Yes. I remember I listened to this interpretation years ago, and then I listened to other conductors, which are also amazing, but this one, this one is something beyond comprehension...
So many conductors do the end of the development of mvt 1 way too fast. It's literally the most heartbreaking moment in music and they blaze right through it. This is one of the only conductors to do it justice
최고의 비창 연주로 손꼽힐만한 연주입니다. 제가 직접 이 연주를 현장에서 봤었던 것으로 기억하는데요, 이렇게 4악장을 깊게 파고드는 연주는 잘 없는 것 같네요. 음반을 들을 때는 4악장이 분위기가 무거워서 끝까지 잘 안 듣게 되는 악장이었는데 이 연주 실황으로 보면서 4악장이 이런 악장이었구나 하고 감탄하며 새로운 세계를 발견 한 것 같았던 그 느낌이 기억이 나네요.. 이 시절 정명훈선생님과 서울시향의 연주를 라이브로 자주 볼 수 있었던 것이 엄청난 행운이었던 것 같아요.
I have heard #6 many times by many different orchestras. But this one brings Tchaikovsky to a new realm of Heaven. I think the conductor was crying, just as I am at the music and the performance. Thank you. A great gift from Seoul.
this piece is just... devastating. always makes me cry real grown man tears. god bless you tchaikovsky, wherever you may be; i know the hand life dealt you was fucked but you always managed to channel those emotions into some seriously moving music. thank you for all you contributed to this world.
This makes me cry. It is one of my favorite Symphonies. I watch it over and over again. I have never seen a Conductor conduct with their entire being like that. What a joy it is to behold. The story is in the Music. Very Gifted Players. 'Extreamely' tuned in. I Love you all. Abundant Thanks. From My heart to yours. Stay Blessed.
I've listened to so many Orchestra perform this piece but none does it the justice this specific orchestra does! Thank you so much for uploading this piece. One of my favorite and the most heartbreaking.
No it's not. It's just normal behaviour of civilized educated poeple at the end of a classical piece. It's rather the exception that poeple can't wait to applaud.
I have heard a lot of versions of this piece - the conductor REALLY really brings out the emotions and in such a timely based fashion, the best version I heard in probably 20 years
@@AnatoArchives You know this is a somewhat recent custom. Not long ago, people would clap between movements and, depending on the public's reaction, the movement was repeated. Don't be so hypercritical.
I fell in love with this piece performed by this orchestra when I was in the eighth grade. Still have yet to hear it be performed better than this. Still my all-time favorite piece ever. That fourth movement kills me every single time
To me few things sum up the futility of our existence like the last two minutes of Tchaikovsky's 6th. What an incredible roller coaster ride the work is is all summed up by the inevitable. Have to fight back the tears at performances, it effects me like no other piece of music.
Oh, if we could only play and enjoy once again, all of us together, the beauty and power of this soulful music, which cannot be described in words, what a happy day it would be for me!
Me, an ex classical pianist student who hasn’t taken the time to listen to classical music until college for a class: 👁👄👁 I knew I remembered liking Tchaikovsky for a reason
soul's catharsis ... a huge drama with small patches of blue sky in grey human life ... shower for brain\mind - why we came on Earth, what is the purpose of our life, why we suffering, where is a God's hand ...? ? ? fantastic masterpiece and this play! this version is the Best!
@@dynis15 my own point of view may be opposite on your's one, but sure - I have it ... one can only say that a divine spark as an art fell down from its heaven into our blind life for changing ourselves more better than all high tech ... regress
Majestic, emotional, tearful, filled with rage and passion. Art can Do so much, and tell so much. The Orchestration is a master lesson for all musicians.
I call it profoundly painful beauty incarnate. The first movement is full of such tenderness and yearning, like the musical equivalent of unrequited love.
Ante la música y el esplendor del Maestro ruso; ninguna palabra tiene sentido. ¡Su obra es inefable! Eterna. Y la interpretación de esta orquesta, es fabulosa. Mil gracias por darnos tanto dicha y, gozo espiritual.
ya he died from cholera like a week after the premiere for this symphony. it is unclear if it was suicide, but many think it was because he told the person who gave him the water that he wasn't afraid of dying, and refused to allow a doctor to check him until he could barely move. scary stuff.
