It's obvious that this audio is pre-recorded, now everyone are waiting for their singing on radio show, because radio show didn't provide auto-tuned or lip-sync
It completely pre recorded Sorry to pop the bubble One good way to know is actually when the Mr removed is this clean And they are really good at making it sound live
@@yossiehoho1777 kebalik. kalo encore nya bagus, mr removed bagus kayak gini org pasti percaya kalo live. encore kan yg bener2 cuman backtrack tanpa vocal.
@@jeannesue9461 setelah kamu dengar suara mereka disini, masih bilang suara mereka ga bagus? Ga bisa nyanyi. Saya sendiri setelah tau sesi encore mereka kurang bagus, langsung cari mr removed nya. Dan hasilnya ga buruk
@@yossiehoho1777 laiya pak, kebalik. Stage ginian masih bisa pake pre-recording. Tp kalo encore kan murni on the spot. Jadi bisa nilai sendiri lah yg asli yg mana
the group with many scandals -Garam a bully -Sakura plastic surgery -Chaewon can't sing, and she did plastic surgery too -Yunjin can't sing too actually -Kazuha no visuals and really unattractive -Eunchae? who's her? LOL hybe debuted the wrong person, why did he just throw gfriend away? pissed me off
@@radwmla kpop fans are so stupid. She literally admitted to having it so it doesn’t matter what she looked like before “her real face isn’t that pretty oh no🥺🥺🥺😢😢😭😭😭” it literally does not matter. How does that affect u. Does it affect her talent? Her personality? Nope.
![[LE▶️PLAY] ‘CRAZY’ MV reaction l 감탄사 가득한😆 백만 볼트 전기처럼 짜릿한 리액션!⚡️💡](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4WZOjz193DE/mqdefault.jpg)
![[LE▶️PLAY] ‘CRAZY’ MV reaction l 감탄사 가득한😆 백만 볼트 전기처럼 짜릿한 리액션!⚡️💡](/img/tr.png)
![[4K] LE SSERAFIM - “FEARLESS” Band LIVE Concert [it's Live] K-POP live music show](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mX3CmeEv0KY/mqdefault.jpg)
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[CLEAN MR Removed] aespa - Supernova | Mnet Mcountdown 240516 MR제거](/img/1.gif)
I will wait for them to appear on the radio to see the color of their voices
me too
did you not see their encore? their live vocal is so bad
It's obvious that this audio is pre-recorded, now everyone are waiting for their singing on radio show, because radio show didn't provide auto-tuned or lip-sync
쇼케이스 엠알제거랑 비교해봤을 때 숨소리나 음정 같은 게 똑같은거보면 ar 맞는듯
미묘하게 달라요오
ar이여도 숨소리는 힘듬 ㅎ
@@한결-p6i 첫주여서 ar깔려있어요
It’s prerecorded. You can even hear the auto tune. But they still did amazing.
안무하면서 몸을 저렇게 흔들어대는데 숨소리 잔잔한 거 들으면 AR인 거 맞는데...
생각한 것보다 잘한 거 보소ㄷㄷ
This is not live at all. You can tell by the other videos with no MR removed where they... don't sound like that. At all ^^
(Yep, the autotune after first chorus is there. LOL)
Prerecorded. But i believe they sing well too. Bcz the songs have less note. I believe chaewon izone.
No. Pre record is the one when they sing blue flame. This one is live.
@@fie97 it's prerecorded also . Read description properly. I know izone sakura raw vocal. So please stop defending for your bts company.
@@fie97 this performance is pre recorded
@@jebablessysalomi3451 what does bts have to do with this lol
@@ps2738 you are all supporting just bcz they're from bts label.
arなのにmrって動画出す人いるから、理解してない人は勘違いしちゃうんよな
最初の週は違うよね
Garam is so stable
첫주여서 ar 깔려있음
idk if it’s pre recorded cause some parts sound like it’s pre-recorded and some parts sound like it’s live… so maybe they did few parts live? idk?
