Supreme Court chaos as Gina Miller’s lawyer has different document page numbers to that of judges
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024
- Confusion took over the hearing as Lord Pannick pointed out an interview with Jacob Rees-Mogg on the Today programme but it is in the wrong place.
The three-day hearing includes appeals on three separate legal challenges of Prime Minister Boris Johnson's plan to suspend parliament for five weeks.
Lord Pannick said the PM sought to “silence Parliament for that period because he sees Parliament as an obstacle in his political aims.”
Read More:
www.thesun.co....
From Brexit breaking news to HD movie trailers, The Sun newspaper brings you the latest news videos and explainers from the UK and around the world.
Become a Sun Subscriber and hit the bell to be the first to know
Read The Sun: www.thesun.co.uk
Like The Sun on Facebook: / thesun
Follow The Sun on Twitter: / thesun
Subscribe to The Sun on Snapchat: / 1633225139
Is this a Monty python sketch
I didn't expect the Spanish Inquisition. Nobody expects the Spanish inquisition !
Its more like a Benny hill
Erm, no.
Stop that. It's getting silly!
@@Alex-sb1rf Lets speed it up and play!!
That will teach them to not let Diane Abbott to do the printing.
Urrr urrr let me get back to you on that
What about that Member of Parliament makes you think she's involved in office admin here? Her gender or her colour?
Robert Murray 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Nice one!
@Robert Murray MPs don't do photocopying for other people
Waste of taxpayers' money.
Yes. 66 billion and rising.
A waste of taxpayers money perfectly sums up Brexit.
@@TheHelenbach who's fault is that
Spot the sun/ daily mail reader. Hint. They love talking about tax payers.
Jim Allen, you in that court? Do any better of a job? How would you do it better?
"Waste of tax payers money" is just a repeated phrase people lobe to say when they not brave enough to originate there own opinion. Enjoy getting yours from the Sun tho, makes you really independent.
so whos running the country then, our governments or gina miller ?????
Dominic Cummings
Mickey mouse
that would be "the lunatics"
Parliament, you dumbarse.
george sorros
What a joke taxpayers paying for this complete shambles
Actually, the taxpayers money has been reduced. The amount of money given to the courts have been slashed over the past 15 years, so the system is at breaking point now.
@Jeanette Howard Her companies owe millions she has no money. So some remainer is financing her. She loves being the centre of attention. Why has she dropped her Indian name? She no respect for that, but she sticks her nose where its not wanted.
@Amanda Hughes how is pushing against the closure of parliament to hide from scrutiny anti democratic
@@arniethesofa Because Parliament is openly attempting to subvert the will of the people as expressed in the 2016 referendum (ie leave the EU). If Parliament was truly trying to be representative of the will of the people, they would have jumped at the offer of a general election which would have truly given the people the obvious choices of Tory/Brexit parties to leave the EU, or Lib Dems to remain in the EU, or Labor (under Corbin) to remain under EU control in the single market and leave in name only.
@@TherealElliot spot on.
Never laughed so much. Remainers are a joke.
Lady Hale literally said at the start of this video that this happens with all these cases. It's got nothing to do with remainers being 'incompetent'
@@alexabbott6015 no it does. We all know remainers are incompetent dictators
@@gethcreator751 Do you even know what a dictator is?? And no, the head of the supreme court literally said it happens in all the cases, not just this one??
@@alexabbott6015 A LOT of these Leaving the EU cases about then?
@RockyVoyage68556_Xbox
THANK YOU! This is what I've been trying to explain. We could get a goodnight brexit deal, but it's ultimately worse than staying in the e.u.
May this continue until October 31st
Can the public start a crowd fund and sue Gina Miller for interfering within the democracy of the British public as will.... I'd love someone to raise funds and sue this woman. She's Brazilian and she's scared she won't be able to launder money out of the UK anymore. I'm sick of these people treating us like push overs. OUT OUT OUT. 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
She is not brazillian mate.
She is not Brazilian but from Guyana
GUYANA EX BROTHEL KEEPER 😇😇👍
She is from British Guyana.....and as much as I am against this using her background is pretty dim. Opposose the action not the person please. Because showing your ignorance will dissolve any intention
How is using the courts one of the three branches of governement interfering with democracy?
One might be forgiven if I was up at court for something and the solicitors paperwork was all over the place the judge would say get out
Won't happen here ! They are here to stop BREXIT the judges included 💩💩💩💩
The result of this case (whatever it may be) will not affect Brexit. It could put pressure on Boris Johnson, but that would be his own fault.
