English DNA: The Genetic (DNA) History of England

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 сен 2024
  • Please support this channel on Patreon: / historydecoded
    Please donate through PayPal using this link: www.paypal.com... - you can also send money through PayPal straight to chdecoded@gmail.com if you don’t want to use the link.
    Please Buy Me a Coffee: www.buymeacoff...
    Subscribe to Celtic History Decoded: / @celtichistorydecoded
    Anglo-Saxon, Celtic or Spanish? The Genetic (DNA) History of England
    What’s the genetic history of England? An Oxford study from 2006 found that most people from England are mainly descendants from ancient Spanish tribes from the Bay of Biscay who settled in ancient Britain around 6-7,000 years ago. In England, according to this study, around 64 per cent of people are descended from these tribes, outnumbering the descendants of Anglo-Saxons by about three to one. In Scotland, about 73 per cent are descended from these tribes, with 83 per cent in Wales.
    Professor Bryan Sykes, the late professor of Human Genetics are Oxford University, said that: "About 6,000 years ago Iberians developed ocean-going boats that enabled them to push up the Channel. Before they arrived, there were some human inhabitants of Britain but only a few thousand in number. These people were later subsumed into a larger Celtic tribe... The majority of people in the British Isles are actually descended from the Spanish." Sykes added that the "the overlay of Vikings, Saxons and so on is 20 per cent at most. That's even in those parts of England that are nearest to the Continent," he said. "The only exception is Orkney and Shetland, where roughly 40 per cent are of Viking ancestry."
    Thus, according to this study, the majority of the people in England are descendants of ancient Iberian tribes, but can we call these people Celts? Well, on first thought, no we can’t, as a Celt is often defined as someone who speaks a Celtic language, and the Celtic languages didn’t develop this early. However, on second thought, these ancient settlers of Britain potentially began speaking the Proto-Celtic language soon after they settled in Britain, and could be considered a proto-Celtic people.
    Barry Cunliffe, the Emeritus Professor of European Archaeology at Oxford, in his book The Ancient Celts, argues that the Proto-Celtic language could have developed thousands of years earlier than initially thought in ancient Britain as a lingua-franca or trading language that linked the Atlantic Zone sometime between 5500-2800 BC.
    Sources:
    Schiffels, S., Haak, W., Paajanen, P. et al. Iron Age and Anglo-Saxon genomes from East England reveal British migration history. Nat Commun 7, 10408 (2016). doi.org/10.103...
    Settlers: Genetics, Geography and the Peopling of Britain - Oxford University Museum of Natural History - www.oum.ox.ac.u...
    Oxford University Museum of Natural History - Genetic Ancestry and the People of the British Isles • Genetic Ancestry and t...
    University of Oxford - Who do you think you really are? A genetic map of the British Isles www.ox.ac.uk/n...
    University of Oxford - People of the British Isles - Population Genetics and Facial Genetics www.peopleofth... www.peopleofth...
    Scotsman - We're nearly all Celts under the skin We're nearly all Celts under the skin | The Scotsman
    The Independent - Celts descended from Spanish fishermen, study finds Celts descended from Spanish fishermen, study finds | The Independent | The Independent
    Patterson N. et al. Large-scale migration into Britain during the Middle to Late Bronze Age. Nature. 2022 Jan;601(7894):588-594. doi: 10.1038/s41586-021-04287-4. Epub 2021 Dec 22. PMID: 34937049; PMCID: PMC8889665. Large-Scale Migration into Britain During the Middle to Late Bronze Age - PMC (nih.gov)
    Barry Cunliffe (2018) - The Ancient Celts (Second Edition) (Oxford University Press)
    Creative Commons Imagery:
    Ziko-C en.wikipedia.o... Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported, 2.5 Generic, 2.0 Generic and 1.0 Generic license creativecommon...
    GPinkerton Notuncurious commons.wikime... Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license. creativecommon...
    Tursclan Xoil commons.wikime... Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license. creativecommon...
    #history #england #dna

Комментарии • 499

  • @celtichistorydecoded
    @celtichistorydecoded  2 года назад +12

    Please let me know your thoughts below...

    • @MAKDÁVID-KRIŽ
      @MAKDÁVID-KRIŽ 2 года назад +1

      GaL moved between PortuGaL,BenGaL and MonGolia and such have connected Iberian peninsula with CaucaSIAN Iberian Kingdom and Siberia.
      Spanish are more of Moors and Carthegean then ManGaL.

    • @MAKDÁVID-KRIŽ
      @MAKDÁVID-KRIŽ 2 года назад +1

      I can’t describe my gratitude to you and Scottish and Gælic people for all the help that indirectly have helped explain many aspects of Hungarian culture and language where Kelet in my language is word used for East for example being similar word to Celtic or the reason why my genetics or of my wife has so many Gælic connections even do being native to Carpathian basin for over 4000 years.
      Orosz as we call Russian is just another of many mysterious you helped me to solve since even do O as Ó can mean as being old Rosz(Ros) and Rus I could bridge or explain how came Hungarian use a different word till I was helped to realise that Ros is actually a Gælic Clan name hence Ó’Rosz is reference to once Rus Gælic identity before adopting a Indo-Iranian language and Orthodox.
      The very same name could be connected to ETRUSCAN where some Italian researchers have connected Hungarians to EtRUSCan while some traced they Italian genetics back to HunGerian which didn’t made any sense since we trace no connection to Roman groups nor Greeks but simply Scythian Hun-Han descendant which again could be explained only due to GaL,GauL,Gælic genetics and identity as Scythian being related to Scothian h Hence why all this various GaL groups appears throughout my genetics including Scordisci who I never have even heard off.Hence after connecting the dots I understood why Rossini is another common name amongst Italians since Ros-Sini(Soni) or Ros Son Is another of Gælic name and another point that proves how huge Gælic tribal alliance actually was since for me it was a surprise to see that my Scythian descendant which is claimed to be a Iranian group turned out to be actually a Gælic in its entirety from my side.
      So thank you very much for I couldn’t figure out the Nostradamus Summer of 1999 quatrain regarding the awakening of King of MonGol meaning ManGaL or many other things without your help and insights.
      Keep up the good work.

    • @CENTRIX4
      @CENTRIX4 2 года назад +2

      R1b L21 research paper published February 2018.
      Original mutation Black Forest Southern Bavarian Alps in Germany.
      R1b sub-clades migrated in different directions from this location.
      Information in video i outdated refer to paper published in February 2018 for correct information.
      ====
      Different eras of migration into Britain and Ireland.
      Described is one of the first waves of R1b migration into Britain.
      The core R1b population n Britain and Ireland Original mutation Black Forest Southern Bavarian Alps in Germany.
      ====
      Proto Indo European language tree published approximately 8 years ago then amendment made using Monte Carlo Method of Statistical Analysis.
      Language divergence of Proto Indo European language Tree accurate to more than 4000 years ago.
      Information about Celtic languages in video is incorrect.
      ====

    • @MAKDÁVID-KRIŽ
      @MAKDÁVID-KRIŽ 2 года назад

      @@CENTRIX4 That is actually the point for Deutsch and Dutch all as HunGerian as Ger Man in form of UnGar like others UGar ,HonGRI,VenGRI,WanGER…and we are MacAr,MakAr,MagYar,MadJar,Mađar…ManGaL so there is no Indo nor Greeko-Evropean language or people on our side of Scythian-Scothian land for it didn’t exist and doesn’t exists.
      SLav -SLöwen are simply identity lost Gælic people who speak a Indo-Iranian language and have a Greeko-Jewish Conversion or while Western have a Roman .
      SakSon is not a Deutsch grammar for if it would have been they would have called themselves Son Von Sak but they haven’t because they where not Deutsch-Dutch especially since they traced a ÆtELstan origins which we call ETELKÖZ and is a land between Carpathian basin and Ural where the identity was and is well known compared to West which obviously is not .
      Saka where Scythians who built CONSTANTA and inhabited in CONSTANTLY long before CONSTANTHYNE was born or CONSTANTHynople was built and it was Saka who has established Hindu-Kush ISTANI culture and empire and Yakutsk or Sakastan who still call themselves as such where Saka like MacAr or Jack-Jak has the same root word of AC-AK which in my language as Mak means Acorn which is Ac Corn in English from the tree Oak a Hungarian word where Ó meaning Old AK tree from which Ak-Ac corn comes from including the Mac-Mak.

    • @rns7426
      @rns7426 Год назад +2

      I’ve always thought that when a DNA test read Scottish, Irish, Welsh, and English that it was all Celtic.
      I don’t believe the whole Anglo-Saxon genocide diatribe. That’s just an impossibility.
      The Brythonic celts easily adapted to Roman rule and culture and just as easily adapted to Anglo-Saxon rule and culture.

  • @ines_ramos
    @ines_ramos Год назад +106

    Happy to see a channel in English that knows about the important Celtic heritage in northwestern Spain. 💚 We're so often forgotten by other Celtic nations.

