For those with Chinese eyes, this would look really flattering. It’s basically a cat eye made for Chinese shaped eyes, commonly used in Douyin makeup. I used to get a lot of compliments about my eyeliner after discovering the technique in hs (I didn’t invent it). You wanna draw a line down where the natural shadow is and at the end of the shadow/concave part of the eye, bring it up at a diagonal. Extend to however you want, but typically you want the upwards portion to be 1:1 or 1:0.8 (the 0.8 being the length of the 2nd part) then draw a line connecting to start (which should be at some point in the eyelash, wherever the shadow or concave part started). When you draw a line, lift your brow a bit so that the line doesn’t end up curved when you open your eyes normally. Then you want to draw a line in a check mark shape from the last at the outer corner to the tip of the wing. For those with large eyes, draw the eyeliner (that’s at the middle of your eye under the lashes and then for the empty space between your inner corner and smallest lash, draw it outside (normally). For those with smaller eyes, just connect the liner from the shadow to the inner corner over the eyelashes. Honestly I tried my hardest to explain it since it’s hard to even show as a video
I’m going to be VERY honest, but part of ningning(+Giselle’s) glow up is because of their weight loss + the fact that they’re using blush As someone who has just recently lost 5+ kilos, I look better even with the exact same makeup
I mostly agree, but her makeup really has changed for the better imo. Their makeup artist used to give her very bold colors and had her eyebrows and lips as focal points, which didn't suit her much
Weight loss and more cosmetic work! Giselle’s lip fillers were noticeable in Whiplash but they actually suit her face really well-people talk about the “SM face” for a reason, but it genuinely looks good, especially for Aespa’s high fashion/futuristic concepts. I just hope they don’t go any further.
@@pearinsomnia9188 HEAVY on the cosmetic work, just thought it was obvious!!! Apparently not looking at some other comments Giselle got her whole face redone, tbh but it looks great! Not sure about Ningning though I'm guessing they took their time with consultations and evaluations before getting anything done, plus Giselle's features have stopped changing as she's reaching 25(PS before 24-25 ish is risky since you're not done growing and your features may still change) hence why she didn't debut with a fully done face
@@Abrigat This too, because they(karina especially) were focused on replicating their AI counterparts, but now their concept has evolved to the point where they're not doing that anymore. It's a mix of weight loss+cosmetic surgery+makeup and styling changes They also seem to work with lighter colour seasons which I really love!!
@@hayley4032 now thats just taking it too far… I wouldn’t be surprised if she had something done recently but to claim that she just had her entire face done is unhinged. Most of her visual changes are just different makeup techniques.
I spotted her long time ago, she always gave me Jennie vibes, this classy look, good stage presence, they have similar facial features too and even move so fluid with their body. idk, maybe I'm wrong for comparing, I actually do t like to compare people but I adore both of them, they are my top 2 k pop girlies. since BP is no more active so much I'm really glad there is aespa and ning2, just makes me miss less BP and Jennie with her hot looks in particular. just the vibe. And since Jennie is certainly it girl of Korea ning2 tho Chinese can get up there pretty easily. she is very memorable. they also both have this type of facial features that no matter what hairstyle or make up they wear they always look fine as heck. sry I ve been fangirling a bit 😂.
your mom is right! these idols and celebrities get procedures done on their faces little by little so no one can notice it and we're just meant to believe it's all natural and their faces. love yourself
'going crazy over ningning' AS THEY SHOULD
AS SHE SHOULD
AS THEY SHOULD
ningning is the MAKNAE 💜
which means she's the YOUNGEST💜
not trying to be MESSY 💜
the always PRETTY💜
and the fact that she ate first is CRAZY 💜
im not tryna be MESSY 💜
The red hair and makeup style they had her in during debut made her look 10x older. Black hair and soft makeup and she looks her age now.
You can't spell stunning without ning.
Fact~
Stun
@@tyl4018 you just proved this person point lol!
