White Holes | Answers With Joe

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 2,3 тыс.

  • @devinfuerst3949
    @devinfuerst3949 5 лет назад +213

    I appreciate that, in a world where men showing emotion to strangers is generally discouraged, you make the effort at the end of every video to say “Love ya guys. Take care..” It really is a nice shred of humanity that you add to your channel. 👍

    • @nic9061
      @nic9061 Год назад +4

      I’m assuming you don’t know many men…. It’s ok. I love you

    • @CRneu
      @CRneu Год назад +4

      @@nic9061 seeing as their username is "devin" i'm gonna wager they know plenty of men and are likely male themself. i could be wrong on their gender though.
      believe it or not in a lot of places and social circles men still aren't supposed to show emotion or be positive.

    • @nic9061
      @nic9061 Год назад

      @@CRneu that’s bs, the only friend named devin that I have is a girl (good job assigning gender based by name) and the two emotions men should have are happy and angry. Where do you get the idea men shouldn’t be positive or only guys should be named Devon you sexist, misogynist, gender assigning doctor 😡 I still love you though

    • @albertalbert4333
      @albertalbert4333 Год назад +3

      Wtf? Don't drag feelings into this...

    • @Drunk3nMonk3y72
      @Drunk3nMonk3y72 Год назад

      I’ve never heard him
      that. Then I probs never make it right to the end.

  • @Kaelygon
    @Kaelygon 5 лет назад +826

    Underrated quote
    "When it comes to cosmological stuff, insane is just the default mode."

    • @TheJelllyFishLover
      @TheJelllyFishLover 4 года назад +7

      I read this at the same time he said it

    • @ChiefLeef
      @ChiefLeef 4 года назад +5

      @@TheJelllyFishLover seriously,i w
      swear it happened with me too

    • @danielstone9978
      @danielstone9978 4 года назад

      It's you who states it as underrated.
      Maybe you should rate this comment, rather than claim the rate to be under...

    • @ChiefLeef
      @ChiefLeef 4 года назад

      @@danielstone9978 the moment I was waiting for,,,,,
      r/whooosh

    • @realzachfluke1
      @realzachfluke1 3 года назад

      @@TheJelllyFishLover LITERALLY SAME lmfao

  • @Nikoisntanotter
    @Nikoisntanotter 5 лет назад +89

    I love how you can simultaneously make me wanna explore the universe while also making me want to go in a corner and cry because no one really matters in the grand scheme of things.

    • @donngreitontordilla1456
      @donngreitontordilla1456 5 лет назад +9

      Allow me to recommend Kurzgesagt's video on optimistic nihilism as a balm for that existential anxiety. Veritasium's is good, too, and the video's called Our Greatest Delusion, if memory serves.

    • @Nikoisntanotter
      @Nikoisntanotter 5 лет назад +1

      Donn Greiton Tordilla I’ll be sure to check them out now! Thanks!

    • @glenjennett
      @glenjennett Год назад

      Why would something you can do nothing about make you cry? Easier to just accept there are things we can do nothing about and go on about your day.

  • @NZBushido
    @NZBushido 5 лет назад +450

    My favourite gravity based response to "What's up?", is: "Outwards from a center of mass"

    • @MrEnjoivolcom1
      @MrEnjoivolcom1 5 лет назад +2

      Hahaha, total greatness!

    • @gpll8135
      @gpll8135 5 лет назад +8

      How many gravity based responses to “whats up” do you know

    • @NZBushido
      @NZBushido 5 лет назад +4

      At least two

    • @kenlarsen6361
      @kenlarsen6361 5 лет назад

      Opposite the center of the nearest planetary body.

    • @kenlarsen6361
      @kenlarsen6361 5 лет назад

      Tilt you head back and look, there it is.

  • @viggovictory
    @viggovictory 5 лет назад +129

    I remember a party I went to, about 4 years ago, that I talked to a physics major about this exact idea, i don’t think either of us have ever talked about it since, but the idea stuck with me, so hearing the idea again from one of my favorite RUclipss is honestly a surreal experience. Though I do feel like it seems more likely now that I’ve heard it somewhere else

    • @kaibaCorpHQ
      @kaibaCorpHQ 5 лет назад +1

      I saw a movie once (for the life of me I can't remember what it was called, but it was some random sci-fi movie on Netflix) and it was going through the life of this guy and about how he was near death, then the end of the movie comes and he dies, then he starts living his life backwards. I hope that's not what happens lol.

    • @ashleysmith1276
      @ashleysmith1276 5 лет назад +3

      Sounds like an awesome conversation to have when you are high af.

    • @Lazy_Tim
      @Lazy_Tim 4 года назад

      @@kaibaCorpHQ
      The Curious Case of Benjamin Button ?

    • @kaibaCorpHQ
      @kaibaCorpHQ 4 года назад +1

      @@Lazy_Tim No that wasn't it. The movie started out with him in a hospital bed in the future, and it was just retelling his life, then at the end they comeback to him in the future and he dies.

  • @shawnblackburn7568
    @shawnblackburn7568 5 лет назад +490

    So we are going to ignore that at the end he made a theory that could possibly be true OK

    • @MrSimonw58
      @MrSimonw58 4 года назад +30

      Very speculative

    • @ulrichsrensen8520
      @ulrichsrensen8520 4 года назад +14

      I would love it if nick lucid could take a look at the hypothesis

    • @tagootuesday6521
      @tagootuesday6521 4 года назад +3

      Simon Watts yeah but I think itd be worth looking into haha he said himself is 100% speculation

    • @crysanthiumvega
      @crysanthiumvega 4 года назад +30

      That logic doesn't loop back around.
      If there is matter in this interlinked universe that's causing enough gravity into ours to dramatically effect the mass of our galaxies, then surely there's enough matter or anti-matter, or substance or whatever you want to call it to punch a hole through their universe back into ours.
      So where are the white holes?

    • @TheGalantir
      @TheGalantir 4 года назад +7

      I don't think so because even in the speculative theory he proposes there's seem to be some weird things happening.
      The anti matter black holes affect our dark matter while he says that our black holes affect the anti matter universes dark energy.
      To me the more logical thing would be that it would effect the same things in both universes, either dark matter or dark energy.
      The other problems is that he says there would be 8 dimensions but to me the more logical would be still 4 dimensions.
      Remember according to this, anti matter just travels in reverse in the time dimensions which means it is still the same time dimension the other ones would also still be the same dimension. So it kinda baffles me where the other 4 should come from.
      This problem arises from the fact that at one point he switches from time traveling backwards to just plain traveling in another dimension.
      Now even if it was traveling in another time dimension this does not instantly mean that the others are also other dimensions, they could still very well be the exact same dimensions.
      Now it might be hard to imagine but when we have only one dimension and two things travel in opposite directions they only touch at one point not everywhere.
      The same thing still holds for 2 and 3 dimensions and as far as i am aware of this still holds true in higher dimensions.
      So the effects should only be visible or noticeable in a tiny part of our universe not everywhere like we see in our universe.
      So no it is extremely unlikely for this theory to be true.
      Keep in mind that in proposing new theories even the smallest details matter.

  • @sulanis8444
    @sulanis8444 4 года назад +63

    So here's the interesting part. The thought that we are going forward in time, and they are going back in time. IS relative to perspective. Would they on the other side consider themselves the normal flow of time and we are the reverse?
    I read some of the comments and I love that people are talking about his theory. I love that even if its True or Not true it still leads to new idea's and new perspectives to add to the idea. I'm not going to pretend to understand it all, but It's so interesting that their may be a negative universe right up against ours.

    • @itsnaughty653
      @itsnaughty653 4 года назад +3

      I guess, it's interesting enough for Christopher nolan to make a Interestellar part 2 😂😂😂

    • @cj92it
      @cj92it 3 года назад +3

      yeah .... I recently came to the conclusion that WE are actually going backwards in time ......

    • @coltonbates629
      @coltonbates629 3 года назад

      @@cj92it How so buddy guy?

    • @cj92it
      @cj92it 3 года назад

      @@coltonbates629 I don't know how.
      It's just an idea, but we can only see things as they were, but never really as they are.

