sookie what you expect to them..for sure its scripted story for the crew staff to make more rating high but i am sure its purposed to her make more screentime whatever bad or good talent...
I've seen all of the rank cuts. none of them are truly as bad as they're edited to be, but the judges are at least being strict to all of them (besides sakura bc I mean she's cute but girl doesn't deserve an A yet )
chocolate milk I agree, even one of the dance teachers told ver she has the potential but lacks the confidence, she went up to C class according to rumors tho, she improvedeuwu
king taeyeon lol tbh she isn’t more talented than suzy. Suzy is an actress (but a real actress not like all the idols who act in a kdrama just because are idols) a model (she is one of the best visuals) and an idol (look her mr removed), so we are still waiting . Have a pretty face is not enough!
@@User63909 yeah but Minju debuted as an actress before joining Pd48. So she's not the attress that act in kdrama because she's an idol. She even got special rookie awards for her acting :) Hopefully she will get to act more in the future! Also Minju is a model too look at her Dispatch x Fila photoshoot hehe
I really hope Minjoo becomes more confident in herself. She HAS potential and it's a shame that people don't see it because of her lack of confidence (and her shy/quiet personality as well). I've been supporting her since the beginning and I don't plan on giving up on her. ♥ Fighting Kim Minjoo ♥
I dont get why people said minjoo is mnet's daughter. She got a screentimes during early eps. But most of them in a bad ways. And this audition video,her dance is not really bad. Mnet just show which she's make mistake while her full performance is okay. No wonder minjoo start to lose confidence. But good thinks,she make it. Izone's Minjoo fighting!!
the Minju in Produce48 and the Minju in IZ*ONE are two COMPLETELY different people. She is sooooo much more confident with her dancing and singing now.
You know what she still had the balls to perform on that stage and she gave her all so it doesn’t matter if it was good or bad. At the end she still debuted in Izone so never give up on your dreams. ✨
Wow I have no words for MNET's evil editing. They totally made her look talentless on the show. This was fairly good. Kim Min Joo, let's debut!!! You can do it!!!
well... to be honest, I do think that this girl did better than Sakura and Jurina in terms of dancing, she got isolation and her choreography is way more complicated. Mnet made that tiny mistake such a big deal, well..how the hell did she get D
I believe in you girl, you got this. this isn't a bad performance but yeah she lacks confidence I hope she can gain a lot of experience from this show! ❤️
I like Minju since I saw her do videos with Kriesha chu!! She's a great dancer and singer but she gets self conscious in front of the judges, as she gets older she will be able to gain her confidence
Sarahdia Cathusca sorry. It's just my opinion. If you don't agree it's okay. Everyone has their own opinion. I'm sure minjoo is actually a good dancer. She's just didn't felt confident because she's never performing alone. She's always with kriesha chu everytime I saw her videos. Thank you for share your opinion ^^
Watching this now after Buenos Aires MV got released, I must definitely say, Minju already has that potential from the very beginning but her skills shoot up really high after getting in to IZONE. I swear she's one of the most versatile members of the group and she undeniable improved a WHOLE LOT! Minju, I'm so proud of you!!!
![PRODUCE48 [단독/풀버전] 스톤뮤직_배은영, 장규리, 이시안, 조유리 ♬Chewing Gum @기획사별 퍼포먼스 180622 EP.2](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0CRZsCWDReE/mqdefault.jpg)
![PRODUCE48 [단독/풀버전] 스톤뮤직_배은영, 장규리, 이시안, 조유리 ♬Chewing Gum @기획사별 퍼포먼스 180622 EP.2](/img/tr.png)
![[ENG]니가 게스트야 MC야❓️최범규🧸요🩵 게스트잖아‼️ 범상치 않은 범쪽 🐶큰 등장 EP.7](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XMGdgwPoLvw/mqdefault.jpg)
본방송에선 악편집을 했나보네 ㅋㅋ;; 풀버전 보니 춤 잘췄구만 본방송에선 편집해서 제일 못춘 부분만 내보냈네 엠넷 개늠들 ㅋㅋㅋ;;
ㅇㅈ요 방송에서 너무 못하고 자신감 없어보이게만 편집함;;;;;;;; 저 정도면 목소리도 매력있고 춤선도 예쁜데 ;;
스토리가 필요했죠
@@정은정-t4z ㅇㅈ 생기부쓰는것처럼
얘네는 제2의 김소혜가 필요했던거지ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
뭐가 잘춘다는거야
이 띵곡을 알다니 민주 이녀석 .,.,
이거 노래 뭔가요? ㅠㅠ
no matter what 요
통했어~~
한윤 루나의 free somebody나 태연의 fashion 들어보세요
한윤 케이시 dream도 좋아용
보컬이 살짝 약하긴해도 춤 약간 엉성한 부분만 짜집기 했네ㅋㅋㅋ 그래서 민주 평가부분이 짧았구나ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
D는 기초가 없는애들 보내는거 아닌가 C는 충분히 받을 실력이라고 생각했는데; 혼자 춤추고 저정도 노래하는거면 괜찮은데
@@my0sotis2738 사쿠라는????
