1070 Showdown - G1 Gaming GTX 1070 vs Strix ROG GTX1070
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 сен 2024
- Lets put the Gigabyte G1 Gaming 1070 up against the Asus Strix 1070!
Big thanks to www.playtech.co.nz for supporting me!
Subscribe and help me get to 20,000 subs, then it will be giveaway time!
![🎮 Gigabyte GTX 1070 G1 Gaming [Обзор, Тест в играх и Разгон]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/boayCdYgkJg/mqdefault.jpg)
![🎮 Gigabyte GTX 1070 G1 Gaming [Обзор, Тест в играх и Разгон]](/img/tr.png)
![BAK Jay - Find Out (For Your Love) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/10FJO_XBCvY/mqdefault.jpg)
Sorry about the low audio, something weird happened with my microphone, will be fixed for next time! 8-]
Hi, I have been a fan of your channel for quite some time now.
I'm about to buy a GTX 1070 G1 Gaming model and I am really worried about getting unbearable coil whine.
From your experience, what are the best ways to eliminate it? A friend of my told me it would be a good idea to leave it under heavy load for the night and that might help, is that true?
All right, I'll continue watching the video now.
+Totalimus I can say absolutely not, unless you have this next to a sleeping baby or something, you won't hear it, and mine turbos all the way up to 2128 and stays up around there without much fuss, haven't pushed it any higher, but will sometime soon
Xavier Metzger Just because coil whine is not present in your GPU, doesn't mean it won't be in others. It's the same as silicon lottery - some have it, some don't, no manafacturer is safe.
+Totalimus I know 5 others with this same card bought at different times and they all have the same experience with it as me, and a burn in time is always a good idea, at least in my opinion
I doubt you know 5 others with the same exact card, hell they probably only made 5 with the way theyre sold out lol. Totalimus is right though, not all cards are the same and some have it and some dont. Gigabyte is a brand that has one of, if not the most coil whine in any of their cards.
this was especially great because i have the STRIX 1070 and my brother has the G1 gaming 1070. Get to rub it in his face that i get 0.1-1 fps more than he does.
Finally an NZ channel! Awesome comparison man. Ordered the G1 yesterday. Can't wait to see what it's capable of, especially since I'm moving over from my old Gigabyte GTX 670.
megachromer How's it working for you? I just ordered mine a few days ago.
My love Asus rog Strix GeForce GTX 1070 OC ❤
thx for the overview and showdown. well done. there is not much you could do better ;) whats that song at 5:51 btw?
I love my G1 1070!
I have one, it kicks ass! But Xtreme Gaming is much better.
+Turuncu Adam can't even find the xtreme anywhere online atm in US
jjoncm1 thats why i couldn't find any in Turkey lol
+Turuncu Adam in Turkey this card is 650$ lmao not everyones price tag..
no you don't. you wish you had the Strix. don't lie
Fuck that. Get the Asus at that point. Made with great quality
here in my country the strix is so expensive :\
the strix where i live is $150 more
Got mine for £300, imported from america, saved a hundred pounds in the uk, even with the shipping. It was probarbly a fluke, but was brand new, had it 8 months, no complaints here.
Get some of those acoustic pads on the walls and you'll be golden, it helps to make the audio better.
Microphone didn't work properly in this video so that's why it sounds a bit rubbish
Sounds fine to me.
TheDeceptikron Just meant it doesn't sound isolated, yes its very good but the acoustic pads make it sound like he is right up on the mic no matter where he is.
Thank you soo much for this review! its perfect im in Australia was looking at the strix model but its $680 compared to the g1 gaming $625. You have helped me make a hard decision in a heartbeat!
this is the G1 you reviewed yeh? www.msy.com.au/saonline/17171-gigabyte-n1070g1-gaming-8gd-8g-gtx-1070-g1-gaming-pci-e-vga-card.html
Dan Patto hey buddy, yes that is the one in the video. I know it's four weeks after wrote this but if you haven't already bought it from MSY get it from Amazon.com! converted to Australian dollars it's still $100 cheaper plus a little bit of postage but not too much. I just ordered mine a couple of days ago :)
corey f hey mate, yeh I already ordered my 1070 and I love it so all good haha :)
Dan Patto nice mate looking forward to mine coming too :)
Add Zotac AMP and EVGA SC to this fight. Thank you !
