“Educate Yourself!” Israeli Soldier DEBUNKS Progressive Leftist on Israel v Gaza
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 май 2024
- The SOSCAST hosted by Adam Sosnick is a pop culture financial podcast that breaks down Lifestyle, Relationships, and Money.
Subscribe for weekly videos: bit.ly/3ge8Kyp
Follow Adam on social media:
Instagram: / sostalksmoney
Facebook: / sostalksmoney
Ask Adam any Question on app.minnect.com/expert/AdamSo...
------
Adam “Sos” Sosnick is a professional networker, financial expert, and podcast host at Valuetainment Media. Sos is a “millionaire minimalist” who values experiences, and relationships and pays it forward.
Sos has lived a true rags-to-riches story. Combined with wealth, a strong network, and a desire to help people Sos started creating innovative content on social media breaking down money in a language everyone can understand. This led to partnering up with Patrick Bet-David, CEO and founder of Valuetainment, a business contact he has known for over 10 years. Now Sos hosts SOSCAST where “Finance meets Romance’' and co-hosts PBD Podcast, a top-rated business podcast. Sos is a major advocate for pursuing success, fulfilling your purpose, and ultimately increasing your status. Invest in yourself, help the people around you, and #SaveThatMoney! 
Развлечения
Don't call hamas animals its disrespect to the animals!!!
Well said
@@sairamsekhar3055says a h!ndu z!onist
Don’t call Israelis animals, it’s disrespect to Americans who are wasting their billions on the terrorist state.
They are a product of Israeli treatment towards them over the years. So if you think they are worse than animals, Israel is on the level of Satan.
Very well said , Personally, i think it would be awesome if we all can leave the animals from harm and abuse and slaughter because we choose a plant based diet!!!❤🌱😉
Accusing Israel of genocide is like calling a rape victim a sex offender.
What sociopaths are you. Are you that delusional to ever compare vile genocidal Israel to rape victim?? Modern Israel worse than Nazi. You don’t kill 300k people for 75 years and oppress them and be victim
He’s a liar 🤥 dirty one
Absolutely right. If 1940 was today, how many of the politicians and media would support Hitler? Very many, I am afraid. Lisbeth
Nah 35000 people being killed fucked up
Palestine started the war by butchering women, children and innocent Jews. When Palestinians get killed they call it genocide. No, this is the WAR you wanted Palestinians! May God bless Israel 🇮🇱
It's genuinely insane how SO many young people today openly defend Hamas. Like, these people aren't literal terrorists. Insane!
They are getting their mind warped by college professors.
It’s demonic delusion
A TV crew asked a student who was protesting what Israel was doing and was holding up a sign and chanting, and asked him his views and why he was protesting. He said I don't know, someone just handed me this sign. He said some of my other student friends asked if I wanted to come to the protest and chain themselves to railings etc. He said yes it sounds fun. Alot of these students LIKE protesting! From black lives matter or the Israel conflict to everything else. They don't know what their talking about and they don't realise what effect it is having on things. To them it's fun it's rebellious, it's standing up to authority.
That’s why propaganda exists
Zionists are fooled by Hamas propaganda! Quote 1- Gazan 🇵🇸 to IDF 🇮🇱: 'We must take down the heads of Hamas. Don't leave this place! People are stupid and do not understand anything. What are we to do with all of this? This is all because of Sinwar and Haniyeh. Haniyeh eats at restaurants in Turkey. And Sinwar eats hidden underground. They eat meat while we eat bullets.' - Source : kfsPPvA8nLE
Quote 2- "HAMAS is killing my people. (...) Most Gazans are against Hamas."-Jordanian -Palestinian Mudar Zahran. - Source : O7Go9af9koY
Like Mosab Yousef, these 2 are Palestinians who
- hate Hamas
- are not necessarily 'pro-Israel'
- are using their real names and faces
- are shouting and so don't sound like their opinions are unpopular.
Israel is dropping leaflets for civilians not Hamas. Zionists are fooled by Hamas propaganda!
Q1
Why don't we just show this to every university? Gazans don't want ceasefire!
Israeli PR shot itself in the foot in my opinion by insisting 'most Palestinians support Hamas.'
Don't interrupt your opponent when they're making a mistake.
- If the pro-Palestine/anti-Israel say most hate Hamas, then Israel won't murder civilians since the civilians are allies of Israel.
- If the pro-Palestine say most support Hamas, then any 'civilian' that Israel directly intentionally and unmistakably targets are not civilians. Lol to pro-Palestine side.
