the lotion is valued at 14$, Dollar tree sells similar for much less, honestly to have the audacity to call the box premium and charge that much is insane. If they keep it up they will be bankrupt in a year. terrible just terrible :( Love you!!
On Boxy’s website it says the base box is average $175 and the premium average is $215. I added your items up based on the manufacturers websites. You’re total was $176.59. You got the $175 you were looking for, but I wouldn’t say that’s a premium box. Especially if the average for the base is $175.
Sending a refreshments item in a premium box would actually fill me with rage. I would absolutely Google all the items and see if you hit close to the $175. That refreshments lotion should be priced on the Ipsy site and I think it’s currently for sale on Boxy site. Chocolate brown lip colors can be considered a neutral for people of color. I’m pale myself, but don’t mind the chocolate brown because I just mix other colors into the brown to alter the color.
YES! Rage!! People don’t have money to throw away right now. That’s terrible!! They can’t give it away they can’t sell it in their sales so they dump in box! No way!
I remember when Ipsy came out with their Ultimate subscription. It was like $70 and had a promised value of like $300 and most of it was Ipsy brands or shit no one had ever heard of. This company is so scammy
100% agree. Refreshments do NOT belong in our boxes. It was also a clean out. I had 3 palettes in my box. The two you had plus the Natasha Denona Jubilee palette we got last year.
They no longer claim the $175 retail value---My January premium box was only $152-only $8 more than my base's value. When I contacted them, they said $175 was an "average" value. I received the Refreshment's unscented lotion as well as a single 1.5" circle pan Doucce eye shadow and both of them counted as 2 of the 6 items in the box. I am soooo disappointed in BC lately. They are really making no effort "wow" us anymore. Do you think Boxy and Ipsy will merge and somehow try to charge us more money??!!!
Your response to the refreshments lotion was so similar to my response! I'm hoping they're getting rid of refreshments. I have yet to receive anything from the line that is actually good. I received a refreshments shampoo in my glam bag x..... I was not happy about receiving such a poor quality item in the most expensive bag. I really wish trendmood offered a subscription box! I would definitely subscribe to that, especially after the box I just received, it was my favorite mystery box so far this year! If the news isn't as exciting as they're making it sound, I may consider dropping Boxycharm or Ipsy.
I just signed up for the box and I was able to choose a free product and supposedly $10 which I cannot find anywhere but they also offered Mr that same brand of that lotion as a free fpr one month subscription ontop of the box and then it's $7 after so that lotion they are offering for $7 as a fefill for members!
This is the first time I wasn't able to get the premium box since it launched & I was having major FOMO. big time. Until I watched unboxings..now I think not getting Feb's box was divine intervention. I only liked the Ace Beauty Lippie. I love REN products but I am swamped w skincare, so much so that I'm using serums on my hands and chest so they don't expire
You might be right because I know with BoxyCharm Premium one can only subscribe for up to 6 months. The other subscriptions one can still sign up for full year.
Sydney the blush pallet was a choice item the eyeshadow pallet was a pallet that everyone who got premium got that beautiful pallet and I have never received a Ace beauty lip products ever and their bullet lipsticks are beautiful too always have been I personally love my premium for February !
I'm not sure what to think about this box. I agree with you that it seems as though it's a clean out type of box, which could be a harbinger of things to come. I liked the Ren Skincare product and the blush palette was really pretty. The Refreshments product was unacceptable imo and the Lippies were not my colors at all.
That blush palette was absolutely stunning! I didn't like the lip shades, and I wouldn't want two in one box. I'd be extremely angry if in a $45 box I got a refreshment product. Thanks for sharing!
Exactly my words! The last few months have been leftover junk. I got three pallets! One expires in 4 days. Also got the unscented ipsys brand body lotion. Totally disaster! They should’ve just not sent out any boxes this month. Still waiting on my base .. I’m not excited
You got 2 palettes in your premium box and I got 3!! I got that blush palette, the royal blue palette, and a mini natasha denona palette. I was really shocked!! I love your videos!! I think I would definitely be a little disappointed if they merged Ipsy and Boxy together because I like Boxy better usually. I did get a really nice Glam Bag X this month though!!! :)
Your box value is around $214. The Ace Beaute lip is $18, the Ciate London palette is $48, the Eloise palette is $55, the Ren skincare is $60, the Refreshment is $14 and the Ciate lipstick is $19 (but currently on sale in Dropshop if $4.99). Seems most got a Refreshment in their box along with one of the products they are trying to clear out the warehouse, so only 4 products actually new to the box. I think the Refreshment should never be in a box, especially a premium box. If I wanted those products, I would subscribe to them or purchase them at the discount prices in the dropshop. I also got another lip product that was my 6th item that was a clearance item in the dropshop. So not happy about 2 items, but the palettes and Ren skincare made up a bit for those....but still! I think this months box review will be very mixed with most getting a Refreshment item and a clearance item. FYI, if you want to check the value of items, you can still see them when you go in to do your review of the box. Only items not listed, are the once everyone got from the clearance items. Those weren't even listed to review.
oooooo .... last year Ipsy was sucky, this year Boxy is losing it ..... hopefully a Great Merge will occur, they'll 'mystery box' all the junk out of the warehouse and get serious about doing an Amazing Job ... the Leader in the Subscription Box Industry!!! Go Boxy! 😃😂🙃
I hope they join together for 1 great box. I think there has been some struggling, especially on the Ipsy side. Then maybe they’ll offer an X or Luxe each month. There is definitely room for improvement.