I just paid 746 usa dollars in the G1 version here in Brazil, the Strix version is around 884. Good to know they are practically the same thing.
ive recently sent my g1 1070 back because the plastic shroud is horrible the rgb lights have dark and light spots and the oc utility is garbage, changing to evga ftw edition
Good choice
good luck with the overheating issues of ftw editions though.. www.techpowerup.com/227133/evga-gtx-1070-1080-overheating-issues-company-says-thermal-pads-a-solution better put them thermal pads on them
Norry Rampage haha how did that turn out?
I come back more and more for the intro music, very catchy, but also enjoy the reviews and info! :)
I want to know which one of the strix is this one the oc or the non oc?
The GTX 1070 Strix built like a tank and it looks way better than the Gigabyte
The Gigabyte is cheaper.
50$ more for 0.5 FPS
Bernd Das Brot The G1 build feels cheap, the RBG lights are crap and the OC utility is garbage. The Asus Strix has a larger heat sink for better cooling. A lot of people are having coil whining problems with the Gigabyte. Which card is better? The Asus Strix.
@@SVTsupercharged yaa u have reason
Thanks for the quality review. Historically I've bought Gigabyte, but just bought a STRIX OC 1070 for $409 US. Love black friday!
dan mahoney Same
dan mahoney fuckkk
Lucky guy fml.
Just bought the Asus Gtx 1070 strix. Really can’t wait to get it and start building my new gaming rig
Great job!
Don't stop making these vids!
Can't wait for your give away!
Love these videos dude! You're really helping me out figuring which one to buy :) Leaning towards the G1 gaming so far :p
I make unbiased consumer advice video's, it's not about being flashy or being worried about offending certain companies, its just about helping guide you guys towards the best graphics cards so you don't waste your money! 8-]
Thanks for the review! By the way, what was the ambient temperature of the room when the temperatures were taken?
Great vid. You gained another sub. I just picked up the strix gtx 1070 for NZ$850 today which I thought was pretty good.
Subscribed mate, this is a fantastic comparison. :)
Really good fucking video, made me decide wich one to pick up. Went for the G1. Thanks for the information.
Finally after the 2yr crazy GPU market used cards are affordable again. Just bought two of these Asus Strix 1070 for $220 out the door which is better then the current $150 or so pricing on them. Compared to 6months ago these would have been $300ea. This level of GPU performances works just fine on my kids high refresh rate monitors. They don't play the latest demanding titles so many of their games can easily run in the 100-200fps range with medium/high detail. Should be a good card for another few years. They are paired up with 5600x/b450/32gb 3200.
Kudos to you for showing the RBG on both cards. Normally you would think thats a given but a lot of the reviews I watched didn't for some odd reason.
nice video very helpful. was debating on these cards i live in the us and the strix is only 20 bucks more right now and i like the lighting better so the vid helped me decide
Great review! You said everything exactly how i would have said it, straight to the point, no "Serious" differences, but the price tag changes it!
Thinking about holding off my purchase until January. Should I look for a newer card or will this one do fine? Wondering about the price differences in a month or so.
Thank you for that - I was really bummed out that I ended up buying the G1 Gaming card until I watched this (prior to payment and receiving of the card).
The ASUS RoG Strix 1070 OC is certainly the better card, facts are facts. But this is like saying Coke is better than Pepsi. Of course it is! However, both are legit world-class manufacturers...Pepsi just has smaller bubbles man. We're NOT saying the Gigabyte 1070 G1 Gaming is the RC Cola of the soda industry.