- The only way this is messed up if the pro-Palestine say 'most hate' while Israel says 'most support'. Lol to Zionist side.
Q2
For the Pro-Palestine who believe 'most Palestinians support Hamas', they support Hamas, right? Then, that makes sense but of course that's disgusting.
Q3
For the Pro-Palestine who say 'most Palestinians hate Hamas', then what's their beef with Israel since Hamas is a common enemy of both Israel & Palestinians?
Q4
I notice Zionists keep fighting the statistic ‘most Palestinians hate Hamas’, by saying the opposite ‘actually, most Palestinians support Hamas.’
Why’d a Zionist fight the statistic ‘most Palestinians hate Hamas’, EVEN IF THE STATISTIC IS FALSE since the (false) statistic supports the Zionists anyway? (Well maybe they're not really Zionists after all.)
Q5
A- 'Most Palestinians hate Hamas' vs B- 'Most Palestinians support Hamas' - If I'm Hamas, then w/c propaganda narrative do I want? (A) I'm using Gazans as human shields vs (B) I'm fighting for the freedom of my people.
Q6
Why'd Israel warn civilians, drop leaflets, build field hospitals & provide aid & corridors if most Palestinians support Hamas?
Q7
How's it unhelpful to agree w/ someone's claim 'most Palestinians hate Hamas', EVEN if it's false?
- Here's why I think agreeing w/ this (possibly false) claim 'most Palestinians hate Hamas' is helpful:
I think Bibi Netanyahu could've done what George Bush & Tony Blair did before Iraq. Tony said 'I hope the Iraqi people hear this message, we are with you, our enemy is not you, but your barbarous rulers.' So Bibi could've said: 'Palestinians, Hamas has stolen aid from you to build tunnels and fight wars while your leaders live in complete luxury, some in Qatar/Turkey. We are with you. We are going to continue to drop leaflets and provide corridors.'
I can't speak for Iraq, but this is a completely defensive war, but if the anti-Hamas make up half of the pro-Palestine then you've cut half the protests.
- Here's why I think DISagreeing w/ this (possibly false) claim 'most Palestinians hate Hamas' is UNhelpful:
Imagine someone named Ashanti is pro-Palestine/anti-Israel but anti-Hamas. Both Ashanti & Israel hate Hamas, but if Ashanti thinks 'most Palestinians hate Hamas' while Israel thinks 'most Palestinians support Hamas' then uh-oh ... Maybe there's a problem when Ashanti sees the death toll '49,999 deaths' ... However if Israel agrees with Ashanti, then Ashanti is inclined to think 'Israel did its best. The deaths are all on Hamas, even if Hamas isn't using human shields. Additionally, Israel has no incentive to target civilians because Israel believes most Palestinians hate Hamas.'
More sources:
- kfsPPvA8nLE
- O7Go9af9koY
- psHOp0
- psoMPl
She fails to realize that Hamas is actually the one trying to commit genocide by the continued terrorist attacks on Israel.
Because she's talking out of her ass. If she talks about the "Nakba" and doesn't admit that the Arab League told the Arabs to leave, she's useless.
It’s explicitly in their charter, can we point to anything of the sort by Israel
Israel has suggested numerous time a 2 state solution and the arabs have refused it.
7 times and counting..
Thats a damn lie. A state consists of a standing army, security, etc. Whatever state that has been mentioned has been with none of those things. They would still be reliant on the security of Israel.
The only time the reality was to be of an actual real state was when Yitzak Rabin was alive and met with Arafat in D.C., the famous hand shake... and look what happened to him.
Israel doesn't want peace, they want their version of peace.
Liar!! from day 1 Zionists are looking for the big israe--l which will include part of Egypt and Jordan and Syria!! ask your religious leaders!!
@@Trip_FontaineFor the Arab Palestinians to be given a full independent state they will need to sign a non aggression pact against Israel. Why? Because every deal that has been offered the Arab Palestinians has been a demilitarized state. In other words the Palestinian state is not allowed to have a military. You cannot be an independent sovereign state if you are not allowed to have a military. The problem is Israel cannot trust a Palestinian state to be militarized because there is no guarantee that the Palestinian state would not attack the Jewish state. For this a non aggression pact has to be negotiated.
@@rudimwongozi2169 You have to take risks to create peace and give people freedom. Freedom is scary. There will be no guarantee the Israeli state won't attack a Palestinian state either. Occupation IS attack. Israel has viciously attacked the Palestinians literally every single day for the last 70+ years. No Western country would tolerate occupation like that without an extremely vi*lent response. I think Palestinians would be perfectly willing to sign a non-aggression pact. That's what every proposed deal has included basically. But asking them to be demilitarized and be defenseless against Israeli violence is ridiculous.