I agree... this is the Supreme court and this is so far a shambles!
You should be able to, excuse the pun, be able to use just your memory, just like the person being questioned in the courts and held accused
Who questions your hi court judges judgement? They really believe that they are supreme? Huh well well well, let one hope that God has not got a different opinion, otherwise ouch
Elites arguing with elites on how to destroy the biggest democratic election result in British history with a winning 1.6million majority is not annoying, it's disgusting. If unelected lawyers can overturn democracythen its high time we " burnt the system to ashes".
people are docile at the moment. the youth could learn to organise like hong kong. I have spent 2 months there on 2 separate holidays. the global elites require a barrage of violent and peaceful resistance over months. tactics must progress to prevent any counter force.
@Anglo Commando I refer you to tseung wan in hong Kong 😅
If brexit isn't delivered by 31st Oct every able bodied person who voted leave should travel down to London and do just that. I'll be first in line, we really should, if even half turned up it would be ample, pure Anarchy
@@williamnunn8847 I think you'll find that the "youth" didn't actually want to leave. That's why we're not rioting or whatever. It's old sods like you just writing angry messages from your armchairs that causes this mess.
I unluckily live 30mns away from Westminster. I have never ever protested or striked in my life, but as a grandfather of 6 boys who lost family members fighting for this country not to be ruled by a foreign power, nothing on earth will stop me protesting and doing whatever I can to help with civil disorder if Brexit is not delivered without a fair or no deal. Government's rarely listen unless its costing them money.
What a disgusting show of total incompetence throw it out its embarrassing
If you watched the entire hearing, the QC for the government did almost the same thing. There are thousands of papers, documents, articles that are all referenced in bundles, it is easy for anyone to make a mistake.
@@PiperTMTotalWar almost?
You don't understand the amount of documents (and version of documents) involved. This videos posted by the sun lol..not gonna be anything significant. Just comment bait for keyboard warriors.
It has nothing to do with the strength )or otherwise) of the case.
@@AA-nh9do Yes. A festival of ignorant and stupidity!
"Always trouble with the documents in these cases" How many ridiculous cases like this actually get to the Supreme Court? What a waste of time and money
hey, blame Johnson - he wanted to appeal.
Lazy (well paid) idiots. One could implement a procedure to check all documents in the court case before each session or court case starts. It could even be done electronically and very quickly, using checksums etc. and would detect ANY difference - down to a single word or letter difference, let alone page number difference. They obviously don't care, and are probably paid by the minute or second, so the longer things take, the money they all make.
I'll be honest they have 5 different documents probably sorted by different people each with potentially 500+ pages and maybe in different formats due to how they transfer it you try and do it perfectly
@@edford3354
That could easily be done on a computer, they have programs for that, it's so simple. To not have a procedure in place to make sure your documents are in order is amateurish.
@@MattCellaneous it's hardly the courts fault if the prosecution or defense give them documents that aren't in order sure maybe they could check them but if one side only has a paper copy like in this case then you can't can you
Who's financing Gina Millers multiple court cases and appeals?
It's self funding, incredible levels of advertising
Probably Blair or Soros
@@pshort4802 Blair?!? Bit random
For once it isn't Russia
The jesuits?
What a joke. Wasting more taxpayer's money.
What a “BUNDLE"
Brexiteers waste the whole economy
As opposed to the billions about to be wasted by a no deal Brexit!!!! This is money well spent!!!!!
Jeanette Howard where's you evidence
And they can't get enough of our money and they are all laughing at us
So these are the best lawyers in the UK, no wonder brexit went so well.
The best lawyers in the UK are those that have left- and good riddance !
Your funny
That's funny
Anti Brexit lawyers are useless. Best we get out of the EU!
It hasn't happened yet you idiot.
Are we going to go through this rubbish every time the government make a decision....and someone does not like it...
Is parliament going to be suspended every time Boris Johnson and his cronies don't get their own way?
Seems like it! It also seems like the supreme court is governing this country now, which is absolutely disgusting, nobody has elected these old crumblers to litigate on our behalf, and that old hag Gina Miller needs to accept that we are leaving the EU whether she likes it or not, nobody elected her to make decisions about our sovereignty either.
Fiasco
all remain supporters ,last count 11 judges on the panel, how many times will the govt be taken to court, no wonder we can't get out , the EU trying to keep us in, ex PMs, most MPs, business people, celebs,
Some lowly pleb will be sacked for embarrassing the self important gezzer in the expensive suit.