Getting a subscription box...Allure was first...was the best thing I had done for myself in a long time. I know many women regularly shop for themselves, and that's cool by me, but I didn't. And so now...Yes...I am beautiful. And I found Allure on your channel. So thanks Sydney 😊
I had a hard time doing things for myself, and now I get a few subscription boxes a month and it makes me feel good!! I feel really beautiful when I get dressed up and put my makeup on!!
Another commenter beat me to it, but that unscented lotion immediately made me think Dollar Tree. If it's an in-house brand, they could manufacture that with a value of of a DOLLAR. Well, less really, because that is the retail price! Ridiculous. And this is only my opinion, but I had unscented. How can you feel expensive if you smell nothing?
Sydney, I've been watching you for two ✌🏼 years, and you've NEVER changed your lip look, ie, just lip gloss, no colour. You can't expect EVERY box to be made for you ❤️
This box did not come across as premium to me at all. Most of the products were pretty subpar. I think the big announcement is going to be boxycharm and Ipsy are only going to be one subscription
Ipsy said that exact thing word for word about epic news also so I believe they are definitely going to merge I think they’ll make a new box or combine some they already have
The brand Essentials/Refreshments “generic” water downed products should not be offered in a BoxyCharm or Ipsy subscription box. I love brand Ciate London, but that lip color is hideous and I love chocolate. Respectfully, I do not like their eye palette either. NP I could easily find someone to give the Ciate London eye shadow palette too. Lip color, 🤢 straight into my trash can. The Ace Beauty packaging is gorgeous, the lip shade, blah! I do love the blush palette 💕 REN skincare is excellent. Several subscribers believe that Ipsy and BoxyCharm will merge into one subscription. I know a few years ago Ipsy bought BoxyCharm. “Yes, I miss Joe” I don’t understand how this will be profitable because several subscribers, including me, have both subscriptions. If they merge into one subscription??? Well I guess I will be receiving one subscription and not two? In my opinion, I don’t see Premium vibes this month.
Whatever epic thing, I sure hope its that theyll only accept enough inventory to give a product out one time in one box. If they want extras for sales fine but don't do that to subscribers They don't do it to people in PR even for paid for. Add the skip a month option. Actually truly use preferences like ipsy does I know sometimes it doesn't seem like ipsy is using preferences but it really has to do with the way you fill out the survey you can't have sometimes or often selected on every product every time I think they did not use my preferences besides when they choose products for me for oily skin when I have dry I noticed they did the best they could with the products they had. I want to see them give us the same type of choices they do in plus and X so we get 3 choices with a bunch of choices catered to our preferences that would be huge honestly that is the number one thing they should do to fix this besides not sharing products. I would be able to run that company a 100 times better than whoever is I can tell you that much. I would also make sure they gave out products that we don't receive like Y in 7 years with all 3 subscriptions to both have I never received a white or a nude eyeliner? I've only received 1 black 1 ever I would love to receive every color of the rainbow besides navy and bronze because that's the only shades they give us. I have never once received a contour stick. Only one time ever have I received a powder foundation. I mean I can keep going for days. They have owned boxy for 2 years and there is not one thing they have done in 2 years to make the company better all they have done is ruin it entirely Oh my gosh you do not receive PR from them? Are you serious? That really bothers me. You are my favorite so you do have authentic experiences I am so sorry I did not know that you did not get PR that is the dumbest thing I have ever heard you are over there purchasing all of their mystery bags and everything shame on them they literally give PR to some people that have like 200 followers it's ridiculous they need to cut back on PR honestly It's like you don't need to send every bag option to people in PR if you're going to send them X you do not need to send them plus that just gets confusing they could make cutbacks there that would not affect paying loyal subscribers. Wow I always admit when I am wrong and I have definitely been wound up in the comments and having no idea that you did not receive PRI do however think they do pay attention to what they give you because they definitely know you are there as a channel because I still haven't seen what happens to me happened to you. I really wish it would happen to somebody that has a channel so that they could put them on blast I don't think that that will be the big change that's coming that would not be exciting or epic to anybody unless it was that you will only see a product one time in 1 bag and there's no excuse for all of this either they have the sales if you can't get rid of it literally drop it down to $3 until it's gone give me a break they're literally filling premium boxes with refreshments products Not to mention when ipsy does refreshments for like points it's 600 points which = a travel size that is the only reason that I tried the refreshments products because I was excited to get a full sized item for 600 points or they do them in Add ons crazy cheap but you want to put it in a premium box there is nothing premium about refreshments at all. I did hear the ciate was great formula.. just not excited for the shades.