토미 은채는 C반에서 잘하는 편이였지 않나용 ...
A 매우 잘함
B 잘함
C보통
D못함
F 매우 못함
국룰 아님?
@@삭제했음계정 이건 맞지
한연생 기준으론 노래 별로고 춤도 그닥.. 일연생 고려하면 최소 C
진짜 MR 그지같이 해줬네 소리 조금만 줄여주지
시발 프사랑 닉땜에 민주가 이소리하는거 직관하는기분이다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@윤주원-n5p ㅇㅈㅇㅈㅋ ㅋ ㅋ
닉넴보고 깜놀함
@@윤주원-n5p 민주가 말하는 느낌ㅋㅌ
ㅋㄹㅋㄹㅋㄹㅋㄹㅋㄹㄹㅇ 민주언니가 말하는듯
I mean this is not as bad as they edited on the show
sookie what you expect to them..for sure its scripted story for the crew staff to make more rating high but i am sure its purposed to her make more screentime whatever bad or good talent...
I've seen all of the rank cuts. none of them are truly as bad as they're edited to be, but the judges are at least being strict to all of them (besides sakura bc I mean she's cute but girl doesn't deserve an A yet )
The only put that part where she almost stumble
Totally agree! And I think this performance didn’t deserve a D but at least a C cause the vocals are weak but the dance was quite good!
Ain’t gonna introduce Myself nah it’s a D, vocals were super weak n dance wasn’t that great either
아무리 노래소리가 작다고해도 음색좋고 못부르는것도아니고 춤도잘추는데 D를주는건 뭔지
뭐든게 주작이죠 뭐
등급재평가는 실력이 엄청좋아저서B라고생각하고 원래도 C정도 돼는거 갔은데 저만그런가요?
소속사에 돈이 없어서 그런거 아닐까요
ㅇㅈ 내생각엔ㄴ 등급주는것도 짜져있을것같다
@@김민주-w5i 그렇게 생각할수도 있겠지만 사쿠라A받은거랑 같이보면 생각이 달라지실수도....
D정도는 아니고 B~C정도 인 것 같은 데 왜 D냐;민주보다 못하는 애들 천지인데 그런 얘들한테는 등급 좋게주고......기준이 도대체 뭐임?자신감이 좀 없긴한데 춤 보면 d까진 아님
트레이너쌤들이 민주의 자신감이 조금 떨어진다는걸 바로 캐치하고 D로 준거죠 그리고 무조건 못하는 연습생은 좋게준건 아니죠 사쿠라는 실력이 좋은편은 아니더라도 일본 클래스 기준과 한국 클래스 기준이 다르기때문에 그 기준을 생각해서 A준거에요
한국클래스 일본클래스 나누는것도 개얼탱이네
@@김반바지 당연히 다르지 같냐 운영방식이 전혀 다른데
자신감만 있었으면 C
ㅂㅈㅂ
I think she have potential. She just needs confidence and need to be less self conscious
chocolate milk I agree, even one of the dance teachers told ver she has the potential but lacks the confidence, she went up to C class according to rumors tho, she improvedeuwu
Claudio Weezy let's hope she keeps on improving and gain more confidence
Agree +1
chocolate milk she reminds me of the old bae jinyoung....
Yes she need more sass in her dance and project her voice more. She has a lot of potential, which I can see in her dance skill.
이때 자신감이 없어서 그렇다고 쳐도 얼굴만 예쁘고 실력은 없는애로 묶어버릴정도는 아니었음..음색도 앵앵거리지 않는 차분한 음색이라 좋았는데 완전 실력없는애로 편집해놨더라...?
mr 소리 쫌만 줄여줬어도 못해도 C 프듀48이라는 점을 감안해서 충분히 B도 받을수있었을텐데...
