They copied from some Dawn article 'A burden on economy' published on April 26, 2024, which was talking about beggers within Pakistan.. but the print actually took those figures in the context of some other report on Pakistani beggars in other countries.. So it becomes nothing more than a click bait.
What's wrong in begging ??.. You mean ONLY the Pakistani government has the exclusive rights for begging? It's really unfair... Pakistani beggars must protest and fight for their rights
I beg to differ, this is distorted information it’s impossible to collect USD 42 Billion by Pakistani simply by begging. Remittance sent by Pakistani workers working abroad only amounted only to 27 Billion USD for the fiscal year 2023
@@brahm-ahamasmi Detail is as specified during India's partition. Muslims have already been given their share as Pakistan. It was India's naivety and goodwill that we have given equal rights to them but growing M population is a concern which should be tackled by taking away their citizenship. Before you say I'm being a bigot first look at different countries elsewhere they've adopted same methods. All the Ms in India shouldn't have accepted Partition if they wanted equal treatment and rights.
@@-YOUNG_MASTER- India's naivety? LOL. Your comment is such that NO STATEMENT MAKES SENSE and you are calling a nation naive. Let me break down some of your BS. "All the Ms in India shouldn't have accepted Partition if they wanted equal treatment and rights." And you have no evidence for your statement. At no time did ALL THE MUSLIMS vote for Pakistan. Not only NOT ALL MUSLIM vote for it, most didn't vote. They were not allowed to vote. So, those who voted, didn't vote unanimously and those who couldn't vote and those who weren't allowed to vote seemingly don't count for you. And those who voted for it didn't understand the consequences of it. Most logical Pakistanis today will tell you their regrets of creating a nation like Pakistan. I am sure you like APJ Kalam, Industrialists like Azim Premji and converts like Rahman and Muslim cricketers when they contribute to victories for BCCI's team, specially against Pakistan and soldiers like Hamid and freedom fighters like Ashfaqulla Khan. I am happy that these are our citizens though I wish that bigots like you could somehow be filtered and what you wish for others be applied to people like you. People like you don't deserve to be citizens of any good society. I am anti-Islamic, but I am not anti-Muslim. I understand the issues of Islam and I consider devout/tribal Muslims to be diseased, and hence to be cured of it, NOT eliminated.
@@Utubeisevil want to learn everything from WA or youtube comments lad? It will take hours for me to type it out why the definition is stupid and that is the reason the government has not been able to to NRC. It is not about 99% people being citizens. It is about 100% people being objectively defined citizens. Those 1% are 10 million people for which no government has any practical plan I hope you understood. If not, read the citizenship laws and try to tell me what to do with the child who was born in India of Bangladeshi Hindus who crossed over to India in 2015. That child is already 9 years old now. Also tell me what to do of the Bangladeshi Muslim women who crossed over to India in 1971 and lost her husband after 2 years and then married a Hindu and now has 5 children with this man and 2 children from her Muslim husband. The women is now 65 and children are 33 to 50 years old with each having big families with even grandchildren. And tell me all this BASED ON THE CITIZENSHIP LAW with WHAT TO DO WITH THEM under the political situation we are in, not your personal wish list. Details!
India is no exception and begging is a profession in India too and each beggar makes more than skilled labour in many cities. The people giving alms are to blame and government cannot curb it anyway.
How do these beggers bring the foreign currency back to Pakistan? These earrings should be helpful to Pakistan then why Dawn is saying it's burden to the economy?
Your information is Fake! $42 billion is a preposterous number! Mam, go to school and get some education before you blurt nonsense here! Kuch bhi bakwas karoge!
It's a fourth pillar of Islam called Zakat. By giving alms to beggars and beggars receiving alms Momins fulfil obligation. It's unislamic act on part of any Muslim country trying to stop begging. Koran doesn't say who can beg and who can't!
@@user-nx2ot4ns8l And that’s reason genuine capitalism can’t develop in Muslim majority state. In India all Muslim capitalism sts come from Hindu convert business class. Rest of the population believe Allah will take care, we can’t change anything! That made them highly fatalistic lazy lot!
In Islam they have Zakat. People must give some part of their income to poor people mostly beggars. That is why we can see beggers in India also begging at masjids.
“We beg. To differ. ”
- Probably Pakistanis.
🤣🤣🤣🤣
they even had a general named Mirza Aslam Beg.
@@TamBramThankyouMam I beg your pardon
Inspired !!
Damn.
How will the Pak PM now go to foreign countries? He is also a beggar!
