I'm 45 years old. I listen to Pink Floyd since I can remember, from early childhood. And I'm always left amazed by them, their lyrics have so much meaning and their instruments, their voices is amazing. I can't get enough of it. My kids also seem to appreciate a bit of Pink Floyd.
I'm 16 and my dad thinks its weird that i listen to this type of music, anytime he hears me listening to this he scoffs😂😂😂 Love pink Floyd as well, this type of music just has a very unique vibe to it
I listen to Pink floyd since i was 6.. now I'm 33.. I'm from Brasil and only started to learned English when i turned 31.. i never heard a band that speak so much to me as pink floyd does. I love it!
They have been my absolute favorite since I was 10 years old. Complete genius. And if someone doesn't understand their music, don't worry it just means that you had a really good pampered life. And mentally you're very stable, lol. When the Wall came out, my boyfriend's father works in music and got his tickets to see the wall before anybody else just I believe 100 people went. Most of the people came out so confused and didn't understand it. I absolutely loved it and understood it all. It actually helped me to make more sense in my life once I saw the visuals that went with the lyrics.
I’m the same way about music and for some reason I didn’t have any opportunity to listen to Pink Floyd until a couple of years ago. I’m 38. I finally did on my own one night. Also I’m Deaf but wear hearing aids. So I only am able to learn a new song by isolating myself with the music I want to learn and repeat it the lyrics so I can study it and sing along if I can. Songs like these have a lot of deep meanings and I have to remember to stop and listen to them especially when I’m going through a tough time. I know a lot of runon sentences but if you get you get it. If you don’t, well I hope you do someday.
Wow. Kudos. I thought I would be 'annoyed' once I saw the 'commentary' appearing during the lyrics. And then I read along and realized it was the same commentary I would have added in 'overlooked comments'. Enjoyed. Shared. and Thank You! Given the small number of 'likes', you might be 'discouraged' by that. Don't be. You can kindle a BLAZE with a single spark 'well placed'. Even when it seems the fire has died out... I'll take this ember and give it a home. And share it as it kindles into more flames.
Kudos? A spark kindles a blaze you're right but it's usually morons with the flint I mean the lyrics are already the lyrics any extras are a bastardization tipping the scales but that happens a lot now in this country Everyone has this ",I'm a smart good person" platform called the interweb and now I got my wife's kid sitting in my easy chair telling me how to think and speak. The damned song's meaning is simple. War Is Hell sometimes it is necessary unless you want to speak German or Chinese or russian
@@gods.urethra1856 Because I'm "Asperger's Syndrome" and my brain works differently. And words I put in partial quotes or Full Quotes are subject to multiple interpretations and I consider meaningless unless defined in further conversation. Like, "Why are you "God's urethra"?"
@@darklurker1239 I'm "Asperger's Syndrome" and my brain works differently. But then trolls like you always crawl out from under bridges from time to time and I've come to expect that. But then you are "Dark Lurker". Lurker: "a person who lurks, in particular a user of an internet message board or chat room who does not participate." But DARK.
Bred on PF when it was new back in '73, after my Nam & Germany tour, never really understood how PF entered my head then, but know after almost 50 years and seeing your take through comments brings it all alive again along with tears of time having flew by. Better get an update and play 'Time' and 'Money' again. For I have found it funny that for the last 50 years PF has been in my head in a very subtle way, they being the source of many of my perceptions of daily life through their lyrics with the band music rolling along through it all as the blender of choice! Keep up the great commenting, you appear to me to be spot on, no annoyance for them as there are so many other vid's on YT as original...cheers mate!
@@peteaxe2067 The Beatles are credited for many innovations that weren’t really theirs. They’re good but no different from the monkeys or the animals. They don’t stick out as much, however Pink Floyd is something you’d hear in todays time if there were still artist that did it for the art and not the money. It’s good to care about both but now it’s just money.
A masterpiece, a landmark in Rock. Several of art’s eternal themes here, so wonderfully expressed through the music’s power and the economic use of simple words. Orwell would, surely, have approved. In fact, there are nods towards the great man such as “down and out”, “tea and a slice”; and, from 1941, “As I write, highly civilised human beings are flying overhead trying to kill me. They do not feel any enmity against me.”