They are both rock solid 1070's -> you aren't going to notice a difference at all. Gigabyte is at the top of their game and there's many angles to you can view the missing 50mhz, lack of excessive lighting and casing meant to match the RoG boards that the ASUS RoG STRIX has, and slightly lesser cooling efficiency that probably isn't needed considering the slightly lower clock speeds and - therefore - overclocking that you would even bother doing...
Both are going to play any game effortlessly, on max, and rock. You'll just get the Gigabyte at a better price - probably a much much better price at that (like I did, in Q1 2020 where the ASUS is still on average about 75-150 USD more).
good video! I actually just bought the strix b/c of the lighting and extra features like xsplit.. now I hope it's better than the free OBS software. I spent hours looking at different cards and actually went with my gut and choose the strix over EVGA and Gigabyte. Your video topped it off Makin my decision just!
Hi +Tech Showdown, That was a nice video... Can you please tell me the power requirements for each card?
Hi, how did you get those clock speeds, the 2050 and 2075? Were they out of the box or overclocked?
to be honest i've really enjoyed how long your videos run for and if u can can you review a evga gtx 1070 ftw edition
Thank you for this video. I was looking for it.
i just bought the msi gaming X 1070
and i am loving it.
temps are pretty normal in gaming around 40-60, though its winter in Australia.
lets see how it does in summer.
There is a tremendous amount of fur in this video.
Yes! These two are on my short list to buy, it was one or the other, thanks for the video
No worries!
strix it is then :) .thanks for this review I've always enjoyed ur reviews ,hoping to see ur channel grow more & more
Thanks, hope it keeps growing too, it is humming along nicely but I have never had a big surge in subs like many channels get to help them grow quicker, still happy with the progress though!
Any plan to put 1070 Zotac AMP! Extreme and MSI Gaming X version on showdown? I'm very interested in Zotac's because of the cheaper price but came with large and thick cooler. Thanks!
The strix in this video is the OC version?
just bought a g1 gaming 1070 from your reviews be a nice upgrade over my 660ti
Must be tough in New Zealand. I just got the ASUS GTX 1070 STRIX for US$300.
Ok dude, you got my vote! 20 dollars difference here, so I will go for the STRIX.
I actually like that it's loaned cards. That means we don't have to scroll through the overclocking part (which differs from card to card anyway) ;)
hey tech showdown, can you do a comparison between the G1 gaming and the MSI gaming x? both 1070
I have ordered the Gigabyte GTX1070 G1 Gaming. And here in Norway it costs 100 dollar(800 NOK) less than the Strix 1070. No way if the microscopic better performance of the strix is worth 100 dollars. Shame on you ASUS for pricing your cards that high when a brand like Gigabyte make just as good products!
ollo1982 I don't think it's asus making it that expensive. Here in the US they cost the same. Must be where you live
Scratch that the asus one is 15$ more. For the RGB I'm going with the strix
ollo1982 it's probably your country not ASUS, where I am they're both currently at the exact same price
ollo1982 We're master race mate, we don't care about costs.
+ChEILoZ There is no such thing! And everyone cares about costs... can you get a GPU that is just as good as the ASUS Strix GPU for 50 bucks less,ofcourse most people will go for the cheaper card that is just as good. Gigagbyte makes fantastic stuff! ASUS is not better in any way!
The strix is $620CAD and in stock while the G1 is $580CAD but in back order, but my Zalman Z11 case can only fit a 290mm card, so I have to wait for the G1 to be back in stock, can't get the strix which seems a bit better :(
Hey dude i'm from NZ too, graphic cards are too expensive here. But i found 1070 G1 for $750 NZD
I love you man!!! Thanks for show the temperature!!! :D
What about EVGA's 1070? Not better to wait for the good models?
yes ! a fucking new zealand tech channel
Even if both cards were identical in performance, temps and price I
would buy the ROG Strix over the G1 gaming as I cant stand the fact that
Gigabyte insisted on including stupid ass red accent lines on the front
of its cooler and that would sit totally out of place with allot of
people's colour scheme.
