Atp I am not even mad about them struggling. Like the choreographer needs to give them easier choreographies considering they can't maintain live vocals that good. Unless they are willing to train as hard as Nmixx to master live vocals with tough choreos, they need to tone down their choreos.
@l9zm I really want to see u doing this dance and trying to sing at the same time! the dance is really difficult, and there is a lot of another performances that they are with their mics on and it's very good for someone that it's dancing at the same time. please stop spreading hate coments on the internet, that's not cool u know...
@@kikiiyuuIdk but maybe because they become exhausted and dont give their all on encores and the hate comments that they receive might create a pressure for them. But yeah they are unstable but they have improved quite a bit so it is really good to see but they do need vocal training. But the easy choreography is hard though
They actually sounded fine live. MR removed strips everything. Including half of the live vocals. It’s not full proof because it’s a technology that has to basically split sound which is nearly impossible. In the process of separating and amplifying different sounds it actually creates a false representation of what the performance sounded like live
This is terrible… Idols are trained to sing while dancing difficult choreo. But I couldn’t see any improvements in them…. Hybe should train them and they are definitely not ready for this…
Yikes! Well we all know they need to take vocal lessons. The other problem here is the ridiculous choreography. I remember watching the MV when it dropped and my first thought was “they really have no plans of singing this live huh?” No one in their right mind who wants to sing will choose that kind of choreography to perform live. I can’t even blame the choreographer since it’s up to the company at the end of the day how comebacks will proceed. My point is that the industry doesn’t care for talents anymore. It’s more about profit, trends, and visuals these days. It was like that back then too but at least the general public upheld a high standard for idols. The ability to sing live was important. Now anyone with a pretty face can debut and hide behind sound engineering.
at the end of the day, do they want to be an idol group or just a dance group? cuz girlies can't even hit a note while standing completely still. they are great dancers yes, but if (God forbid fr) they ever injure themselves, or when they get way older, what will they have left besides their very pretty faces? idols are singers first and dancers second, at least that was the case until the 4th gen.
Whats the point that you trying to show here ? 😅 this channel really insult idols everyday like u doing any better .. people working hard to sing and dance expression .. and are u sure that this is like actual thing ? These people crazy .. love the peoples hard work and add things gd for u instead of judges everything
There is no insulting here, simply posting their performance without background music. They do this for plenty of groups- basically any group that gets an encore. The point is that some of us like to know what live vocals without background music sounds like.
Atp I am not even mad about them struggling. Like the choreographer needs to give them easier choreographies considering they can't maintain live vocals that good. Unless they are willing to train as hard as Nmixx to master live vocals with tough choreos, they need to tone down their choreos.
@l9zm I really want to see u doing this dance and trying to sing at the same time! the dance is really difficult, and there is a lot of another performances that they are with their mics on and it's very good for someone that it's dancing at the same time. please stop spreading hate coments on the internet, that's not cool u know...
@@mariana-pf4ht I dont't think that is a hate comment. Op just said they need to tone down the choreo in order to sing better. There is no hate.
honestly they're even unstable during encores
@@kikiiyuuIdk but maybe because they become exhausted and dont give their all on encores and the hate comments that they receive might create a pressure for them. But yeah they are unstable but they have improved quite a bit so it is really good to see but they do need vocal training. But the easy choreography is hard though
I am not defending and I know it is not excuse but I think some of them are not confident and it shows in their voice@@kikiiyuu
omg i'm so worried about how they will perform this song in Coachella :( too hard for them to give live performance in this current condition :(
cuz the choreography is too intense and their live vocals are not that good ...
Don't worry they'll kill the coachella performances for sure
They actually sounded fine live. MR removed strips everything. Including half of the live vocals. It’s not full proof because it’s a technology that has to basically split sound which is nearly impossible. In the process of separating and amplifying different sounds it actually creates a false representation of what the performance sounded like live
@@myaelink825their vocals are always on point?? MR drowns out their voices.. don’t make assumptions
They will have to rely on heavy backtrack for the vocals. I don't think they will have any problem with the stage presence and stuff.
퍼포먼스도 좋지만 라이브 가능한 안무로 좀 짜주면 안되나? 저렇게 숨차는데도 밝은표정으로 노래하고 화음까지 넣는거 진짜 대단하다👍
남돌 보면 저거보다 훨씬 빡센 안무에 라이브 엄청 잘하는 사람도 널림 여돌도 힘든 안무에 라이브 잘하는 팀들 많고 핑계지 군대에서 뛰면서 군가 시켜도 저거보다 잘 합니다
2세대 여돌들은 하이힐 신고 방방 뛰면서 ar하나도 안깔린 라이브를 했었는데… 안무의 문제가 아닌 듯
그럼 있지 엔믹스 여자친구가 뭐가 되냐
Le Sserafim the best ! ❤
Can u even hear their live vocals?
