I think he is right but there are other legendary singers sitting down there like Shreya mam and Shankar sir and if they are saying something then that should also be taken into consideration. Their points were also valid. When they are singing duet it's kind of a team work. So I feel it's very well carried out by Rahul. They could award maybe lesser marks to Neeti but shouldn't have created a scene.
Yes definitely what the hell is agar main by forgetting the lyrics and stopping in between not even the four lines she could sing without forgetting it is because exams are also not supposed to be like that by seeing and answering the questions by asking for the others to tell and repeat the answer of the question so he got angry at Neeti Mohan and Mika Singh for asking the next line to audience others might not accept it so that they also don't forget it because we all know that very well
@@ashishjangir88nope. If they too think singers forgetting lines is okay in a competition or balance in a duet is not necessary then their opinion doesn’t matter at all, no matter how big of a singer they are. Respect goes both ways.
What the others are failing to understand is that Shaan Sir isn't pointing out the lyrics forgetting part in particular. He was merely highlighting that it had to be a duet performance, but ended up with the guy singing most of the song, rendering that girl to almost being backing vocals. In the end the performance was great and that dude's presence of mind was good, but the whole essence of it being a duet was lost. It shows Shaan Sir's vast knowledge not just in music, but all about performance, stage presence and audience interaction.....mad respect to him
I agree Shaan was judging correctly and honestly he was not favouring anyone I think as neeti was from Shankars team hence Shankar was saying that both of them converted it into moment he was just covering up the mistake of neeti no one bothered about it but shaan did bother and was a responsible judge
@@ApunHiBhagwanjudging is not always waaah tum mumbai aa rahe ho. Its more than that. And if someone points out flaws and faults its called judgement. And he is a judge. Ego ki baat kahan se aa gayi?😂
@@RandomRUclipsEnjoyerYea, and also it's a competitive show, and the lady forgetting her lyrics just shows that the other contestants are more focused and better
Being a basketball coach I understand how Shaan must be feeling. He is fighting for the right cause and for his whole team as well. Points matter because we all put our best efforts to win.
@@noname-qq9ow jan Anu Malik Music Composer ban skta h.. Badsha aur Tony kakkar sensational singer ban skte he, selomon bhoi aue aliya bhat movie me gama gaa skte h to for Mikka xhupiya hop hoper kyu nhi ban skta😂😂😂.. Bollywoodiya me kachro ka bhandar laga hua h 1 mikka dhundhne jaoge to 1000 badshah aur mikka milege😂
Seeing Shaan and Neeti going together so well with each other on the sets of Voice India Kids..... increased my respect for both of them....none of them took this incident onto their heart..
Shaan sir's point is "this is duet performance so both must share 50-50%. But here is male part is 80% and female part is just 20% and still she didnt complete all 20% part of singing because she forgot the lyrics...and Shaan sir is saying,"He has sang 80% song and she has just 1 %"
btw.. i dare you.. If there were any other celebrity other than him, audience would have wooooed.. But it was Shaan, the legend. So people believed him, just wonder what character he possesses... hats off
Exactly. Singing compi mein song k lyrics thodi bhuloge .. aur agar bhool gaye the theek hai .. points kam milenge .. presence of mind k liye appreciation milega points nahi. Mika k argument kitna illogical tha.
Singing competition ka mera jitna limited knowledge hai usmein sirf Singing ko judge karte hai na like sur, taal , feel etc ismein agar lyrics bhul gayein ek do baar toh marks kaatneka kya criteria hai??
shaan is right. The show is not about what audience enjoy. This is a singing competition nd if you are not singing right then you should not b appreciated, lyrics are the core of a song.
But he needs to chill a bit. Yes he was right but he needs to be polite . Every judge has their opinion and they will judge according to their judgement.
All public don't know "sur - taal" it's not justice to judge the performance based on Audience. Today's singers are using softwares to mould their voice, even Salman Khan started singing, lol. If decision need to be made by Audience then why Judges?? "Judges Ghanta hilane k liyea hai kya??" Totally Agreed with Shaan.
It's really surprising how music directors like Shankar sir and himesh sir supported this incident . Even Shreya ji supported it. Shaan sir protested , but it wasn't enough. This is real competition
Unko appreciate krna chahiye tha .. contestant ko demotivated na feel ho .. jo galti ki us situation ko acche se handle kiye uske liye bahot points deduct honge which is also true. Shaan's points were actually right. Crowd ne bhi agree kiya aur even host Ayushmaan ne bhi.
Shaan is completely right. it is a great mistake if someone forgets the lyrics in a competition when you are being judged. it may be ok in a concert, because the team or audience may support him/her.
Shaan is logical and correct. You cannot consider a singer who forgets the lines and uses presence of mind to overcome the lapse to some extent, better than a singer who has sung the whole song with perfection. Anyone in place of Shaan whould be frustrated. Shankar Mahadevan was pathetic. As soon as the song was over, he started yelling 'presence of mind'.
Are you crazy? They are human beings not machines. I love Shaan but people foget lyrics to thei own songs while performing on stage. There are lots of factors, they are musicians yes, but they were also for the entertainment, one can compensate the other.
