulgar
By refering to soneof ther points before.
I maynot be 100% correct about his views
But..
His thought processes seemed to be based on the assumption of philosophical naturalism.
He seems to be in partial-disagreement with spiritual realm (as he hisagrees with evil-eye), and only limited the cause effect criteria to emiprical one.
While in Islam its clear that we have a spiritual reality which cannot be empirically observed, and hard to make sense with inductive methods.
We have deduction based reasoning - which helps us to acquire ilm-ul-yaqeen, the knowledge certainty. (unlike the knowledge of science which is uncertain and susceptible to change)
That's why we go back to Quran and Sunnah, without any bias towards philosophical assumptions of liberal, modernists and empiricist.
And with the strong rules of inference we believe it can genuinely happen, behind our perception. Regardless of what empiricist and reductionist says about reality.
We clearly know - science has a problem of induction, and so the empiricism has. Thus we cannot use this paradigms to judge and scrutinize the traditional narrations. The traditional scholars had a strong mechanism to uphold Islamic epistemology, so no point of orientalist-lenses to revisit those narrations. Otherwise one would hit the axe on their own feet.
So please, better consider revisiting the thought peocess, asumptions or lenses of redutionist, empiricist and cursed-orientalists (as this is what their world-view is meant for, already to change), we cant use a world-view which uncertain within itself to counter the knowledge of certainty.
Thank You.
as muslims we have to believe in the unseen. if our prophet said the evil eye is real then its real. no need for discussion.
Why is this so called doctor ignoring the fact that the two quls, al-falaq and al-nas were sent down to the prophet because of the magic that was done to him, may the peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and that magic is a pact made between a magician and a shaytaan and that none of them can harm you except with Allah's permission. Wallahi no saheeh hadith narrated from the prophet are problematic and may Allah guide you from the clear error that you are upon. This is definitely problematic that you think that you find the hadith about the sahaaba who was inflicted by evil eye to be untrue. May Allah save us from walking upon the wrong path and believing it to be true. For surely then are we truly lost like the nasaaris and yahuud who have earned the wrath of Allah.
I love Dr. Shabir but he has no knowledge of the jinn, sihr, and evil eye. I don’t blame him since I was just like him. Mashallah he hasn’t ever experienced that and I hope he never does.
But I understand his approach to the Hadiths. For me it’s the other way around. I found the HDithhs that deal with magic to be more credible than the ones that deal with lies such as alcohol is haram, blasphemy against God’s prophet (Bukhari 323 for example) and so on.
The Hadiths are BS (45:6-7) but the ones about magic are somewhat true. I have personal examples of magic, jinn possession, and evil eye. All are actually interlinked.
Evil eyes are real because few persons I knew if the said the plant looks good then the plant rots also one lady looked at me and admired my looks when I was baby I got diarrhoea of blood.
If you take it upon yourself to decide correct and wrong hadiths. You will later do that with the Qur'an.
This man is misguiding others while misguided. Havoc to muslim ummah. May ALLAH guide you
I don’t think the message is deciding which Hadiths to label right or wrong, the message is to fact check whatever you’re told. You should always check on authenticity and veracity of any Hadith, this should be second nature. The Quran doesn’t have a need for this since it is the actual holy scripture.
السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته
I think Harut and marut are not angels because that is contradicting with that angels never do evil things , so i asked a relative arabic scholar about this ayah to make sure then we've found two things that the word ما is related to ما both of soliman and two angels that الله tells us they did not do it (soliman and the two messengers angels) , the second thing ببابل هاروت و ماروت thats called in arabic تقديم و تاخير means it is a new story here الله did not say هاروت و ماروت ببابل to link the two angels to this phrase in the end he knows best الله اعلى و اعلم hope the scholar shabbir make researches about it and tell me what he will find
والسلام عليكم .
Ahmed Galal They did not teach it except that they told them this is a test from your Lord and not to learn from this . It was to clarify the difference between Sihr and a miracle giving to a Nabi (Peace be upon them). They didn't disobey Allah (Swt) nor was it malice or considered evil. Rather followed the command to test and show the people what Sihr really is all about and also freeing Sulayman (As) from the accusations of disbelief and being a magician due to the fact Allah (Swt) had giving him many Miracles and a Kingdom Like never before or after. I hope that helps brother May Allah guide us all to the sirat almustaqeem.
