JUST LIKE HEAVEN Dinosaur Jr (cover) VS The Cure (original) | GOOD COVER BAD COVER

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 дек 2024

Комментарии • 51

  • @willchristopher1899
    @willchristopher1899 10 месяцев назад +21

    Robert Smith preferred the version by Dinosaur Jr. and said the Cure always played closer to the Dinosaur Jr. version.

    • @TakenUsernameAuradium
      @TakenUsernameAuradium 7 месяцев назад +1

      I don't hear the difference from the studio version and the live versions when the cure plays it. Can you point out any differences

  • @s.collintuck3227
    @s.collintuck3227 9 месяцев назад +12

    Best. Cover. Ever.

  • @flawedcorerecords4918
    @flawedcorerecords4918 10 месяцев назад +12

    When I was 14 I discovered I could partly pull out my headphones from the jack and hear songs in a different way. Vocals kinda removed. You get to hear stuff buried in the mix… and on Dinosaur Jr’s version of Just like Heaven you can hear Mascis burp loudly with reverb.
    Anyway…

    • @TakenUsernameAuradium
      @TakenUsernameAuradium 7 месяцев назад +1

      I think it only removed the mono signal when you do that

  • @ChimeraLV
    @ChimeraLV 9 месяцев назад +7

    I think I remember reading about the abrupt ending. That the Master tapes got fucked, and just abruptly ended, and after listening they just liked it and kept it as is.

  • @bryanforis1839
    @bryanforis1839 Год назад +4

    This way they are in the rock and roll hall of fame

  • @asseater5773
    @asseater5773 Год назад +7

    I recommend listening to Little Fury Things, great dinosaur Jr song. Also I love your channel

  • @chrisandersen5635
    @chrisandersen5635 Год назад +3

    I just saw The Cure almost two weeks ago. They played for almost three hours. Many of the hits, deep album cuts and seven new songs that are possibly on the forthcoming album if they ever actually release it. They still sound great. Just like The Cure. Been listening since 1985 when Head on the Door was the current album. They helped me through some times.

  • @anthonypallen7919
    @anthonypallen7919 Год назад +2

    Robert Smith is a very underated musician. The band rocks loud live . I'm seing em next weekend in Mtl

  • @salvadorJugodelucuma20
    @salvadorJugodelucuma20 6 месяцев назад +2

    THIS COVER REALLY IS THE BEST I HAVE EVER HEARD!

  • @predeterminedmeat5024
    @predeterminedmeat5024 Год назад +2

    Original Just Like Heaven was alright. Dinosaur Jr killed it. Robert Smith agrees! Also Dinosaur Jr ran out of tape on the cover of Just like heaven because the album they did before that single had a lot of layering

  • @flatwavemike1269
    @flatwavemike1269 11 месяцев назад +2

    The Cure can’t be beat but the cover is great in context. Im sure it’s hard to understand Dinosaur Jr without hearing their music. I’ve seen it live so many times from both bands and never disappointed in either.

  • @daytrippingcalifornia3270
    @daytrippingcalifornia3270 5 месяцев назад +1

    Husker Du's cover of The Byrds' Eight Miles High is another phenomenal cover. It will knock your socks off.

  • @Alifesalife
    @Alifesalife 4 месяца назад +2

    J’s vision and expression through guitar is unmatched. Can’t stand the sickly sweet soppiness of the original or any cure song tbh.

  • @enriquemora9272
    @enriquemora9272 Год назад +2

    Love Song. I guess that's the other Song from the Cure you were trying to remember.

  • @mattjohn4731
    @mattjohn4731 Год назад +4

    Was the end even more shocking than the scream on "YOOUUU"? Heheh that's Lou Barlow screaming. He does that on a few songs, "Don't" in particular, quite bleak sounding, like early Stooges but much noisier. But they have some much cleaner songs you would like. Feel The Pain, Out There, Over It, Freak Scene, and their later music videos are great. They feature great guests such as Henry Rollins, Maria Bamford, Fred Armisen... Also OFF! makes excellent music videos. Do you have any taste for hardcore or noise? I do, obviously heheh

    • @mattjohn4731
      @mattjohn4731 Год назад

      Oh live '97, Lou was kicked out in like '89. So that bassist was Mike, who did not scream YOU. J is great, he's my happy times concert dude

  • @bassage13
    @bassage13 3 месяца назад +1

    Big Muff is all over that DJ cover.

  • @stevepreece2931
    @stevepreece2931 Год назад +1

    I loved the cure as a teenager and still do. First album for me was seventeen seconds, had one of my favourites; the forest on it.

  • @wozzab9136
    @wozzab9136 Год назад +1

    One of my favourite covers. Love both versions

  • @mattgreenway9270
    @mattgreenway9270 7 месяцев назад +1

    Dinosaur Jr does awesome covers, this is one of their best.