Thing is tough she forget the lyrics but they created a moment and shown the creativity so shankar ji was asking marks for that like agar 2 marks agar katte bhi hai to ek mark unke presence of mind ko bhi dena chahiye
Let's be honest it's beautiful how he improvised and Shankar ji and Shreya mam only appreciating that they also said we are not giving any extra points for that just praising the singers
Shaan sir's point is "this is duet performance so both must share 50-50%. But here is male part is 80% and female part is just 20% and still she didnt complete all 20% part of singing because she forgot the lyrics...and Shaan sir is saying,"He has sang 80% song and she has just 1 %"
Shaan has a very valid point. I've seen very good singers being sent home in song competitions when they forgot the words. Although Shaan's way of putting his point across is wrong but Mika really pushed him further. The matter was being settled when he chose to start the fight all over again.
Shaan showed a bit too anger but he is completely justified as this is not just a stage show but a competition where every little moment during the singing is judged, otherwise everyone is brilliant singer and all would stand in the same line if these mistakes are ignored and overlooked. Respect for Mahadevan sir for his so polite personality
His anger was manipulated by others. Its justified. Anyone would get frustrated if a simple and logical point is not being fathomed by ppl of same profession.
Did u not see how Shankar Mahadevan just seconds after the performance manipulated the judges saying about the presence of mind as if they had to neglect the fact that the contestant amidst the competition forgot her lyrics
Shaan was right. His anger was manipulated by all the others to show as if he was wrong. Mika is a use-n-throw-song singer, why would he argue with a better singer??? I faintly remember seeing this and getting angry for those singers who forgot the lyrics :-)
Bhai koi ye chi bol raha Ki unkon extra points do. But the way that guy helped his partner was truly amazing something you would hardly ever see again. So that spirit of helping your partner in a tough moment should be appreciated. If he had'nt done they would have end the song and that's it.But instead you got to see something spectacular.Shaan was over angry.Which was unnecessary.
Nai yaar mika ka point sahi hai... Gaane mei sirf feel hone chaiye, ek don word miss ho jaye iska matlab ye nhi hai ki hum song ko enjoy hi na kar sake.
@@dildeep01 mika was born in Durgapur, West Bengal.. And for us Bengali we appreciate music and songs. And we criticize when it's wrong in case of music!
I haven't expected a great singer like "Shreya Ghosal" defending that.. Shaan Sir is very much justified.. Shankar Sir tried to lure the judges by covering up the whole flaw with "presence of mind" and even judges agreed by nodding their heads acknowledging it .. kya qtiyapa hai.. when Shaan Sir saw things going too far.. he protested and he is right and justified !!
Nai yaar Mika ka point sahi hai... Gaane mei sirf feel hone chaiye, ek don word miss ho jaye iska matlab ye nhi hai ki hum song ko enjoy hi na kar sake. Aur Shaan sir ko pata hona chaiye ki koi bhi perfect nhi hota, galti toh har insaan se hoti hai. Itne saare log ke samne perform karna koi choti baat nahi hai. Ho sakta hai ki woh ladki darr gayi ho, ya shyad nervousness ke waje se ye galti hui usse...
Bhai yaar...mika sir itne fudakfudak kar bol raha hai chalo man liya mika sir sahi hai lekin shaan sir bhi judge ki khursi par bhehta hai thora aarama se bolo
@@johnparks6936 Galti to sabse hoti he Bhai lekin ye show yaha pe competition chal raha he agar galti ki hai to use cover kyu kiya ja raha he galti ke marks katne chahiye Shan sir sirf yahi batana chahte ke ki agar galti ki he to marks bhi kam hone chahiye
@@johnparks6936 bhai sahab ye ek singing competition hain na ki koi live performance. Agr aap ke kisi subject me 100 me se 25 marks or pass 33 wala hain to aapko aese hi pass kr dena Chahiye jb tk aap use level k liye capable nhi ho to kese krde. Ye to wahi waali bt ho gyi ki exam mera chemistry ka tha me physics likh k aa gya or presence of mind ye huyi ki mene sheet khaali nhi choddi
Shaan's argument was that it was a competitive show and every mistake in the performance should be taken in account rather than saying " it was improvised " or " the audience enjoyed the performance "
Do you know that shaan and shreya are legend of their time... Ayushman is no competition for them... They are legends.... I know that you're a gen Z teen ager that's why you don't know about shaan and shareya.. I am also a gen Z teen but i knw that they are way beyond ayushmaan
Look, shaan's point was definitely right...but it wasn't justified! He could've handled it in better way...but if he can scold contestants and judges in singing competition...even he is a judge reacting so inappropriately is that necessary? Instead of scolding he could've made them realise their mistake and motivated them for further...
Absolutely right. I was scrolling through the comments to find out someone who has this kind of understanding. Shaan was right but there were other legendary singers present there like Shankar sir and Shreya mam. Their point was also valid.