Clair Ridge 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I'm that lowly pleb in a law firm. The job of us plebs is one of significant importance
@@hatchingdraggon8073 so much for your time, perhaps you are all ready for causality
The guy in the expensive suit was once a pleb himself.
@@AppByDesign what is your responsibility to the public, is name calling of your university teaching
What a farce 😂😂😂 where is Gina Miller getting money from to finance this joke ??
Think she's putting it about in many different places
Goerge Soros
Husband works for Soros
@@garyd6421 wow, soros is such a nice guy if that's true, saving the taxpayer money.
public money
Who's bankrolling Miller? That's what people want to know.
@neil eastell No No it's her husband he is sitting behind her in the video.
She is crowd funding.
@@kevster1007 Ah, it's sweet that there are still some innocents in the world.
neil eastell The Government will pay the costs most likely considering she won.
it is self funded, sorry to take the wind out of your anti-EU sails.
How as this case been brought to court so soon yet we voted leave and nothing
The court case was based on facts
@@M896 especially the fact of the page numbers, oops they also got that wrong
Because the vote leave campain was unlawful and based off lies
@@foryou6888 Vote Leave's "inaccuracies" were not exactly photocopying errors though were they?
@@M896 neither were the vote leaves
Let's see if our judges are independent or the stooges of Brussels and vested interests.
If the judges want to be political they should be made to face election like MPs
This isn't a political issue, its a legal one. The legality of Johnsons actions have nothing to do with any political leanings
@@alexabbott6015 there is no legal issue.
The Queen is the law
@@gethcreator751 No, Parliament is Sovereign at the Queens prerogative. There's also a conflict of interest if the Queen only gets advice from her government when its her government who wants the power to prorogue parliament. Definitely a constitutional grey area...
John Silverton THEY ARE PART OF THE NWO MACHINE!!!!!WE SIMPLY CANNOT WIN????THERE IS NO JUSTICE???EVIL SEEMS TO BE WINNING!!!!!!!
*"Great" Britain is not a clown it's the entire circus*
000236 000236 only the leftists
Only labour
000236 000236 A three ring circus!
What about Major, peroqued Parliament for much longer in Oder to cover the cash for questions scandal, hope they will ask him about that
As an employer
i would sack the bloody lot of em
If anybody was told to do something by their employer and 3 years later it's still not been done, they would be sacked long ago. How do these politicians get away with it !
I take it by that, you're no longer going to pay tax then ?
Like me.
Like we all should.
@@millomweb like I get a choice
Be careful they may think your poaching for something
@@LordLorenzo834 We all get a _choice_ !
This always happens, eh? 1850 quid a day plus copying, phones, lettes, interviews, 'taking instructions', 'associates' etc: all paid by the friggin' Taxpayer.
A.M. Fortas nope
Court proceedings are paid for by the people taking part in the case. Not by the taxpayers.
Raky 2427 I think he is a fool
Tommys out yesssssss
LOL...what a farce!
Her husband will want his money back
her husband isnt paying for it
Which husband
This probably worked in Scotland and they just agreed with the remoaners
@Will just like your reply lazy with sarcasm low wit like your intelligence
if it was us in court it would be throne out for wasting the courts time ???
gina miller cannot count anyway, as 17.4 is more than 16, putrid gina loves all this and the guardian reporters are in heat for this feeble case,ha ha
What a total embarrassment
Page 1 billion, I’m sure you must have it. 🤡
LMAO
Knowing Gina millers, it'll be page 5 & 3/4
Lol it's a joke
Lmfaoovl, that is the first page kind sir. Lmao
Courts deciding political matters. How very European.
Sorry Your a shambles. Case dismissed. Get out.
I'm sorry your comment is also incorrectly written, dismissed.
@@tobywenman4769 Knob.
"A lawyer can steal more with his briefcase than a hundred men with guns."
A. Capone
Raymond Cooper Ah the late, great murderous mafioso. A fantastic and inspirational quote indeed!
What is going on here? are they making this up as they go?? PATHETIC!
They have no right to do this! Such muppets I swear what a waste of time
If Henry VIII were around, every one of these clowns would be on the block.
nobility gets the block, common criminals like these get the rope, the slow tyburn "jig "
Along with monks and women. Good old Henry. Salt of the earth
@@farmerned6
Hang on! (pun intended) what about the old 'hanging, drawing and quartering' ... that special punishment reserved for traitors?
We could bring that back, it would be a good way to ensure that the wishes of the majority were respected ... 😂
@@YabbaDadADo He definitely had the solution to those 30 year old harassment claims.