    • @lonestarr1490
      @lonestarr1490 3 года назад +1

      "Would they on the other side consider themselves the normal flow of time and we are the reverse?"
      Most probably. I mean, that's what it means for the field equations being invariant under the direction of time. Assigning a '+' and a '-' (or a 'positive' and a 'negative') is more or less a matter of definition ...
      ... Except for the stuff that actually breaks t-symmetry, like spontaneous magnetization in the ferromagnet or chiral spin liquids (whatever this is). So yeah, it makes a difference, but it's unclear (at least to me) to which extent this would make a noticeable difference in such a time reversed universe.

  • @TrapDaily
    @TrapDaily 5 лет назад +202

    This sounds crazy but makes alot of sense at the same time

    • @MikeFoxGolf
      @MikeFoxGolf 4 года назад +3

      I agree it does seem to explain the unexplained.

    • @stupiddykeenie
      @stupiddykeenie 3 года назад

      Same forward time?

  • @jpeezy6273
    @jpeezy6273 5 лет назад +219

    Joe: Disney said they wanted their own Star Wars
    Disney: Buys it

    • @napatora
      @napatora 4 года назад +3

      @Olwydd lucas did that well before he sold it. it could be argued that it was his selling the franchise to disney that ruined it.

    • @viveka2994
      @viveka2994 4 года назад +4

      @@napatora prequels are 10x better than new trilogy, plus the third one is good

  • @swilso421
    @swilso421 5 лет назад +243

    "Disney wanted their own Star Wars"
    Ironic

    • @nosuchthing8
      @nosuchthing8 5 лет назад +10

      Yes, but prescient. Disney ruined both.

    • @celtisafricana4984
      @celtisafricana4984 4 года назад +4

      Disney wants anything that they think will fill their coffers. At one point there was even a rumour that through a subsidiary, they owned a porn studio... true or not, I can't say

    • @janosskublics7438
      @janosskublics7438 4 года назад

      Now they have three, and each sucks

    • @coltonbates629
      @coltonbates629 3 года назад +1

      @@janosskublics7438 a LOT more than 3

    • @janosskublics7438
      @janosskublics7438 3 года назад

      @@coltonbates629 i meant the movies that were made under the leadership of Disney.

  • @BumTheGame
    @BumTheGame 5 лет назад +876

    Disney's cheesy attempt at Star Wars... looks like history likes to repeat itself :)

    • @joescott
      @joescott  5 лет назад +76

      Yeah, I was struck by the irony after I recorded it.

    • @leeSouthend
      @leeSouthend 5 лет назад +7

      Saw The Black Hole at the cinema. So pants and that ending yep we have no clue what would happen so lets just drop some acid and film 20mins of bright colours. ;-)

    • @amanuelamanuel
      @amanuelamanuel 5 лет назад

      Shots fired!

    • @AscendantStoic
      @AscendantStoic 5 лет назад

      Spot on 🤣

    • @mrboatface4023
      @mrboatface4023 5 лет назад +4

      new star war movies bad, upvotes to the left

  • @DarthStone
    @DarthStone 5 лет назад +253

    Dude, you just made my morning with that Liberace’s Butthole reference. I just spilled my coffee.

    • @joescott
      @joescott  5 лет назад +28

      Not that I've seen the real thing, just guessing.

    • @Jamie-Russell-CME
      @Jamie-Russell-CME 5 лет назад

      @@joescott What mysterious protypes have been thrust fro?. The world will never know!

    • @Jamie-Russell-CME
      @Jamie-Russell-CME 5 лет назад +3

      @@joescott Check out Dr.Russell Humphreys model of the origin of the universe via white hole and gravitational welling and time dillation.
      He predicted the magnetic field strength of Mercury dead on while everyone else was orders of magnitude off.

    • @rudydaberry122
      @rudydaberry122 5 лет назад

      Joe Scott there’s a black whole picture that nasa took recently and it’s made history

    • @Jenab7
      @Jenab7 5 лет назад +2

      During the 1950s, Liberace sued a writer for the Daily Mail who, in an editorial column, described Liberace in a way that suggested he might be a homosexual. And he won. The jury awarded him an amount of money that would be equivalent to about $250,000 today.
      Later, it turns out that Liberace was, indeed, a homosexual. The jury had gotten it wrong. Liberace judicially swindled somebody out of a quarter million (today's) dollars by telling a lot of lies in court.
      He also published a cookbook. One of the recipes in it is "Liberace's Sticky Buns." No kidding. You can find the recipe with a search engine.

  • @lulaaro3193
    @lulaaro3193 5 лет назад +506

    There is a serious brain bucket warning for this video.

    • @ivanmwinje5385
      @ivanmwinje5385 5 лет назад +17

      My kind of video then! Lets do this.

    • @joescott
      @joescott  5 лет назад +28

      Yeah, forgot to put the warning label at the beginning.

    • @elprimeracuariano
      @elprimeracuariano 5 лет назад +3

      I had read alongs of Cinderella and Pinocchio 😊

    • @codyv308
      @codyv308 5 лет назад +9

      @jom j speculation is *how* we make sense of things. Ask enough questions and you'll get the answer eventually. That's why we do this.

    • @MtnTow
      @MtnTow 5 лет назад +3

      @jom j No, unfortunately readlongs were a real thing. Literacy was a challenge for a while.

  • @exoplanets
    @exoplanets 5 лет назад +211

    My mind is being *continuously blown* when I watch your videos.

    • @nicholasperkins4655
      @nicholasperkins4655 5 лет назад +1

      El Shaddai means God Almighty in Hebrew
      It comes from the Akkadian word shaddu which means mountain
      The Arabic word for mountain is sana
      Sana means thread of summer in Japanese
      Sana means eternity in Sanskrit
      The Ancient Jews believed that the earth(cosmos in Greek) was flat
      Albert Einstein modeled the cosmos with an infinite flat sheet of space/time
      A black hole is an infinite pit in space/time
      An infinite mountain in space/time would be an infinite white hole.
      Dark Energy and Dark Matter can be explained by finite quantum spinning white holes(tachyons) that exist for a few planck instances.
      Some scientists believe that the big bang was a white hole
      If God is an infinite white hole than the Father would be the infinite omnilarity of the white hole, the Son would be the infinite tachyon, and the Holy Spirit would be the infinite tachyonic wave(space)
      Space does not expand: The cosmos is shrinking while space is constant. This means that the speed of light is shrinking each planck instant in a way that makes it appear constant
      If the cosmos is shrinking then the density of energy is increasing.
      This means that all energy will become a black hole because of Schwarzschild radius
      The beginning of the big bang had 0 entropy which means 100% of the universe was light
      The universe now has less than 5% light
      Conclusion the 3 dimensional cosmos is inbetween an infinite infinitely dimensional white hole and an infinite 0 dimensional black hole.
      Good does not need evil to exist
      Black Holes are not eternal because of Hawking radiation
      If you don't abide in Jesus Christ and the Trinity you will be deleted
      Only Jesus Christ is the Lord of the Sabbath
      You have the choice to be loved everlastingly or to suffer infinite entropy as your last memory that seems forever because 0 time is eternal to a tachyon
      Please choose the Perfect Agape of God.

    • @Pharozos
      @Pharozos 5 лет назад +1

      If you like this kinda stuff and are looking for more Isaac Arthurs channel is really good.

    • @jeffvader811
      @jeffvader811 5 лет назад +2

      @@nicholasperkins4655
      You keep using these words. I do not think they mean what you think it means.

    • @jeffvader811
      @jeffvader811 5 лет назад

      @Real Donald Trump
      I would say it all makes sense now, but...

    • @chopin65
      @chopin65 5 лет назад +1

      The headaches!

  • @lyall52
    @lyall52 4 года назад +11

    I find this pretty deep as at the end it feels like a strong connection to yin and yang, good and bad, darkness and light. It feels like there has to be an opposite to a black hole, an equally impressive opposite

  • @Dwarficus
    @Dwarficus 3 года назад +17

    More for the brits: Red Dwarf's episode about white holes is a classic, the story explored white holes also releasing time and the crew had to seal it using planet pool. Back when the BBC was good.

    • @canada.mackem
      @canada.mackem 2 года назад +1

      He also has a video about time running backwards. He’s definitely a dwarfer. 🤣

    • @magor137
      @magor137 Год назад

      So what is it?

    • @Dwarficus
      @Dwarficus Год назад

      @@magor137 I've never seen one before -- no one has -- but I'm guessing it's
      a white hole.

