Very pleased with the outcome of this case however, the plaintiff was less credible than the defendant. Judge had no reason to talk to her like that the company fired him for a reason it’s not her fault if so, she would’ve been fired too.
I def get vibes from the plaintiff that he's rude and disrespectful. That won't work on everyone sir. Some people will not tolerate disrespect, regardless of your position in the workplace.
I thought the same because he kept pronouncing her name differently. That's so disrespectful. He worked with her for a while so he knows how her name is pronounced.
I have had managers like him and worse throughout my work career. You give a nobody a little bit of power/authority and they freaking abuse it! I hope the defendant is doing well. 🙂
The wife said he called her and said, I’m fine just go. That’s why she got out the car and went back in. He said he called her to pick him up. Why say I’m fine just go to someone that’s supposed to pick you up? THAT WAS A THREAT TO FIGHT HER!
He wasn't just fired for this one reason; this was just the final straw. Human Resources been silently building a case based on his previous complaints/behaviors. Glad they got rid of him and I don't even work there 😅
Agree, I see straight through him and his wife. I believe this man was extremely disrespectful. Many mangers treat there workers wrong, and some would curse you out because they feel they're above you and they want get fired. I totally believe everything that young lady said about him.
The wife put the nail in his coffin. The wife isn't bright. She should have never asked to speak if she wasn't following her husband's words. They should have rehearsed more at home or never even tried to sue.
The wife testified that he called her and said, “I’m fine. Just go.”That’s why she got out the car and went back in. He testified that he called his wife to pick him up. Why say I’m fine just go to someone that’s supposed to pick you up? THAT WAS A THREAT TO FIGHT HER!
The wife actually tried to cover for him but he already said what went down so one of them would have been lying but it didn’t matter because he already put the nail in his coffin
Usually when investigations take place someone is talking to management on the down low. Someone told the district manager---in private----about the plaintiff's behaviors. That's why he was fired. And frankly, the defendant came off as much more credible anyway.
I definitely believe the plaintiff threatened to slap her. He further tried threatening her with his wife to scare her. He knew THAT was the reason he was fired as JM stated. That’s the reason he tried to fancy up the lie about he didn’t want to argue with a woman so he called his wife. Puuuhleasee. Your manager above you is a woman so he could’ve taken it to her.
JM asking the defendant did she abide by the process?…she only did what the store manager said…answer these questions & boom he was fired! I believe things went down just so! The plaintiff may have had other complaints in, for them to fire him like that. Ijs 🤔
The judge treated the defendant so wrong. He reads facial expression completely the wrong way. I believe the defendant was telling the truth she didnt stumble over one word when she told her side, she only did what HER manager instructed her to do. He's talking to her like she works in management or HR and should know this.
I so believe the defendant…JM was looking for a reason to believe this lying a$$ dude bc he “worked” his way up to store mgr like that means something 🙄
Why do you black women love to belittle a black man when he works? I suppose if he was a drug dealer or a felon without a job you’d be praising him. The level of triflingness today is quite sad. 🙄
@@Nevaeh1 ma’am, with all due respect, BS. This lady attempted to disparage this man which by the way is quite common with a lot of you and your “sistas.” Go attempt to fool someone else gullible. 🙄
There is a lot of women just like the defendant lying to get someone fired because they’re in their feelings. This is the behavior of a toxic bitter women that many of my brothers have to deal with constantly. This is why I only hire men when I make hiring decisions. 🙄
@@alexissimmons2597 I’m admitting I don’t hire women because of toxic, bitter behaviors that drag into the workplace. Have you seen the behaviors of your “sistas?” I have plenty of videos I can show you to um perhaps wake you up. 🙄
I used to be a big fan of mathis but time and time again he lets his feelings overshadow the actual evidence. In this case it was a he said she said. There was no evidence either way but still proceeded to cut down the defendant from the beginning. Thats a problem.
@webster2086 just because she takes a minute to answer a question does not mean she's lieing. Mathis likes to talk over people and ask multiple questions fast before letting someone explain.
