1. All accused servants were with their respective owners that night, confirmed by their owners. 2. The killer covered hemraj's body with cooler panel and bedsheets and then locked the terrace. Why will some outsider do this ? Talwars locked the terrace, they wanted to blame hemraj for it and were waiting to dispose the body of hemraj perhaps next day. They didn't know that it will be such a big drama and they won't get opportunity to dispose the body. 3. After killing two persons, and knowing that parents are sleeping in next room, Killer didn't run away, but he opened personal bar and drank scotch whiskey. Wow...Just wow. 4. When police broke the lock, Talwars kept denying recognizing hemraj...LoL..while his family recognized him. The same person served dinner to the family in same dress just one day ago. And they couldn't recognize? 5. Aarushi's body and surroundings were readjusted, as proved from blood mark patterns, killer was so dumb that he was adjusting aarushi s body and her toys and books instead of running away. 6. Aarushi's room could not be opened from outside without key, parents claim that they forgot key on nearby hanger that day, wow, and same day servants also came...Wow great coincidence. 7. That day Parents gifted a birthday present camera to Aarushi ...too early ....Many days before the birthdate. Again a coincidence ? 8. Aarushi's phone got switched off at 9:40 pm that day, {first time in a recent year} the girl used to chat with her friends till 12:30 AM everyday. She was murdered at around 1 AM, phone got switched off at 9:40...Ok again coincidence. 9. That day Nupur personally brought Aarushi from school to home. Otherwise she used to come with driver other days. Again a coincidence. 10. Nupur's phone was also switch off that day , first time in entire year. Again a coincidence. ? 11. Hemraj did not eat dinner that day, He took food for himself in a plate, but then didn't eat. Usually he used to have dinner at 10 pm. again coincidence ? 12. Talwar claimed that he was awake till around 11:30. But around 12, just one 30 mins later Aarushi's friend Anmol called on home-landline, the phone was kept in Bedroom of Talwars, but no one responded. That day was special. Ok so the 10 PM time is very important, something happened around 10 PM which led to phone-switch off of Aarushi and Hemraj not taking his dinner. 13. Hemraj told a NGO activist that his life was at stake , Activist asked him to tell his owner (Talwars) he said "HE CAN'T". 14. In all this, Wife of Hemraj must be neutral and obviously she has no enmity towards Talwars and no friendship with Servants. If she had doubt about servants she would accuse them, Coz they also killed her husband.. Why did she blame Talwars? She says that her husband told her on call that dentist couple is threatening him, and not paying his salary, so he can't travel back to nepal. Why would his wife lie ? 15. When their only child died, parents didn't cry much, their supporters say every human reacts differently, and I agree When some loved one dies, people get shock & trauma and it's completely normal if they don't cry. BUT Nupur went straight in a television show just few days after murder, and kept uttering cheesy lines like my daughter was my world, flower of my garden and so on. These are filmy & poetic lines, no one becomes poetic after such a big loss, so poetic , that it begins to look scripted and acting , even anchor seemed shocked that how can this woman make such lines under this much pressure & trauma. 16. IG Kaul, CBI noticed that parents were not supportive, and kept giving contradictory statements, and defied orders and kept removing items & renovating their house despite warnings by CBI. All they cared about defending themselves, and showed no interest in finding the culprits. 17. UP police , at first observation accused Talwars until their gang bought CBI IG Arun Kumar who proposed his out of the world theory. 18. CBI final team accused Talwars again on the base of 138 circumstantial evidences, and court convicted them lifetime imprisonment. 19. High Court released them due to lack of direct evidence , but didn't say that they were innocent. ◆ There are only two things people say while defending the Parents : A) Parents can't kill their daughter : it's emotional stereotype, Indrani Mukherjee also killed her daughter, and if you search you will find parents killing & raping their children. It's rare but not impossible. B) in NARCO test Krishna admitted that he killed Hemraj with Khurki : Again a big lie. News channels used selected clips of him, when the doctor put words into his mouth. As part of plan of IG Kumar & Talwars. NARCO test ends mental ability to resist, Person becomes passive, and can't resist much and agrees to the words he listens. That's why this test is not admissible in courts. Take two examples : you & me talking about Earth, I'm saying that Earth is flat, you are laughing at it, and denying it. Now if you're put under NARCO test, and asked What shape earth is? You'll say Round few times, but if asked again n again you'll also say IT'S FLAT, cause somewhere this answer is in your subconscious mind, and you don't want to resist questioner, so you'll admit earth is flat, despite your belief that it's round. Second example : Even if someone ask you 2-3 times under NARCO, that You're alien, aren't you? You'll end up admitting it coz your mind can't resist. Same thing happened with Poor Servants (you can check it yourself in NARCO video)... Servants denied their involvement, hundred times and accused Talwar & their illicit affairs motive behind murder. But doctor kept telling them no you did it, no you did it, don't lie. Lol..And at one instance he just said yes mam. wow. One more thing to be noted that before narco , atleast for 30 Days the servants were tortured and accused often that you killed her with khukri, khukri, khukri. So it was obvious that under NARCO they will give many contradictory statements and that's what happened. NARCO test is like a induced dream. When u live in a environment, dealing with same things for a long period, you'll see dreams about this and talk in sleep about this. But this talk and dream is never reality, you know it. But still in NARCO servants didn't disclose any strong plotline, motive or evidence , but PARENTS DID. The parents were also put under NARCO test, but their video were not made public, as it was not part of the plan by IG Kumar. It is available in CBI's reports though, you can find it on internet. In that narco test : - Dentist couple admitted that Rajesh killed both Arushi & Hemraj with a golf stick. - Whenever the Name of Hemraj was mentioned, the couple showed extreme anger & hate towards Hemraj. Why? So if we can blame Servants on the base of fabricated & edited NARCO video, why can't you blame the parents. They also accepted murdering. This list goes on, even a child can tell that parents killed her. For what reason ? That's mystery.
Bhai itna lamba likhne kya jarurat thi mujse puch lete...Dr talwar already accepted in police custody in front of ssp satish ganesh ..golf stick theory ne yahi se to janam liya...sare evidence rajesh talwar ki car me the except golf stick jo flat me hi chupayi thi .. wo haridwar aasthi visarjan nahi evidence visarjan k liye gya tha ..apne kabi suna hai koi sikh aasthi visarjan karte huye ..esa koi ritual inke waha nahi hai...
@@rajendrakhani8282 Yes, SSP Satish was on point from very beginning, he solved the case entirely. I watched his interviews very sharp mind and truly a man of honour! IG Kumar ne sara case complicated kiya hai...Khair Kumar sahab ki aadat hai elite logo ko bachane ki....Nithari Case me bhi Pandher ko bacha liya unhone...
Dr. T D Dogra is not just a forensic expert, he is an ex-director of AIIMS and also ex-professor of Forensic Medicine. One of the best forensic experts of the nation.
Sir , bahar se koi aye + muder karke Chad par le jaye..phir evidence clean kare..phir bhi family walo ko pata nehi Chalta ??..family members ke bina ye possible hi nehi ha
Arushi murder mystery a long history and shown on TV not only me number of viewers watch it and the case handed over to CBI and charges on her parents MrTalwar and Mrs Talwar proved guilty and jailed for 9a long time now where was this witness at that time?
the way Dr Dogra explained how renowned is the Talvar family is and how much the Aarushi was costly for her parents, actually tells the reasons for so much of negligence in the investigation. Well tried Dr Dogra but perceptions and assumptions are not enough for so many factual raised unsolved questions. May the souls rest in peace.
Madam I've biological kids and adopted kids too. I treat them money the same lines No mine or others. But onebthing I felt. If your own biological kid suffers from any defect syndrome, you feel tensed worried, tearful, think think think etc which ruins you and the child, negativity sweeps in. But if adopted kid has a defect it dies not pinch uou that much. You think.like a doctor, try positive ideas for the child's bright future. As mycadopted children are physically handicapped. Mentally I'm not tensed like other parents whose own children may be having a defect. Here Arushi was a tailor made baby. Yhesexare doctors, they see deaths, accidents... what I saw read in newspapers was arushis mother more cljnging on to husband . If someth8 g happens like that no matter how much educated you scream. But here dark silence was maintained... Anyway people within irongates should know more than outsiders. Big people, moneyed people, influential people....what they utter is correct
After listening to how influential both families were and one grandparent was the professor of this guy, I doubt if this man will speak honestly and he might even try to save the doctor couple if they were the actual murderers. But nobody actually knows what happened that night and I'm only trying to play the devil's advocate role here by giving another angle to this explanation.
Please Read my theories and reply .. Theory 1 नौकर की मौत छत पर हुई थी । एसा हो सकता है कि नौकर कातिल को जानता हो । कातिल आया हो, वो दोनो cigarette या दारू पीने के बहाने छत पर गए हों । वहां उसने नौकर को मारा हो और नीचे आके लडकी को भी मार दिया हो । वो दो चौकीदार जो shift बदलकर काम करते थे उनके बारे मे CBI क्या सोचती है, क्या उनकी जांच हुई ? Imagine करो आप एक flat मे पिछले छ महीने से रह रहे हो, तो जाहिर सी बात है कि आपके वहां के चौकीदार से अच्छी दोस्ती हो जाएगी । एसा बिल्कुल possible है कि उस रात हेमराज ने चौकीदार को बुलाया हो या फिर खुद वो चौकीदार वहां आया हो और ये दोने छत पर गए हों और वहां उसने पहले हेमराज को मारा हो और फिर नीचे आकर Arushi को मारा और एक और important बात , चौकीदार की जगह कोई और व्यक्ति भी हो सकता है, कोई पडोसी या society आस पास का कोई व्यक्ति । और चौकीदार के लिए घर के तालों की चाबियां बनवाना कोई बडी बात नही रही होगी और फिर हम उस नौकरानी को कैसे भूल सकते हैं, उसके लिए चाबी हासिल करना कोई बडी बात नही रही होगी वह भी इसमे मिली हो सकती है । एक बात बताओ, जिस तरह चाबी को ऊपर से नीचे फेंका जा सकता है , उसी तरह नीचे से ऊपर भी फेंका जा सकता है। हो सकता है चौकीदार इसमे मिला हो, उसने पहले हेमराज को मारा, फिर आरुषि को, और बाहर से Lock कर के चाबी balcony से Rajesh को दे दी । और इस बात की भी बहुत संभावना है कि उस Building का कोई व्यक्ति ही कातिल हो, और अगर चौकीदार सच बोल रहा है कि उस रात न कोई Building से अंदर गया और न बाहर आया ,तो यह शक और मजबूत हो जाता है , चाबी को दरवाजे के नीचे से सरका दिया होगा, य अपनी balcony से उनकी balcony मे फेंक दी होगी, या किसी अन्य तरीके से अंदर पहुंचा दी होगी । एक और बहुत important बात, Dr Talwar ने Vo Camera online मंगवाया था, और उसे देने कोई आया था और उस Camera को हेमराज ने recieve किया था उसके बारे मे Police ने क्या पता किया ? Theory 2 मुझे लगता है कि दो या दो से अधिक लोग इसमे शामिल हैं, case कुछ तथ्य एसे हैं जो इस ओर इशारा करते हैं, डाॅ डोगरा (Forensic Expert, जिन्होने सबसे पहले Investigate किया) कहते हैं कि कोई आया था और उसने हेमराज को मारा और मारते वक्त आरुषी ने उसे देख लिया इसलिए उसने आरुषी को भी मार दिया। अब मुझे एक बात बताओ,आरुषी इतनी समझदार तो थी कि Murder का मतलब जानती थी,एक 13 साल की लडकी जो आधी रात को अपने घर मे एक Murder देखती है और आकर चुप चाप सो जाति है ? मां बाप को नही जगाती चीखती नही हैं बस आकर सो जाती है ? यह बहुत अजीब नही है ? मुझे लगता है, कि आरुषी ने Murder तो नही देखा होगा पर हां यह जरूर देखा होगा कि कौन आया है और वो उन्हे शायद जानती थी । खैर जाने या न जाने जो लोग आए थे वो हेमराज को मारने के बाद यह Risk तो नही ले सकते थे कि वो आरुषी को छोड दें और उन्होने उसे भी मार दिया । अब मै कैसे कह सकता हूं कि दो या दो से अधिक लोग थे ? एक बात बताओ Investigation से यह बात पता चली थी कि हेमराज की मौत अरुषी के कमरे मै नही हुई थी यह तो बिल्कुल तय है ,क्योंकि हेमराज के blood और DNA का एक भी Trace उस कमरे मे नही मिला । अब ध्यान से समझो ,हेमराज का खून बहुत बहा था,जिसने भी हेमराज को मारा उसके शरीर पर खून तो उछला ही होगा,अगर वो ही आरुषी का कातिल है तो उसके कमरे मे हेमराज के खून का एक भी सुराग क्यों नही मिला ? जिसने भी हेमराज को मारा, उसने आरुषी की नही मारा यहां तक की वो कमरे मे आया भी नही बाहर से ही चला गया ,आरुषी को दूसरे आदमी ने मारा और फिर वो देनो गायब हो गए , य Parents मे से कोई एक अरुषी का कातिल हो सकता है, भागने वाले ने बाहर से दरवाजे बंद कर दिए । यह बात मानना बहुत मुश्किल है कि इतने कम समय मे सारे सबूत मिटा दिए हों ,वो भी आधी रात अंधेरे मे। हो सकता है आरुषी की मां का किसी के साथ Affair हो , पडोसी आया हो , दोनो को हेमराज आरुषी ने देखा हो और हेमराज को वस लोग समझाने terrace पर ले गए हों..... अब यहां तक सब Normal है, लेकिन धीरे धीरे बात बढी और वहां कहा सुनी हुई हो और हेमराज को मार दिया हो...अब इन्हे नही पता था कि बात बढ जाएगी और हेमराज मर जाएगा । Nupur अंदर चली गई और Arushi को मार दिया हो । लेकिन यह थोडा मुश्किल सा लगता है ,क्योंकि एसा कुछ होता तो Nupur के Narco test मे कुछ तो पता चलता । आप Dr Dogra की Theory मेरी दो या दो से अधिक लोग वाली बात जोडें तो बात कुछ हो सकने वाली लगती है । चौकीदार और Ground floor के पडोसी पर मुझे पूरा शक है, यहां तक की आजू बाजू का कोई Neighbor भी हो सकता है ।
Story of Dr Dogra is indigestible . There can be professional sympathy or old relationship of Talwar couple's parents. In a normal condition , if someone kills so precious single child, how will his / her parents react ? As soon as they know the brutal killing of their child, they will definitely yell, cry and inform police and neighbours . But it didn't happen that night. Talwar couple didn't yell, didn't cry , didn't call police. When the domestic help ( Maid ) came to work in the morning, she found both husband - wife sitting aside to dead body of Arushi patiently and told her that Hemraj killed Arushi and ran away. That maid informed about this incident to neighbours and then Police was informed. Dr Talwar informed police that Hemraj killed her daughter and ran away. He forced police to go to Nepal to search Hemraj and arrest him. Dr Talwar locked the door of upstairs. When Police asked him to open the lock , he told that Key was misplaced. We must not forget that Hemraj's dead body was found on the roof after two days. Why did Dr Talwar misguided police ? Why did he stop Police to go on roof ? There are so many circumstantial evidences which clearly indicate that Killer didn't come from outside.
You are assuming so much about other people's emotion. They were crying after maid entered their house. Hemraj wasn't present so the Talwar in haste directly blamed hemraj and told the police to find him. Why do you think every people should start yelling after looking at dead body of their loved ones? Different People might show different reactions.
Arushi Father Killed her, bcoz she must be having affair with Hemraaz, and they were spending good time with each other, but suddenly her Dad or mom came across this event, so in Anger , Mr Talwar hit the Stick to Arushi and then he took Hemraaz on terrace where he killed Hemraaz. After that , their Daughter left her last breath, then Miss Talwar cleaned her vagina with cotton, and to show this a murder they made cut on Aarushi's body...
@ြğňအ412ř Can you believe this someone came from outside, killed two persons , one of the dead bodies was taken on roof and other one was killed in room and Talwar couple didn't know ? Dono masti se sote rahe. As you say some cry and some freeze ? Not some, Only Talwar couple froze like ice. They were so shocked that they even didn't call police.
Yes, in another case of Mumbai girl of std 9 came home, mother (who took early retirement to pay services to Radha Krishna temple ) as usual was not at home, girl was alone and she saw a rat or cockroach in kitchen therefore couldn't take food from kitchen, she called watchman to get rid of cockroach rat, but that bloody security guard raped her and killed her So even if u don't keep servant, girls are at risk, we have to teach girls to be bold courageous to face any situation Female middle age servants are better Most foolish was her own mother, why she should leave house whn girl is expected to return from school
Exactly! Like I know his father, I know her father! They are very well known doctor and all! What rubbish! I Don't think if this comes in way of investigating one of the more gruesome crimes it won't solve but it will go nowhere! Rubbish!
Mr Dogra sir didn't mention the biggest point that after Murder of Hemraj the roof gate was locked from inside. After few days of murder police came and opened the ROOF GATE from inside. The point is NO MURDERER IN THIS WORLD WILL TRY TO LOCK THE GATE AFTER 2 MURDERS IN THE HOUSE, unless the murderer is from inside the house.
Family members ke bina ye murder possible hi nehi ha. Bahar se koi aa kar do murder kar diye aur kisi ko pata nehi chala ye kaise possible ha??...golf stick wali theory best suit hota ha
Guy kills hemraj on the terrace. He doesnt want the body to be discovered. So he locks it from inside. He then realizes that arushi has seen him in the house. So, he kills arushi. What is so difficult and complicated in this?