She says genocide is based on "intent" and she is correct. However a country that is intending to commit genocide doesn't distribute flyers, make phone calls and leave social media posts telling people to move south for their own safety. According to the UN 70% of residents did move south and eventually 200,000 more wised up and moved once operations started. If I was intending to commit genocide there would be no targeted bombing, but carpet bombing. There would be no aid, no water no food.
There is no aid, no water, no food....and yes there's plenty of intent, many politicians called for the extermination of the Palestinians, the new knaba but I suppose it's better than shooting kids in the face for throwing rocks at you 💪 the mighty idf
Exactly.
Stop fooling yourself . IDF have killed or injured over 100,000 people .
Braindead.
And then.....bombs fall on the locations people have been moved to.
Let's be brutally honest with our appraisal of the situation and avoid ducking behind the usual covet of 'self defence', ' human shields' and the 'world's' most moral army'.
Look at what you see. And see it. Millions displaced from their homes. Millions whose homes are now rubble.
The systematic destruction of all civil infrastructure. The systematic destruction of hospitals. The decimation if a functional healthcare system. Sewerage systems destroyed. Clean water sources destroyed or shut down. Over ten thousand children torn to pieces by Israeli ordinance. Many more scarred and missing limbs. Orphaned.
Look at the pictures. What do you see? Do you see a place fit for habitation? Where will the sick and injured go? How can 2.5 million people rebuild their lives?
If you cannot bring yourselves to call this genocide then what will you call it?
Be brutally honest. If not here then in your own soul. You have no empathy for the Arabs who remind Israelis that they live in stolen land. Their presence is an uncomfortable reminder that you have been committing acts of terror and dispossession for decades. The soul of Israelis is soaked in the blood and tears of the people you pushed aside to realise your dreams of a Jewish homeland
You got your prize. But at what cost?
It shrivelled your hearts and froze your intellect such that you see what you have been taught to see.
The guy who speaks so rapidly and with such certainty is unable to see the circumstances in any other way than what he and generations before have had imprinted on their collective consciousness.
You cannot be the sole holder of the truth... your truth just looks right past a dirty history. That dirty history continues in the same vein today..
The irony of these children chanting “from the river to the sea” and claiming genocide
Exactly the problem Palestine are chanting Genocide while protesting against “Genocide”
@@Emmyzouas Hamas leader said, we have them right where we want them. By Israel dragging it out and giving more opportunity to create moral outrage, they are hurting their image on world stage
They love smacking you in the head while screaming how they’re victims. It’s a really weird and pathetic mentality.
This man needs to think about going into politics himself. He's articulate, educated, sensible, and has an aura of calmness that would do well.
You should watch his other videos
Yeah they teach very well how to lie just like other politicians. You all are the slaves of the system.Believing the lies are normal these days
I feel sorry how brainwashed she is, she's so wrong on pretty much every point.
He is the one who is brainwashed
But very clever !
Yep wait until she finds out that the UN doesn’t protect citizens that afraid for their lives in countries and the UN returned those citizens to their government to be killed
@@sergeharrison5804😂😂😂
She is pathetically ridiculous.
God bless that Israeli soldier for telling the truth main stream news media won't tell
No more gods all religion is poison to this world. Have a look yourself.
The young guy knows what its like to have ordnance flying around trying to kill you, a realist unlike some.
lol that was propaganda by genocidal nation of Israel
Jews never tell the truth
Israel doesn't allow independent journalist in Gaza, why? They don't want witness of Israeli war crimes. There are multiple evidences of IDF targeting civilians on purpose, obviously not in this pro Zionist channel
Wow! This IDF guy is fantastic and well balanced… speak of humanity in a fair way..
I have never seen a debate where the pro-palestinian person wasn’t a complete idiot.
I highly recommend watching Norman Finkelstein debates.
@@brownsugar00000 He‘s one of the most confused people I’ve seen.
@@brownsugar00000no thanks, his aggression and horrible voice drives me nuts, besides why should I listen to a Kapo, who lives in the USA and doesn’t know more about Israël than any person abroad.
@@brownsugar00000 he is, as opposed to being stupid, is seriously mentally ill. look into his eyes, there's something very ill and sick in his soul
Being an idiot is a requirement for hamas supporters.
My husband and I aren’t Jewish - but we love Rudy ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️. And we both stand with Israel!
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
And Arab. And I was already pro Israel before Oct 7. But after Oct 7 - hearing Rudy gave me hope that the world wasn’t gonna implode onto itself.