    • @celtichistorydecoded
      @celtichistorydecoded  Год назад +7

      Thanks Inés

    • @RS-ln3ns
      @RS-ln3ns Год назад +9

      @roberto lang SPANISH PEOPLE ARE IBERIANS. WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT ? THEY'RE MORE IBERIAN THAN ANYONE ELSE IN THE WORLD.

    • @diaglas93
      @diaglas93 Год назад +1

      pleasee stopp you are not celts you are iberians stop please

    • @RS-ln3ns
      @RS-ln3ns Год назад

      NORTHERN SPANIARDS ARE CELTS + IBERIANS, WHETHER YOU LIKE IT OR NOT. ACCORDING TO PROFESSOR BRYAN SYKES, THE CELTS FROM THE BRITISH ISLES, ORIGINATE FROM NORTHERN SPAIN AND THEY DO LOOK EXACTLY ALIKE.

    • @diaglas93
      @diaglas93 Год назад +1

      @roberto lang you can cry! we have nothing in common with you Iberian boy! i m brythonic and gaelic not Eduardo los tacos dos gaspacho

  • @Survivethejive
    @Survivethejive 2 года назад +40

    2006 is stone age when it comes to genetic science. The Sykes study was very crude and just looks at uniparental markers. It is completely debunked. Just look at studies since 2015 to understand ancient genetics.
    Cunliffe's theory doesn't hold water since the spread of Celt material culture begins in central Europe. The POBI study didn't actually use ancient samples to determine the Anglo-Saxon ancestry while the 2016 one from nature did, but only ten samples so wasn't as conclusive as the new one from this week which has hundreds of samples including 80 Anglo-Saxon skeletons.
    The new paper is the only one you need to refer to for this

    • @christianwithers7335
      @christianwithers7335 10 месяцев назад +1

      These channels are wildly inaccurate and spread lies. Watch Survive the Jive for true SCIENTIFIC research analysis

    • @user-cn8cz3qz6z
      @user-cn8cz3qz6z 2 месяца назад +1

      This 2006 study is non-sense as we all know the modern British population arrived with the Bell-Beakers 4500 years ago, not 6000 years ago from Spaniards. However, the overall point is correct that English people are majority Celtic by blood. The most recent study that pro-Germanics love to quote even supports this, as it flatly states Anglo-Saxon admixture caps at 45% in east Anglia, signifying that every region is still majority pre-Anglo-Saxon (ie Brythonic Celtic).

  • @kk-ei5zz
    @kk-ei5zz Год назад +24

    English born, but with Scottish, Welsh, Irish and Spanish grandparents!

    • @mrjw6701
      @mrjw6701 Год назад +4

      That’s a great mix 👍

    • @kk-ei5zz
      @kk-ei5zz 4 месяца назад

      @@ChristianPatriarchy u so smart

    • @Angelcynn_2001
      @Angelcynn_2001 7 дней назад

      English is an ethnicity, not nationality

  • @angusarmstrong6526
    @angusarmstrong6526 Год назад +20

    The latest studies show a 90% replacement by the belbeekers during the bronze age

    • @marineta8360
      @marineta8360 Год назад

      The belbeeker culture originated in the south of the Iberian peninsula

    • @angusarmstrong6526
      @angusarmstrong6526 Год назад +6

      @@marineta8360 sources?

    • @saguntum-iberian-greekkons7014
      @saguntum-iberian-greekkons7014 3 месяца назад

      That was mainly male replacement. As they were very horny they mated up with lot of local girls, even with the Basques

  • @joanofarcxxi
    @joanofarcxxi 7 месяцев назад +5

    I am Portuguese born and raised in Portugal. We have to this day strong Celtic traditions and ceremonies still in certain villages and we speak Gallego which has its origin in Gaelic, or vice versa. My maternal grandparents and my mom spoke Gallego.

  • @biliusmaximus9510
    @biliusmaximus9510 Год назад +11

    Everytime i hear this guy i feel like he's going to headbutt me.

    • @ryankelly3411
      @ryankelly3411 10 месяцев назад +2

      he might thats how we roll

    • @47nrubreddew
      @47nrubreddew 6 месяцев назад

      🤣🤣

    • @ryanhanna1375
      @ryanhanna1375 4 месяца назад +2

      Highlander is a great movie.

    • @bastian9693
      @bastian9693 Месяц назад

      It’s sorta hard to understand what he’s saying lol

  • @friendlysperg1372
    @friendlysperg1372 2 года назад +14

    The Earliest modern humans to inhabit Britain were the Western Hunter Gatherers (WHG) who first came after the ice age glaciers receded north and exposed the land. They lived in Britain through the Mesolithic until the Neolithic when Farmers carrying ancestry from Anatolia spread through Europe into Britain (It wouldn't have been an island yet), and created a new Race of people of part WHG ancestry and part Anatolian Ancestry called the Early European Farmers (EEF). Their reign in Britain was more short lived than their predecessors because they only lived here for about 1500 years before around 90% of their ancestry was replaced by the First ever wave of Indo-Europeans from the Lower-Rhine, which also marked the start of the Bronze Age.
    It should be noted as this point that every subsequent migration to genetically effect Britons were just later waves of these same Indo-Europeans and came largely from the same Area, meaning we are still today very genetically similar to the people who lived here 4500 years ago.
    After this first wave of IO people, there was a minor influx of a central European people likely originating from the Hallstatt culture, who would leave a limited genetic impact but largely effect the culture by importing Celtic language/culture. The Roman period came next leaving no significant genetic lineage. Finally in the 5th century the Germanic people settled, largely coming from the area in and around the Jutland peninsula (Angles, Jutes, Saxons, Frisii) who at first caused Significant ancestral replacement in the South/East, but since then internal migration within Britain has resulted in a more distributed proportion of that Ancestry.
    Today English people trace their Ethnogenesis to the Anglo-Saxons, who emerged from the fusion of three ancestral components, Celtic Britons, Germanic Tribes, and (to a lesser degree) French-like people. All of whom are Indo-European descended North-west Europeans.

    • @jcoker423
      @jcoker423 4 месяца назад

      Thank God someone knows what they are talking about. BTW by 'French-like' I assume you mean Franks.

  • @internetenjoyer1044
    @internetenjoyer1044 2 года назад +19

    i think, aside from the details and the wrangling about terms like saxon and celt (i mean to be fair we havent had a celtic or saxon culture in britain for a millenium), that the natives of the British Isles are more alike than unalike. And that to me, as someone with Irish, Scots, English and Welsh in me, and a proud unionist, is encouraging

  • @ChadwickTree
    @ChadwickTree Год назад +12

    im actually Basque and Galician funnily enough and they are very different indeed. Both in looks and culture but I do think they have some ancient connection seemingly. MY hapalog groups are both "celtic" and I feel spiritually Celtic ...somehow a DNA test also have me alot of celtic genetic marker results. I definitely appreciate the mentions my understanding also that it was a kind of round about through history in the atlantic. Iberian tribes then inturn developed celtic cultures back in their lands that far back aswell. Im definitely partial to the idea that the Atlantic coast is Celtic

    • @asturiasceltic3183
      @asturiasceltic3183 Год назад +7

      I think they look very similar but Basque males faces tend to be more robust with thicker bones in the face and Galicians, Asturians have daintier faces. Basques can have a squarish chin while Galicians and Asturians are more oval. They have the same face but Basque guys look stronger.

    • @ChadwickTree
      @ChadwickTree Год назад +1

      @roberto lang Im just stating the differences in my cultural upbringing with grandparents from the different regions , i know nothing about genetics. What i stated is my lived truth only i wouldnt be suprised if they are connected/similar or the same genetically or in some ancient context

    • @MiloManning05
      @MiloManning05 Год назад +2

      @Jack Birdie Irish look the most basque

    • @RS-ln3ns
      @RS-ln3ns Год назад +3

      @@MiloManning05 THAT'S VERY TRUE.

    • @dangercat9188
      @dangercat9188 Год назад +2

      This may be off topic but hear me out. So I'm Hispanic American and I took two DNA tests like 2 years ago because I was bored and curious lol but I found out that I have some Scottish and Welsh and my Spanish dna was mainly northern around the Asturias and Galicia region. But it makes sense because my grandad from my pops side was from Galicia (idk where exactly though) and my grandma from my mom's side was from the basque area. I've always loved celtic culture and music and even the food (lamb stew 😋) so is that the reason why I'm into that? Of course I'm not gonna ignore my African native dna but when speaking of Europe in specific, that's what I got. I got some Italian, French, Portuguese, Danish and Swedish too (idk why scandinavia is there but it's like 3% so that's interesting).

  • @lyncourt1
    @lyncourt1 8 месяцев назад +3

    This explains why my Y DNA reflects a Spanish component. I'm American, and my family heritage is 1/2 English, 1/4 Scottish and 1/4 German. Thank you for this very interesting bit of information!

    • @ramadamming8498
      @ramadamming8498 3 месяца назад +1

      But within all those are many varied genetic signatures. DNA tests online are also very general and you can get different results with two tests or different companies. English is largely, Briton, West Germanic and Gaulish genetics, Scottish is largely Gael, Norse and also Lowland West Germanic, German is . . . .where to start with that one ! There are vast differences between southern Germany, Western, Northern
      and Eastern. Eg Eastern will have a lot of Slavic genetics, and so on .. .