Don't know whether he is right or not. I had followed that case that time and being a Doctor it's difficult to digest these things told by Sir. First of all it was not a weapon like Khukri but a sharp weapon like Scalpel which is an Medical instrument. Second thing It was told that Rajesh was awake till half an hour before the time of murder and was using internet from Arushi's room. Third it is difficult to digest that a murder happens next to your room and you don't even know about it. And react to it in the morning when maid comes.
She was sexually assaulted too that's why private parts were cleaned and many person where there at the time of murder this ain't work of one person both were killed with one sharp edged weapon only there was two entrance to house front door & back door it was work of an outsider probably servants coz of circumstances or it's someone else only as said by dr dogra or it's parents only coz of their suspicious behaviour & action
When ppl like Mr Dogra are being used to put blame on the dead, you know what the truth is. Besides all the points you made against the parents, there was no forced entry in the house. That makes it crystal care who did it. The parents cleaned all the evidence. And blame was put on the shoddy investigation. The media, judiciary and the state machinery was all hands in glove with the culprits. Dead cant speak, but those who are alive need to ensure that justice doesnt get lost.
Please Read my theories and reply .. Theory 1 नौकर की मौत छत पर हुई थी । एसा हो सकता है कि नौकर कातिल को जानता हो । कातिल आया हो, वो दोनो cigarette या दारू पीने के बहाने छत पर गए हों । वहां उसने नौकर को मारा हो और नीचे आके लडकी को भी मार दिया हो । वो दो चौकीदार जो shift बदलकर काम करते थे उनके बारे मे CBI क्या सोचती है, क्या उनकी जांच हुई ? Imagine करो आप एक flat मे पिछले छ महीने से रह रहे हो, तो जाहिर सी बात है कि आपके वहां के चौकीदार से अच्छी दोस्ती हो जाएगी । एसा बिल्कुल possible है कि उस रात हेमराज ने चौकीदार को बुलाया हो या फिर खुद वो चौकीदार वहां आया हो और ये दोने छत पर गए हों और वहां उसने पहले हेमराज को मारा हो और फिर नीचे आकर Arushi को मारा और एक और important बात , चौकीदार की जगह कोई और व्यक्ति भी हो सकता है, कोई पडोसी या society आस पास का कोई व्यक्ति । और चौकीदार के लिए घर के तालों की चाबियां बनवाना कोई बडी बात नही रही होगी और फिर हम उस नौकरानी को कैसे भूल सकते हैं, उसके लिए चाबी हासिल करना कोई बडी बात नही रही होगी वह भी इसमे मिली हो सकती है । एक बात बताओ, जिस तरह चाबी को ऊपर से नीचे फेंका जा सकता है , उसी तरह नीचे से ऊपर भी फेंका जा सकता है। हो सकता है चौकीदार इसमे मिला हो, उसने पहले हेमराज को मारा, फिर आरुषि को, और बाहर से Lock कर के चाबी balcony से Rajesh को दे दी । और इस बात की भी बहुत संभावना है कि उस Building का कोई व्यक्ति ही कातिल हो, और अगर चौकीदार सच बोल रहा है कि उस रात न कोई Building से अंदर गया और न बाहर आया ,तो यह शक और मजबूत हो जाता है , चाबी को दरवाजे के नीचे से सरका दिया होगा, य अपनी balcony से उनकी balcony मे फेंक दी होगी, या किसी अन्य तरीके से अंदर पहुंचा दी होगी । एक और बहुत important बात, Dr Talwar ने Vo Camera online मंगवाया था, और उसे देने कोई आया था और उस Camera को हेमराज ने recieve किया था उसके बारे मे Police ने क्या पता किया ? Theory 2 मुझे लगता है कि दो या दो से अधिक लोग इसमे शामिल हैं, case कुछ तथ्य एसे हैं जो इस ओर इशारा करते हैं, डाॅ डोगरा (Forensic Expert, जिन्होने सबसे पहले Investigate किया) कहते हैं कि कोई आया था और उसने हेमराज को मारा और मारते वक्त आरुषी ने उसे देख लिया इसलिए उसने आरुषी को भी मार दिया। अब मुझे एक बात बताओ,आरुषी इतनी समझदार तो थी कि Murder का मतलब जानती थी,एक 13 साल की लडकी जो आधी रात को अपने घर मे एक Murder देखती है और आकर चुप चाप सो जाति है ? मां बाप को नही जगाती चीखती नही हैं बस आकर सो जाती है ? यह बहुत अजीब नही है ? मुझे लगता है, कि आरुषी ने Murder तो नही देखा होगा पर हां यह जरूर देखा होगा कि कौन आया है और वो उन्हे शायद जानती थी । खैर जाने या न जाने जो लोग आए थे वो हेमराज को मारने के बाद यह Risk तो नही ले सकते थे कि वो आरुषी को छोड दें और उन्होने उसे भी मार दिया । अब मै कैसे कह सकता हूं कि दो या दो से अधिक लोग थे ? एक बात बताओ Investigation से यह बात पता चली थी कि हेमराज की मौत अरुषी के कमरे मै नही हुई थी यह तो बिल्कुल तय है ,क्योंकि हेमराज के blood और DNA का एक भी Trace उस कमरे मे नही मिला । अब ध्यान से समझो ,हेमराज का खून बहुत बहा था,जिसने भी हेमराज को मारा उसके शरीर पर खून तो उछला ही होगा,अगर वो ही आरुषी का कातिल है तो उसके कमरे मे हेमराज के खून का एक भी सुराग क्यों नही मिला ? जिसने भी हेमराज को मारा, उसने आरुषी की नही मारा यहां तक की वो कमरे मे आया भी नही बाहर से ही चला गया ,आरुषी को दूसरे आदमी ने मारा और फिर वो देनो गायब हो गए , य Parents मे से कोई एक अरुषी का कातिल हो सकता है, भागने वाले ने बाहर से दरवाजे बंद कर दिए । यह बात मानना बहुत मुश्किल है कि इतने कम समय मे सारे सबूत मिटा दिए हों ,वो भी आधी रात अंधेरे मे। हो सकता है आरुषी की मां का किसी के साथ Affair हो , पडोसी आया हो , दोनो को हेमराज आरुषी ने देखा हो और हेमराज को वस लोग समझाने terrace पर ले गए हों..... अब यहां तक सब Normal है, लेकिन धीरे धीरे बात बढी और वहां कहा सुनी हुई हो और हेमराज को मार दिया हो...अब इन्हे नही पता था कि बात बढ जाएगी और हेमराज मर जाएगा । Nupur अंदर चली गई और Arushi को मार दिया हो । लेकिन यह थोडा मुश्किल सा लगता है ,क्योंकि एसा कुछ होता तो Nupur के Narco test मे कुछ तो पता चलता । आप Dr Dogra की Theory मेरी दो या दो से अधिक लोग वाली बात जोडें तो बात कुछ हो सकने वाली लगती है । चौकीदार और Ground floor के पडोसी पर मुझे पूरा शक है, यहां तक की आजू बाजू का कोई Neighbor भी हो सकता है ।
डाक्टर डोगरा साहब कभी-कभी अनुभव काम नहीं आता है,माफ़ करें आप सीनियर डाक्टर, विशेषज्ञ हो सकते हैं किंतु आपके बयानों से कहानी में हल्का हल्का बनावटी सा लगता है जैसे कि कोई मनगढ़ंत बातें
No dear her parents are very high profile person and they disguised very much Read article in Wikipedia or others IPS Rajesh Pandey also explore it in own view
The most logical explanation of the event, which I had suspected for so many years and now confirmed by expert. Cannot believe our system where parents are jailed for this. The biggest mistake of the parents is that they allowed strangers to get inside the home, it should have been a strict no. They paid very dearly for this one mistake.
@@manikwadhwani4867 by the logic of that cut on throats. Such cuts can only be made my experts, and the lock on the terrace door. It was a lock, why will someone lock the terrace someone lock it?? If some other guy killed hemraj on terrace he could have just killed and ran why he would lock that door??? Tbh the main killer was the parents.
Maa baap ne khoon Kiya hai ye theory to mujhe bhi samajh nahi aayi. Ha ye bilkul theek lagati hai. Ki servent ke dost logo ne murder Kiya. Dr. Sahab ki theory apni jagah bilkul thik bhi hai..
@@sabherwaltraveler5496 janabe ali.. agar Jo log ye kah rahe hai ki parents ne murder Kiya .. kyuki wo Hemraj ke sath dekhi gayi thi. To ye murder unplanned hua. Mr. Talwar ne kya ye socha hoga ki agar ghar Maine police aayegi or wo Terrace par nahi jayegi. Ye chutiyapa hai. Bhai police ki galati thi nahi to ye case kab ka solve ho gaya tha. Movie dekhoo. Maine kal hi dekhi hai..
जब किसी विभाग में आपके कोई जान पहचान या दोस्त रिश्तेदार होते हैं तो आपको जरूर थोड़ा बहुत फायदा मिलता है, इस केस में बहुत से अधिकारी तलवार परिवार के जान पहचान वाले थे फिर भी आरूषि-हेमराज को न्याय नहीं मिला, हाँ ये जान पहचान का फायदा तलवार दम्पति को जरूर मिला।
Nobody at Arushi's home at the time of her murder is above suspicion in this case. Forensic pathologist Tirath Das Dogra's reputation is tainted in this case due to his certificate not being accepted by CBI. Even in this interview, Dr. Dogra is more interested in building the case to absolve Arushi's parents than in giving any new information about the murder. This murder case exposed the incompetence of many investigators associated with this case as well as the press and other people, who damaged or tainted or destroyed the evidence by rushing to the murder location before the investigation authorities could secure the place. The only lesson to be learned by the common man is that parents must prioritize the welfare of their child over working late, partying, or earning more money. Those who cannot put their child's interest above their own have no right to bring a child into this world.
Yes. He does not believe that the talwars can be murderers. May be he knows them.closely and so he has a cause to believe so. The angle of his side should have been studied than coming of fancy kind of stories involving honour killing. They were feom affluent family and mostly they dont mind to see their sibblings with boy friend/girl friwnd. Further thay could have planned such case than becoming hyper.
जब कोई घटना बहुत जटील लग रही हो तो समझ लेना वास्तव में घटना बेहत सरल है सारी जटीलता हमारे विचारोमे है | आरुषी की हत्या उसके माता पिता द्वारा गुसे मे हुई ,परंतु उसके लिये उनको अलग सजा की जरुरत नहीं उनका वर्तमान जीवन ही उनके लिये सजा बन गया है
But still many things are fishy .. normal people are not fools since he is related to Arushi parents he is supporting them and making them guilty free or else why he is publicly coming and telling to media..After so many years🤔
Iski galti he yeh thi ye program mai isne bataya yeh pehle se janta hai Talwar family ko even Talwar parents ko nhi batata toh yakin kar lete iski jhuti kahani par
@@niru7911 there are still many fools around here who are blindly believing the TALWAR movie and keep ranting in every comment section that "why would parents do this to their only child?"
This is a classic case where actually God only knows what happened that night.There are many questions that arise if whatever the doctor is narrating is true. All I can hope n pray for even after so many years is may both the victims soul rest in eternal peace 🕊️
सब अपना अपना राय देते हे आरुषि मर्डर पर लेकिन पुलिस और फॉरेंसिक का काम ही संदिग्ध था आरुषि के हत्या के बाद पुलिस ने हेमराज को फरार बता दिया फिर एक दिन बाद उसी घर के छत पर से हेमराज की लाश मिली, ये कोन सा जांच था की मर्डर के बाद उन्होंने छत पर ताला लगे होने के कारण छत पर जाना जरूरी ही नहीं समझा
FLAWS IN THE THEORY - 1. If that person killed someone on the terrace, why would he lock the balcony door. To hide? And left the Arushi's body in open? Naah .. person will only hide servent's body so people think he is the suspect because of his absence. 2. If my daughter is killed,.am ready to break all the doors of my house if needed. But family didn't let police to break the lock and tell them they r not finding the keys . 3. Arushi was next to her parents room. Little insights.. her room lock can be only open from inside or with key from outside which only parents have. Her room was locked. One person (even the known one) came, broke the door, killed arushi and arushi didn't scream at all..parents didn't even hear the lock breaking noices. Woww.. 4. This person is related and very well known to the family. He said that he knows tha grandfather of the arushi. Most probably chances are they are told to say this in public to save the reputation.
It is shameful people like u fall for sensational media trial and throw parents under the bus who already lose their only child..just shameful..i can answer every point of yours but i know i will be wasting my time
@@27sadhu you are delusional if you think parents are God's and can't do anything wrong. All dysfunctional families psychopaths and narcissist are created by parents. Be realistic and see things for what they are instead of looking at thing's from rose tinted glasses.
1. Because aarushi's murder was unplanned and spontaneous, initial plan was to kill hemraj and hide his body, and people would assume he just ran off and cops wont care to search for a servant too much 2. Just he says she says, you were not there. most likely police gave such allegations against parents in order to make excuse when everyone will ask police why did they not open the terrace door on first day , when they were totally clueless and careless and just assumed servant has run off after murdering the call and didnt bother to open terrace 3. Door could have had key left in as Nupur said , or maybe aarushi came outside to have some snacks from kitchen or maybe heard some noise..either she came out herself assuming it must be hemraj in the kitchen... 4. All the evidence points to outsider with friendly entry...someone who dominated hemraj be it due to loan lender or just being some criminal..he was in hemraj room since 9 pm almost..hemraj was hiding him and was so scared he left his dinner untouched...hemraj also didnt drink, so that explains outsider drinking the alcohol as wine and beer bottle was found...could have been 2people too...find the person who made the 8.30 call from PCO to hemraj and u have the killer
Among all the theories I heard on this case, this one is the most convincing. Truth is always simple and logical. Shame on over-enthusiastic ignorant media who destroyed the evidence due to which the poor girl (and their parents most likely) never got justice. Om Shanti Shanti Shanti.
Hello, both the victims throat was slit with surgical precision. And based on this theory the murderer had enough time to take the body to the servant quarters and lock the room besides cleaning the crime scene of blood and evidence. Finally the main door is also locked which was opened by the maid in the morning from outside when the house lady threw the keys from inside the house. Clearly the parents are the main suspects with motive. What this gentleman is making up some story which does not address the key questions. This was a good cover up by police.
@@kevincastelino3209 exactly..! I haven't even watched this video fully.. I'm at 6th mins of the video.. And I came to understand, that this doctor is on the Thalvars side.. It's clear, that he's biased..
One more point to ponder is that the parents are not actively trying and eager to find out the brutal murderer of their only child..any parent in similar situation would run from pillar to post in punishing the murderer at any cost.
One thing is sure, this case remained unsolved and justice was butchered due to media blunders. Even in 26/11 terrorist attack, it was due to media intervention that the police and army action took so long because media was showing it live and the handlers of the terrorists were giving them inputs from the live coverages only. It was 3rd day that government blocked live reporting of the 26/11 events. I remember that time, it was early 5 am in the morning in our tuition class. Sir was watching the news and one of my friend said "in atankwadiyo ko bhi toh pata chal raha hoga ki kya ho raha he TV mein dikha rahe hein sab". Aek 9th class ke bacche ko ye baat samajh mein aa gayi par media ke so called pade likhe journalists ko nahin. Some of these media personals are vultures. In name of TRP, national security and lives of people were put on stake. Sometimes media in this country is so irresponsible that any sin is undermined in the name of TRP. Same happened in the Arushi case. Poor Arushi ji and Hemraj ji. Media trials really need to stop. Same media is absent when lot of mishappeinings occur in this country. Pahle Rahul Gandhi ji se fursat nahin hoti thi, aur aaj kal Narendra Modi ji se. Ground level issues toh gayab hi ho chuke hein. Unemployment, inflation, economic crisis, education issues, women issues, caste atrocities, poor people, marginalized people, all are lost in the race of TRP. Lagta hi nahin ki is media ke liye gareeb aadmi desh ka hissa bhi he.
Bro both, Rajdeep Sardesai and Barkha Dutt got Padma Shri in 2008 by the congress for their live coverage of the Mumbai terror attacks. I see them no less than any terrorists. They must be put behind the bars coz they got blood on their hands of many innocent people.
If we believe whatever Dr.Dogra said then there are many loopholes which are confusing and need to be cleared first....... 1)If Khemraj was murdered on terrace and Aarushi was murdered in her room by this friend of Khemraj,,then from where the blood came on the steps leading to the terrace?? 2)If Aarushi knew that a friend has come to meet Khemraj at late night why did she not inform her parents?Obviously the friend is threat to her vanity. 3)Even if the friend thought that Aarushi is witness and comes to murder her she would have shouted loudly to alert parents and shouted for help. 4)Worst assumption is saying that the culprit friend drinking whiskey after the double murder.A murderer always runs away from the crime scene as soon as possible.He doesn't sit aramse to drink whiskey ,that too at the victims place. 5) When the maidservant came next morning ,she would have seen some blood stains at the entrance as the murderer left from entrance.But she didn't see any blood there.Only she saw Mrs Talwar coming at the entrance n telling that Khemraj is missing and locked the door.Dats why she throws the duplicate keys for the maidservant . 6)Why will murderer spend some more time in locking the Talwar couple in their own house?And how did he get the keys to lock them inside,he is a stranger to the keys,only Khemraj knew which keys are used where! Dogra being a Dictor,doesn't know the name of IVF,artificial insemination.The way he is telling about the prestigious grandparens and how Aarushi was a valuable child is obviously is to whitewash the Talwars All above questions need to be answered.
Are bhai tere Sare question k javab diye hai unne bas keys vale ko chor kar, or ivf ka naam ni aata ye to bolne ki koi baat ni hai, wo aiims ke director the 😂 koi mamuli banda ni h wo, ye sab saval uske dimag me bhi aaye honge par batana sahi ni samjha because main baat batayi unne
@@sandeepchaudhary9670Why would you assume the killer wouldn't lock the terrace gate or house door. Well guess what the killer did it and now he's free without any suspicions.
