Thanks for bringing up the talaak issue, Hassan. I wholeheartedly agree. No drama ever shows the other school of thought where despite saying talaak 3 times, it's accepted as 1 and then there's a waiting period which allows for reconciliation. It becomes so one dimensional and takes away from the wisdom of religion. Really getting fed up of these immediate talaaks being portrayed on TV. You're right - religious issues need to be portrayed more responsibly.
Exactly! Atleast before they used to show that when they gave the 3 times wale talaq there would be witnesses present...ab to phone call pe talaq ho raha hai matlab kya...?
@Sania Rehan I think your misinformed. Talaq given in a state of ighlaq according to a majority of scholars is not valid. Please research this. Majority of evidence points to this. There’s 3 types of anger. Two which come under ighlaq and one which is mild anger where it is counted.
@Sania Rehan Just because your hearing something for the first time doesn’t mean that it’s wrong. If you feel like you already know so much then you would also know that as Muslims when it comes to matter of fiqh you would always go with the majority of view and majority of evidence points towards it not being counted as three in one go. I am hanafi myself and I have reached out and researched this evidence for over a week.I can confirm that my findings are correct and let’s say for a second even if ‘it wasn’t’ then according to law and order in 1968 triple talaq was abolished in 19 countries anyway? Including Pakistan too (please research) once again this is something our scholars also have a responsibility of addressing. And ofcourse, talaq in intoxication or coercness is also not counted think about it - Our whole religion itself is based on intention. Islam itself means to submit. It contradicts the whole essence of our religion and what it teaches. Just because your scholar says so and so doesn’t mean it’s 100% correct. We as Muslims have the responsibility to seek knowledge ourselves and understand it too. Even when talaq is given in Ighlaq - anger is of three types. Then it’s counted or not counted based on what kind of anger it was. And your telling me it’s over in a matter of seconds cause the guys said it three times? Pls research!! And ofcourse Allah knows best.
Sahi treeqa yehi h k 1 waqt me 1 bar hi talaq di jaye lekin agar koi 3 talaq 1 sath deta h tb bhi wo 1 consider ki jayegi hmaray haan jo ye concept h k 3 talaq 1 sath di jaye to bs talaq ho gye to ye rule Hazrat Umar k zamanay me apply hua tha qk log bar bar talaq de kr biwiyon se sulah kr lete the is cheez ko rokne k lye Hazrat Umar Farooq ne phir 3 talaq ko hatmi talaq qarar diya imam abbu hanifa ne is ko apni book me quote kiya or pak me log imam abu haneefa ko zyada mante hn islye ye rule apply kiya jata h pak me...halan k hadith k lihaz se dekha jAye to 1 waqt me beshak jitni bhi talaq di jaye wo 1 talaq hi kehlayegi.
We really don't need dramas like Muqaddar.What purpose has this drama served till now.Isn't it glorifying a person who harrassed ,kidnapped and forcefully married a girl.Its just like giving free license to a person that go get the girl of your choice in a criminal way ,as later your sincere love will melt her heart and you would be able to win her heart. Just giving a motta sa name like stockholm Syndrom can't normalise or cover this whole evil concept.
I totally agree with Hassan. Abducting a woman and forcing her into marriage against her wishes is heroic behavior? In which world, culture or religion? I don’t watch this play, but had the producer/ director/ writer shown just one scene where the feudal lord expresses remorse for his actions to the heroine, goes and apologizes to her family that would have been helpful. Had they allowed the woman and the family members to articulate their anguish, their humiliation, their sense of helplessness in the face of his actions - that would have helped. Even now, if they show her resuming her education and then working for the women and girls in the feudal lords village alongside her stepdaughter - that would be good. At least it will suggest a constructive way of addressing with these feudal practices entrenched in our culture. Hasan is right - when you have such a wide reaching platform, you have a responsibility to inform and educate, not just entertain.
I agree with Hassan with his concern regarding the divorce scene in Kashf. These days divorce is so causally thrown into each drama like it's no big deal. I believe that the proper consequences of a divorce need to be shown including the technical and religious aspects of it as well so that the younger generation can learn that it is in fact not something to be taken lightly as it can destroy lives.
Well said. yep and also as a muslim we must try to learn ourselves, do our own research about those technicalities. Since growing up i always watched in dramas with three talaqs happening and just few years back I found out thats not the case. So many families have ruined their lives behind this wrong concept.
I agree with Hassan completely about Muqaddar. Even in Jalan, Nisha is being shown as the worst person ever. Why shouldn't Saif ur Rehman be treated the same way?
Yes Hasan is right in saying if a person has done something bad he should have been shown to pay for it. From Raima's perspective, I can understand that she has no other option now and she has accepted the incident as her fate and now is loyal and in love with her husband. But from Saif ur Rehaman's perspective, he has been bad to his first wife than he abducted this innocent girl and tortured her family and forced her into an unwanted relationship, so why did he get the punishment for all this. This shows our public that it is OK for a rich and powerful person to abduct a girl. Also they showed Farkhanda begum as villian however she is just a normal yet powerful woman who has been mistreated by her husband all her life and now she has become the killer of her husband. Why such hypocrisy?
I completely agree with Hassan on Muqaddar’s point. The content created on tv really influences people. They have glorified the character of Saif ur Rehman, its really terrible.
I agree with Hassan on Talaaq issue. I never like when people give talaaq instantaneously,..it also give impression that talaaq is so easy in Islam which is in fact not correct.
@@ayrizchowdhury7170 it is ijmaa of ummat. All school of thoughts say that three talaq at once is the wrong way to give, however talaq happens. Only ehle hadith and Arabic scholars say that it doesn't happen. It is a very long debate.
1:32. I am lucky that i discovered yr show and two highly educated and intellectual people 1 year back.,, who think logically and Bring fun in our daily routine, who make us laugh.... I think the viewers are more lucky than you guyz😃😃😃😃
Absolutely agree with Hassan in case of Muqaddar. Stockholm syndrome is actually reaction to a trauma which Raima also went through. They never showed the PTSD (post traumatic stress syndrome) in Raima's personality. I know somebody who went through Stockholm syndrome, but she had clear symptoms of PTSD while being in that relationship.
Regarding Muqaddar, I agree with Hassan. The problem is that the masses of our country are not that educated and hence, they do not have critical analyzing skills. They feel what the drama-makers want them to feel and thus, in this drama they believe that Saif is a hero while, in reality, he was a villain.
How is Ulfat’s love same when she has served her husband in a platter to another woman??? That means when she’s ready to share her husband means her love is already flawed so if Shahaan’s love has become flawed Ulfat deserves it!!!
As far as I can remember,Shahan refused to marry shafaq when ulfat asked him to do so. He decided to marry her when she(shafaq) committed suicide . So no Ulfat isnt entirely wrong.Shahan's 360 degree change when he actually claimed to loved Ulfat is so disturbing.