Talk about an antidote to the hate and propaganda we see coming from the left.
❤❤❤
Beep boop 🤖 ☝🏼
@@RaccooniusIIIHi, bot.
@RaccooniusIII find ur missing grey matter yet?
@@RaccooniusIII Remember Mothers Day is for mom''s not men in dresses. Your day is April 1st.
This woman seriously needs to educate herself on facts she literally has no clue what she’s talking about
Who is she?
She's not interested in the truth, just replying with propaganda.
This isn't genocide. Otherwise you'd be able to see the ground glowing from space.
@@michaelchristopher2003 shes not even Arab to begin with just another case of a white person spreading lies and believing what Arabs fed her yet this white woman thinks from some lies she knows Arab history and can give lessons on a continent she just found out exists
I honestly think social media has created this contrarian economy where you always disagree with whatever the other person says. It's so gay
she has to educate herself, firstly who started it, get real lady,hamas is the genocider are you that dumb
I am sick fed up of people saying a 17 Yr old or an adult under 25 is a child, at that age they are not children. They may be young adults with the same freedoms as young adults but not children that's, ridiculous
I read recently that 18-24 year olds are now in the "late adolescent" stage.
@@ProudCanadian-vv6bk because leftists control academia and they change the data to support their stats.
i won’t lie when i first started researching this conflict i was very pro palestine and said really disgusting things about the israelis but the more i read and the ore i learn it’s more and more clear that supporting israel is the only side that makes sense
Same here❤
Thank you for your honesty. God bless you for your support..spread the word
I massively respect your ability to not be brainwahsed and go in search of the truth. Go where ever the truth and the evidence takes you
@@richlewis6822
Very well said!
I'd recommend starting with non-biased sources. This interview only has pro-Israeli voices, so it's not the best source of balanced information. The woman there didn’t even get a chance to respond, making it feel one-sided. In reality, both sides might share some blame. Try to read arguments from both perspectives and make sure you look at non-biased sources to get a clearer picture.
I will always stand with Israel because I know how this story ends 😏🫡
The story ends in consistency, Israel will always win. I stand with Israel as well
@@geniuswhay they always win. Coming from a Christian.
Israel always survives. Whether or not we win depends on our behavior.
When Christ cones back to rule the world, his home will be in Isreal. Weather they believe or not is no affecting of truth. They will win. Common history will show that to you. If you are a Christian you will know. @@lianjosua5669
U r Soulless
That woman is terrible liar she keeps repeating the lies they entire world knows is not true
She thinks she's right. She's been fed líes or half truths or biased info. But she's learnt to express them convincingly. I wonder what she thought of the Israeli soldier 's words. I was glad she was there to hear that.
I've seen that woman on the 'Whatever' podcast a couple of times, maybe more. I don't watch often. She seems to like herself alot
Standing ovation for that young man!
You know the world is sick when terrorists are thanking students for doing protests for them.
Exactly.. if a terrorist is thanking you… maybe you’re on the wrong side
Rudy is just so good at what he does. He’s very gentle, and does not attack nor belittle his debate opponents. He will say what he agrees about with his opponent. He is very quick on his feet with his thoughts, and forms very strong, logical arguments that are hard to refute.
He’s such a kind soul, but I think he’s a bit naive.
@@markbisson6166 Totally agree. I don't think the Arabs who left Palestine in 1948 so the Jews could be massacred have a right to return (let alone their descendants, who never lived there). Not only would they drag Israel into the economic gutter (Israel GDP per capita is over 10x all the states that border it) but they'd pose an unmanageable security threat. None of them contributed to what Israel is today, yet they must have received several times what they lost in a war they started in foreign aid since then. Not to mention the Jews persecuted out of the Arab/Muslim states.
@@_anon464 couldn’t have put it better myself. A democratic one state solution would be horrible for Israel.
Right of return is nonsense! Doesn't exist anywhere else on Earth. He's living in a fairytale world. Why does he make it like most Palestinians don't support Hamas?
Rudy has killed children, women and elderly.
He's giving solutions. She's just repeating rhetoric.
He was proven to be correct. The UN came out a few days ago saying that the casualties number is Gaza if about half of what Hamas said.
This soldier is an intelligent well spoken and real life hero to many !!
Many of the combatants are under 18 and so are classified as 'child.' Also there are women combatants but they are counted as civilians. There is so much deceit from Hamas and the Gazans
@jackiereed3132 I really hope you don't have kids. Since it's obvious you don't value the lives of children at all.
are you saying that IDF are fighting with children and little girls?