@@PhenomenalDiva dear i am stunned that you have commented that these guys didnt harm me so i should keep shut! but since this was a high profile case since 2008 and it has so many web documentaries, and 2 movies. So now the case has become a case of national interest and just like every national interest case i can also comment. And my comment is my opinion that parents have killed the daughter. Period!
@@TheTruthSpeaker007 I didn’t say that u should keep ur mouth shut. But that you or anyone shouldn’t jump on the bandwagon without checking both sides of the coin. Assuming whatever one pleases about people whom they don’t know or have ever been harmed by them In anyway is 100% wrong. If the father had killed the daughter, he would have breathed a sigh of relief & celebrated his freedom when he & his wife was given a clean chit instead of re-opening the case & invite trouble for himself . On that note , I rest my case as I’ve not taken it upon me to debrainwash the brainwashed minds.
He is the one who gave "khukhri" theory, defending parents. Also, his sympathy towards Talwars and connections with them is alarming. Had his story been acceptable, police would have had tried to solve case in this direction as well. We all are aware that there were just 2 possibilities assumed i.e. the Talwars being murderers or Krishna being murderer. The story is simply newly fabricated.
उस रात घर में केवल चार लोग थे, जिनमें दो मार दिये गये और दो जिवित बचे, उस रात बिल्डिंग में न कोई बाहर से आया और न कोई अन्दर से बाहर गया, ये सबसे प्रमुख और पक्की बात है, कत्ल के बाद बहुत सोच समझकर सबूत मिटाये गये, फर्श को साफ किया गया, आरुषि वाली बैडशीट बदली गयी, बार-बार इंटरनेट चालाया गया, टेंशन में रातभर बीयर पीयी गयी..... बाहर से आकर कत्ल करने वाला इतने घण्टे देकर आराम से सबूत नहीं मिटा सकता, पकड़े जाने का भय और वो भी दो लोगों का कत्ल करने बाद, इंसान जल्दी से निकलने की कोशिश करेगा.....
I remember hearing at that time that arushi's parent has a very influential clintale including top notch politicians like mayawati and few more names which i dont remember now..as patients..and from this experts version also it is clear that even her grand parents were also very reputed people in their field...so i think this case will always remain a mystery.
Dogra Sir, you are forgetting that till 12:30 night, Rajesh Talwar was on internet, which he had accepted to CBI officer. You are saying that the person who killed Aarushi & Hemraj, dragged the body to terrace or say killed Hemraj in terrace, killed Aarushi in her room, cleaned her room of any blood stains and then drank whisky from that belonged to Rajesh Talwar, knowing fully well that the parents were sleeping in a room 10 feets away? Sir aap kyon mazaak kar rahein hain?
This case was very neatly explained in a movie named 'talwar'..... what happened during the investigation beginning to end was portrayed very well .... and irfan khan did a great job...
The movie was done to clear Talwar family from the case. See the rich doctor couple in U.P. can never be made accused until and unless they have something fishy to hide. They had enough money to give to police and CBI to put the blame on their servants. If they would not have had any role their name would have never come up. I still believe that it was the father who killed her child in the heat of moment.
@@adarshverma2014 really is that so easy to buy CBI with money.... at first police had no clue who had killed her after they found the body of the servant they made an assumption that this could had happened and started probing her parent ..... although they have all the traces and evidences (on the basis of which forensic probe could be conducted) of murder but they let those destroyed... and preceded the investigation..... the police always do this on the basis of assumption without any evidence.... Why did the police or CBI did not able to prove them guilty.... even after being jailed over 6 months they were evicted...
No one entered from outside. Even if the loan master entered, cannot kill hemraj like that in someone's house based on an argument.Also it was not necessary to kill witness in such a way, whereas all doors locked from inside. The incidence of killing, must require a bigger reason than just a Loan. I don't agree with Doctors story....
If parents killed their child as well as servant and cleaned/cleared evidences do you think they will keep the main gait locked from inside and let police know that nobody could come from outside? The person who killed both Hemraj and Aarushi locked the door from inside and must have escaped by jumping compound wall so that people will suspect that some one from inside the home killed both of them.
@@Anonymo13 they didn't had much time to think about all this as it was not pre planned. If what you say is true then how did the murderer escaped? , why bedshits were changed from Aarushi's room? why her private part was cleaned with chemicals ( which only doctors know), why they let people come inside house and spoil the evidence/dna? why their wifi was used in midnight? why there were phone calls made during mid night? all are coincidence?there are a lot of such circumstancial evidences which points towards them.
@@loveandlife5274 yess... everyone think tht parents killed arushi but why a 14 year old girl will hv physical relation wth an old age man...other theory says tht arushi got to know about the wife swapping thing she got depressed and fought with them for same
सबसे पहले तो एक वरिष्ठ नागरिक के सामने किस तरीके से बैठ जाता है उसेसीखो आप एक वरिष्ठ नागरिक के सामने टेबल पर बैठे हैं आपके जूनियर भी इस प्रकार सेही बैठे हैं कोई कॉलेज का प्रोग्राम तो यह किसी चाय की थड़ीपर बैठे हैं आपने एक वरिष्ठ नागरिक का अपमान किया है और आप जैसे एगोइस्ट पत्रकार किसी कर्म के नहीं है
Exactly Remembers the Next Day's News Paper when it happened. I read it that time and followed this case for a long time. I watched the movie also but Today after 15 years of this gruesome massacre, I came to know the actual reason for her Death. May her Soul Rest in Peace.🕊️
I have read the entire book by Aviruk Sen. Mr. Dogra it seems don't know what he is talking about. Aviruk Sen specifically mentioned that the three friends of Hemraj were involved in murder. The NARCO test was conducted and it is mentioned in book with all the summary that all the three agreed that they were at Hemraj house and one of them had killed Arushi. I just want to know how in the hell three people who in the eyes of judiciary had not committed murder agree to be at Talwar's house and one of them agreeing murdering Arushi. Not only the culprits but entire police force is to be blamed for this mess. The parents were imprisoned not because they were found guilty but police had no evidence that any other person might have entered the house to commit murder (even though they had evidence but had neglected time over time).
Why no one from outside could have killed arushi- 1. Body of Hemraj was on roof that was locked from inside. Only Servant of house or Family Members knows about where are Keys for roof. Also No one can jump roofs to go in and out of that Colony as it has one gate with watchman and then also lock stairs from inside. 2. The blood of hemraj had drag marks from terrace roof means body was dragged upstairs but whole blood till stairs and door of terrace was cleaned mostly. 3. Person has high intelligence to put body against ac exhaust so body decompose smell continuously flys away. 4. The cuts on neck made on Arushi was smaller in length uniform like professional and was put after her death from head injury. While hemraj died from longer uniform neck cut and was also hit. 5. Hemraj has Head injury at back side and Arushi had neck injury on from right side of head. And was hit with same object, suggesting Murder hitted Arushi and hemraj at same time but Arushi died and Hemraj must have went in shock or unconscious state. 6. To remove blood you need to have Required right material to clean evidence that not any normal person knows what to use. 7. The case was not of robbery but still Hemraj and Arushi’s mobile went missing. Why will someone take away their phones they aren’t worth anything. Only in case of those phones have some call records or data that can suspect suspicions you need to hide them. And if killer is from outside they wont call arushi but only hemraj so only Hemraj phone should have went missing. 8. If someones dear daughter dies you would work for her justice and well aware as doctor for crime scene evidence maintenance. You wont get house cleaned in 2 days with special solutions. You would go with police to make sure the process of catching Hemraj is expedited not just sit and wait until you already know he is dead too. 10. Interestingly there were two golf sticks in camera scene photographs but police had one in possession how would one golf stick missed as if grif stricken dad going in and out for investigation and jail was thinking to play golf? And he later on 2-3 years handed that stick to cbi! 11. The request of family members to forensic team to not to mention any assault if any is also strange as a family you would fight for your dead daughters justice as they didn’t know hemraj was dead till then considering he was alive. 12. Reports suggest her clothes were changed after death even innerwears and private ares were very well cleaned up- (this part not so sure though) So you all can draw the inference! I rest my case.
Also the thing is hemeaj"s body was hidden with sheets. Why outsider will try to hide the body? Talwar family just wanted to hide the body so that they could disposs it off when the right time came.
Your comment is complete BS. It's the job of the police and forensic teams to bring the correct evidence from the scene FOR investigation. When the police messed up COMPLETELY and allowed 100s of people into the house before investigation even started, why blame this Senior doctor???
मैं भी पूरे दिन टीवी पर देखा करती थी,मुझे नूपुर तलवार को देखकर उसकी बातों से नहीं लगा कि वो किसी सदमे जैसे स्थिति में है। जिसके एक मात्र बेटी की हत्या हो गई हो वह इतनी सहनशीलता से सब कुछ बयां नही कर सकते, जैसे वो कर रही थी। कुछ तो है??
जी सही कह रहे हैं. आरुषि जैसी प्यारी बच्ची को अभी भी पूरा न्याय नहीं मिला है उस समय भी एक और परिवार.. और घर के दूसरे जो इनके निकट हैं...कई सबूत मिटाने की बात सामने आई थी. तथाकथित High profile... या किसी भी परिवार का कोई गहरा राज कोई बच्चा जान जाए तो उसे रास्ते से हुआ देते हैं. दो मुखौटे वाले लोग. समाज की एक कड़वी सच्चाई है..हेमराज की बॉडी नहीं मिलती तो उसे ही लोग गुनहगार समझते रहते आज तक.
With due regards, this version of the case misses the fact that the alleged murderer must have exited the house as well. But in the morning when the maid arrived, the main door was locked from inside and the terrace door was also locked from inside. Leaving no other way from which the alleged person must have escaped.
@@luciifer666 from Wikipedia (it points to a media report on web archieve, check that if you don't trust wiki), search "painting" if you want to skip to the relevant section en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Noida_double_murder_case#The_case_against_the_Talwars
May her soul rest in Peace. I was in 9th standard when this case came out, now I am old & understand life much better. One should not trust anybody except their parents it becomes more important for girls to do so.
@@anuraganurag7505 oh right ., that’s why they served jailed time & not because they tried to reopen the case despite being given a clean chit by the CBI & courts. 🤦♀️
Sourabh sir, in my polite opinion, whenever you do interview, please let speaker talk his complete story, to make any sense! Otherwise interview is quite raw and worth listening to!
A person who gives a loan does not kill. Having a young girl in the family and a man servant is a strict no no, and then he used to be alone with her when the parents did not come back from work. This person is trying to protect the family. They did it out of rage and it was an accidental murder of the daughter. Hem Raj was punished thereafter and was killed when he ran to the roof to escape.
She was sexually assaulted too that's why private parts were cleaned and many person where there at the time of murder this ain't work of one person both were killed with one sharp edged weapon only there was two entrance to house front door & back door it was work of an outsider probably servants coz of circumstances or it's someone else only as said by dr dogra or it's parents only coz of their suspicious behaviour & action..
Dogra Sir, I have heard the interview of Hemraj's wife in Nepal, she did not mention about any house. They were living in their mud house ... with handicapped son. Were you not the person in AIIMS who gave fake certificate that ONLY khukhri could have made those cuts ... your certificate was not acceptable to CBI. If you can prove that Hemraj had made a new house in Nepal, just one report or photograph , I will accept your theory.
He is making up a story. Loan master kills the man coz he was not paying up. Why he wld murder him? He needs to get his money back. He will scare him, beat him up etc. Totally baseless story. This is something cooked in the family only. Parents behaviour in the next morning says that. What is this docs explanation for girl's washed private part or the wetness behind her bottom.
Wow, what a beautiful story teller is Mr. Tirath Das Gupta, he has self exposed himself that he was a Student of Arushi's Grandfather's. And he is described fantastically that Arushi's murdered had been executed by the persons from which Hemraj has taken Home Loans......Mr. Tirath Das Dogra indirectly told the truth that who is murdered and acclaimed that the murderer was very known to Arushi...... Now what is left to understand....
@@bharatmanvendrakaushik his theory is bogus and almost nobody agrees with it, there are so many plot holes in this, to name a few why would this X killer would lock the terrace gate after killing hemraj, also arushi did not die due to the cut in the neck but due to the blunt force trauma on the head, how did the killer get the access to Arushis room which was supposed to be locked, what about the bloody finger print on the glass, why was arushis body cleaned, this guy is sold out and trying to save talwar's
@@ssdfhuasdfhj101ocking the terrace door has no specific meaning but what any person does subconsciously rather than just leaving it open, also arushis room can be opened from inside, he might have knocked the door as that was the only option to kill her, if he was known to her.also only thing that confuses me is that why he took time to stage her body after killing her, if eliminating the eye witness after killing hemraj was his only motive , why would he spend time with arushis body and increase his chances of getting caught by her parents, who were in the next room.
@@2284917 the door was not just bolted, it was locked with a lock that is something very puzzling, also the face of arushi was covered, it is a well known forencis theory that killers that are related to victim tend to cover their dead face as they cannot look at the face
Question 1. How come the door was closed from inside and did both parents not see anything ? 2. As it was observed by investigation that the cut made was with professional medical equipment in a perfect manner so was the financer (if he was) qualified to make a precise cut ? 3. Why was the body cremated before the post mortem ?
@@RahulHaritOfficial it's also very strange that why would a murderer pull the body all the way up to the roof after the murder. His motive was finished once he murdered , his next move would be to leave the house ASAP and not drag that heavy body to the stairs and if he had the access to the keys and knowledge of stairs then he also must have known that the Talwars were next door. So he kills Hemraj and Arushi , drags hemrajs body while the Talwars are present and spares them. Quite weird and Delhi police would have solved this case in 3 days if they were not corrupt. Also isn't it weird that Arushi's body was quickly cremated before her postmortem. No parent would let their murdered child be cremated before they know the exact reason of death and time of murder of their beloved child which is only possible with the help of Postmortem.
@@vaishalivats5005 Yeah as if Talwars wouldn't have given money to its producers to clear their name in front of public. You must be one of those to believe that Sanjay Dutt has quit taking hard drugs after watching the movie Sanju.
@@nuclear9977 no it's not like that but still question remains. It was resolved on the basis of theory as facts were manipulated at earlier investigation which means knowing the law fact and responsible doctors body was cremated without autopsy. So doubt will always remain whatsoever theory is presented.
There are few discrpancies Why was Hemrajs body covered and hidden in such a way it could not be seen WHY WAS THE TERRACE DOOR LOCKED ? Why would a killer take all the efforts to lock the terrace door. Mind you the Terrace door lock keys were with the Talwars, since they could not come as they were immersing Arushis ashes, they told the police to break the lock. Why would the killer sit down and drink whisky after murdering, there were blood marks on whisky bottle. Normal reaction of killer SHOULD be to make a hasty exit. Why was there router/internet activity in Rajeshs room deep into the night If Hemraj was murdered on terrace why there were blood trails on stairs. Why were Arushis remains disposed of the next day itself. Normally they are done on 10/11/12th day. If the parents were "Educated" why did they allow the crime scene to be contaminated by all relatives and nieghbours. Why was Arushis room cleaned before police arrived, why were mattresses removed And many more........
In a documentary i saw When the maid came in the morning, the door was locked from inside. The dead body of Hemraj was found 2 days after his murder on the terrace. The gate of the terrace was locked, when police asked Arushi's parents about keys they said they don't know where the Keys.
इतना कुछ होता रहा और तलवार दाम्पति पूरी रात चैन की नींद सोते रहे... Nice और नौकर के बारे मे कोई जानकरी न रखना भी अच्छी बात है... 👌बहुत आदर्श व्यक्ति थे दोनों... 😂
बिलकुल सही कह रहे हैं कोई बाहर से आया ही नहीं ये उन दिनों मीडिया में ख़ूब आ रहा था… CBI अदालत ने माता पिता को आरोपी ठहराते हुए आजीवन कारावास दिया था बाद में सबूत न मिलने पर उनको निर्दोष क़रार दे दिया गया । जैसे श्रद्धा आफ़ताब केस ,इसमें आफ़ताब ने क़बूल भी कर लिया कि उसी ने मारा है उसी ने टुकड़े किया है फिर भी सबूत जुटाने में लगे हैं
@@Vijaykmr11 schi bta yr mera to sala dinag khrab ho gya Kon murderer hai yaar? Agar hemraj ke dost nepali ne dono ko mara hai to Us time arushi ke mmy papa kahan the?😅
If arushi had seen the murder she might have raised her voice or ran to her parents room why didn't her parents woke up till then ? Doctor is known to talwar family it's ok and good , but why known person got taken as investigating doctor in this case ?
She had not seen the murder...but she had seen him coming to home...and later when the murder of hemraj would have been found..she would be the eye witness of his friend coming to meet him at night
When the doctor has personal acquaintance with the main accused i.e. her parents, his opinions are bound to be partial. Opinions should only be taken from a third party who is not related to the victim or the accused and can give impartial information. I am sure Dr. is giving his opinion based on his experience but he does seem influenced by her parents.
She was sexually assaulted too that's why private parts were cleaned and many person where there at the time of murder this ain't work of one person both were killed with one sharp edged weapon only there was two entrance to house front door & back door it was work of an outsider probably servants coz of circumstances or it's someone else only as said by dr dogra or it's parents only coz of their suspicious behaviour & action
Arushis mom never pressed the police to find the killer and once said "I hope someone is out there who has killed her".. What does this mean.. Hope.... It means she is not even sure if someone killed her... If her daughter was killed by someone they would have gone crazy with anger.. But they have been always calm
I don't agree with this theory - a professional killer will never made a mistake to kill someone in someone else house. Aarushi's Parents didn't know who is coming to there home is unbelievable as well. In the end,its like noone killed both as Parents proved not guilty n noone else either. A sad ending n heartbreaking too as both deserved justice!!!