I'm not sure if its Stockholm syndrome in Raima's case. She doesnt fall in love with Saif just because she is in captivity. In her case, it's just a compromise. She couldnt find a way out from her situation. She just accepted her fate (muqaddar). She is a practical person who just decided to give this marriage all she got in order to survive.
Oh my God hassan. Honestly im so GLAD THAT FINALLY someone from media FINALLY addressed the fact that saying talak three times means NOTHING. Its a long process for divorce. U have to wait for 3 months for the next talak and then months for third. You’re such an educated and wise man hassan. Thankyou for existing 🤣 ♥️and dont let amma change everything to drama :p soz amna ilytoo! thanks for addressing serious issues i really hope you read my comment hassan :)
@Manal, just to clarify that initially 3 meant 1( for emphasis 3 Times it was pronounced) in Arab culture but when people started to abuse the practice and started to keep wife for ever then in times of Hazrat Umer(RA) , the original ruling of one at a time was prevailed so after that 3 at once ( disliked) or 3 at different occasions ( preferable ) counts as 3 and irreversible. 3 as 1 in beginning was cultural thing rather than as Quranic revelation .Quranic revelation tells 3 talaq , does not mention 3 as 1 and total 9 talaq.
One crucial message given in dramas like 'Dulhan' and 'Galati' is that girls should take possession of the important documents related to their marriage. Dulhan tells that girls should have a copy of their Nikah Naama and knowledge about the whereabouts of Moulvi Sahab and both Gawah. Likewise, Galati tells that in the case of 2 Talaq, the girl should have something in written form.
There are so many movies and serials where they justify how the woman falls in love with her stalker, her rapist. I have a really difficult time accepting that Raima is the agentic subject here rather than being totally victimized by Saif's misogyny and that of the writer, director, and the audience rooting for the couple's happy ending.
Agree on the very dramatic style of Ary digital dramas lately...we watch PK dramas because they ARENT like Indian dramas. Why emulate what everyone doesnt want to watch?!
I do not watch Muqaddar, but I do watch your review on it every week. I do not understand why they glorify someone who is a criminal just because he is nice to his wife, who he kidnapped and forced her to marry him. It is sad to hear that people are upset that he dies in this week's episode. What is the message? It is okay to kidnap a girl and force her into marriage just because "he loves her"? That makes no sense to me. I love Prem Gali though! The Dada's character is so cute with his expressions and the way he speaks. The whole "talaq le na chathi hai tou theek hai, zinda salamaat ho gi!" made me crack up! I am thoroughly enjoying Prem Gali! 😂😂
After Jalan, another aggrieved, ill treated, innocent character, Kashif, is left to die. From normalising, abductions and forced marriages, we now have forced deaths.🙄 Amongst this madness, Prem Gali is a ray of sunshine. Apart from spreading laughter, it is sending out positive, much needed messages to the society at large, in a very appealing manner. Kudos!
I must say that whenever I see a disturbing episode of any drama , I wait to run to u guys to satisfy my irritation....by listening to ur discussion s just like my kids get irritated and run to me for help...😂
Exactly hassan you are so right about the comments on muqaddar! I was also shocked to read the sad comments like o my god saif died, hero ko maar detay hain, ab kya bacha dramay main!! O yaar come on! Tum logon nay saifu ko danish bana dia !
I second hasan, responsibility multiplies by so many times when specially religious matters are portrayed on television. They show divorce as if peanuts.
OH MY GOD HASSAN AND AAMNA..........i laughed my guts out at your hard core punjabi dig at the London wala friend in Jalan!! Hurrah!! you guys nailed it!
It’s not always about metaphorical aspect. 99.9% of the masses watch these dramas and sometimes without realising they follow what is shown blindly. It’s very easy to follow what’s shown and these are things that cannot be ignored. Especially where religion is concerned. Hassan has done the correct thing by researching and forwarding this message to viewers. I hope writers and directors learn from this as nearly every single drama has a divorce taking place in it and they’re feeding incorrect information to the public who are being misled. Thank you Hassan for looking into my comments and addressing this serious issue.
In ‘Bikhray Moti’, Zulfi is expressing he is falling in love with Aizah and her reactions and panic is portrayed so beautifully. She calls her mother right away to pray for her. I think the ending is going to be very interesting, if he gets sick... how will she react. She seems to have developed a soft corner for him.
Zahid is my only fav actor~ but i agree on the discussion abt MTA!😂 it was hilarious, i actually feel bad for zahid, he deserves to do better characters then just a average man stuck between his two wifes! i honestly don't like the story of MTA. soniya and zahid both deserves better. hope to see them in better projects in future, inshallah😊
Thank you Hassan for addressing the issue regarding the triple talaq. I mentioned it after researching it thoroughly myself and I’m glad that you looked into this and addressed it to your viewers. Our writers have a responsibility to be careful when showing this to the audience as many people foolishly follow without understanding the religious fiqh behind it.
Agree with Hassan completely about the talaq process and shocked that Amina brushed it off so lightly. I feel Aamina has started arguing for the sake of arguing nowadays. Hassan had a completely valid point, that this ridiculous 3-talaq scene in multiple dramas has been done to death and they have trivialized the talaq process. Especially in a drama like Kashf, where the talaq process would have an impact on the story. Who would have thought Hassan - your opinions are increasingly more mature than Amina's!
On the topic of Talaaqs there is a very interesting trivia from the industry. Apparently long time back Sameena Peerzada and Usman Peerzada were working together in a drama and in the drama his character divorces hers by saying Talaaq 3 times and Muftis in Pakistan were up in arms that that Sameena Peerzada and Usman Peerzada are divorced in real life!! You guys can probably verify that through your sources!
I share Hassan views on muqaddar. Didnt like the character of saifu and never felt soft corner for him due to all he has done to Ryma or his the way he treated his other wife. He was a criminal who kidnapped, married someone by force, raped her. He was a criminal and should have been punished for what he has done.
And There's my PROBLEM with Jalan...The Seduction scene. That should not be shown in Pakistani television, its a scene of a sexual nature and therefore goes against our values and culture. This show should have never been made, its helping Americanize our society and therefore ruin it.
Totally agree. It has crossed all limits and is hurting our society. I'm sick and tired of Minal Khan as well, I wish she would just bugger off already
I'm sorry but literally there was no physical intimacy or vulgar words used in that scene. Whatever "Seduction" that was visually shown was merely down to the tone of voice and expressions used in the scene by the actress. Hence they played it safe in that scene and no limits were crossed in it.
@@MultiBigbird01 these scenes were unnecessary. Kids as young as 13 watch these shows and people watch them with families. Your story should have that much power where such scenes are not needed take humsafar for instance.
in muqaddar drama they should not kill saif ur rehman.they glorified him by saving raima s life.they should have shown at least a bad ending for him or a repentance what he did to raima in the starting.i am really disappointed from this drama.
Do watch Aangan if you already haven't. It was a wonderful show by the same writer director combo - Qasim Ali Mureed and Faiza Iftikhar. I believe you will love it.