Then this should have been over in a week
@@WaguihSiagand so did the US in Vietnam.
People don't want to understand how much of a monster Dogma is. Rather be the violence of Islam or the oppression of Communism, it is standard for belief systems like those to abuse and utilize children to attack their enemies. Especially those with Judeo-Christian and Western values because those social structures place women and children on tbe highest of innocence and safety pillars in their society. So, it's often used as a weakness.
Islam attacks it directly by allowing marriages of little girls well before they've bled and indoctrinating children into combat environments at the age of 5 and Communism attacks it directly as Antonio Gramsci prescribes because he considered Child Innocence to be one of the 5 Pillars of Western Culture (see his Communist work, Cultural Hegemony)
Trusting terrorists to report numbers is insane. Anyone believing that is mentally ill. And for the people fro the un allowed in certain places, they are being fed numbers to report. They have no freedom to roam around with Hamas in power.
Some comment I saw that was great said that once a child picks up a gun, they no longer should be considered a child.
absolutely right
Eeexactly. Once you decide to try and take another persons life, you are fair game.
......that is the dumbest shit i ever heard in my life.....
im guessing you are children urself?
My son is 13....he has shot guns, held guns, and goes to target practice..... And ur saying just b/c of that "they no longer should be considered a child"
....smfh.... crazy low IQ
HOW AND WHY are ppl SOOOOO ignorant and low IQ in 2024, WHILE spending HOURSSSS every single day on the internet..... and yet know NOTHING about ANYTHING unless its on TMZ or about the Kardashians.
smfh... embarassing
That is the harsh reality. I'd also add that a combatant is still a combatant even if they ditch their weapon unless they formally surrender. Otherwise they are still a valid target.
god sees your thoughts. fear him. be good
It's so great to finally hear the voice of reason delivered calmly by Rudy! This woman though, no words necessary
I’m not Jewish but I support them.
You don’t have to be Jewish to support Israel,you just have to be a human being with morals.
A very well spoken soldier
To call Hamas animals is giving them way too much credit and disparaging to animals.
But what the innocents?
Do u see right there u have dehumanised an entire population I don’t know if that’s laziness on your part or racism?
The IDF is worse.
At bigotsstaymad
What do you mean? Which inocente are you referring to? You need to explained man, your question is confusing!
@@Oneydy so the op called hams human animals like what the isreals say. However the army aren’t really seeking out Hamas with Israeli superior army could go ground force they are carpet bombing everyone which incudes women and children and non Hamas. There’s a distinction. So are they taregrting Hamas with intel they have its 2024 or just carpet bombing everyone?
What a brilliant mind has the gentleman. Bless his soul.
She forgot to say "until Hamas is destroyed" but then she is a proxy spokesperson for Hamas. 35k is nothing in an entire war, especially when you consider that most of them are Hamas fighters, many of whom are child soldiers aged 16, 17, and 18.
if 35k is “nothing”, then 1,160 is really nothing… according to your logic.
1200 people in a few hours!!!!! In one day!!! And not because of bombs attended to terrorists sites, but because of a horrific massacre, rape, kidnapping and more!!! HUGE!!! HUGE DIFFERENCE@@brownsugar00000
Not really. 1400 dead in a TERROR ATTACK.
15K Palestinens on the ithe hand died in a war in a 1 to 1.4 ratio between combatants to civilians @@brownsugar00000
@@xoxlove6101 when Israel fights to maintain an occupation, it’s called a “war” and when Palestinians fight against occupation, it’s called a “terror attack”. 🧐
This guy talks absolute sense.
Rudy is such an amazing speaker. The woman however, seems to have got her information from tiktok and now thinks she's an expert. She was wrong on pretty much every single thing that she said.
Does she not understand how traumatic Oct 7 was to Israel and the Jews in the Diaspora? The IDF took 3 weeks to go into G@s@. On Oct 8 we Jews saw the world turn on Israel and haven’t relented since.
No one understands. That’s why they allow themselves to demand the state of Israel to acknowledge the way they’d like to see because they don’t care and don’t understand what we went and still are going through. Even the ones who care don’t understand. So let alone those who don’t really care about us.
This young IDF soldier should be the next Israeli Prime Minister. Very well spoken about the current situation and what his ideas are about the future in that region.
HES BIAS
Go Israel. This guy is talking absolute sense! 👍
She bought into propaganda
This is how a debate should be run. No interjections. But saying I disagree, in these areas when it’ s that persons turn to speak
The soldiers last statement, suggesting that the one state isn’t Israel, but would take in all Palestinians and Jews, would be disastrous for the Jews. The Arabs already have a state called Jordan.