  • @-joshuapatrick-6512
    @-joshuapatrick-6512 5 лет назад +47

    "And when gravity gets so strong that each universe touches each other, that becomes black / white holes in both universes"
    Mind blown. A possible way that our own universe was generated via a white hole. I always theorized that the big bang wasnt a singular explosion, but rather, what if it was a non-stop "fountain" constantly ejecting matter and pushing everything apart.
    Maybe -WE- are in the strange reverse time universe...

    • @oleksii3923
      @oleksii3923 5 лет назад +4

      And what if "that other" universe has ended in the event we call "big bang" that was only a staring point for us?

    • @BJDiamandis
      @BJDiamandis 4 года назад +2

      If black holes and white holes are caused by both universes touching one another, its crazy to think that one of the white holes that has existed was the Big Bang.
      But imagine this: time is linear, in time (in our dimension) we reach the point where our planet (and the surrounding areas) are consumed by a black hole. Would we just fall into another Big Bang? Whose to say that was the first Big Bang? What if life as we know it is just a repetitive cycle on loop.

    • @inomad1313
      @inomad1313 4 года назад +2

      So, if our universe is expanding, does that mean that the other universe is collapsing? If so, do they have a “Big Bang theory”? If they do, are they just assuming that their universe has reached its maximum radius and is now collapsing back to its origins?
      Does all of this mean that on the other side of the center of the Milky Way is a White Hole and the beginning of another “Big Bang”? Or is it a microscopic white hole that is producing dark matter in the other/another universe?

    • @catpoke9557
      @catpoke9557 Год назад

      @@oleksii3923 Imagine the big bang for the other universe is the big crunch

  • @MonasteryK
    @MonasteryK 5 лет назад +227

    Disney said 'We need to have our own Star Wars' so they ... bought it.

    • @urdnal
      @urdnal 5 лет назад +21

      And promptly shat all over it

    • @boggless2771
      @boggless2771 5 лет назад +2

      @@urdnal i actually like star wars rebels and the star wars storys (solo and rogue 1). TLJ and ROJ absolutely suck though.

    • @RobinTheBot
      @RobinTheBot 5 лет назад

      They're making gangbusters. You hate it but you're not going to the theatre as much as the people who do.

    • @jasonbrady3606
      @jasonbrady3606 5 лет назад

      George Lucas shouldn't have made any other starwars movies until everyone who had watched the first ones had passed away.
      That's not my problem.

    • @ThrottleKitty
      @ThrottleKitty 5 лет назад +2

      Disney technically hasn't made money on Star Wars, they've spent what, 4~5 billion buying the franchise, and have spent about another 10 billion on funding the new movies, and they've been dropping in popularity pretty quick. It's easy to forget how much it COSTS to make movies, just because people go and pay to see it and you see huge sells numbers, doesn't mean they made money off their 15 billion dollar investment. If they do make money off the franchise, it'll be a while.

  • @packetcreeper
    @packetcreeper 5 лет назад +52

    Joe, your hypothesis is intriguing and makes sense. I always enjoy watching.

    • @GodofWhoopass
      @GodofWhoopass 5 лет назад +2

      What if you had something that was the opposite of a black hole that shot light out instead of pulled it in and resisted gravity in some way maybe like nuclear fusion.
      Isn't that a freaking star or am i missing something here?

    • @powerstation0872
      @powerstation0872 5 лет назад +2

      @@GodofWhoopass Yeah except a star doesn't have infinite mass and density. The light and radiation is due to the fusion of hydrogen and helium from the extreme pressure of gravity. So like conceptually you're right but physics says you're wrong. A white hole would basically be a black hole reversed in time, like Joe says in the video.

    • @inomad1313
      @inomad1313 4 года назад +1

      Zombie Raccoons A white hole would repel the planets/etc away from it. A star attracts planets/etc to it.

  • @OCDTraci
    @OCDTraci 5 лет назад +26

    80's baby here and I can vouch for Joe: read-along books were the shit

    • @edwarddore7617
      @edwarddore7617 3 месяца назад

      I remeber the record versions also.

  • @IanValentine147
    @IanValentine147 5 лет назад +66

    brilliant. can't wait for PBS SpaceTime to comment on your idea.

    • @qoo9437
      @qoo9437 5 лет назад +1

      Pretty sure this was a joke, otherwise how else would he know that channel

    • @Nick_Slavik
      @Nick_Slavik 5 лет назад +1

      Hahaha that's nuts! ibam totally checking out PBS Space Time after this haha

    • @fighteer1
      @fighteer1 5 лет назад +2

      The thing is that we’ve already solved the black hole information paradox. The quantum information is encoded in the black hole’s event horizon and escapes back out as Hawking radiation.
      That said, the GR math does say that the event horizon demarcates a separate region of space time that is causally disconnected from our universe. This looks like an alternate universe.

    • @interstellarsurfer
      @interstellarsurfer 5 лет назад +2

      @@fighteer1 Hawking radiation is a proposed solution, yes. Whether it's 'proved' is debatable. Call me when you have a black hole in a jar we can study. 😋👌

    • @PR4DE
      @PR4DE 5 лет назад +2

      @@interstellarsurfer Might actually be sooner than you think. Microscopic black holes is a thing that could exist.

  • @Lilmiket1000
    @Lilmiket1000 5 лет назад +7

    wow this video blew my mind! some of these theories you mentioned I've never heard before. And I spend days researching and learning about these things. This is some good stuff!

  • @nothisispatrick4644
    @nothisispatrick4644 5 лет назад +98

    I call them glory holes
    Huh how times change

    • @DirkLuijk
      @DirkLuijk 5 лет назад +13

      Glory holes but then in reverse. lolwut

    • @MedicatedOMO
      @MedicatedOMO 5 лет назад +6

      @@DirkLuijk Massive explosions ensue....

    • @joescott
      @joescott  5 лет назад +21

      I will just chuckle sensibly from the side over here.

    • @ianmacfarlane1241
      @ianmacfarlane1241 5 лет назад +7

      @@joescott You're on the other side of the glory hole.....is this what you're saying?

  • @paulwalker2133
    @paulwalker2133 5 лет назад +4

    Hi Joe, this is your best video yet. And actually makes a lot of sense especially the part about touching universes and black/white holes. I’d love to hear more about this...

  • @hazonku
    @hazonku 5 лет назад +1

    That is a totally batshit insane theory, Joe. Like galaxies having supermassive black holes at their centers, or large events creatings ripple of gravitational waves. I LOVE it. Best reason for dark matter I've heard yet.

  • @joey_after_midnight
    @joey_after_midnight 5 лет назад +15

    Your idea sounds kind of like Brane Theory.. where two different Membrane Universes influence one another with close proximity. I don't think a complete bridge however has ever been proposed. The idea of black holes as Time machines however that absorb the "spill over" of Mass trying to transition to energetic particles by delaying it.. spreading it out over Time.. and sloshing that information as a side effect back into the Universe by Hawking radiation like a FunHouse mirror by 'Imprinting' it on the Hawking Radiation (wind) like Solar Wind eddies is a simpler way of looking at it.

  • @sibel2209
    @sibel2209 5 лет назад +43

    Finally something exciting to listen to before bed 🙌🏼 Keep up the great work, Joe!

    • @joescott
      @joescott  5 лет назад +6

      Wouldn't you want to listen to something relaxing before bed?

    • @etenivity9703
      @etenivity9703 5 лет назад

      I personally find that Joe's scientific ramblings are great for waking up!
      (I use pink noise to fall into comfortable slumber. You should try both 😁)

    • @jimmyshrimbe9361
      @jimmyshrimbe9361 5 лет назад +1

      Check out Isaac Arthur, Fraser Cane and John Michael Godier. Arvin Ash, too

    • @KarryKarryKarry
      @KarryKarryKarry 5 лет назад +1

      If you need some good old existential dread then Joe is your guy.. Also exurb1a has some interesting riffs on the subject.

    • @joescott
      @joescott  5 лет назад +3

      Ooof. Do NOT watch exurb1a before bed.

  • @SuperCHC1
    @SuperCHC1 5 лет назад +21

    "I don't know how black holes do". -Joe Scott and everyone who has ever existed.