The ciate lipstick was the afterthought. You picked the blush palette. Royal associated with blue. You are at 175 the ren you picked and that is like 70. You think too much about stuff. The other 5 items need to be 105
I do like the refreshments deodorant but I'm not like omg it's just a deodorant to use that doesn't irritate my skin ... for now anyway let's hope it doesn't irritate me later. But no I don't want it as an item in my premium box I'm with you in that
If I paid for that box I would be flippin pi**ed (rhymes with “hiss”)! I canceled my Boxy and Ipsy last April 2022 and have not missed it one time! I still like watching unboxing videos, but I’m starting to get mad for the creators who pay for these ridiculous excuse of a box! I was a member for 3 years and saw pretty much all the same products circulate over and over. I wish more people would cancel so it would force them to up their game! Eyescream Beauty Box(and bag) and Slay Glam Box has done it! Even Zeasee Cosmetics (who I’m not happy with right now) puts out a great box with great value every month and they have a much smaller pool if products to create with! Boxy/Ipsy👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻
I still haven’t received my January box or the February box 😡 although I received an email yesterday saying February has been shipped but still nothing for January. Boxycharm will not answer when to expect it, all they say is I’ll get an email once it does🤷♀️ anybody else having this problem?
Absolutely. BoxyCharm customer service/support is nonexistent. Don’t give up though. Go into your account, my items, scroll down to your BoxyCharm boxes. You should have a tracking number. If you don’t have a tracking number this means your box was never shipped.
@@cherylharrison3789 yes, I’ve been looking and no tracking. Boxycharm confirms it hasn’t shipped but will not tell me when it will ship. Offered me a 12.00 credit. Why on earth am I going to spend more money when they aren’t shipping anything lol. So frustrating😡
Not a good box at all. No theme and the only good thing was that blush...that was pretty. I'm not a fan of nude or even lipstick so I always end up giving those away. Thanks so much for taking one for the team...haha
I'm sorry that your box you felt was so awful, I guess I should feel blessed that I actually received my box by the 7th of this month, and I had seven awesome items in my box. I thought boxycharm actually did really good this month. Ace Beaute is an amazing Indy brand with gorgeous eyeshadow palettes and beautiful lip products. I felt very happy to receive that lipstick in my box.
Wth! That's messed up! I bet that lotion has no better ingredients than dollar trees Dermasil! Not that it's bad, I love dermasil for what it is! And it's 1.25. I haven't had ipsy or boxy in over 2 yrs now, and honestly I don't think they've improved much at all. I swear I always got the shittiest products!
The refreshments body cream is only $14 I believe that is disgusting that they put a $14 product in premium I do not receive chocolate Brown colors I used to now all I receive is read which I do not use at all I received red 2 months in a row they give us whatever is not selling they do not give us what is trending at all. I think that's why we do not receive high end eyeliner honestly OK I also have to admit my premium was technically better than your premium because I did get the Ace liquid lipstick which I would have been very upset if I didn't. I have not checked the color though. I love the ciate formula It is one of my favorites but that shade is terrible OOK I guess you did get the Ace also so weird.. I have only received 3 liquid lipsticks from boxy out of all 3 subscriptions in the past year and they are all in the past 3 months 2 were red and one is the Ace I'm very happy about that I don't think they should put 2 of the same product in any Box like they have done 2 primers, 2 palettes. I actually do not care for ren and I think it's ridiculous that they give out a specific skin concern to everybody like I received it and I do not have redness it's annoying. 2 lipstick and 2 palettes. I have actually seen 2 products by the same brand and I've also seen 2 palettes several times. There is no reason for them to be cleaning out anything though because they have the sales they have excellent products and there with plenty of inventory to give us good products with no excuses.
I dont think that you’re crazy. I do think that they did put together a hodgepodge for this month. And that chocolate lippie - that doesn’t look good on anyone. And I hate body lotion that’s unscented. But both of those palettes are nice especially the blush. Having said that I dropped premium for 2023 and I’m not sorry about that yet.