성량이 작아서 그렇지 기본적으로 음색도 좋고 노래도 끝까지 부르는데다가 춤도 엥간한데...
B는 아님
She is like the prettiest korean contestant for me
same
Hyewon is better
Yep. She is actually because Yiren is Chinese
@@Sophie-wb5lq with awkward face
@@Sophie-wb5lq big eyes
민주 춤선 진짜 너무 예뻐.. 지금은 춤실력도 엄청 늘어서 개오짐ㅜㅜ
얘가 D고 사쿠라가 A라고??
진심으로 이해가 안 되네요...
사쿠라는 스타성이 있고 무대를 많이서서 생긴 자신감 덕분에 아닐까요?
@@지현-t3f8k그렇게 따지면 다른 BCD에도 끼많은 애들이 많았지 장원영 B아니였음?
@@지현-t3f8k 등급평가는 실력으로 따져야지 스타성으로 따지는건 아니잖아요 ㅎㅎ 제가 생각하기에 스타성 있고 끼도 많은 분들은 사쿠라 이외에도 많았던것 같아요 장원영 등등...
@@유나-t3m3s 소유쌤 빼고는 다 올 에이 괜찮다 했는데 소유쌤이 B주자고 했어서..ㅠㅠ
아니 춤선 너무 깔끔하고 예쁜데 .. 역시 민주는 숨겨진 댄스 재능캐였어 춤선과 느낌을 살릴줄 알아
Super pretty, but need more confidence and improvement. She will be lit.
she would be perfect if her voice is good & stable. her dancing is actually great except mnet edited it in a bad way 🙄🙄
Everyone doubted her at first, but honestly, Minju has turned out to be a really solid idol. I’m really proud of how far she’s come!
진짜 이쁘다
이거 보고 지금 센터 찢는 민주 보니까 가슴 웅장해짐 정말 많이 성장했구나 울아가....ㅜㅜ 얼마나 연습했을까
민주ちゃん 頑張って!!💪🔥
日本から 応援してるよ📣✨
근데 민주는 진짜 노력을 많이한게 느껴지네 데뷔하고나니까 실력이 점점 늘어
一人でこういう風に出来るのがかっこいい
メンバーになってさらにかっこいい
She is really good tho, why mnet made her mistake like a big deal
i still cannot find her mistake??
aphrodite zzz 1:06
She's not good enough... Her singing is weak and she is not confident at all.
@@mylind2948 She Has Potential
Its not even a mistake lmao
춤 기본적으로 다 추는데..? 난 무슨 본방 보면서 강혜원처럼 얼굴만 이쁜 연생인 줄 알았는데 춤선이 되게 이쁜데?
minju have it she just lacks confidence and little improvement. but atleast in the re-evaluation she moved up to C. very good girl!!! fighting!
Kim Minjoo can be the next Suzy, she just needs more confidence in herself
ONCEfineapplinus No one can be the next Suzy
Alonso Martiarena no one can be the next suzy but can be better than Suzy
king taeyeon lol tbh she isn’t more talented than suzy. Suzy is an actress (but a real actress not like all the idols who act in a kdrama just because are idols) a model (she is one of the best visuals) and an idol (look her mr removed), so we are still waiting . Have a pretty face is not enough!
No one could beat suzy, yoona, jiyeon, nana and krystal
@@User63909 yeah but Minju debuted as an actress before joining Pd48. So she's not the attress that act in kdrama because she's an idol. She even got special rookie awards for her acting :)
Hopefully she will get to act more in the future!
Also Minju is a model too look at her Dispatch x Fila photoshoot hehe
She is the next Bae Jin Young
She really is
She has potential. She's graceful and her visuals are impressive.
Her visuals are nearly off the charts IMO, LOL.
私は普通に上手いと思うんだけどなぁプロから見たらDなんだよなぁ
Minju is this season's Bae Jinyoung. Believe me. Mnet gonna show her improvement later in the future episodes.
After Violeta MV, Minjoo has improved a lot. She gained confidence. 😍 Saranghae Minguri 💞
I think this might be the seasons Bae Jinyoung
Edit: Damn this blew up don't let Park Minji flop again
Quincee Day I truly hope so
i think so and I hope so
Quincee Day :////
Oh yeah that's what I think too, but I hope she will become more confident.