Crass
❤
The beggars are providing a great service - now the remaining Pakistanis can feel pious by giving the beggars some money.
Check out the 42 billion USD yearly again !! just for context Pakistan's total remittance is around 25 Bn usd !
It must be 4.2 billion or 420 million.
I agree. The number suprised me. Not sure it is correct
They copied from some Dawn article 'A burden on economy' published on April 26, 2024, which was talking about beggers within Pakistan.. but the print actually took those figures in the context of some other report on Pakistani beggars in other countries.. So it becomes nothing more than a click bait.
They added PAK PMs earnings too
@@mhadiscientia just lazy journalism ! a fig like $42bn should have instantly caused a red flag when paks total GDP is $300 bn
What can you expect from the citizens of the country that stands with a begging bowl at the doors of IMF and World Bank ?
"Yatha Raja, Thatha Praja"
What's wrong in begging ??.. You mean ONLY the Pakistani government has the exclusive rights for begging? It's really unfair... Pakistani beggars must protest and fight for their rights
"Yatha Raja, Thatha Praja" - "As the King, so the Citizens !"
$42 billion a year? That’s not possible. Not possible AT ALL. Your statistics can’t be true.
I think 42billion Pakistani Rupees.
I beg to differ, this is distorted information it’s impossible to collect USD 42 Billion by Pakistani simply by begging. Remittance sent by Pakistani workers working abroad only amounted only to 27 Billion USD for the fiscal year 2023
They need to eat so can’t send all the money
Absolutely correct. $42 a billion a year from begging is simply not possible. They probably meant $42 million
Pak could earn extra income by offering professional qualifications in begging 😂
Lots of basic grammatical mistakes in this reporting. The reporter is mixing Dollars and Rupee in her reporting.
You talk foolishly, concentrate on the main point!
But I do understand what she wants to convey.
@@liberalindian8079 Such mistakes compromise the credibility of the reporting especially one coming from a professional organization such as Print.
@@sujoy1968Even I felt it is unprofessional. But I don’t think journalism gets the brightest minds in any society
Wah bhai wah kya developed country Pakistan is! Beggers going abroad 😅
What surprised me in this video is to know that even the Pakistanis have a National citizenship cards!
And we are still debating whether we need NRC.
Devil is in the kid. Devil is defining citizen and then implementing that stupid definition
@@brahm-ahamasmi Detail is as specified during India's partition. Muslims have already been given their share as Pakistan. It was India's naivety and goodwill that we have given equal rights to them but growing M population is a concern which should be tackled by taking away their citizenship. Before you say I'm being a bigot first look at different countries elsewhere they've adopted same methods. All the Ms in India shouldn't have accepted Partition if they wanted equal treatment and rights.
@@brahm-ahamasmi "stupid definition"? what stupid definition is currently giving u citizenship status?
@@-YOUNG_MASTER- India's naivety? LOL. Your comment is such that NO STATEMENT MAKES SENSE and you are calling a nation naive. Let me break down some of your BS.
"All the Ms in India shouldn't have accepted Partition if they wanted equal treatment and rights."
And you have no evidence for your statement. At no time did ALL THE MUSLIMS vote for Pakistan. Not only NOT ALL MUSLIM vote for it, most didn't vote. They were not allowed to vote. So, those who voted, didn't vote unanimously and those who couldn't vote and those who weren't allowed to vote seemingly don't count for you. And those who voted for it didn't understand the consequences of it. Most logical Pakistanis today will tell you their regrets of creating a nation like Pakistan.
I am sure you like APJ Kalam, Industrialists like Azim Premji and converts like Rahman and Muslim cricketers when they contribute to victories for BCCI's team, specially against Pakistan and soldiers like Hamid and freedom fighters like Ashfaqulla Khan.
I am happy that these are our citizens though I wish that bigots like you could somehow be filtered and what you wish for others be applied to people like you. People like you don't deserve to be citizens of any good society.
I am anti-Islamic, but I am not anti-Muslim. I understand the issues of Islam and I consider devout/tribal Muslims to be diseased, and hence to be cured of it, NOT eliminated.
@@Utubeisevil want to learn everything from WA or youtube comments lad? It will take hours for me to type it out why the definition is stupid and that is the reason the government has not been able to to NRC.
It is not about 99% people being citizens. It is about 100% people being objectively defined citizens. Those 1% are 10 million people for which no government has any practical plan
I hope you understood. If not, read the citizenship laws and try to tell me what to do with the child who was born in India of Bangladeshi Hindus who crossed over to India in 2015. That child is already 9 years old now.