    • @lyncourt1
      @lyncourt1 3 месяца назад +1

      @@ramadamming8498 Thank you so much for your comment. I find it all incredibly interesting! 🙂

  • @VoiceAcrossTheField
    @VoiceAcrossTheField Год назад +3

    Great information !

  • @ShireTommy_1916_Somme-Mametz
    @ShireTommy_1916_Somme-Mametz 2 года назад +15

    My dad is English, my mam is Welsh so I am Anglo-Saxon and Briton.
    Maybe Norse or Iberian too.

    • @noahtylerpritchett2682
      @noahtylerpritchett2682 Год назад +1

      Why do you say "mam" instead of mom or mum

    • @ShireTommy_1916_Somme-Mametz
      @ShireTommy_1916_Somme-Mametz Год назад +2

      @@noahtylerpritchett2682 mam is the Welsh accent

    • @malcolmstead272
      @malcolmstead272 Год назад +4

      @@ShireTommy_1916_Somme-Mametz We in Northumberland say mam.

    • @ShireTommy_1916_Somme-Mametz
      @ShireTommy_1916_Somme-Mametz Год назад +1

      @@malcolmstead272 Northumberland kept most of its Briton blood and dialect as they were only subjugated by the Germanic tribes, not removed.

    • @AmericansMarryCousins
      @AmericansMarryCousins Год назад +6

      Even if both your parents were english youd stil only have a minority of anglo saxon dna and a majority of native dna. English have at maximum 40% anglo saxo dna pe person but most are actually 20% or lower anglo saxon dna, in certain areas its not even 5% average

  • @MEANASSJAMSTER
    @MEANASSJAMSTER Год назад +3

    I think that 50 generations has created a wide and varied mixture... - especially after the railways came and then the airports ...until widespread travel it was possible to tell a Liverpool face from a Manchester face... - same faces now have transport and live randomly anywhere...

  • @davidhookway514
    @davidhookway514 Год назад +3

    I am similar to others on here.- English, Irish, French. - The Immigrants from approximately 1948 ,building up to today were absolutely not needed, and has always been a Political Agenda.

  • @TyrSkyFatherOfTheGods
    @TyrSkyFatherOfTheGods Год назад +9

    Wow! Just last weekend I checked my 23 & Me profile, and was shocked to discover that my paternal haplogroup has been reclassified as R-M167. The haplogroup has its origins in the Pyrenees Mountains of the Spanish-French border. It is most prevalent among Catalonian and Aragonese men, according to Wikipedia. Here's the perplexing part. My father's male lineage can be traced back to 1315 in Staffordshire, England; and 23 & Me classifies me as 94% British and 5% other Northern European.

    • @celtichistorydecoded
      @celtichistorydecoded  Год назад +2

      Fascinating, thank you

    • @michaelcandido2824
      @michaelcandido2824 Год назад +1

      Yea you got to go back 6000 yrs to make that connection to the pyrenees if you have t had a Spanish member since.

    • @johnpatrick5307
      @johnpatrick5307 Год назад

      There was a mass migration to Britain by Early European farmers, about 1000BC, replacing Beaker people and introducing Welsh (See: mass Migration to Britain in Late Bronze Age).
      Sounds like your father is descended from them.

    • @michaelcandido2824
      @michaelcandido2824 Год назад +1

      @roberto lang Anglo saxons she’s a much later wave then the celts but all of them remain imbedded in the dna

    • @TyrSkyFatherOfTheGods
      @TyrSkyFatherOfTheGods Год назад

      @@michaelcandido2824 Videos like this helped me discover possible routes of migration along the coasts. Our common ancestors were a lot more mobile than I once believed; whether Anglo-Saxon, Celt, or a blend of both.

  • @frankmitchell3594
    @frankmitchell3594 Год назад +5

    Would this connect the Megalith builders in Iberia with the Megalith builders in Orkney, the Hebrides and southern England?

    • @jcoker423
      @jcoker423 4 месяца назад +1

      First Farmers

    • @padraigmaclochlainn8866
      @padraigmaclochlainn8866 2 месяца назад

      Yeah but they weren't Celts, Celts ended up replacing them through disease and interbreeding

  • @pelinalwhitestrake8195
    @pelinalwhitestrake8195 5 месяцев назад +3

    The best way i was told on what describes the UK is that its Celto-Germanic since its a mix of both cultures and ethnicities

    • @michaelking1091
      @michaelking1091 26 дней назад

      Pretty sure there’s splashes of Latin diluted in there also.

    • @johnbrereton5229
      @johnbrereton5229 12 дней назад +1

      ​@@michaelking1091
      No there is no Latin, only in the language not in the dna.

    • @michaelking1091
      @michaelking1091 11 дней назад

      @@johnbrereton5229 yes there is. They can be called other things like proto Italians , but Latin is used synonymous for that group. Etruscans and Greeks in Italy would have been a separate group

    • @johnbrereton5229
      @johnbrereton5229 11 дней назад

      @@michaelking1091
      The original commentator was talking about English genetics, not Italian. Therefore I think his description of Celtic/Germanic is quite accurate. Your comment claimed their was Latin dna present too, but there isnt, the Romans left no DNA in England only their language.

    • @michaelking1091
      @michaelking1091 10 дней назад

      @@johnbrereton5229 there is. It’s not as prominent but it’s diluted. Plenty of Latins stayed behind following the “Roman withdrawal of Britain”. It shows up in both Brit’s and French genetics (albeit not as prominent as Germanic and Celt) Alan Wilson has some good scholarship on this worth looking into.

  • @nothinginterestinghappens3819
    @nothinginterestinghappens3819 Год назад +6

    Were these Iberians that migrated more similar to the Basque, Portuguese or Spanish and is there any relation to the Vettones?

    • @Jfidkxidksi
      @Jfidkxidksi Год назад +1

      Galicians and north Portugal

    • @albanianboss2342
      @albanianboss2342 Год назад +1

      it's just that from the south of portugal to the north of scotland the populations have a common celtic genetics and the rest of france, (except alsace and the neighboring regions) are all of 50 or 60% celtic stock . Spain as well as Portugal 40 to 60% and England is easily 60-70% Celtic
      it is the Celtic world as influential as other large ethnic groups in Europe such as the Slavs or the Germans
      I even think that English (the most spoken language in the world) is somehow a little Celtic language

    • @MiloManning05
      @MiloManning05 Год назад +1

      Basque

  • @GuerillaTVChannel
    @GuerillaTVChannel Год назад +4

    What’s the genetics of the North of England

  • @VeritasIncrebresco
    @VeritasIncrebresco Год назад +5

    Gentlemen, don't skip leg day. Or any day for that matter.

    • @elwolf8536
      @elwolf8536 Год назад

      Trouble is I'm skipping everyday at the moment 🙃

  • @EmisoraRadioPatio
    @EmisoraRadioPatio Месяц назад

    Wow this was quite the surprise

  • @kevingriffin1376
    @kevingriffin1376 Год назад +12

    If we use Y DNA to provide a history of the population of Britain (Ireland downstream of Britain) it strongly supports a near total replacement of stone age Britons by middle Bronze Age Indo-Europeans. That works well with the Indo-European language (call it Q-Celtic) arriving in Britain at that time. P-Celtic arrived with the late Bronze Age migration replacing Q-Celtic in most of Britain (pretty much the same territory later quickly overtaken by Anglos).

    • @johnpatrick5307
      @johnpatrick5307 Год назад +1

      True - but the Anatolians made a comeback, replacing the Indo-Europeans in Britain.

    • @jackieblue1267
      @jackieblue1267 8 месяцев назад +2

      @@johnpatrick5307 No they didn't. I've had this conversation with you on other videos about dna studies.

  • @todobienrico
    @todobienrico Год назад +3

    The Celts are not as ubiquitous as you want to believe. each land has its history, and its prehistory, with its natives. And since the environment shapes the genetics of the inhabitants, it is stupid to think that geographical areas so remote and isolated have exactly the same inhabitants or natives. It contradicts the very theory of evolution.
    So no, the natives of the Iberian Peninsula have a certain physical appearance, and the natives of the British Isles had a different physical appearance.

  • @albert21able
    @albert21able Год назад +3

    The farmers who built Stonehenge were 90% replaced by the Beaker People from the Lower Rhineland, The Celts came later

    • @MiloManning05
      @MiloManning05 Год назад +2

      In England

    • @jackieblue1267
      @jackieblue1267 8 месяцев назад +2

      @@MiloManning05 Ireland and Britain had a near complete population turnover in the Bronze Age with Beakers that were all R1b-L21 which is still the most common ydna especially in Ireland today.