Drama Ning: I'm a stunnah!
Honestly, have you guys noticed how drastically Ningning and Giselle changed? Like… they’re goddesses
Ningning has always been so pretty to me
Ningning has always been pretty 🤍
ningning looks more amazing in her chinese style make up, whenever she have an activity in china she looks 100x amazing.
Yes and the outfits are way better too. She's upgraded when she goes back to China.
You ended making the liner the same thickness across the lash line 😂
For those with Chinese eyes, this would look really flattering. It’s basically a cat eye made for Chinese shaped eyes, commonly used in Douyin makeup. I used to get a lot of compliments about my eyeliner after discovering the technique in hs (I didn’t invent it). You wanna draw a line down where the natural shadow is and at the end of the shadow/concave part of the eye, bring it up at a diagonal. Extend to however you want, but typically you want the upwards portion to be 1:1 or 1:0.8 (the 0.8 being the length of the 2nd part) then draw a line connecting to start (which should be at some point in the eyelash, wherever the shadow or concave part started). When you draw a line, lift your brow a bit so that the line doesn’t end up curved when you open your eyes normally. Then you want to draw a line in a check mark shape from the last at the outer corner to the tip of the wing. For those with large eyes, draw the eyeliner (that’s at the middle of your eye under the lashes and then for the empty space between your inner corner and smallest lash, draw it outside (normally). For those with smaller eyes, just connect the liner from the shadow to the inner corner over the eyelashes. Honestly I tried my hardest to explain it since it’s hard to even show as a video
i have chinese hooded eyea😅 and i suck at makeup but im gonn try
Maknaes arent supposed to eat first, but Ningning always devours.
Ningning is the makarena💜
Its because Ningning is the MAKNAE 💜
ning2 is the MAKNAE 💜
Which means she’s the youngest💜 💜 (not trying to be messy)
@@l30xx04 and the fact she ate first is CRAZY 💜
I LOVE YOU FOR THIS AND I LOVE MINGHAO IN UR PFP
@@mymelojun THANK YOUUU 💕💕
@@l30xx04 YWW 💗💗 also carat & my you're SO cool
Wow you drew it so perfectly
I’m going to be VERY honest, but part of ningning(+Giselle’s) glow up is because of their weight loss + the fact that they’re using blush
As someone who has just recently lost 5+ kilos, I look better even with the exact same makeup
I mostly agree, but her makeup really has changed for the better imo. Their makeup artist used to give her very bold colors and had her eyebrows and lips as focal points, which didn't suit her much
Weight loss and more cosmetic work! Giselle’s lip fillers were noticeable in Whiplash but they actually suit her face really well-people talk about the “SM face” for a reason, but it genuinely looks good, especially for Aespa’s high fashion/futuristic concepts. I just hope they don’t go any further.
@@pearinsomnia9188 HEAVY on the cosmetic work, just thought it was obvious!!! Apparently not looking at some other comments
Giselle got her whole face redone, tbh but it looks great! Not sure about Ningning though
I'm guessing they took their time with consultations and evaluations before getting anything done, plus Giselle's features have stopped changing as she's reaching 25(PS before 24-25 ish is risky since you're not done growing and your features may still change) hence why she didn't debut with a fully done face
@@Abrigat This too, because they(karina especially) were focused on replicating their AI counterparts, but now their concept has evolved to the point where they're not doing that anymore. It's a mix of weight loss+cosmetic surgery+makeup and styling changes
They also seem to work with lighter colour seasons which I really love!!
@@hayley4032 now thats just taking it too far… I wouldn’t be surprised if she had something done recently but to claim that she just had her entire face done is unhinged. Most of her visual changes are just different makeup techniques.
Ning Ning always eats 💜
Your makeup looks flawless--
Step 1: Be naturally pretty
She lost weight and toned her body🫶🏽
NING NING BIASES ASSEMBLE ❤️
She looks like joy
several sm idols all end up with the same face really.