Only a person who is VERY JUST n MORAL can write such a LONG POSTS to expose d CULPRITS !!.👍♥️.D thing s sm1 CARES..!! N cant see any1 being WRONGED !! Hats off Mr. Vingurjar 👍🧡💞
Extremely tragic🥲may their Souls rest in peace 🙏🏽can’t imagine how the Parents lived their life after their only child murdered and they were sent to prison ..no one knows what happened that night
I am not questioning the credibility of the guest but the fact is that we still don't know who killed Arushi.. justice is yet to be served & our judiciary system has failed big time atleast in this case.. What can i say man😔 May her soul rest in peace.. Om Shanti🙏
It's not judiciary's fault. Rather the fault is solely of our investigating agencies. Judge ko pehle din se pata hota hai ki kaun guilty hai. Wo evidence ka wait karte rehta hai par evidence nhi aata hai.
@@vaibhavsingh471 Aap ne jo kaha yeh sab film o me achcha lagta hai but With all due respect I think it is,and let me be very clear I am not saying our judiciary system is a failure or fuck things up every time but man..there are few instances like that and court has the power to make the decision,atleast they should have set examples by punishing those Cops hard..there was a unforgiving amount of negligence during first investigation so yeah,I wish I have kinder words but it is what it is..most of us in our society specially in powerfull postions people who doesn't give a flying fish and has no fear for judicial system whatsoever..
She was sexually assaulted too that's why private parts were cleaned and many person where there at the time of murder this ain't work of one person both were killed with one sharp edged weapon only there was two entrance to house front door & back door it was work of an outsider probably servants coz of circumstances or it's someone else only as said by dr dogra or it's parents only coz of their suspicious behaviour & action
Who killed ssr,disha salian ,jiah khan.Disha was raped and thrown naked from the 4th floor of a party attended by well known goondas and passed off as suicide.The same type of mafia connected with politicians have raped and killed arushi.Our police are not so foolish as to not to find out but they are helpless. Crime scene kn arushi and ssr case was thoroughly destroyed by professional person not by parents and the whole drama was presented to the public.
@@SheilaRoy-d4d Lol now who will target one 13 yr old girl to rape and kill her that too in her own house when parents are present at house ssr case is different where mafia politicians are involved somewhat i suspect her ex bf coz he is a big shot guy he was desperate for her and she also used to avoid him also hemraj called to dubai one day before murder also talvar were members of wife swapping club swingers used to come at their house possibly this all can be connected but it can't be revealed
This guys version makes more sense than everything we have heard about this case until now. May that little girl's soul rest in peace...my heart was with the parents even then and still goes to them...I wish this case would have been solved for the sake of the parents and the stigma attached....what a shame...
I don't understand how people can believe this newly fabricated theory. If the killer was someone else (who gave loan) that means krishna and other servants are innocent. And then his narco test confession and what was shown in TALWAR movie was also wrong. This doctor is simply trying to defend parents in some way or the other. He himself said that he personally knows rajesh talwar's father.
This is the most clear and plausible dissection of this case I have ever seen / heard. The evidence backs up this forensic pathologists version. R.I.P Arushi. Question is....will the killer ever be found?
@@john2007150 if u had followed the case from start 2 finish u would know why they couldn’t hear anything . The aircon in their room made a lot of noise due to which no noise from the outside could be heard in their room. The CBI even did a drill test & confirmed that indeed nothing can be heard inside when the aircon was on.
Nice story created. Raat ko chhote bachon ko sunana. Do kamre ke makan mein do murder or parents ko pata he nahi. Only Rajesh Tawar killed them with golf stick. Dr. Sahib ko kitne paise mile hain false story sunane ke.
It's hard to believe that these gruesome murders happened without anyone noticing it. Either the killer was an absolute expert at causing damage to the voice box, or it was an inside job. may be both. Arushi and Hemraj both deserve justice, but the question is: will it be served?💔
Itne saal nahi hua...ab kya hoga....same in Sushant Singh Rajput murder case..all the evidences were destroyed and a fictitious story was build up to make it look like suicide
Killer wasn't an expert, he left clues and evidence in abundance but our authorities and media were expert in mishandling the case and destroying those evodences.
Are Arushi k parents ne hi mara, this old man defending them because of connections with them, Talwar family had excellent connections with influenced people, even in CBI
This theory of Dogra is likely incorrect if the Loan person killed both then who locked the Door from the inside, as it was clearly reported when the maid came in the morning it was locked from the inside.
Dear no one knows about the door theory and the house help clearly said she dosn remember if the house was locked from inside. So it was the other servant Krishna pls watch this documentary Arushi beyond reasonable doubts ul kno the truth.
Aarushi was murdered by her own parents. Pls understand that if an outsider killer did this, he would have not locked the terrace door and then killed aarushi & left so easily. it was the parents who did this & only god knows the reason behind this. One more thing i would like to highlight if this was done by any servant they would have cracked down in front of police...it was a well planned murder and only an educated person like her parents could plan all this as hemraj was killed brutally however aarushi throat was slit like a surgeon cut, Not easy to kill their own child in a brutal way. This will remain a mystery and a poor soul left for her heavenly abode without getting a justice 😔
Absolutely!!! Parents ne naukar ko maar kar chhat par chupa diya aur seedha blame bhi ussi par lga diyaa, iss case mein kuch bhi nahi tha, totally open tha,but media ne achcha bewakoof banaaya,
Dr. Dogra looks upto the Talwar family, one of them was a senior professor of his. There are several discrepancies- the finger points towards the parents.
Whoever is saying that the parents are the murders answer me these:- 1.Hemraj phone being picked up in the morning for 2 sec then getting disconnected at 1 km radius. Hemraj ka phone Ghar ke bahar kese gaya if parents were the murders Clearly indicates murderer was an outsider 2. Why would they kill their daughter? Ohh because they caught her with hemraj in between a intercourse? Tell me koi golf stick uthane room se bahar kyu jayfa woh bare hands se Hemraj ko hata sakta aur usse peet sakta tha Par nhi woh pehle room se bahar golf stick laya fir usse mara. 3. The Pillow cover with blood stains was found at Krishna's house. Along with a kukri. 4.Camera was gifted early:- That's because it arrived via courier a day before also the parents wanted to give her a early birthday surprise because arushi wanted to record his 14th birthday. Aur agar unhone usse birthday se 8 din pehle de diya camera on the same day of murder Iska matlab toh murder pre-planned kiya hoga parents ne?? This contradicts the theory that hemraj was caught with Arushi 5.Lack of Motive: The Talwars were speculated to have committed the murders due to a perceived motive related to honor or personal issues. However, proponents of the outsider theory argue there was no substantial evidence linking them directly to the crime. You can check what a beautiful message Arushi had wrote for her mother on mother's day 4 days before the murder indicating no conflict between the two I can 100% Bet that the killer was an outsider As someone called hemraj from A nearby PCO before the murders happened.
@@hyp3842 Let me give you 4 perfect facts which may change your mind:- A) If an outsider killed hemraj, Why would he locked the door and left locking the main door B) Aarushi friend called at 12 am on landline which was kept in rajesh room, Why didnt he lifted the call? C) Hemraj was killed brutally not aarushi, again indicated that outsider should not have any sympathy for her too while killing D) Aarushi and hemraj phone got switched off at 10 pm, Nupur phone also got switched off around same time which is not a coincidence but a planned thing. Her phone got switched off first time in a year, what a coincidence? Please understand if this would have been done by servants, police would have cracked them in a day. Parent killed them both...Believe it or not
@@nitinpoplyA new modified Theory... . Someone very familiar well known with Hemraj and Aarushi had quarrel with Hemraj that night . He must be dominating Hemraj with money borrowing . Under influence of alcohol Unknown killed hemarj first . Aarushi witnessed that and was killed by unknown . Parents got to know this And tried to cover up everything so that blame would not come on them ... Any objection to this theory
लल्लन भाई कोर्ट के अंतिम डिसीजन को यदि word by word यदि पढ़ लेते तो ये वीडियो आप अपने सस्ती लोकप्रियता के लिए नही बनाते। अब इस मुद्दे को उछाल कर आप बेमतलब का मुद्दा मात्र अपने चैनल का व्यू बढ़ाने के लिए कर रहे हो। सब जानते हैं क्या हुआ और कोर्ट का भी quote भी पढ़ लिया करो।
I don't believe his theory, the terrace was locked and the parents refused to give the keys at first place. As per forensic arushi's was killed at around 2-3 AM in the night.
Ye baat kisne batai k unhone Dene se mana kiya police ne khud check nai kiya toh unpe blame daal diya ghar ka Tala toh tha nai k bina permission k tod nai sakte the jiske ghar pe khoon hua uski Har ek baat mani police ne
@@Akankshasingh-ci7nd पहली बार ताला तो था न। उसकी चाबी के लिया कहा था हेमराज को पता होगी। ताला अंदर से लगा यही एक एविडेंस पैरेंट्स के खिलाफ। पूरा खेल खेला तलवार ने।
Yes, correct. No one entered from outside. Even if the loan master entered, cannot kill hemraj like that in someone's house based on an argument.Also it was not necessary to kill witness in such a way, whereas as all doors locked from inside
In that case, if the parents are not guilty, they must be definately knowing the person who's guilty. If the murderer was known to Arushi & Hemraj, parents must also be having some idea, who's it
She was sexually assaulted too that's why private parts were cleaned and many person where there at the time of murder this ain't work of one person both were killed with one sharp edged weapon only there was two entrance to house front door & back door it was work of an outsider probably servants coz of circumstances or it's someone else only as said by dr dogra or it's parents only coz of their suspicious behaviour & action..
1. All accused servants were with their respective owners that night, confirmed by their owners.
2. The killer covered hemraj's body with cooler panel and bedsheets and then locked the terrace. Why will some outsider do this ?
Talwars locked the terrace, they wanted to blame hemraj for it and were waiting to dispose the body of hemraj perhaps next day. They didn't know that it will be such a big drama and they won't get opportunity to dispose the body.
3. After killing two persons, and knowing that parents are sleeping in next room, Killer didn't run away, but he opened personal bar and drank scotch whiskey. Wow...Just wow.
4. When police broke the lock, Talwars kept denying recognizing hemraj...LoL..while his family recognized him. The same person served dinner to the family in same dress just one day ago. And they couldn't recognize?
5. Aarushi's body and surroundings were readjusted, as proved from blood mark patterns, killer was so dumb that he was adjusting aarushi s body and her toys and books instead of running away.
6. Aarushi's room could not be opened from outside without key, parents claim that they forgot key on nearby hanger that day, wow, and same day servants also came...Wow great coincidence.
7. That day Parents gifted a birthday present camera to Aarushi ...too early ....Many days before the birthdate. Again a coincidence ?
8. Aarushi's phone got switched off at 9:40 pm that day, {first time in a recent year} the girl used to chat with her friends till 12:30 AM everyday. She was murdered at around 1 AM, phone got switched off at 9:40...Ok again coincidence.
9. That day Nupur personally brought Aarushi from school to home. Otherwise she used to come with driver other days. Again a coincidence.
10. Nupur's phone was also switch off that day , first time in entire year. Again a coincidence. ?
11. Hemraj did not eat dinner that day, He took food for himself in a plate, but then didn't eat. Usually he used to have dinner at 10 pm. again coincidence ?
12. Talwar claimed that he was awake till around 11:30. But around 12, just one 30 mins later Aarushi's friend Anmol called on home-landline, the phone was kept in Bedroom of Talwars, but no one responded.
That day was special.
Ok so the 10 PM time is very important, something happened around 10 PM which led to phone-switch off of Aarushi and Hemraj not taking his dinner.
13. Hemraj told a NGO activist that his life was at stake , Activist asked him to tell his owner (Talwars) he said "HE CAN'T".
14. In all this, Wife of Hemraj must be neutral and obviously she has no enmity towards Talwars and no friendship with Servants.
If she had doubt about servants she would accuse them, Coz they also killed her husband..
Why did she blame Talwars?
She says that her husband told her on call that dentist couple is threatening him, and not paying his salary, so he can't travel back to nepal.
Why would his wife lie ?
15. When their only child died, parents didn't cry much, their supporters say every human reacts differently, and I agree When some loved one dies, people get shock & trauma and it's completely normal if they don't cry.
BUT
Nupur went straight in a television show just few days after murder, and kept uttering cheesy lines like my daughter was my world, flower of my garden and so on.
These are filmy & poetic lines, no one becomes poetic after such a big loss, so poetic , that it begins to look scripted and acting , even anchor seemed shocked that how can this woman make such lines under this much pressure & trauma.
16. IG Kaul, CBI noticed that parents were not supportive, and kept giving contradictory statements, and defied orders and kept removing items & renovating their house despite warnings by CBI. All they cared about defending themselves, and showed no interest in finding the culprits.
17. UP police , at first observation accused Talwars until their gang bought CBI IG Arun Kumar who proposed his out of the world theory.
18. CBI final team accused Talwars again on the base of 138 circumstantial evidences, and court convicted them lifetime imprisonment.
19. High Court released them due to lack of direct evidence , but didn't say that they were innocent.
◆ There are only two things people say while defending the Parents :
A) Parents can't kill their daughter : it's emotional stereotype, Indrani Mukherjee also killed her daughter, and if you search you will find parents killing & raping their children. It's rare but not impossible.
B) in NARCO test Krishna admitted that he killed Hemraj with Khurki : Again a big lie. News channels used selected clips of him, when the doctor put words into his mouth. As part of plan of IG Kumar & Talwars.
NARCO test ends mental ability to resist, Person becomes passive, and can't resist much and agrees to the words he listens. That's why this test is not admissible in courts.
Take two examples : you & me talking about Earth, I'm saying that Earth is flat, you are laughing at it, and denying it.
Now if you're put under NARCO test, and asked What shape earth is? You'll say Round few times, but if asked again n again you'll also say IT'S FLAT, cause somewhere this answer is in your subconscious mind, and you don't want to resist questioner, so you'll admit earth is flat, despite your belief that it's round.
Second example : Even if someone ask you 2-3 times under NARCO, that You're alien, aren't you? You'll end up admitting it coz your mind can't resist.
Same thing happened with Poor Servants (you can check it yourself in NARCO video)...
Servants denied their involvement, hundred times and accused Talwar & their illicit affairs motive behind murder.
But doctor kept telling them no you did it, no you did it, don't lie. Lol..And at one instance he just said yes mam. wow.
One more thing to be noted that before narco , atleast for 30 Days the servants were tortured and accused often that you killed her with khukri, khukri, khukri. So it was obvious that under NARCO they will give many contradictory statements and that's what happened.
NARCO test is like a induced dream. When u live in a environment, dealing with same things for a long period, you'll see dreams about this and talk in sleep about this. But this talk and dream is never reality, you know it.
But still in NARCO servants didn't disclose any strong plotline, motive or evidence , but PARENTS DID.
The parents were also put under NARCO test, but their video were not made public, as it was not part of the plan by IG Kumar. It is available in CBI's reports though, you can find it on internet.
In that narco test :
- Dentist couple admitted that Rajesh killed both Arushi & Hemraj with a golf stick.
- Whenever the Name of Hemraj was mentioned, the couple showed extreme anger & hate towards Hemraj.
Why?
So if we can blame Servants on the base of fabricated & edited NARCO video, why can't you blame the parents. They also accepted murdering.
This list goes on, even a child can tell that parents killed her. For what reason ? That's mystery.
Everything Is so true
Bhai itna lamba likhne kya jarurat thi mujse puch lete...Dr talwar already accepted in police custody in front of ssp satish ganesh ..golf stick theory ne yahi se to janam liya...sare evidence rajesh talwar ki car me the except golf stick jo flat me hi chupayi thi .. wo haridwar aasthi visarjan nahi evidence visarjan k liye gya tha ..apne kabi suna hai koi sikh aasthi visarjan karte huye ..esa koi ritual inke waha nahi hai...
Bang on. Very real systematic explanations.
@@rajendrakhani8282 Yes, SSP Satish was on point from very beginning, he solved the case entirely. I watched his interviews very sharp mind and truly a man of honour!
IG Kumar ne sara case complicated kiya hai...Khair Kumar sahab ki aadat hai elite logo ko bachane ki....Nithari Case me bhi Pandher ko bacha liya unhone...
Woah 😮
"Agar app meri story janana chaho to bata deta hoon" - A tight slap on the ever interrupting journalist.
😂
It was so irritating to see the interruptions
😆😆😆😆😆😆
😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂
Dr. T D Dogra is not just a forensic expert, he is an ex-director of AIIMS and also ex-professor of Forensic Medicine. One of the best forensic experts of the nation.
⁰⁰
He clearly lost his mind here
Sir , bahar se koi aye + muder karke Chad par le jaye..phir evidence clean kare..phir bhi family walo ko pata nehi Chalta ??..family members ke bina ye possible hi nehi ha
Exactly
Arushi murder mystery a long history and shown on TV not only me number of viewers watch it and the case handed over to CBI and charges on her parents MrTalwar and Mrs Talwar proved guilty and jailed for 9a long time now where was this witness at that time?
the way Dr Dogra explained how renowned is the Talvar family is and how much the Aarushi was costly for her parents, actually tells the reasons for so much of negligence in the investigation. Well tried Dr Dogra but perceptions and assumptions are not enough for so many factual raised unsolved questions.
May the souls rest in peace.
Madam I've biological kids and adopted kids too. I treat them money the same lines
No mine or others. But onebthing I felt. If your own biological kid suffers from any defect syndrome, you feel tensed worried, tearful, think think think etc which ruins you and the child, negativity sweeps in. But if adopted kid has a defect it dies not pinch uou that much. You think.like a doctor, try positive ideas for the child's bright future. As mycadopted children are physically handicapped. Mentally I'm not tensed like other parents whose own children may be having a defect.