Ameen
Muhammad Abdullah Ar Rahman
Amin , but my opinion is because of arabic reading , read the whole ayah و لكن الشياطين كفرو يعلمون الناس السحر that means that the devils from human and jinn who were and are teaching magic (decieving) and as i mentioned in the comment above the word ما before the two angels is the same word ما before prophet sulaiman wich means they did not do that in arabic we say it عطف our lord mentioned also that no one will see the angels except when his death , he said also when he sent angels to help the prophet and the believers he said you do not see them , and in the end hope our lord guide us and forgive us if we were mistaken , peace
Ahmed Galal Ameen. That's where the middle ground comes in because we know Allah doesn't contradict himself so what is contradictory to Allah we must investigate. When it says they did not do it we have to know they mean magic (disbelieve). Automatically to practice Sihr is definitely Disbelief in Allah the Angels can't do things out of there on will especially disobey they clarify they didn't do it Meaning Sulayman (As) and Harut & Marut they are not responsible for the practice of sihr the people where initially doing this with the help of the shaytans. He stop them from doing this and the minute he took away there books it became a issue that he is the Magician because he has all these miracles how we know your not doing Magic. Only once all that has taken place did Allah step in to set the record straight for the people of Sulayman (As) And then sent Harut and Marut. Allah knows best
Muhammad Abdullah Ar Rahman
You know brother harut and marut are not angels in my opinion because in arabic there is something called تقديم و تاخير i don't know the english name of it , anyway it is a grammer means that it is a new story seprated from the story before it like our lord said ببالبل هاروت و ماروت means at babel harut and marut and that is the تقديم و تاخير if it is not تقديم و تاخير it will be harut and marut at babel هاروت و ماروت ببابل so it is a new story here seprated from denying the accusation of sulaiman and the two angels who were reveal for him the words of our lord from disblieve because they accused them of disblieve , so allah begins a new story about harut and marut which they may be human and as you,ve said allah knows best الله اعلم
Lol ur dumb. Harut Marut were angels who were transformed and given human traits and appearance and a free will just as a test.
As much as I admire Dr Shabir for his knowledge and contributions, I have to say that I disagree with this video. The evil eye is real and so is black magic.
Dear Muslims, please call Christian Prince on RUclips to get another view on these subjects. Thank you.
There were no clear answer at all. The only thing I understood from this clip is "It depends on how you translate". For Shabir we should faver new reverts and make them easy to understad and accept. That notion is not necessorily prijecting the reality.
Havig said so, Dr Shabir is very intellegent and thus can easily sell his Idea. Thak you Dr.
If you denying this hadith it is denying the teaching of the Prophet SAW. therefore I think sheikh shabir has to check his new
advisors because shaytaan lives within the people,stay firm and don't destroy what you have been building for years.
First of all the Heading is wrong "Problematic" Dr. Shabbir have to confirm that the Hadith which he narrated is Sahee, Hasan etc. And he simply says this hadith doesn't fit to our understanding so We have neglect them. Well Many thing and Hadiths doesn't come under our understanding Ex : Dajjal, Gog Magog, or born again on Judgement day. By saying it doesn't match to our today's world or today's understanding than you are becoming "Munkeer E Hadith" I remember Sir Syed Ahmed Khan the great personality and founding father of Aligarh University India also had same view in his book.
just because some thing says sahih does not make it true, stop taking the books of men as the book of God
How dare you deny clear words of Allah and the messenger? How do people follow you?
where does he deny verses of the qur'an?
My relative who is a Muslim doesn’t agree with some of what he says. Does Ally say he doesn’t believe in black magic at all?
In the battle of Uhud didn’t the Prophet pbuh get hurt and his tooth got knocked out too ? I believe no doubt overall god protects his prophets but can there be a little damage (hardship) yes! It’s God’s book and he does protect it from error like it says in the Quran, but saying magic didn’t effect the prophet at all idk , I believe things happened to the prophet so we can learn from them and the last surahs came for that reason !!
Is Aisha (host) married?
Yes she is happily marred
Astaghfirulah. May Allah Subhanahuwata’ala guides all of us to the straight path and protect us from misinterpretating his book. May Allah Subhanahuwata’ala eradicates doubts in our minds about His book. And may Allah Subhanahuwata’ala protect us from worshiping our own intellect as god.
With all due respect. You are wrong here Dr. Please take this video down because you are putting doubts into Muslims minds.