I’m sorry on no level should a refreshments be considered an item as an item included in the box! How dare they shove refreshments down member’s throats!!!xoxoxo
Depends which royal family you are talking about I think it's an excellent box You really are grumpy 😡 these days Sorry, might be time to say our goodbyes 😢 I come on here to be cheered up, not depressed
You can choose to but if you receive 2 is a totally different story I received 2 credits to drop shop which you cannot even combine because I was not getting my choice and I was also getting a repeat and premium was far from exciting the fact that they included a refreshments product oh boy I cannot even say what was going through my mind. It is completely unacceptable refreshments has been advertised all over ipsy and boxy the people that want to purchase it fine good for them. The people that don't want it should not be forced to have it. I did try a few of their products because ipsy Had them for 600 points for full size items I think that definitely explains the value of these products also so I tried the hand cream the bar of soap and the wipes all of which were absolutely terrible I don't think the body lotion would have even been acceptable in base maybe glam bag but that's still pushing it because it's own subscription In order to be in premium they would have had to include the razor with the refill cartridges with the pillow shave cream for me to find it acceptable no item under $15 should be in the premium we literally pay so much more money for one extra product Oh yes and not to mention I can't remember if it was you or not but I saw 2 people in PR that didn't receive their choice last month FOR THEIR PAID BOXES for the 1st time ever and what did boxy do? They included an extra product. I don't know I don't sugar coat anything and I don't care if people don't like it I literally feel disrespected by them I've been with them for 7 years with all 3 subscriptions to both ipsy and boxy. I'm sorry but that is proof that people in PR do not have authentic experiences getting these boxes and they wouldn't unless they had them under a different name going to a different address you will never be able to experience what subscribers experience and that's the facts. I love you to death this is not me giving an attitude towards you at all I want to make that clear. But the 2 people in PR that I saw that received an extra product they were like oh wow that's really cool I didn't know they were doing that and I said they most definitely are not doing that I should know considering I have received 14 out of 18 months either not getting my choice or getting a repeat. This month after everything I have been through It really topped the cake for me and my email Was far from nice I was pissed. I still am. It's very misleading to people that do not have the subscription so people that Do not get their choice are going to be thinking they should be receiving a 6th product and a credit and that is Not going to happen and this is with people in PR paid for boxes just Like I have said they treat your paid for boxes differently then they treat ours they pay Attention to detail making sure that you do not have 14 out of 18 months where you receive a credit. That's just not going to happen or I have received terrible variations and not one person That gets PR and does videos but has paid 4 boxes ever received the variations I received. I love you just please know never in a million years would I give you an attitude I know sometimes I come off weird if I don't state that I'm not giving you an attitude or use emojis or whatever haha That's one thing I have never done is add up the totals of the products for my Box I just trust that they will be OK I have received an email from boxy before stating that it was not up to the value it was supposed to be but I have never noticed
They also ignore contact attempts...I signed up again a year ago and missed my choice item (no replacements) for three months...not to mention other problems and drop shop purchased beginning of December arrived a week ago and missing 2 items that I was charged for...but will get a partial refund in two weeks...smh...
@@belizas777 oh its bad they have had errors where is says your order didnt go through so you keep trying because of that and all of the items are in your cart still. $700 later one time. $400 later another. Then yep getting ahold of them.. Impossible
the lotion is valued at 14$, Dollar tree sells similar for much less, honestly to have the audacity to call the box premium and charge that much is insane. If they keep it up they will be bankrupt in a year. terrible just terrible :( Love you!!
That was my EXACT THOUGHT!! Dollar Tree.
A Boxy mess 😢
On Boxy’s website it says the base box is average $175 and the premium average is $215. I added your items up based on the manufacturers websites. You’re total was $176.59. You got the $175 you were looking for, but I wouldn’t say that’s a premium box. Especially if the average for the base is $175.
Good to know. Thanks
Can i say you look like pure sunshine & joy today. I instantly think of summer and happiness when i look at you.
Sending a refreshments item in a premium box would actually fill me with rage. I would absolutely Google all the items and see if you hit close to the $175. That refreshments lotion should be priced on the Ipsy site and I think it’s currently for sale on Boxy site.
Chocolate brown lip colors can be considered a neutral for people of color. I’m pale myself, but don’t mind the chocolate brown because I just mix other colors into the brown to alter the color.
I believe the value will tally up because of the REN skincare. Agreed. Not a Premium box though.
YES! Rage!! People don’t have money to throw away right now. That’s terrible!! They can’t give it away they can’t sell it in their sales so they dump in box! No way!
I remember when Ipsy came out with their Ultimate subscription. It was like $70 and had a promised value of like $300 and most of it was Ipsy brands or shit no one had ever heard of. This company is so scammy
I cancelled boxy charm a while ago. I didn't like getting off brand products when I was paying for premium !!!
I usually subscribe for a few months and then I cancel and wait about 6 months before subscribing again. It works pretty well for me that way.
Yes’s I’m going to cancel they’ll be cleaning out the old expired junk for the next few months
100% agree. Refreshments do NOT belong in our boxes.
It was also a clean out. I had 3 palettes in my box. The two you had plus the Natasha Denona Jubilee palette we got last year.
For premium? That’s terrible!
They no longer claim the $175 retail value---My January premium box was only $152-only $8 more than my base's value. When I contacted them, they said $175 was an "average" value. I received the Refreshment's unscented lotion as well as a single 1.5" circle pan Doucce eye shadow and both of them counted as 2 of the 6 items in the box. I am soooo disappointed in BC lately. They are really making no effort "wow" us anymore. Do you think Boxy and Ipsy will merge and somehow try to charge us more money??!!!