  • @victorbortolussi2964
    @victorbortolussi2964 Год назад +6

    Dinosaur Jr. was grunge before Nirvana. 😂

    • @fraincs
      @fraincs 9 месяцев назад +3

      Kurt ask J Mascis to join Nirvana

    • @genericwhitemale1114
      @genericwhitemale1114 14 дней назад

      I mean there were a ton of bands who were doing grunge before Nirvana. Alice in Chains for example. Nirvana just got famous because Kurt offed himself.

  • @steveg8102
    @steveg8102 6 месяцев назад +1

    Yes way ... P.s. listen to the song in a jar...it's amazing.

  • @robshaw2639
    @robshaw2639 Год назад +1

    omg. this was out of the blue... did not expect The Cure in this series... I can go on and on about The Cure. OK. one more listen to the cover before I comment...

  • @AMGK
    @AMGK 5 месяцев назад +1

    Dinosaur jr 🦖💜🔥

  • @brienjennings8432
    @brienjennings8432 7 месяцев назад +2

    the live version is absolutely just like heaven

  • @annaclarafenyo8185
    @annaclarafenyo8185 7 месяцев назад +1

    This is actually the plot of "Finnegans Wake", I never realized it before.

  • @aobsession
    @aobsession 6 месяцев назад +1

    Dinosaur Jr. always! But did anyone come here to plug the AFI version performed in front of the Cure at an MTV tribute to the Cure?

  • @Chief2112
    @Chief2112 Год назад +1

    How much Cure are you familiar with? I’d love to see more reaction to them. I think they are so incredible. Roberts instrumentation and sense of melody is incredible.

  • @robshaw2639
    @robshaw2639 Год назад +1

    OK. let's talk - there are 2 kinds of 80s bands: those stuck in the 80s (I'll refrain from naming names with last name Iris and others ...) and those who were looking forward (The Cure, Jane's Addiction, Morrissey, Sting...) So, even though I've never heard of this - it's a good cover... this band was clearly moving forward from the 80s in a good way... To be fair, there are good 80s-stuck bands (Human League, Blondie, Eurythmics...). oh. wait. I wan't supposed to name names... oops.

  • @g0ated2k81
    @g0ated2k81 3 месяца назад

    i would 100% watch a video of you reacting and listening to a dino jr album and this cover rocks 🤟🤟

  • @dylandenney3980
    @dylandenney3980 8 месяцев назад +1

    Give You're Living All Over Me a listen. It's the most interesting album in their discography to me. You can hear their influence on grunge, shoegaze and stoner rock

  • @Absorbvids
    @Absorbvids Месяц назад

    It’s a great cover, it’s its own thing. You need to dig deeper into their catalog.

  • @bocswu
    @bocswu 9 месяцев назад

    13:25 I first heard this on their best of album Ear-Bleeding Country from 2001. I had your reaction. I returned the CD and said I'd like another copy because there was a song that was faulty. Nope, turns out I was the one that was faulty.

  • @rand9994
    @rand9994 4 месяца назад

    Great vid man. Check out J's cover of Fade Into You by Mazzy Star. I hope you've listened to more of Mascis, his solo albums are incredible. My fave DJ album is Where You Been. I wish I could experience them again for the first time like you did here.

  • @rimskykorsakov2892
    @rimskykorsakov2892 Год назад

    The Cure... Now there's a rabbit hole

  • @LinnRooney
    @LinnRooney 3 месяца назад

    Check out breathe

  • @donnelson6694
    @donnelson6694 Год назад

    The original just can't be beat but the live version from Dinosaur Jr is a decent cover in my opinion.

  • @anthonypallen7919
    @anthonypallen7919 Год назад

    I'll go with the cure on this one lol

  • @sonicsrasta
    @sonicsrasta 2 месяца назад +1

    😂the only band as cool as Dinosaur was Royal Trux😂

  • @michaelwatson7479
    @michaelwatson7479 4 месяца назад

    Dinosaur jr version is so in your face, it can be jarring but the lazy vocal drawl really suits the melody and lyrics of the song - that "Must have been asleep for days" line, lol

  • @victorbortolussi2964
    @victorbortolussi2964 Год назад

    Thats It! 😂
    But there is better versions.

  • @sethcashman1011
    @sethcashman1011 Год назад

    Yeah, I have to say, I appreciate artists (Dinosaur Jr. included) covering songs and marking their territory. Sometimes it really works well. But, in this case, I'll stick with the original, thank you.

  • @enriquemora9272
    @enriquemora9272 Год назад +2

    Different, original, that's for sure. But I wouldn't say it's a good cover. Don't like it. Maybe the problem is that the original song is such a perfect tune imo.

  • @Owlstretchingtime78
    @Owlstretchingtime78 Год назад +1

    It's laughable that these two versions should be compared. I love Dinosaur Jr, but they just rode roughshod over a beautiful song!

  • @MrKatsdad2112
    @MrKatsdad2112 Год назад

    To me this is both good and bad. I love the idea, but the execution is not my favorite. I've always felt it's a young band that's still figuring out there sound and learning the studio. Dinosaur Jr. along with the Pixies are so influential on the Grunge movement. You could have heard Start Choppin or Feel like Pain both were minor hits in the 90s.