Dimensions would be nice, as I have come across conflicting information more than once when trying to find a card's dimensions. Getting a final answer from someone who has the card(s) in hand and took a measuring tape to them is very useful.
To anyone who says that's "boring", no shit. Information comes first in content like this.
You won't damage either one of the cards by overclocking them in due part to NVIDIA's Greenlight program. The max voltage for a GTX 1070 is 1.09v, which cannot be surpassed without a Bios or hard mod.
Is this Strix, from comparison video, the STRIX-GTX1070-O8G-GAMING version? The OC Edition with 1860 MHz boost?
Hello,
after the many reviews i came to the conclusion that all of the manufacturers and variants from the same manufacturer are pretty identical
the difference is
1) in cheapest models there could not be backplate - this is important
2) the different highlighting - up to me this is not important
3) 2-3 fans and different radiators configuration
4) manufacturer overclocked from the box (but the same i can do and manually with the soft, right, so no reasons to overpay for what they did from the box ?)
5) one card looks faster than another simply because one model is a bit overclocked from the box than another, i didnt see yet that slower 1070 card won few FPS over another 1070 abit overclocked from the box because has better components or smth. else , NO a bit overclocked from the box always wins and im sure if you overclock the slower one to the frequency of the faster one they will show the same results, what do you think ?
so few FPS shouldnt be counted at all
6) silence and temperature could be measured when both works on the same frequencies, so you need to overclock the slower to the frequencies of the faster one, in this case we can really compare how much one cooling system works better than another and in this case i believe difference could be higher that 1 degree or 1 db
unfortunately no one of the reviewers do not place different similar chip cards in similar circumstances :(
very few observers shows us the cooling system in disassembled way, so we can see the radiators size, what kind of components these radiators cover, if pipes have direct connection to the GPU (like in gigabite G1) or through the metal plate (like in msi gaming X), no body says us about the construction of the fans used, how many balls used and so on may influence to the noise in future and life time of the fans at all.
without all these details and identical circumstances (in matter of frequencies) comparing to cards is meaningless.
for example overclocked from the box card will be faster than less overclocked but the same time it will be heating harder as a results fans could produce more noise
how you could compare such a cards and say that one is more silent or another has higher temperature or shows better FPS ?
waiting for the MSI - ASUS comparison because MSI more silent than Gigabyte (because 2 bigger fans more silent than 3 smaller) and could be overclocked better than Giga
as well as waiting for EVGA about which very low information
and i hope you will compare the rest cards in the similar circumstances, give us more details about radiators and fans and will compare on the same frequencies :)
what about version 2 of this comparison ? :) any ways thanks and like, good job and waiting for more manufacturers compared :)
Bought both of the cards. Asus came out 50$ less expensive for O8C version than G1. Performance of both cards is similar. However, G1 looks and feels really cheap vs Asus. The cooler on G1 is tiny compared to strix. Fans look pretty brittle and cheap too. For the amount of money spent ASUS is a much better choice.
Is that the oc edition for asus strix kinda confused with the oc and non oc edition cause I heard the non oc has no rgb lights on it how true it is just curious
i have a question for you tech showdown please can you do a video on a gtx 1070 with a intel core 2 duo iv'e been thinking of upgrading my work computer into a gaming pc
which card would you get if the price is around the same in my country?
1) Asus PCI-Ex GeForce GTX 1070 ROG Strix 8GB GDDR5 (256bit) (1506/8000) (DVI, 2 x HDMI, 2 x DisplayPort) (STRIX-GTX1070-8G-GAMING)
2) Gigabyte PCI-Ex GeForce GTX 1070 Windforce OC 8GB GDDR5 (256bit) (1556/8008) (DVI, HDMI, 3 x DisplayPort) (GV-N1070WF2OC-8GD)
and finally if I am there to choose g1 gaming of GTX 1070 (10-20$ more) how much it will be faster in comparison to Asus Rog Strix, not in the Overclocked edition.