At that time these types of things are started to happen for the trp and some good and real singer like shaan and sonu nigam were upset about it.. because day by day it's increasing
@@ashishjangir88 really! In a singing show they didn't point out the contestant mistake atleast for once. Atleast they had to say something to neeti but they defended her ki do lines hi gayi to kya hua . So shaan's anger was justified
@@yuvraj9317 only if Shaan would let them speak. Shreya was clarifying herself and Shaan straightaway interrupted her. Shaan is absolutely right, but it's not like the others are trying to gang up on him. He should've considered that even if the judges are wrong, he needs to make them realize and not interrupt. The other judges were doing precisely that. They tried to hear him out before presenting their arguments. The only idiot here is Mika.
Noone would have predicted Ayushmann (host) would become so big in the future. Also, Bigger surprise was in the first episode of this show when after final round, Shaan strikers had won against Himesh’s team based on points but somehow Himesh’s team was declared the winner.
Compitition k view se Shaan Sir sahi hain but....Maine live dekha tha ye tv par.....and it's amazing.... Rahul ne itne ache se smbhala tha....or Neeti ne bhi... yeh best performance tha😍❤️
Yes.. there was a presence of mind. But it's a competition.. It would be unfair for other teams who sing the complete song and score same marks. Shaan was absolutely right!
Neeti with time has refined her singing, she's sung Sapna jahan with great vocals. Rahul is no less either, but everytime it looks like he's imitating Sonu Sir too much.
Shaan is right. Those are the days where lata ji, Kishore Da and legends were used to sing the songs in one take and these are the singers who don't even record in studio in one take. Bright future of Indian music industry.
Sahime ye video dekhkar samajh mai aata hai ki Rahul ne bahot bade aur acche genuine dost kamaye hai film Industry bollywood mai har jagah par. Aur Rahul se ye sab log bahot jyaada pyaar karte hai.
I am amazed to see Shankar ji and Shreya ji talking like this in a competition where u should have to be perfect there are no marks for handwriting in a competitive examination, it's not a live show where the singer is tired and forgot the lines, they have to be fully prepared when they are competing against others. Giving them points for presence of mind like this is unfair by the side of other contestants.
In a singing contest of my college my partner got nervous and forgot the lyrics so I had to sing his part too... we got the third price because it had to be a duet song... even in a small college contest rules are rules I'm totally agree with shaan
shaan's point was right about the whole scene but he reacted too angrily he could have said that like shankar sir. it's not honorable for such a single to walks off a show open his jacket and go rude just cuz others don't agree with him. he was right for sure. but the point was they tried to comfort the singer by appreciating them offcourse they will have to suffer with the points. shaan could have done that with a bit harmony
@@prabalrai8560 Well it's their perception. Even they know better than us, they are legendary singers. Such small things are bound to happen at any stage of life. So it's no big a deal according to me. It's better to calm the contestant and point out their mistakes in a better way and ask them to keep those mistakes in mind and not commit in future.
@@ashishjangir88 aree vo calm hi rhta, but ussko gussa isliye aaya qki other judges ni us chiz ko point out krke galti niklne ke bjae aur badhwa dere hai, toh kisko bhi gusa aaega yrr ki jis chiz k competition hai usme ye fault hi hai yaha kiska presence of mind dekhne k liye ni bnaya gya tha show, shan was totally right and stood against everyone
![Eminem - Temporary (feat. Skylar Grey) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZaK9Wi5ho0o/mqdefault.jpg)
Shaan is correct. It is competition and not a concert ... but He was alone right.
wahsher wwv Ww c wwc wwc
Wec
Ayushman was with him I guess
Why are you taking it seriously? 😂 This drama was all staged. They quarrel with each other only for TRPs.
@@AsheeshKumar-p7eit's not the nowadays reality show, these old reality shows were real.
@@RandomRUclipsEnjoyer Really bruh? This clearly looks staged. Even a 10 year old can see that.
Rahul vadiya is so underrated .. how he handled the situation is awesome .. but shaan was right
He is now 1 runnerup in BIGG BOSS 14
@@tihamimujawar4259 i didn't like him in bigg Boss though
Rahul is best singer he is self made man ...hell with this nepotism
@@xerovireda8476 not better than shaan
@@tusharmathur5360 who is comparing him with shaan ...shaan is legend I meant rahul is way better thn todays overrated singers
When reality show used to be Real🙌🏻😂 Shaan was right though 😂
Shann is 100% right. He has better knowledge of music performances.
Not better than other 3 judge except mika
Bhai scripted h 😂
@@CryptoQuadCore777 this was not scripted brother others reality shows are scripted
@@CryptoQuadCore777tum Iss samane ke reality shows ki baat kar rahe ho..voh time alag tha
@@CryptoQuadCore777 Back then fights were not scripted
I personally think Shan is 100 % RIGHT !
Musicians are NOT CLOWNS ! !
I think he is right but there are other legendary singers sitting down there like Shreya mam and Shankar sir and if they are saying something then that should also be taken into consideration. Their points were also valid. When they are singing duet it's kind of a team work. So I feel it's very well carried out by Rahul. They could award maybe lesser marks to Neeti but shouldn't have created a scene.
Yes definitely what the hell is agar main by forgetting the lyrics and stopping in between not even the four lines she could sing without forgetting it is because exams are also not supposed to be like that by seeing and answering the questions by asking for the others to tell and repeat the answer of the question so he got angry at Neeti Mohan and Mika Singh for asking the next line to audience others might not accept it so that they also don't forget it because we all know that very well
Wo shankar sir ke teamse the isliye unhone unki wakalat ki agar wahi banda dusre team me hota to shankar sir wakalat karte kya ye samjho?
