ruclips.net/video/Ogh0xKwbWj8/видео.htmlsi=DGxVkwpHjMns200p Would love to see you react to this video. PTX performed in a tribute to John Williams and sang the star wars theme a cappella at first then joined by a symphony orchestra. The costumes alone were something else.
This is a standard song for them to perform off mic. I actually like it a lot when it's performed in such an intimate way. When they do it on stage or in this recording, I'm less drawn to it. It's still obviously great, because it's Pentatonix. But in the future when you one day need stuff to react to, I think the private performance versions of these are worth a listen. It's just one of those songs that is really elevated by them hearing each other with their naked ears and just existing in that feeling.
I wait for your PTX reactions. Thank you for this. Your analyses of Pentatonix music is so fascinating; I look forward them them over any other reactor. (I wish you did more. 😉)
Thank you so much! I'd love to do one every day 😅 But I'm able to do 4-5 videos a week, and need to show other artists some love too - so I hope roughly 1 PTX video a week is pretty good going for now (And it means I won't run out of PTX videos as quickly )
I was so lucky! A VIP ticket to a PTX concert used to include a private concert--just 10 fans in a dressing room with Pentatonix (and a few staff), and they would sing one song--no microphones, just 5 singers, standing just inches away from us. And when I was there, they chose to sing "Valentine." My daughter had never heard that song, and she was mesmerized. It would have been so much safer for them to choose a more choral song, full of pretty harmonies and occasional scrunchy chords. But they chose this quirkly little song with intricate timing that could easily go wrong forty different ways--and of course, they nailed it. This song reminds me of the displays of Swarovski crystals at the company store in Austria. Sharp, clear, brilliant, and somehow both cold and warm at the same time. Amazing. I really appreciate your transcriptions of the arrangements. They are a perfect accompaniment to your acute analyses. Thank you.
I don't know what I enjoy more, if it's the musical analysis or the faces you make when you listen to the song. I can see the love and fascination you have for the music, and I love that 🙌🏻
They "beautified" the original to me. In Pentaholic terms, they "upgraded" it. I had forgotten this one and I really love it! I like the sort of disjointed beginnings then the move to the beautiful melodious sections. Having not heard the original until today, I might not have even attempted to hear it from PTX. The sweet singing of Mitch is heartwarming for me. He doesn't always perform with this sweet voice. He's always in great voice, but this one feels very innocent. They were so young here. I love your open mindedness of giving it a try anyways and it was clear from your face that there were parts that really got to you. When you play it on a keyboard, I find it really lovely for my ears. I never get tired of your style of reactions. Are "Can't Hold Us (Macklemore Ryan Lewis), "Say Something", Can't Help Falling In Love" by Elvis covers and their original made about the time of Daft Punk medley called "Love Again" on your list? Thank you once again!
Yes, Mitch's voice did sound particularly sweet in this one! And yes, all 4 of those are on my list (alongside over 40 other PTX songs, not including Superfruit or anything 😅) We'll get there....in time
Yaaaaaaaaasssssss! I was so hoping you would react to this cover today! I love it. That intro is so clever. I love it when PTX covers an unconventional song like that and give it such a fresh approach. Another such cover is Come Along from Cosmo Sheldrake... it’s all over the place and yet catchy. It is from the Matt Sallee era so I will patiently wait. Happy Valentine Day to everyone! ❤️🤗
Oh the live off mic version of this definitely needs to be heard. They used to do this for their vip groups when there was maybe 10 people at most watching. So the cell phone videos hold up. Plus its a couple years later than this video and you know how Mitch keeps getting better and better as he ages. Ptx getting such a beautiful arrangement out of this original reminds me of their cover of the song Come Along. The original is very weird and not very melodic, but somehow ptx make it work even with the weird lyrics. I guess it will be awhile until you get to it though since its in the Matt Era. I wouldn't be opposed to you mixing the eras up. Just saying there's a lot of good stuff since Matt joined too.
There is a live version of this that is quite excellent by PTX! Would have loved to see you react to the live one! It's off mic and glorious! This will have to do for now! Your reactions amaze me! You're the best! Thank you!
517 views and 208 likes! I hope this shows how much we Pentaholics appreciate your fantastic analyses, even if some other artists might bring in more overall views. I'd actually never heard the original and I really enjoyed your comparison and comments. I've also never really listened to Avi, Kirstie and Scott's individual lines in that one part abd I've always been a bit confused by it, so thanks for going into detail on that!
Great breakdown of a song that always confused me a bit. I remember thinking what am I listening to, and why do I like it? lol. Happy Valentine's Day! ❤
Yes, you've exposed me to songs I hadn't heard. So thank you! I became a super fan just this past summer. I fell madly in love with Mitchell Grassi and his angelic voice and can't get enough of the songs I found.