Visit Morocco and spend a day or two with a roque and you will realize very quickly that black magic and evil eye is in fact a reality. To protect yourself from going down the wrong path and to protect Muslim Umah who respect you from leaving Islam due to the doubts you cause them to have, please take this video down ASAP. I love you for the sake of Allah and don’t want you to mislead Muslim ummah unintentionally.
I was also a skeptic in black magic and evil eye until spent a year and a half in Morocco and had a chance to witness the effect of magic and evil eye in person. Magic and evil eye is as real as the fire is hot and the ice is cold.
May Allah Subhanahuwata’ala guides us all. Assalamualiakum.
Yes... Brother.... I feel they are just taking Quraan only to understand things.. Then i believe they shud not eat Fishes 🐠 coz in the Holy Quraan it is written things which are dead by itself (without being halaal) shud not be eaten.. And Fishes are not halaal then....
Yes he is not clear. What is he trying to substantiate? The reality of magic, Jinns and evil eye. Or the reality of superstition, magic tricks, and false or Daif hadiths? Because based of Knowledge from the Holy Quran and hadith the two topics he is addresing does exist. However, one does not cancel the other. He has a problem with logic and what is concrete thinking .
So, if evil eye and magic are true, doesn't that contradict with the 6th Article of Imaan? Just asking.
Rizwan Pallickal Moidu
There are no contradictions in the book of Allah, the Quran. If we are unable to comprehend a verse in the Quran, it doesn’t mean that what it says is not true. It just means the meaning of the verse is not meant to be clear or it was due to our lack of knowledge in the subject.
As Allah says In Surah Al Imron verse number 7,
“It is He who has sent down to you, [O Muhammad], the Book; in it are verses [that are] precise - they are the foundation of the Book - and others unspecific. As for those in whose hearts is deviation [from truth], they will follow that of it which is unspecific, seeking discord and seeking an interpretation [suitable to them]. And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allah . But those firm in knowledge say, "We believe in it. All [of it] is from our Lord." And no one will be reminded except those of understanding.”
Islam means total submission to the will of God and total obedience to His law. If we want to claim that we are a true Muslim, what do we do? We submit and we obey Allah’s commands totally.
With due all respect to Dr. Ally, his knowledge in this subject is lacking and he shouldn’t be doing what he is doing in this video.
Please note brother, I’m not here trying to tarnish Dr. Ally reputation anyway. I believe he is sincere in trying to educate the ummah. But as human, we are prone to make mistakes. May Allah forgives, guide us to the right path and keep our hearts firm on the truth.
I love this scholar for the sake of Allah but I disagree with most of his stance on many hadiths evil eye and magic exist
I dont think the angels need to telll the people how to cause rift between husband and wife, since this is with out anyone teaching is within us human nature, something has to far more then simply teaching them this. That has to be magic. Magic is not fake, people do al sort of black magic.
who really wrote quran?
Salam
Stick to debating religion Dr shabbir Ali n leave the field of Roqya to those who are experienced init
Abd Rahman how about you leave this video?
I'm more confused after watching this video.
He does not know what he is talking about.
@@TheDrRow i believe only someone like an ahle Quran can talk like this
Rainmaker Artist Journey you don’t know what you are talking about
All the videos of Dr. shabir have one thing in common... he encourages you to doubt Ahadees i.e. sayings of the Prophet SAW. He conveniently choose to draw his own conclusions on things just as the others he aims to correct. I do not agree with him on a lot of things. Wallah Ualam.
Those who put Quran( words of ALLAH) as primary source, will definitely find many contradiction in hadeeth( words of human saying that prophet Muhammad said this and that).
@@KenAiden It is in the Quran that Allah says that the Prophet SAW does and says nothing aside from the command of Allah himself. Quran and Ahadees and very much related.
Mutahir rasul you are right but not just hadith but also tha quran tha probalem is that there things that he can't deny there many muslims who get sick because of magic and evil eye this guy is keep twisting tha Quran and hadith
Without any evidence making his conclusions like he is revealed to something. ALLAAH is watching
Yes he is not clear. What is he trying to substantiate? The reality of magic, Jinns and evil eye. Or the reality of superstition, magic tricks, and false or Daif hadiths? Because based of Knowledge from the Holy Quran and hadith the two topics he is addresing does exist. However, one does not cancel the other. He has a problem with logic and what is concrete thinking .