@@ashishjangir88nope. If they too think singers forgetting lines is okay in a competition or balance in a duet is not necessary then their opinion doesn’t matter at all, no matter how big of a singer they are. Respect goes both ways.
What the others are failing to understand is that Shaan Sir isn't pointing out the lyrics forgetting part in particular. He was merely highlighting that it had to be a duet performance, but ended up with the guy singing most of the song, rendering that girl to almost being backing vocals. In the end the performance was great and that dude's presence of mind was good, but the whole essence of it being a duet was lost.
It shows Shaan Sir's vast knowledge not just in music, but all about performance, stage presence and audience interaction.....mad respect to him
he seemed egoistic person , making unnecessary fuss
@@ApunHiBhagwan he's not egoistic. Hes doing what he's supposed to do, tht is judge the performance
I agree Shaan was judging correctly and honestly he was not favouring anyone I think as neeti was from Shankars team hence Shankar was saying that both of them converted it into moment he was just covering up the mistake of neeti no one bothered about it but shaan did bother and was a responsible judge
@@ApunHiBhagwanjudging is not always waaah tum mumbai aa rahe ho. Its more than that. And if someone points out flaws and faults its called judgement. And he is a judge. Ego ki baat kahan se aa gayi?😂
@@hbinitials7 right , i am also judging and pointing his flaws. His behavior is certainly egoistic , u agree or disagree
Its too much funny when mika has involved in a argument with shaan about music. Because shaan baap hai uska😂😂
shaan first time very angry upar se mika(with no brain)
@@tusharmathur5360 mika aaj india no.1 aa... mika saka baap aa
@@dildeep01 sabka pta nhi tera jrur h
@@tusharmathur5360 apne baap ko ese nahi kehte beta....
@@dildeep01 Bhai gaanjha wageraah kam phuka kar xd
Even in temper, Shaan manages to be graceful.
hah lol hr couldn’t even control that..he wss right but he desrespected all of them
@@surajpancholi8072he just disrespected Mika and no one else, are you dumb and blind?
and ofc he would be angry as other judges weren't even considering his point
@@RandomRUclipsEnjoyerYea, and also it's a competitive show, and the lady forgetting her lyrics just shows that the other contestants are more focused and better
He's MS Dhoni of music, thala for a reason!
Being a basketball coach I understand how Shaan must be feeling. He is fighting for the right cause and for his whole team as well. Points matter because we all put our best efforts to win.
Yes and he was very logical with his argument. He was never in the wrong
mika is clearly saying that " i don't know who made me a singer"
shaan is right ,atleast he is standing on his right point
😂😂😂
मीका तो चुतिया है, पता नहीं इसे सिंगर क्यों मानते हैं?
😅😅
shaan was absolutely right....I surprised with rest of judges for supporting Shankar Ji..
Shankar ji? He himself started to manipulate. Its a fucking competition, not a interview for job or a joke on stage performance.
Shankar is senior.. that's why other's agreed.. bt they shdnt hv
Rahul was from Shankar's team so Shankar tried to defend him by manipulating other judges.
Few years later Neeti Mohan,Shaan,Mika Singh worked as judges in the voice together 😂😂
😂😂
Neeti and shankar were then judges in The Rising Star
😂😂
could you explain what you are trying to say by all of them worked together?
😂😂😂
After 12 years this reel is trending and for sure it became a moment 😂😂
Shaan the smily face..1st time so angry..kuch to galat hua hay yar..
Lol, he was alone among the bunch of chutiyas.. Mika to gawar hai hi, I didn't expect this from Mahadevan.
@@kuls43 Exactly brother 🙄🙄🙄
@@kuls43 Even shreya wasnt with shaan.... pata nahi kya ho gya logo ko. Ayushmaan was the only one who was with shaan.
@@kuls43 Mika sale ko judge kisne banaya...usko tho music ka m bhi nehi paya
@@noname-qq9ow jan Anu Malik Music Composer ban skta h.. Badsha aur Tony kakkar sensational singer ban skte he, selomon bhoi aue aliya bhat movie me gama gaa skte h to for Mikka xhupiya hop hoper kyu nhi ban skta😂😂😂..
Bollywoodiya me kachro ka bhandar laga hua h 1 mikka dhundhne jaoge to 1000 badshah aur mikka milege😂
Seeing Shaan and Neeti going together so well with each other on the sets of Voice India Kids..... increased my respect for both of them....none of them took this incident onto their heart..
Even though this video was posted 8 years back, I still say Shaan was right. We all back you Shaan! Marks kaatne chaiyye!!
*Eats another popcorn*
Last line 😂😂😂😂
Lmfao
Average lafda enjoyer, like me.
😂
Tu big boss dekh na bhai yaha Q aaya hai
Even Ayushmaan said ki shaan ke point me bilkul logic hai...
Shaan sir's point is "this is duet performance so both must share 50-50%. But here is male part is 80% and female part is just 20% and still she didnt complete all 20% part of singing because she forgot the lyrics...and Shaan sir is saying,"He has sang 80% song and she has just 1 %"
Right
Ayushman is wise
@@debadeba1722 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣..... kya logic aa....