I could tell this man was lying from a mile away. Cuz if someone is trying to avoid an incident they walk away! Then he tried to lie about why he had his wife come to the store… like be for real. I hope this is a learning lesson for the both of them about professionalism and how to conduct yourself at work. For example why would people assume that you and your family planned to steal a purse? I dislike some people I’ve worked with as well but you would never suspect it.
How JM gon tell the defendant to sue the employer for taking her off the schedule because of their "due process" but not tell the Plaintiff he had to sue the employer for "wrongful termination"?
I believe the defendant even tho she was a bit shakey in the Beginning.The wife is just as slow as her husband!!!! JM wanted to look out for homeboy but he had no choice to side with the defendant!!!!
Aw, she was about to tell Judge Mathis that her mom loves him. Judge was very impatient with the defendant. I also don’t understand why it’s so hard to believe he would call her a b word or threaten her infront of customers 🤔
Did you see how she was standing facing the defendant at the end? She was trying to intimidate the defendant. She definitely came to that store to fight. It’s really trifling to call your wife to fight and she brought the three kids along. SMDH
Judge started off acting like an asshole! He yelling at the girl and over talking her then Gonna ask why she hesitate to answer!! Judge might have had a bad day or something he lashing out like a fool!
Judge Mathis acts so stupid sometimes. If she didn’t go through the process, then that means the district manager had more than enough means to believe that he acted in the wrong and let him go anyway. Again, happy that the snatched his ass off the air.
Whatever. I believe the defendant. The plaintiff comes off as polite in court however, we know that he is not like that on a day-to-day basis. I’m sure he does call those women bitches, and then I guarantee you he threatened to slap her in front of people. she should’ve had witness statements or something like that, but probably people were afraid to lose their jobs or be involved you know how that goes. And his wife had no business speaking, because she had no business coming up there, unless she is an employee on the clock that same day, so she’s irrelevant. I believe the defendant. I just think that she was a little overwhelmed a bit by judge Mathis and I think when she first spoke, she was about to say something about it was an honor or a pleasure to meet him, or to be in his courtroom, but as soon as she started speaking, he immediately cut her off and got into the case and didn’t let her give any background on herself, so Judge Mathis is being a little overbearing And over-talkative of people as he usually does. Maybe his back was hurting in this case, but I’m glad the plaintiff didn’t get anything, but I think the defendant should have been awarded something, but I think she would have needed more evidence. (just the fact of him calling his wife up there {of course to whoop her ass} should show that he’s a liar anyway)
Mathis is not a judge. He’s an arbitrator. He can’t arrest anyone. I would cuss his ass out. I would love to see all the cases I didn’t make it to TV because people were checking him and he was too embarrassed to release it
The defendant just needed to be a little more clearer when getting asked questions. That’s why the judge was getting irritated with her. And as far as the plaintiff, his wife was better off not speaking. She made things worse for his case. Just ghetto SMH.
I do believe he threatened to slap her. And I don't know why the judge felt like she was being defensive I don't feel like she was I feel like she told her side of the story
JM was being rude to her, I believe her. I think he did say "he would have his wife to come smack her." She wasn't acting defensive at all. The judge must've been PMS'ing that day.
Any man working around women in any workplace environment needs to be very careful working around them. They can take any little thing the wrong way and cry to HR, which is the Police BTW int eh workplace environment. Best to just keep it strictly professional with them at all times and don't drop your guard around them.
You nailed it 💯 on the head your gonna be in the wrong regardless and that even if you complement them sex harassment dawg if you do and dawg if you don't Shout out to the 🤡
I can't stand JM, the defendant was telling the truth, he just wanted this man to win because he worked his way up. Judge Mathis needs to smoke more weed and stay calm.
He bought this on himself! you can’t call your wife up to the job ; that’s basically a threat . i’m not getting why judge mathis is acting like he was right in doing that.