Very different but then this is PTX. One cannot pigeonhole their music style. I think they have such a large fanbase in all age categories because of this (imo). "Complex" is a good description. Thanks again for the reaction I've come to expect. 😊
Wow, almost 300 listens in just the first hour, you’re doing great! I had never had the impulse to go look up the original, now it looks like I will, so thanks. Lovely reaction, full of information that I would never be able to pick out on my own. You’re the best! Peace …
@@SirHairlessI’m not really impressed with the original, it seems disjointed and out-of-focus somehow. Now, if I heard it on repeat while cooking, it may just grow on me … but I much prefer the PTX version.
Babytonix, how young they are! I have no idea how I missed this in my Pentaholic binging times, I am kind of geeking out about the interesting time changes and crystal chime effect of their voices, I can really see them enjoying this, more challenging than a traditional song, fun like Making Christmas, which is Awesome vocally and visually, I am not a Nightmare Before Christmas person, but musically I was immediately fascinated by the complexity, Mitch had even commented that it was musically the most difficult song to date. I love the clarity of Mitch’s countertenor, so pure and pleasant. Wonderful to see a flashback with Avi too. Thank you Sir Hairless ❤
I haven't heard this one before! They are just masterful arrangers aren't they, as well as great singers. This level of synergy is so rare. Mitch's vocals are always stellar and Scott's voice so velvet. Kirstin's distinctive timbre took the back seat here to allow Mitch to stand alone. Avi kept his line subtle and supportive, while Kevin, as always, held the whole thing together with his complex layers and qualities of rhythm. { Just reflecting on what Kevin might have done if he'd continued to complete his medical studies. Would he have been humming or beat boxing while conducting surgeries?! } ... Which reminds me... A few years back I was having a nerve block in my neck, under what they called "a light anaesthetic' {ie; not as deep under as a 'general' but enough not to be fully conscious } Woke up, briefly, on the trolley being wheeled back to Recovery Unit, with the Aneathetist walking beside me, grinning. Seeing I was awake, he said; "So, you're a bit of a Blues singer!" " Jazz too..." I blurrily replied, before dropping straight back to sleep. Later, I woke up properly and went; "Whaaaaaat!?" "What happened!?" They must have had some background music going in Theatre, and I must have burst into song! I can just imagine the pandemonium as he was trying to place the needle precisely at the right nerves by my spinal chord. Were they dashing about shouting; " Hold Her STILL!" " CUT The MUSIC!! 😵 I was desperately curious to find out - but there was ONE big question that held me back - and it was this... As I went under, that Anaethetist had his back to me, bending over, and my last conscious thought was; " What a nice arse that man has! ... ... ... " Horrifying! Did I talk about his arse whilst under - as well as sing??? 😵💫🥴😰 Was too chicken to ring him and find out...
😅 I was left a bit confused by the original version as well. There are some songs from Jesse Ware that I like but this was not one of them. Then PTX covers it and W🤩W!! I LOVE this song now and to me it's hauntingly BEAUTIFUL! This song was a standard for vip fans in the Avi era. There are a lot of fan clips of them singing this beautifully live, no mics.
First time hearing this song. Love it. Love how you break things down for those of us who are not musically trained it is like a music appreciation class. I have learned so much.
Yay! Didn't expect a PTX reaction today; what an eggcellent reaction! I have actually never heard this song, (shocker) so I wasn't prepared with their parts and lyrics, but alas, the main lyrics were on screen (closed captioning doesn't always work with music.) Then, you went and slapped the lyrics and their parts on the screen.... #BRILLIANT. Oh my gosh! I have tears in my eyes. This one was so easy for never having heard it. Thank you, thank you, thank you. I'm so blessed and grateful.
Please never apologize about the details you provide. For many of us that is why we subscribe. If you are interested in Mitch and Scott-you might want to listen to Superfruit.
Yes yes YES!!! A MILLION TIMES YES! As much as I love PTX, I absolutely adore Superfruit. I rewatch their channel bc they are just too funny and their music... superb. I can't pick a favorite but the Beyonce and Empire mashups are so so good and Nicki Minaj/Beyonce Feeling Myself are mesmerizing. Katy Perry's Rise with Mario Jose , Brian Justin Crumb, and Mary Lambert have brought tears to so many reactors as well as myself because it's just so overwhelming especially when you know the story behind the collaboration. When you do react, as I know you will at some point, don't forget to watch beyond the "subscribe' ....Bloopers to make us all laugh. Mitch and Scott have such a wonderful chemistry it's undeniable. They are soul mates...bff no doubt. I truly have been hoping everyday that you've chosen them for a reaction. Can't wait to see if you like them as much as their fans do. Happy Valentine's Day!!!
Oh my God! I loved it!!! Never heard this. Didn't really get into them until Mary Did You Know came about. Didn't watch when they were on the TV Show. Thank you again for analyzing the music. I want to hear again over and over
Loved the breakdown and attention to detail. That beginning, I had no idea. Just makes me appreciate again how good PTX is and how I simply am not musically talented. I didn't even pick up on that stuff and can't imagine ever being able to come up with stuff like that. Keep em coming. Thoroughly enjoy the way you break down these songs.
