Rethinking Islam: Seth Andrews interviews Adam Elmasri on

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 137

  • @freethinker902
    @freethinker902 Месяц назад +39

    as an ex muslim from Afghanistan, living in the west , I admire what you are doing . Thanks alot.

    • @shahidmiah917
      @shahidmiah917 Месяц назад +1

      Wasn’t it the Western coalition that destroyed Afghanistan? Just to control the pipelines. They set it back 100 years.

    • @allahmuhammad225
      @allahmuhammad225 Месяц назад

      An ex-Muslim from Afghanistan? That’s like finding a unicorn in the Pashtun Taliban territory! It’s almost like the Taliban’s efforts to drag people back to the 7th century are just inspiring more people to sprint away from Islam faster than Mohammed could chase after his adopted son’s wife! I mean, while they’re busy banning women’s education and dreaming of flying donkeys, you’ve got people opening books and leaving behind the desert fairy tales. Makes you wonder, how long before they start banning thinking altogether?

    • @Just_logic
      @Just_logic Месяц назад +1

      And yet many academics reverting to Islam. Why do you think that is?

    • @cmamet.m6526
      @cmamet.m6526 Месяц назад

      @@Just_logic the simple answer is, they don't speak, read arabic,. they don;'t know what real islam is, they don't know what's written in Quran, instead they get a polished version of Quran in English.they don't know, Quran calls non muslims as bigs, dogs and donkeys.

    • @pipuldewan1582
      @pipuldewan1582 Месяц назад

      They may be but I find no rebuttal of Adam's logic .Why it is soo difficult to find out if it is that obvious.isn't it injustice to mankind bcz how we normal human being find that soo hidden god?

  • @cmamet.m6526
    @cmamet.m6526 Месяц назад +42

    as an ex muslim and Kurd, salute your great works.

    • @Zarghaam12
      @Zarghaam12 Месяц назад

      If one was ignorant of history in the first place then it matters not what one decides to call oneself!

    • @cmamet.m6526
      @cmamet.m6526 Месяц назад +1

      @@Zarghaam12 Muslim IQ?

    • @Sweeti924
      @Sweeti924 Месяц назад

      @@cmamet.m6526
      Muslim IQ: you can become Muslim no matter your history.
      Hypocrisy:

    • @malakhdr8963
      @malakhdr8963 Месяц назад

      Hi dude, i think we same, and long time i looking for some one like u,

  • @allahmuhammad225
    @allahmuhammad225 Месяц назад +12

    Adam, I’ve got to say, your critiques of Islam are absolutely brilliant. The way you break down the Quran and expose the actions of Mohammed with such logic and clarity-it’s refreshing and eye-opening. It’s clear you approach things not just with knowledge, but with fairness and a sharp mind, and that’s rare these days. English might be your second language, but the strength of your arguments and your insights come through loud and clear. Keep doing what you’re doing-your work is making a real impact, and it’s appreciated more than you know!

  • @thenun1846
    @thenun1846 Месяц назад +6

    As an Egyptian ex Muslim, I love Adams content

  • @ardohlr9938
    @ardohlr9938 Месяц назад +16

    Thanks Adam Elmasri and thanks to many people like you

  • @bebo_995
    @bebo_995 Месяц назад +14

    As a fellow ex Copt I saulte you, what you said is exactly what we all went through.

  • @rammul7801
    @rammul7801 Месяц назад +8

    My journey from belief to disbelief was one of excitement, empowerment, and liberation... there was no trauma or depression. Religion never made real sense and was never organic. I had to force it.

    • @sarakunb621
      @sarakunb621 Месяц назад +2

      Similar to my journey 🎉

    • @Bob-b7x6v
      @Bob-b7x6v 19 дней назад

      Felt the same way as a Roman Catholic. Never really bought into the dogma, I mostly attended mass to honor my father.

  • @bennywolf72
    @bennywolf72 Месяц назад +4

    So glad you had Adam on your podcast!! And so glad to hear about RfR in Australia… such a needed resource. ❤

  • @chr_my
    @chr_my Месяц назад +5

    Really nice to listen to Adam talking about stuff, especially about the situation in Egypt. I read some works by Mark Durie and Bat Ye'or recently, and there was so much in there that is troubling. Please stay safe man, thanks for the video.

  • @ev7802
    @ev7802 Месяц назад +1

    You are a hero, Adam! Keep speaking. Thank you for defending freedom!

  • @OmarHamza-nz9ob
    @OmarHamza-nz9ob Месяц назад +21

    ✊🏽 I am an ex moslem, suppose I am living in a non moslem country. Suddenly, my friends who are violent islamists come to know about it and ask me, "Why do you left islam?" Despite living in a safe country, the moment is very critical and dangerous for me. If I said anything without thinking which is perceived as offensive, the violent islamists will instantly assault me. Now tell me what answer should I give in such situation?