@@davidraveh5966 wow, I knew that he had likely killed himself (mainly because he wasn't able of accepting his sexuality) but I had no idea about the water and the doctor stuff. Where did you get that information?
@@geronimodaloia6143 Wikipedia Biographer Alexander Poznansky writes that on 1 November 1893 [O.S. 20 October] (Wednesday) Tchaikovsky had gone to the theatre to see Alexander Ostrovsky's play The Ardent Heart. Afterwards, he went with his brother Modest, his nephew Vladimir "Bob" Davydov, the composer Alexander Glazunov, and other friends to a restaurant named "Leiner's", located in Kotomin House at Nevsky Prospekt, Saint Petersburg. During the meal, Tchaikovsky ordered a glass of water. Due to an outbreak of cholera in the city, health regulations required water served in restaurants to be boiled before being served. Tchaikovsky was told by the waiter that no boiled water was then available. He then reportedly requested cold unboiled water, which was brought. Warned by others in his party not to drink it, the composer said he did not fear contracting cholera and drank the water anyway.[1] The next morning, at Modest's apartment, Pyotr was not in the sitting room drinking tea as usual, but in bed complaining of diarrhea and an upset stomach. Modest asked about calling a doctor. Tchaikovsky refused, instead taking cod liver oil to no avail. Three days later, he was suffering from full blown cholera. His condition worsened, but he still refused to see a doctor. A doctor was finally sent for but he was not home so another one was called. The diagnosis of cholera was finally made by Dr. Lev Bertenson. In the meantime, Tchaikovsky would seem to improve but then would regress and get much worse. His kidneys began to fail. A priest was called from St. Isaac's Cathedral to administer last rites but the composer was too far gone to recognise what was going on around him. He died at 3 a.m. on 6 November 1893.[2]
@@davidraveh5966 Ok, so now I'm totally sure he did intend to kill himself. It's so sad to think that he probably took that choice because he could not live openly his sexuality, and I believe this symphony is prooved of how he was feeling. Such a tragic fourth movement is for me the best way of expressing through music how death seems to be. You know, those quiet timpani beats at the very end are like the final heartbeats of a person who is passing away. And dude, that section at 14:51 is pure depression
@@geronimodaloia6143 btw, I always considered beethovens symphony no 9 and Tchaikovsky symphony no 6 to be exact opposites. Both have four movements. With beethovens getting more depressing until the decision to live (beethoven contemplated suicide because of his deafness), and ends with the incredible decision to continue making music. Tchaikovsky wrote a symphony that got faster and more intense, up until the end, where it seems that he just had enough. Knowing the history really makes a difference in how I perceive the music.
![[공연실황] 4K | 정명훈 & 도쿄필하모닉 with 이지혜, 문태국 | Myung-Whun Chung conducts Tokyo Philharmonic Orchestra](/img/1.gif)
The best version of symphony. Many thanks for the conductor, he is great , and all players
Yes. I remember I listened to this interpretation years ago, and then I listened to other conductors, which are also amazing, but this one, this one is something beyond comprehension...
You are correct. This version is outstanding.
So many conductors do the end of the development of mvt 1 way too fast. It's literally the most heartbreaking moment in music and they blaze right through it. This is one of the only conductors to do it justice
Perhaps the best version, second only to the one by the London Philarmonic Orchestra of 1948 conducted by Sir Adrian Boult.
This is my favorite interpretation of the 6th. It should have 1 million views
Miyung Chung conduct perfectly ever ❗💟 I love this conductor
삶의 고비고비 죽고 싶은 충동에 휩싸일 때마다 4악장을 듣습니다. 이런 음율을 계속 듣고 싶은 마음에 살고 싶어지기도 하더라고요.
벌써 32년이나 잘 버텼네요.