The plaintiff is dead wrong why would u try to sue the defendant over something you did wrong & something u created it makes no sense u should of never threatened her in the first place as a manager that is so unprofessional…smhhhh ‼️
Why the wife acting as if she’s won a prize? I believe the defendant 100%. JM needs to stop emphasizing with folks and treating their adversaries as if they are not credible because he has feelings for the other
This young lady is confused why Judge Mathis is coming at her like that, and I'm confused too. He has no idea what goes on in these types of industries. Everything isn't always documented. People have friends amongst their employees and co-workers and they don't want to go through the trouble of the paperwork. Judge Mathis doesn't really rule by the law. At least Judge Judy tries to.
Very pleased with the outcome of this case however, the plaintiff was less credible than the defendant. Judge had no reason to talk to her like that the company fired him for a reason it’s not her fault if so, she would’ve been fired too.
Not the wife being proud to be a part of this drama 😂
With the kids in the backseat at that. 🤦🏽♂
I def get vibes from the plaintiff that he's rude and disrespectful. That won't work on everyone sir. Some people will not tolerate disrespect, regardless of your position in the workplace.
I thought the same because he kept pronouncing her name differently. That's so disrespectful. He worked with her for a while so he knows how her name is pronounced.
Definitely get those vibes!! How JM didn’t I don’t understand smh
I have had managers like him and worse throughout my work career. You give a nobody a little bit of power/authority and they freaking abuse it!
I hope the defendant is doing well. 🙂
The wife said he called her and said, I’m fine just go. That’s why she got out the car and went back in. He said he called her to pick him up. Why say I’m fine just go to someone that’s supposed to pick you up? THAT WAS A THREAT TO FIGHT HER!
How is calling your wife for confrontation avoiding confrontation?
By telling her I’m not going to argue with you. I’ll call my wife
He wasn't just fired for this one reason; this was just the final straw. Human Resources been silently building a case based on his previous complaints/behaviors. Glad they got rid of him and I don't even work there 😅
Agree, I see straight through him and his wife. I believe this man was extremely disrespectful. Many mangers treat there workers wrong, and some would curse you out because they feel they're above you and they want get fired. I totally believe everything that young lady said about him.
What?😂
agreed
The wife put the nail in his coffin. The wife isn't bright. She should have never asked to speak if she wasn't following her husband's words. They should have rehearsed more at home or never even tried to sue.
The wife testified that he called her and said, “I’m fine. Just go.”That’s why she got out the car and went back in. He testified that he called his wife to pick him up. Why say I’m fine just go to someone that’s supposed to pick you up? THAT WAS A THREAT TO FIGHT HER!
Right.
@@conniechoward Because he's a liar.
The both act slow to me 😂
The wife actually tried to cover for him but he already said what went down so one of them would have been lying but it didn’t matter because he already put the nail in his coffin
Usually when investigations take place someone is talking to management on the down low. Someone told the district manager---in private----about the plaintiff's behaviors. That's why he was fired. And frankly, the defendant came off as much more credible anyway.
He called his big linebacker up there to jump out and back in the car threatening her with the kids in back!!
😂😂😂😂
But yet black women should be fit, feminine and submissive but this woman was anything but
😂
Why was JM talking to the defendant like that 😕
The way he was treating her....omg!
Because the dude got fired and he was proud of him
Facts..smh he been messy akot lately.. what's going on w him..smdh!!
@@dollasava9635Bingo! Lol he praised him up so he had to keep boosting
Imagine getting all 3 of your kids dressed shoes on coats hats on piled on the car to fight?!?!?!?! 😂😂😂 a fool and a mess
I believe the defendant on this one that’s why he was terminated. His wife really messed up his case by lying.
I definitely believe the plaintiff threatened to slap her. He further tried threatening her with his wife to scare her. He knew THAT was the reason he was fired as JM stated. That’s the reason he tried to fancy up the lie about he didn’t want to argue with a woman so he called his wife. Puuuhleasee. Your manager above you is a woman so he could’ve taken it to her.