Also tell me what to do of the Bangladeshi Muslim women who crossed over to India in 1971 and lost her husband after 2 years and then married a Hindu and now has 5 children with this man and 2 children from her Muslim husband. The women is now 65 and children are 33 to 50 years old with each having big families with even grandchildren.
And tell me all this BASED ON THE CITIZENSHIP LAW with WHAT TO DO WITH THEM under the political situation we are in, not your personal wish list.
Details!
$42 billion equals to 63% of Pakistan 2024-25 budget. It’s such a shame for our country.
India is no exception and begging is a profession in India too and each beggar makes more than skilled labour in many cities. The people giving alms are to blame and government cannot curb it anyway.
National Profession of Pakistan is begging. Even their Prime Minister's primary job is to beg
Oh no! This move will ban the passports of its own ministers and beaurocrats too 😂
Pakistan has dubious government and sent overseas for begging and supporting Pakistan economy,
Same situation we have in India, everywhere beggers roaming in Delhi.
Porkistani 🐷🐖🐗🐽 spotted
somone can ignore begging for awhile. but not if you are involved in stealing or trafficking and kidnapping 😢😢....
So what, isn't the Pak govt. not begging from Saudi Arabia and UAE? Leaders can beg, but ordinary citizens can't?
Very informative video plz make a video on indian beggers also and human trafficking business in india
This Beggar MENACE is growing every where
Yedha Raaja thadha praja > Their citizen following what their Gov does for a living
So no passport for PM Shehbaz and Finance minister Aurangzeb
No harm in begging
That's why Pakistan does not focus on economy.
Does this amount including the govt also?
Himm Indian don't see them self u ar still in Hunger index in 2024 do samthing abaut it😂😂
Don't worry ask them to drink secularism. Or ask Kata kat scheme
Bhikaristan really needs khata khat scheme 😂
then Pakistani PM’s passport must be scrapped
They just following
Zardari & Shabaz
Total beggars population of pakistan is 245,209,815.. Makes it Approximately 246 million beggars
It's forecast to double to 546 Million by the end of the century 😢
They do better than the rest of us.
This definitely has to be stopped! Good update on this nuisance social issue. It is definitely organised business.
Pakistan economy paani me gayi....chapak chapak
Their Govt is the biggest beggar.
42 billion are u mad?
$42 billion that the can track ..
How do these beggers bring the foreign currency back to Pakistan?
These earrings should be helpful to Pakistan then why Dawn is saying it's burden to the economy?
They beg to be Pakistani.
So Pakistani PMs cant travel abroad now ?
99% are daalkor bunjabi
Your information is Fake! $42 billion is a preposterous number! Mam, go to school and get some education before you blurt nonsense here! Kuch bhi bakwas karoge!
This news is melody to my ears.
Begging in the blood
Bhikari Kom Pakistan and Bangaladesh
Desh ka PM hi beggar hai to baaki awwam ka kya kahe?
Pakistan ❎
Bhikaristan✅
It's a fourth pillar of Islam called Zakat. By giving alms to beggars and beggars receiving alms Momins fulfil obligation. It's unislamic act on part of any Muslim country trying to stop begging. Koran doesn't say who can beg and who can't!
Begging is religious act 😅
@@user-nx2ot4ns8lyes begging is a pious religious act sanctioned by quran
@@user-nx2ot4ns8l Yes beggars in Islam has pretty high status! No beggars no Jakat and 4th pillar of Islam to beg and give alms destroyed!
@@mikesheth5370
I get it now.. purely religious
😅😅
@@user-nx2ot4ns8l And that’s reason genuine capitalism can’t develop in Muslim majority state. In India all Muslim capitalism sts come from Hindu convert business class. Rest of the population believe Allah will take care, we can’t change anything! That made them highly fatalistic lazy lot!
Instead of paying money on war they should do something for its ppl Islam countries are very poor they ain’t no jobs there
They beg frm every1
Sad...
Bhikharistan😅😅😅🎉🎉😂😂😂❤❤
💋
In Islam they have Zakat. People must give some part of their income to poor people mostly beggars. That is why we can see beggers in India also begging at masjids.
Print weeps and moans for Porkisthan, along with the Khan Market and Lutyen's now get much less than 500 views than the displayed
Ho gyi bakchodi tumhe lootne ka moka ab nhi milega 10 sal se desh ko loot rhe ho ye h tumhari desh bkti