서울시향 연주자분들과 정명훈 상임지위자께 감사드려요.
4악장을 마무리하는 지휘자님의 후두둑 옥같은 눈물 한 방울이 가슴에 퍼지네요
만만한 안생길이 그리 많을까요
돌아서 돌아서 참으며 갑시다
저도 그렇습니다. 잘 버티셨네요.
저에게도 버틸 힘이 생겼으면 좋겠습니다.
@@즐거운편지-v5t the conductor drops a tear himself 😭
@@Daniel_Official_10 It's a matter of interpretation. It could as well be a drop of sweat.
0:31 1악장 20:31 [속보] 단체로 기침이 심해
20:59 2악장 28:43 3악장 29:17 후다닥
36:53 여기서 박수를 참아내는 음잘알들 37:19 4악장
감사합니다 ㅋㅋㅋ
This is one of the greatest symphonies I have ever heard.
You should hear Gergiev! This was ok but Valry Gergiev is a god~~~
최고의 비창 연주로 손꼽힐만한 연주입니다. 제가 직접 이 연주를 현장에서 봤었던 것으로 기억하는데요, 이렇게 4악장을 깊게 파고드는 연주는 잘 없는 것 같네요. 음반을 들을 때는 4악장이 분위기가 무거워서 끝까지 잘 안 듣게 되는 악장이었는데 이 연주 실황으로 보면서 4악장이 이런 악장이었구나 하고 감탄하며 새로운 세계를 발견 한 것 같았던 그 느낌이 기억이 나네요.. 이 시절 정명훈선생님과 서울시향의 연주를 라이브로 자주 볼 수 있었던 것이 엄청난 행운이었던 것 같아요.
I have heard #6 many times by many different orchestras. But this one brings Tchaikovsky to a new realm of Heaven. I think the conductor was crying, just as I am at the music and the performance. Thank you. A great gift from Seoul.
Perfect music for the times we are living in.
Amen to that
Hi John
Amazing how a comment like this is truly timeless
this piece is just... devastating. always makes me cry real grown man tears. god bless you tchaikovsky, wherever you may be; i know the hand life dealt you was fucked but you always managed to channel those emotions into some seriously moving music. thank you for all you contributed to this world.
very well said-- my sentiments exactly
Best comment ever!
49:25 Tears dropped.. i love last few seconds of this performance waiting for spreading last sound,,
Ansik no, he’s sweating
@R.TizzleTheTVShowGuy nah man, he's crying
R.TizzleTheTVShowGuy
you doofus he’s crying
ꨄ ThatsALittleBassist there we go. Another man/women of culture as well
Let me reconcile you all. He's sweating and crying at the same time. Thanks.
This makes me cry. It is one of my favorite Symphonies. I watch it over and over again. I have never seen a Conductor conduct with their entire being like that. What a joy it is to behold. The story is in the Music. Very Gifted Players. 'Extreamely' tuned in. I Love you all. Abundant Thanks. From My heart to yours. Stay Blessed.
너무너무 출근하기 싫을때 1-4악장 완곡하면 삶의 희노애락을 느끼면서 결국 출근합니다
제가 제일 사랑하는 버전
I think the director did a very good job on this one. I respect the man
I've listened to so many Orchestra perform this piece but none does it the justice this specific orchestra does! Thank you so much for uploading this piece. One of my favorite and the most heartbreaking.
8분경부터 나오는 1악장의 메인테마... 클래식 음악사에 길이 남을 불멸의 테마일듯... 슬픔, 갈등, 고뇌... 모든 느낌을 다 떠올리게 한다..
모든 음악 통틀어서도 손꼽힐정도로 아름다운듯요...
그 메인테마를 앞뒤에서 받쳐주는 멜로디도 훌륭합니다
유튜브에서 영원히 없어지면 안되는 영상
Mere words are useless to describe the beauty of this music.
Couldn’t have said it better myself!
Oh hi again
Amen
What a deeply sad song of suffering....so beautiful and lovingly interpreted. I couldn't tear myself away.