  • @μυστηριώδεςΤριλωνο

    M colombian with britons roots in this part of the globe people only talk about the vikings but m glad to watch this video talking about the celtic side cuz i m ginger and people dont know that being red heads is our celtic side and our heritage

  • @nadinefay1560
    @nadinefay1560 4 месяца назад

    It’s nice to know where I and my siblings got hazel eyes from, Spain! I was a little perturbed as both parents have blue eyes. I feel very special 😊

  • @Souliban
    @Souliban Год назад +15

    Spanish are Celtic too

    • @asturiasceltic3183
      @asturiasceltic3183 Год назад +2

      Northwest Spaniards are...The rest no

    • @asturiasceltic3183
      @asturiasceltic3183 Год назад +5

      @robertolang9684 North Africans never ruled Asturias the way they did Andulucia. Why is Asturias a celtic nation and invited to the NYC St Patricks' Day Parade along with Galicia? The rest are not celtic nations nor invited. I am so glad I hurt your feelings. Just look at them and look at people from Asturias. And there is nothing you can do about it.

    • @asturiasceltic3183
      @asturiasceltic3183 Год назад +2

      @robertolang9684 "Asturias is Spain..The rest is just reconquered territory."................................. Is the FAMOUS saying.

    • @asturiasceltic3183
      @asturiasceltic3183 Год назад

      @robertolang9684 How is he my ancestor if there was no MENA or African in my family's DNA test. You mad because you ugly and not handsome and fine featured like my ancestor in my avatar.

    • @Souliban
      @Souliban Год назад +1

      ​@@asturiasceltic3183 I'm talking about DNA. Which is in all Iberia

  • @IosuamacaMhadaidh
    @IosuamacaMhadaidh 10 месяцев назад +1

    My dna is mostly "English and northern European", but heavy roots in Scotland on my family tree. I identify with and gravitate towards Scottish people and culture though. I have ancestors from multiple clans, most recently through my mother's father, the clan Drummond. Any other Drummonds that read this comment on my post and say hello 😊 Tha gaol agam ort Alba 🇺🇸🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 (still learning Gaelic)

  • @yomismo530
    @yomismo530 7 месяцев назад +1

    I am Galician, from Northwestern Spain, with 16 Spanish family names. I made some DNA tests and all suggested that I am about 30% English. I was shocked, I couldn't believe it because I haven't any relationship with England. I am a brown man, typical Spanish.

    • @jcoker423
      @jcoker423 4 месяца назад

      Maybe the Peninsular War when Brit armies were in Spain fighting the French

    • @chesvilgonzalezvilches8309
      @chesvilgonzalezvilches8309 3 месяца назад

      🇪🇸 Pues yo 100% español, ni una gota de inglés, irlandés, o gallego. Blanco, rubio, ojos grisáceos/azulados.

  • @angyliv8040
    @angyliv8040 6 месяцев назад +1

    Im from Spain and both parents are from north Spain (Galicia and Catalonia). They both have around 10% of celt from uk islands. But I think this test don’t take into account the Celt which is Iberian. My father also have 19% English. My family in both sides don’t have any ancestors known from outside Spain. So we don’t know if this Celt dna is not original from the celts in Spain. Btw I went to Scotland once and I felt at home, very friendly and close people there. 😊

    • @Angelcynn_2001
      @Angelcynn_2001 5 месяцев назад

      Your father's English blood may be from the Iberian war 1813, Englishmen helping the Spanish guerrillas

  • @nothingbutmilk6576
    @nothingbutmilk6576 7 месяцев назад +1

    Cunliffe is not a linguistics professor and I"m not aware of any linguistics professor who would agree with his theory that the Proto Celtic language arose in the British Isles. The most likely origin point for a Proto Celtic language is the Urnfield culture which arose in Central Europe around 1300 BC. The 1st people who brought Steppe ancestry to the British Isles between 2300 and 1800 BC were lower Rhine Bell Beakers who were genetically descended from the Corded Ware culture. The people of the Corded Ware culture spoke an Indo European language that linguists believe was the early ancestor of today's Celtic, Italic, Germanic, Baltic, and Slavic languages. However, it isn't 100 per cent certain that the Rhine Bell Beakers retained the Indo European language of their Corded Ware ancestors. Descendants of the Early European Farmers living in Spain circa 2800 originated the Bell Beaker culture that was adopted by the Rhine Bell Beakers. It's theoretically possible that the Rhine Bell Beakers could have also adopted whatever non Indo European language the Spanish Bell Beakers spoke along with the Spanish Bell Beaker's material culture. In addition, the Celtic and Italic languages are very closely related and many linguists believe that there had to have been a Proto Italo-Celtic Language in central Europe (possibly spoken by the Unetice culture). Cunliffe's hypothesis doesn't explain the connection between the Italic and Celtic languages.

  • @joeyjuandiaz6195
    @joeyjuandiaz6195 Год назад +4

    Coo I'm Mexican with 41 % Spanish 7% Spanish basque, 2%scotish 39% native Mexican where all brothers 🥊🔥

  • @heylooknohienz
    @heylooknohienz Год назад +3

    So that mean anglo saxons and celts are native to all those isles?

  • @Gudha_Ismintis
    @Gudha_Ismintis 2 года назад +6

    Not sure bout 'Spanish' - a bit of a click baity title - Western European Hunter Gatherers might be a better description

    • @celtichistorydecoded
      @celtichistorydecoded  2 года назад +1

      Fair point, less concise however

    • @VeritasIncrebresco
      @VeritasIncrebresco Год назад

      Beeker culture came from Iberian peninsula I believe. Modern Spaniards do not look like the peoples who originally migrated to the British Isles 7,000 years ago

    • @vedranpostek2394
      @vedranpostek2394 Год назад +5

      @@VeritasIncrebresco Bell Beakers came from the central Europe. They were a mixture between around 48% Yamnaya Indo-Europeans with 52% ENF(Mixture of Anatolian farmers with WHG). Nothing in common with the Spain

    • @Souliban
      @Souliban Год назад +1

      The fact that both countries share the same Celtic culture.......is important to know you are not right at all

    • @Souliban
      @Souliban Год назад +3

      @@VeritasIncrebresco In fact , current Spanish looks exactly as Celts and Iberians

  • @jasonrandall5148
    @jasonrandall5148 Год назад +1

    Wot of the legend that the Ancient british came from ancient Sumeria then came through spain. And then the other lengend of Brutus of troy.

  • @michaelcandido2824
    @michaelcandido2824 Год назад +9

    there were celts in spain and they did speak celtic languages however the dna of the UK comes from the basque country in spain in the pyrenees and that dna has been unchanged mostly due to the RH negative factor that most of them have , which made it hard to have live births with those who where Rh pos. For those who say that either population dont look similar in appearance obviously hasnt seen what they look like on average. While some parts of spain have some mediterrian features most of all of spain is celtic blood followed by Roman blood. Most contributions by the the mediterrians, sephardic jews and berbers will be in the south of spain and in small numbers ( single digits). People in the UK would link closest to the Basque in spain.

    • @michaelcandido2824
      @michaelcandido2824 Год назад +3

      @roberto lang that is not even remotely true. Only certain areas of Scotland are like that. Dna evidence suggest that the majority of ancestral dna comes from Spain 6000 yrs ago. That ancient ancestry still shows up to this day in modern populations, that goes as well England , ireland, and Wales. This genetic input is the Celtic stock and of course there where other small contributions but not on the magnitude of the base foundation.

    • @michaelcandido2824
      @michaelcandido2824 Год назад

      @roberto lang the admixtures are small compared to what they got from the Spanish. Spain had many different people come and go but the core genetic of Spain is and was Celtic predominantly not Mediterranean like Italy.

    • @michaelcandido2824
      @michaelcandido2824 Год назад

      @roberto lang Iberia is Spain and Portugal though. Celt’s spanned from Spain to Anatolia

    • @saguntum-iberian-greekkons7014
      @saguntum-iberian-greekkons7014 Год назад +1

      As a Spanish descent i can tell you that for the Spaniards its not that simple of saying “That region is more x” it is way more complicated. You see, during the Reconquista, northerners were encouraged to settle in southern part of Spain and that habit continued after 1492, thats why there are many blonde types in the south as well as Mediterranean looking in the north. In Spain (and Portugal) everyone has moved , making it difficult to retrace the origins, unless the Basques of course

    • @skylinelover9276
      @skylinelover9276 10 месяцев назад

      ​@robertolang9684is Napoleon and Hitler are Ev13 DNA paternal?

  • @MyrddnWllt
    @MyrddnWllt 11 месяцев назад +1

    So I’m my family you have the whole selection of European phenotypes. Some of us look Spanish, some look very Celtic and some look outright Scandinavian. I feel this is what the British genome is like visually. Most families I’ve met in Britain are the same with their not really being an established “look” inherent in the family and the genetics being varied.

  • @chesvilgonzalezvilches8309
    @chesvilgonzalezvilches8309 6 месяцев назад

    🇪🇸 Las tribus celtas atlánticas estaban diseminadas por casi toda la península. En el sudoeste estaban los Celtici. Profesores de Oxford investigan hace tiempo la conexión de Tartessos como la civilización protoceltica del sudoeste.

  • @Jamestele1
    @Jamestele1 8 месяцев назад +1

    I have a Welsh surname (Powell-Jones), with most of my ancestry from all over Scotland - literally: Sutherland, McMurry, Snodgrass, Murdoch, McRea, Whitson, Murray, Black, Creig, and so on. I've done several DNA tests, and am apparently typically British - Ya hoo, I'm cool!