maybe like that
Well if i look at thw desc it says it's pre recorded
It completely pre recorded
Sorry to pop the bubble
One good way to know is actually when the Mr removed is this clean
And they are really good at making it sound live
첫주는 ar이 맞음 요즘 숨소리도 녹음해서 티도 안남
pre-record but it's ok, they slay 😻
THIS IS LIVE
@@divalestari8361 ini prerecord kok kak udah banyak yg bilang, lagipula gapapa klo idol pre-record apalagi dance nya susah
@@divalestari8361 ini pre records ya
Lipsync
@@uwucioo8932 setuju se stabil apa pun suara nya pas bagian mereka ngedongak in kepala kok gak goyang suaranya
@@divalestari8361 FANS DENIAL
아 기대한것보다 잘하네 했는데 댓글보니 ar이구나
아닌데
@@return9109 첫주차는 ar입니닩
@@return9109 맞는데 사녹인데
Totally pre record, its different with iKon and Monsta x
I totally agree, and there's no comparison
그룹멤버 한명 논란인거 빼고봐도 이건 ar
채원언니는 음원이랑 최대한 비슷하게 하려고 노력한다고 해야되나 쫀득쫀득하게 잘부른다 너무 내취향 ㅠㅠ
음원 맞아요 라이브 아니고 ar임 에스파처럼
MR들으면서 모든 걸그룹중 가장 잘 했다고 생각해요!! 르세라핌 화이팅!! 항상 응원합니다!
첫주는 거의 모든 아이돌 립싱크에용
르세라핌도 좋지만, 엔믹스도 라이브가 미쳤어요
@나나나나나나빌레R.O.C.K??!!! 숨소리 안들리나요 음 안맞는 부분도 있는데..?
@@boocarat0116 사녹 맞는데
첫주차는 에이알인거 다 아는데 왜 맨날 엠알제거 채널들은 왜 컴백 초 때 무대ㅏㅁ 올림… ㄹㅇ 좀 어이없네
So basically they just dancing on the stage... LOL 🤣
중간 중간에 숨소리 있는거 보니깐 mr제거 맞는거 같은데
라이브 너무 잘한다❤ 르세라핌 화이팅
ar 깔면 직접 부르는 것 처럼 숨소리도 들려요
@@Magnolia- 그건 아니고 라이브 AR 이라고 숨소리 다 녹음해놓은 음원을 따로 사용해요
앵콜때도 이렇게 못불렀는데 춤추면서 이게 될리가 있냐... 딱봐도 ar이지
Ar이고 뭐고 잘만하면 돼잖아
앵콜 한번 실수때문에 그러냐..
진짜 레전드네
IT'S PRE RECORDED TOMORROW ON MUSIC BANK IT WON'T BE PRE RECORDED-
Hope so
Music bank also has pre recorded performances
첫주라 ar 아닌가요?
와 근대 숨소리 진짜 예술적으로 넣엇내 막귀가 들으면 진짜 라이브인줄알듯
라이브 맞아요!
ar 맞아요.
진짜 ㅇㅈ 숨소리 다 자연스럽게 넣음
0:50 kkura's vocalllll
so bad
@@radwmla is you?
@@radwmla who bad?? You
it sounds like pre-recorded ver...
It is
사쿠라💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕
첫주는 항상 모든 걸그룹이고 다 ar깔려서 나와요
모든걸그룹은 아닌것같아요
스테이씨 첫주에 ar안깔던데
있지도 안까는데
엔믹스는 데뷔쇼케 때부터 라이브함ㅋ 전곡 립싱크로 데뷔쇼케한 아이즈원하고는 다름
@@아-e7k9g ㅇ
이거 ar 아닌가용?
뭐야 ar이잖아 ㅡㅡ 속았누
라이브라고 확신할수없는건 ar일경우 mr빼고 들으면 반주만 빠진거라 보컬은 남아있음
그렇기때문에 라이브인걸 확인할거면 ar을 빼보는게 라이브 입증에는 도움이됨 그럼 조금 새는소리가 그소리가 라이브
MR除去対策されてる音源かな？
Garam...semangatnya
사쿠라 옛날보다 진짜 잘한다.(mr제거)
the fact that they are ALREADY so stable although still rookie……🤩
it's pre recorded
@@slaven8914 still it’s their voice and they sing it😀
@@jakesarchieve3315 that's just means that they sing well, not that they're stable lol
It's pre recorded so thats why they're so stable
@@mirai3991 lol just prove me by watching their live stage mr removed😚
이거 사기 아님?? ㅋㅋㅋ AR 깔려있잖아 ㅋㅋㅋ 그리고 댓글들 무슨 알바임?? 너무 뻔히보여
ar 떡칠하는 게 에스파랑 다를 바 없네ㅋㅋ 아이브도 라이브는 꽝이고...4세대 걸그룹 중에선 엔믹스가 보컬 원탑이고 후에 나올 와쥐 걸그룹도 라이브 잘 하겠지ㅋ
Perfection y'all!