👏👏👏
JM asking the defendant did she abide by the process?…she only did what the store manager said…answer these questions & boom he was fired! I believe things went down just so! The plaintiff may have had other complaints in, for them to fire him like that. Ijs
🤔
The judge treated the defendant so wrong. He reads facial expression completely the wrong way. I believe the defendant was telling the truth she didnt stumble over one word when she told her side, she only did what HER manager instructed her to do. He's talking to her like she works in management or HR and should know this.
I so believe the defendant…JM was looking for a reason to believe this lying a$$ dude bc he “worked” his way up to store mgr like that means something 🙄
Why do you black women love to belittle a black man when he works? I suppose if he was a drug dealer or a felon without a job you’d be praising him. The level of triflingness today is quite sad. 🙄
@@Nevaeh1 ma’am, with all due respect, BS. This lady attempted to disparage this man which by the way is quite common with a lot of you and your “sistas.” Go attempt to fool someone else gullible. 🙄
You just want to side with the female because she is a female...SMH
I believe the Judge as well, because he uses actual logic when making decisions.
Agreed!
@timothy huh? Yall sistas? Huh? Self hate is real!
What the hell is going on at that store with all this drama..arguing and purses getting stolen and all these altercations???
Same thing I thought lol smh
I was wondering what store it would be. Maybe Family Dollar?
@@lala95jRight!😂😂😂
Lol or dollar general 😂😂@lala95j
I believed the defendant in this particular case. She just came off a little more believable than the plaintiff did. Just me
True she was truthful about what she did and everything
There is a lot of women just like the defendant lying to get someone fired because they’re in their feelings. This is the behavior of a toxic bitter women that many of my brothers have to deal with constantly. This is why I only hire men when I make hiring decisions. 🙄
@@timothyjacob6381So you admittedly discriminate against women in the hiring process because of past experiences?
Setting that aside, this one I actually believe.
@@alexissimmons2597 I’m admitting I don’t hire women because of toxic, bitter behaviors that drag into the workplace. Have you seen the behaviors of your “sistas?” I have plenty of videos I can show you to um perhaps wake you up. 🙄
He knows his wife is HUGE! Ofc he called her up there
For certain.
Valid point 😢
I don't get it
I heard she has a preliminary tryout for the WWE!! 🤔 ⚖️
@@isiahwarner3087 Lol.
JM so quick to judge off EMOTIONS SMFH
Right he was talking to the defendant, like she was an ingrate.
How would she know what HR said to him? The judge is as wrong.
Naw buddy definitely did what she said.
I used to be a big fan of mathis but time and time again he lets his feelings overshadow the actual evidence. In this case it was a he said she said. There was no evidence either way but still proceeded to cut down the defendant from the beginning. Thats a problem.
She started off sounding like a liar.
Valid points indeed 😢
@webster2086 just because she takes a minute to answer a question does not mean she's lieing. Mathis likes to talk over people and ask multiple questions fast before letting someone explain.
@@Angel-zs9zb Right! Because she was actually answering him, he was just cutting her off. It was weird
But the husband and wife had two different stories.
I could tell this man was lying from a mile away. Cuz if someone is trying to avoid an incident they walk away! Then he tried to lie about why he had his wife come to the store… like be for real. I hope this is a learning lesson for the both of them about professionalism and how to conduct yourself at work. For example why would people assume that you and your family planned to steal a purse? I dislike some people I’ve worked with as well but you would never suspect it.
Lol and I thought my workplace was a mess!
How JM gon tell the defendant to sue the employer for taking her off the schedule because of their "due process" but not tell the Plaintiff he had to sue the employer for "wrongful termination"?
Why isn’t he suing his employer for a wrongful termination
Seriously.
Cause I believe he's lying
@@williamharris5976 your right… that’s the long and the short answer.
I kept listening for him to expand on this.
11:25 glad he told his wife to be quiet 😮
The plaintiff is definitely lying
I believe the defendant even tho she was a bit shakey in the Beginning.The wife is just as slow as her husband!!!! JM wanted to look out for homeboy but he had no choice to side with the defendant!!!!