That would be an automatic cancel for me! Terrible! They lie! It always said 175
My box sucked. I canceled Ipsy and am at the point of canceling boxy too! So disappointed
I’m canceling both now until
They get it straightened out, if they ever do. This is terrible old warehouse expired junk and refreshments nobody wants.
I got the same box Total Value $215 Refreshments $14
I've been considering going back to Boxycharm But after seeing this video, nope. I can go to TJ or Marshall's and get more bang for my buck.
I received the stupid body cream too and am not happy about it either
Please complain to them about it.
Your response to the refreshments lotion was so similar to my response! I'm hoping they're getting rid of refreshments. I have yet to receive anything from the line that is actually good. I received a refreshments shampoo in my glam bag x..... I was not happy about receiving such a poor quality item in the most expensive bag. I really wish trendmood offered a subscription box! I would definitely subscribe to that, especially after the box I just received, it was my favorite mystery box so far this year! If the news isn't as exciting as they're making it sound, I may consider dropping Boxycharm or Ipsy.
I have received refreshments wipes and cleansing balm. Both smelled rancid. The replacements still stunk. Ugh
That’s terrible they put it in X TERRIBLE!! Omg! They need to donate it all to a shelter!
I just signed up for the box and I was able to choose a free product and supposedly $10 which I cannot find anywhere but they also offered Mr that same brand of that lotion as a free fpr one month subscription ontop of the box and then it's $7 after so that lotion they are offering for $7 as a fefill for members!
This is the first time I wasn't able to get the premium box since it launched & I was having major FOMO. big time. Until I watched unboxings..now I think not getting Feb's box was divine intervention. I only liked the Ace Beauty Lippie. I love REN products but I am swamped w skincare, so much so that I'm using serums on my hands and chest so they don't expire
In the updated terms & conditions for the premium box, it talks about the box being discounted.
You might be right because I know with BoxyCharm Premium one can only subscribe for up to 6 months. The other subscriptions one can still sign up for full year.
That’s terrible
Sydney the blush pallet was a choice item the eyeshadow pallet was a pallet that everyone who got premium got that beautiful pallet and I have never received a Ace beauty lip products ever and their bullet lipsticks are beautiful too always have been I personally love my premium for February !
I'm not sure what to think about this box. I agree with you that it seems as though it's a clean out type of box, which could be a harbinger of things to come. I liked the Ren Skincare product and the blush palette was really pretty. The Refreshments product was unacceptable imo and the Lippies were not my colors at all.
That blush palette was absolutely stunning! I didn't like the lip shades, and I wouldn't want two in one box. I'd be extremely angry if in a $45 box I got a refreshment product. Thanks for sharing!
Exactly my words! The last few months have been leftover junk. I got three pallets! One expires in 4 days. Also got the unscented ipsys brand body lotion. Totally disaster! They should’ve just not sent out any boxes this month. Still waiting on my base .. I’m not excited
That’s why is canceled Boycharm. I do not like Ipsy brands & products lines in Boycharm,
I cancelled my last month for a while anyway I'm glad I did
You got 2 palettes in your premium box and I got 3!! I got that blush palette, the royal blue palette, and a mini natasha denona palette. I was really shocked!! I love your videos!! I think I would definitely be a little disappointed if they merged Ipsy and Boxy together because I like Boxy better usually. I did get a really nice Glam Bag X this month though!!! :)
Your box value is around $214. The Ace Beaute lip is $18, the Ciate London palette is $48, the Eloise palette is $55, the Ren skincare is $60, the Refreshment is $14 and the Ciate lipstick is $19 (but currently on sale in Dropshop if $4.99). Seems most got a Refreshment in their box along with one of the products they are trying to clear out the warehouse, so only 4 products actually new to the box. I think the Refreshment should never be in a box, especially a premium box. If I wanted those products, I would subscribe to them or purchase them at the discount prices in the dropshop. I also got another lip product that was my 6th item that was a clearance item in the dropshop. So not happy about 2 items, but the palettes and Ren skincare made up a bit for those....but still! I think this months box review will be very mixed with most getting a Refreshment item and a clearance item. FYI, if you want to check the value of items, you can still see them when you go in to do your review of the box. Only items not listed, are the once everyone got from the clearance items. Those weren't even listed to review.
oooooo .... last year Ipsy was sucky, this year Boxy is losing it ..... hopefully a Great Merge will occur, they'll 'mystery box' all the junk out of the warehouse and get serious about doing an Amazing Job ... the Leader in the Subscription Box Industry!!! Go Boxy! 😃😂🙃
I hope they join together for 1 great box. I think there has been some struggling, especially on the Ipsy side. Then maybe they’ll offer an X or Luxe each month. There is definitely room for improvement.