Hassan and Amna you both look absolutely amazing. I love both of your smiles. More than the serials, I like watching your reviews. Honestly even when I don't watch the drama I still listen to your review. Cause they are really enlightening.
Today i watched OST of Hira Mani's new drama with Junaid. I mean they are still repeating similar plot where a husband and wife are married for 10 years and then a girl comes between them. Please ask these makers when are they gonna give us some quality content? Has Pakistani drama industry stuck in some kinda rut or what is wrong with them?
Dulhan: to answer Aamna's question as to what a woman is supposed to do when her nikaah witnesses are dead and the groom has done a runner, as in other countries, the original marriage certificate or its equivalent is always given to the bride -- never to the groom. It's the woman who keeps it because a man seldom needs it. If Pakistani dramas are anything to go by then Marriage (and divorce) laws seriously need revising and tightening in Pakistan.
The only good n best thing in Jalan is Kinza Apaa .. I loved that much strong sister!! Never seen older sister this much strong in dramas.. yes the actress played an inspirational character at least for me 👏👏
I completely agree with hassan this is the issue of our dramas they always make sure “heroes “ like all male characters even though they are playing negative characters at the end of day writers/ directors will glorify them as hero, we don’t know weather its demand from all these heroes or whatever the reason is awful . They must clearly differentiate between good and bad. Also I am agree with you hassan the back in Bollywood they put that concept of divorce and as we know Islam is very logical religion and I will request writers/directors please stop portraying religion in wrong way.
Hasan..u r right about muqaddar..thatshow we normalize by showing this all these years..that's how common people like hero like villain and no sympathy for raima... If saifurrehman wouldn't have attractive personality, do we still make him or treat him as a hero
Completely agree with Hassan on the divorce concept. I was shocked to find out that majority people in our society aren't aware of the concept of triple talaq. It doesn't exist. Makers bank on dramatization without being mindful of the fact that they're spreading wrong information among the audience.
I agree with Aamna on Muqaddar. At the end of the day, we glorify the villains like she said. Deewangi was way more problematic than muqaddar if you watched the show. He had killed his pregnant wife, aborted nageens baby by paying the doctor etc.... now coming back to Muqaddar, the show was obviously going to glorify Saif because our audience has an obsession with the male heroes. As for addressing the Stockholm syndrome, what choice did Rahima have? She married him to save Haris and the family, and after that she was completely isolated. The only person who even talked to her in those two years was Saif. The show is problematic, but most of our shows are and there won’t be a change till the mentality of the writers change. As for Hasan saying he wouldn’t mind it if this was irl, but since it’s a drama he has a problem, but that’s something we can always say that these things do happen in real life? How many woman stay in abusive relationships after being manipulated? Bad things happen. I personally feel Jalan is more problematic than Muqaddar, as is Tum Ho Wajah etc.....
Hassan Bhai & Amna,.. I love the fact how you two are able to have healthy arguments while staying respectful towards each other and Yet you guys are a perfect team of two who have different point of views but mutually appreciative of each others thoughts and opinions. Keep up the good work guys!!
I agree with hassan's views on muqadar....i really hate the character of sardar saif ur Rahman...they've glorified criminal activity like beauty and beast...its a drama but if that happen with someone in real life its not a fairy tale....and its very problematic that most of people don't understand this, they actually like women being abused, helpless and dependent....raima's character was very strong, confident and independent but they've broken her... for me it was unbearable to watch muqadar....I was hoping they'll show something about saif ur rehman's atonement, but instead they've made his first wife 'THE VILLAIN'
I’m very glad Hassan brought up a very important point about 3 talaqs. I come from Saudi Arab and there there’s no such concept as 3 talaqs being considered as 3! Our media shows the instant three talaqs always leaving a female in a very week position which is not what our religion say for females. The light has to be put on this very important subject through our media for more clarity in people.. good point Hassan 👏 👏
Thank you Hassan for commenting on 3 talaq. May Allah reward you for removing theses ignorant concepts, so entrenched in our society. It’s zulm and portrays such a bad image of Muslims around the globe of how women are treated. Jazzak Allah Khairan.
A farmaish / request for Hasan and Aamna, Please interview Wasay Chaudhry in person ( not on zoom ) for your channel. I think a wide ranging conversation between three such articulate and well informed people would be wonderful. Thank you.
Amna & Hasan - I'm just catching up on dulhan now after ur rave reviews. However, if you haven't, may I suggest that you watch Aisi Hai Tanhai starring Sami Khan & Sonya. What an epic performance by both. Thats the drama that made me really sit up and notice Sami Khan. His performance was so measured in that drama. Highly recommend
I have to agree with amna on muqaddar. Saif ur rehman ko tou glorify buhat phele hee kardia tha there was no point of killing him for his actions now. At the end of the day raima suffered saif didn't suffer at all. Raima did not get her first love haris and now when she was finally happy they killed saif. Also she is pregnant now. Also yes it was a slow episode i have been saying this since the 20th episode.
I agree with Amna on Kashf. It is a metaphorical symbolic action. Wajhdan ne jitna 27 episodes main toot ke Kashf ko chaha, uska natija yeh hua ke Talaq dete hi woh pagal hona shru ho gaya.
I just watched kashf 's sec last ep and boy it was so GOOOD! I was crying the whole time for the situation that had turned out for Kashf.. she is being torn by everyone .. no one understands what she is going through even wajdan.. and her performance once wajdan divorces her is FANTASTIC .. YOU SHED TEARS WITH HER!! KUDOS to everyone for a fantastic job ! Specially Hira mani 😍 .. looking forward for the last ep .. and during this ep I was thinking that kashf should just die .. this is beyond bearable for her.. 😭
i don't even watch Muqaddar but i feel disgusted over ppl commenting that Rahma and Saifu should've been living together happily every after.. these are the same ppl who said Hamza should've been happily married with Rumi in Ishqiya... how come and how can ppl forget the main evil plot that these antagonists have played : ( the damn guy abducted the girl no matter how good he is afterwards ..period ! like Hamza destroyed Hamna's life , no matter how good he was at the end ..period !
I did not see the Kashf episode this week but after listening ur review I'm gonna watch it for sure.... I actually follow ur channel because the reviews are very influencing...👍👍👍
Hassan is quite right I don’t know why writers don’t care about this sensitive issue please read from Quran It takes more than seven months its very much clear in Quran
To be honest all dramas are just taking awareness issues. And abusing those topics for romantic story. Example- Show a person with mental problem and romance daal do. Show honor killing, dowry whatever. But never show justice. Like in Khaani or Yakeen ka safar (That lawyer brother's story)
I totally agree with hasan when you are showing any religious matter writers and directors should do their research because they influence their audience.
Muqaddar makes no sense...and it was very wrong of haris to cry in front of his wife saying that I love raima and you have me ..that should be enough for you...only in our society can a man confess his love for another woman in front of his wife and she doesn't slap him and walk out...