  • @Fempath
    @Fempath 5 лет назад +5

    Definitely not the first to theorize white holes being the other end of black holes pouring into another dimension or universe, I thought of this years ago as well and I’m sure I wasn’t alone. I really enjoyed your dive into the ideas behind them 😊

  • @TheBlueprintsOrlando
    @TheBlueprintsOrlando 3 года назад +2

    Joe, your shower thought (lumps and bruising) is most definitely a “thing”. Possibly the best thing. Keep it up bro.

  • @_abdul
    @_abdul 5 лет назад +11

    The last bit of Hawking's radiation : 6:37

  • @sitedev
    @sitedev 5 лет назад +42

    White holes, black holes ... I only ever seem to encounter R's holes.

    • @ValentineC137
      @ValentineC137 5 лет назад +3

      I hear what you did there

    • @jackielinde7568
      @jackielinde7568 5 лет назад +3

      What about pie holes, ear holes, bung holes. arse holes, moth holes, sink holes, drain holes, and holes in reality?

    • @noahway13
      @noahway13 5 лет назад

      For some reason that reminded me of something George Carlin would say.

    • @accutronitisthe2nd95
      @accutronitisthe2nd95 5 лет назад +1

      For me, it's "A" holes...

  • @diyeana
    @diyeana 5 лет назад +42

    According to the scientists on the mining ship, Red Dwarf, if you throw a planet into a white hole it will destroy it.

    • @MrGonzonator
      @MrGonzonator 5 лет назад +12

      So what is it?

    • @oxenford539
      @oxenford539 5 лет назад +7

      @@MrGonzonator I've never seen one before, no one has. But i'm guessing it's a white hole.

    • @turtle2720
      @turtle2720 5 лет назад +4

      Dwarfers... my kind of people :)

    • @zubinel9540
      @zubinel9540 5 лет назад +6

      So What is it?

    • @BladeSkate
      @BladeSkate 5 лет назад +3

      Only joking!

  • @Vikanuck
    @Vikanuck 3 года назад

    I’m only 33 and I honestly think I had ALL of the X-Men read along’s, Star Wars read along’s and some other ones thrown into the mix.
    But those things were awesome man.
    It was the best way to teach you how to add emphasis to what you now read as an adult.

  • @khristianbeeck
    @khristianbeeck 5 лет назад +9

    I would love to see a part 2 of this video, maybe talking JUST about the Cpt-Theorem

  • @thegreatnovel322
    @thegreatnovel322 5 лет назад +39

    Disney's cheesy attempt at StarWars alive and well it is.

    • @joescott
      @joescott  5 лет назад +7

      Comment like Yoda you did.

    • @thegreatnovel322
      @thegreatnovel322 5 лет назад +2

      @@joescott Lol you seen this coming.

  • @anarchyantz1564
    @anarchyantz1564 5 лет назад +18

    Red Dwarf's White hole episode was a good way to describe it. White hole spewing time lol.

    • @michaeldmingo1525
      @michaeldmingo1525 5 лет назад +2

      I was looking for this comment.

    • @dudebroski9460
      @dudebroski9460 5 лет назад

      I freaking love that show!!!!! Rimmer is such a smeg head...

    • @anarchyantz1564
      @anarchyantz1564 5 лет назад +1

      @@dudebroski9460 Its odd really how when I was younger and first saw it on BBC2 I thought Lister was the cool one and Rimmer the up tight twat, but as I got older and learned more about what Arnold went through and why he became "him" I empathise more with him and find Lister the annoyance.

    • @dudebroski9460
      @dudebroski9460 5 лет назад

      @@anarchyantz1564 i mean... He did kill everybody though.... And he was so uptight that he couldnt even deal with himself lol... Kachanskis boob lol.. That show was amazing. I think i may be the only American fan lol

    • @anarchyantz1564
      @anarchyantz1564 5 лет назад

      @@dudebroski9460 Actually its really popular in the US. Years ago when I worked in London for a software firm, had some of the US clients over and they were big fans as well. Technically it was an accident and realistically the blame should go to those in charge for getting an unqualified technician to repair a drive plate for what apparently was a critical system. He did even take full blame even to the point he tried to deny his own council on the prison world. Really though the entire lot of Dwarfers are all flawed, which is what made it great. Best episodes for me though has to be the emmy award winning Gunmen of the Apocalypse and Polymorph, especially the scene where Rimmer walks in as Kryten is is on top of Lister (complete with his groinal attachment hose) "going at it" to remove his polymorphed boxers and says "You'll bonk anything you will, I cant say I am surprised". I cannot watch the scene without streams of tears running down my face from laughing.

  • @Xero328
    @Xero328 5 лет назад +39

    So I’m assuming a white hole has the opposite of gravity in an event horizon. K. So there would always be radiation and light coming out of it. Wouldn’t this be the best place for a dyson?

    • @jensphiliphohmann1876
      @jensphiliphohmann1876 5 лет назад +10

      > _...the opposite of gravity..._
      No. If a WH is a time reversed BH, it ain't no repellor. Imagine you throwing a ball upwards which will slow down until it reaches a point of return and then falls down again, and you catch it. What were the time reversed version to it? Yes, exactly the same. Gravity is still an attractive force.

    • @GodofWhoopass
      @GodofWhoopass 5 лет назад +2

      What if you had something that was the opposite of a black hole that shot light out instead of pulled it in and resisted gravity in some way maybe like nuclear fusion.
      Isn't that a freaking star or am i missing something here?

    • @Josh729J
      @Josh729J 5 лет назад +2

      Am I crazy or does information not get destroyed but propelled out in the form of a quasar etc

    • @TheNinthGeneration1
      @TheNinthGeneration1 4 года назад +1

      It would need to be strong enough to hold itself together. A white hole would basically be a warping of space upwards which would cause space time to push against it outward instead of pull inwards

    • @hiimapop7755
      @hiimapop7755 4 года назад

      @@TheNinthGeneration1 Yeah, it needs an absurd amount of energy just to maintain it's physical form, especially if it's large enough to spew out entire stars.

  • @abigailcrossman3373
    @abigailcrossman3373 2 года назад +4

    Makes perfect sense to me- just wish I could do all the complicated maths that supports these theories.

  • @bigtallneversmall32
    @bigtallneversmall32 5 лет назад +4

    I totally remember that book and tape!! Thank you Soo much for the trip down memory lane!!

  • @thomassesselmann2093
    @thomassesselmann2093 5 лет назад +10

    Way to just casually solve the mystery of dark matter right at the end there Joe. Scientists are going to be pissed.

    • @scottmantooth8785
      @scottmantooth8785 5 лет назад +1

      Great! you've just killed the invisible swordsman and decades of future thesis papers submitted for peer review

  • @sebione3576
    @sebione3576 5 лет назад +71

    Somewhere, buried in this comment section is a statement left by a misunderstood genius that could be the key to unlocking all the mysteries of the universe.
    But you'll never see that comment because it'll be buried by all the people up-voting some meme-lord's joke.

    • @theflowerhead
      @theflowerhead 5 лет назад +2

      And at least 50% of them won't even be that funny or clever.

    • @justinpyle3415
      @justinpyle3415 5 лет назад +5

      This will be that memelord joke

    • @murilokleine
      @murilokleine 5 лет назад +11

      The great expansion is actually caused by another universe analog to ours but with reversed time. As ours expand, the other shrinks. The shrinking accelerates our expansion, our expansion decelerates their collapse, all until we flip, and so the cycle is born anew, we collapse, they expand. If time is by itself a dimension, when we hit its limits, like ripples hitting a wall, we reverse the trajectory. Once forward, now in reverse. The eternal struggle of entropy and chaos.
      Here's the comment, now give me the nobel already

    • @sebione3576
      @sebione3576 5 лет назад +12

      @@murilokleine if your statement is true, then you already have the Nobel prize in our parallel universe, but you're about to have to give it back.

    • @pldcanfly
      @pldcanfly 5 лет назад +2

      But in that Universe it makes total sense to start life as a nobelprize winner trying to become a child again. Although it's really strange to imagine backwards in time thoughts and what life (if possible) in such a universe would look like.

  • @jumpkickman1993
    @jumpkickman1993 5 лет назад +21

    Yes Joe, your shower theory is sort of a "thing". The idea that another universe is bruising our universe causing black holes.
    Your idea was genuinely unique though. Write it down

    • @mulletmann6558
      @mulletmann6558 5 лет назад +3

      he did better, he made a video of him saying it.