@@dildeep01 tera kya logic hai. Lol hypocrisy
Back then people were so open to point out their opinion
Tbh, it’s a singing competition, and you can’t be forgetting lines in between the song. Shaan was right here.
btw.. i dare you..
If there were any other celebrity other than him, audience would have wooooed..
But it was Shaan, the legend.
So people believed him, just wonder what character he possesses... hats off
Exactly. Singing compi mein song k lyrics thodi bhuloge .. aur agar bhool gaye the theek hai .. points kam milenge .. presence of mind k liye appreciation milega points nahi. Mika k argument kitna illogical tha.
@@topgamingclips2431 k
Singing competition ka mera jitna limited knowledge hai usmein sirf Singing ko judge karte hai na like sur, taal , feel etc ismein agar lyrics bhul gayein ek do baar toh marks kaatneka kya criteria hai??
@@ashutoshnair2572 ekdm katne chahiye lyrics bhulne ka
shaan is right. The show is not about what audience enjoy. This is a singing competition nd if you are not singing right then you should not b appreciated, lyrics are the core of a song.
Norooz Jan Agree with you! Shaan was right.
Norooz Jan Shaan is absolutely right.This is a singing competition & not a stage drama , where you can show of your presence of mind & all ...
Exactly
No one is focusing how coincidentally the lyrics are also "Aggar Main Ruk Gayi Abhi" 💀💀
Exactly dude😂😂 I also didn't notice
HAHHAA
Nice catch lol
Bhai your presence of mind😮
Damn💀😹
shaan's aim is protect the honor of music
But he needs to chill a bit. Yes he was right but he needs to be polite . Every judge has their opinion and they will judge according to their judgement.
@@Sams-ch1jg A judge has to be righteous and impartial
Shaan was right here.👍
Surprised to see Niti at her initial stage.
Mika audience se lyrics puch rha hai.. lol.. gano ki aukat to pta thi dimang ki bhi dikha di..
@@kuls43 *dimag chutiye.
@@kuls43 abe mikaela Saba baap aa... kise galayfemi main maat reh... ye baki singers use same kuch nahi...
@@dildeep01 mikha jhaant hai.
@@dildeep01 🤣🤣🤣🤣shaan usse lakh guna bada singer h....aur gane pta h Mika k🤣 kutta song
times when reality shows used to be real!!
All public don't know "sur - taal" it's not justice to judge the performance based on Audience. Today's singers are using softwares to mould their voice, even Salman Khan started singing, lol. If decision need to be made by Audience then why Judges?? "Judges Ghanta hilane k liyea hai kya??" Totally Agreed with Shaan.
Salman actually sang a song couple years after you posted this comment, haha. What a disgrace.
It's really surprising how music directors like Shankar sir and himesh sir supported this incident . Even Shreya ji supported it. Shaan sir protested , but it wasn't enough. This is real competition
Himesh was in support of Shaan in this episode and Ayushman too
This is because they all ( other than shaan) are salman Khan ke paltu . That's why shaan is not successful now
Unko appreciate krna chahiye tha .. contestant ko demotivated na feel ho .. jo galti ki us situation ko acche se handle kiye uske liye bahot points deduct honge which is also true. Shaan's points were actually right. Crowd ne bhi agree kiya aur even host Ayushmaan ne bhi.
@@ritiknoatilhari5531 himesh support mei nehi tha
Sir sir sir 🤦♂️
The way Rahul handled the situation takes my ❤
I agree with shaan. A singer should always justify with song. It doesn't matter it's duet or solo.
Even ayushman was supporting shaan, but others are talking so unprofessionally.
5:57 Even the audience says 'you are right' to Shaan
Shaan is completely right. it is a great mistake if someone forgets the lyrics in a competition when you are being judged. it may be ok in a concert, because the team or audience may support him/her.
Shaan is logical and correct. You cannot consider a singer who forgets the lines and uses presence of mind to overcome the lapse to some extent, better than a singer who has sung the whole song with perfection.
Anyone in place of Shaan whould be frustrated. Shankar Mahadevan was pathetic. As soon as the song was over, he started yelling 'presence of mind'.
yes
@@jefferyashraf1391 singer at kabali?
Even arijit singh forgot...
Are you crazy? They are human beings not machines. I love Shaan but people foget lyrics to thei own songs while performing on stage. There are lots of factors, they are musicians yes, but they were also for the entertainment, one can compensate the other.
@@trishitasaikia1163 Bhai tumhe impromptu thore hi gaana hai. Ye log prepare toh karte hi hai aur judgement hona hai toh yahaa toh number katenge
Rahul vaidya made a moment out of the mistake..
Hats off man! 👏👏👏👏
Mika- 10 saal me 1500 show?
Saal me 150 show 🤣🤣🤣
bro they are same in calculation😂
😂
@@kshitizmayank7208Abe yahin to kehna chahta hai woh ki Mika phek raha hai. Mika thodi na saal me 150 show karta hai. Use your mind bro
You are another fool..... according to calculation it's the same number..... Indians are fools😂😂😂
Gadha hai wo
I am with Shaan...he right, its not just a show...its a competition.