Here Arushi was a tailor made baby. Yhesexare doctors, they see deaths, accidents... what I saw read in newspapers was arushis mother more cljnging on to husband . If someth8 g happens like that no matter how much educated you scream. But here dark silence was maintained... Anyway people within irongates should know more than outsiders. Big people, moneyed people, influential people....what they utter is correct
I don't understand ma'am what are you trying to explain. This comment is only on the negligence in investigation nothing else
Maam kuch samajh me nahi aaya, that what you are talking about....?@@geethascharlu7098
After listening to how influential both families were and one grandparent was the professor of this guy, I doubt if this man will speak honestly and he might even try to save the doctor couple if they were the actual murderers. But nobody actually knows what happened that night and I'm only trying to play the devil's advocate role here by giving another angle to this explanation.
Please Read my theories and reply ..
Theory 1
नौकर की मौत छत पर हुई थी । एसा हो सकता है कि नौकर कातिल को जानता हो । कातिल आया हो, वो दोनो cigarette या दारू पीने के बहाने छत पर गए हों । वहां उसने नौकर को मारा हो और नीचे आके लडकी को भी मार दिया हो ।
वो दो चौकीदार जो shift बदलकर काम करते थे उनके बारे मे CBI क्या सोचती है, क्या उनकी जांच हुई ?
Imagine करो आप एक flat मे पिछले छ महीने से रह रहे हो, तो जाहिर सी बात है कि आपके वहां के चौकीदार से अच्छी दोस्ती हो जाएगी । एसा बिल्कुल possible है कि उस रात हेमराज ने चौकीदार को बुलाया हो या फिर खुद वो चौकीदार वहां आया हो और ये दोने छत पर गए हों और वहां उसने पहले हेमराज को मारा हो और फिर नीचे आकर Arushi को मारा और एक और important बात , चौकीदार की जगह कोई और व्यक्ति भी हो सकता है, कोई पडोसी या society आस पास का कोई व्यक्ति ।
और चौकीदार के लिए घर के तालों की चाबियां बनवाना कोई बडी बात नही रही होगी और फिर हम उस नौकरानी को कैसे भूल सकते हैं, उसके लिए चाबी हासिल करना कोई बडी बात नही रही होगी वह भी इसमे मिली हो सकती है ।
एक बात बताओ, जिस तरह चाबी को ऊपर से नीचे फेंका जा सकता है , उसी तरह नीचे से ऊपर भी फेंका जा सकता है।
हो सकता है चौकीदार इसमे मिला हो, उसने पहले हेमराज को मारा, फिर आरुषि को, और बाहर से Lock कर के चाबी balcony से Rajesh को दे दी ।
और इस बात की भी बहुत संभावना है कि उस Building का कोई व्यक्ति ही कातिल हो, और अगर चौकीदार सच बोल रहा है कि उस रात न कोई Building से अंदर गया और न बाहर आया ,तो यह शक और मजबूत हो जाता है , चाबी को दरवाजे के नीचे से सरका दिया होगा, य अपनी balcony से उनकी balcony मे फेंक दी होगी, या किसी अन्य तरीके से अंदर पहुंचा दी होगी ।
एक और बहुत important बात, Dr Talwar ने Vo Camera online मंगवाया था, और उसे देने कोई आया था और उस Camera को हेमराज ने recieve किया था उसके बारे मे Police ने क्या पता किया ?
Theory 2
मुझे लगता है कि दो या दो से अधिक लोग इसमे शामिल हैं, case कुछ तथ्य एसे हैं जो इस ओर इशारा करते हैं, डाॅ डोगरा (Forensic Expert, जिन्होने सबसे पहले Investigate किया) कहते हैं कि कोई आया था और उसने हेमराज को मारा और मारते वक्त आरुषी ने उसे देख लिया इसलिए उसने आरुषी को भी मार दिया।
अब मुझे एक बात बताओ,आरुषी इतनी समझदार तो थी कि Murder का मतलब जानती थी,एक 13 साल की लडकी जो आधी रात को अपने घर मे एक Murder देखती है और आकर चुप चाप सो जाति है ? मां बाप को नही जगाती चीखती नही हैं बस आकर सो जाती है ? यह बहुत अजीब नही है ?
मुझे लगता है, कि आरुषी ने Murder तो नही देखा होगा पर हां यह जरूर देखा होगा कि कौन आया है और वो उन्हे शायद जानती थी । खैर जाने या न जाने जो लोग आए थे वो हेमराज को मारने के बाद यह Risk तो नही ले सकते थे कि वो आरुषी को छोड दें और उन्होने उसे भी मार दिया ।
अब मै कैसे कह सकता हूं कि दो या दो से अधिक लोग थे ?
एक बात बताओ Investigation से यह बात पता चली थी कि हेमराज की मौत अरुषी के कमरे मै नही हुई थी यह तो बिल्कुल तय है ,क्योंकि हेमराज के blood और DNA का एक भी Trace उस कमरे मे नही मिला ।
अब ध्यान से समझो ,हेमराज का खून बहुत बहा था,जिसने भी हेमराज को मारा उसके शरीर पर खून तो उछला ही होगा,अगर वो ही आरुषी का कातिल है तो उसके कमरे मे हेमराज के खून का एक भी सुराग क्यों नही मिला ?
जिसने भी हेमराज को मारा, उसने आरुषी की नही मारा यहां तक की वो कमरे मे आया भी नही बाहर से ही चला गया ,आरुषी को दूसरे आदमी ने मारा और फिर वो देनो गायब हो गए , य Parents मे से कोई एक अरुषी का कातिल हो सकता है, भागने वाले ने बाहर से दरवाजे बंद कर दिए ।
यह बात मानना बहुत मुश्किल है कि इतने कम समय मे सारे सबूत मिटा दिए हों ,वो भी आधी रात अंधेरे मे।
हो सकता है आरुषी की मां का किसी के साथ Affair हो , पडोसी आया हो , दोनो को हेमराज आरुषी ने देखा हो और हेमराज को वस लोग समझाने terrace पर ले गए हों.....
अब यहां तक सब Normal है, लेकिन धीरे धीरे बात बढी और
वहां कहा सुनी हुई हो और हेमराज को मार दिया हो...अब इन्हे नही पता था कि बात बढ जाएगी और हेमराज मर जाएगा ।
Nupur अंदर चली गई और Arushi को मार दिया हो ।
लेकिन यह थोडा मुश्किल सा लगता है ,क्योंकि एसा कुछ होता तो Nupur के Narco test मे कुछ तो पता चलता ।
आप Dr Dogra की Theory मेरी दो या दो से अधिक लोग वाली बात जोडें तो बात कुछ हो सकने वाली लगती है ।
चौकीदार और Ground floor के पडोसी पर मुझे पूरा शक है, यहां तक की आजू बाजू का कोई Neighbor भी हो सकता है ।
Story of Dr Dogra is indigestible . There can be professional sympathy or old relationship of Talwar couple's parents. In a normal condition , if someone kills so precious single child, how will his / her parents react ? As soon as they know the brutal killing of their child, they will definitely yell, cry and inform police and neighbours . But it didn't happen that night. Talwar couple didn't yell, didn't cry , didn't call police. When the domestic help ( Maid ) came to work in the morning, she found both husband - wife sitting aside to dead body of Arushi patiently and told her that Hemraj killed Arushi and ran away. That maid informed about this incident to neighbours and then Police was informed. Dr Talwar informed police that Hemraj killed her daughter and ran away. He forced police to go to Nepal to search Hemraj and arrest him. Dr Talwar locked the door of upstairs. When Police asked him to open the lock , he told that Key was misplaced. We must not forget that Hemraj's dead body was found on the roof after two days. Why did Dr Talwar misguided police ? Why did he stop Police to go on roof ? There are so many circumstantial evidences which clearly indicate that Killer didn't come from outside.
You are assuming so much about other people's emotion. They were crying after maid entered their house. Hemraj wasn't present so the Talwar in haste directly blamed hemraj and told the police to find him. Why do you think every people should start yelling after looking at dead body of their loved ones? Different People might show different reactions.
Arushi Father Killed her, bcoz she must be having affair with Hemraaz, and they were spending good time with each other, but suddenly her Dad or mom came across this event, so in Anger , Mr Talwar hit the Stick to Arushi and then he took Hemraaz on terrace where he killed Hemraaz. After that , their Daughter left her last breath, then Miss Talwar cleaned her vagina with cotton, and to show this a murder they made cut on Aarushi's body...
He has useless theory of 3rd person, not possible at any how.
@ြğňအ412ř Can you believe this someone came from outside, killed two persons , one of the dead bodies was taken on roof and other one was killed in room and Talwar couple didn't know ? Dono masti se sote rahe. As you say some cry and some freeze ? Not some, Only Talwar couple froze like ice. They were so shocked that they even didn't call police.
How did u solve it? Wow! ☺️☺️☺️☺️
Never Keep Servants at your Home, let them go back to their own home at night never leave your child alone with the servants, moral of the story
Yes very true, never trust them, why the hell he opened the door for others at night, it's scary
Yes, in another case of Mumbai girl of std 9 came home, mother (who took early retirement to pay services to Radha Krishna temple ) as usual was not at home, girl was alone and she saw a rat or cockroach in kitchen therefore couldn't take food from kitchen, she called watchman to get rid of cockroach rat, but that bloody security guard raped her and killed her
So even if u don't keep servant, girls are at risk, we have to teach girls to be bold courageous to face any situation
Female middle age servants are better
Most foolish was her own mother, why she should leave house whn girl is expected to return from school
👍👍👍
@@kalpananarendra7599 👍🏽
@@kalpananarendra7599 absolutely
He starts with building a solid profile about the Talwars that has no bearing on the case. It only lays doubts whether his inferences were subjective.
And the question is why no body investigated from this point of view?
Exactly! Like I know his father, I know her father! They are very well known doctor and all! What rubbish! I Don't think if this comes in way of investigating one of the more gruesome crimes it won't solve but it will go nowhere! Rubbish!
Shut up u old man
Right
@@alikhalid76dxb this is a joker who is trying his best to save his fellow doctors.
Buy some chairs for lallantop team as well
Right...unko bhut stylish lgta h ye 😂😂😂😂😂😂 real me this is so funny and awkward
😂😂😂
Haaa Ajeeb hai
Mr Dogra sir didn't mention the biggest point that after Murder of Hemraj the roof gate was locked from inside. After few days of murder police came and opened the ROOF GATE from inside.
The point is NO MURDERER IN THIS WORLD WILL TRY TO LOCK THE GATE AFTER 2 MURDERS IN THE HOUSE, unless the murderer is from inside the house.
Murderer who is inside know this thing too
Why he will do this stupid thing to setup a trap for himself
Very valid point but never discussed any person with common sense can make out that dr is culprit.Dr sahib is saving his colleague with fake arguments
Family members ke bina ye murder possible hi nehi ha. Bahar se koi aa kar do murder kar diye aur kisi ko pata nehi chala ye kaise possible ha??...golf stick wali theory best suit hota ha
Guy kills hemraj on the terrace. He doesnt want the body to be discovered. So he locks it from inside. He then realizes that arushi has seen him in the house. So, he kills arushi. What is so difficult and complicated in this?
@@fun3721 Then How he escapes??
Don't know whether he is right or not. I had followed that case that time and being a Doctor it's difficult to digest these things told by Sir. First of all it was not a weapon like Khukri but a sharp weapon like Scalpel which is an Medical instrument. Second thing It was told that Rajesh was awake till half an hour before the time of murder and was using internet from Arushi's room. Third it is difficult to digest that a murder happens next to your room and you don't even know about it. And react to it in the morning when maid comes.
She was sexually assaulted too that's why private parts were cleaned and many person where there at the time of murder this ain't work of one person both were killed with one sharp edged weapon only there was two entrance to house front door & back door it was work of an outsider probably servants coz of circumstances or it's someone else only as said by dr dogra or it's parents only coz of their suspicious behaviour & action
When ppl like Mr Dogra are being used to put blame on the dead, you know what the truth is.
Besides all the points you made against the parents, there was no forced entry in the house. That makes it crystal care who did it.
The parents cleaned all the evidence. And blame was put on the shoddy investigation. The media, judiciary and the state machinery was all hands in glove with the culprits.
Dead cant speak, but those who are alive need to ensure that justice doesnt get lost.
Parents r the culprits…. They must have seen something with their own eyes, which should not have been seen
Unhone mara hota to lash ka thikana laga dete pehle aur fir missing complaint likhva dete police station me
Exactly.
केस मेँ आरोपी का पकड़ा न जाना और केस का अनसुलझा रह जाना, एक बड़ा शक पैदा करता है!
ये शक पुलिस, cbi और दंपत्ति सभी पर होता है?
Uske baap ne mara
@@mohitpatel6998 ये संभव हैं!
Please Read my theories and reply ..
Theory 1
नौकर की मौत छत पर हुई थी । एसा हो सकता है कि नौकर कातिल को जानता हो । कातिल आया हो, वो दोनो cigarette या दारू पीने के बहाने छत पर गए हों । वहां उसने नौकर को मारा हो और नीचे आके लडकी को भी मार दिया हो ।
वो दो चौकीदार जो shift बदलकर काम करते थे उनके बारे मे CBI क्या सोचती है, क्या उनकी जांच हुई ?
Imagine करो आप एक flat मे पिछले छ महीने से रह रहे हो, तो जाहिर सी बात है कि आपके वहां के चौकीदार से अच्छी दोस्ती हो जाएगी । एसा बिल्कुल possible है कि उस रात हेमराज ने चौकीदार को बुलाया हो या फिर खुद वो चौकीदार वहां आया हो और ये दोने छत पर गए हों और वहां उसने पहले हेमराज को मारा हो और फिर नीचे आकर Arushi को मारा और एक और important बात , चौकीदार की जगह कोई और व्यक्ति भी हो सकता है, कोई पडोसी या society आस पास का कोई व्यक्ति ।
और चौकीदार के लिए घर के तालों की चाबियां बनवाना कोई बडी बात नही रही होगी और फिर हम उस नौकरानी को कैसे भूल सकते हैं, उसके लिए चाबी हासिल करना कोई बडी बात नही रही होगी वह भी इसमे मिली हो सकती है ।
एक बात बताओ, जिस तरह चाबी को ऊपर से नीचे फेंका जा सकता है , उसी तरह नीचे से ऊपर भी फेंका जा सकता है।
हो सकता है चौकीदार इसमे मिला हो, उसने पहले हेमराज को मारा, फिर आरुषि को, और बाहर से Lock कर के चाबी balcony से Rajesh को दे दी ।
और इस बात की भी बहुत संभावना है कि उस Building का कोई व्यक्ति ही कातिल हो, और अगर चौकीदार सच बोल रहा है कि उस रात न कोई Building से अंदर गया और न बाहर आया ,तो यह शक और मजबूत हो जाता है , चाबी को दरवाजे के नीचे से सरका दिया होगा, य अपनी balcony से उनकी balcony मे फेंक दी होगी, या किसी अन्य तरीके से अंदर पहुंचा दी होगी ।
एक और बहुत important बात, Dr Talwar ने Vo Camera online मंगवाया था, और उसे देने कोई आया था और उस Camera को हेमराज ने recieve किया था उसके बारे मे Police ने क्या पता किया ?
Theory 2
मुझे लगता है कि दो या दो से अधिक लोग इसमे शामिल हैं, case कुछ तथ्य एसे हैं जो इस ओर इशारा करते हैं, डाॅ डोगरा (Forensic Expert, जिन्होने सबसे पहले Investigate किया) कहते हैं कि कोई आया था और उसने हेमराज को मारा और मारते वक्त आरुषी ने उसे देख लिया इसलिए उसने आरुषी को भी मार दिया।
अब मुझे एक बात बताओ,आरुषी इतनी समझदार तो थी कि Murder का मतलब जानती थी,एक 13 साल की लडकी जो आधी रात को अपने घर मे एक Murder देखती है और आकर चुप चाप सो जाति है ? मां बाप को नही जगाती चीखती नही हैं बस आकर सो जाती है ? यह बहुत अजीब नही है ?
मुझे लगता है, कि आरुषी ने Murder तो नही देखा होगा पर हां यह जरूर देखा होगा कि कौन आया है और वो उन्हे शायद जानती थी । खैर जाने या न जाने जो लोग आए थे वो हेमराज को मारने के बाद यह Risk तो नही ले सकते थे कि वो आरुषी को छोड दें और उन्होने उसे भी मार दिया ।
अब मै कैसे कह सकता हूं कि दो या दो से अधिक लोग थे ?
एक बात बताओ Investigation से यह बात पता चली थी कि हेमराज की मौत अरुषी के कमरे मै नही हुई थी यह तो बिल्कुल तय है ,क्योंकि हेमराज के blood और DNA का एक भी Trace उस कमरे मे नही मिला ।
अब ध्यान से समझो ,हेमराज का खून बहुत बहा था,जिसने भी हेमराज को मारा उसके शरीर पर खून तो उछला ही होगा,अगर वो ही आरुषी का कातिल है तो उसके कमरे मे हेमराज के खून का एक भी सुराग क्यों नही मिला ?
जिसने भी हेमराज को मारा, उसने आरुषी की नही मारा यहां तक की वो कमरे मे आया भी नही बाहर से ही चला गया ,आरुषी को दूसरे आदमी ने मारा और फिर वो देनो गायब हो गए , य Parents मे से कोई एक अरुषी का कातिल हो सकता है, भागने वाले ने बाहर से दरवाजे बंद कर दिए ।
यह बात मानना बहुत मुश्किल है कि इतने कम समय मे सारे सबूत मिटा दिए हों ,वो भी आधी रात अंधेरे मे।
हो सकता है आरुषी की मां का किसी के साथ Affair हो , पडोसी आया हो , दोनो को हेमराज आरुषी ने देखा हो और हेमराज को वस लोग समझाने terrace पर ले गए हों.....