    • @jumpkickman1993
      @jumpkickman1993 5 лет назад

      @@mulletmann6558 true. Idk if you can claim an idea from a video you made. I could be totally wrong but I think it has to be officially written down.

    • @SLLabsKamilion
      @SLLabsKamilion 5 лет назад

      Nah. Mantrid already destroyed the light universe.
      *I DESTROYED A UNIVERSE!*
      *I DESTROYED A UNIVERSE!*
      *I DESTROYED A UNIVERSE!*
      *I DESTROYED A UNIVERSE!*
      ruclips.net/video/4TW10sZP6Io/видео.html
      The LEXX Season 2, Episode 24, "End of the Universe", April 23, 1999.

    • @mulletmann6558
      @mulletmann6558 5 лет назад

      @@jumpkickman1993 I dont either but I'm sure if he did write it down and contest someone else with this proof hed definitely win.

  • @JournalistJim
    @JournalistJim 5 лет назад +4

    Joe... You sir, Have Blown my mind.

  • @donnanobel514
    @donnanobel514 5 лет назад +9

    There was a "White hole" episode on "Red Dwarf" - SMEG!

  • @Zahaqiel
    @Zahaqiel 5 лет назад +32

    An equal-but-inverse cohabiting anti-universe connected by black hole/white hole pairings as the source of "dark matter" would make dark matter potentially predictable in its patterning (for any given point in time in this universe, the anti-verse would be at the end state of our universe minus the current age of the universe), so that seems unlikely.
    Also doesn't explain dark energy.
    Also we'd probably see black holes that don't make sense in our universe because they'd be caused by white holes in the other universe coming back the other way, and that universe would be configured closer to the end state of our universe so the masses wouldn't line up - giving us black holes from stars that haven't gone nova yet, in places where those stars haven't reached yet.
    Also we'd probably see local gravitic effects that don't make sense for our solar system.
    Also just in general, that set up would be siphoning matter in our universe into the other universe unless that universe *also* had black holes which connected to white holes in our universe which we don't have, without which the system would lead to an energy imbalance between the universes where the other universe would slowly consume ours. Also would matter from our universe entering their universe be matter or antimatter on the other side?
    Basically, the short version answer seems to be "don't stick time travel in your information paradox solution, it's a bad idea".
    Less woo-woo in just hypothesising that maybe pilot wave theory is true and has some interaction with the information of matter that passes into a black hole because time dilation means all that information is permanently encoded on the event horizon of the black hole, and PWT could possibly propagate that information out back into the universe.

    • @benjaminhedrick
      @benjaminhedrick 5 лет назад +1

      Yes. Based on everything we know and can calculate, yes to this, all day.

    • @coder159
      @coder159 5 лет назад +1

      Thank you alot for this. I hope Joe does a video on your last point!

    • @zec.4491
      @zec.4491 5 лет назад +5

      Sort of understood what youre saying so bear with me, what i understood (from the video) is that from the big bang there was a “regular” matter universe, ours, and an anti matter one, however the anti matter one is in reverse and it actually ends at the big bang by the gravity crunch thing. So right now it is in its ending years and white holes are appearing in its universe spewing out more anti matter making the gravity crunch thing happen. And thats why we have more black holes because our universe is making the white holes on their side. And then at the end of our universe the anti matter universe would be just starting meaning they would get black holes while we get white holes which then causes our universe to end through the gravity crunch thing.
      Idk if that made sense or not but id like to hear what you think of this

    • @ntactime_w3488
      @ntactime_w3488 5 лет назад +2

      I ran into an issue and that is when you mentioned potentially a white hole in a different universe creating the black hole we see in ours. A white hole would only exist *because* of the said black hole.

    • @morkovija
      @morkovija 5 лет назад

      Dude. thats like an essay you splurged here! I'll have to read it in batches like bed time story!=)

  • @FlorestanTrement
    @FlorestanTrement 5 лет назад +7

    What about the Janus cosmologic model? It's supposed to solve both dark matter and dark energy, and even enable FTL.

  • @zbcrazy
    @zbcrazy 4 года назад +48

    “White Holes” was my college nickname.

  • @paperbagfilms
    @paperbagfilms 3 года назад

    1st Law of Thermodynamics (aka, The Conservation Of Energy) states: energy can be neither created or destroyed during a process; it can only change forms. Therefore, the total energy of the universe is a constant. Energy can, however, be converted from one form to another.
    There is a finite amount of energy in the universe. All matter is just a temporary collection of energy. Matter falling into a black hole will go somewhere else in another form.
    A log has a given amount of potential energy. But burn it and the log form is destroyed, but the energy is converted into light, heat, ash, etc.
    Here, wrap your head around this - because everything is energy, this would also mean your thoughts. Thoughts would also be a form of energy. An amount of energy is required for every thought you have. Once you are done with that thought, the energy in the form of your thought is no longer required. The thought may be gone from your head, but the energy for that thought is not gone. That energy still exists, just in another form.
    By the way, BLACK HOLE (1979) awesome movie for the time…have the movie on dvd. Maximillian Schell (1930-2014), was a fabulous villain.

  • @billrandell4641
    @billrandell4641 5 лет назад +13

    How about the theory that our Universe IS IN a Black Hole??

    • @leomelvinfernandez7380
      @leomelvinfernandez7380 5 лет назад

      It would clash w this theory since , in this theory a black hole is a tunnel to another universe/dimension, not a container for one . in your theory there would be infinite universes inside each black hole/universe , but the question is where is the base universe and how do w get there . #ChrisisOnInfiniteEarts OR is it #RickandMortyMicroverse.

  • @panheadmichael2537
    @panheadmichael2537 5 лет назад +5

    I remember asking for a video of this subject a while back. Glad you finally did it 😁👍

  • @MrGonzonator
    @MrGonzonator 5 лет назад +18

    Regarding your "shower thought", if we assume that the anti universe is exactly the same starting mass and physical constants, how would it be possible to create more dark matter than there is visible matter in our universe? I believe the ratio is like 85% dark already.
    Or are you saying that even our own universe would have started out much heavier but that 85% of OUR mass has already disappeared into primordial black holes which look like dark matter in the anti universe?

    • @MedicatedOMO
      @MedicatedOMO 5 лет назад

      Give it a few years......ignorance is still in charge.

    • @turtlingmywaydown3999
      @turtlingmywaydown3999 5 лет назад +4

      I think the thought was that the 'bruise' part that the anti matter universe interacts with us and distribute some dark matter here. My thought would be that there was even more dark matter; so that universe would be bigger than ours and distribute more than we have here or that we merged?
      All theory I'm just a bartender who likes science

    • @minimoogle3335
      @minimoogle3335 5 лет назад +2

      Do whiteholes experience gravity?..

    • @MrGonzonator
      @MrGonzonator 5 лет назад

      @@minimoogle3335 time reversed gravity. They push stuff away, you cannot escape once you reach a black hole horizon and you cannot enter a white hole one.

    • @inkitatus1
      @inkitatus1 5 лет назад

      there's no dark matter, its an electromagnetic universe. ruclips.net/video/E4pWZGBpWP0/видео.html

  • @dirk_gently
    @dirk_gently 5 лет назад +4

    "Vincent's my name, shooting's my game - try me." - I always liked The Black Hole growing up.

    • @interstellarsurfer
      @interstellarsurfer 5 лет назад

      I haven't watched it - but by that line alone, I feel you're describing a cut-rate Han Solo? 🤔

    • @dirk_gently
      @dirk_gently 5 лет назад +1

      @@interstellarsurfer more like r2d2, with fewer beeps and a surprising amount of attitude.

  • @Zanzopan
    @Zanzopan 5 лет назад

    Hey Joe, I think a better way to explain the reverse universe and the black - white pairing is to point out that reverse does not mean backwards. They are black holes in both universes but because time is relative to the local universe they appear as white holes in the "reverse" universe and each universe is reverse to the other.

  • @Qsie
    @Qsie 3 года назад

    Never considered it until now, but: maybe a white hole/neutron star is what happens when a black hole evaporates enough?
    Saying this since there's a minimum mass required for black holes to form, and it's (probably?) true that as it evaporates mass through Hawking radiation, it returns from a singularity into whatever dense object it might have been had it less mass to start off with.