Quincee Day why?? Jinyoung was good tho in class evaluation, he just didn't dare to stare at the camera and he got C
일본에서 응원하고 있어요🇯🇵
꽃길 걷자!! 파이팅💪
This is better than the edited version. 💞
김민주 힘내세요 ❤
I really hope Minjoo becomes more confident in herself. She HAS potential and it's a shame that people don't see it because of her lack of confidence (and her shy/quiet personality as well). I've been supporting her since the beginning and I don't plan on giving up on her. ♥ Fighting Kim Minjoo ♥
프듀 악마의 편집 ㄷㄷ
엄청 못한 것처럼 만드는 매직
우리 민주 실력 많이 늘었고 저때부터도 기본이 되어있었기때문에 여기까지 올수있었던 것같아
I dont get why people said minjoo is mnet's daughter. She got a screentimes during early eps. But most of them in a bad ways. And this audition video,her dance is not really bad. Mnet just show which she's make mistake while her full performance is okay. No wonder minjoo start to lose confidence. But good thinks,she make it. Izone's Minjoo fighting!!
She has potential and is not that bad... I'm sure she will become very good by the end of the show
웃는게 참 이뻐... 나도 모르게 시선이 가버린다구,,,, 저 무지개옷을 발랄하게 소화하다니...
Kim Minju: Debuted as 11th place
가슴이 웅장해진다.....
Wait she actually did a really good job!!
Gosh darn it mnet editing!!
I'm so super duper proud of you, Minju Angel! So much improvement from this to now. Bravo!♡♡♡
근데 춤선 진짜 예쁘네 D까지는 아닌데..,.,?
かわいい
추천영상에 떠서 다시 봄. 올챙이 시절도 실력 좋아요. 노력쟁이니까
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 지금도 채연님이랑 정말 열심히 노력 하신다고 해요
잘추는 민주는 D면서 일연생 벚꽃은 Aㅋㅋㅋㅋ 말이 되냐?ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 조작진짜ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
잘추는건 아님 D는에반데 C정도 받을수준
@@코코볼-e5e 벚꽃에 비하면 잘춘다는 말이에용
@발광머리앤 팩트라 뭐...ㅎ 닉값하지 말구 그냥 가실래요^^?
우주먼지 김민주 올려치는건 알겠는데 가만히 있는 사쿠라 후려치지는 꼬라지하고는 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@코코볼-e5e 김민주 올려치는거 아니구 사쿠라 내려치는거 아닌데요? 아이즈원 덕질 안하는 사람이에요ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그리고 올려치든 내려치든 어차피 주작은 주작 다른 댓글들 보면 사쿠라 A인거 이해 안가는 사람들 졸라 많아요ㅎㅎ 안그러던가?
(주작이 아이즈원잘못이라고 한ㄱ 아니에요ㅋ 혹시나 본인 난독증가지고 내가 아이즈원잘못이라니 뭐니 하는 흑우 있을까봐ㅎ 본인 흑우되지 마시라고 하는 말이기두 하구요ㅎㅎ)
저때는 비록 자신없는 모습이었지만 2020년 민주는 누구보다 더 당당한 모습!
이때부터 춤선이 예뻤구나
the Minju in Produce48 and the Minju in IZ*ONE are two COMPLETELY different people. She is sooooo much more confident with her dancing and singing now.
Just needs more confidence and improve her dance lines. But she really has the star aura to go to the top! Fighting 우리 민민! You can do it!
see how minju improves in izone make me proud of her very much
매일같이 와서 2번씩보고가요 민주누나. 다시 한번 커버해줘요~~
This is not bad, the editing from the previous episode made this looked so bad. Be more confident Minjoo, you can do it. 🙌
MINJU DEBUTED
You know what she still had the balls to perform on that stage and she gave her all so it doesn’t matter if it was good or bad. At the end she still debuted in Izone so never give up on your dreams. ✨
다리가 긴거야 얼굴이 작은거야... 나는 왜 아이즈원 다 끝나서야 김민주 좋아하고 있음???? 진짜짱나...ㅠㅠ
민주 엔젤 꽃길만 걷자
Wow I have no words for MNET's evil editing. They totally made her look talentless on the show. This was fairly good. Kim Min Joo, let's debut!!! You can do it!!!