By approaching Islam through western framework, u r making "Islam" comfortable even for Bill Gates and George Bush! But let me clear that Islam is neither escapism nor dependent on your problematic interpretation. Islam has its own value system and some part of it even though appear problematic or embarassing to you, can't be compromised for the sake of western values.
Sorry - Islam has to make sense or it won’t be fit for purpose. Human consciousness expands with every generation. And you can’t expect Muslims living in modern Canada or USA to live according to the lifestyle and the understanding of a 7th Century desert Arab. For all generations, the core of Islam is that you should be a good person. You don’t need to believe in fantastical tales to do that. Love yourself and love others and do the right thing.
@@lamson8349 That means it is okay for us to modify the content of Quran and hadith than to modify our own selves!! I recall the hadith which states that to stand firm on the path of Islam would be as tough as to hold a burning coal in one's palm.
@@lamson8349 You are literally contradicting what Allah said in the Quran and what Allah commanded.
May Allah guide you.
Than you never have seen or experienced someone who has done black magic on people, or people who had black magic and who were cured by the quran and ruqyah.. so what you are saying is not true.. im sorry
May Allah guide this man, he is very bold and misguided.
Only God can judge
bigelowtech only God can judge what is the heart since He is the only One that knows the intentions of men. But once a man has spoken, he is at the mercy of his fellow brothers and sisters to support him if what he says is true and reprimand him if what he says is false. That’s why Allah says Surah Al Imron verse 110: to enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong...
I totally agree with his perspective which is absolutely correct. I can't believe that people believe one can harm anyone by sighting itself as though allah does. Isn't a shirk that believing one has one of the Allah's power. In quran allah says nothing is like him and anything happens when he orders happen..
Your approach towards Hadith is great may ALlah bless you
In my old age, Satan has been my most faithful and useful Companion, not those calling themselves Muslims - those damn and damned creatures - not all of them, obviously!
BAFS
He dont believe in magic. Why is it when people are possessed by jinn.
The jinn speaks through that person and says that i was sent by a magician to possess this person. So he's talking rubbish. Just because you aint been inflicted with magic or evil deosnt mean it dont exist.
He didn’t say he doesn’t believe in Jins.
I know this video is old but I wanted to leave a comment and say I did not benefit and that your channel shouldn’t produce videos like this that are ambiguous and not clear. I don’t even feel like the host understood what this guest was saying. On matters that pertain to major parts of our faith you should be CLEAR not trying to satisfy this person and that person. If it is in a sahib Hadith I accept it. If it’s in Quran I accept it. Everyone knows Hadith goes into more detail that Quran. I feel like this served only to put doubts in the minds of Muslims. I would consider clarifying this content or taking it down. I’m being sincere in my advice. Salaam!
Voodoo is a religion and not "magic"... it's thausands of years old
I surely did not benefit from this video! It is an insult to my intelligence and personal life experiences!
BAFS
Brother I see you in every video on "let the Quran speak" and you don't sound happy 😊. Any ideas or issues feel free to discuss us. Assalaamu Alaikum Warahmatu LLahi Wabarakaatuh. Ramadan Karim 2019.
Fremaux : did u just say “insult to your intelligent” 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤪. That someone has revealed that your imaginary jinn (unseen) friend doesn’t exist 🤣.
That’s what happens when you distance yourself from the Quran . (Basically you lost the plot)
Surah ibrahim v22: shaytan has no Authority or control over us and can only give WasWassa (whisper)
Surah An Nas: Allah confirms, shaytan can only give WasWassa (whisper).
It’s the free will which Allah has given to you to act good or evil based on what u hear 👂.
@@ableskill You are another blind and damn fanatical preacher of what you do not know and do not understand!
Get baptized, maybe then you will be given a PROPER name! Sadik FAST STRENGTH, my foot!
BAFS
@@BAFREMAUXSOORMALLY 🤣🤣🤣🤪.
Mate, atleast I know how to read, unlike you let alone understanding anything, you can’t even read 🤣!
That’s why you blind follow and practice the like of your forefathers did.
But it doesn’t bother me, coz people like u will die off along with your superstitious beliefs.😁
Allah clearly states this Quran been revealed plainly easy to read and understand.....😂
Go and ask your imaginary jinn (unseen) friend , how to read.. and why not even blame your jinn friend for all your problems, rather being a man and start taking responsibility for your own actions.
Pathetic!🤯