That is the answer, right?
Push all Arabs to another place. Make life unbearable that they leave.
You have just described ethnic cleansing.
Maybe in 200 years if islam would be death as christianity in europe.
Thank you. When I say this, people look me as if I was crazy.
The Arabs already have numerous nations of their own. Some of these Arab nation can't stand the idea of a nation of Jews living among them, and the rest are trying to normalize relations with Israel because they know it would benefit them greatly to do so.
Agree. The palestinian Arabs have been taken in all over the Middle East, and have been kicked out by fellow Arabs because of their extremism. Jews should not be forced to keep them.
Palestinian Arabs must go to another Arab country forever.
This woman is tedious. Adam, she isn’t smart. She’s an ideologue with zero good faith.
Brainwashed... send her to Gaza.
She defines genocide as "intention", not actual action. That's embarrassing.
He knows she isn't smart. He's patronizing her, and I can't blame him for doing so.
@@user-gc6wd7dm4w Well, we can certainly prove that most Palestinians want all Jews dead. So, isn't that genocide under your definition?
@@user-gc6wd7dm4whuh? How has there been such a low death rate then? It’s not as though they’re incapable of killing way more people.
This man is well spoken. Excellent.
The drone college kids don’t know any of this
thanks for having the 'short 20 min video'. Its much appreciated.
She is a bold faced liar just like the rest .
Thank you for this
Wow! That was the best discussion of the views from both sides!
I honestly don't understand why they keep doing debates between people who've experienced life and inexperienced influencers. I don't understand how anyone can think Erin on the right, or anyone like her, has ANYTHING to contribute to conversations like this. It'd be like pairing a fast food worker with a 50 yr old doctor to discuss healthcare. I wish we would stop giving these people an audience when they're professional contrarians by trade.
Nah. We need to see more of this. So people see how dumb these leftists are.
Love this comment so well said, and I couldn’t agree more
They never bring educated Palestinians that can argue with facts. They always bring on emotional and females that can't argue
We do it all the time in the west. Feelings, emotions, and ideologies vs lived expertise. With 0vid, you had infectious disease experts vs late night talk show hosts.
I'm very much on the right and very conservative but I agree that Erin is a very smart individual. Have you watched her debates on different podcasts? She's very well informed. I'm not saying I agree with anything she says but I do admit she's very intelligent
Her face at the end was priceless. Rudy is such a gentleman.
Thanks for an amazing debate.
This was an impressive debate. Well done on both sides.
The right of return is the most ridiculous thing. No other country has that. Can we, jews, demand return to Yemen? Morocco? Algeria? Iran? Iraq? Poland? Germany? No.
Jews no. Muslims yes.
It's even more ridiculous when you consider that everyone is related if we go back thousands of years to the time of the ancient Jews. Every single person in the world is probably a descendant of a Jew that lived in ancient Israel, because your family tree is so huge if you go back that far and all it takes is one person to connect you. The only possible exceptions to this MIGHT be highly isolated tribes in the Amazon or other remote areas like that. Google "genetic isopoint." So there is no real ancestral heritage that gives Jews the right to live in Israel, because everyone has that same heritage. The only real claim is that they have a right to live there since they are in some kind of cultural continuity with the Jews of ancient Israel. But Muslims and Christians are also culturally "descended" from ancient Israelites. Why don't they also have a right of return then? The right of return might make sense if we are talking about people expelled from their homeland 2 or 3 hundred years ago. But when we are talking about 2 or 3 thousand years ago, it's utter nonsense. Thanks for reading my rant. :-)
yes, you can. you can live wherever you want , no one took you out from there
the senior advisor to the King of Morocco ( Andrea Azolai ) is a Jew there are many jews that still live in muslim countries !! Stop lying!!
@@user-up5up8ki1u no true, and you know it if you are from an Arab country. There are a handful of Jews combined in all Arab countries. Jews were kicked out from their Arab native countries with no money and not properties. Arabs chanting in the streets "edbah el yahood" = slaughter the Jews. Country to Israel there are close to 1 m Arabs living or working happily in Israel. Your lies are abvous.
The famous alway quoting officials. Have you hear the other side? Yes Israel is held in a different standard. Israel could have destroyed Gaza in 2 days. Let that sink in.
@imakimmy2
0 seconds ago
This is so sad and that you are proud of this . Genocide. Hamas is using their "own people" in genocide. And Then there are those right in this video using these children for the benefit of Hamas. Shame. THIS IS NOT ABOUT ANYTHING OTHER THAN TERRORISTS.
