At this time, joy vocal was so under appreciated. Now, she's our tone fairy. Time flies and I'm happy people appreciate how unique Park Sooyoung tone is.
yeah, and now Red Velvet get the appreciation that they deserve because of her musicality and the concepts they bring in the kpop industry. Fuck, IM SO FUCKING PROUD
Even way back then, in 2015, you can tell that there's something special about Red Velvet!! Their harmonization on this song is very good, much better then any other Kpop girl group I've seen! As we all know, they would go on to prove their greatness over the succeeding years.
it's really REALLY crazy to think that RV has already amazing vocals on their debut, but they still find a way to improve a lot. I MEAN ALL OF THEM. COMPARING THEIR PERFORMANCE HERE AND IN CHRISTMAS IT IS REALLY NOTICEABLE THEY'RE BIG IMPROVEMENT. IM SO PROUD
I'm so proud of Joy. She's under appreciated when they debuted, but look at her now. 🥺 Beating against all odds. You worked hard, baby girl. Others might not see how you strive but we, true luvies, can. You deserve all the love in the world. Fighting! 🥺💚💚
My only wish in this performance that the members to have responded to Wendy when she was looking at them and singing harmonies like at 1:58 and 3:06 :)
Wow... I just realized this was the first time Wendy really caught my attention! Before I was more interested in Seulgi and probably Irene, but Wendy's eyes right here... *chef kiss Now, after 6 years without having a bias on RV, during quarentine Wendy has become my bias (yes while she was on hiatus 🥺🤧) Thankfully she's back right now and more active than ever! Hopeful to see more RV as group in the NEAR VERY NEAR future
The first wish is for us to be happy like we’re today. The second wish is for us to be together even after more winters. The third wish is to let other wishes come true.
They all look so beautiful .. this sweet song keeps me in the light when darkness comes. Seulgi is my bias ... you can Feel it when she sings ... but they are are True Gems ... each breathtaking in their own way ... and together ... MAGIC ! 💖 We love you so much !
Like the wish tree, let's be happy red velvet, our leader, the best woman in this generation, it always be and always will be irene. Let's happy girl and we're always here, we're together❤️💛💙💚💜
![Birthday - Red Velvet レッドベルベット [Music Bank] | KBS WORLD TV 221209](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rxbtMt7CRQk/mqdefault.jpg)
![Birthday - Red Velvet レッドベルベット [Music Bank] | KBS WORLD TV 221209](/img/tr.png)
![[Winter Garden League 수상작] Red Velvet 레드벨벳 '세가지 소원 (Wish Tree)' MV](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nTYYYor2Zfw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[kbs world] 뮤직뱅크 - 레드벨벳, 세가지 소원.20151225](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/lQMurE1kdhU/mqdefault.jpg)
![MAMAMOO - All I want for christmas is you / Um Oh Ah Yeh [Music Bank Christmas Special / 2015.12.25]](/img/1.gif)
Seulgi really fits with all the members voices. When it comes to harmonization I think she's really the best with it.
come here because on psycho ep 1 vlive rv sing this hehehe red velvet best vocal group since debut ♡
At this time, joy vocal was so under appreciated. Now, she's our tone fairy. Time flies and I'm happy people appreciate how unique Park Sooyoung tone is.
yeah, and now Red Velvet get the appreciation that they deserve because of her musicality and the concepts they bring in the kpop industry. Fuck, IM SO FUCKING PROUD
And after 4 years they sing this song together again in a small but precious crowd of Reveluvs.. this is my ultimate Christmas song
i came back to this after that one and i've gotta say... they have IMPROVED.
Wendy and Joy's voice mix well but Seulgi and Wendy's harmony is the best for me
Nowadays, joy and seulgi is in their best harmony
The best harmony is SeulWenJoy
Yessss wendy and seulgi voice blend so well
2:05 wendy is perfection
Joy's emotion shows right through her face. I love her voice!!!
Even way back then, in 2015, you can tell that there's something special about Red Velvet!! Their harmonization on this song is very good, much better then any other Kpop girl group I've seen! As we all know, they would go on to prove their greatness over the succeeding years.
I'm crying over the lyrics. I watched the mv before coming here. I felt the pain of the lyrics for the girl in the mv.
They are all so perfect!!
Joy's body,face,hair,voice everything is goals!
wendyyyyy....you should be in mask best singer...
I'm from the future and she went to KOMS twice now. She went to the 3rd round and almost won that one too!
@@bdzmru8489 lol u very r
it's really REALLY crazy to think that RV has already amazing vocals on their debut, but they still find a way to improve a lot. I MEAN ALL OF THEM. COMPARING THEIR PERFORMANCE HERE AND IN CHRISTMAS IT IS REALLY NOTICEABLE THEY'RE BIG IMPROVEMENT. IM SO PROUD
Joy and Wendy 😍😍😍😍😘😘😘😘🌸🌸🌸🌸
Yeri looks so gorgeous 😍
Wendy and Joy look so beautiful same with Irene and Selgui [ tell me if I spelled that wrong lol ]
+Senpai Milani Seulgi! :)
+mewantspocky Thank you!
I love seulgi's voice ,,, OMGGG OUR MAIN DANCER
Wendy is a perfect woman who can do anything and this is a legendary video.
omg look how Hard joy is trying and her voice sounds amazing seulgi as always perfekt
Wendy and Irene😍😍😍
Wendy is prettiest when she sings 😍 all of them are queen of vocals and visuals 💗💛💙💚💜
Joy's voice😍💕🍎
레드벨벳은 발라드도 잘 어울리네. 발라드 낼거면 꼭 가을이나 겨울에 내자!