It's about the voices inside his head, the Generals ordering him about, telling him to do things he din't agree with. Well that's my interpretation of the song based on the concept of the album
The following dialogue by the band's roadie, Roger "The Hat" Manifold, one of his two spoken segments on the album, is heard before the Dick perry's second saxophone solo (5:04): ''Well I mean, they're not gonna kill ya, so like, if you give 'em a quick sh ... short, sharp shock, they don't do it again. Dig it? I mean 'e got off light, 'cause I coulda given 'im a thrashin' but I only hit 'im once. It's only the difference between right and wrong innit? I mean good manners don't cost nothin' do they, eh''? The respective Alliteration was sh ... short, sharp shock. The phrase "short, sharp shock" means "a punishment that is ... severe but only lasts for a short time".It is an example of alliteration. Although the phrase originated earlier, it was popularised in Gilbert and Sullivan's 1885 comic opera The ''Mikado''', where it appears in the song near the end of Act I, "I Am So Proud".It has since been used in popular songs, song titles, and literature, as well as in general speech. Thanx Floydiens .
There Couldn't be a Better Song to End it for Today please Read Along with the Lyrics... very Powerful and very Meaningful.. Thank You From Scorpion 🦂 Lighthouse Artworks and 🎶 🎵 Music ❤ Love and Light, Pass it On
I wish you would have left your own personal interpretation of the lyrics out, very annoying, we all can take them our own way...either than that thanks
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #46 ПОСЛЕДНИЙ УРОВЕНЬ [Клинки Мрк'грш'траклар-а] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9vwX3vlPQhc/mqdefault.jpg)
Nobody had a Style of Music 🎶 Like These Great Musicians ❤
I'm 45 years old. I listen to Pink Floyd since I can remember, from early childhood. And I'm always left amazed by them, their lyrics have so much meaning and their instruments, their voices is amazing. I can't get enough of it. My kids also seem to appreciate a bit of Pink Floyd.
I'm 16 and my dad thinks its weird that i listen to this type of music, anytime he hears me listening to this he scoffs😂😂😂
Love pink Floyd as well, this type of music just has a very unique vibe to it
Q
I listen to Pink floyd since i was 6.. now I'm 33.. I'm from Brasil and only started to learned English when i turned 31.. i never heard a band that speak so much to me as pink floyd does. I love it!
I’ve been listening to Pink Floyd for over 50 years and here I am in 2024 still playing Pink Floyd
me too
They have been my absolute favorite since I was 10 years old. Complete genius. And if someone doesn't understand their music, don't worry it just means that you had a really good pampered life. And mentally you're very stable, lol. When the Wall came out, my boyfriend's father works in music and got his tickets to see the wall before anybody else just I believe 100 people went. Most of the people came out so confused and didn't understand it. I absolutely loved it and understood it all. It actually helped me to make more sense in my life once I saw the visuals that went with the lyrics.
I’m the same way about music and for some reason I didn’t have any opportunity to listen to Pink Floyd until a couple of years ago. I’m 38. I finally did on my own one night. Also I’m Deaf but wear hearing aids. So I only am able to learn a new song by isolating myself with the music I want to learn and repeat it the lyrics so I can study it and sing along if I can. Songs like these have a lot of deep meanings and I have to remember to stop and listen to them especially when I’m going through a tough time. I know a lot of runon sentences but if you get you get it. If you don’t, well I hope you do someday.
I know a lot of runon sentences but If you get it you get it ❤
This music will be around forever
Brilliant commentary
I born to Pink when I was 16, since then I've been hearing them till the end of my days
Wow. Kudos. I thought I would be 'annoyed' once I saw the 'commentary' appearing during the lyrics. And then I read along and realized it was the same commentary I would have added in 'overlooked comments'. Enjoyed. Shared. and Thank You! Given the small number of 'likes', you might be 'discouraged' by that. Don't be. You can kindle a BLAZE with a single spark 'well placed'. Even when it seems the fire has died out... I'll take this ember and give it a home. And share it as it kindles into more flames.
“Why” do “you” put “quotes” around “every” other “word”
@@gods.urethra1856 He was probably high when he commented this.
Kudos?
A spark kindles a blaze you're right but it's usually morons with the flint
I mean the lyrics are already the lyrics any extras are a bastardization tipping the scales but that happens a lot now in this country
Everyone has this ",I'm a smart good person" platform called the interweb and now I got my wife's kid sitting in my easy chair telling me how to think and speak.
The damned song's meaning is simple.
War Is Hell
sometimes it is necessary unless you want to speak German or Chinese or russian
@@gods.urethra1856 Because I'm "Asperger's Syndrome" and my brain works differently. And words I put in partial quotes or Full Quotes are subject to multiple interpretations and I consider meaningless unless defined in further conversation. Like, "Why are you "God's urethra"?"
@@darklurker1239 I'm "Asperger's Syndrome" and my brain works differently. But then trolls like you always crawl out from under bridges from time to time and I've come to expect that. But then you are "Dark Lurker". Lurker: "a person who lurks, in particular a user of an internet message board or chat room who does not participate." But DARK.
Beautiful interpretation, thank you!