.... How very sackable ...
Some of these people need to resign, they are getting too old for this
its like the house of lords waste of space
@@bigal3617 they've expertise in law making, so that it's not waste of space
@@kristofszecsi4598 not seeing much 'expertise' in this video
They are auto retired once they reach 65.
I just hope Miller gets saddled with all the costs! Who the heck is she anyway ?
One word “clowns” 😂😂
Joke the lot of you !!! 17.4 million votes ? You haven’t lost them have you ????
LOL....loved that comment!
It's been made perfectly clear that this case is independent from brexit
@@tobywenman4769 lol you seriously believe that? haha
@@charg1nmalaz0r51 what does suspending parliament have to do with brexit? If you believe suspending parliament will affect brexit in any way then it should not have been suspended, the pm should not be able to suspend parliament on a whim for his own political gain. If the choices parliament makes when they're allowed to vote doesn't please you then they are other issues.
Jacqui Smith would have lol...
Classic this Gina! This will be your legacy....disorganised desperation 🤗
I hope the world isn't watching this debacle
It’s pretty much a global phenomenon at the moment, a regrettable process but at least we’re finally starting to get to grips with these subversive scoundrels
This is most likely not to be shown on BBC news, as it makes a mockery of the Remain cause again.
we are locked in iron chains at the moment. like the grunts of the death knight in the 3D shooter quake. iron chains. iron chains!
They are unfortunately, it's comparable to the Trump delusion syndrome.
You must have been in a coma for the last three years.
This farce is as good an example as any as to why no one should take a case to court.
A friend of mine(a Cambridge 1st graduate) was in a jury and while by law he was not allowed to give me any details - he told that that the whole thing was an awful experience and told me to avoid jury service at all costs.
Ah yes, I'll take heed of your comment and if I'm ever raped I'll not bother going to court. Thanks for the heads up
@@Slarti It is indeed a complete waste of time.
@@noahhughes2501 I think his point is that a number of cases that seem to be brought are ridiculous. Obviously cases involving offences against the person as you describe must be tried.
@@mmcfarlane001 we do pay for courts for a reason. without them we couldn't appeal unwanted government decisions, wrongful imprisonment or sue etc, etc. It's on the same level as our healthcare; completely indispensable
Chuck them out documents incorect
They should but they won't the supreme court is as corrupt as the EU
Wow these people must have nothing of true value in their lives to sit there and deal with that......And for what exactly? To show the PM how he was wrong? At least the PM is trying to restore some form of order in Paliament.
🤣very professional🤣.
shambles -just about sums up the substance of this case .-should be thrown out now
@@normanleighton6526 If the case had no substance, it would have been thrown out at lower levels of the Judiciary...
@@alexabbott6015 -it already has been under english law
@@normanleighton6526 Yeah and we live in a union with Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales therefore it gets to go to the supreme court...
@@alexabbott6015 -yeah ,for a final ruling after an appeal by Miller and a referral from Edinburgh after they reached a different decision .
It seems that if you are funded or loaded you can overturn a countries government rules(well the UK anyway). What the hell is happening !! Gina Miller is really Nadira Singh.
Theyre using tv and radio interviews as evidence. The world has truly gone mad 🙄🙄🙄
I think someone got a night visit from Jimmy McGill.
Brilliant👍🏼🤣
Denis Siberian brilliant comment.
Denis Siberian Love it! 🤣😂🤣 That’s very clever! 👏👏👏
Kinky
So they spent a couple of minutes organising the documents. Hardly chaotic.
Be gone ye voice of reason. This here be the internet.
Absolutely useless...and you are all wasting your time 🤣
If I were the judge I would just give Gina Miller a 30 years prison sentence for attempting to disrupt democracy.....throw her behind bars!!!.
That's why you're not a judge. Because you clearly don't respect the rule of law in the UK.
Gina Miller and her cronies all over. A JOKE.
I count ten judges sat around that table! how absurd, its like the twenty admirals sat at the Royal navy desk whilst we have one ship at sea. All whilst the justice system is under enormous pressure and these officials are being used for this nonsense. The should be prosecuting real cases
Gina Millers expression at 3:35 is priceless. All that money and they can't even supply digital copies on a flash drive that are all the same....ha.ha.ha
how does someone like Gina Miller have so much sway over the UK legal System? Are the Pro-EU establishment backing her?
@Movenpick Eurodivers tell that to the media soyboy...
They're trying to penalise boris for trying to do his job
How long will it take to solve this Brexit mess before Parliament is burned to the ground.