  • @Tsudico
    @Tsudico 5 лет назад +4

    I've long thought that the extreme warping of spacetime that occurs in a black hole would create pocket universes. Those universes, like ours, would have started from a singularity explosion (white hole). I wonder if it could explain the inflationary period due to the addition of energy from the parent universe and when the influx of matter/energy from the parent universe's black hole stopped, inflation stopped.
    But I can't think of how it can be tested, so it's only my opinion of how things might be and not necessarily how it actually is.

    • @interstellarsurfer
      @interstellarsurfer 5 лет назад

      |But I can't think of how it can be tested, so it's only my opinion of how things might be, and not necessarily how it actually is.
      This should be the required prologue to every Cosmology paper, ever. 😁👌

  • @jnkx4559
    @jnkx4559 5 лет назад +19

    That was an extremely long 3 minute introduction to white holes

    • @ianmacfarlane1241
      @ianmacfarlane1241 5 лет назад +1

      I thought that the entire video was going to be Joe reminiscing about old Disney movies, or cassettes, or books, or.......
      ......Liberace.

    • @etenivity9703
      @etenivity9703 5 лет назад +3

      I find it hilarious how good Joe is at that! I often get so engrossed in the intro topic so much I forget about the actual point of the video, until he says the "that brings us to..." 🤣

    • @ritikkarkera1330
      @ritikkarkera1330 5 лет назад

      @@etenivity9703 IKR! True random stuff

    • @rafqueraf
      @rafqueraf 5 лет назад

      because it's hard to get in and easy to get out

    • @noahway13
      @noahway13 5 лет назад

      And he does the intro after a third of the video. It always surprise me.

  • @PeterKadar
    @PeterKadar 5 лет назад +6

    …insane is the default mode… xD love it!

  • @elainejsteed2399
    @elainejsteed2399 2 года назад

    This is exactly what popped into my mind as soon as you started talking about white holes

  • @bullseyecanada
    @bullseyecanada 3 года назад +1

    Not to date MYSELF, but we had read along books that came with a 7" piece of vinyl. And if you scratched it, the story skipped.

  • @forloveofthepage2361
    @forloveofthepage2361 5 лет назад +25

    Each white hole is the birth of a universe. Tinfoil, but interesting.

    • @KristofferEngstrom
      @KristofferEngstrom 5 лет назад +2

      I really like that idea. Like if every black hole in our universe together is gathering material for another white hole/big bang.

    • @MarkGast
      @MarkGast 5 лет назад +1

      If that happened the universe would have an actual center. That doesn't describe our universe.

    • @forloveofthepage2361
      @forloveofthepage2361 5 лет назад

      @@MarkGast nothing says that it bursts in all directions, but like i said. Tinfoil.

    • @MarkGast
      @MarkGast 5 лет назад

      @@forloveofthepage2361 Funny, black holes a gravitationally attractive in all directions. Why would a "whitehole" have a preferred direction?

    • @forloveofthepage2361
      @forloveofthepage2361 5 лет назад

      @@MarkGast No idea. Not an astrophysicist, but how many things in nature exude energy uniformly in all directions? Has it been proven that a black hole consumes the same in all directions? Scientist cant agree on the state of electrons, but they know for certain that the universe has no "center". How? I dont want to be combative. I am honestly asking.

  • @whytho1707
    @whytho1707 5 лет назад +9

    You should talk about Kugelblitz some time, a theoretical black hole made entirely from light.

    • @fisharepeopletoo9653
      @fisharepeopletoo9653 5 лет назад

      I thought thats what this video would be about

    • @ThrottleKitty
      @ThrottleKitty 5 лет назад +2

      It is theorized as being made from light, It's not made OF light. It's the idea of a "heat singularity" essentially, and we know almost nothing about them. Including if they could be real, what they would look like, act like, or basically anything else about them. They are actually an entirely different thing that a black hole, acting nothing like them or white holes. In fact, it'd be more accurate to call The Sun a type of black hole than to call a Kugelblitz a type of black hole. The only way it's similar to a black hole is the concept of a "singularity" existing at its core. Though, as stated, that is not a singularity of mass, light, or energy. It is a singularity on the heat spectrum. It creates the same "endless whirlpool" of heat that a black hole does of gravity.
      Some vague guesses would suggest that anything entering it's event horizon would be burned away into pure energy and shined away. Where as a white hole physically pushes you out, and a black hole physically sucks you in. A Kugelblitz doesn't interact with you physically on a gravitational level, it excites every atom in your body to a point you "join it's singularity" automatically past it's event horizon.
      But this is nothing like the nuclear fusion / fission you'd expect to see. Your atoms would "boil" apart, and you would just dissolve into a soup of smooth uniformly heated particles. In some theorized versions, it's actually physically impossible for it to dissipate heat, meaning not only would it state "infinitely hot" forever, but it would also have a harsh line before and after the event horizon where everything is "mostly fine" and then suddenly the laws of physics close around you and erase you from existence. Because of this, they may also share a visual similarity to black holes, in being completely black. If not, they are likely the reverse, and shine brighter than any object in the universe, gram for gram.
      It's also worth noting they can possibly be unimaginably tiny, meaning their gravitational affect can be basically nothing. Though, some theories predict them as requiring so much energy as to reach the mass of a black hole in the process, essentially making it back into a "type of black hole" so to speak. But a lot of people contest that interpretation, as blurs the lines between the two a bit to much.
      Though, it is also worth noting, that one theory does suggest a Kugelblitz is actually just another name for an object we've already discovered. A quasar. It's theorized a large enough black hole being orbited quickly enough by large enough number of bright enough stars could create a natural Kugelblitz by focusing the light from all the stars into a point on the horizon crescent of the black hole. It is worth noting, that the Kugelblitz and black hole are still technically separate objects in a binary pair, with the collision of their event horizons causing... the horrible, confusing mess we see coming from any given quasar.
      This theory isn't really rock solid in its details, but it shows how potentially complex the idea of multiple kinds of singularities can get. As well as just how loose our understanding on them is.

    • @nosuchthing8
      @nosuchthing8 5 лет назад

      Wait, any region of space can be transformed into a black hole as long as the collective gravity creates an escape velocity at or higher than the speed of light. So in theory a large group of stars in a tight orbit could do it.

  • @SquirrelASMR
    @SquirrelASMR 5 лет назад +8

    What if white holes are on the other end of black holes, and you get spaghetti killed entering the black hole, but the white hole shoots out in the exact reverse order, so you get reassembled and reborn again on the other side.

    • @ianmacfarlane1241
      @ianmacfarlane1241 5 лет назад

      Exactly!!

    • @oogigroo9129
      @oogigroo9129 5 лет назад +1

      Squirrel ASMR it is more likely that you would be disassembled into pure energy spewing out the other side. As if it were the case you were reassembled, this hypothesis would not work because we would have been seeing stars and planets and other astral bodies assembling themselves all over our universe. But objects getting turned into pure energy and shot out of a white hole in another universe could explain FRB's and or possibly GRB's.

  • @jenniferkopp2923
    @jenniferkopp2923 4 года назад +1

    I never seen or heard of Disney’s black hole hearing what you said makes me grateful for that

  • @budove58
    @budove58 5 лет назад

    @joe yeah that's kind of the explanation as understood by the penrose spacetime diagram. Although it's not necessarily understood as 8 dimensions, but the same 4 dimensions reversed in respect to each universe. The 3 spatial dimensions, when you cross the event horizon, change into time, and time becomes spatial. So when you cross the event horizon you're no longer spatially moving to the center of singularity, but rather you're moving through time toward an infinity. The inverse would also be true for a white hole.

  • @disproportionateprogressio8415
    @disproportionateprogressio8415 5 лет назад +9

    Hey Joe, could you try an episode on Penrose's Conformal Cyclic Cosmology? Different but beautiful theory.

  • @whoisblargh
    @whoisblargh 5 лет назад +38

    I've never seen one before -- no one has -- but I'm guessing it's
    a white hole.

    • @talltroll7092
      @talltroll7092 5 лет назад +5

      So what is it?

    • @joescott
      @joescott  5 лет назад +5

      Feel like I should have reached out to Bobby Llewellyn.