अब यहां तक सब Normal है, लेकिन धीरे धीरे बात बढी और
वहां कहा सुनी हुई हो और हेमराज को मार दिया हो...अब इन्हे नही पता था कि बात बढ जाएगी और हेमराज मर जाएगा ।
Nupur अंदर चली गई और Arushi को मार दिया हो ।
लेकिन यह थोडा मुश्किल सा लगता है ,क्योंकि एसा कुछ होता तो Nupur के Narco test मे कुछ तो पता चलता ।
आप Dr Dogra की Theory मेरी दो या दो से अधिक लोग वाली बात जोडें तो बात कुछ हो सकने वाली लगती है ।
चौकीदार और Ground floor के पडोसी पर मुझे पूरा शक है, यहां तक की आजू बाजू का कोई Neighbor भी हो सकता है ।
@@mohitpatel6998court me sabit nai hua
Rong story
डाक्टर डोगरा साहब कभी-कभी अनुभव काम नहीं आता है,माफ़ करें आप सीनियर डाक्टर, विशेषज्ञ हो सकते हैं किंतु आपके बयानों से कहानी में हल्का हल्का बनावटी सा लगता है जैसे कि कोई मनगढ़ंत बातें
Absolutely right 👍
Jo aam public ko saaf dikhta hai
Use ye Dr. Aur saurabh dvivedi jaise pade likhe andhe kyu nahi dekh pate
Sorry mujhe to nahi laga..
Apni hi banyi hui story lag rahi hai
रवीश कुमार को जरूर बुलाइए, गज़ब हो जाएगा🔱🔱🔱
Salute to 👏 police officer & media, they made the crime scene a fish market. Otherwise, it could be solved.
Govt failure
No dear her parents are very high profile person and they disguised very much
Read article in Wikipedia or others
IPS Rajesh Pandey also explore it in own view
Ya
Police was made to do
Parents killed her, honor killing as she and Henraj were in a sexual relationship, 4 ppl were there only
The most logical explanation of the event, which I had suspected for so many years and now confirmed by expert. Cannot believe our system where parents are jailed for this. The biggest mistake of the parents is that they allowed strangers to get inside the home, it should have been a strict no. They paid very dearly for this one mistake.
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅❤❤😅
No, the ex CBI director also thinks that the Talwars were involved
@@HighRollerSkatesat which logic ?
@@manikwadhwani4867 by the logic of that cut on throats. Such cuts can only be made my experts, and the lock on the terrace door. It was a lock, why will someone lock the terrace someone lock it?? If some other guy killed hemraj on terrace he could have just killed and ran why he would lock that door??? Tbh the main killer was the parents.
@@manikwadhwani4867 ghar me 2 murder ho gaye hai or parients ghode bech ke so rahe hai
Case solved , viewers shocked . Thanks Daddu
@@sabherwaltraveler5496lekin maa baap hi kyu karenge apne hi bachii kaa..
Trye@@sabherwaltraveler5496
Maa baap ne khoon Kiya hai ye theory to mujhe bhi samajh nahi aayi. Ha ye bilkul theek lagati hai. Ki servent ke dost logo ne murder Kiya. Dr. Sahab ki theory apni jagah bilkul thik bhi hai..
@@sabherwaltraveler5496 janabe ali.. agar Jo log ye kah rahe hai ki parents ne murder Kiya .. kyuki wo Hemraj ke sath dekhi gayi thi. To ye murder unplanned hua.
Mr. Talwar ne kya ye socha hoga ki agar ghar Maine police aayegi or wo Terrace par nahi jayegi. Ye chutiyapa hai. Bhai police ki galati thi nahi to ye case kab ka solve ho gaya tha. Movie dekhoo. Maine kal hi dekhi hai..
@@ashoksaxena754😂😂😂😂😂😂
जब किसी विभाग में आपके कोई जान पहचान या दोस्त रिश्तेदार होते हैं तो आपको जरूर थोड़ा बहुत फायदा मिलता है, इस केस में बहुत से अधिकारी तलवार परिवार के जान पहचान वाले थे फिर भी आरूषि-हेमराज को न्याय नहीं मिला, हाँ ये जान पहचान का फायदा तलवार दम्पति को जरूर मिला।
Nobody at Arushi's home at the time of her murder is above suspicion in this case. Forensic pathologist Tirath Das Dogra's reputation is tainted in this case due to his certificate not being accepted by CBI. Even in this interview, Dr. Dogra is more interested in building the case to absolve Arushi's parents than in giving any new information about the murder. This murder case exposed the incompetence of many investigators associated with this case as well as the press and other people, who damaged or tainted or destroyed the evidence by rushing to the murder location before the investigation authorities could secure the place. The only lesson to be learned by the common man is that parents must prioritize the welfare of their child over working late, partying, or earning more money. Those who cannot put their child's interest above their own have no right to bring a child into this world.
Right
You are cent percent right sir. I m also intrested to know and solve the case.🙏🙏. Why a case let unsolved?.
Talwar went bankrupt after bribing such people
Yes. He does not believe that the talwars can be murderers. May be he knows them.closely and so he has a cause to believe so. The angle of his side should have been studied than coming of fancy kind of stories involving honour killing. They were feom affluent family and mostly they dont mind to see their sibblings with boy friend/girl friwnd. Further thay could have planned such case than becoming hyper.
You are very intelligent you must be teaching Forensic Medicine and toxicology in AIIMS Delhi
जब कोई घटना बहुत जटील लग रही हो तो समझ लेना वास्तव में घटना बेहत सरल है सारी जटीलता हमारे विचारोमे है | आरुषी की हत्या उसके माता पिता द्वारा गुसे मे हुई ,परंतु उसके लिये उनको अलग सजा की जरुरत नहीं उनका वर्तमान जीवन ही उनके लिये सजा बन गया है
Right
Yes right
Well said 👍
सत्य ।
Exactly
Or ye doctor unka well known tha isliye ye b gumrah kar rha h shuru se hi
Thankful for discussion!! It's ubsolved case ; Quite mystery. Looking forward to it !!!
Just like Sheena Bora case.
@@rashmeemakkhija4646
Obviously. But I think this is more mysterious.
He very well knows about parents of Rajesh and nupur talwar. So we can easily understand his sympathy about him...
Yes. Tht s alarming.
He knows very well his duty too. Btw
But still many things are fishy .. normal people are not fools since he is related to Arushi parents he is supporting them and making them guilty free or else why he is publicly coming and telling to media..After so many years🤔
Iski galti he yeh thi ye program mai isne bataya yeh pehle se janta hai Talwar family ko even Talwar parents ko nhi batata toh yakin kar lete iski jhuti kahani par
@@niru7911 there are still many fools around here who are blindly believing the TALWAR movie and keep ranting in every comment section that "why would parents do this to their only child?"
This is a classic case where actually God only knows what happened that night.There are many questions that arise if whatever the doctor is narrating is true. All I can hope n pray for even after so many years is may both the victims soul rest in eternal peace 🕊️
Ask God
you are wrong
killer also knows what happened
This year best acting award goes to journalist.. ऐसे सुनरहे है जैसे कुछ पता नाहो 😂😂
Because of the incompetence of the local police.
Not sure about ur god but killers knew for sure, isn't it Sherlock
डा.साहब कहानी बहुत अच्छी बनाए है।
Talwar movie nhi dekha apne?
@@preethiraj4441movie bhi such hoti h kya kahi ???
@@preethiraj4441Nahin Aisi koi movie bhi hai kya
@@kavitaarya882 poora incident ko padke thaiyyar krk banaya hai... must watch.....
@@kavitaarya882 its a true story... Watch it...
सब अपना अपना राय देते हे आरुषि मर्डर पर लेकिन पुलिस और फॉरेंसिक का काम ही संदिग्ध था आरुषि के हत्या के बाद पुलिस ने हेमराज को फरार बता दिया फिर एक दिन बाद उसी घर के छत पर से हेमराज की लाश मिली, ये कोन सा जांच था की मर्डर के बाद उन्होंने छत पर ताला लगे होने के कारण छत पर जाना जरूरी ही नहीं समझा
FLAWS IN THE THEORY -
1. If that person killed someone on the terrace, why would he lock the balcony door. To hide? And left the Arushi's body in open? Naah .. person will only hide servent's body so people think he is the suspect because of his absence.
2. If my daughter is killed,.am ready to break all the doors of my house if needed. But family didn't let police to break the lock and tell them they r not finding the keys .
3. Arushi was next to her parents room. Little insights.. her room lock can be only open from inside or with key from outside which only parents have. Her room was locked. One person (even the known one) came, broke the door, killed arushi and arushi didn't scream at all..parents didn't even hear the lock breaking noices. Woww..
4. This person is related and very well known to the family. He said that he knows tha grandfather of the arushi. Most probably chances are they are told to say this in public to save the reputation.
Exactly he is saving them ..
Mr. Talwar has given camera to arushi that night to pretend that we love arushi. But it was preplanned.
It is shameful people like u fall for sensational media trial and throw parents under the bus who already lose their only child..just shameful..i can answer every point of yours but i know i will be wasting my time
@@27sadhu you are delusional if you think parents are God's and can't do anything wrong. All dysfunctional families psychopaths and narcissist are created by parents. Be realistic and see things for what they are instead of looking at thing's from rose tinted glasses.
1. Because aarushi's murder was unplanned and spontaneous, initial plan was to kill hemraj and hide his body, and people would assume he just ran off and cops wont care to search for a servant too much
2. Just he says she says, you were not there. most likely police gave such allegations against parents in order to make excuse when everyone will ask police why did they not open the terrace door on first day , when they were totally clueless and careless and just assumed servant has run off after murdering the call and didnt bother to open terrace
3. Door could have had key left in as Nupur said , or maybe aarushi came outside to have some snacks from kitchen or maybe heard some noise..either she came out herself assuming it must be hemraj in the kitchen...
4. All the evidence points to outsider with friendly entry...someone who dominated hemraj be it due to loan lender or just being some criminal..he was in hemraj room since 9 pm almost..hemraj was hiding him and was so scared he left his dinner untouched...hemraj also didnt drink, so that explains outsider drinking the alcohol as wine and beer bottle was found...could have been 2people too...find the person who made the 8.30 call from PCO to hemraj and u have the killer
He is not telling, he is convincing people to believe his story.
You are right 👍
Jhoota hai
You are right
Dr. Will support Dr.
Janna jaruri h
ruclips.net/user/shortsV44bjGOPDxM?feature=share
Among all the theories I heard on this case, this one is the most convincing. Truth is always simple and logical. Shame on over-enthusiastic ignorant media who destroyed the evidence due to which the poor girl (and their parents most likely) never got justice. Om Shanti Shanti Shanti.
Exactly..
True
Hello, both the victims throat was slit with surgical precision. And based on this theory the murderer had enough time to take the body to the servant quarters and lock the room besides cleaning the crime scene of blood and evidence. Finally the main door is also locked which was opened by the maid in the morning from outside when the house lady threw the keys from inside the house. Clearly the parents are the main suspects with motive. What this gentleman is making up some story which does not address the key questions. This was a good cover up by police.
@@kevincastelino3209 exactly..!
I haven't even watched this video fully.. I'm at 6th mins of the video.. And I came to understand, that this doctor is on the Thalvars side.. It's clear, that he's biased..
False. How the killer escaped and locked the home from inside? This was the mystery in this case and no answer or theory was found whatsoever.
Perfect analysis, all doubts are clear.
Kya clear h?..?
One more point to ponder is that the parents are not actively trying and eager to find out the brutal murderer of their only child..any parent in similar situation would run from pillar to post in punishing the murderer at any cost.
Because father only was the murderer.
Parents only askec court to reopen the case and then whole case was built against them only. Pls read the matter to know the facts in order.
Very true
Agreed
Parents ne hi to mara hai
One thing is sure, this case remained unsolved and justice was butchered due to media blunders. Even in 26/11 terrorist attack, it was due to media intervention that the police and army action took so long because media was showing it live and the handlers of the terrorists were giving them inputs from the live coverages only. It was 3rd day that government blocked live reporting of the 26/11 events. I remember that time, it was early 5 am in the morning in our tuition class. Sir was watching the news and one of my friend said "in atankwadiyo ko bhi toh pata chal raha hoga ki kya ho raha he TV mein dikha rahe hein sab". Aek 9th class ke bacche ko ye baat samajh mein aa gayi par media ke so called pade likhe journalists ko nahin. Some of these media personals are vultures. In name of TRP, national security and lives of people were put on stake. Sometimes media in this country is so irresponsible that any sin is undermined in the name of TRP. Same happened in the Arushi case. Poor Arushi ji and Hemraj ji. Media trials really need to stop. Same media is absent when lot of mishappeinings occur in this country. Pahle Rahul Gandhi ji se fursat nahin hoti thi, aur aaj kal Narendra Modi ji se. Ground level issues toh gayab hi ho chuke hein. Unemployment, inflation, economic crisis, education issues, women issues, caste atrocities, poor people, marginalized people, all are lost in the race of TRP. Lagta hi nahin ki is media ke liye gareeb aadmi desh ka hissa bhi he.
Bro🙏🏻💯
Bro both, Rajdeep Sardesai and Barkha Dutt got Padma Shri in 2008 by the congress for their live coverage of the Mumbai terror attacks. I see them no less than any terrorists. They must be put behind the bars coz they got blood on their hands of many innocent people.
Nice say
You are ABSOLUTELY RIGHT .
JAI HIND
Very true totally agree with you..
If we believe whatever Dr.Dogra said then there are many loopholes which are confusing and need to be cleared first.......
1)If Khemraj was murdered on terrace and Aarushi was murdered in her room by this friend of Khemraj,,then from where the blood came on the steps leading to the terrace??
2)If Aarushi knew that a friend has come to meet Khemraj at late night why did she not inform her parents?Obviously the friend is threat to her vanity.
3)Even if the friend thought that Aarushi is witness and comes to murder her she would have shouted loudly to alert parents and shouted for help.
4)Worst assumption is saying that the culprit friend drinking whiskey after the double murder.A murderer always runs away from the crime scene as soon as possible.He doesn't sit aramse to drink whiskey ,that too at the victims place.
5) When the maidservant came next morning ,she would have seen some blood stains at the entrance as the murderer left from entrance.But she didn't see any blood there.Only she saw Mrs Talwar coming at the entrance n telling that Khemraj is missing and locked the door.Dats why she throws the duplicate keys for the maidservant
.
6)Why will murderer spend some more time in locking the Talwar couple in their own house?And how did he get the keys to lock them inside,he is a stranger to the keys,only Khemraj knew which keys are used where!
Dogra being a Dictor,doesn't know the name of IVF,artificial insemination.The way he is telling about the prestigious grandparens and how Aarushi was a valuable child is obviously is to whitewash the Talwars
All above questions need to be answered.
Are bhai tere Sare question k javab diye hai unne bas keys vale ko chor kar, or ivf ka naam ni aata ye to bolne ki koi baat ni hai, wo aiims ke director the 😂 koi mamuli banda ni h wo, ye sab saval uske dimag me bhi aaye honge par batana sahi ni samjha because main baat batayi unne
Yes, no murderer will lock the house or terrace gate lock
@sandeepchaudhary....yes
So many queries are there to be answered.
@@sandeepchaudhary9670Why would you assume the killer wouldn't lock the terrace gate or house door. Well guess what the killer did it and now he's free without any suspicions.
Tu jaake investigation kr naa yaha kahe gyan pel rha hain itna dimag hain to jaa vha pe
इतनी लंबी बातचीत के पता चला की सिर्फ़ बकवास ही हुआ. हाँ सिर्फ़ ये पता चला की लड़की आर्टिफिशियल थी, और एक ही बच्ची थी |
because he doesn't know anything, he just guesses the thing with his prejudiced mind... and talking irrelevant...
This Dr dogra is a shame on entire medicos. This guy is one of the kingpin.
& Who is the kingpin here Mr.Butcher? Going by ur name, is it u?
@@PhenomenalDiva no its arushi's parents who are demon
@@TheTruthSpeaker007 when u don’t know the facts, it’s best not 2 judge people , especially people who don’t know u , haven’t harmed u in anyway.
@@PhenomenalDiva dear i am stunned that you have commented that these guys didnt harm me so i should keep shut!
but since this was a high profile case since 2008 and it has so many web documentaries, and 2 movies. So now the case has become a case of national interest and just like every national interest case i can also comment. And my comment is my opinion that parents have killed the daughter. Period!
@@TheTruthSpeaker007 I didn’t say that u should keep ur mouth shut.
But that you or anyone shouldn’t jump on the bandwagon without checking both sides of the coin. Assuming whatever one pleases about people whom they don’t know or have ever been harmed by them
In anyway is 100% wrong.
If the father had killed the daughter, he would have breathed a sigh of relief & celebrated his freedom when he & his wife was given a clean chit instead of re-opening the case & invite trouble for himself . On that note , I rest my case as I’ve not taken it upon me to debrainwash the brainwashed minds.
गलत स्टोरी बताई है कोई किसी दूसरे के घर में जाकर तीसरे का मर्डर नहीं करेगा, जबकि वो उसको रास्ते से भी उठा सकते थे सॉरी बट आई ऑब्जेक्ट दिस स्टोरी.
He is the one who gave "khukhri" theory, defending parents. Also, his sympathy towards Talwars and connections with them is alarming.
Had his story been acceptable, police would have had tried to solve case in this direction as well.
We all are aware that there were just 2 possibilities assumed i.e. the Talwars being murderers or Krishna being murderer.
The story is simply newly fabricated.
It was a case of ' honour killing'.mercyless parents.
