Hon’ble High Court being the highest constitutional machinery of the state has summoned the Secretary ( Transport ) to answer some of the queries. And the secretary genuinely replied to all the queries of the hon’ble judges’ so respectfully and humbly! This is how the system works! ❤️
"The argument is quite impressive and knowledgeable. One thing not clarified by the officer is that 'After 31/03/2020, manufacturers cannot sell vehicles to dealers, but can dealers sell vehicles to customers?'"
U r wrong. Once SC gives Order its the Govt duty in tat to issue notification etc. in compliance of apex court's order. Public will read such notifications. Public cannot be expeced to read court's lengthy judgments. Hence, concept of ignorance of law is no excuse cannot apply
Usually Mr Agarwal takes important decisions.I personally appreciate him & his decisions.There are only two officers (i.e. Mr Amir Subhani & Mr Deepak Agarwal) in Patna (Bihar) who take wise decisions & are usually open to public opinion. 🙏
I don't understand why so many people are praising the secretary. Being of that stature, he's not even addressing to the question the judge is asking. The judges stopped asking him the question growing tried of making him understand their requirement to know!
This IAS does not seem to understand the limited point being made by the judges. He keeps ok referring to the SC case etc etc when it is the position of the judges thay suitable correction must be made in the translated order. He is blinded by God knows what.
This two Judges just wants to show their power instead of understanding the issue and they have to cajole and ask the secretary in what is the core issue and how this sort of litigation can be curtailed and avoided.
The body language, finger pointing, way of response when Court repeatedly telling about the different meaning of so called translated notification etc. worth to be noticed. In plea of supreme court rulings the original issue on the face of a document has been cleverly side tracked.
If there was some other judge he would have shown the door to this secretary who is full of egos. He can't explain in simple English that' why there is different versions of affidavit in English and Hindi. He has no answer whether dealer can purchase vehicle from manufacturer or not. I wasted 20 minutes listening bush beating of the secretary.....
Yes , exactly.... wether dealer can purchase or not Same question answer is everytime supreme court sepreme court . But he didn't answer the question like yes or no
If the dealer is first purchaser then every customer is second purchaser that is not the case as first purchaser ne as first owner is never recorded as first owner dealer can not purchase any vehicle in the capacity as dealer he only acts as intermediary so contention of dealer IA absurd if its invisible individual capacity its different
@@hiheloByby6902 please search patna high court here you will find live streams. From there you can make clippings. I also though the same but now I don't know whatever may be the reason but the proceedings go live on court days.
@@dr.swapneel6519 that is Only In civil cases..that too Only when Court allows.. Otherwise one can't live stream. In High courts we deal with Appellate Advocacy .. there is nothing much sensitive issues
![Twenty One Pilots - The Line (from Arcane Season 2) [Official Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XCz7WUotXs8/mqdefault.jpg)
Hon’ble High Court being the highest constitutional machinery of the state has summoned the Secretary ( Transport ) to answer some of the queries. And the secretary genuinely replied to all the queries of the hon’ble judges’ so respectfully and humbly!
This is how the system works! ❤️
Very good.
Highest constitutional post in a state is governor
The secretary is very well read. He knows his case. That's how an officer should be
Sri Sanjay Kumar Agarwal was DM of Nalanda. He is my Inspiration. Good to see him again.
He was also dm of patna ..
"The argument is quite impressive and knowledgeable. One thing not clarified by the officer is that 'After 31/03/2020, manufacturers cannot sell vehicles to dealers, but can dealers sell vehicles to customers?'"
Power of IAS. Wisdom of judiciary. Jai hind 🇮🇳
Mr secretary is sorted, calm, genius and got upper hand on every point. 🔥
Very soft spoken and calm high court judges😇Respect
Not every time
When the judges said do you expect people to know supreme court judgement,
The IAS could have replied under concept of Ignorantia juris non excusat.
You are right
Mtlb kya h iska aur kha se liya gya h yeh term
@@planetofrocks6868 ignorance of law is no excuse
U r wrong. Once SC gives Order its the Govt duty in tat to issue notification etc. in compliance of apex court's order. Public will read such notifications. Public cannot be expeced to read court's lengthy judgments. Hence, concept of ignorance of law is no excuse cannot apply
SC judgements are precedents not law
Usually Mr Agarwal takes important decisions.I personally appreciate him & his decisions.There are only two officers (i.e. Mr Amir Subhani & Mr Deepak Agarwal) in Patna (Bihar) who take wise decisions & are usually open to public opinion. 🙏
😂
I don't understand why so many people are praising the secretary. Being of that stature, he's not even addressing to the question the judge is asking. The judges stopped asking him the question growing tried of making him understand their requirement to know!
for state very safe goal played by mr Agrawal.
It's very clearing seen transaction done night 11.30, which business or shope having that business hour.
From 18:34 to 23:52 From where the dealer can purchase the vehicles? God dammm… “FROM WHERE”?
This IAS does not seem to understand the limited point being made by the judges. He keeps ok referring to the SC case etc etc when it is the position of the judges thay suitable correction must be made in the translated order. He is blinded by God knows what.
This two Judges just wants to show their power instead of understanding the issue and they have to cajole and ask the secretary in what is the core issue and how this sort of litigation can be curtailed and avoided.
The body language, finger pointing, way of response when Court repeatedly telling about the different meaning of so called translated notification etc. worth to be noticed. In plea of supreme court rulings the original issue on the face of a document has been cleverly side tracked.
Yes dealer is no purchaser and his name will not appear in R C book as first owner
Here I think Judges are Confused
I thought I he took some bribe from automobile company
Not a fair decision.
If there was some other judge he would have shown the door to this secretary who is full of egos. He can't explain in simple English that' why there is different versions of affidavit in English and Hindi. He has no answer whether dealer can purchase vehicle from manufacturer or not. I wasted 20 minutes listening bush beating of the secretary.....
Yes , exactly.... wether dealer can purchase or not Same question answer is everytime supreme court sepreme court . But he didn't answer the question like yes or no
If the dealer is first purchaser then every customer is second purchaser that is not the case as first purchaser ne as first owner is never recorded as first owner dealer can not purchase any vehicle in the capacity as dealer he only acts as intermediary so contention of dealer IA absurd if its invisible individual capacity its different
Individual
Secretary is not giving straight answers!
लाखो का नुकसान लोगो का गरीब लोग
Are there such video recordings of lower courts? It would be very interesting to observe examination of witnesses etc.
Patna high court is live on youTube
No cameras Allowed in Courts of Trial or original Criminal Jurisdiction Courts ...
@@hiheloByby6902 please search patna high court here you will find live streams. From there you can make clippings. I also though the same but now I don't know whatever may be the reason but the proceedings go live on court days.
@@dr.swapneel6519 that is Only In civil cases..that too Only when Court allows.. Otherwise one can't live stream.
In High courts we deal with Appellate Advocacy .. there is nothing much sensitive issues
कोट को कया दिकत हे हमारी गडी को पजिकरण से जज साहाब हमारा नुकसान हो राहा हे
West Bengal mein nahi ho raha hai kya Karen
Registration kab shuru hoga
Gazab bejati karai hai ias ne 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Dr sar bs4 bick registration West Bengal Hoga Kya
Not good decision as per my opinion.
BJP gunda sarkaar gunda raj
Mr secretary should have used Hindi
BS 4 Vehicle Registration kob hoga??
Ha bhai
Aap ko bs4 ka registration karwana hai ??
@@ratanjain3488 ha bro
Pless respond
Hindi ku court mai use nahi karte? Rashtra bhasha kya eng hai???
Language of high court and supreme court is english.