Omg I love watching both of you !! so so refreshing MashaAllah always in a happy mood teasing eachother such a pleasant depiction of friendship !!! Didnt know about your channel before but now i am so so addicted to it always looking forward to seeing your episodes and interviews ! Kudos to you Hassan and Amnah Love Saba !
Jalan is helping destroy our values and society, that "Seduction" where she is touching his face and lips, It Crosses all lines. This show has to end and the actors have to be punished. This show is going in a backward direction its the opposite of Ertragrul in every way. Ertragrul is doing so well because its show Islamic values and instead of promoting shows like that, were watching Jalan and allowing it to be made? Disgusting. Lets be honest the actors could have chosen anything, Minal Khan has 6 million followers, she could have chosen a ton of different projects and the reason she did not was because all the haram garbage she has been engaged in her personal life that has led her to chose haram projects as well. Jalan does not fit her brand neither does her personal life choices. Jalan and Minal Khan's career are a perfect example of how the Pakistani industry ruins a Masoom Girls life. And Jalan has to end and Minal Khan needs to be banned from Pakistani Entertainment industry.
I am here for only 7 min of intro..cause I don't watch any of these dramas...but watch all d drams coming in next weak in review. Only here for u sir hassan and amna mam.baki mai sari videos complete dekti hu without skipping a sec..
Every time I am watching drama.. Back of the mind its going hassan aur amna is pe kia kahein ge ab.. Do interview supporting actors too. They are mostly underrated for example sabeena
MTA is an absolute nonsense show. I cannot relate to even a small prospect of its dynamic. What have they done? Keeping the religious aspects aside( and I am not saying that it's not important). If the same dynamic was bet two men and a woman. And the guys had made this same very plan and just for money one of the guy divorced his wife, and forced her to marry the other guy. It would have been a serious issue. A freaking serious issue. Nobody would have watched it then. I hate how our society is selectively critical of issues. I can't take it anymore. I love Sonya( Soniya/Sonia) a lot, and I absolutely love to watch her onscreen. Ofcourse everyone has a creative liberty. But but but this is not acceptable. So not acceptable. And I don't know Hassan and Amna if you have raised this point, but I would really like to hear both of your views on this. Kudos.
I only imagine want did d actors thought after reading d script I don't find any one scence which can be appreciated or can be taken in account d main theme of d drama could have been executed in a balanced manner n I m sorry to say that performances r vry weak
@@intriguingrat2461 ikr. It's really disappointing. And I think everyone should note on that Ulfat and Shafaq both are to be blamed for whatever misogny they had planned. This whole two wifes drama and the bad dynamic should be blamed on both. And why should Ulfat be loved the same, when she literally sold her husband to another woman for bloody money(no matter how much it was). What kind of love allows that? Pure BS. Expected better from Sonya and Zahid
Zahid ahmed is a phenomenal actor, but i agree with u guys on the discussion about MTA , actually this whole story is kinda so weird... i feel bad for zahid~he deserves to do better characters then just a average pak man stuck between his two wifes~ the story is showing nothing special, just confusion and just as u said, it's really odd~ also soniya is a brillient actress as well, looking forward to her interview~ Hope to see both of these amazing actors in better projects in future. inshallah~
Fan here from Hyderabad Deccan India We see your channel always after watching the dramas on RUclips, few important observations I would like to share , please let me know if I am right 1) there is always an ACCIDENT in any Hum Tv dramas even if it's necessary or not (eg , there was an accident of rohaan in shanakht which was not needed, but as it's a humtv drama they did). Kindly confirm if atleast 95% of all humtv dramas have accidents. 2) Mateen saab ( mere paas tum ho) never makes it to final episode of any drama he works in except few. 3) and the villian or vamp always gets away with either becoming insane or die due to accident..in last episodes..( eg jhooti..I thought she would suffer but she got away with becoming a mental patient) I like your reviews...just hope u confirm my observations. Thank you
Thanks for bringing up the talaak issue, Hassan. I wholeheartedly agree. No drama ever shows the other school of thought where despite saying talaak 3 times, it's accepted as 1 and then there's a waiting period which allows for reconciliation. It becomes so one dimensional and takes away from the wisdom of religion. Really getting fed up of these immediate talaaks being portrayed on TV. You're right - religious issues need to be portrayed more responsibly.
Exactly! Atleast before they used to show that when they gave the 3 times wale talaq there would be witnesses present...ab to phone call pe talaq ho raha hai matlab kya...?
@Sania Rehan I think your misinformed. Talaq given in a state of ighlaq according to a majority of scholars is not valid. Please research this. Majority of evidence points to this. There’s 3 types of anger. Two which come under ighlaq and one which is mild anger where it is counted.
@Sania Rehan Just because your hearing something for the first time doesn’t mean that it’s wrong. If you feel like you already know so much then you would also know that as Muslims when it comes to matter of fiqh you would always go with the majority of view and majority of evidence points towards it not being counted as three in one go. I am hanafi myself and I have reached out and researched this evidence for over a week.I can confirm that my findings are correct and let’s say for a second even if ‘it wasn’t’ then according to law and order in 1968 triple talaq was abolished in 19 countries anyway? Including Pakistan too (please research) once again this is something our scholars also have a responsibility of addressing. And ofcourse, talaq in intoxication or coercness is also not counted think about it - Our whole religion itself is based on intention. Islam itself means to submit. It contradicts the whole essence of our religion and what it teaches. Just because your scholar says so and so doesn’t mean it’s 100% correct. We as Muslims have the responsibility to seek knowledge ourselves and understand it too. Even when talaq is given in Ighlaq - anger is of three types. Then it’s counted or not counted based on what kind of anger it was. And your telling me it’s over in a matter of seconds cause the guys said it three times? Pls research!! And ofcourse Allah knows best.
Sahi treeqa yehi h k 1 waqt me 1 bar hi talaq di jaye lekin agar koi 3 talaq 1 sath deta h tb bhi wo 1 consider ki jayegi hmaray haan jo ye concept h k 3 talaq 1 sath di jaye to bs talaq ho gye to ye rule Hazrat Umar k zamanay me apply hua tha qk log bar bar talaq de kr biwiyon se sulah kr lete the is cheez ko rokne k lye Hazrat Umar Farooq ne phir 3 talaq ko hatmi talaq qarar diya imam abbu hanifa ne is ko apni book me quote kiya or pak me log imam abu haneefa ko zyada mante hn islye ye rule apply kiya jata h pak me...halan k hadith k lihaz se dekha jAye to 1 waqt me beshak jitni bhi talaq di jaye wo 1 talaq hi kehlayegi.
ruclips.net/video/VYoiugOPNj0/видео.html
We really don't need dramas like Muqaddar.What purpose has this drama served till now.Isn't it glorifying a person who harrassed ,kidnapped and forcefully married a girl.Its just like giving free license to a person that go get the girl of your choice in a criminal way ,as later your sincere love will melt her heart and you would be able to win her heart.