I'm here csz we don't have content from RV today :(
:')
RV’s harmonization is peak talent. 🥺
Omg Joy is a gem. Her voice is perfect
I'm so proud of Joy. She's under appreciated when they debuted, but look at her now. 🥺 Beating against all odds. You worked hard, baby girl. Others might not see how you strive but we, true luvies, can. You deserve all the love in the world. Fighting! 🥺💚💚
이때 웬디 미모 최고였음
My only wish in this performance that the members to have responded to Wendy when she was looking at them and singing harmonies like at 1:58 and 3:06 :)
I love Joy voice!!! She’s awesome as❤️
Wendy looks so beautiful in this style
아빠❤❤❤❤
I just love Yeri and Seulgi's harmony :) Red Velvet Fighting!!!
Joy's voice is sooooo.... pretty just like her.
Wendyy really look so pretty with this look!
*ps : actually all of them looks gorgeous🙈❤️
3:05 Wendy waiting Seulgi to look at her😂
Aww thats tragic
예림언니 너무 예쁘다 진짜
Irene
Seulgi & Wendy
아 완전 추억이다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 2015년 연말이 생각난다 ....ㅠ ㅠ
joy 😍
omaygawd wendy is so pretty and wishing everyone a merry christmas here
I'm agree Wendy is freaking good without bangs. Can't wait for Christmas!!
Wendyyyhhhhyy!bb!bbbb!
that harmony THOOOOO they are all so beautiful and have such great voices jelly af man 😭😭😭
Wendy is so pretty
I really love Seulgi's lower register...
Seulgi amazing
The lyrics are so touching..and I miss FOREHEAD WENDY!
wendy is life ! 👄💚💛💙💜❤💟
no lies, ICE CREAM CAKE album is such a gift
Woah, Wendy looks like a half-blooded foreigner here.. Blows my mind
Harmonies for Days !!!!
Red Velvet harmonies are among best of the best in the world right now
wendy and seulgi..OMG...
wendy is a bae
Finally...i really need that subtittle❤
Red velvet's lyrics is always meaningful and amazing
Get well soon wendy💙
Seulgi feel well👍🏻👍🏻
Red velvet ❤❤❤❤❤
Real talented+ real visual = Complete package
wendy
I miss red velvet 🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺 this song really ...😭💖💛💙💚💜
When fans singing this in their concerts that's really warm my heart :((
Wow... I just realized this was the first time Wendy really caught my attention! Before I was more interested in Seulgi and probably Irene, but Wendy's eyes right here... *chef kiss
Now, after 6 years without having a bias on RV, during quarentine Wendy has become my bias (yes while she was on hiatus 🥺🤧)
Thankfully she's back right now and more active than ever! Hopeful to see more RV as group in the NEAR VERY NEAR future
이건 진짜 매년 겨울마다 들어줘야 함…
cute 😭
Wendy, you are amazing
They're all so beautiful 😍 they really are.
The first wish is for us to be happy like we’re today.
The second wish is for us to be together even after more winters.
The third wish is to let other wishes come true.
Bring back Wendy's forehead!!! She's so gorgeous without bangs!!!
Indeed
I hope this 2020 we will going to have Winter Album of Red Velvet. It really suit for them.
Still one of my favourite RV songs ever T.T
Wendy! 💙💙💙💙💙
와 웬디 존예롭다 진짜
2003911아기정은달밤요일삼춘병원
아빠훈
자ㅜㅜㅜ정은사랑해요
Aaaa aw!! Wendy! Unni!
My favorite Christmas song by a Kpop group ever.
My joy ❣️ I miss you!!
I missed your voices girls 🤧🧡
Love you Seulgi, Irene, Joy, Wendy and Yeri❤😊
omg joy ur vouce is so amazing. 😍😍😍😍
예리👍
Wendy really beautiful
They all look so beautiful .. this sweet song keeps me in the light when darkness comes. Seulgi is my bias ... you can Feel it when she sings ... but they are are True Gems ... each breathtaking in their own way ... and together ... MAGIC ! 💖 We love you so much !
This is where i fall in love with wendyy
와 항상 예쁘지만 웬디 저때 개이쁘다
This is like an SNSD song. The vocals! ❤️
Sooyoungaaaaaa!~~~
Everything is just perfect! 😍
BACK TO HERE AFTER 5 YEARS
/crying/
MERRY CHRISTMAS EVERYONE💚💜💗💛💙
🤍🤍
they are so perfect... keeping perfect facial expressions as they sing perfectly
This was so beautiful I am crying
RED VELVET IS A TRUE PERFECT HARMONY GIRLGROUP EVEN FROM ROOKIE DAYS
Like the wish tree, let's be happy red velvet, our leader, the best woman in this generation, it always be and always will be irene. Let's happy girl and we're always here, we're together❤️💛💙💚💜
Merry Christmas everyone. 🎄
Wendy so pretty
My number one Christmas song this year ahead of GOT7's confession.
irene so beautiful
Until now, this song still me loves it. The lyrics are so touching with red velvet voice that really gives me real emotion
Waiting for red velvet ot5 comeback
wow the vocalssss
The lyrics makes me cry...Hope my Christmas this year will be a happy one.
Wendy ❤️❤️❤️❤️😍😍😍😍
초4때 나와서 그 후로 계속 들었는데 벌써 20살이야 말도 안돼
Wendy is more more beautiful with this hairs style
Happy holidays everyone ♥️
crying over this vid and it's only april 😭😭😭