Shaan is absolutely correct. I don't understand why Shreya & Shankar Ji are defending the singers.
It is team compition.
Sanker ki team ki ladki lyrics bhooli but wo presences of mind k liye point magne lga apni team k liye.
Thing is tough she forget the lyrics but they created a moment and shown the creativity so shankar ji was asking marks for that like agar 2 marks agar katte bhi hai to ek mark unke presence of mind ko bhi dena chahiye
Let's be honest it's beautiful how he improvised and Shankar ji and Shreya mam only appreciating that they also said we are not giving any extra points for that just praising the singers
I am the one who came here after watching reels 😂
No me too 🙋♀️😆🤭
Shaan gussa hua Matlab kuch galat hua hai shaan is right
Shaan sir's point is "this is duet performance so both must share 50-50%. But here is male part is 80% and female part is just 20% and still she didnt complete all 20% part of singing because she forgot the lyrics...and Shaan sir is saying,"He has sang 80% song and she has just 1 %"
👌
shaan sir was 100 % right .
Shaan was right point aisi choti choti bato k hi to hote hai
True😅
Shaan has a very valid point. I've seen very good singers being sent home in song competitions when they forgot the words. Although Shaan's way of putting his point across is wrong but Mika really pushed him further. The matter was being settled when he chose to start the fight all over again.
Is fight k chakkar mai rahul ka badiya performance overlooked ho gaya
Shann is right its a competition not a program where audians decide whether a song is good or bad
Audians.. really? Audience. Pls correct it
Yeah and they are judge. So judge based in the way they sing not whether you enjoy it or not
Shaan showed a bit too anger but he is completely justified as this is not just a stage show but a competition where every little moment during the singing is judged, otherwise everyone is brilliant singer and all would stand in the same line if these mistakes are ignored and overlooked. Respect for Mahadevan sir for his so polite personality
His anger was manipulated by others. Its justified. Anyone would get frustrated if a simple and logical point is not being fathomed by ppl of same profession.
@@punkchica619 he got angered after Mika saying audience and audience
Did u not see how Shankar Mahadevan just seconds after the performance manipulated the judges saying about the presence of mind as if they had to neglect the fact that the contestant amidst the competition forgot her lyrics
Shaan - Aap Pagal ho gye ho kya?
Mika - Toh kya
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Shaan was right. His anger was manipulated by all the others to show as if he was wrong. Mika is a use-n-throw-song singer, why would he argue with a better singer???
I faintly remember seeing this and getting angry for those singers who forgot the lyrics :-)
Correct
Right
she didnt forgot a line she forgot a lot more than that..... so i am with shaan on this one
yes absolutely shan is right
@Nilotpal Sarmah she forgot lyrics, not her voice. For playback you don't need to learn the song. You can look and sing.
@@sandipadas9216 but here live competition was going on .....u can'not get marks on forgetting the lyrics
@@tusharmathur5360 yes right...i don't remember why I commented on playback singing... Lol...
@@sandipadas9216 lol....no problem
Rahul vadiya handled it so well such a talented guy
shaan is right
antu_neel he is always ri8
Absolutely... since it is a competition...
Bhai koi ye chi bol raha Ki unkon extra points do.
But the way that guy helped his partner was truly amazing something you would hardly ever see again.
So that spirit of helping your partner in a tough moment should be appreciated.
If he had'nt done they would have end the song and that's it.But instead you got to see something spectacular.Shaan was over angry.Which was unnecessary.
Nai yaar mika ka point sahi hai... Gaane mei sirf feel hone chaiye, ek don word miss ho jaye iska matlab ye nhi hai ki hum song ko enjoy hi na kar sake.
What show is this lol
shaan ji akele sab pe bhari hai
Ek shaan sab pe bhaari to sab ki bolti band kara de na ar rahamam Or shaan ye dono asli judge h
@@tanveerkhan8331 Shankar mahadevan is also legend. dunno what happened to him here🙄
@@anshumansingh8358 Ego !
@@anshumansingh8358 partiality hai yeah.... hypocrite hai yeah shankar
Because he has the logic
Performance mast thi 👍 baki rabdi rona dheke bhi maja aya👌
shaan is 100% correct
I agree
I agree
I also agree
Mika is zero in front of Shan
Yes
Mika and Javed zero in front of shaan and ar rahamam rahamam sir se yaad aaya real jurge
@@tanveerkhan8331 which javed u'r talking about?
-100
Shan was ready to beat up Mika 😂
"aap lala karke gaa dijeyana pura gana" 😂😂
Shan is absolutely ok.....Shan said Mika ko Kya pagal ho😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ye MIKA toh ladkiyon ki hi side leta hai kya ??? ...SHAAN IS RIGHT☺️
Shaan was right. Watching it in 2022 and still feels great to see that whole comment section was so true then and was saying in Shaan's favor ❤️
Totally agreed with Shaan Sir! #respect
shaan....you nailed it. It's a Competition not a Acting...WTF presence of mind
Peak popcorn moments, missing raw moments like these in today's times 🤌
Shaan to Mika: "Kya aap dimaag ghar pe rakhke aaye ho?"
Mika: "Kya kyaa??"