Bred on PF when it was new back in '73, after my Nam & Germany tour, never really understood how PF entered my head then, but know after almost 50 years and seeing your take through comments brings it all alive again along with tears of time having flew by. Better get an update and play 'Time' and 'Money' again. For I have found it funny that for the last 50 years PF has been in my head in a very subtle way, they being the source of many of my perceptions of daily life through their lyrics with the band music rolling along through it all as the blender of choice! Keep up the great commenting, you appear to me to be spot on, no annoyance for them as there are so many other vid's on YT as original...cheers mate!
ONE of the best songs
An iconic song from Pink Floyd great sax sound is and them great❤
I am so high rightt now. I don't remember why I started typing
@PamelaThomas470 have an amazing night and an even better next year!
Same
Thank you for a brilliant of the lyrics, all ways loved pink Floyd
@@DelusionalReality1914😊😊
@@DelusionalReality1914😊😊
I dare say it, pink Floyd's music is way more mature and advanced than.......
Beatles
mopl
How and why
@@peteaxe2067 The Beatles are credited for many innovations that weren’t really theirs. They’re good but no different from the monkeys or the animals. They don’t stick out as much, however Pink Floyd is something you’d hear in todays time if there were still artist that did it for the art and not the money. It’s good to care about both but now it’s just money.
Understatement award 🥇 👏🏻 Do people actually compare the two very often? Your choice of words ‘mature’ and ‘advanced’ are perfect.
IMHO the Beatles are fucking overrated... Rolling Stones, The Doors, and Pink Floyd are better
A masterpiece, a landmark in Rock.
Several of art’s eternal themes here, so wonderfully expressed through the music’s power and the economic use of simple words. Orwell would, surely, have approved. In fact, there are nods towards the great man such as “down and out”, “tea and a slice”; and, from 1941, “As I write, highly civilised human beings are flying overhead trying to kill me. They do not feel any enmity against me.”
Thanks for the explanations
Excellent music!!!!
It's about the voices inside his head, the Generals ordering him about, telling him to do things he din't agree with. Well that's my interpretation of the song based on the concept of the album
I love this. I was wrong, I love the editorial you put on the songs. Thank you/
eu Amo Pink Floyd nascir en 1973❤
This another song exploring Sid's mental state. Us and them, ups and downs, highs and lows,, everything in life like a battle.
Thank you. So much.❤
Awesome idea with the commentary! I wish more people would do this.
The following dialogue by the band's roadie, Roger "The Hat" Manifold, one of his two spoken segments on the album, is heard before the Dick perry's second saxophone solo (5:04):
''Well I mean, they're not gonna kill ya, so like, if you give 'em a quick sh ... short, sharp shock, they don't do it again. Dig it? I mean 'e got off light, 'cause I coulda given 'im a thrashin' but I only hit 'im once. It's only the difference between right and wrong innit? I mean good manners don't cost nothin' do they, eh''? The respective Alliteration was sh ... short, sharp shock. The phrase "short, sharp shock" means "a punishment that is ... severe but only lasts for a short time".It is an example of alliteration. Although the phrase originated earlier, it was popularised in Gilbert and Sullivan's 1885 comic opera The ''Mikado''', where it appears in the song near the end of Act I, "I Am So Proud".It has since been used in popular songs, song titles, and literature, as well as in general speech. Thanx Floydiens .
Excelent! Thanks
I am listening to the whole album and an advertisement split this masterpiece
Roger kills it. What a great Lp! Dick perry on sax.
His name is actually Arthur, they only called him Dick because he has a huge penis. Apparently.
Who the fuck is disliking these videos??
Us = Bluebloods and Them = Red Bloods. yet, you remain none the wiser.
There Couldn't be a Better Song to End it for Today please Read Along with the Lyrics... very Powerful and very Meaningful.. Thank You From Scorpion 🦂 Lighthouse Artworks and 🎶 🎵 Music ❤ Love and Light, Pass it On
Let there be light.
Blueband jugs lol
Hold tha light.
I dig it. 🙏
Many of us stand a chance at embracing one another after our vehicle has expired.
Black and blue
And who knows which is which and who is who
I think I'm gonna End it Here for Today Totality Should of been on a Tuesday ENJOY and Stay Safe Out There..Love and Light All❤
Pink Floyd pra sempre
Well, I'm blasting off for Io, Jupiter's moon. Anybody with me 🤔🤪🚀
Had the potential to be a good video, until it truncated before the song was over (with an ad, no less).
Love song hate crapolla underneath. NO NEED to be educated thanks on morality of warfare
Greatest album of all time. Don't accept this BS interpretation in nay way.
I wish you would have left your own personal interpretation of the lyrics out, very annoying, we all can take them our own way...either than that thanks
@@merlinthegray Well answered ;=)
Broi, the interpretation helps expound on what Pink Floyd are trying to imply about the song.