I agree she kinda looks like a mix of joy and Jennie
got work done on her face, again, and got better make up
AHH NINGIE IS MY BIAS I LOVE AESPA
U are beautiful with that eye liner ❤
Omg! We have the same hairclip! Btw i lovee your eyeliner!
girl i love ur voice
U llol so much better without bangs
Share the eyeliner you used.
what eyeliner are you using??? it’s sooo thin! perfect for this look!
I love your voice
I used to do eyeliner like this
As they should
What eyeliner do you use!!! Its so thin!
NewJeans Hanni makeup pls
I spotted her long time ago, she always gave me Jennie vibes, this classy look, good stage presence, they have similar facial features too and even move so fluid with their body. idk, maybe I'm wrong for comparing, I actually do t like to compare people but I adore both of them, they are my top 2 k pop girlies. since BP is no more active so much I'm really glad there is aespa and ning2, just makes me miss less BP and Jennie with her hot looks in particular. just the vibe. And since Jennie is certainly it girl of Korea ning2 tho Chinese can get up there pretty easily. she is very memorable. they also both have this type of facial features that no matter what hairstyle or make up they wear they always look fine as heck. sry I ve been fangirling a bit 😂.
this is called puppy liner. this is not a new thing.
I NEED THAT EYELINER WHERE DID YOU BUY IT???
What contacts are you using?
Reminded me of ahyeon 😭
Which eyeliner is that?
I have hooded eyes 😢
Ning ning is the maknae
Does someone know whats the name of these forums are where koreans talk about idols?
idk like theqoo, pann...?
What is the eyeliner you use?
Lip filler going brrrrrr
imo it looks incomplete 😭😭
She’s basically imitating Jennie
Does anyone know which eyeliner that is?
But I don’t want to change the way I look. My mom says I’m already beautiful but makeup is everywhere
your mom is right! these idols and celebrities get procedures done on their faces little by little so no one can notice it and we're just meant to believe it's all natural and their faces. love yourself
Which eyeliner is this?
This is actually 90s style
1:04:40 cmq è probabile sia un joke con right on time xo in japanes
"How hot shes gotten" HAAAH!? SHE HAS BEEN HOT SINCE FOREVER BRUH but I get what u mean 😂
How we get beautiful lips?
2nd pic looks like Karina too 😭
It's just not abt the makeup.. Ning lost some weight and her chubby looks are gone..and don't forget she's so hot even without makeup
Its not Ningning its her makeup artist
1:13:04 ceh ho letto io fino a mo e poi suddenly mi ricordo che c'è stato il xhaprer change
I don’t know who she is, but to me it seems that her skin just got lighter and her hair style was changed
Did she had a nose surgery???
Nah its not her eyeliner its just her 😭
The doctor that did your rhinoplasty did a horrible joke 😢 you can see the scaring through ur make up
Ningning is the MAKNAE 💜
@@zoey4148 I’m not tryna be MESSY 💜
Ningning is eating
its so ugly😭 looks good on ning2 tho
ramsor gnal sakalam
each video you are like 20 shades lighter lmao..
Ayo!first hereeee
Peseficly?
That's literally so basic 😐
A S I A N F I S H IIIINNNGG
omg yes asian style makeup is cute but ASIAN FISHING ISNT
She's literally Asian I'm pretty sure??
how can a asian, asianfish?
I didn’t know people were still accusing people who try EA styles of makeup of Asian fishing 💀
@@nukes_are_delicious She is 😭
She is literally Asian babes 😂
Didn't kpop stuns bully Aespa onto plastic surgery
what do you mean? They had surgery before they debuted
SM idols have a lot of work done, it always looks good, let’s move along.
Did you get a nose job?
Uneven nose
ningning is the MAKNAE💜
@@ggggggglllllggg which means she’s the YOUNGEST 💜
ningning is the MAKNAE 💜