Aw, she was about to tell Judge Mathis that her mom loves him. Judge was very impatient with the defendant. I also don’t understand why it’s so hard to believe he would call her a b word or threaten her infront of customers 🤔
Ur wife lost the case for you boo boo 😂😂😂
The way Judge Mathis spoke to this young lady was cringy.
This is giving Family Dollar energy
😂😂
YOOOOOOOO HAHAHAHAHAHA you are dead wrong. Dont act like you aint never bought nothing from the family dollar 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😹😹😹
Yes😂
@@agchitty😂😂there’s a difference between shopping there and fighting there
I guess he had issues with other people not just her
He knows he lied and his own wife told on him.
They were looking for reason to fired that guy. If the young lady register came up short several times they would have terminated her.
It’s always best to walk away from the mess…
I believe the defendant
Everyone did except JM 🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️ he was trippin hard
She looks like she will attack. Thats his muscle
😂😂😂😂
Did you see how she was standing facing the defendant at the end? She was trying to intimidate the defendant. She definitely came to that store to fight. It’s really trifling to call your wife to fight and she brought the three kids along. SMDH
Judge Mathis on his period again
He always is..
😂
🤣😢
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
You made me choke on my grits this morning!!!! 😩
Judge started off acting like an asshole! He yelling at the girl and over talking her then Gonna ask why she hesitate to answer!! Judge might have had a bad day or something he lashing out like a fool!
Judge Mathis acts so stupid sometimes. If she didn’t go through the process, then that means the district manager had more than enough means to believe that he acted in the wrong and let him go anyway. Again, happy that the snatched his ass off the air.
Judge Mathis does get on my nerves sometimes. Yeah he did threaten to slap her in front of customers. He probably hit his wife too.
Many male managers treat their subordinates with disrespect and also may sexually harass them.
Why I feel like y'all work at Ross dress for less 😂😂😂
Wife should have kept quiet.
Her statement was irrelevant.
I think it was her attitude toward JM that messed her case up
She didn't have a bad attitude. She. just looks that way. LOL I also think she was a little intimidated.
I'm here My Beloved Favorite Judge ***ASHAY ***
Managerial Mayhem…me sending passive aggressive emails to my corporate nemesis all day.
😂
They must work at Fridays or something 🤣
Plaintiff is a liar.
Both of them should've been fired.
Whatever. I believe the defendant. The plaintiff comes off as polite in court however, we know that he is not like that on a day-to-day basis. I’m sure he does call those women bitches, and then I guarantee you he threatened to slap her in front of people. she should’ve had witness statements or something like that, but probably people were afraid to lose their jobs or be involved you know how that goes.
And his wife had no business speaking, because she had no business coming up there, unless she is an employee on the clock that same day, so she’s irrelevant.
I believe the defendant. I just think that she was a little overwhelmed a bit by judge Mathis and I think when she first spoke, she was about to say something about it was an honor or a pleasure to meet him, or to be in his courtroom, but as soon as she started speaking, he immediately cut her off and got into the case and didn’t let her give any background on herself, so Judge Mathis is being a little overbearing And over-talkative of people as he usually does. Maybe his back was hurting in this case, but I’m glad the plaintiff didn’t get anything, but I think the defendant should have been awarded something, but I think she would have needed more evidence.
(just the fact of him calling his wife up there {of course to whoop her ass} should show that he’s a liar anyway)
Mathis gang roll call 🤙
Mathis is not a judge. He’s an arbitrator. He can’t arrest anyone. I would cuss his ass out. I would love to see all the cases I didn’t make it to TV because people were checking him and he was too embarrassed to release it
I didn’t even think of that…the cases that didn’t make it to tv 😂
😂 I can’t stand him
😂
The defendant just needed to be a little more clearer when getting asked questions. That’s why the judge was getting irritated with her. And as far as the plaintiff, his wife was better off not speaking. She made things worse for his case. Just ghetto SMH.