Just giving a motta sa name like stockholm Syndrom can't normalise or cover this whole evil concept.
haha...mota sa name..loving dis comment
Agreed
I totally agree with Hassan. Abducting a woman and forcing her into marriage against her wishes is heroic behavior? In which world, culture or religion?
I don’t watch this play, but had the producer/ director/ writer shown just one scene where the feudal lord expresses remorse for his actions to the heroine, goes and apologizes to her family that would have been helpful. Had they allowed the woman and the family members to articulate their anguish, their humiliation, their sense of helplessness in the face of his actions - that would have helped.
Even now, if they show her resuming her education and then working for the women and girls in the feudal lords village alongside her stepdaughter - that would be good. At least it will suggest a constructive way of addressing with these feudal practices entrenched in our culture.
Hasan is right - when you have such a wide reaching platform, you have a responsibility to inform and educate, not just entertain.
I agree 100%! Very wise suggestion!
Its not even entertaining bro...as a woman its insulting to watch what they've done with raima and first wife of saif ur rehman..
I agree with Hassan with his concern regarding the divorce scene in Kashf. These days divorce is so causally thrown into each drama like it's no big deal. I believe that the proper consequences of a divorce need to be shown including the technical and religious aspects of it as well so that the younger generation can learn that it is in fact not something to be taken lightly as it can destroy lives.
agreed, well said
Well said.
yep and also as a muslim we must try to learn ourselves, do our own research about those technicalities.
Since growing up i always watched in dramas with three talaqs happening and just few years back I found out thats not the case.
So many families have ruined their lives behind this wrong concept.
Totally agree with you
I agree with Hassan completely about Muqaddar. Even in Jalan, Nisha is being shown as the worst person ever. Why shouldn't Saif ur Rehman be treated the same way?
Sara Naveed ruclips.net/video/hinpY_rojg8/видео.html German VLOG
Yes Hasan is right in saying if a person has done something bad he should have been shown to pay for it. From Raima's perspective, I can understand that she has no other option now and she has accepted the incident as her fate and now is loyal and in love with her husband. But from Saif ur Rehaman's perspective, he has been bad to his first wife than he abducted this innocent girl and tortured her family and forced her into an unwanted relationship, so why did he get the punishment for all this. This shows our public that it is OK for a rich and powerful person to abduct a girl. Also they showed Farkhanda begum as villian however she is just a normal yet powerful woman who has been mistreated by her husband all her life and now she has become the killer of her husband. Why such hypocrisy?
I completely agree with Hassan on Muqaddar’s point. The content created on tv really influences people. They have glorified the character of Saif ur Rehman, its really terrible.
I agree with Hassan on Talaaq issue. I never like when people give talaaq instantaneously,..it also give impression that talaaq is so easy in Islam which is in fact not correct.
Very few scholars say that just saying three talaq at a time counts as three talaq
@@ayrizchowdhury7170 it is ijmaa of ummat. All school of thoughts say that three talaq at once is the wrong way to give, however talaq happens. Only ehle hadith and Arabic scholars say that it doesn't happen. It is a very long debate.
Agree
1:32. I am lucky that i discovered yr show and two highly educated and intellectual people 1 year back.,, who think logically and Bring fun in our daily routine, who make us laugh.... I think the viewers are more lucky than you guyz😃😃😃😃
Absolutely agree with Hassan in case of Muqaddar. Stockholm syndrome is actually reaction to a trauma which Raima also went through. They never showed the PTSD (post traumatic stress syndrome) in Raima's personality. I know somebody who went through Stockholm syndrome, but she had clear symptoms of PTSD while being in that relationship.
Can you tell more about the person? I'm just curious about how Stockholm syndrome works? How was the person affected?
Regarding Muqaddar, I agree with Hassan. The problem is that the masses of our country are not that educated and hence, they do not have critical analyzing skills. They feel what the drama-makers want them to feel and thus, in this drama they believe that Saif is a hero while, in reality, he was a villain.
How is Ulfat’s love same when she has served her husband in a platter to another woman??? That means when she’s ready to share her husband means her love is already flawed so if Shahaan’s love has become flawed Ulfat deserves it!!!
As far as I can remember,Shahan refused to marry shafaq when ulfat asked him to do so.
He decided to marry her when she(shafaq) committed suicide .
So no Ulfat isnt entirely wrong.Shahan's 360 degree change when he actually claimed to loved Ulfat is so disturbing.
@@hizanoor2721 Ulfat insisted he marry Shafaq for money, yes shahan’s attitude is disturbing but Ulfat deserves it.
Ulfat is super irritating.how is Shayan putting up with her for so long.
Agreed
Sami is showing so much variation...even in saraab, just by looking at his eyes, one can tell if he is the real asfandyar or an illusion.
Kashf's divorce scene was heart breaking and as amna said it was a performance of hira's lifetime and junaid's too...big applause
Exactly
Definitely, it was performed very well
I'm not sure if its Stockholm syndrome in Raima's case. She doesnt fall in love with Saif just because she is in captivity. In her case, it's just a compromise. She couldnt find a way out from her situation. She just accepted her fate (muqaddar). She is a practical person who just decided to give this marriage all she got in order to survive.
Oh my God hassan. Honestly im so GLAD THAT FINALLY someone from media FINALLY addressed the fact that saying talak three times means NOTHING. Its a long process for divorce. U have to wait for 3 months for the next talak and then months for third.
You’re such an educated and wise man hassan.
Thankyou for existing 🤣 ♥️and dont let amma change everything to drama :p soz amna ilytoo!
thanks for addressing serious issues i really hope you read my comment hassan :)
Thanks Manal
-- Hassan
@Manal, just to clarify that initially 3 meant 1( for emphasis 3 Times it was pronounced) in Arab culture but when people started to abuse the practice and started to keep wife for ever then in times of Hazrat Umer(RA) , the original ruling of one at a time was prevailed so after that 3 at once ( disliked) or 3 at different occasions ( preferable ) counts as 3 and irreversible.
3 as 1 in beginning was cultural thing rather than as Quranic revelation .Quranic revelation tells 3 talaq , does not mention 3 as 1 and total 9 talaq.
One crucial message given in dramas like 'Dulhan' and 'Galati' is that girls should take possession of the important documents related to their marriage. Dulhan tells that girls should have a copy of their Nikah Naama and knowledge about the whereabouts of Moulvi Sahab and both Gawah. Likewise, Galati tells that in the case of 2 Talaq, the girl should have something in written form.
There are so many movies and serials where they justify how the woman falls in love with her stalker, her rapist. I have a really difficult time accepting that Raima is the agentic subject here rather than being totally victimized by Saif's misogyny and that of the writer, director, and the audience rooting for the couple's happy ending.
Struggling with accepting Amna's take on this. Like...no!
Also i share Hasan’s school of thought re divorce. Generally speaking, in Pak dramas its very common to show men utter talaq x3 and thats that. Wrong!