Even the crowd sings better than them
이렇게 추면서 라이브가 가능...해?? 그리구 노래 늘은건 모르겄다...
Eunchae ❤
This is terrible…
Idols are trained to sing while dancing difficult choreo. But I couldn’t see any improvements in them….
Hybe should train them and they are definitely not ready for this…
윤진 빼곤 노래를 부르는 건지 웅얼거리는건지 모르겠음... 댄서가 아니라 가수인데 노래에 좀만 더 신경 써주면 안되나.. 퍼포먼스에만 집중하는 느낌😢
댄서도 가수도 아니라 아이돌임.. 아이돌한텐 춤도 퍼포먼스도 노래도 중요한 요소인 거고.. 거기다 끼나 비주얼 같은 것도 중요함 댄서는 춤을 잘 춰야 하고 가수는 노래를 잘 불러야 하는 게 맞지만 아이돌은 춤 노래 외에도 다른 요소들도 중요하게 생각해야 함
끼도 비주얼도 넘치는 그룹인 건 맞는데 아이돌도 가수에 포함되는 거니까요 .. 프로필보면 가수라 되어있어요
원래 노래 자체가 웅얼거리는 노랜데 뭐ㅋㅋ
그럼 가만히 서서 노래하는 발라드 가수 좋아하셈
저번 컴백보다는 확실히 늘긴 늘었고 카즈하 생각보다 훨씬 잘하고 윤진,채원,은채 다 괜찮음..! 근데 너무 힘든게 느껴져서 안무좀 라이브 잘할수 있게 짜줬으면 좋겠음..
jumped and all and still didnt stop singing the song for a single second
the jealous kpoppies could never say the same about their lipsync idols
“Nmixx has been added to the chat “
Just compare blackpink and lesserafim coachella lsrfm was literally screaming🤣🤣
they all improved a lot since debut !
They are literally screaming or mur muring, what did they improve?😅
퍼포먼스 가수지.
왜 노래부르기 어려운 댄스를 시키나
Ugh my ears
아니 사쿠라는 한국어도 못하고 영어도 못하면 노력을 하든가 일본에서 활동 하는게 편할것 같은데 욕 안 먹고
woowww
맴버들 전부 다 노력하고 잘하는게 보이는 사람? 손? 근데 갠적인 생각인데 퍼포먼스도 좋은데 노래 부르기 힘들꺼 같은데?
Yikes! Well we all know they need to take vocal lessons. The other problem here is the ridiculous choreography. I remember watching the MV when it dropped and my first thought was “they really have no plans of singing this live huh?” No one in their right mind who wants to sing will choose that kind of choreography to perform live. I can’t even blame the choreographer since it’s up to the company at the end of the day how comebacks will proceed.
My point is that the industry doesn’t care for talents anymore. It’s more about profit, trends, and visuals these days. It was like that back then too but at least the general public upheld a high standard for idols. The ability to sing live was important. Now anyone with a pretty face can debut and hide behind sound engineering.
Can you removed mr in vevo video?
could you make touchin&movin mr. remove pleaseeeee thank you 🥺
Ppl be believing everything they see on RUclips haha
Euchae is the only one that managed to pull off her lines 😢
lol her part while dancing is easy bro, compared it to chaewon or kazuha. eunchae during clap my hand part, she is literally walking
Well it's not like she has that many but she still slayed!! The others did fine as well
at the end of the day, do they want to be an idol group or just a dance group? cuz girlies can't even hit a note while standing completely still. they are great dancers yes, but if (God forbid fr) they ever injure themselves, or when they get way older, what will they have left besides their very pretty faces? idols are singers first and dancers second, at least that was the case until the 4th gen.
its not like all idols become singers as they get older, most just become actors and models
은채 진짜 잘한다 ❤
?
?
윤진은 음역대가 안맞아서 그런가..? 다들 안맞아보이는데
Please don't video blur
they have to bc of copyright
@@jypthekidsmissyouathome I don't know that
Whats the point that you trying to show here ? 😅 this channel really insult idols everyday like u doing any better .. people working hard to sing and dance expression .. and are u sure that this is like actual thing ? These people crazy .. love the peoples hard work and add things gd for u instead of judges everything
There is no insulting here, simply posting their performance without background music. They do this for plenty of groups- basically any group that gets an encore. The point is that some of us like to know what live vocals without background music sounds like.
노래를 거의 안부르네
Vocal còn yếu hơn Newjeans:))
잘하는데 춤좀 바꿔라 노래를 부르라는거냐..이게;;