    • @Jamestele1
      @Jamestele1 7 месяцев назад

      @robertolang9684 Did you NOT read that I have done DNA testing? Not very well-read, are we? No need to respond, as it is obvious that you is retarded

  • @cinaedmacseamas2978
    @cinaedmacseamas2978 3 месяца назад

    So, are the English predominantly descended from ancient, pre-farming Iberians or the Anglo-Saxons?

  • @Angelcynn_2001
    @Angelcynn_2001 9 месяцев назад +2

    Why would I be Spanish? You literally call me a Sassanaech (Saxon) 😂😂😂

  • @colonelturmeric558
    @colonelturmeric558 Год назад

    Additional comment, my family has roots in scotland, ireland and present day cambria, scottish paternal last name of Anderson and my maternal side gramps’ surname is Deeley, an irish name. His father was a canadian pilot named lt. Peacock whom he never met, which apparently roots in Dumfries. The double helix thickens:)

  • @ShireTommy_1916_Somme-Mametz
    @ShireTommy_1916_Somme-Mametz 2 года назад +10

    But we don't look Spanish

    • @RS-ln3ns
      @RS-ln3ns Год назад +1

      THE PEOPLE FROM NORTHERN SPAIN ARE NOT AND DO NOT, LOOK ANYTHING LIKE THE PEOPLE FROM SOUTHERN SPAIN. THEY LOOK VERY CELTIC. MANY PEOPLE FROM IRELAND, SCOTLAND AND SPECIALLY, WALES, HAVE DARK BROWN EYES, THICK EYEBROWS AND BLACK CURLY TO FRIZZY HAIR. THEY DON'T EXACTLY LOOK SCANDINAVIAN.

    • @malcolmstead272
      @malcolmstead272 Год назад

      The Spanish today are not the same people who migrated north, since then they have been invaded by Moors and other north African tribes.

    • @RS-ln3ns
      @RS-ln3ns Год назад +1

      @@malcolmstead272 HOW DO YOU KNOW ? HAVE YOU BEEN ALL AROUND SPAIN ? YES. SPAIN HAVE BEEN INVADED BY THE NORTHERN AFRICANS BUT THE SPANISH PEOPLE FROM NORTHERN SPAIN ARE NOT THAT MIXED WITH THE MOORS OR ANY OTHER NORTHERN AFRICAN TRIBES, ESPECIALLY, THE BASQUE PEOPLE. MANY SCOTTS, IRISH AND WELSH PEOPLE, LIKE I SAID, HAVE DARK BROWN EYES, THICK EYEBROWS AND BLACK CURLY TO FRIZZY AFRICAN TYPE OF HAIR SO THOSE TYPES, MUST HAVE A MIXTURE OF NORTHERN AFRICAN DNA FROM THE PAST. NOBODY HAS AFRICAN TYPE HAIR, UNLESS THEY ARE FROM AFRICA OR FROM A COUNTRY, LIKE SPAIN, WHO ARE MIXED WITH NORTHERN AFRICANS. MANY SPANIARDS ALSO HAVE AFRICAN TYPE HAIR. PEOPLE FROM NORTHERN SPAIN HAVE THE EXACT SAME FACIAL FEATURES AS THE PEOPLE FROM THE BRITISH ISLES, ESPECIALLY IRELAND. JUST BECAUSE THE NORTHERN AFRICANS INVADED SPAIN, THAT DOESN'T MEAN THAT THE ORIGINAL CELTIC PEOPLE THERE HAD VANISHED. THEY STILL EXIST AND NOT ALL ARE MIXED WITH NORTHERN AFRICANS. MOST WESTERN AND NORTHERN EUROPEAN COUNTRIES HAVE NOW, GOT A LARGE PERCENTAGE OF MUSLIM IMMIGRANTS, FROM PAKISTAN, MOROCCO, ALGERIA, TURKEY, INDIA AND BANGLADESH LIVING THERE, ESPECIALLY, THE UK. MANY OF THESE IMMIGRANTS HAVE BEEN LIVING THERE, SINCE THE 1950'S AND MORE AND MORE OF THEM ARE CONTINUING TO MARRY THE NATIVE EUROPEAN WOMEN FROM EUROPE. SOON, ALL WESTERN AND NORTHERN EUROPEAN PEOPLE WILL ALL BE MIXED WITH THE PEOPLE FROM THE MUSLIM NATIONS.

    • @RS-ln3ns
      @RS-ln3ns Год назад +1

      THERE ARE MANY PEOPLE FROM THE BRITISH ISLES, ESPECIALLY, IRELAND, WHO HAVE A PERCENTAGE OF IBERIAN DNA, SHOWN IN THEIR DNA TEST RESULTS AND THERE ARE ALSO MANY PEOPLE FROM NORTHERN SPAIN, WHO HAVE SCOTTS, IRISH AND WELSH DNA, SHOWN IN THEIR DNA TEST RESULTS. THIS IS NOT HARD TO BELIEVE, WHEN YOU CONSIDER THE FACT THAT NORTHERN SPAIN IS JUST, DIRECTLY, ACROSS THE SEA FROM THE BRITISH ISLES AND THAT PEOPLE HAVE ALWAYS, THROUGHOUT HISTORY, IMMIGRATED TO OTHER COUNTRIES, ESPECIALLY TO, THE NEAREST COUNTRY TO THEIRS. THEY DIDN'T HAVE AEROPLANES BACK THEN BUT THEY'VE ALWAYS HAD BOATS TO TRAVEL ON.

    • @Souliban
      @Souliban Год назад +6

      Thanks God. That's why Mr Bean and Xabi Alonso looks so different 😘

  • @LoveLove-gw2td
    @LoveLove-gw2td Год назад +5

    Many British have Spanish DNA

  • @seanfaherty
    @seanfaherty Год назад +2

    I think this fella needs to compare Maternal and Fraternal DNA

  • @cdanerz3677
    @cdanerz3677 2 месяца назад

    Well more recent research and studies found that the majority of English people ancestry is actually Anglo-Saxon

  • @paulmattsson2878
    @paulmattsson2878 Год назад +2

    And within it all are the Neolithic people, who were there prior to the arrival of everyone else. They are still there too.

    • @MiloManning05
      @MiloManning05 Год назад +1

      Yes it’s clear to see

    • @johnpatrick5307
      @johnpatrick5307 11 месяцев назад

      They made a comeback (See: mass migrations in the Late Bronze Age).

  • @jackieblue1267
    @jackieblue1267 8 месяцев назад +1

    Study quoted above is ancient in dna study terms and completely outdated now. That Sykes study was based only on ydna and not even looking at subclades. It was based on the erroneous idea that ydna R1b was holed up in the Franco-Cantabrian Ice Age Refuge and that Europe was repopulated from that refuge. With newer dna studies it is now known that R1b was not even in Western Europe until the Bronze Age and it originated in the Steppe. Also the majority R1b in Britain and Ireland is a completely different clade than the majority clade in the Basque and Spain. Also anyone looking at autosomal dna can see there is no particularly close link between these populations. It is important to use the latest dna studies and not older ones that have been shown to be erroneous because of lack of data at the time.

    • @ESCAGEDOWOODWORKING
      @ESCAGEDOWOODWORKING 5 месяцев назад

      All branches of R1b are found in all other locations to one degree or another, and as R1b all related in the past. I'm R1b and FTDNA places my paternal line R-Z149, in what today is Kent, England, back about 1750 BCE, and I'm of direct Spanish ancestry. others living today from the US, France, England, and 17 other countries share R-Z149. And this is just my individual example, multiply that by many other Y DNA test takers, and what you find without trying, is that we're all related, not only via paternal Y DNA, but maternal mtDNA, as well as autosomally. My list of current day Y DNA matches are found across the world, FTDNA has a map feature, and so your 'completely different' is a bit lacking, though broadly different branches of R1b exist, they're all found in different places just the same. As far as R1b coming West from the Steppe, that's the current understanding with a lot of samples that point to that being so.

    • @jackieblue1267
      @jackieblue1267 5 месяцев назад

      @@ESCAGEDOWOODWORKING Not really. For example all the Bell Beakers in Britain and Ireland that have been tested were R1b-L21 and all the ones in Iberia were DF27. So why would that be? There is still a lot of unknown on this subject but more information is coming out. We now know that R1b did come from Corded Ware so Bell Beakers are off-shoots of Corded Ware.

  • @VoiceAcrossTheField
    @VoiceAcrossTheField Год назад +2

    I wonder if the story of king Arthur is maybe true connected to driving away most of the Anglo-Saxon ?

    • @colonelturmeric558
      @colonelturmeric558 Год назад +1

      Look up Arthur’s comet, very very interesting implications which could have caused the collapse of the celtic civilisation in england

    • @jcoker423
      @jcoker423 4 месяца назад

      As the UK speaks English, he didn't do a very good job.
      Read Age of Arthur by Morris for a better explanation

  • @Souliban
    @Souliban Год назад +2

    Look at Orlando Bloom, Mr Bean, Catherine Z Jones, Victoria Beckham....and then just for example...Fernando Torres, Xavi Alonso, Javier Clemente, all of them castillian non basques. Do you still thinking the same?