My favourite Tchaikovsky symphony and this is surely one of the best interpretations ever. Well done, Chung Myung-Whun and Seoul Philharmonic!
정말 말이 필요 없네요! 끝에 지휘자에게서 떨어지는 땀 한 방울이 완벽한 마침표 같았습니다.
What an adventure into emotional depths where beauty and sorrow are joined.
40:44 신이나님 지휘자 계속 보고, 훙웨이황님 지휘자보다가 옆동료 호흡 같이하려고 보고. 이그렇게 멋지다.
45:55 마지막으로 주제선율. 세컨임가진님 멋진리드. 현전체 하나가됨.
오랜만에 이 버전을 찾아서 감격했어요. 이렇게 다시 보게되어 주말 아침부터 열심히 듣습니다. 우리 서울시향과 정명훈마에 화이팅입니다.~**
마지막의 그 고요함이 레전드다 ㄹㅇ
No it's not. It's just normal behaviour of civilized educated poeple at the end of a classical piece. It's rather the exception that poeple can't wait to applaud.
차이코프스키.....하...ㅠㅠ..어떻게 이런 선율을 게다가 심포니로 만들 수 있는거죠..?....하.....😭😭😭❤❤❤
The 4th movement is so heart wrenching :(
I have heard a lot of versions of this piece - the conductor REALLY really brings out the emotions and in such a timely based fashion, the best version I heard in probably 20 years
오늘은 남은 여름을 떠나보내는 마음이니까...정명훈님의 세계 제일 비창을
세 번 반복해 들어봅니다
37:00 that's very impressive no one clapped
Clapping between movements should be prohibited
W a i t -
I didn't know
Because there's a screen in front of people that says which movement that they are playing
I always almost clap after the 3rd mov.
@@AnatoArchives You know this is a somewhat recent custom. Not long ago, people would clap between movements and, depending on the public's reaction, the movement was repeated.
Don't be so hypercritical.
This will never be better than what you just witnessed. Incredible performance.
The Best version
This was indeed a very soulful (Seoul Phil) performance
Thanks Dad
@@Silverhineko- lol
I fell in love with this piece performed by this orchestra when I was in the eighth grade. Still have yet to hear it be performed better than this. Still my all-time favorite piece ever. That fourth movement kills me every single time
You wont ever have a better version than this.
Really enjoy watching this Conductor.
Conducting really changes the way a symphony sounds; from length of each note to the level of articulation it’s something to marvel
Its amazingly funny when a movement ends and everybody starts suddenly dying
Except for at the end of the last movement. That was remarkable.
47:57 listen to the principal cello solo... the last of Tchaikovsky’s screams put into one instrument
Soli*
17:22 impossible to avoid that passage without falling in love with Tchaikovsky
Who's here after watching twoset conspiracies
Mee
Me
Lol I did
Me
Yes, the ending sounds like death
What a treasure of amazing music and performance! Just stunning!
To me few things sum up the futility of our existence like the last two minutes of Tchaikovsky's 6th. What an incredible roller coaster ride the work is is all summed up by the inevitable. Have to fight back the tears at performances, it effects me like no other piece of music.
Omg, the 3rd mvt, they did it!
49:26 조용한 가운데 땀방울 똑 떨어지는 거 너무 멋있네
the tear of conductor Myung-Hoon Jung at the end.. was ............ wow.... Respect for him.
49:26
That's not a tear, darling.
@@TFreckle what? You think it was sweat? There is no sweat on his face at all.
TFreckle
It’s a tear, please go somewhere else
Oh, if we could only play and enjoy once again, all of us together, the beauty and power of this soulful music, which cannot be described in words, what a happy day it would be for me!
Is that you John? Yes it is. Well then hello
Ttyl when you comment again in a month or so. Can't blame you
여러 지휘자의 비창을 들어봤지만 정명훈의 비창은 특히 더 격렬하고 깊은 좌절이 느껴짐
듣다보면 자살하기 직전의 깊은 절망이 느껴지는 것 같다
that's why we need music
49:41 "oh my god"
JC Schwartz HAHAH
What an amazing performance of an Astonishing Symphony.