Ipsy said the same thing about epic news. They did “tease” to combine last year but claimed it’s just a rumor.
I got 3 palettes in my base box and they didn’t have the product I chose, they gave me $6 to use in their store. What a joke 😐
The store is all old stuff that expired years ago! It should be donated to a shelter!!
Getting a subscription box...Allure was first...was the best thing I had done for myself in a long time. I know many women regularly shop for themselves, and that's cool by me, but I didn't. And so now...Yes...I am beautiful. And I found Allure on your channel. So thanks Sydney 😊
So glad you're doing stuff for yourself bwe always as women do stuff for others but not ourselves
I had a hard time doing things for myself, and now I get a few subscription boxes a month and it makes me feel good!! I feel really beautiful when I get dressed up and put my makeup on!!
Another commenter beat me to it, but that unscented lotion immediately made me think Dollar Tree. If it's an in-house brand, they could manufacture that with a value of of a DOLLAR. Well, less really, because that is the retail price! Ridiculous. And this is only my opinion, but I had unscented. How can you feel expensive if you smell nothing?
Mines had the Touch of Soul palette that expires 2/28! They definitely have been getting rid of all products the last few months.
I canceled Ipsy and boxy because I was so tired of getting ciate London! Every box! I’m not a fan of them.
Sydney, I've been watching you for two ✌🏼 years, and you've NEVER changed your lip look, ie, just lip gloss, no colour.
You can't expect EVERY box to be made for you ❤️
But they don’t use your pride at all
I've also been hearing that ipsy and boxycharm were going to merge
I was initially steamed about getting a Refreshment item in my box but I'm willing to give it a try. It better be good, though.
I got the same box and I was Pissed because 2 lippies and Ipsy product and that color of Ciate London is Horrid
This box did not come across as premium to me at all. Most of the products were pretty subpar. I think the big announcement is going to be boxycharm and Ipsy are only going to be one subscription
Hi Sydney you look amazing as always I love that shirt on you! Love your videos
Ipsys card said the same exact thing
Ipsy said that exact thing word for word about epic news also so I believe they are definitely going to merge I think they’ll make a new box or combine some they already have
The brand Essentials/Refreshments “generic” water downed products should not be offered in a BoxyCharm or Ipsy subscription box. I love brand Ciate London, but that lip color is hideous and I love chocolate. Respectfully, I do not like their eye palette either. NP I could easily find someone to give the Ciate London eye shadow palette too. Lip color, 🤢 straight into my trash can. The Ace Beauty packaging is gorgeous, the lip shade, blah! I do love the blush palette 💕 REN skincare is excellent. Several subscribers believe that Ipsy and BoxyCharm will merge into one subscription. I know a few years ago Ipsy bought BoxyCharm. “Yes, I miss Joe” I don’t understand how this will be profitable because several subscribers, including me, have both subscriptions. If they merge into one subscription??? Well I guess I will be receiving one subscription and not two? In my opinion, I don’t see Premium vibes this month.
I’m still waiting for mine to arrive, how long does it take them to ship??
I got 3 palettes. I got the orange palette instead of the Ren. Everything else is the same.
Check expiration dates. I received expired product this month. NOT impressed!
So they’re not off to a really great start for a $178 value!xo
Whatever epic thing, I sure hope its that theyll only accept enough inventory to give a product out one time in one box. If they want extras for sales fine but don't do that to subscribers They don't do it to people in PR even for paid for. Add the skip a month option. Actually truly use preferences like ipsy does I know sometimes it doesn't seem like ipsy is using preferences but it really has to do with the way you fill out the survey you can't have sometimes or often selected on every product every time I think they did not use my preferences besides when they choose products for me for oily skin when I have dry I noticed they did the best they could with the products they had. I want to see them give us the same type of choices they do in plus and X so we get 3 choices with a bunch of choices catered to our preferences that would be huge honestly that is the number one thing they should do to fix this besides not sharing products. I would be able to run that company a 100 times better than whoever is I can tell you that much. I would also make sure they gave out products that we don't receive like Y in 7 years with all 3 subscriptions to both have I never received a white or a nude eyeliner? I've only received 1 black 1 ever I would love to receive every color of the rainbow besides navy and bronze because that's the only shades they give us. I have never once received a contour stick. Only one time ever have I received a powder foundation. I mean I can keep going for days. They have owned boxy for 2 years and there is not one thing they have done in 2 years to make the company better all they have done is ruin it entirely Oh my gosh you do not receive PR from them? Are you serious? That really bothers me. You are my favorite so you do have authentic experiences I am so sorry I did not know that you did not get PR that is the dumbest thing I have ever heard you are over there purchasing all of their mystery bags and everything shame on them they literally give PR to some people that have like 200 followers it's ridiculous they need to cut back on PR honestly It's like you don't need to send every bag option to people in PR if you're going to send them X you do not need to send them plus that just gets confusing they could make cutbacks there that would not affect paying loyal subscribers. Wow I always admit when I am wrong and I have definitely been wound up in the comments and having no idea that you did not receive PRI do however think they do pay attention to what they give you because they definitely know you are there as a channel because I still haven't seen what happens to me happened to you. I really wish it would happen to somebody that has a channel so that they could put them on blast I don't think that that will be the big change that's coming that would not be exciting or epic to anybody unless it was that you will only see a product one time in 1 bag and there's no excuse for all of this either they have the sales if you can't get rid of it literally drop it down to $3 until it's gone give me a break they're literally filling premium boxes with refreshments products Not to mention when ipsy does refreshments for like points it's 600 points which = a travel size that is the only reason that I tried the refreshments products because I was excited to get a full sized item for 600 points or they do them in Add ons crazy cheap but you want to put it in a premium box there is nothing premium about refreshments at all. I did hear the ciate was great formula.. just not excited for the shades.