Agree on the very dramatic style of Ary digital dramas lately...we watch PK dramas because they ARENT like Indian dramas. Why emulate what everyone doesnt want to watch?!
I do not watch Muqaddar, but I do watch your review on it every week. I do not understand why they glorify someone who is a criminal just because he is nice to his wife, who he kidnapped and forced her to marry him. It is sad to hear that people are upset that he dies in this week's episode. What is the message? It is okay to kidnap a girl and force her into marriage just because "he loves her"? That makes no sense to me.
I love Prem Gali though! The Dada's character is so cute with his expressions and the way he speaks. The whole "talaq le na chathi hai tou theek hai, zinda salamaat ho gi!" made me crack up! I am thoroughly enjoying Prem Gali! 😂😂
Stockholm Syndrome bohat rarely hota hai,its not so common but hamaray dramas mn her doosre character ko yeh bimari hoti hai
😂
After Jalan, another aggrieved, ill treated, innocent character, Kashif, is left to die. From normalising, abductions and forced marriages, we now have forced deaths.🙄 Amongst this madness, Prem Gali is a ray of sunshine. Apart from spreading laughter, it is sending out positive, much needed messages to the society at large, in a very appealing manner. Kudos!
I must say that whenever I see a disturbing episode of any drama , I wait to run to u guys to satisfy my irritation....by listening to ur discussion s just like my kids get irritated and run to me for help...😂
Specially Amna ❤️
I do the same ....😆😅
I couldn't agree more!
Me : Tired beyond words.Almost ready to go to bed
*something haute uploads a new video*
Me: Sleep what sleep? 🤪
Hahaha lots of love to you
-- Hassan
Exactly hassan you are so right about the comments on muqaddar! I was also shocked to read the sad comments like o my god saif died, hero ko maar detay hain, ab kya bacha dramay main!! O yaar come on! Tum logon nay saifu ko danish bana dia !
The performances of Everyone in Kashf are great... especially hira mani .. i think this is her best performance till date
I second hasan, responsibility multiplies by so many times when specially religious matters are portrayed on television. They show divorce as if peanuts.
Thank you Hassan for highlighting Star Plus dishum... dhishum...
When you both switch to Punjabi thats like 'the moment ' of fun for me! 😂
OH MY GOD HASSAN AND AAMNA..........i laughed my guts out at your hard core punjabi dig at the London wala friend in Jalan!! Hurrah!! you guys nailed it!
Same 😂
Same here 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
It’s not always about metaphorical aspect. 99.9% of the masses watch these dramas and sometimes without realising they follow what is shown blindly. It’s very easy to follow what’s shown and these are things that cannot be ignored. Especially where religion is concerned. Hassan has done the correct thing by researching and forwarding this message to viewers. I hope writers and directors learn from this as nearly every single drama has a divorce taking place in it and they’re feeding incorrect information to the public who are being misled. Thank you Hassan for looking into my comments and addressing this serious issue.
In ‘Bikhray Moti’, Zulfi is expressing he is falling in love with Aizah and her reactions and panic is portrayed so beautifully. She calls her mother right away to pray for her. I think the ending is going to be very interesting, if he gets sick... how will she react. She seems to have developed a soft corner for him.
Religious issues should be portrayed carefully like divorce and others.
Totally agree with Hasan
Hassan and Aamna's discussion about Mohabbat Tujhe Alvida....Can't stop laughing 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
It was hilarious. Trying not to say but understanding the obvious. Can see how both are so tickled. Lol.
Zahid is my only fav actor~ but i agree on the discussion abt MTA!😂 it was hilarious, i actually feel bad for zahid, he deserves to do better characters then just a average man stuck between his two wifes! i honestly don't like the story of MTA. soniya and zahid both deserves better. hope to see them in better projects in future, inshallah😊
Thank you Hassan for addressing the issue regarding the triple talaq. I mentioned it after researching it thoroughly myself and I’m glad that you looked into this and addressed it to your viewers. Our writers have a responsibility to be careful when showing this to the audience as many people foolishly follow without understanding the religious fiqh behind it.
Agree with Hassan completely about the talaq process and shocked that Amina brushed it off so lightly. I feel Aamina has started arguing for the sake of arguing nowadays. Hassan had a completely valid point, that this ridiculous 3-talaq scene in multiple dramas has been done to death and they have trivialized the talaq process. Especially in a drama like Kashf, where the talaq process would have an impact on the story. Who would have thought Hassan - your opinions are increasingly more mature than Amina's!
Absolutely agree
Absolutely not agree please study fiqa and islam than speek please don't come with out knowledge
On the topic of Talaaqs there is a very interesting trivia from the industry. Apparently long time back Sameena Peerzada and Usman Peerzada were working together in a drama and in the drama his character divorces hers by saying Talaaq 3 times and Muftis in Pakistan were up in arms that that Sameena Peerzada and Usman Peerzada are divorced in real life!! You guys can probably verify that through your sources!
Konsa drama tha ye?
I share Hassan views on muqaddar. Didnt like the character of saifu and never felt soft corner for him due to all he has done to Ryma or his the way he treated his other wife. He was a criminal who kidnapped, married someone by force, raped her. He was a criminal and should have been punished for what he has done.
Sensable talk + positivity + amazing team work +honest review + amazing friendship = something haute 💚
Loved it 😊
And There's my PROBLEM with Jalan...The Seduction scene. That should not be shown in Pakistani television, its a scene of a sexual nature and therefore goes against our values and culture. This show should have never been made, its helping Americanize our society and therefore ruin it.
Totally agree. It has crossed all limits and is hurting our society. I'm sick and tired of Minal Khan as well, I wish she would just bugger off already
I'm sorry but literally there was no physical intimacy or vulgar words used in that scene. Whatever "Seduction" that was visually shown was merely down to the tone of voice and expressions used in the scene by the actress. Hence they played it safe in that scene and no limits were crossed in it.
@@MultiBigbird01 she touches his face and lips, she lets her hands massage his face, and the whole show has been like this so don't play that nonsense
@@MultiBigbird01 these scenes were unnecessary. Kids as young as 13 watch these shows and people watch them with families. Your story should have that much power where such scenes are not needed take humsafar for instance.
Meanwhile the entire nation has been watching game of thrones full of nudity and borderline pornography.... they didn’t show any sexuality in jalan.
in muqaddar drama they should not kill saif ur rehman.they glorified him by saving raima s life.they should have shown at least a bad ending for him or a repentance what he did to raima in the starting.i am really disappointed from this drama.
Prem Gali is the only drama worth watching. True entertainment and such comic relief 🤣
Do watch Aangan if you already haven't. It was a wonderful show by the same writer director combo - Qasim Ali Mureed and Faiza Iftikhar. I believe you will love it.
Yesss!!!not to be missed
kashf------ i am agree with hassan ...... talaak is sensitive issue and it should be shown on television considering that sensitivity
Hassan and Amna you both look absolutely amazing. I love both of your smiles. More than the serials, I like watching your reviews. Honestly even when I don't watch the drama I still listen to your review. Cause they are really enlightening.