    • @Solmbarnes
      @Solmbarnes 5 лет назад +2

      @@talltroll7092 only joking,

  • @hershy1594
    @hershy1594 5 лет назад +7

    Look up the holographic principal. It solves the information paradox from what I've heard

    • @wpgspecb
      @wpgspecb 5 лет назад

      Leonard susskind bet Stephen hawking that information wasn't destroyed in black holes, he proved hawking wrong. The black hole war is the book

    • @hershy1594
      @hershy1594 5 лет назад

      @@wpgspecb Yeah the holographic principal is really interesting. Not only is all information that goes into a black hole "imprinted" on in that void in space it is also "imprinted" on the edge of the ovservable universe in some interpretations. The lengths our universe goes to preserve information is weird

    • @ThrottleKitty
      @ThrottleKitty 5 лет назад +1

      @@wpgspecb This is actually, technically a misnomer. Hawking "admitted defeat on the issue" he was not "PROVEN wrong". There is a huge gap in those two. As important, smart, and amazing as Hawking was, he's still just a guy, subject to bias and opinions, while being limited by our understanding of the universe as a species. In actuality, we have no strong evidence as to what happens approaching or past the event horizon of a black hole in any capacity, it's entirely possible every single theory we have on them is incredibly wrong for some heretofore unseen reason.

    • @wpgspecb
      @wpgspecb 5 лет назад

      @@ThrottleKitty I think you need to reread his statement where he PAID Susskind his bet in defeat.

    • @ThrottleKitty
      @ThrottleKitty 5 лет назад +1

      @@wpgspecb I think you need to reread my comment. He admitted defeat that he had a good explanation for the paradox. In reality, neither theory has been *_PROVEN_* , either or neither could be true. *_We have no idea what actually happens at, near, or past the event horizon of a black hole!_* It's all theoretical. Hawking paying out on a bet doesn't serve as scientific evidence.

  • @dannymccune1888
    @dannymccune1888 4 года назад +1

    There was an article in an astronomy magazine in the 80's or 90's that said you could create your own universe by getting Superman to squeeze 20kg of matter down to a singularity. BANG, a new universe somewhere you can never go, see, or even know about.
    In the beginning...
    There was nothing.
    No matter, no space, no time, no energy.
    Then God said, "Pull My finger!"

  • @wingflanagan
    @wingflanagan 5 лет назад

    Actually, in the 70's, photochemical traveling mattes were usually done with blue screens, not green. Green as a screen color is relatively recent. Since we were dealing with actual film, the process involved lots of rephotographing different elements through an optical printer to get them onto one piece of film. Involved and expensive process, with limited possibilities for re-doing and an inability to see the results "live". You never knew if it looked right until the final product came back from the lab. If it had problems and there was no time or money left, you were kinda stuck with the result. So yeah, bad mattes were pretty common, even in big budget films.

  • @navBUDDa
    @navBUDDa 5 лет назад +4

    It’s pretty hard to blow my mind, but this video just did.

  • @davidmccartney189
    @davidmccartney189 5 лет назад +4

    “You’re dating yourself?” now that’s safe sex

  • @mashrien
    @mashrien 5 лет назад +7

    8am wake up call.. srsly Joe?
    Lemme grab my tinfoil and poptarts.

  • @james.sirois
    @james.sirois 5 лет назад

    Ive been working on a philosophy wherein I explore the possibility of existence and non-existence co-existing. This clip gave me some interesting info to help expand on it. Thanks Joe!

  • @gamalipi
    @gamalipi 5 лет назад

    I love your idea Joe, makes sense to a point, especially if white holes on either side are smaller than a lighwave length. I somehow got the idea that a black hole can provide enough vacuum in a distorted spacetime to allow white holes to exists. The jets of matter spilled at relativistic speeds launched from black holes could be the prove of existence of the white holes inhabiting nearby a black hole

  • @hansisbrucker813
    @hansisbrucker813 5 лет назад +10

    Lol I had the same idea about a time reversed mirror universe a while ago 😁
    I am not a physicist though 🤔

    • @Josh729J
      @Josh729J 5 лет назад

      It takes a supercomputer 40 minutes to replicate one second of brain activity. Not sure the extra handful of IQ points is required for any human to have a flash of brilliance and understanding

  • @2000johnwhite
    @2000johnwhite 5 лет назад +8

    Didn't Sagittarius A (the black hole at the centre of out galaxy) do something odd recently?

    • @nicholasperkins4655
      @nicholasperkins4655 5 лет назад +1

      El Shaddai means God Almighty in Hebrew
      It comes from the Akkadian word shaddu which means mountain
      The Arabic word for mountain is sana
      Sana means thread of summer in Japanese
      Sana means eternity in Sanskrit
      The Ancient Jews believed that the earth(cosmos in Greek) was flat
      Albert Einstein modeled the cosmos with an infinite flat sheet of space/time
      A black hole is an infinite pit in space/time
      An infinite mountain in space/time would be an infinite white hole.
      Dark Energy and Dark Matter can be explained by finite quantum spinning white holes(tachyons) that exist for a few planck instances.
      Some scientists believe that the big bang was a white hole
      If God is an infinite white hole than the Father would be the infinite omnilarity of the white hole, the Son would be the infinite tachyon, and the Holy Spirit would be the infinite tachyonic wave(space)
      Space does not expand: The cosmos is shrinking while space is constant. This means that the speed of light is shrinking each planck instant in a way that makes it appear constant
      If the cosmos is shrinking then the density of energy is increasing.
      This means that all energy will become a black hole because of Schwarzschild radius
      The beginning of the big bang had 0 entropy which means 100% of the universe was light
      The universe now has less than 5% light
      Conclusion the 3 dimensional cosmos is inbetween an infinite infinitely dimensional white hole and an infinite 0 dimensional black hole.
      Good does not need evil to exist
      Black Holes are not eternal because of Hawking radiation
      If you don't abide in Jesus Christ and the Trinity you will be deleted
      Only Jesus Christ is the Lord of the Sabbath
      You have the choice to be loved everlastingly or to suffer infinite entropy as your last memory that seems forever because 0 time is eternal to a tachyon
      Please choose the Perfect Agape of God.

    • @RobinTheBot
      @RobinTheBot 5 лет назад +9

      @@nicholasperkins4655 incredible to witness actual mental illness in action. There are people who live you, please seek help and allow yourself to be helped.
      You sound perfectly reasonable to yourself, but to us it's bordering on gibberish. I know I sound unreasonable to you but please believe me.

    • @blakedblake6143
      @blakedblake6143 5 лет назад

      @@nicholasperkins4655 What?

    • @tacey01
      @tacey01 5 лет назад

      RobinBot tats just cruel. Gaaakgakgakgak

    • @2gj906
      @2gj906 5 лет назад

      It got a bit hungry most likely from interstellar gas or slowly sucking the S0-2

  • @y.shaked5152
    @y.shaked5152 5 лет назад +9

    11:50 - The universe is under no obligation to make sense to you, Joe. :)

  • @kattybat73
    @kattybat73 5 лет назад

    Joe, this is hands down my favourite video of yours. I am in total agreeance about white holes, it makes so so soooo much sense. You blew my mind but I'm so excited about it. I want everyone to see this. White hole theory is like the key to all my wonders

  • @IAmFirstborne
    @IAmFirstborne 5 лет назад +1

    *Joe:* "So, in black hole/white hole pairs, there is no singularity, just bridges to another reality."
    *Also Joe:* Laughs insanely and head explodes.
    *Me:* Vomits 100% pure confusion
    *Also Me:* Likes video

  • @Ironcladded
    @Ironcladded 5 лет назад +4

    1:02 Man, that's long nails for you.

  • @briansilverwood8892
    @briansilverwood8892 5 лет назад +5

    Damn you Joe... Your theory will keep me up for the next couple days now.
    Great topic and love your show!

  • @naveej
    @naveej 5 лет назад +4

    I had similar thoughts but when I continue this is where I get stuck: Any matter that falls into a black hole takes an infinite time to reach the other side/end/bottom right? Would that mean that time and flow of things have a basic direction (once positive and negative)? Would that also/otherwise imply that the bending towards the other 'membrane/dimension' (11:11) is just part of two 'universes' interacting but they are only part of a megaverse. The 'Megaverse' keeps hold on to the infinite number of possible quantum state matter can take, could be also seen as an additional dimension which we have no access to (multiverse theory saving the day?).

    • @mattm9584
      @mattm9584 5 лет назад +1

      objects that are falling into a black hole do not take an infinite amount of time from their perspective. From their perspective, time moves faster and faster but from our perspective they move slower and slower. It's all about relativity.