Hello, is this asus strix 1070 OC or non OC?
gigabyte pcb looks kinda "deformed" by the backplate screws...is it a worthy matter ?
Is that the Strix OC edition?
+Tech Showdown I am about to buy a card and i am very confused which is better as the prices almost so close on Amazon now ( only 6 USD difference ) which isn't a big deal , between MSI gaming ( without X ) GTX 1070 or Gigabyte G1 gaming GTX 1070 ? or should i get the X version ?
Gigabyte seems to be faster core clock out of the box but had very loud and noisy fans and cheap plastic design compared to last gen and so many people RMA their cards because of that , while this one despite being too strong and aesthetically more appealing , has bigger memory clock which has no significant effect on performance and seems struggling to increase with core clock despite it have two power cords 6+8 pins and consumer too much power than Gigabyte which seems a huge let down compared to the results i have seen, it should beat Gigabyte in terms of speed but it didn't
Can you please make a video comparing those two exact models because seems like the whole internet has no one ever thing to compare such relatively close rivalry cards before, Cheers and keep up the good work
The beard! Nice vid man!
nice video man. simple and informative
What are the settings on Heaven ? I usually run with,
Directx 11
Quality = ultra
Tessellation = extreme
Anti Aliasing = x8
Res = 1920 x 1080
I've hit 80.0 fps with and OC'd gtx980 hybrid and about 73fps when its stock, looking for an upgrade.
Ambient temperature? It's important to have the actual Delta Tº
Got the Strix on sale for $449 USD, totally worth it.
Which is value for money Asus Strix 1070 or strix 1070 oc..because i can't understand between two products..is this only base clock and boost clock defference or any other deference between two models....because some people telling about this two product they all have done 2100mhz during overclock using gpu tweek software... so why should i buy this oc version paying 20$ more than normal version?Give me an valuable feedback
Awesome, a Kiwi... I got the gigabyte card form PB tech in Hams. Major problem getting the bloody led's to work. Had it for a month and still no go
hey bro try installing the gigabyte software for the card off their website the lights wont work without it ive heard im about to install a g1 1070 tommorow so ill tell you how i go
I have, also reinstalled windows and everything, Gigabyte cant solve it either, pretty fucked off about it
gigabyte got hold of me. it's going back under warranty
And now the second card has fucked out!!! Dont buy the G1 card its shit. Plenty of cooling and both screens stopped working. Going back again!!!! Getting a refund this time and going for the strix
Hi, I have a question that I would really appreciate any help with answering. Firstly for context, I'm considering purchasing a new gpu but possibly waiting until holiday specials. I currently own a Gigabyte gtx 670 which may be now showing issues. My question primarily is with what perfromance and energy consumption differences i might expect between my 670 and a 960ti or 1060 please? Also, in a lesser note, when it comes to the big bwo competitors, even though Nvidia has seemingly been solid for me, I refuse to be a complete fan boy and shall listen to any advice also. Thank you to anyone who reads this and bothers to reply! :)
949$ for the 1070 Strix? In germany we pay around 550$! (~490€uro)
Thank you, really help me to choose the best option for me. Greetings from Mexico.
asus apology strix is the standard version or the version OC
One of these, or MSI Gaming X?
Hello,thx for comparative.Can you test the different configuration output vidéo on multiscreen,with card double dvi output,and card simple dvi,to see the difference Hertz maximum capable on multiscreen dvi+dvi and dvi+hdmi or DP?I think architecture is different for that and big economy due to that less one dvi output.Thereby justifying the lower production cost, not an effort to nvidia on its fine engraving and price or not on this.
Hey bro, would you recommend the gigabyte gtx 1070 xtreme gaming edition over these?
I will let you know when I start testing it which will be soon hopefully, just got a bunch of RX480 and 1060 content to get through too!