Today i watched OST of Hira Mani's new drama with Junaid. I mean they are still repeating similar plot where a husband and wife are married for 10 years and then a girl comes between them. Please ask these makers when are they gonna give us some quality content? Has Pakistani drama industry stuck in some kinda rut or what is wrong with them?
Dulhan: to answer Aamna's question as to what a woman is supposed to do when her nikaah witnesses are dead and the groom has done a runner, as in other countries, the original marriage certificate or its equivalent is always given to the bride -- never to the groom. It's the woman who keeps it because a man seldom needs it. If Pakistani dramas are anything to go by then Marriage (and divorce) laws seriously need revising and tightening in Pakistan.
The only good n best thing in Jalan is Kinza Apaa .. I loved that much strong sister!! Never seen older sister this much strong in dramas.. yes the actress played an inspirational character at least for me 👏👏
Hassan Saab. I find your way of analysis and research and depth of thinking very progressive and very supportive of women. Kudos!!
I completely agree with hassan this is the issue of our dramas they always make sure “heroes “ like all male characters even though they are playing negative characters at the end of day writers/ directors will glorify them as hero, we don’t know weather its demand from all these heroes or whatever the reason is awful . They must clearly differentiate between good and bad. Also I am agree with you hassan the back in Bollywood they put that concept of divorce and as we know Islam is very logical religion and I will request writers/directors please stop portraying religion in wrong way.
Hasan..u r right about muqaddar..thatshow we normalize by showing this all these years..that's how common people like hero like villain and no sympathy for raima...
If saifurrehman wouldn't have attractive personality, do we still make him or treat him as a hero
Hassan And Amna is like family to us , I want to gift them ethnic Rajasthani clothes as love, but unfortunately I can't in current scenario!
Loved the conversation about the friend in London...laugh out loud moment.
the MTA review was just too funny i couldn't hold my mind from wandering lol!!
Completely agree with Hassan on the divorce concept. I was shocked to find out that majority people in our society aren't aware of the concept of triple talaq. It doesn't exist. Makers bank on dramatization without being mindful of the fact that they're spreading wrong information among the audience.
Muqaddar is promoting the idea that consent doesn't matter and eventually the woman will accept it. Its so so wrong
Good sense of humor+lots of positivity+beautiful people=something haute
Thank you. Your feedback means a lot!
-- Hassan
I agree with Aamna on Muqaddar. At the end of the day, we glorify the villains like she said. Deewangi was way more problematic than muqaddar if you watched the show. He had killed his pregnant wife, aborted nageens baby by paying the doctor etc.... now coming back to Muqaddar, the show was obviously going to glorify Saif because our audience has an obsession with the male heroes. As for addressing the Stockholm syndrome, what choice did Rahima have? She married him to save Haris and the family, and after that she was completely isolated. The only person who even talked to her in those two years was Saif. The show is problematic, but most of our shows are and there won’t be a change till the mentality of the writers change. As for Hasan saying he wouldn’t mind it if this was irl, but since it’s a drama he has a problem, but that’s something we can always say that these things do happen in real life? How many woman stay in abusive relationships after being manipulated? Bad things happen. I personally feel Jalan is more problematic than Muqaddar, as is Tum Ho Wajah etc.....
Hassan Bhai & Amna,.. I love the fact how you two are able to have healthy arguments while staying respectful towards each other and Yet you guys are a perfect team of two who have different point of views but mutually appreciative of each others thoughts and opinions. Keep up the good work guys!!
I just paused at the 14th minute Hassan Bhai your views on muqaddar are just right on point . More power to you guys are the best💜
Love to watch ur all reviews and other programs...
Aamna don't reveal anything about interview details until it is done, which is very good... I personally believe in it.
I agree with hassan's views on muqadar....i really hate the character of sardar saif ur Rahman...they've glorified criminal activity like beauty and beast...its a drama but if that happen with someone in real life its not a fairy tale....and its very problematic that most of people don't understand this, they actually like women being abused, helpless and dependent....raima's character was very strong, confident and independent but they've broken her... for me it was unbearable to watch muqadar....I was hoping they'll show something about saif ur rehman's atonement, but instead they've made his first wife 'THE VILLAIN'
I’m very glad Hassan brought up a very important point about 3 talaqs. I come from Saudi Arab and there there’s no such concept as 3 talaqs being considered as 3! Our media shows the instant three talaqs always leaving a female in a very week position which is not what our religion say for females. The light has to be put on this very important subject through our media for more clarity in people.. good point Hassan 👏 👏
Thank you Hassan for commenting on 3 talaq. May Allah reward you for removing theses ignorant concepts, so entrenched in our society. It’s zulm and portrays such a bad image of Muslims around the globe of how women are treated. Jazzak Allah Khairan.
Something Haute is one of the best!
You guys literally deserve an applaud👏👏👏👏👏👏
Working whole heartedly 7 days a week is not a joke!!!
Highly appreciated 😇
Thanks Nashwa! Your feedback means a lot
-- Hassan
@@SomethingHaute 😇
A farmaish / request for Hasan and Aamna, Please interview Wasay Chaudhry in person ( not on zoom ) for your channel. I think a wide ranging conversation between three such articulate and well informed people would be wonderful. Thank you.
Uffff london wali conversation was extremely hilarious 😆 i watched it three times and still laughed a lot
Amna & Hasan - I'm just catching up on dulhan now after ur rave reviews. However, if you haven't, may I suggest that you watch Aisi Hai Tanhai starring Sami Khan & Sonya. What an epic performance by both. Thats the drama that made me really sit up and notice Sami Khan. His performance was so measured in that drama. Highly recommend
Nikah has. To be formally registered by nikah khwan with 3 copies.evidence can’t vanish.
I have to agree with amna on muqaddar. Saif ur rehman ko tou glorify buhat phele hee kardia tha there was no point of killing him for his actions now. At the end of the day raima suffered saif didn't suffer at all. Raima did not get her first love haris and now when she was finally happy they killed saif. Also she is pregnant now.
Also yes it was a slow episode i have been saying this since the 20th episode.
I agree with Amna on Kashf. It is a metaphorical symbolic action. Wajhdan ne jitna 27 episodes main toot ke Kashf ko chaha, uska natija yeh hua ke Talaq dete hi woh pagal hona shru ho gaya.
Good job guys..... entertaining, thought provoking and hopefully eye opening 👍
I just watched kashf 's sec last ep and boy it was so GOOOD! I was crying the whole time for the situation that had turned out for Kashf.. she is being torn by everyone .. no one understands what she is going through even wajdan.. and her performance once wajdan divorces her is FANTASTIC .. YOU SHED TEARS WITH HER!! KUDOS to everyone for a fantastic job ! Specially Hira mani 😍 .. looking forward for the last ep .. and during this ep I was thinking that kashf should just die .. this is beyond bearable for her.. 😭
i don't even watch Muqaddar but i feel disgusted over ppl commenting that Rahma and Saifu should've been living together happily every after.. these are the same ppl who said Hamza should've been happily married with Rumi in Ishqiya... how come and how can ppl forget the main evil plot that these antagonists have played : ( the damn guy abducted the girl no matter how good he is afterwards ..period ! like Hamza destroyed Hamna's life , no matter how good he was at the end ..period !