노래도 본인이랑 잘 어울리고 음색도 좋고 춤도 나쁘지 않은데 D라니... 너무한 걸...?
아이즈원에서 민주가 제일 많이 늘었어 ㅜㅜㅜㅜ 짱이야
well... to be honest, I do think that this girl did better than Sakura and Jurina in terms of dancing, she got isolation and her choreography is way more complicated. Mnet made that tiny mistake such a big deal, well..how the hell did she get D
I always see Bae Jinyoung in her.They both lack confidence at the beggining.Also the are both humble and not greedy for center position
파이팅 민민!!!
Shes not bad.. Its just.. She gravely lack confidence. I know she just met a lot of girls with amazing skills. But come on.. You can do it.
Kim Minju Fighting!!!!!!!!
I believe in you girl, you got this. this isn't a bad performance but yeah she lacks confidence I hope she can gain a lot of experience from this show! ❤️
예전에 본방 볼 때부터 생각한건데 춤선 이쁨
When she gets used to the competition and the stage she'll be amazing and noticeable MIJOO WE BELIEVE IN YOU
She is sooooooo pretty. I’m glad she had her debut. She has potential and hardworking. 😻
연습벌레 울 밍구리 오랜만에 옛날모습보니 눈물난당 ㅠㅠㅠ
가장 빛날수 있는 가능성을 품은 원석
A까진 아니지만...민주가 어떻게 D냐ㅠㅠ
C 정도가 딱 괜찮을 듯 D는 아님ㅠ
눈나.. ㅠㅠ 사ㅏㅇ랑해..
Her dancing style is just like kriesha chu's style... ❤
I like Minju since I saw her do videos with Kriesha chu!! She's a great dancer and singer but she gets self conscious in front of the judges, as she gets older she will be able to gain her confidence
민주 짜란다!짜란다!
Her dance was not bad at all. She can be the lead dancer in pd48 new group ❤
Michel Yemima she’s not bad, but lead dancer ? No. There are many trainee better than her like the little girl in CNC
Sarahdia Cathusca sorry. It's just my opinion. If you don't agree it's okay. Everyone has their own opinion. I'm sure minjoo is actually a good dancer. She's just didn't felt confident because she's never performing alone. She's always with kriesha chu everytime I saw her videos. Thank you for share your opinion ^^
Michel Yemima yes of course I respect your opinion
Sarahdia Cathusca thank you ^^
You can see that she tried her best. The dance wasn’t good it was pretty bad. I really like her and I respect your opinion but I can not understand it
She's working so hard
깅밍듀 이 귀염둥이 이때부터 알아봤어 춤선 개이쁨
Watching this now after Buenos Aires MV got released, I must definitely say, Minju already has that potential from the very beginning but her skills shoot up really high after getting in to IZONE. I swear she's one of the most versatile members of the group and she undeniable improved a WHOLE LOT! Minju, I'm so proud of you!!!
she’s hardworking though, but she has less confidence, you can do it kim minjoo!
근데 보면 잘한연습생들도 빨리한 연습생들 등급이 낮게나왔다고 생각함
뒤로갈수록 높은등급이 없으니까 기준이 낮아지는느낌..?(개인적인 생각입니다)
아니 이게... 이게 D라고? 편집본 보고 댓글 봤는데 D라길래 안 믿겨서 무편집본 보러왔음 무슨 진짜 최소 C는 받겠구만... 춤 잘추고 노래 잘하는것까진 아니라해도 이정도면 C 받지 프듀에 더 못하는 애들 수두룩한데 이해가 안가네
Baby girl fighting😍
원곡 안듣고 일부러 이거 들어요 청량감 뿜뿜
hands down the best video ever
Please support Kim minju..let her debut she is great..
주기적으로 보러 옵니다 노메러왓민주 사랑해
I can't stop listening to this track and this is even better than BoA original Track
SR.Strontium me too, i like the instrumental remix
普通に上手いと思ったのは私だけ？
それな
Omg look at her now, she's literally a star 🤩
나 민주 목소리 너무 좋아
킹민주
dont be nervous Kim Minjoo be confident we know that you are a good dancer and all around too. goodluck
와 너무이쁘다
Awwww she is soooo pretty........
she can be a talented idol in the future just like twice.....
And to all those who believed in Minjoo during PD days! You guys are all amazing!! See our Minguri now!!! shining on stage and slaying!!!! 🥺🥺🥺🥺