    • @naveej
      @naveej 5 лет назад +2

      @@mattm9584 fair point, thank you :)
      but does that rule out the rest of the thoughts?

    • @mattm9584
      @mattm9584 5 лет назад +1

      @@naveej I like the megaverse idea. It make sense to me. If one universe is matter and the other universe is antimatter, why wouldn't they be two sides of the same coin?

    • @naveej
      @naveej 5 лет назад +1

      @@mattm9584 thats what i was thinking. I obviously lack the skills to calculate any of it, but I d like to hear back from someone who can - or someone who can tell me if this is testable or not

  • @dpop8378
    @dpop8378 5 лет назад

    When I was a child I've read a short story about the astronaut who traveled to the edge of the galaxy to explore the black hole, the ship entered the black hole and... nothing, only a few sentences describing a ship in space with a baby on board. It was a very old book with a sci-fi short stories, I can't remember the name of the story or the author but was quite fascinating. The story was first published somewhere in the 70s, it was one of my grandmother's books, sadly I can't access this book any longer (long story).

  • @KaoticReach1999
    @KaoticReach1999 5 лет назад +4

    It's a Yin Yang thing
    Where there is black holes...there is white
    Maybe
    Sometimes
    Ehhh

  • @Myles_C_1261
    @Myles_C_1261 5 лет назад +10

    Red Dwarf 1991 UK comedy episode "White Hole", anybody else?

    • @Hunnter2k3
      @Hunnter2k3 5 лет назад +4

      So what is it?

    • @xzonia1
      @xzonia1 5 лет назад +2

      I've never seen one before - no one has - but I'm guessing it's a white hole.
      (Never use the restroom when you've gone through a white hole!) :)

    • @chrisandrews5004
      @chrisandrews5004 5 лет назад +1

      Only joking

    • @TheTwitGamer
      @TheTwitGamer 4 года назад

      OK, so it's decided, then. We consult Holly.

  • @MrGonzonator
    @MrGonzonator 5 лет назад +9

    Awesome!
    Also, how did I find this video when it's not even out yet...?
    Maybe a white hole has thrown a chunk of future Joey goodness in my direction?

  • @lennybogart
    @lennybogart 4 года назад

    Hello Joe, gotta say I’m not sure about what you said about dark matter and ‘bruises’ in our universe. However, what I found very interesting was the black hole/white hole theory of how they’re linked in a yin-yang type fashion and I think it makes a lot of sense. I want to explore this theory more, so thanks for the great and inspirational video which gave me new motivation to explore the universe and other dimensions *(just using a pen and some magic paper, whilst sitting at home on the sofa, nowhere near any kind of horrendously dangerous mega rockets with a space shuttle hanging off the side)* from a new, particular aspect!

  • @willpowerfpv3246
    @willpowerfpv3246 Год назад

    I had the Black Hole read along record, AND Raiders of the Lost Ark, as well as the Fox and the Hound, and a few others. I played them on my Strawberry Shortcake plastic briefcase record player that my mom bought me for $5 at a garage sale. It got me into a lifelong obsession of collecting vinyl records, and later on going on on to be a turntablist DJ.

  • @sentinelwarren2239
    @sentinelwarren2239 5 лет назад +4

    When Black holes & White holes collide they probably create Grey holes.

    • @zazugee
      @zazugee 5 лет назад +1

      Hounds?

    • @scottmantooth8785
      @scottmantooth8785 5 лет назад

      also a big astrophysical mess of contentious theories and snide speculations and slander towards opposing views

  • @leonbrown3095
    @leonbrown3095 5 лет назад +22

    Please do a video on how the Simpsons keeps telling the future!!!!

  • @CeltKnight
    @CeltKnight 5 лет назад +4

    Back in MY day, read-a-longs featured full-sized LP albums ... vinyl, baby!
    aaannnddd they were just as lame (though they seemed really cool at the time) ;)

  • @nrouzbeh
    @nrouzbeh 2 года назад +1

    What if every particle is a wave and in a black hole due to extreme forces at play, this wave form stops, just stops. What we recieve as radio signals from around a black hole is precursor to this process?

    • @philosophiamourningstar9424
      @philosophiamourningstar9424 2 года назад

      If that wave form were to just STOP....then the thing I'm wondering, would that then mean, essentially, TIME stops....and if so, what would a consciousness experience in this place?
      Edit: the reason I say time would stop is because, the way we "perceive" time is cause and effect, but if all wave form stops, then there is no longer causes and effects, therefore, no longer Time🤓

    • @nrouzbeh
      @nrouzbeh 2 года назад

      @@philosophiamourningstar9424 maybe time is just our preception and doesn't exist on it's own? So because everything reduces to zero at the heart of a black hole, there can't be anything there to quantify time thus, at that point time simply doesn't exist, because there is no conscious being to perceive it.

  • @tiffanymarie9750
    @tiffanymarie9750 Год назад

    Diane Duane has a character (yes a character) who is a white hole in So You Want To Be A Wizard. This makes me so nostalgic for being 10 and reading scifi for the first time.

  • @BEM684
    @BEM684 5 лет назад +7

    If somebody wanted to make a porn parody of this video, they wouldn't even have to change the name.

  • @loungelizard836
    @loungelizard836 5 лет назад +3

    Why don't we in our Universe get any White holes? I mean other than the President of course.

    • @nicholasperkins4655
      @nicholasperkins4655 5 лет назад

      El Shaddai means God Almighty in Hebrew
      It comes from the Akkadian word shaddu which means mountain
      The Arabic word for mountain is sana
      Sana means thread of summer in Japanese
      Sana means eternity in Sanskrit
      The Ancient Jews believed that the earth(cosmos in Greek) was flat
      Albert Einstein modeled the cosmos with an infinite flat sheet of space/time
      A black hole is an infinite pit in space/time
      An infinite mountain in space/time would be an infinite white hole.
      Dark Energy and Dark Matter can be explained by finite quantum spinning white holes(tachyons) that exist for a few planck instances.
      Some scientists believe that the big bang was a white hole
      If God is an infinite white hole than the Father would be the infinite omnilarity of the white hole, the Son would be the infinite tachyon, and the Holy Spirit would be the infinite tachyonic wave(space)
      Space does not expand: The cosmos is shrinking while space is constant. This means that the speed of light is shrinking each planck instant in a way that makes it appear constant
      If the cosmos is shrinking then the density of energy is increasing.
      This means that all energy will become a black hole because of Schwarzschild radius
      The beginning of the big bang had 0 entropy which means 100% of the universe was light
      The universe now has less than 5% light
      Conclusion the 3 dimensional cosmos is inbetween an infinite infinitely dimensional white hole and an infinite 0 dimensional black hole.
      Good does not need evil to exist
      Black Holes are not eternal because of Hawking radiation
      If you don't abide in Jesus Christ and the Trinity you will be deleted
      Only Jesus Christ is the Lord of the Sabbath
      You have the choice to be loved everlastingly or to suffer infinite entropy as your last memory that seems forever because 0 time is eternal to a tachyon
      Please choose the Perfect Agape of God.

    • @Andrew-hp1yj
      @Andrew-hp1yj 5 лет назад

      Because we live in the Chicago of the universe.

  • @the_Kutonarch
    @the_Kutonarch 5 лет назад +4

    Broke: Black Holes
    Woke: White Holes
    Joke: Japanese Holes
    Poke: Them Holes

  • @johnsmith-vn9cs
    @johnsmith-vn9cs 5 лет назад

    i think the first question you have to ask yourself when thinking about dark matter, is how your theory fits with the current understanding of dark matter distribution. Most dark matter than we know of is gathered in and around existent (normal matter) galaxies BUT we also found a few galaxies without the usual dark matter halo.
    Any theroy that would have dark matter simply appear from a different dimension is obviously wrong as experimental data shows it has to have at least some relationship with existent matter as to gather up around galaxies.

  • @SamuraiPipotchi
    @SamuraiPipotchi 4 года назад

    So when me and my friend were a fair bit younger, we started designing a sort of game/series idea that was based around the idea that people didn't really know what black holes were - there were actually a portal to a universe where times flows backwards....
    And now you're telling us that maybe that's just what happens and I feel so fucking giddy about the idea that I was momentarily an astrophysicist.

  • @johnmclaughlin4778
    @johnmclaughlin4778 5 лет назад +4

    Dude you waste a lot of water in the shower. ☺