I did not see the Kashf episode this week but after listening ur review I'm gonna watch it for sure.... I actually follow ur channel because the reviews are very influencing...👍👍👍
True 🙋 maine bhi😂✌
Quran main talaq ka tariqa bataya hai jo teen muktalif waqt main di jati hai aik waqt main aik talaq hi consider ho gi
Hassan is quite right I don’t know why writers don’t care about this sensitive issue please read from Quran
It takes more than seven months its very much clear in Quran
MashaAllahhh Hassan bhai, I really appreciate your analysis of triple talaq. MashaAllahhh. Allah apky ilm me izafa kry or hum sbko hidayat de.
One of the most heartbreaking episodes of Kashf
Prem Gali mein Jo language msg dia wo buhat acha hai... Hamza k Ghar waly Punjabi bolty Hain aur Joya ki Nani Urdu good msg
To be honest all dramas are just taking awareness issues. And abusing those topics for romantic story. Example- Show a person with mental problem and romance daal do. Show honor killing, dowry whatever. But never show justice. Like in Khaani or Yakeen ka safar (That lawyer brother's story)
I totally agree with hasan when you are showing any religious matter writers and directors should do their research because they influence their audience.
Amna please let hassan to give his opinion too. He has also right to speak and give his opinion.
Muqaddar makes no sense...and it was very wrong of haris to cry in front of his wife saying that I love raima and you have me ..that should be enough for you...only in our society can a man confess his love for another woman in front of his wife and she doesn't slap him and walk out...
Omg I love watching both of you !! so so refreshing MashaAllah
always in a happy mood
teasing eachother
such a pleasant depiction of friendship !!!
Didnt know about your channel before
but now i am so so addicted to it
always looking forward to seeing your episodes and interviews !
Kudos to you Hassan and Amnah
Love
Saba !
Thanks Saba. Now that you know about our channel I hope you have subscribed 😊
-- Hassan
Thoroughly enjoyed this episode, bada maza aya and i love prem gali!
And yes amna its so funny when u call shafaq , “meesni”.. love u for this 😜
Jalan is helping destroy our values and society, that "Seduction" where she is touching his face and lips, It Crosses all lines. This show has to end and the actors have to be punished. This show is going in a backward direction its the opposite of Ertragrul in every way. Ertragrul is doing so well because its show Islamic values and instead of promoting shows like that, were watching Jalan and allowing it to be made? Disgusting. Lets be honest the actors could have chosen anything, Minal Khan has 6 million followers, she could have chosen a ton of different projects and the reason she did not was because all the haram garbage she has been engaged in her personal life that has led her to chose haram projects as well. Jalan does not fit her brand neither does her personal life choices. Jalan and Minal Khan's career are a perfect example of how the Pakistani industry ruins a Masoom Girls life. And Jalan has to end and Minal Khan needs to be banned from Pakistani Entertainment industry.
PREACHHH🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼
Ugh trueee.It was a gross scene.Even the scene w that Asfan in a bath robe🤮🤮🤮
@@khadijak674 which episode?
@@nasimkapadia5896 why? Emmad irfani was a part of it too. The writer, director and producer too. Dont be selective with your outrage. 🙄
Waiting for hair care video by Amna 🥳🥳🥳 much needed!
I am here for only 7 min of intro..cause I don't watch any of these dramas...but watch all d drams coming in next weak in review. Only here for u sir hassan and amna mam.baki mai sari videos complete dekti hu without skipping a sec..
Please interview Farhan Saeed for Prem Gali
Every time I am watching drama.. Back of the mind its going hassan aur amna is pe kia kahein ge ab..
Do interview supporting actors too. They are mostly underrated for example sabeena
Lol you guys made me laugh so much during MTA and jalan review! 🙌 Thankyou both of you!!
EXACTLY HASSAN!!! Everyone was UPSET with Saif dying it made no sense to me
im agree with with Hassan's point of view about muqadar
I was waiting eagerly for this episode and also amnas interview of bilal and madiha was awesome lots of love ❤❤
MTA is an absolute nonsense show. I cannot relate to even a small prospect of its dynamic. What have they done? Keeping the religious aspects aside( and I am not saying that it's not important). If the same dynamic was bet two men and a woman. And the guys had made this same very plan and just for money one of the guy divorced his wife, and forced her to marry the other guy. It would have been a serious issue. A freaking serious issue. Nobody would have watched it then. I hate how our society is selectively critical of issues. I can't take it anymore. I love Sonya( Soniya/Sonia) a lot, and I absolutely love to watch her onscreen. Ofcourse everyone has a creative liberty. But but but this is not acceptable. So not acceptable.
And I don't know Hassan and Amna if you have raised this point, but I would really like to hear both of your views on this.
Kudos.
I only imagine want did d actors thought after reading d script I don't find any one scence which can be appreciated or can be taken in account d main theme of d drama could have been executed in a balanced manner n I m sorry to say that performances r vry weak
@@intriguingrat2461 ikr. It's really disappointing. And I think everyone should note on that Ulfat and Shafaq both are to be blamed for whatever misogny they had planned. This whole two wifes drama and the bad dynamic should be blamed on both. And why should Ulfat be loved the same, when she literally sold her husband to another woman for bloody money(no matter how much it was). What kind of love allows that? Pure BS. Expected better from Sonya and Zahid
THIS. I've been saying this since the drama has aired. She sold her husband. If we change the genders the husband will be thrown behind the bars. Y
Zahid ahmed is a phenomenal actor, but i agree with u guys on the discussion about MTA , actually this whole story is kinda so weird... i feel bad for zahid~he deserves to do better characters then just a average pak man stuck between his two wifes~ the story is showing nothing special, just confusion and just as u said, it's really odd~
also soniya is a brillient actress as well, looking forward to her interview~
Hope to see both of these amazing actors in better projects in future. inshallah~
Fan here from Hyderabad Deccan India
We see your channel always after watching the dramas on RUclips, few important observations I would like to share , please let me know if I am right
1) there is always an ACCIDENT in any Hum Tv dramas even if it's necessary or not (eg , there was an accident of rohaan in shanakht which was not needed, but as it's a humtv drama they did).
Kindly confirm if atleast 95% of all humtv dramas have accidents.
2) Mateen saab ( mere paas tum ho) never makes it to final episode of any drama he works in except few.
3) and the villian or vamp always gets away with either becoming insane or die due to accident..in last episodes..( eg jhooti..I thought she would suffer but she got away with becoming a mental patient)
I like your reviews...just hope u confirm my observations.
Thank you
Ya you are right...quite uncanny how u think..
Something haute ..please respond