I looked up all the prices on everything. My paper is not near me right now
my premium box was totally different
The ciate lipstick was the afterthought. You picked the blush palette. Royal associated with blue. You are at 175 the ren you picked and that is like 70. You think too much about stuff. The other 5 items need to be 105
The lotion is 12.99 at Walmart 😩😂
I hope it is epic news
Hey Sydney 😀💞🤗 I hope you get a great exciting box 🎁
Btw- getting that Refreshments lotion in my Premium box would have sent me into an all American RAGE
Ace Beauty lipstick $17.99
I do like the refreshments deodorant but I'm not like omg it's just a deodorant to use that doesn't irritate my skin ... for now anyway let's hope it doesn't irritate me later. But no I don't want it as an item in my premium box I'm with you in that
Think you mayb onto something. I received 3 eyeshadow paletts a makeup sponge and my choice. Luke stuff was just t
Sorry.. like stuff was just thrown in. Boxy has been doing this for my last 2 or 3 boxes. I cancelled my account with them
If I paid for that box I would be flippin pi**ed (rhymes with “hiss”)! I canceled my Boxy and Ipsy last April 2022 and have not missed it one time! I still like watching unboxing videos, but I’m starting to get mad for the creators who pay for these ridiculous excuse of a box! I was a member for 3 years and saw pretty much all the same products circulate over and over. I wish more people would cancel so it would force them to up their game! Eyescream Beauty Box(and bag) and Slay Glam Box has done it! Even Zeasee Cosmetics (who I’m not happy with right now) puts out a great box with great value every month and they have a much smaller pool if products to create with! Boxy/Ipsy👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻
Maybe worth $120...I'd be fuming! That's not premium. That's not even a good base box. 😕
I still haven’t received my January box or the February box 😡 although I received an email yesterday saying February has been shipped but still nothing for January. Boxycharm will not answer when to expect it, all they say is I’ll get an email once it does🤷♀️ anybody else having this problem?
Absolutely. BoxyCharm customer service/support is nonexistent. Don’t give up though. Go into your account, my items, scroll down to your BoxyCharm boxes. You should have a tracking number. If you don’t have a tracking number this means your box was never shipped.
@@cherylharrison3789 yes, I’ve been looking and no tracking. Boxycharm confirms it hasn’t shipped but will not tell me when it will ship. Offered me a 12.00 credit. Why on earth am I going to spend more money when they aren’t shipping anything lol. So frustrating😡
Body cream is $14
Not a good box at all. No theme and the only good thing was that blush...that was pretty. I'm not a fan of nude or even lipstick so I always end up giving those away. Thanks so much for taking one for the team...haha
I'm sorry that your box you felt was so awful, I guess I should feel blessed that I actually received my box by the 7th of this month, and I had seven awesome items in my box. I thought boxycharm actually did really good this month. Ace Beaute is an amazing Indy brand with gorgeous eyeshadow palettes and beautiful lip products. I felt very happy to receive that lipstick in my box.
I see them merging, that would be a huge mistake...
Other than the collaboration ipsy has going on they are a bust.
Wth! That's messed up! I bet that lotion has no better ingredients than dollar trees Dermasil! Not that it's bad, I love dermasil for what it is! And it's 1.25. I haven't had ipsy or boxy in over 2 yrs now, and honestly I don't think they've improved much at all. I swear I always got the shittiest products!
Certainly it wasn't a curated box.
I do love chocolate brown lip colors I would feel so blessed If i receive a chocolate lip color, where I live its so hard to find that kind of shades
Eesh, yeah that box is a stinker.