Its not parliament though isit. Its boris johnson and this stupid brexit mess. Just scrap the entire thing
not long i hope
@@robinvanpersie2219 It's Boris Johnson and Brexit? did Boris call for the referendum or accuse himself of illegality? The UK voted to leave the EU...if anything it's the leftists causing all the chaos.
Think your just saying random words and hoping for idiots to agree lol
@@robinvanpersie2219 and whats remains plan. Eu is open that eu aims to abolish uk and other member states by dissolving them into a single state of europe as demanded over the weekend by crazy hardline euro nationalist verhofstadt. So whats remainers plan to avoid that?
Why is the Judge apologising for the mix up with the paper work, I watched for quite a while until I lost my patience, and turned off, I believe after the that shambles I would have dismissed the case, and tell them to reapply when their mess is sorted out. If I was sitting on this case, also as it is not a Law case but Political it,s out of their jurisdiction.
Why do the judges not get up and walk out and tell miller and her snob lawyer to come back when they can get their act together
This is an indictment as to her illegal claims. It's karma.
Time for we the people to sort it out Gina.
It's gina Miller legal team tactic for delaying or prolong the proceedings of the SC 😎😎.
nonsense, it is simply inefficient and probably untrained clerks. Which is ludicrous.
@@julietsolomon2444 sounds like it is but who knows? 😎😎
I'm sick of gina Miller someone should take her to court for preventing the will of the people.
Oh dear or dear.. they've got their handles all mixed up and the numbers, what a joke these lot are, we have 19...but we haven't got others...it's laughable...
Total shambles 🤦♂️
God if this is what happens in the legal system heaven help us.....!!!! This is really ridiculous.......what a joke. Gina hot under the collar!!
Anything involving Gina Miller is a FARCE 😂😂😂😂😂
What time do they say "crash out" and " fall off a bridge"?
ASAP
just after cliff edge......but before they didnt know what they voted for...
@andy pandy..who bothers voting for anything in Britain ? it,s a mugs game different people different parties all just run by the same controllers for their own gains and wealth.When will people ever learn
arrogant, egoistical disgraceful Miller looks frustrated
Stop all the clocks, cut off the telephone.
Prevent the dog from barking with a juicy bone,
Silence the pianos and with muffled drum
Bring out the coffin, let the mourners come.
democracy has died, britain is dead
How appropriate that you should quote Auden's satire on the death of a dictator (albeit with your own last line).
@@AlexWent I hit the spot sometimes thnx
@feelings Are Not Arguments The keystone of British government is called the Westminster system. Where each arm of government is independent of the other. The Police the judicial system and the political branch cannot interfere with each other. For any court to sit in judgement of political manoeuvring is a betrayal of democracy because the magistrates are not elected and have no mandate
Another frigging shambles
Jesus they can't even get the page numbers right, we are doomed!
the entire premise of the legal challenge seems to be Gina Millers lawyers are mind readers and KNOW what Boris was thinking when he prorogued parliament. D:
@Movenpick Eurodivers court of law you need proof
Hahahahahahaha
So chaotic I can hardly believe it wow
Surely, any other case would have been thrown out of court, or at least deferred due to the incompetence of the plaintiff's legal representative.
Finally something newsworthy from The Sun!
I actually watched it. There was no "chaos". The judges hadn't opened their envelopes containing the additional documents and this was sorted in no time.
She’s a disgrace attacking a democratic decision
Guess the printer was a Brexiter perhaps!
WHO paying to do this chaos in UK..Where are MI5 & MI6..
Ha ha the 'Supreme' Court is having a bit of bother and the 'bother' is the inability to read from the same page - Brexit personified lol.
This explains the confusion over Brexit. If you turn to the page regarding the referendum vote you will see we voted "leave".
Lol
Who the hell is paying for this crowd?
Why’s the Supreme Court a single eye ??
It was far from "chaos".
They solved the issue in no time at all and got straight back to the matter at hand.
Can we not take politicians to court for what they're doing to the people of the uk????
COMPLETE AND UTTER SHAMBLES !!!!
What a mess, and this is the highest court in the land. This case should be thrown out.. It certainly would if the shoe was on the other foot.
Given the sheer volume of documents involved and in various formats, together with the speed this had to be put together, things like this are likely to happen. It's an unprecedented complex case, can't wait to hear what the Court thinks of the arguments - that's what's going to count.
sums it all up!
This not defending the Remainer's or Parliament but dragging the Court's through the MUD in spectacular fashion at least if they are BIAS it will be for the World to See!!