    • @johnpatrick5307
      @johnpatrick5307 11 месяцев назад +1

      Yes - you'd probably know better than me on where these people came from..... - its a common look in Britain - and one that is NOT commented on - More common than "Anglo Saxon"!
      I will say that Britain was colonised by Early European farmers in the Late Bronze age.

    • @Souliban
      @Souliban 11 месяцев назад +1

      @@johnpatrick5307 no, the common look of British is worse. I know. They are not common. 🤣

  • @Irene-im8xi
    @Irene-im8xi Год назад +3

    Did Spain really exist 6,000 years ago though?

    • @joe8256
      @joe8256 10 месяцев назад

      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hispania

  • @robgould6190
    @robgould6190 Год назад +2

    Were these people celtiberians?

  • @johnnypickles5256
    @johnnypickles5256 2 месяца назад

    They weren't Spanish, they were tribes that had migrated there mainly because of the climate change that made northern Spain a refuge . Mixing concepts

  • @danpictish5457
    @danpictish5457 Год назад +1

    Sir bary Cunnlife is a star!

  • @Alice.in.Marmalade
    @Alice.in.Marmalade 8 месяцев назад

    Curious to know what does England & Northwestern Europe DNA refers to? would that be Celtic, or Saxon? ( I am of German ancestry but DNA test my results show England?)

    • @EgoHead710
      @EgoHead710 8 месяцев назад

      North-western Europe is the Denmark, Northern Germany and the East Netherlands.
      As far as Celtic or Germanic goes..........you're both.

    • @ramadamming8498
      @ramadamming8498 3 месяца назад

      English is mostly a mix of Lowland West Germanic, Gaulish ( Celt, maybe mixed a bit with Frankish ) and Briton - the most consistent is the West Germanic, the biggest range is Briton ( Brythonic ), meaning, some people can be only 15% Briton, others 60%. There are regional variations and balances but around a third each of these. The 'Gaul' is probably via a mix of pre Germanic migration but also northern France and Belgium have Gaulish genetics. Kent and Ghent are said to be of the same origin :-)

  • @Auggies1956
    @Auggies1956 Год назад +1

    My DNA shows all of the British Isles, Denmark and Southern Italy.

  • @elwolf8536
    @elwolf8536 Год назад +4

    I'm English most of my dna is north west Europe

    • @jujuba5487
      @jujuba5487 Год назад +2

      If so you are not English at all. 🤣

    • @elwolf8536
      @elwolf8536 Год назад +5

      @jujuba no my dna a is typical for English, nice try

    • @johnpatrick5307
      @johnpatrick5307 Год назад

      Belgian?

    • @elwolf8536
      @elwolf8536 Год назад +2

      @@johnpatrick5307 England nortwest Europe and Scandinavia Scotland irland

  • @grumpyowl66
    @grumpyowl66 Год назад +2

    My DNA test shows 52.5% southern Scottish, 31.5% English, and 16% Scandinavian. No other countries just those 3. Family lives/d in Northumberland, Alnwick area. Traced family back to 1700s, but still researching history of family.
    Might seem boring, but nice to know am not a mongrel lol

  • @Paul.Morgan
    @Paul.Morgan Год назад +1

    Basques, not Spanish? It makes sense that all the peoples along Europe's Atlantic coast might be partly related.

    • @asturiasceltic3183
      @asturiasceltic3183 Год назад +3

      Probably... I have often heard that dark hair and very light skin is a common trait amongst women who live along the European Atlantic.

  • @VoiceAcrossTheField
    @VoiceAcrossTheField Год назад +2

    Could the ancient French be the Celtic Gauls ?

    • @celtichistorydecoded
      @celtichistorydecoded  Год назад +4

      Yes, that's right Scott, that's a big part of their history

    • @ramadamming8498
      @ramadamming8498 3 месяца назад

      Only really or mostly in Belgium and north, north France and they came from central Europe, for example, the Bohmians and others

  • @Valhalla88888
    @Valhalla88888 Год назад +8

    The original inhabitants of Britain are the Welsh who are not a Celtic tribe but a British Tribe. The English are a Germanic tribes from Denmark and today's Germany why the English call themselves British Brits is laughable the only real Brits are the Welsh, the Scots are a tribe washed up on the shores of Hibernia and conquered northern Hibernia to form Scotia and the people are called the Scotti as in Scots, the Scotii are not Hibernian Irish they are either from Iberia or Austria 🤔

    • @benjaminpicton7235
      @benjaminpicton7235 Год назад +3

      Welsh are the true brits

    • @johnpatrick5307
      @johnpatrick5307 Год назад +3

      Scotti are just the old name for the Irish - indeed the Irish were called that until the middle ages.
      The Irish are Indo-Europeans, not Iberian - indeed they are the most Indo-European people in Europe.
      See: Son of Manu.
      The Welsh are not Celts.

    • @benjaminpicton7235
      @benjaminpicton7235 Год назад +1

      @@johnpatrick5307 the welsh are definitely Celts wtf 😂

    • @johnpatrick5307
      @johnpatrick5307 Год назад +4

      @@benjaminpicton7235
      "Fibre Optic" had it right - the Welsh are mostly the original Britons - the Welsh language came from the migration of EEF farmers in the late Bronze age.
      I note that they have a similar amount of "Great Britain" DNA to the English, but less "Northwest Europe" DNA than they have. (Ancestry DNA).
      So they are not Celts (except for being a third Irish!)

    • @benjaminpicton7235
      @benjaminpicton7235 Год назад +1

      @@johnpatrick5307 the Brythonic peoples were celts

  • @_hesha_7092
    @_hesha_7092 4 месяца назад

    The Spanish people weren't the Spanish people yet though. They went through a transformation similar to the British with the injection of multiple different types of people over thousands of years

  • @MickeyMouse-el5bk
    @MickeyMouse-el5bk 2 месяца назад

    Just watching the EM final 2024...

  • @stella8726
    @stella8726 2 года назад +10

    Oh noooo, we’re all Spaniards 😱 I was only joking with my Mum the other day that bagpipes were Spanish Lol
    …thanks for another good video Steven 😊

    • @celtichistorydecoded
      @celtichistorydecoded  2 года назад +2

      Thanks Stella

    • @MAKDÁVID-KRIŽ
      @MAKDÁVID-KRIŽ 2 года назад +1

      GaL moved between PortuGaL,BenGaL and MonGolia and such have connected Iberian peninsula with CaucaSIAN Iberian Kingdom and Siberia.
      Spanish are more of Moors and Carthegean then ManGaL.

    • @MAKDÁVID-KRIŽ
      @MAKDÁVID-KRIŽ 2 года назад +1

      @Forrest Gump Mi Lán Northern Italian city has a meaning in HunGerian language where Mi means Us where Lán is word used for Lion which is related to ULán Bátor or City Brave Lion Capital of MonGolia.
      It’s a genetic fact that earliest graves in MonGolia where of people identical to Scythians meaning Hungarian,Ukrainian and Western Rus Sian people who where and are Gælic as per genetics or GauL according to my Hungarian genetics.
      Where Rus appears to a version of Ros Gælic Clan name.
      It’s a fact that 1500 years ago in Carpathian basin some people had Identical genetics to current MonGolians while some where a mix of Hungarian and MonGolia and some where simply local Hungarian meaning ManGaL.

    • @shawnm2405
      @shawnm2405 2 года назад +3

      Bagpipes are normal thing in northern Portugal. Very traditional.

    • @MAKDÁVID-KRIŽ
      @MAKDÁVID-KRIŽ 2 года назад

      @Forrest Gump Hi.Well as a Hungarian I have genetic relationship from Ireland all the way to Ural in this current time even do Hungarians have retreated from ETELKÖZ for a while.This genetics of my appears to be actually of ETEL or commonly known as a Attila the Hun like where we still have sometimes some MonGolian features where Khanty,Mansi,Uyghurs…are all relatives us and yes MonGols as well culturally and genetically.
      There are many studies done on the topic by Hungarians but it’s a fact that pre orthodox and Islamic time HunGerians freely did move across A Sian land and so did MonGolians like Yakutsk and intermarriages where not rare or strange since people had a same culture background.
      Our word for Brother/Sister is Testvér Tést meaning Body and Vér meaning blood which in English translates as Blood of my body where Blood covenant or Vérszerződés was a practice to unify families something that GaLhas performed in West just as MonGols in East so your drawn to Celtic culture is understandable since at some point it was connected.

  • @brianadams1907
    @brianadams1907 Год назад +1

    Talking about "Stirring the pot" ! Read the comments from all the "x-spurts" on genes and genetic heritage, throw a bit of history and a dash of "what we look like" , and we have a real shit storm of unprovable "facts , science and history" ! Hold up , I'm gonna get a bag of popcorn , a cold drink and the book I've been reading...I'll be right back. Hahajha.