He misguided the investigation fabricating fifth person
उस रात घर में केवल चार लोग थे, जिनमें दो मार दिये गये और दो जिवित बचे, उस रात बिल्डिंग में न कोई बाहर से आया और न कोई अन्दर से बाहर गया, ये सबसे प्रमुख और पक्की बात है, कत्ल के बाद बहुत सोच समझकर सबूत मिटाये गये, फर्श को साफ किया गया, आरुषि वाली बैडशीट बदली गयी, बार-बार इंटरनेट चालाया गया, टेंशन में रातभर बीयर पीयी गयी..... बाहर से आकर कत्ल करने वाला इतने घण्टे देकर आराम से सबूत नहीं मिटा सकता, पकड़े जाने का भय और वो भी दो लोगों का कत्ल करने बाद, इंसान जल्दी से निकलने की कोशिश करेगा.....
Who is this Krishna??
@@alpha9539 Nepali logo ke khilaf racist bakwas band kar. On average sab ek jaise hi hote hain.
I remember hearing at that time that arushi's parent has a very influential clintale including top notch politicians like mayawati and few more names which i dont remember now..as patients..and from this experts version also it is clear that even her grand parents were also very reputed people in their field...so i think this case will always remain a mystery.
@@kanchanpanwar 🤣😂 the conspiracy theories keep on coming , now suddenly they had a influential clientele 🤦♀️
This unsolved case is best example of either reckless parent's insane cruelty or incompetent & doubtful integrity of CBI.
Dogra Sir, you are forgetting that till 12:30 night, Rajesh Talwar was on internet, which he had accepted to CBI officer. You are saying that the person who killed Aarushi & Hemraj, dragged the body to terrace or say killed Hemraj in terrace, killed Aarushi in her room, cleaned her room of any blood stains and then drank whisky from that belonged to Rajesh Talwar, knowing fully well that the parents were sleeping in a room 10 feets away? Sir aap kyon mazaak kar rahein hain?
Agreed
Her parents killed Arushi
He spoke some half shit.
@@piyushkumar-ju2ph why
Buddha grand parents se paise khake kuchh bhi bol raha
Superb doctor sahab and welldone lalantop❤
This case was very neatly explained in a movie named 'talwar'..... what happened during the investigation beginning to end was portrayed very well .... and irfan khan did a great job...
That movie is BS.
@@apieceoflife2732 a piece of trash
Ghanta ...
The movie was done to clear Talwar family from the case. See the rich doctor couple in U.P. can never be made accused until and unless they have something fishy to hide. They had enough money to give to police and CBI to put the blame on their servants. If they would not have had any role their name would have never come up. I still believe that it was the father who killed her child in the heat of moment.
@@adarshverma2014 really is that so easy to buy CBI with money.... at first police had no clue who had killed her after they found the body of the servant they made an assumption that this could had happened and started probing her parent .....
although they have all the traces and evidences (on the basis of which forensic probe could be conducted) of murder but they let those destroyed... and preceded the investigation..... the police always do this on the basis of assumption without any evidence....
Why did the police or CBI did not able to prove them guilty.... even after being jailed over 6 months they were evicted...
यह सुन कर ऐसा लगता कि की जैसे कोई अपने करीबी रिश्तेदार को बचा रहा हो।
bilkul shi khaa
😂
मुझे भी ऐसा ही लगा।
सही कहा मुझे भी ऐसा लगा, एक डॉक्टर दूसरे डॉक्टर को बचा रहा है
Yes 👍🏻 सुबह दरवाजा अंदर से बंद था ये ही सबको पता है तो क्या मारने वाला हेमराज से लोन लेकर सुरंग खोद कर गया था बाहर।
No one entered from outside. Even if the loan master entered, cannot kill hemraj like that in someone's house based on an argument.Also it was not necessary to kill witness in such a way, whereas all doors locked from inside.
The incidence of killing, must require a bigger reason than just a Loan.
I don't agree with Doctors story....
Bhai Mujhe bhi yahi laga, ho na ho parents hi hai killer.
If parents killed their child as well as servant and cleaned/cleared evidences do you think they will keep the main gait locked from inside and let police know that nobody could come from outside?
The person who killed both Hemraj and Aarushi locked the door from inside and must have escaped by jumping compound wall so that people will suspect that some one from inside the home killed both of them.
Yes its the parents who killed her ...
@@Anonymo13 they didn't had much time to think about all this as it was not pre planned. If what you say is true then how did the murderer escaped? , why bedshits were changed from Aarushi's room? why her private part was cleaned with chemicals ( which only doctors know), why they let people come inside house and spoil the evidence/dna? why their wifi was used in midnight? why there were phone calls made during mid night? all are coincidence?there are a lot of such circumstancial evidences which points towards them.
@@loveandlife5274 yess... everyone think tht parents killed arushi but why a 14 year old girl will hv physical relation wth an old age man...other theory says tht arushi got to know about the wife swapping thing she got depressed and fought with them for same
सबसे पहले तो एक वरिष्ठ नागरिक के सामने किस तरीके से बैठ जाता है उसेसीखो आप एक वरिष्ठ नागरिक के सामने टेबल पर बैठे हैं आपके जूनियर भी इस प्रकार सेही बैठे हैं कोई कॉलेज का प्रोग्राम तो यह किसी चाय की थड़ीपर बैठे हैं आपने एक वरिष्ठ नागरिक का अपमान किया है और आप जैसे एगोइस्ट पत्रकार किसी कर्म के नहीं है
अरे वाह क्या कहानी बनाई सर जी अभी तक आप कहाँ थे १४ वर्ष बीतने के बाद दर्शन दिये आपको साष्टांग प्रणाम है🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Well planned murder by professional s no use debating
🤣
बुढढे ने सारे केस इसी तरह उलझा दिए होंगे उसका मर्डर तो उसके मां बाप ने किया पर पैसे की ताकत भी कोई चीज होती है सलाम है तुम लोगों को
mat bolo bacchi ka murder hai koi choti baat nhi hai
Hahaha sahi kaha Maulana Azad k director talwar k papa inke batchmate hai kya
😅😅😅😅😅😅
Plz watch Talvaar movie
Hahahahahaj
Exactly Remembers the Next Day's News Paper when it happened. I read it that time and followed this case for a long time. I watched the movie also but Today after 15 years of this gruesome massacre, I came to know the actual reason for her Death. May her Soul Rest in Peace.🕊️
Aap ki kahani sacchi aur tarksangat lagati hai.
Now I am confused, is he a doctor or advocate of talwar family
He changes his profession according to money.
In India normal people have more knowledge than one of the best forensic experts of India 😂😂😂
Maaksudu
True many Armchair detectives here spreading their $ hit
Aarushi was so beautiful and attractive. 💞❤️💖💞
@@krishnaswami3362 ye krle bhai tu 😹
I have read the entire book by Aviruk Sen.
Mr. Dogra it seems don't know what he is talking about.
Aviruk Sen specifically mentioned that the three friends of Hemraj were involved in murder.
The NARCO test was conducted and it is mentioned in book with all the summary that all the three agreed that they were at Hemraj house and one of them had killed Arushi.
I just want to know how in the hell three people who in the eyes of judiciary had not committed murder agree to be at Talwar's house and one of them agreeing murdering Arushi. Not only the culprits but entire police force is to be blamed for this mess.
The parents were imprisoned not because they were found guilty but police had no evidence that any other person might have entered the house to commit murder (even though they had evidence but had neglected time over time).
Why no one from outside could have killed arushi-
1. Body of Hemraj was on roof that was locked from inside. Only Servant of house or Family Members knows about where are Keys for roof. Also No one can jump roofs to go in and out of that Colony as it has one gate with watchman and then also lock stairs from inside.
2. The blood of hemraj had drag marks from terrace roof means body was dragged upstairs but whole blood till stairs and door of terrace was cleaned mostly.
3. Person has high intelligence to put body against ac exhaust so body decompose smell continuously flys away.
4. The cuts on neck made on Arushi was smaller in length uniform like professional and was put after her death from head injury. While hemraj died from longer uniform neck cut and was also hit.
5. Hemraj has Head injury at back side and Arushi had neck injury on from right side of head. And was hit with same object, suggesting Murder hitted Arushi and hemraj at same time but Arushi died and Hemraj must have went in shock or unconscious state.
6. To remove blood you need to have Required right material to clean evidence that not any normal person knows what to use.
7. The case was not of robbery but still Hemraj and Arushi’s mobile went missing. Why will someone take away their phones they aren’t worth anything. Only in case of those phones have some call records or data that can suspect suspicions you need to hide them. And if killer is from outside they wont call arushi but only hemraj so only Hemraj phone should have went missing.
8. If someones dear daughter dies you would work for her justice and well aware as doctor for crime scene evidence maintenance. You wont get house cleaned in 2 days with special solutions. You would go with police to make sure the process of catching Hemraj is expedited not just sit and wait until you already know he is dead too.
10. Interestingly there were two golf sticks in camera scene photographs but police had one in possession how would one golf stick missed as if grif stricken dad going in and out for investigation and jail was thinking to play golf? And he later on 2-3 years handed that stick to cbi!
11. The request of family members to forensic team to not to mention any assault if any is also strange as a family you would fight for your dead daughters justice as they didn’t know hemraj was dead till then considering he was alive.
12. Reports suggest her clothes were changed after death even innerwears and private ares were very well cleaned up- (this part not so sure though)
So you all can draw the inference! I rest my case.
Also the thing is hemeaj"s body was hidden with sheets. Why outsider will try to hide the body? Talwar family just wanted to hide the body so that they could disposs it off when the right time came.
Ap ka bethne or bitha kr sawal krne ka jo andaz hai .wo mujhe bohot pasand aata hai
This person has cleverly changed the story because he too is related to the medical profession and doesn't want a bad name for Talwars
Yes .....👍
Yes whitewashing
Yes
Your comment is complete BS. It's the job of the police and forensic teams to bring the correct evidence from the scene FOR investigation. When the police messed up COMPLETELY and allowed 100s of people into the house before investigation even started, why blame this Senior doctor???
Pls don't blame without iota of truth.
Finally a new truth about this case came out. GOOD JOB👏👏👏👏👏 I WAS IN COLLAGE THOSE DAYS, NATIONAL MEDIA GOT TRP.
Let him finish his statement, respect the speaker. Har jagah expertise daalne lagte hai.
@@king_vingyes he is a true badbola
Saurabh beech me bahut bolta hai raajdeep ki tarah😂😂
Ha yr 😂
Bhai unki Umar hogyi h, yaad dila rhe h ...help kr rhe h...i don't see why you're upset about it
haan na. It's so irritating
Thank you for sharing this video.
मैं भी पूरे दिन टीवी पर देखा करती थी,मुझे नूपुर तलवार को देखकर उसकी बातों से नहीं लगा कि वो किसी सदमे जैसे स्थिति में है। जिसके एक मात्र बेटी की हत्या हो गई हो वह इतनी सहनशीलता से सब कुछ बयां नही कर सकते, जैसे वो कर रही थी। कुछ तो है??
जी सही कह रहे हैं. आरुषि जैसी प्यारी बच्ची को अभी भी पूरा न्याय नहीं मिला है उस समय भी एक और परिवार.. और घर के दूसरे जो इनके निकट हैं...कई सबूत मिटाने की बात सामने आई थी. तथाकथित High profile... या किसी भी परिवार का कोई गहरा राज कोई बच्चा जान जाए तो उसे रास्ते से हुआ देते हैं. दो मुखौटे वाले लोग. समाज की एक कड़वी सच्चाई है..हेमराज की बॉडी नहीं मिलती तो उसे ही लोग गुनहगार समझते रहते आज तक.
जी हां
Matlb
With due regards, this version of the case misses the fact that the alleged murderer must have exited the house as well. But in the morning when the maid arrived, the main door was locked from inside and the terrace door was also locked from inside. Leaving no other way from which the alleged person must have escaped.
Right...also one more thing ...washing and painting done by arushis parents to destroy the evidence
@@mohammedrafeeq8550 they proved that CBI was informed of the painting beforehand
@@potbot887 no cbi denied that nobody from police told them to do so
@@luciifer666 from Wikipedia (it points to a media report on web archieve, check that if you don't trust wiki), search "painting" if you want to skip to the relevant section en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Noida_double_murder_case#The_case_against_the_Talwars
None of the doors were locked from inside
The home door was latched from outside which could have been done by the parents to make up a story
May her soul rest in Peace. I was in 9th standard when this case came out, now I am old & understand life much better.
One should not trust anybody except their parents it becomes more important for girls to do so.
I think people wanted to know whether arushi ever had affair with sevant or not??
@Indian_loner yes when this case came out, I remembered it as its my birthday date n so when new updates in case were revealing, I was really shocked
@@panksy2776 not a chance. If the parents gave her no attention and love and she had the servant for company then it is a bad situation.
मैंने सुना है के आरुषि के p. m. मै आया था के वो sexualy एक्टिव भी थी
@@ganeshamamata1117 har baat me salmaan khan or rahul gandhi ko kyun laate ho ji....🤣🤣
Rich, Influential, Well-connected parents bought every single step in criminal justice system...Police, CBI, Forensic, Media, Advocate, Judge...everyone..
@@anuraganurag7505 oh right ., that’s why they served jailed time & not because they tried to reopen the case despite being given a clean chit by the CBI & courts. 🤦♀️
@@PhenomenalDiva Bhai bada prachita case h time machine hota toh dekh ke ata
@@imposter1721 ???
Sourabh sir, in my polite opinion, whenever you do interview, please let speaker talk his complete story, to make any sense! Otherwise interview is quite raw and worth listening to!
A person who gives a loan does not kill. Having a young girl in the family and a man servant is a strict no no, and then he used to be alone with her when the parents did not come back from work.
This person is trying to protect the family. They did it out of rage and it was an accidental murder of the daughter. Hem Raj was punished thereafter and was killed when he ran to the roof to escape.
I believe this version of the incident more than any other because this seems logical. Thanks for sharing this view.
He would he run to roof and not outside of house when doors of terrace were locked
But Hemraj merder done half an hour before Aarushi's murder as per reports
She was sexually assaulted too that's why private parts were cleaned and many person where there at the time of murder this ain't work of one person both were killed with one sharp edged weapon only there was two entrance to house front door & back door it was work of an outsider probably servants coz of circumstances or it's someone else only as said by dr dogra or it's parents only coz of their suspicious behaviour & action..
Parents are the killers for sure and I agree with you on that but I don’t think it’s accidental.
Dogra Sir, I have heard the interview of Hemraj's wife in Nepal, she did not mention about any house. They were living in their mud house ... with handicapped son. Were you not the person in AIIMS who gave fake certificate that ONLY khukhri could have made those cuts ... your certificate was not acceptable to CBI. If you can prove that Hemraj had made a new house in Nepal, just one report or photograph , I will accept your theory.
point bro--- Dr Dogra theory is loaded in favour of talwar , and cant b digested
Yes dogra is actually the one that messes up this case. He should be ashamed of himself.
Right Brother, This Doctor is well known to the family, obviously he will take their side
@@deepakaggarwal9214 s,,,, u r absolutely rt,,,,,
He is making up a story. Loan master kills the man coz he was not paying up. Why he wld murder him? He needs to get his money back. He will scare him, beat him up etc. Totally baseless story. This is something cooked in the family only. Parents behaviour in the next morning says that. What is this docs explanation for girl's washed private part or the wetness behind her bottom.
finally some answers🎉
Wow, what a beautiful story teller is Mr. Tirath Das Gupta, he has self exposed himself that he was a Student of Arushi's Grandfather's. And he is described fantastically that Arushi's murdered had been executed by the persons from which Hemraj has taken Home Loans......Mr. Tirath Das Dogra indirectly told the truth that who is murdered and acclaimed that the murderer was very known to Arushi...... Now what is left to understand....
He says that Arushi's grandfather was Cardiothoracic surgeon, while Mr Dogra did his specialization in forensic science
@@bharatmanvendrakaushik his theory is bogus and almost nobody agrees with it, there are so many plot holes in this, to name a few why would this X killer would lock the terrace gate after killing hemraj, also arushi did not die due to the cut in the neck but due to the blunt force trauma on the head, how did the killer get the access to Arushis room which was supposed to be locked, what about the bloody finger print on the glass, why was arushis body cleaned, this guy is sold out and trying to save talwar's
@@ssdfhuasdfhj101 yes as i remember..
Arushi s body was cleaned specially vagina so that sperm traces could not be found
@@ssdfhuasdfhj101ocking the terrace door has no specific meaning but what any person does subconsciously rather than just leaving it open, also arushis room can be opened from inside, he might have knocked the door as that was the only option to kill her, if he was known to her.also only thing that confuses me is that why he took time to stage her body after killing her, if eliminating the eye witness after killing hemraj was his only motive , why would he spend time with arushis body and increase his chances of getting caught by her parents, who were in the next room.
@@2284917 the door was not just bolted, it was locked with a lock that is something very puzzling, also the face of arushi was covered, it is a well known forencis theory that killers that are related to victim tend to cover their dead face as they cannot look at the face
Question 1. How come the door was closed from inside and did both parents not see anything ?
2. As it was observed by investigation that the cut made was with professional medical equipment in a perfect manner so was the financer (if he was) qualified to make a precise cut ?
3. Why was the body cremated before the post mortem ?
@@vaishalivats5005 seen both the versions but still questions still not clear
@@RahulHaritOfficial it's also very strange that why would a murderer pull the body all the way up to the roof after the murder.
His motive was finished once he murdered , his next move would be to leave the house ASAP and not drag that heavy body to the stairs and if he had the access to the keys and knowledge of stairs then he also must have known that the Talwars were next door.
So he kills Hemraj and Arushi , drags hemrajs body while the Talwars are present and spares them.