    • @nobs997
      @nobs997 Месяц назад +5

      Tell them is none of their business

    • @jeangatti9384
      @jeangatti9384 Месяц назад +2

      Use taqiyyah and become a munafiq

    • @echoe4806
      @echoe4806 Месяц назад +3

      Stay safe my friend!

    • @shahidmiah917
      @shahidmiah917 Месяц назад +1

      Just change friends? Or you can stop insulting/mocking/abusing Muslims online. That might help. I checked your channel and it was made solely for insulting. Disgusting human being.

    • @servantofgod3058
      @servantofgod3058 Месяц назад +1

      "Why do you left Islam"
      "the moment is very critical"
      Nice English

  • @amuaiz
    @amuaiz Месяц назад +1

    Support your works from Malaysia

  • @uchechukwupriscillia845
    @uchechukwupriscillia845 Месяц назад +10

    Great work

  • @assyriannahrin
    @assyriannahrin Месяц назад +6

    In Iraq too, your I.D shows your religion

  • @Sherzodbek_Abdullayev
    @Sherzodbek_Abdullayev Месяц назад

    I loved the conversation ❤

  • @Hamdan999-w2u
    @Hamdan999-w2u Месяц назад +5

    Adam Elmasri talks FACTS.
    Prior to leaving Islam i myself studied the Quran..Sahih Hadis and Tafseer from cover to cover both in Arabic, English and Malay text.
    Proven Islam is man made religion.
    This is one of the reasons why I left Islam i am an ex muslim from Malaysia.
    There were hundreds of thousands of invincible Apostates in Malaysia...we never declare just ignore all the stupid and illogical teaching..

  • @KrishnaAdji
    @KrishnaAdji Месяц назад +3

    Hello Adam Elmasri,
    I'm a Muslim from Indonesia who is searching for the truth among fanatics. I often encounter arguments about scientific miracles (i'jaz ilmi) in the Qur'an from friends, especially regarding embryology. My research has led me to two perspectives: either the Qur'an, as Allah's word, is free of scientific errors, or it contains statements that don't align with modern science. I'm unsure which view to accept, as I personally have doubts about i'jaz ilmi claims. Could you share your thoughts on this? Thank you for your time and insights. And, if the Qur'an completely contains things that are not in accordance with science that the apologists say, I will leave Islam.
    Warm regards from Indonesia❤

    • @AdamElmasriEnglish
      @AdamElmasriEnglish  Месяц назад +1

      Thank you for your comment. Please follow my channel and watch other videos where I talk about errors in the Quran.
      I will aim to make a video in the future about the so called ‘ijaz ilmi’

  • @Bob-b7x6v
    @Bob-b7x6v 19 дней назад

    You're a brave man. Islam and reason mix worse than Christian fascism does. Keep up the good work, friend.

  • @Rico-Suave_
    @Rico-Suave_ Месяц назад +3

    Great video, thank you very much , note to self(nts) watched …… 41:41

  • @um-l9o
    @um-l9o Месяц назад +7

    ❤❤❤

  • @mazin16091969
    @mazin16091969 Месяц назад +6

    🌹🌹🌹🌹

  • @karnobot9814
    @karnobot9814 26 дней назад

    No magic required! I wish we have this caption in front of every bible.

  • @assyriannahrin
    @assyriannahrin Месяц назад +1

    8:23 the name thing
    It's every where in the islamic countries,they recognize you by name , especially if you are ethnically different too

  • @PRO-el7oy
    @PRO-el7oy Месяц назад +4

    Prince Adam 👑💙

  • @AliHashmi-l5d
    @AliHashmi-l5d Месяц назад

    hello Adam. can you do a video talking about the linguistical miracles of the Quran. how would you respond to the argument from the Arabic perspective? what do you as an Arabic speaker say about the eloquence of the quran etc.

  • @Timmy-bb7ch
    @Timmy-bb7ch Месяц назад +2

    my dad was a pastor in Dallas I left church for islam in 2002. I knew god wasn't a trinity and sun does not orbit the earth and eating a cheeseburger and flushing toilets on sabbath was not a sin

    • @hastigehond
      @hastigehond Месяц назад +4

      Which church teaches it's a sin to eat cheeseburgers or flush on a Sabbath? Which church preaches the Sun orbits the Earth? 😂

    • @kaly7256
      @kaly7256 Месяц назад +1

      you think you are NOT a trinity?

    • @Timmy-bb7ch
      @Timmy-bb7ch Месяц назад +2

      @@kaly7256 I KNOW I'm not a trinity thats roman paganism 101

    • @kaly7256
      @kaly7256 Месяц назад

      @@Timmy-bb7ch
      are you only body & mind? you don't have an eternal divine soul? Like me ? ( (Hermes the Trismegistus) much older than the Greeks )is the correct (not Roman ), that is, you think that people can made the internet that we now talk with, but God has not placed us in a spiritual communication network?
      calm down and pay attention to the coincidences, it's your communication with your higher self ...