😂😂😂😂
Abe chal.be bong.... Mika is great.... Mika ke boot tak ki aukat nahi sabki..
@@dildeep01 mika teri maa ka yaar hai...samajh gya 🤣🤣🤣
@@dildeep01 mika was born in Durgapur, West Bengal.. And for us Bengali we appreciate music and songs. And we criticize when it's wrong in case of music!
@@ravithakur0041 hahhhahaha bhai leli
@@dildeep01 mila teri maa ka yaar hai...jo sab jagah aa kar use defend kar raha hai...tu😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣
please Mika ji shut up!.....you are not eligible to be a judge....please don't ever try to do that....
Saikat Das 😂😂😂
"Aap dimag ghr me rakh ke aaye ho kya" was too funny 🤣🤣🤣
I haven't expected a great singer like "Shreya Ghosal" defending that.. Shaan Sir is very much justified.. Shankar Sir tried to lure the judges by covering up the whole flaw with "presence of mind" and even judges agreed by nodding their heads acknowledging it .. kya qtiyapa hai.. when Shaan Sir saw things going too far.. he protested and he is right and justified !!
Nai yaar Mika ka point sahi hai... Gaane mei sirf feel hone chaiye, ek don word miss ho jaye iska matlab ye nhi hai ki hum song ko enjoy hi na kar sake. Aur Shaan sir ko pata hona chaiye ki koi bhi perfect nhi hota, galti toh har insaan se hoti hai. Itne saare log ke samne perform karna koi choti baat nahi hai. Ho sakta hai ki woh ladki darr gayi ho, ya shyad nervousness ke waje se ye galti hui usse...
Bhai yaar...mika sir itne fudakfudak kar bol raha hai chalo man liya mika sir sahi hai lekin shaan sir bhi judge ki khursi par bhehta hai thora aarama se bolo
@@johnparks6936
Galti to sabse hoti he Bhai lekin ye show yaha pe competition chal raha he agar galti ki hai to use cover kyu kiya ja raha he galti ke marks katne chahiye Shan sir sirf yahi batana chahte ke ki agar galti ki he to marks bhi kam hone chahiye
Mika Singh singing k bareme zyada janenge ya shaan?Mika ko to khud gaana nahi ata
@@johnparks6936 bhai sahab ye ek singing competition hain na ki koi live performance.
Agr aap ke kisi subject me 100 me se 25 marks or pass 33 wala hain to aapko aese hi pass kr dena Chahiye jb tk aap use level k liye capable nhi ho to kese krde.
Ye to wahi waali bt ho gyi ki exam mera chemistry ka tha me physics likh k aa gya or presence of mind ye huyi ki mene sheet khaali nhi choddi
Shaan is right, I agree with Shaan
Me too
me too
Me too. I also agree with Shaan.
Shaan's argument was that it was a competitive show and every mistake in the performance should be taken in account rather than saying " it was improvised " or " the audience enjoyed the performance "
Shan is 100% rite... if someone forgot the lyrics then what the hell was he/ she telling the world through his her song?
Shaan - aap pagal ho gaye ho kya
Mika - to kya 🤣🤣
😂🤚🏻
Shan is absolutely right and others is talking like unprofessional.
Shaan is the man!
💄 kay
shaan is right
shaan is right
Apparently, Shaan was not instructed and paid like other judges to just blatantly sing praises for the singers.... even after committing blunders.
Shaan is absolutely right, Mika is completely nonsense I think
Mika pagal hai
You are right i dont know how mikha become a musician
Rahul Presence of Mind best
This shows the difference between a real passionate singer and other commercial singer.
The main person who is being ingnored by them here is the most successful person right now out of them, that's Ayushman Khurana for you 😊😉😉
So you are saying Ayushmann Is more famous than Shreya Shaan Mika Himesh
@@pallab30k24 That is Gen Z for you. Comparing bollywood celebs with All India Singers..
This is so absurd comparison
Dont compare anyone with shaan atif shreya and arijit
Do you know that shaan and shreya are legend of their time... Ayushman is no competition for them... They are legends.... I know that you're a gen Z teen ager that's why you don't know about shaan and shareya.. I am also a gen Z teen but i knw that they are way beyond ayushmaan
Shaan sir sahi bol rahy hai
ya kea har kisi ko sir sir bolty ho
Look, shaan's point was definitely right...but it wasn't justified! He could've handled it in better way...but if he can scold contestants and judges in singing competition...even he is a judge reacting so inappropriately is that necessary? Instead of scolding he could've made them realise their mistake and motivated them for further...
Absolutely right. I was scrolling through the comments to find out someone who has this kind of understanding. Shaan was right but there were other legendary singers present there like Shankar sir and Shreya mam. Their point was also valid.
At that time these types of things are started to happen for the trp and some good and real singer like shaan and sonu nigam were upset about it.. because day by day it's increasing
@@ashishjangir88 really! In a singing show they didn't point out the contestant mistake atleast for once. Atleast they had to say something to neeti but they defended her ki do lines hi gayi to kya hua . So shaan's anger was justified
Shaan was so soft throughout the argument. But other idiot judges couldn’t understand his point. His point is entirely justified.