All that stuff isn't high end
The refreshments body cream is only $14 I believe that is disgusting that they put a $14 product in premium I do not receive chocolate Brown colors I used to now all I receive is read which I do not use at all I received red 2 months in a row they give us whatever is not selling they do not give us what is trending at all. I think that's why we do not receive high end eyeliner honestly OK I also have to admit my premium was technically better than your premium because I did get the Ace liquid lipstick which I would have been very upset if I didn't. I have not checked the color though. I love the ciate formula It is one of my favorites but that shade is terrible OOK I guess you did get the Ace also so weird.. I have only received 3 liquid lipsticks from boxy out of all 3 subscriptions in the past year and they are all in the past 3 months 2 were red and one is the Ace I'm very happy about that I don't think they should put 2 of the same product in any Box like they have done 2 primers, 2 palettes. I actually do not care for ren and I think it's ridiculous that they give out a specific skin concern to everybody like I received it and I do not have redness it's annoying. 2 lipstick and 2 palettes. I have actually seen 2 products by the same brand and I've also seen 2 palettes several times. There is no reason for them to be cleaning out anything though because they have the sales they have excellent products and there with plenty of inventory to give us good products with no excuses.
Boxycharm n ipsy are he same company
Two brown lip glosses? Weird.
Yaaaay I’m the first one here
I dont think that you’re crazy. I do think that they did put together a hodgepodge for this month. And that chocolate lippie - that doesn’t look good on anyone. And I hate body lotion that’s unscented. But both of those palettes are nice especially the blush. Having said that I dropped premium for 2023 and I’m not sorry about that yet.
This box, as well as the last 4 months of boxes, have been junk thrown together. Duplicates, no choices, expired items. Just a joke
I’m sorry on no level should a refreshments be considered an item as an item included in the box! How dare they shove refreshments down member’s throats!!!xoxoxo
Ipsycharmer???
A Boxy mess. 😢
ace beaute gloss is 16.99 on their own website.
i just looked at it said the same thing. also, if you keep looking some of it was 12.99.
Please unsub from them this is getting sad
What a crappy box, sorry not sorry
Depends which royal family you are talking about
I think it's an excellent box
You really are grumpy 😡 these days
Sorry, might be time to say our goodbyes 😢
I come on here to be cheered up, not depressed
You can choose to but if you receive 2 is a totally different story I received 2 credits to drop shop which you cannot even combine because I was not getting my choice and I was also getting a repeat and premium was far from exciting the fact that they included a refreshments product oh boy I cannot even say what was going through my mind. It is completely unacceptable refreshments has been advertised all over ipsy and boxy the people that want to purchase it fine good for them. The people that don't want it should not be forced to have it. I did try a few of their products because ipsy Had them for 600 points for full size items I think that definitely explains the value of these products also so I tried the hand cream the bar of soap and the wipes all of which were absolutely terrible I don't think the body lotion would have even been acceptable in base maybe glam bag but that's still pushing it because it's own subscription In order to be in premium they would have had to include the razor with the refill cartridges with the pillow shave cream for me to find it acceptable no item under $15 should be in the premium we literally pay so much more money for one extra product Oh yes and not to mention I can't remember if it was you or not but I saw 2 people in PR that didn't receive their choice last month FOR THEIR PAID BOXES for the 1st time ever and what did boxy do? They included an extra product. I don't know I don't sugar coat anything and I don't care if people don't like it I literally feel disrespected by them I've been with them for 7 years with all 3 subscriptions to both ipsy and boxy. I'm sorry but that is proof that people in PR do not have authentic experiences getting these boxes and they wouldn't unless they had them under a different name going to a different address you will never be able to experience what subscribers experience and that's the facts. I love you to death this is not me giving an attitude towards you at all I want to make that clear. But the 2 people in PR that I saw that received an extra product they were like oh wow that's really cool I didn't know they were doing that and I said they most definitely are not doing that I should know considering I have received 14 out of 18 months either not getting my choice or getting a repeat. This month after everything I have been through It really topped the cake for me and my email Was far from nice I was pissed. I still am. It's very misleading to people that do not have the subscription so people that Do not get their choice are going to be thinking they should be receiving a 6th product and a credit and that is Not going to happen and this is with people in PR paid for boxes just Like I have said they treat your paid for boxes differently then they treat ours they pay Attention to detail making sure that you do not have 14 out of 18 months where you receive a credit. That's just not going to happen or I have received terrible variations and not one person That gets PR and does videos but has paid 4 boxes ever received the variations I received. I love you just please know never in a million years would I give you an attitude I know sometimes I come off weird if I don't state that I'm not giving you an attitude or use emojis or whatever haha That's one thing I have never done is add up the totals of the products for my Box I just trust that they will be OK I have received an email from boxy before stating that it was not up to the value it was supposed to be but I have never noticed
They also ignore contact attempts...I signed up again a year ago and missed my choice item (no replacements) for three months...not to mention other problems and drop shop purchased beginning of December arrived a week ago and missing 2 items that I was charged for...but will get a partial refund in two weeks...smh...
@@belizas777 oh its bad they have had errors where is says your order didnt go through so you keep trying because of that and all of the items are in your cart still. $700 later one time. $400 later another. Then yep getting ahold of them.. Impossible