  • @joykendrick6156
    @joykendrick6156 Год назад

    My Heritage DNA is 53% English, 26.4 azores Portugal

  • @victorcampbell1868
    @victorcampbell1868 Год назад +2

    The famous Spanish flag "Aspas de Borgoña " comes from the scottish flag (St Andrews)

    • @Souliban
      @Souliban Год назад +2

      It's just the opposite....

    • @victorcampbell1868
      @victorcampbell1868 Год назад +2

      @@Souliban Well, it was a gift from the scottish regiments who fought in Spain

    • @Souliban
      @Souliban Год назад +1

      @@victorcampbell1868 St Andrews cross comes from Patrax Crucifixion in Greece of St Andrew, Roman Empire. And the Spanish Empire used Aspas de Borgoña , a bit different, from James de Fearless of Burgundy (Borgoña) Spain during that time. St Andrew was their Patron

  • @DerekDerekDerekDerekDerekDerek
    @DerekDerekDerekDerekDerekDerek 7 месяцев назад +3

    Scottish propaganda 😂

  • @adamlewellen5081
    @adamlewellen5081 11 месяцев назад

    So as I understood, Ireland, Scotland and Wales are the holdouts.... England was Concord by the Saxon first and the Romans second... . This is were the English found and kept their conquering spirit...

    • @andym9571
      @andym9571 3 месяца назад

      Romans first..then the Anglo Saxons

  • @gwynwilliams4222
    @gwynwilliams4222 Год назад +1

    So you are saying that English people are Welsh I don't think English people like being called Welsh

    • @stanleywoodison8699
      @stanleywoodison8699 Год назад +2

      We couldn't give a monkeys what you call us. We just don't care.

    • @mrjw6701
      @mrjw6701 Год назад +2

      Imagine how the Welsh feel when Americans refer to the U.K. as England.

  • @veronicalogotheti1162
    @veronicalogotheti1162 Год назад +1

    The Scots and Picts are not Celts
    Look at the names

  • @veronicalogotheti1162
    @veronicalogotheti1162 Год назад +1

    Picts and scot are vikings

    • @andym9571
      @andym9571 3 месяца назад

      The Scots ( Scotti ) were an Irish tribe

  • @Alasdair37448
    @Alasdair37448 2 года назад +5

    This was something that had me very confused at first when I got my genetic results it said my family on my fathers side was from lowland Scotland was English and had 0% Germanic tribes talk about confusing! The trick here is that the Britons of north England are the same genetically as those of lowland Scotland and were Celtic peoples not Anglo-Saxon.

    • @realitywins9020
      @realitywins9020 Год назад +2

      Southern Scotland and Northern England were home to Welsh speaking kingdoms such as Strathclyde and Cumbria

    • @johnbrereton5229
      @johnbrereton5229 Год назад +2

      @@realitywins9020
      Not actually Welsh speaking, Brythonic speaking.

    • @johnpatrick5307
      @johnpatrick5307 Год назад

      @@johnbrereton5229
      Whats the difference?

    • @johnbrereton5229
      @johnbrereton5229 Год назад +2

      @@johnpatrick5307
      Though they all developed from Brythonic they had regional differences Cumbrian was different to Welsh, as was Cornish. In fact Brythonic, is as different to Welsh as Old English is to English.

    • @johnpatrick5307
      @johnpatrick5307 Год назад

      @@johnbrereton5229
      But the people were NOT Celtic - there was a mass migration of Anatolian farmers about 1000BC, introducing the language.
      See: Mass Migration into Britain in late Bronze Age.

  • @tbrown4080
    @tbrown4080 4 месяца назад

    This has to be wrong about the British origins in Spain as Britons have multiple origins.

    • @Floren_Andro
      @Floren_Andro 3 месяца назад

      The Spanish also have multiple origins, but that does not prevent the British from having origins from the north of Spain in the same way that the British have, as you say, various origins.

  • @Garcwyn
    @Garcwyn Год назад +2

    Cheddar man was in reality Manchego man

  • @nicholasr82
    @nicholasr82 8 месяцев назад

    Who were the people already there before the celts. Also you misrepresented the study. They moved through Spain but they were also in France and the celts were a western people. Their dna go to northern isreal.
    Also remember, Spain of then was nothing like the people of Spain today just like Turkey was not the same people as it is today and like Egypt wasn't the same people as it is today.

  • @user-gd1yg6le1h
    @user-gd1yg6le1h 7 месяцев назад

    Think it little to simplistic , lot does not fit the archeology, uk is a mix of groups with inflows of cultures and styles, lot of Anglo and celt style were invented by Christian propaganda and Victorian make believe

  • @TheGrouch2000
    @TheGrouch2000 Год назад +1

    I am Asturian. My Scottish friends are not going to take this news well. 😀

    • @asturiasceltic3183
      @asturiasceltic3183 Год назад +6

      I don't understand why wouldn't they take the news well.. They have an idea Asturias is a celtic nation. They are from Europe and know a lot about European history and genetics..They are not dumb. It's the USA Americans of Scottish ancestory that have a problem with it not the Europeans.

  • @Lacteagalaxia
    @Lacteagalaxia Год назад

    Before we went there now you come here to look your origins🤣

  • @dorothysimpson2804
    @dorothysimpson2804 Год назад +2

    I had my DNA tested, I knew I was part Welsh, English, Scottish and Irish.
    Result 33.8% Scandinavian
    32.2% Welsh, Scots and Irish
    29.3% English
    2.5% Italian
    .9% Iberian
    .9% West Asian (Turkish?)

    • @alvanrigby6361
      @alvanrigby6361 Год назад +1

      I would find it very difficult to understand how they could classify DNA according to national boundaries. The genetic distinctions between the Lowland Scots and Northern English would make these differences virtually meaningless.

    • @dorothysimpson2804
      @dorothysimpson2804 Год назад

      @@alvanrigby6361 it must be more intricate than just borders. People in different parts of the world eat different foods that would translate into later descendants. The Scots were not one people, they were Picts, Scotti Irish, Viking and French. Northern England had Anglo Saxons, Vikings and Normans plus Neolithic Brits. Every area has nuances.

    • @alvanrigby6361
      @alvanrigby6361 Год назад +3

      @@dorothysimpson2804 And Scottish lowlanders had Anglo-Saxon ?

    • @dorothysimpson2804
      @dorothysimpson2804 Год назад

      @@alvanrigby6361 possibly, the border did keep fluctuating.

    • @MiloManning05
      @MiloManning05 Год назад +1

      @@dorothysimpson2804 lowland Scot’s aren’t Gaelic

  • @michaelwale9933
    @michaelwale9933 Год назад

    Doest his mean you'll let us into the Celtic union.

  • @ardibeltzak1197
    @ardibeltzak1197 Год назад

    🤣🤣🤣.cuantos comentarios estupidos hay que leer.... la realidad es que todos somos africanos..

  • @deanamodeo4072
    @deanamodeo4072 Год назад +1

    There were no Spanish people 7000yrs ago. Those terms don't apply

  • @EnglishBOYxxx
    @EnglishBOYxxx Год назад

    You can literally see it in white Spanish people, they look the same as English but like old version

    • @phoenixrose1192
      @phoenixrose1192 Год назад +2

      No, they don’t. English people of European ancestry are very diverse in looks, but if we are to generalise, I’d say they look more like the northern French and German people.
      I’ve been to Spain, English people look nothing like Spanish people! 😂

    • @asturiasceltic3183
      @asturiasceltic3183 Год назад

      @@phoenixrose1192 Look at singer Marc Almond when he was young especially in the "Tears Run Rings" video.

    • @phoenixrose1192
      @phoenixrose1192 Год назад +1

      @@asturiasceltic3183 I’m not disagreeing, but the OP is saying that in a general sense, all English people look exactly the same as Spanish people. So exceptions do exist, essentially.

    • @asturiasceltic3183
      @asturiasceltic3183 Год назад +2

      @@phoenixrose1192 From what I seen most look Anglo-Saxon in London except the Irish type you see there.

    • @M-nd8uv
      @M-nd8uv Год назад

      "White spanish people" spanish people are White originally!

  • @davidmoore2568
    @davidmoore2568 Год назад

    But Spanish celts nowadays have some Phoenician, Jewish and moorish blood

    • @Randsom
      @Randsom Год назад +3

      no

    • @davidmoore2568
      @davidmoore2568 Год назад

      @@Randsom yes it is cuz Phoenicians settled Spain in 900 bce, moors conquered most of your country in 800 years and lot of Spaniards have some jewish dna.

    • @Randsom
      @Randsom Год назад +4

      @@davidmoore2568 Dont you see the video only 5 percents of spaniards have moorish or jewish blood. Spaniards havent mix with them. All the studies says it but maybe you are more intelligent. I made dna test FTDNA 0 percent moorish or jewish.

    • @Randsom
      @Randsom Год назад +2

      @@davidmoore2568 And you are from Australia so it is sure you have some native australian blood. I mean a big big percentage of australoid says studies and dna test on youtube?

    • @davidmoore2568
      @davidmoore2568 Год назад

      @@Randsom also you have some phoenician dna cuz they settled your country in 900 bce

  • @heathmahaffey2342
    @heathmahaffey2342 2 года назад +2

    So we are all Hispanic!!!