@@yuvraj9317 only if Shaan would let them speak. Shreya was clarifying herself and Shaan straightaway interrupted her. Shaan is absolutely right, but it's not like the others are trying to gang up on him. He should've considered that even if the judges are wrong, he needs to make them realize and not interrupt. The other judges were doing precisely that. They tried to hear him out before presenting their arguments. The only idiot here is Mika.
i lov shaan. he is always perfect
shaan is really right
Noone would have predicted Ayushmann (host) would become so big in the future.
Also, Bigger surprise was in the first episode of this show when after final round, Shaan strikers had won against Himesh’s team based on points but somehow Himesh’s team was declared the winner.
Shaan to Shaan h.❤️ but neeti abhi iske sath judge h😂.
rahul ka kahi Pata nhi😢
Shaan is right if it is competion then marks will be deducted......
Shaan soch Raha hai o Shreya Ghoshal Se A6a singer hai.....Arijit ka juri vi nahi hai Shaan
Atik Sarkar
Tu uske jhant me latakta jue ke brabar bi ni h.. Ye bhi janle..😂
Atik Sarkar tu beta music sunna band kar de, tere ko pata hai shan abhi tak total kitna gana gaha hai,
@@atiksarkar1544 😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 kuch bhi, 😂😂🤣🤣
If someone would've supported Shaan, he would be calm and explained his pov.
Shaan is right....ya he is very justified...are they out of there mind....I respect Mika also but what is wrong is wrong and Mika is wrong....
OMG!!! I'm seeing first time $han fighting !!!
shaan is just frustrated he is not getting songs these days
Compitition k view se Shaan Sir sahi hain but....Maine live dekha tha ye tv par.....and it's amazing.... Rahul ne itne ache se smbhala tha....or Neeti ne bhi... yeh best performance tha😍❤️
After seeing bb14, rahul and rubina's fight it seems this is much more serious argument than bb14.. 😂😂
Yes.. there was a presence of mind. But it's a competition.. It would be unfair for other teams who sing the complete song and score same marks. Shaan was absolutely right!
Saw this episode - Shaan was perfectly justified !!!
Kya naseeb he, Rahul is more batter then neeti but famous neeti zyada ho gae
It's okk ab chaa rha hai Rahul hr jagah ......he is the best
Famous lol
Aajkal kaise famous hota Hain paata Hain
Waise bhi yeh ladki Hain....😌😌😌
Neeti with time has refined her singing, she's sung Sapna jahan with great vocals.
Rahul is no less either, but everytime it looks like he's imitating Sonu Sir too much.
In this argument Shaan is RIGHT.
Prem Chand yee
Thats same like forgetting to answer a question in the exam and then arguing with the examiner that you didnt see the question
Shaan is right. Those are the days where lata ji, Kishore Da and legends were used to sing the songs in one take and these are the singers who don't even record in studio in one take. Bright future of Indian music industry.
Sahime ye video dekhkar samajh mai aata hai ki Rahul ne bahot bade aur acche genuine dost kamaye hai film Industry bollywood mai har jagah par. Aur Rahul se ye sab log bahot jyaada pyaar karte hai.
I am amazed to see Shankar ji and Shreya ji talking like this in a competition where u should have to be perfect there are no marks for handwriting in a competitive examination, it's not a live show where the singer is tired and forgot the lines, they have to be fully prepared when they are competing against others. Giving them points for presence of mind like this is unfair by the side of other contestants.
The only person who is concerned with justice is Shaan
Shaan:- Audience kiyun jaanegi lyrics
App dimag ghar pe rakh aaye ho kya
😎
Destruction in seconds 👍😉😆
Shaan sir is real talented 🙏
In a singing contest of my college my partner got nervous and forgot the lyrics so I had to sing his part too... we got the third price because it had to be a duet song... even in a small college contest rules are rules I'm totally agree with shaan
No you got 3rd coz you both suck hahah
Actually shaan is right
shaan's point was right about the whole scene but he reacted too angrily he could have said that like shankar sir. it's not honorable for such a single to walks off a show open his jacket and go rude just cuz others don't agree with him. he was right for sure. but the point was they tried to comfort the singer by appreciating them offcourse they will have to suffer with the points. shaan could have done that with a bit harmony
Harshwardhan Singh the judges you're talking about who according to u shud have given less marks gave them 9 and 10.....
Agree
@@prabalrai8560 Well it's their perception. Even they know better than us, they are legendary singers. Such small things are bound to happen at any stage of life. So it's no big a deal according to me. It's better to calm the contestant and point out their mistakes in a better way and ask them to keep those mistakes in mind and not commit in future.
@@ashishjangir88 aree vo calm hi rhta, but ussko gussa isliye aaya qki other judges ni us chiz ko point out krke galti niklne ke bjae aur badhwa dere hai, toh kisko bhi gusa aaega yrr ki jis chiz k competition hai usme ye fault hi hai yaha kiska presence of mind dekhne k liye ni bnaya gya tha show, shan was totally right and stood against everyone
The way male contestant handled it was amazing
Shaan has a valid point
Mika n himesh wording kaha say boolay gay wou tou naakh say gaatay h
Shaan is on fire and he haj logic in it and he is absolutely justified.