Quite weird and Delhi police would have solved this case in 3 days if they were not corrupt.
Also isn't it weird that Arushi's body was quickly cremated before her postmortem.
No parent would let their murdered child be cremated before they know the exact reason of death and time of murder of their beloved child which is only possible with the help of Postmortem.
@@vaishalivats5005 Yeah as if Talwars wouldn't have given money to its producers to clear their name in front of public.
You must be one of those to believe that Sanjay Dutt has quit taking hard drugs after watching the movie Sanju.
@@nuclear9977 no it's not like that but still question remains. It was resolved on the basis of theory as facts were manipulated at earlier investigation which means knowing the law fact and responsible doctors body was cremated without autopsy. So doubt will always remain whatsoever theory is presented.
nope, there was post mortem done on arushi s body as well
There are few discrpancies
Why was Hemrajs body covered and hidden in such a way it could not be seen
WHY WAS THE TERRACE DOOR LOCKED ? Why would a killer take all the efforts to lock the terrace door. Mind you the Terrace door lock keys were with the Talwars, since they could not come as they were immersing Arushis ashes, they told the police to break the lock.
Why would the killer sit down and drink whisky after murdering, there were blood marks on whisky bottle. Normal reaction of killer SHOULD be to make a hasty exit.
Why was there router/internet activity in Rajeshs room deep into the night
If Hemraj was murdered on terrace why there were blood trails on stairs.
Why were Arushis remains disposed of the next day itself. Normally they are done on 10/11/12th day.
If the parents were "Educated" why did they allow the crime scene to be contaminated by all relatives and nieghbours. Why was Arushis room cleaned before police arrived, why were mattresses removed
And many more........
Tu bhakt haina ?
@@Ankitsharma.jackjack
Bhakt kiska
No Bhakt
Hate all polticians
Hamam mai sab nange hai
@@Naresh00009It's not Halal it's Hamam ( Turkish or Arabic Bathub)
@@Naresh00009 Coming to your Questions, u r 1000% spot on .... Killers r her Parents
@@arvindahuja1996
Sorry
Corrected
In a documentary i saw
When the maid came in the morning, the door was locked from inside.
The dead body of Hemraj was found 2 days after his murder on the terrace. The gate of the terrace was locked, when police asked Arushi's parents about keys they said they don't know where the Keys.
I think parents are the killers.
Very simplistic explaination,
Yeah, after watching this it seems like ek simple story ko kitna complicate kiya gaya.....
इतना कुछ होता रहा और तलवार दाम्पति पूरी रात चैन की नींद सोते रहे... Nice और नौकर के बारे मे कोई जानकरी न रखना भी अच्छी बात है... 👌बहुत आदर्श व्यक्ति थे दोनों... 😂
और दूर बैठ कर मोबाइल पर किसी को judge करना भी अच्छी बात नहीं है पार्थ!
ओ चैन की निंद नहीं सो रहे थे, नोकर की बॉडी ठिकाने लगानेके लिये पुरी रात मेहनत कर रहे थे!😂
बिलकुल सही कह रहे हैं कोई बाहर से आया ही नहीं ये उन दिनों मीडिया में ख़ूब आ रहा था… CBI अदालत ने माता पिता को आरोपी ठहराते हुए आजीवन कारावास दिया था बाद में सबूत न मिलने पर उनको निर्दोष क़रार दे दिया गया । जैसे श्रद्धा आफ़ताब केस ,इसमें आफ़ताब ने क़बूल भी कर लिया कि उसी ने मारा है उसी ने टुकड़े किया है फिर भी सबूत जुटाने में लगे हैं
@@Vijaykmr11 schi bta yr mera to sala dinag khrab ho gya
Kon murderer hai yaar?
Agar hemraj ke dost nepali ne dono ko mara hai to
Us time arushi ke mmy papa kahan the?😅
Yese adarsh ki beti bhi fertilizer se hui or mrte huy pta ni..... Or yese sanskar hua ki pta bhi ni chla
If arushi had seen the murder she might have raised her voice or ran to her parents room why didn't her parents woke up till then ? Doctor is known to talwar family it's ok and good , but why known person got taken as investigating doctor in this case ?
Arushi didn't see the murder....she saw the murderer while coming to meet hemraj....
True
Paise khane ke liye
@@captainguts4571Right 🇨🇦
She had not seen the murder...but she had seen him coming to home...and later when the murder of hemraj would have been found..she would be the eye witness of his friend coming to meet him at night
Dogra uncleji you are an inspiration and always feels good to meet you.Wishing a healthy life
बहुत अच्छे से बचाया है डॉक्टर साहब ने अपने डॉक्टर मित्रों को 😊
Abe paagal ho kya ! Parents do logon ko maar ke so Gaye aur Krishna jo khud bola maine mara wo innocent hai wtf
When the doctor has personal acquaintance with the main accused i.e. her parents, his opinions are bound to be partial. Opinions should only be taken from a third party who is not related to the victim or the accused and can give impartial information. I am sure Dr. is giving his opinion based on his experience but he does seem influenced by her parents.
She was sexually assaulted too that's why private parts were cleaned and many person where there at the time of murder this ain't work of one person both were killed with one sharp edged weapon only there was two entrance to house front door & back door it was work of an outsider probably servants coz of circumstances or it's someone else only as said by dr dogra or it's parents only coz of their suspicious behaviour & action
Actually such a person should not be allowed in investigation at all, let be police team, forensic team or medico legal section.
Arushis mom never pressed the police to find the killer and once said "I hope someone is out there who has killed her".. What does this mean.. Hope.... It means she is not even sure if someone killed her... If her daughter was killed by someone they would have gone crazy with anger.. But they have been always calm
I don't agree with this theory - a professional killer will never made a mistake to kill someone in someone else house.
Aarushi's Parents didn't know who is coming to there home is unbelievable as well.
In the end,its like noone killed both as Parents proved not guilty n noone else either.
A sad ending n heartbreaking too as both deserved justice!!!
Only a person who is VERY JUST n MORAL can write such a LONG POSTS to expose d CULPRITS !!.👍♥️.D thing s sm1 CARES..!! N cant see any1 being WRONGED !! Hats off Mr. Vingurjar 👍🧡💞
Extremely tragic🥲may their Souls rest in peace 🙏🏽can’t imagine how the Parents lived their life after their only child murdered and they were sent to prison ..no one knows what happened that night
I am not questioning the credibility of the guest but the fact is that we still don't know who killed Arushi..
justice is yet to be served & our judiciary system has failed big time atleast in this case..
What can i say man😔
May her soul rest in peace..
Om Shanti🙏
It's not judiciary's fault. Rather the fault is solely of our investigating agencies. Judge ko pehle din se pata hota hai ki kaun guilty hai. Wo evidence ka wait karte rehta hai par evidence nhi aata hai.
@@vaibhavsingh471 Aap ne jo kaha yeh sab film o me achcha lagta hai but With all due respect I think it is,and let me be very clear I am not saying our judiciary system is a failure or fuck things up every time but man..there are few instances like that and court has the power to make the decision,atleast they should have set examples by punishing those Cops hard..there was a unforgiving amount of negligence during first investigation so yeah,I wish I have kinder words but it is what it is..most of us in our society specially in powerfull postions people who doesn't give a flying fish and has no fear for judicial system whatsoever..
She was sexually assaulted too that's why private parts were cleaned and many person where there at the time of murder this ain't work of one person both were killed with one sharp edged weapon only there was two entrance to house front door & back door it was work of an outsider probably servants coz of circumstances or it's someone else only as said by dr dogra or it's parents only coz of their suspicious behaviour & action
Who killed ssr,disha salian ,jiah khan.Disha was raped and thrown naked from the 4th floor of a party attended by well known goondas and passed off as suicide.The same type of mafia connected with politicians have raped and killed arushi.Our police are not so foolish as to not to find out but they are helpless. Crime scene kn arushi and ssr case was thoroughly destroyed by professional person not by parents and the whole drama was presented to the public.
@@SheilaRoy-d4d Lol now who will target one 13 yr old girl to rape and kill her that too in her own house when parents are present at house ssr case is different where mafia politicians are involved somewhat i suspect her ex bf coz he is a big shot guy he was desperate for her and she also used to avoid him also hemraj called to dubai one day before murder also talvar were members of wife swapping club swingers used to come at their house possibly this all can be connected but it can't be revealed
This guys version makes more sense than everything we have heard about this case until now. May that little girl's soul rest in peace...my heart was with the parents even then and still goes to them...I wish this case would have been solved for the sake of the parents and the stigma attached....what a shame...
Why that person (killer) lock terrace door ?
Please read and watch more about this to understand the clear case.
2007 वो टाईम.....
I don't understand how people can believe this newly fabricated theory. If the killer was someone else (who gave loan) that means krishna and other servants are innocent. And then his narco test confession and what was shown in TALWAR movie was also wrong.
This doctor is simply trying to defend parents in some way or the other. He himself said that he personally knows rajesh talwar's father.
@@ashi_s exactly, i mentioned the same in my comment
This is the most clear and plausible dissection of this case I have ever seen / heard. The evidence backs up this forensic pathologists version. R.I.P Arushi. Question is....will the killer ever be found?
Being himself as a doctor he is supporting dr parents only.
He is saving them.
This was clear case of honour किलिंग
This is such heart breaking story 😢
Still I don't agree/ 2 murders happen and parents can't hear anything. Many loopholes are there in the story.
@@john2007150 if u had followed the case from start 2 finish u would know why they couldn’t hear anything .
The aircon in their room made a lot of noise due to which no noise from the outside could be heard in their room. The CBI even did a drill test & confirmed that indeed nothing can be heard inside when the aircon was on.
Nice story created. Raat ko chhote bachon ko sunana. Do kamre ke makan mein do murder or parents ko pata he nahi. Only Rajesh Tawar killed them with golf stick. Dr. Sahib ko kitne paise mile hain false story sunane ke.
It's hard to believe that these gruesome murders happened without anyone noticing it. Either the killer was an absolute expert at causing damage to the voice box, or it was an inside job. may be both.
Arushi and Hemraj both deserve justice, but the question is: will it be served?💔
Itne saal nahi hua...ab kya hoga....same in Sushant Singh Rajput murder case..all the evidences were destroyed and a fictitious story was build up to make it look like suicide
Killer wasn't an expert, he left clues and evidence in abundance but our authorities and media were expert in mishandling the case and destroying those evodences.
my ll
Are Arushi k parents ne hi mara, this old man defending them because of connections with them, Talwar family had excellent connections with influenced people, even in CBI
@@puneetrathi2610 right
This theory of Dogra is likely incorrect if the Loan person killed both then who locked the Door from the inside, as it was clearly reported when the maid came in the morning it was locked from the inside.
what about manish gupta case and balwant singh case kanpur??
Dear no one knows about the door theory and the house help clearly said she dosn remember if the house was locked from inside. So it was the other servant Krishna pls watch this documentary Arushi beyond reasonable doubts ul kno the truth.
I am not convinced by his story ,complete clean chit de diya . Also he got connections with the family
So he is the person who saved real murderer.
True this crooked old man is the real culprit
Aarushi was murdered by her own parents. Pls understand that if an outsider killer did this, he would have not locked the terrace door and then killed aarushi & left so easily. it was the parents who did this & only god knows the reason behind this. One more thing i would like to highlight if this was done by any servant they would have cracked down in front of police...it was a well planned murder and only an educated person like her parents could plan all this as hemraj was killed brutally however aarushi throat was slit like a surgeon cut, Not easy to kill their own child in a brutal way. This will remain a mystery and a poor soul left for her heavenly abode without getting a justice 😔
Very sad to know that even our so called cbi was unsuccessful to solve the case . It questions the credeblity of CBI
Right
Absolutely!!! Parents ne naukar ko maar kar chhat par chupa diya aur seedha blame bhi ussi par lga diyaa, iss case mein kuch bhi nahi tha, totally open tha,but media ne achcha bewakoof banaaya,
Yes parents are the killers
You guys must be stupid Nepalis are known to be very violent they are not afraid of anything.
Very saddening and unfortunate. Hope the parents were able to find some solace over the years.
RIP.
Lol parents only killed her
Her parent is a murderer. Cause he is doctor n influential person in delhi
@@karmilosequeira4249 Okay, Sherlock Holmes 🤣
आरूषि was so beautiful. I love her photo. I have it always in my phone.
@@krishnaswami3362 That's hella creepy bro 😝
Dr. Dogra looks upto the Talwar family, one of them was a senior professor of his.
There are several discrepancies- the finger points towards the parents.
Whoever is saying that the parents are the murders answer me these:-
1.Hemraj phone being picked up in the morning for 2 sec then getting disconnected at 1 km radius. Hemraj ka phone Ghar ke bahar kese gaya if parents were the murders Clearly indicates murderer was an outsider
2. Why would they kill their daughter?
Ohh because they caught her with hemraj in between a intercourse? Tell me koi golf stick uthane room se bahar kyu jayfa woh bare hands se Hemraj ko hata sakta aur usse peet sakta tha
Par nhi woh pehle room se bahar golf stick laya fir usse mara.
3. The Pillow cover with blood stains was found at Krishna's house. Along with a kukri.
4.Camera was gifted early:- That's because it arrived via courier a day before also the parents wanted to give her a early birthday surprise because arushi wanted to record his 14th birthday.
Aur agar unhone usse birthday se 8 din pehle de diya camera on the same day of murder Iska matlab toh murder pre-planned kiya hoga parents ne??
This contradicts the theory that hemraj was caught with Arushi
5.Lack of Motive: The Talwars were speculated to have committed the murders due to a perceived motive related to honor or personal issues. However, proponents of the outsider theory argue there was no substantial evidence linking them directly to the crime.
You can check what a beautiful message Arushi had wrote for her mother on mother's day 4 days before the murder indicating no conflict between the two
I can 100% Bet that the killer was an outsider
As someone called hemraj from A nearby PCO before the murders happened.
@@hyp3842 Let me give you 4 perfect facts which may change your mind:-
A) If an outsider killed hemraj, Why would he locked the door and left locking the main door
B) Aarushi friend called at 12 am on landline which was kept in rajesh room, Why didnt he lifted the call?
C) Hemraj was killed brutally not aarushi, again indicated that outsider should not have any sympathy for her too while killing
D) Aarushi and hemraj phone got switched off at 10 pm, Nupur phone also got switched off around same time which is not a coincidence but a planned thing. Her phone got switched off first time in a year, what a coincidence?
Please understand if this would have been done by servants, police would have cracked them in a day. Parent killed them both...Believe it or not
@@nitinpoplyA new modified Theory...
.
Someone very familiar well known with Hemraj and Aarushi
had quarrel with Hemraj that night
.
He must be dominating Hemraj with money borrowing
.
Under influence of alcohol
Unknown killed hemarj first
.
Aarushi witnessed that and was killed by unknown
.
Parents got to know this
And tried to cover up everything so that blame would not come on them
...
Any objection to this theory
Mind blowing analytical observation hats off you my mind always,says that their parents are real accused
लल्लन भाई
कोर्ट के अंतिम डिसीजन को यदि word by word यदि पढ़ लेते तो ये वीडियो आप अपने सस्ती लोकप्रियता के लिए नही बनाते।
अब इस मुद्दे को उछाल कर आप बेमतलब का मुद्दा मात्र अपने चैनल का व्यू बढ़ाने के लिए कर रहे हो।
सब जानते हैं क्या हुआ और कोर्ट का भी quote भी पढ़ लिया करो।
Truly said, may be it is a sponsored interview
Yaar that time I was 6 year old, this story left great impact on my mind, ..... Even I was not able to sleep for 2 days........ 😭😭😭😭
😂😂
Sitting arrangement of the Lallantop staffs was ridiculous...and unprofessional....
I don't believe his theory, the terrace was locked and the parents refused to give the keys at first place. As per forensic arushi's was killed at around 2-3 AM in the night.
Ye baat kisne batai k unhone Dene se mana kiya police ne khud check nai kiya toh unpe blame daal diya ghar ka Tala toh tha nai k bina permission k tod nai sakte the jiske ghar pe khoon hua uski Har ek baat mani police ne
@@Akankshasingh-ci7nd Police killed Arushi
@@Akankshasingh-ci7nd पहली बार ताला तो था न। उसकी चाबी के लिया कहा था हेमराज को पता होगी। ताला अंदर से लगा यही एक एविडेंस पैरेंट्स के खिलाफ। पूरा खेल खेला तलवार ने।
Which forensic report have you read that aarushi murder timing was at around 2-3 am...
@@rajendrakhani8282 😂😂 sahi kaha
Clear lie, this man is a friend of talwar family...That murder was done by her parents as they see both of them together in objectionable condition.
Most probably yhi hai jo aap keh rhe hai...
Yes, correct. No one entered from outside. Even if the loan master entered, cannot kill hemraj like that in someone's house based on an argument.Also it was not necessary to kill witness in such a way, whereas as all doors locked from inside
Talwars hired a third person to kill both of them
In that case, if the parents are not guilty, they must be definately knowing the person who's guilty. If the murderer was known to Arushi & Hemraj, parents must also be having some idea, who's it
Read my points
Not necessarily her parents knew him
Yes, Aisa ho hi nahi sakta ki Aarushi kabhi batayi na ho.
Aur kabhi na kabhi koi na koi to dekha hi hoga ki koi aata hai inke ghar
You are right
She was sexually assaulted too that's why private parts were cleaned and many person where there at the time of murder this ain't work of one person both were killed with one sharp edged weapon only there was two entrance to house front door & back door it was work of an outsider probably servants coz of circumstances or it's someone else only as said by dr dogra or it's parents only coz of their suspicious behaviour & action..
आरुषि आज भी इंसाफ नही मिला इस बात का आज भी दुख है इस रहस्य का पर्दाफाश होना चाहिए