WTFFFF is wrong with this judge???
The plaintiff says Uhhh 500 times
& ofcourse its a big funky cosplaying as a black woman lil white girl as his wife. Never fails.
I suspect he doesn't like black women. I can believe he disrespects his black female employees.
Exactly! 💯 Typical.
This was just a royal MESS. That man was just🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
The wife said she just straight lied in the courtroom; she did too
Feels like they're been told off by the CEO of the company 😂
I do believe he threatened to slap her. And I don't know why the judge felt like she was being defensive I don't feel like she was I feel like she told her side of the story
Where did they work at? Sounds like there was constant drama! I believe the defendant! The plaintiff looks like he did and said all that!!
Why did he ,call his wife. So he knew he was wrong.
They must’ve had enough evidence Human Resources don’t fire you for nothing he’s lying
I wonder how many times the plaintiff has to spell his name when asked?
Haitian.
That YEEEESSS took me out 😂
JM was being rude to her, I believe her. I think he did say "he would have his wife to come smack her." She wasn't acting defensive at all. The judge must've been PMS'ing that day.
Any man working around women in any workplace environment needs to be very careful working around them.
They can take any little thing the wrong way and cry to HR, which is the Police BTW int eh workplace environment.
Best to just keep it strictly professional with them at all times and don't drop your guard around them.
You nailed it 💯 on the head your gonna be in the wrong regardless
and that even if you complement them sex harassment dawg if you do and dawg if you don't
Shout out to the 🤡
I want to know what store it is so I'll know not to go there.
If you close your eyes, you'll see Bryson Tiller. Husband sounds just like him 😅
Of course that's what his wife looks like 😂😂😂
Embarrassing....😂😂😂😂 he should have just let this go and get another job.😂😂😂 The wife😂😂😂😂😂. Oh lawd you can't make this stuff up.
I can't stand JM, the defendant was telling the truth, he just wanted this man to win because he worked his way up. Judge Mathis needs to smoke more weed and stay calm.
Is this why Mrs. Mathis is throwing up the Deuces Deuces!✌️#inmychrisbrown voice
Best way to get into management is to find out who management doesn’t like and get them fired
There sure is a lot of drama in the dollar stores 😂
Now I'm REALLY Curious as 2 WHAT STORE is dis?! Location?!
All dis Nonsense!!
He definitely did what she said at work.
I definitely believe the defendant I know men like this, 1 complaint without an proof does not get you fired
Exactly. I've went to MANY Fast Food Places & heard the Workers cursing up a Storm! It was tacky, ratchet People so that made me leave.
He bought this on himself! you can’t call your wife up to the job ; that’s basically a threat . i’m not getting why judge mathis is acting like he was right in doing that.
Neither one of them had a case to begin with
The plaintiff is dead wrong why would u try to sue the defendant over something you did wrong & something u created it makes no sense u should of never threatened her in the first place as a manager that is so unprofessional…smhhhh ‼️
The plaintiff looks like the type to get into with women. Glad the case got dismissed
If she came for lunch why would she leave?
Why the wife acting as if she’s won a prize? I believe the defendant 100%. JM needs to stop emphasizing with folks and treating their adversaries as if they are not credible because he has feelings for the other
He was treating the defendant wrong.
JM smh I think I can be a better judge , this is ridiculous.
Wife should’ve kept her mouth shut
I hate to say I I’ve worked with my share of unpolished women and if you tell them anything their temper or lies come out depending on their trauma
Whew Chi this is deep SMH
Judge on one of his hate women days.
How/why would the defendant write up her superior? JM got that all wrong.
This young lady is confused why Judge Mathis is coming at her like that, and I'm confused too. He has no idea what goes on in these types of industries. Everything isn't always documented. People have friends amongst their employees and co-workers and they don't want to go through the trouble of the paperwork. Judge Mathis doesn't really rule by the law. At least Judge Judy tries to.
Judge Mathis is full of it.
He should have been fired.
Sounds like Judge almost said you people @ 1:55