Прекрасный дирижер и великолепный оркестр. Браво, Сеул.
I love the silence after the finale of this version where I need room for feeling not lightning applause.
Esta es la mejor interpretación que he escuchado de muchísimas orquestas perfect!
A sumptuous, heroic reading! How lucky for us to hear such performance. Bravi, maestro and players, both.
Me, an ex classical pianist student who hasn’t taken the time to listen to classical music until college for a class: 👁👄👁 I knew I remembered liking Tchaikovsky for a reason
This will forever have a place in my heart. To appreciate this music is to appreciate life.
By far my favourite Symphony. Can´t describe the feelings it brings me! How I envy the people who where there... I have to see it live aswell
빛나는 정명훈 마에스트로👍
FABULOUS symphony. What a tragedy.
cannot stop listening
Einfach nur wunderschön! Und auch wunderschöne Menschen! Assiaten sind wunderschöne Menschen!
Genau so wie Europäer und Schwarze..
2010 광저우 아시안게임 때 정명훈 지휘자가 취재기자들을 불러 인터뷰한 적이 있는데... 그때 처음 그를 봤다... 이후 클래식을 알게 되면서 그를 유투브에서 자주 만나고 있다. 감사할 따름이다. 예술의 전당에서 딱 한번 봤을 뿐이다.
그를 다시 보고 싶다.
This is so spectacular...I wish I had the vocabulary to express how wonderful Tahaikovsky is 😍😟
Some music is beyond what words can describe
One and only Tchaikovsky, his struggle of sexual orientation. I listen this symphony more than 300 times, never feel tired.
me too
soul's catharsis ... a huge drama with small patches of blue sky in grey human life ... shower for brain\mind - why we came on Earth, what is the purpose of our life, why we suffering, where is a God's hand ...? ? ? fantastic masterpiece and this play! this version is the Best!
майтрейя майтреевич, interesting comment, I’d like to know your view on things like that
@@dynis15 my own point of view may be opposite on your's one, but sure - I have it ... one can only say that a divine spark as an art fell down from its heaven into our blind life for changing ourselves more better than all high tech ... regress
@@illusionyx907 yes, you are right, I added a comment also to understand Tchaikovski troubled life, behind his masterpieces.
Karen Noble, You have said so
A great recording, violas are top tier quality, much commitment from the players. I Saved this post.
Majestic, emotional, tearful, filled with rage and passion. Art can Do so much, and tell so much. The Orchestration is a master lesson for all musicians.
8:08 ~ 16:16 Need I say more?
Yes, I want to say about...um..................beauty itself.
Hi yet again
I call it profoundly painful beauty incarnate. The first movement is full of such tenderness and yearning, like the musical equivalent of unrequited love.
Bravo! Bravo! Excelente , emocionante , irrepreensível apresentação
Awesome director!
I am in love with the first clarinet
I have no words for this amazing song, thank you, a big thank you, thank you so much !!!
0:07 I love how they smile at him!
maybe that woman is his daughter-in-law
Ante la música y el esplendor del Maestro ruso; ninguna palabra tiene sentido. ¡Su obra es inefable! Eterna. Y la interpretación de esta orquesta, es fabulosa. Mil gracias por darnos tanto dicha y, gozo espiritual.
Chong is the best conductor!
THANK YOU ALL 4 YOUR INSPIRING PERFORMANCE! BLESSINGS!
Absolute brilliante! Full of passion! @gbong7 Thanks for bringing it back!
I think tchaikovsky needed a hug :(
ya he died from cholera like a week after the premiere for this symphony. it is unclear if it was suicide, but many think it was because he told the person who gave him the water that he wasn't afraid of dying, and refused to allow a doctor to check him until he could barely move. scary stuff.
@@davidraveh5966 wow, I knew that he had likely killed himself (mainly because he wasn't able of accepting his sexuality) but I had no idea about the water and the doctor stuff. Where did you get that information?