    • @Timmy-bb7ch
      @Timmy-bb7ch Месяц назад

      @@kaly7256 scram kid. trinity is roman paganism foreign to Jesus. who also warned us not to wide/road /free salvation of church pedos and who started Sabbath sundown Friday. muslims al day Friday. christians on Sunday the day rome worshipped the sun god maybe its you who should pay attention to the coincidences muslim 2002

  • @THEGOAT6782
    @THEGOAT6782 Месяц назад +2

    Adam Al-Masry is an atheist from a Christian background with Christian parents. He specializes in theology and studied it at one of the best universities in the world. He lives in the Western world with a Christian majority and speaks English. Despite all this, he speaks little about Christianity and is more critical of Islam. It is clear that you have lost your credibility and previous neutrality.

    • @AdamElmasriEnglish
      @AdamElmasriEnglish  Месяц назад +3

      There are clear reasons why doctors fight cancer more than they fight flu… despite the fact that most doctors get the flu, they focus more on fighting cancer!!
      Doctors lost credibility in my eyes too!

    • @INJEEL_1028
      @INJEEL_1028 Месяц назад

      It’s call tribalism.

  • @Qeewee8500
    @Qeewee8500 Месяц назад +1

    Im still yet to find a ex christian online. Gosh exmuslims are the force of enlightenment

    • @nnekayewande5835
      @nnekayewande5835 Месяц назад +1

      If you view muslim apologetics video, in the comment section you will see alot of threads where people say they are ex Christians who are now muslims

    • @Qeewee8500
      @Qeewee8500 Месяц назад +1

      @@nnekayewande5835 Im sure there is, The question is you dont see 'ex Christian' exposing Christianity with the same enthusiasm as ex muslims exposing islam. its a real eye opener

    • @INJEEL_1028
      @INJEEL_1028 Месяц назад

      @@Qeewee8500ex Christian becomes Islam scholars and they are not into small talk, ex muslim becomes atheist and not Christian’s .

    • @Qeewee8500
      @Qeewee8500 Месяц назад

      @@INJEEL_1028 Ex Muslims becoming atheist are actually my favourite. quite interesting topics, specially about science

    • @INJEEL_1028
      @INJEEL_1028 Месяц назад

      @@Qeewee8500 quite an interesting statement, the problem is I’m yet to see a valid reason for people to leave Islam.

  • @LeaveMeAloneBleez
    @LeaveMeAloneBleez Месяц назад +1

    hello adam, do you believe that jesus was crucified or not? thanks dude big fan from the arabic channel

    • @AdamElmasriEnglish
      @AdamElmasriEnglish  Месяц назад

      Yes I do - just as a historical event (not theologically meaningful)

  • @mfvohra101
    @mfvohra101 Месяц назад +1

    And the answers are:
    Pharoah said it in sarcasm. He didn’t really mean it!
    Zulqarnain, the king Cyrus, reached the west end of turkeye. It has bunch of islands there that’s why Quran said it appeared to him as if Sun is setting into murky water rather than in the sea!

    • @sarakunb621
      @sarakunb621 Месяц назад +3

      Is this sarcasm or serious? For anyone who thinks this is serious, please consider: In Arabic wajada means found, as in literally found. The same word is used after to refer to finding a group of people. There is no evidence that the word ever meant "appears" instead of physically find. Can you find one example of this word being used to mean "appear" other than this alleged one? It is in ENGLISH where the word "found" can mean physically find or appears. If you speak another language you can see that the word physically find is different than appears to.

    • @mfvohra101
      @mfvohra101 Месяц назад +1

      Quran says when he reached the place of sun setting he saw sun is setting in the murky water where he found a nation nearby!
      It’s been discovered now that place was west end of Türkiye!
      This anti-Islamic guy is very outdated, very behind!

    • @mfvohra101
      @mfvohra101 Месяц назад +1

      Wa wajada ka zaallun fahada!

    • @uthman2281
      @uthman2281 Месяц назад

      ​@@sarakunb621
      yeah according to you

    • @sarakunb621
      @sarakunb621 Месяц назад +1

      ​​@@mfvohra101yes, you are proving my point. This is from Surah 93 verse 7 and means "And he found you lost and guided you". This means he literally found someone that was lost and guided them, it doesn't mean he appeared to be from his perspective lost and guided him.

  • @shahidmiah917
    @shahidmiah917 Месяц назад +2

    Why would you bring an
    Ex-Christian to talk about Islam? That’s quite a lame pathetic way of getting views.