These aren't their live vocals fyi
@@ssc6386 well yes i know!
no
0:37 근데 그 갈색머리 누구임. 음색 개 좋당
허윤진이요
4세대 여돌 중에서 노래 제일 잘하네.. 역대급이다 ,,,, 6명 전부 메인보컬급
Ar이라서 그래요 근데 실제로도 잘할수 있을수도?
실제로 잘하면 ar깔 이유가 없지...에스파랑 같은 이유
엔믹스는 쇼케부터 전부 라이브였음
@@밍-f9l nmixx를 잊지 마세요. 그들은 첫 번째 일요일에도 항상 라이브😍😍
so stable, but they use pitch correction right?
그냥 ar인디;
It is pre recorded or not?
Pre recorded.
더쇼 앵콜로 개망했음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
First btw-
🥰
Genuine question, how do pre-recorded works? Are they recording in a studio then use it while performing???
best vocalist of 4th generation
I think nmixx better in vocal
@@merumours86 i agree ...
Can we just agree they're on if the best because best will obviously belong to three groups already
@Uaena!!! aespa?? lypdinc group
エムカでも生歌なの凄！
これARじゃないんですか？
@@アリ-u7c そうなんですか！よく知らずにコメントしてました。
これ音源だよね？
Gara-gara encore, kualitas vokal mereka diragukan.
Padahal disini jelas sekali suaranya
Kalo encore bagus, mr.removed ga usah diragukan lagi.
@@coksuna3888 makanya ga adil menilai saat encore
@@yossiehoho1777 kebalik. kalo encore nya bagus, mr removed bagus kayak gini org pasti percaya kalo live. encore kan yg bener2 cuman backtrack tanpa vocal.
@@jeannesue9461 setelah kamu dengar suara mereka disini, masih bilang suara mereka ga bagus? Ga bisa nyanyi.
Saya sendiri setelah tau sesi encore mereka kurang bagus, langsung cari mr removed nya.
Dan hasilnya ga buruk
@@yossiehoho1777 laiya pak, kebalik. Stage ginian masih bisa pake pre-recording. Tp kalo encore kan murni on the spot. Jadi bisa nilai sendiri lah yg asli yg mana
이거 보니까 여자친구가 좀 떠오른다
이거 ar이에요? 아님 라이브에요?
사전녹음 ar이용
라이브 역대급으로 잘 하네 대박
生歌と音源の区別もつかねえのか
これはどっちですか？音源かプレレコに聞こえる
The amount of autotune lmao
썸넬 있지 유나인줄 이쁘다
ar은 음원 자체를 까는게 ar이라 그건 아니고 사전녹음이네. 뭐 어디서 격하게 뛰고 온 다음에 녹음한듯 그렇게 연출한다던데
lipsync
Well there's no shame in doing so
막귀들 참 많네
これ生歌じゃないですよ。一週目は口パクですね~
MR除去だよ。口パクなら声聞こえないやつだから。
@@YuYu-mg1si この番組用に事前登録して修正した音声を流してるから聞こえるんだと思いますよ😇
@@YuYu-mg1si 完全に対策されてます🥱口パクですぅ~
@@memenomu9095 そうなんだ😳知ったかぶってしまった…笑
Most stable group of 4th gen 🙌🏼
Pre recorded
pre recorded vocal performance is the reason they are stable
These are actually stable groups
Itzy, StayC, Gidle Aespa (Coachella)
@@Jungkook_fr why u bringing other groups into this💀
Your statement was Most stable group of 4th gen when they're not i gave you examples since you don't seem to understand what stable singing is
@@Jungkook_fr + nmixx, everglow
the group with many scandals
-Garam a bully
-Sakura plastic surgery
-Chaewon can't sing, and she did plastic surgery too
-Yunjin can't sing too actually
-Kazuha no visuals and really unattractive
-Eunchae? who's her? LOL
hybe debuted the wrong person, why did he just throw gfriend away? pissed me off
What’s wrong with plastic surgery-????
@@camillashimwa7671 it's a scam because her real face isn't that pretty
@@radwmla kpop fans are so stupid. She literally admitted to having it so it doesn’t matter what she looked like before “her real face isn’t that pretty oh no🥺🥺🥺😢😢😭😭😭” it literally does not matter. How does that affect u. Does it affect her talent? Her personality? Nope.
you should get away 💅🏻💅🏻
@@radwmla most kpop idols have done plastic surgery and that's fine..how is that a reason to hate chaewon and sakura? 💀