@@geronimodaloia6143 Wikipedia
Biographer Alexander Poznansky writes that on 1 November 1893 [O.S. 20 October] (Wednesday) Tchaikovsky had gone to the theatre to see Alexander Ostrovsky's play The Ardent Heart. Afterwards, he went with his brother Modest, his nephew Vladimir "Bob" Davydov, the composer Alexander Glazunov, and other friends to a restaurant named "Leiner's", located in Kotomin House at Nevsky Prospekt, Saint Petersburg. During the meal, Tchaikovsky ordered a glass of water. Due to an outbreak of cholera in the city, health regulations required water served in restaurants to be boiled before being served. Tchaikovsky was told by the waiter that no boiled water was then available. He then reportedly requested cold unboiled water, which was brought. Warned by others in his party not to drink it, the composer said he did not fear contracting cholera and drank the water anyway.[1]
The next morning, at Modest's apartment, Pyotr was not in the sitting room drinking tea as usual, but in bed complaining of diarrhea and an upset stomach. Modest asked about calling a doctor. Tchaikovsky refused, instead taking cod liver oil to no avail. Three days later, he was suffering from full blown cholera. His condition worsened, but he still refused to see a doctor. A doctor was finally sent for but he was not home so another one was called. The diagnosis of cholera was finally made by Dr. Lev Bertenson. In the meantime, Tchaikovsky would seem to improve but then would regress and get much worse. His kidneys began to fail. A priest was called from St. Isaac's Cathedral to administer last rites but the composer was too far gone to recognise what was going on around him. He died at 3 a.m. on 6 November 1893.[2]
@@davidraveh5966 Ok, so now I'm totally sure he did intend to kill himself. It's so sad to think that he probably took that choice because he could not live openly his sexuality, and I believe this symphony is prooved of how he was feeling. Such a tragic fourth movement is for me the best way of expressing through music how death seems to be. You know, those quiet timpani beats at the very end are like the final heartbeats of a person who is passing away. And dude, that section at 14:51 is pure depression
@@geronimodaloia6143 btw, I always considered beethovens symphony no 9 and Tchaikovsky symphony no 6 to be exact opposites. Both have four movements. With beethovens getting more depressing until the decision to live (beethoven contemplated suicide because of his deafness), and ends with the incredible decision to continue making music. Tchaikovsky wrote a symphony that got faster and more intense, up until the end, where it seems that he just had enough. Knowing the history really makes a difference in how I perceive the music.
정명훈 is a fantastic conductor
the technique and playing quality is suberb and excellent thanks to the deligent of the orchestra.the members' harmony is a universal framelike.
this is amazing
오랜만에 들으러 왔어요
숨막힌다 들을때마다
BRAVO BRAVO BRAVO OMG THAT WAS AMAZING
what an unbearable pause at 14:50. couldnt pick a more inconvenient time.
I choked. It's also one of the best recordings I've heard of that moment...
Lol. I've gotten used to it.
I wish there was a recording as good as this with no pause
I like to think of it as the emotion being so strong in this moment, that even the recording breaks
If you’re here for the season of the worthy bunker music it’s at 10:57
Lol
세컨 부수석분 너무 아름다워요...
This performance has a lot of Seoul
The last part is very impressive.
Il maestro Chung dirige divinamente……
Wow ! Genius !
Awesome!!!
BRAVISSIMO!!!!
This symphony does not end; it dies.
47:20 The guy in the viola last desk was sleeping
Anson Lam, when it’s his turn to play, he looked like he is waking up. 😆
Yhe conductor is one of the best nowadays
Who else is here from Twoset to see how depressing the fourth movement is?
Me
In which episode was it?
Inna Sokolova I thinks it’s a video about composer conspiracies
@@octave11thpianist58 hey I subscribed to you
Came for 4th movement from twoset. Stayed for 15:00 Largamente (i think how you spell it) section.
that 4th mov is a gorgeous heart crusher
Che grande Maestro!
이젠 이시절은 절대다시돌아올수 없겠지
꿈이였던곳 안녕