Israel could but do not. Hamas, if given a
0 seconds ago
This is so sad and that you are proud of this . Genocide. Hamas is using their "own people" in genocide. And Then there are those right in this video using these children for the benefit of Hamas. Shame.
Whatever is in the heavens and whatever is on the earth is exalting Allāh.[1] To Him belongs dominion, and to Him belongs [all] praise, and He is over all things competent (Quran 64:1
The original Qur'an was poetry exalting Jesus. That's why Muhammed tried to burn all the oldest copies. There are many copies of Qur'an, but all are vastly different. Historians and Jesus' face covering and shroud have proven His death and resurrection. I'm sad that people don't even read or research true history. Praises to King Jesus. He is coming back for His followers! Jesus loves Jews and Muslims ☪️ 🙏 and shows Himself to them in dreams. Jesus says that those who sincerely seek Him will find Him!
@@coachwork what is sad is you are blaming other people not reading the history yet you the one doesn’t know anything about history or your own beliefs Based off your comment. before to let accept Islam the only true religion for all mankind. Stop worshiping a Muslim prophet of God which is Jesus. Jesus said I’m going to my father and your father, my God and your God that’s mean his telling you he have a God. so pls worship the God of Jesus and the God of all prophet from Adem - Muhammad( PBU all of them.which is Allah.
He is very smart the way he turns aggression I to a peaceful conversation! Bravo!
Thankyou ❤️🔥
This woman keeps hopping around on different podcasts. She has no credibility. Why do they keep giving her a platform?? She got kicked of Whatever podcast because she was trolling the entire time.
Exactly 👍
She got destiny in her ear
Notice how she completely avoided the question and didnt give answers for key points
Rudy is amazing! Israel is more moral than Palestinian will ever be even in 30 or 40 years .
Wow rudi , amazing explanation
Rudy is always good at explaining the fair side! He is one of the best at it! He definitely knows what he is talking about!
Rudy is an Israeli propagandist
Everything this woman says is either a word salad or untrue.
What about the womens of Palestine is that untrue too
@@mohammedmalik1312what about them?
@@ilsetoet9209 fact that are dying,facts that are giving birth in war zone.facts that they are watching their children in pieces because of Israel terrorism,fact that there are getting starved
Are u a women and if u are,are u a feminist
this woman says.. anbody can become a woman.. just another delusional who thinks she's smart😂
This video was straight 🔥
Rudy is a hero! So much humanity and knowledge
The Israeli soldier speaks the truth of experience on the ground in Gaza. However, while he is criticizing the Israeli government for not stopping the brainwashing by the Hamas of its people in schools, etc, he should also have criticized the UN for its body UNRWA whose teachers are doing the brainwashing.
What brainwashing??? Israel has just killed 15k children.
Yeah I think he gives his government way too much responsibility. he also talked about 'giving free speech to palestinians'.. that's not in Israel's power & rights to give, they have their own leaders that they voted for.
Impressive young man with excellent situation analysis and offering excellent suggestions moving forward.
Excellent discussion!
Rudy Rochman is simple the best ❤
Just one question: Does Egypt grant Gazans access to food, water and electricity? I don’t think so. Only Israel does. And why is it being pointed at if it doesn’t want to give out these any longer? Why isn’t the people complaining at Egypt as well which in turn, doesn’t allow any Gazans to cross its frontier?
Are you suggesting that Gazans be allowed a port and an airport, so that they could be self sufficient?
you retard how many times do you have to be told that os not Egypt who occupies gazza is israel
There is more to it than you think. Egypt was spused to provide gaza with electricity, but the Palestinians did not pay the bills. So Israel provided the electricity and subsidized it to a degree, looking to better the condition in Gaza. But after October 7, they hed enough...
Easy, because they are not Jewish
There was also a huge instability in Egypt because of the Palestinians. So they are not so keen to support them again.
Thank you we need more people like u
She did not listen to a word anyone said
First time I encounter a conversation where they mention the fact that "women and children" does not equal "civilians" in this war.
Thanks.
Try learning how the hamas health ministry makes up numbers instead of believing them lmfao.
She doesn't realise all her arguments can be used against her.
The way that woman was looking at him was like I can’t believe he’s dunking on me this bad😂
She is not smart
She isn’t that smart, she really doesn’t know what she is talking about
She is an intelligent person brainwashed by her educators.
Totally ignorant of the facts of the case ! So why give her air time ????
I am confused. She is actually quoting Israeli officials so why the hell you guys cannot see the reason?