    • @RS-ln3ns
      @RS-ln3ns Год назад +2

      SPANISH PEOPLE ARE SOUTHERN EUROPEANS AND NOT HISPANICS. MAYBE YOU HAVE HISPANIC DNA IN YOU, IF YOUR AMERICAN. I MEAN, AMERICANS HAVE BEEN LIVING AMONG MEXICANS, AS WELL AS, OTHER LATIN AMERICANS, FOR GENERATIONS, SO IT'S VERY POSSIBLE.

    • @heathmahaffey2342
      @heathmahaffey2342 Год назад +2

      @@RS-ln3ns it was more of a tongue in cheek comment. The US census bureau considers Spaniards to be Hispanic, any person with Spanish culture. It’s a very hot topic for some. They consider Latinos to be from the Americas however.

    • @heathmahaffey2342
      @heathmahaffey2342 Год назад +2

      @@RS-ln3ns also, Hispanic is not considered a race at all. It’s just a way for someone to identify with Spanish culture. In the US they would actually mark White (Hispanic or non-Hispanic).

    • @RS-ln3ns
      @RS-ln3ns Год назад

      @@heathmahaffey2342 SPANISH CULTURE IN SPAIN, IS VERY DIFFERENT TO THAT OF SOUTH AMERICA. THEY SPEAK THE SAME LANGUAGE AND HAVE SPANISH SURNAMES AND THAT'S ABOUT IT BUT EVERYTHING ELSE IS VERY DIFFERENT, E.g. MUSIC, GOOD AND DANCES Etc. BLACK AMERICANS HAVE BRITISH SURNAMES, THEY SPEAK ENGLISH AND MANY HAVE BRITISH DNA IN THEM BUT THE AMERICANS DON'T REGARD THEM AS BEING BRITISH AND DON'T IDENTIFY THEM WITH BRITISH CULTURE, EITHER SO I CAN'T UNDERSTAND WHY THEY REGARD SPANISH PEOPLE AS BEING THE SAME AS THE PEOPLE OF SOUTH AMERICA, WHO ARE REALLY, AMERICAN INDIANS MIXED, UNLIKE THE SPANISH, WHO AREN'T. THERE ARE OTHER LANGUAGES SPOKEN IN SPAIN, NOT JUST SPANISH. THEIR SURNAMES AND MUSIC IS ALSO DIFFERENT, DEPENDING ON THE PART OF SPAIN BECAUSE THE PEOPLE FROM DIFFERENT PARTS OF SPAIN, ARE NOT EVEN, THE SAME AS EACH OTHER, MUCH LESS, THE SOUTH AMERICANS.

    • @RS-ln3ns
      @RS-ln3ns Год назад +1

      @@heathmahaffey2342 IT SHOULDN'T REALLY BE A HOT TOPIC. THE AMERICANS HAVE TO UNDERSTAND THAT SPANISH PEOPLE FROM SPAIN ARE NOTHING, OTHER THAN SOUTHERN EUROPEANS AND THE PEOPLE FROM SOUTH AMERICA ARE AMERICAN INDIANS, WHO MAY HAVE SOME SPANISH DNA BUT THEY ARE NOT SPANISH EUROPEANS. SPANISH CULTURE AND LATIN AMERICAN CULTURE, ARE NOT THE SAME, EITHER. JUST BECAUSE 2 COUNTRIES SPEAK THE SAME LANGUAGE, THAT DOESN'T MEAN THEY ARE THE SAME PEOPLE AND HAVE THE SAME CULTURE. LATIN WAS A ROMAN LANGUAGE. THE ROMANS WERE FROM ITALY. THE REASON WHY THE SOUTH AMERICANS ARE CALLED LATINOS, IS BECAUSE THE LANGUAGE THEY SPEAK (SPANISH) HAS A LOT OF LATIN WORDS. THE REASON WHY THAT IS BECAUSE THE ROMANS HAD INVADED SPAIN, OVER 1000 YEARS AGO AND HAD FORCED THE SPANISH TO SPEAK LATIN WHICH WAS THE LANGUAGE OF THE ROMANS. THE FRENCH LANGUAGE ALSO HAS A LOT OF LATIN WORDS BECAUSE FRANCE HAD ALSO BEEN A ROMAN EMPIRE. THE BRITISH HAS SOME LATIN WORDS IN THEIR LANGUAGE, AS WELL, FOR THE SAME REASON SO THEREFORE, THE REAL LATINOS ARE THE ITALIANS.

  • @johnnyjumpup859
    @johnnyjumpup859 Год назад

    The most important group to ever move to Britannia is the Romans .. they were there for nearly five hundred years.. and laid out the blueprint for modern England.. the German gypsies were inconsequential ... the Norman's after 1066 provided artistic flair and the route to the British empire via the Tudors...

    • @phoenixrose1192
      @phoenixrose1192 Год назад +6

      It was the Anglo-Saxons who laid out the blueprint for modern England.
      As the historian Eric John wrote in the 20th century: “It was the Anglo-Saxons who made England, the Normans who attempted to make Great Britain. And as yet they have not succeeded so well.”
      The Normans were inconsequential, especially given how they adopted English ways and even accepted an English identity. That’s properly why there’s no such thing as a “Norman culture”, they’re just English like the rest of the tribes.

  • @vedranpostek2394
    @vedranpostek2394 Год назад +3

    You have nothing in common with Moortugeese and Spaniards who have up to 6% non European Iberomaurusian autosomal admixture (Iberomaurusian is mixture between 55% unknown western euroasian/caucasoid and 45% ghost negroid ANA). Moortugeese, Galicians and Asturians(who have the most north African dna) are distant on pca even from Basques. Meanwhile, all Brits and Irish are nearly the same genetically. You are mixture between 42-48% WSH/Yamnaya(EHG+CHG) and 52-58% EEF(35% AHG+ 13%WHG+2% Natufian)

    • @RS-ln3ns
      @RS-ln3ns Год назад +1

      WHAT DO YOU KNOW ABOUT BRITAIN AND THE BRITISH ISLES OR SPAIN ? HAVE YOU EVER BEEN THERE ? YOUR NOT EVEN EUROPEAN YOURSELF. VEDRAN POSTEK . THAT'S A RUSSIAN NAME. RUSSIANS ARE NON EUROPEANS. THEY ARE BALTIC, AND ASIAN MIXED. THE PEOPLE FROM NORTHERN SPAIN ARE CELTIC AND LOOK VERY MUCH LIKE THE PEOPLE FROM THE BRITISH ISLES. I GREW UP AMONG THE IRISH AND ALSO KNOW A LOT OF SCOTTS AND WELSH PEOPLE, AS WELL AS THE PEOPLE FROM NORTHERN SPAIN. I'VE EVEN, BEEN TO SCOTLAND SO I SHOULD KNOW. IT'S THE PEOPLE FROM SOUTHERN SPAIN AND NOT THE NORTH OF SPAIN, WHO ARE THE ONES WITH THE MOST NORTH AFRICAN DNA. THE BASQUE PEOPLE HAVE NO AFRICAN DNA, AT ALL. YOU OBVIOUSLY, KNOW NOTHING, ABOUT SPAIN, BRITAIN OR THE BRITISH ISLES SO STOP BEING IGNORANT.

    • @Souliban
      @Souliban Год назад +8

      Everything ok at home ? 🙂 Ok so that's why MrBean and Xabi Alonso looks so different?

    • @Jfidkxidksi
      @Jfidkxidksi Год назад +1

      Complete lie, Galicia and north Portugal are regions genetically similar to the British in general. North Portugal has almost no moor dna

    • @Souliban
      @Souliban Год назад +1

      @@Jfidkxidksi Not only Galicia. The whole Spanish population. Ireland and UK have a lot of people that could be Andalucians ( lucky them) And the Opposite.

    • @michaelcandido2824
      @michaelcandido2824 Год назад

      dude is just a troll with some white supremacy agenda. Spanish and portugeuese are european and the british are their offspring , the facts speak for itself.

  • @roydeckard112
    @roydeckard112 Год назад +1

    Impossible to focus on what this guy is saying, impossible with that accent lol

  • @bobcprimus
    @bobcprimus Год назад +3

    Aye but, ginger Scots areny Spanish, that's for certain.

    • @MiloManning05
      @MiloManning05 Год назад +1

      He’s talking about Irish Iberians.

    • @asturiasceltic3183
      @asturiasceltic3183 Год назад +3

      I heard Scots say that the Picts and Basques are related.

    • @MiloManning05
      @MiloManning05 Год назад +2

      @@asturiasceltic3183 no they aren’t

    • @asturiasceltic3183
      @asturiasceltic3183 Год назад +3

      @@MiloManning05 Yes, they do say it. Scotland and Asturias are celtic nations that both get invited to bagpipe at the NYC St Patrick's Day Parade and NOTHING you can do about it.

    • @asturiasceltic3183
      @asturiasceltic3183 Год назад +1

      @@MiloManning05 Why does it bother you that Asturias and Galicians are related to the Irish and a similar culture. This is why YOU bother me. I am tired of uneducated people who come on here and spew lies contaminating others with their miseducation.