    • @AdamElmasriEnglish
      @AdamElmasriEnglish  Месяц назад +1

      If you want to be objective, may be because this ex-Christian is a native Arabic speaker who also studied the Quran since childhood and he has a degree in textual criticism of ancient literature?
      It is only pathetic if you’re totally biased towards your beliefs rather than logical thinking!

    • @Yahman1969
      @Yahman1969 Месяц назад

      Why? I was a Christian who reverted to Islam and being raised as a Christian can help you interpret Islam differently to born Muslims. The born Muslim lacks that insight.

    • @shahidmiah917
      @shahidmiah917 Месяц назад

      @@AdamElmasriEnglish I checked your background. Biblical studies, ancient literature and textual criticism is not knowledge of Quran, Hadith or Islamic History and on top of that your not a Muslim or even an Ex Muslim. You have never cited from Islamic literature of any kind. You simply have no authority on the subject. You should stay in your lane and stick to Coptic Christian issues.

    • @shahidmiah917
      @shahidmiah917 Месяц назад

      @@Yahman1969 that would make sense if he was an Ex Muslim? He is an ex Christian Atheist trying to shed light on Islamic experiences.

  • @TruthSeeker-c6z
    @TruthSeeker-c6z Месяц назад +6

    Can you make a video on the cruelties of the Jahiliyya period which is often shown in Islamic propoganda. I mean, they literally portray Muhammad as a messiah who saved society from evil. For eg: The burying of girls.

    • @AdamElmasriEnglish
      @AdamElmasriEnglish  Месяц назад +2

      I will try to make it in the near future.
      Would you be able to support my work on Patreon?

    • @TruthSeeker-c6z
      @TruthSeeker-c6z Месяц назад +2

      @@AdamElmasriEnglish I would love to. Does that require money, because I'm unable to do online transactions at this point.

    • @stephanelaumonier8298
      @stephanelaumonier8298 Месяц назад

      🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑​@@AdamElmasriEnglish❤🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷💰💰💵💵💵💵💵💵💵

    • @uthman2281
      @uthman2281 Месяц назад

      ​@@TruthSeeker-c6z
      They do it for money
      Don't trust them

    • @uthman2281
      @uthman2281 Месяц назад

      ​@@AdamElmasriEnglish
      you have nothing but your opinion

  • @Bob-b7x6v
    @Bob-b7x6v 19 дней назад

    The Copts always piqued my interest. They were always closest to the origins to Christianity, but EVERYONE treated them like garbage. Egyptian Muslims literally made them the trash men. It's a wonder Coptic Christianity didn't get gutted and recycled into mainline Christianity like Gnosticism and Zoroastrianism did. I always root for the outsiders and underdogs in human culture.

  • @VAYLINN3309
    @VAYLINN3309 Месяц назад +1

    It funny how ex Christian all his videos is criticizing islam 😂
    Seriously what is you problem with islam

    • @AdamElmasriEnglish
      @AdamElmasriEnglish  Месяц назад +1

      It is problematic how this Arabic speaking ex-Christian knows a lot more about Islam than the average Muslim.
      Perhaps this is why he speaks up!

  • @osmansaid4601
    @osmansaid4601 Месяц назад

    Atheist and thinking are oxymoron. I call atheist the magicians

  • @hermitally419
    @hermitally419 Месяц назад

    He's an ex Christian, not an ex Muslim.
    Plus a lot of what he is saying shows utter ignorance of the basics.

    • @AdamElmasriEnglish
      @AdamElmasriEnglish  Месяц назад +1

      I urge you to show the evidence for my utter ignorance!

  • @swalehissa777
    @swalehissa777 Месяц назад +1

    Big liar

    • @echoe4806
      @echoe4806 Месяц назад +1

      What is the lie?

    • @sarakunb621
      @sarakunb621 Месяц назад

      Evidence?

    • @AdamElmasriEnglish
      @AdamElmasriEnglish  Месяц назад +2

      Please tell me what I lied about in this video?

    • @swalehissa777
      @swalehissa777 Месяц назад

      @@AdamElmasriEnglish he said lie about the meaning of christ. Someone selected to be a leader for the children of only Israel who have been lost not for the not for all mankind. And they’re still lost. That’s why we still have problems in Muslim land because of them. Allah only is saviour. Even in your fake bible job 25:4 any man who was born of woman is unclean how can you compare with God. If that man who is islamaphobic. And the interview I will correct them in every thing. 1865 in daloware usa they were allowed to marry 7 years old. Issac married rebecca when she was 3 years old. Joseph 90 married Mary when she 12 years old. In your fake bible.

    • @swalehissa777
      @swalehissa777 Месяц назад

      @@echoe4806 every thing you islamaphobic stinking

  • @sorro9384
    @sorro9384 Месяц назад +5

    Marrying 6 yr old 😢wtf

  • @thepalebluedot4171
    @thepalebluedot4171 Месяц назад

    Adam and Seth, are they blood related ? 😂😂😂