@@samii6178 misquoting
This woman refuses any facts that dont line up with her false version of the Truth. She is a perfect example of what we are seeing in the world today
I'm Israeli living in Israel, Thank you for sharing the truth ❤️🇮🇱❤️❤️
What is so great about this conversation is that everyone is staying calm and THEY ARE ACTUALLY HAVING A DISCUSSION AND COMMUNICATING!!!!!!! AND LISTENING TO EACH OTHER!!!!! This IDF soldier has some excellent ideas and this woman is very articulate. This is how it is done folks!!!! Sit down, put your reactive emotions aside and listen! Communicate! Decide how you can work together to get everyone's needs met. Be in the present and the future and not in the past.
The soldier is also spot on regarding the scapegoating of Imperialist guilt on Israel...he brings up so many good points. I hope he becomes a leader.
He told the truth when he called her an idiot without calling her an idiot
Its not a political issue, and Genocide is when it is actually policy at a government or national leader level to eradicate another group or race to the last person , that is actually what Hamas and Iran their backers have a wish to do to the Jews
Yeah most people don’t understand the Palestinians are cannon fodder for the surrounding islamic states, these states will not allow Israel and Palestine to become friends.
Thank you Rudy Rochman for speaking truth love your work ❤❤
Christ is King! Repent!
I don't think this girl knows what "genocide " means, she clearly hasn't read a dictionary..
Excellent video
love the Israely guest! Smart knowledge reasonable👏
Love Israel. They stand for truth and justice . Pray for peace in Jerusalem and all the land of Israël
What a joke - are you a comedian?
@@astorrian6247
No, he is probably learnt history.
@@astorrian6247 just not ignorant
Rudy Rochman is incredibly smart and so elegant. Also, right on!!!
Hi - appreciate your calm way of expressing your views. Can you please explain or do a video on the history between Israel and Palestine. Everyone seems to have their version along with strong opinions. Thank you
Obvious double standard with Israel.
Good
@@ibot2157 yeah because that makes sense lmao. Not
@@nate6795 It does, Israel is our democratic ally, Palestine is not.
Obvious double standard with Gaza
It's a triple standard. Israel is the only country on the planet that can never make a mistake.
Yes! I agree with the IDF soldier!
Good conversation
By her definition itself, Israel is still not doing any genocide.
She just repeating slogans without knowing the facts she doesn’t know nothing about Israel
It's sure easy to criticize a war 2000 km away in a classroom.
How does somebody have the audacity, to be so disrespectful to a soldier who is SERVING IN THE IDF in these places and was (and IS) actively involved in the war?! Who is THERE. What a tool.
Well, he killed children, women and elderly. Do u respect people who do that???
@@deficrypto1234 in what context?
@@deficrypto1234why does Hamas mot hide them underground with food and water? There's only one side that TORTURES babys and it is not Israel
@@deficrypto1234First of all how do you know which people he killed if any? Second-that’s a war. What are you even saying? Would you disrespect a woman who killed her rapist while being raped?
Fulfilling 'the right to return' for the Palestinians is a death sentence for the Jewish state.
Fulfilling 'the right to return' for the Palestinians is Lebanonisation of Israel.
Besides before rushing to feel guilty for white colonization, one should look on the past centuries and even today slavery and colonizers. Hint: The vast majority are not at all people.
The Israeli soldier is speaking honestly and truthfully.
she speaks like a robot, no feelings, just pure propaganda
This women. Great example of pesky little facts will not change her perfectly good lies
She didn't hear a word they said.
Completely brainwashed.
They never do
We don’t talk enough about how Christians within Gaza are systematically discriminated against - for years. This is apartheid. In Israel, Jews, Christians, and Muslims live together. The number of Christians within Gaza and the West Bank has gone down dramatically.
Exactly!!!!!
Yes, because if hamas
Yes and what I find ironic is that there are Arab Israeli Christians in the north that will waive the Palestinian flag and bash Israel but act like there communities don’t have the highest standard of living there as Arab Christian’s than any other place in the Middle East lol (not including the gulf because those are expats)
Christians don't count, didn't you know that.
I think the Palestinian Christians had to flee to the West Bank because of Hamas occupying Gaza. I could be wrong though. Christians get persecuted everywhere they go in the middle east just like Jews do.
I like how he mentioned that before Israel went into gaza, soon after october 7th, there were celebrations around the world!
Always good to see Rudy ! Wishing you the best Sir 🙏
Her answers literally made *no sense*, she's just quoting Hamas propaganda like a zombie, not realizing how bad it looks and sounds and IS really.
Thank You Abba Father for Exposing Truth🙏