Awesome :) thanks!
i want a g1 instead of a strix rog as my case h440 is a couple milaitres off but i dont like the colour any advice for painting it
Did you put the STRIX in OC mode?
dam how bigger is the 1070 strix compare to the 1070 gaming X Twin Frozr i only got the gaming x twin frozr but i have order the strix 1070 i just hope it can fit in my case i just hope its a little bigger just a little compare to the gaming x
The G1 is 20Euros Cheaper in Portugal. I think its safe to say that the Strix is the better option
Iv just had to RMA the G1 gaming , i was getting black screens ( running dual monitors ) after gaming , i could game for anywhere between 10 mins and an hour , but if i rebooted the PC i would get no display at all , had to move the card down to the PCIE x8 slot to get a display , but again the problem would repeat it self after a reboot and i would have to move the card back up to the x16 slot to get a signal again ,
have you tried running dual monitors ? do you get the same problem as mine did?
i just hope it was a dodgy card and it's not the same across the line of G1 gaming 1070's . as it was/is a bloody good card .
Both of these cards are on Amazon for the same price here in the US in case anyone is looking as of 9/6/16
Hey Kev, it would be nice if you did ROG 1060 vs. ROG 1070 showdown!
Yes I will be doing 1060 showdown's soon, just making sure I get appropriate models, lots of reviewers are testing non-reference 1060's vs reference 480's and that isn't fair so I am going to wait until I can get a founders edition 1060 to put up against my reference 480, that way it is 100% fair!
Nice, waiting for that, even tho i'm more interested in 1070, which i will be getting soon. 480 vs 1060 isn't that much of a competition imo, AMD just lost for now, in every way imaginable. As for an idea, you can do triple NVIDIA showdown, for example ROG 1080 vs. 1070 vs. 1060, just to see how much "space" is between them and determine for which resolutions are every one of them appropriate. As a see it atm:
GTX 1060- Very High end 1080p gaming, medium level 2k gaming
GTX 1070- Super very high end 1080p gaming, high end 2k gaming, medium 4k gaming
GTX 1080- Overkill for 1080p, super high end on 2k, high end on 4k
RX 480- High end 1080p, low to medium 2k gaming
Can u buy urself a mic ? 30$ are enough bro.. just do it
If he has enough money to get these GPUs he should just pick up something like an AT2035
read the description
If you paid any attention, you would hear him say: "They're borrowed"...
Got my 1070 strix and it's amazing, can only recomend .
I've gotten 2100+ on my overclock though i keep it at around 2088 no problem when playing games for long periods. fans never go over 50% so pretty much inaudible in my h440 case. pushing the fans to 100% makes it sound like a jet taking off, i guess if you want the most cooling and noise isn't an issue you could get better clocks.
Never personally been a fan of Gigabyte and usually go with EVGA. Running the FTW 1070 atm and i think its pretty much on par if not better than these two. 459$
The strix actually runs much cooler. If ambient is 21-22c, expect the strix to run 62-63c at load. Most Evga 1070's run in the 70's. Evga has way better support though.
hi, the asus is the oc version?
My G1 isn't silent at all when going full load when compared to my old asus 280x
how did u controlled the rgb lighting on asus motherboard?? i have asus prime z and the rgb fusion app is showing nothing
STRIX wins hands down in cooling, the cooling design on the STRIX does not play around in that.
As the time I typing this, it's $850 on Playtech for the Strix vs the $830 for the G1 Gaming, and since I have a ROG mobo, I guess I'll go with the Strix.
dont want to spend extra 50$ for the asus strix idk if I should get the g1 gaming i heard the fans are cheap
I've been seeing this card on eBay for about $350 and lower. I'm just being patient until I see one for $300 or less then I'll buy one.
man, u really gotta say that huh? now they are almost 600 and nvidia keep raising the price cuz AMD did pretty bad
Zotac AMP extreme 1070 vs Asus Strix 1070 which is better?
how do you keep your system so clean?!
could you please do a video of you playing rainbow 6 seige with the strix 1070?
if its 30$ more expensive is it worth then ?