I'm treating myself with my national Shapsugian music today, but saw the notification and thought to at least say hello and give another 👍 for spending a holiday on it. Have a nice evening, Sir
Happy Valentine's Day, Sir Hairless! I always enjoy your breakdowns, thanks. Avi just posted a short of My Funny Valentine. It's gorgeous! I'll leave a link, not to react to, just for your enjoyment. Cheers!
Wishing a day filled with love to you and all who commemorate Valentine's today! Here in Brazil Valentine's day is celebrated on June 12, and today we're actually celebrating the closure of our longer and happier national holiday: the Carnaval!🎉🎊
Thank you! I have some friends celebrating over in Rio at the moment and it looks so sunny - I'm so jealous ☀ Our sun over here at this time comes in the form of this music 🎶
@@SirHairlessWow, that’s very cool😃Next year you should try to join your friends and come to Brazil to celebrate Carnaval with us in our tropical Summer!🏖Now I got curious to know what music style you prefer to listen during this wintery time in UK?🎶
It did look very fun And sunny...I've forgotten what the sun is! It doesn't exist in my land @@Maria...-mo5qm Music style is just a wide range of things! But not my 'summer' songs which tend to be a bit more upbeat and happy. But, as you can imagine, a lot of my music listening now is through Sir Hairless as this takes up every single second of my free time 🎶
Happy Valentines! It is a gorgeous Texas morning here! Finished a painting last night and framed it this morning. Love can be terrifying…..but love never fails!
I love this song, though I've never heard the original. As always, Mitch's vocal gymnastics blow me away, and he always sticks the landing. Wait--that's real gymnastics. 🤪 I really like the part at "'cause I know about my love" where the harmonies do that smooth slide (musical terms: what are they? 🤷♀️) When I'm "enjoying" another night of insomnia and listening to the radio, I love it when PTX's versions of this and "We Are Young" come on, though I don't like the original of that song. Wow, I'm wordy today! 😆
I don't know of a term for that! The term for sliding between notes in music is glissando, so maybe chord-glissandi Sorry to hear about the insomnia At least you're listening to some nice music
Yay! I really hoped you'd do this one on Valentine's Day! Another great reaction and analysis. I know what you mean, it is a bit confusing as a song, but I actually think it's perfect for Valentine's Day because it has so much feeling and Mitch's voice always grabs me by the heart - especially on this one and The Prayer. Honestly, he could sing the phone book to me or a shopping list and I still think he would make me feel emotional. You have done some Dimash reactions now. His voice is technically probably the best in the world but he just doesn't move me the way Mitch does. As you say there is multi tracking on this video here, but just for your own interest (and I would love to hear what you think!) do watch this private performance of Valentine. It is just them, no mics, nothing. They all stand in a line with their eyes shut and are so in tune with each other it's unbelievable. ruclips.net/video/ARRWlFndZkA/видео.htmlsi=KS9NEdwlaf4_wKN1. Mitch and Scott's voices sound so beautiful together - it's evident on this one and The Prayer, plus all the Superfruit songs. The back and forth between them on the Prayer is one of the most beautiful things I'ver ever heard in my 54 years! On some of the Superfruit videos you can see Scott shut his eyes and just appreciate Mitch's voice - I'm thinking in particular of Hiphop goes Broadway I think either 1 or 2? Superfruit is less PG just as a warning! For another really emotional one which really features Kirstie watch 'Say Something'. It's beautiful. She's also the lead on 'Rather be' and 'Shallow'. They really don't have egos about who features the most on songs - they always want to serve the music and use the best voice for each arrangement. If you want to see how they work with their arranger Ben Bram (the 6th member of Pentatonix!) I would watch the making of Evergreen - you will find it fascinating from a musician's perspective! Thank you again - as always I'm sad that I have to wait another whole week before you do another PTX one! Thank you for enriching my musical life!
Thanks for the comment, Anita! I imagine I'll be polling something Superfruit-related in the weeks or months to come, not sure what yet but they are getting recommended ever so much now All three you mentioned where Kirstie has the lead are on my list👌Watching Evergreen has also been recommended a lot, but some others mentioned it may contain musical spoilers for songs I've not yet heard, so it's a bit tricky
@@SirHairlessThat is fair enough re Evergreen and you haven't got to the 'Matt years' in your PTX reactions yet so maybe best to wait for that one till you've done some of those maybe at Christmas as Evergreen was a festive album. You have a long way to go in your PTX journey - and I for one can't wait!
Ahh yes! I’d hoped you might do this song… and after thinking about your deep dive into it, I think I’m glad I hadn’t heard the original, although it was interesting (&jarring) to see the clips. I’m really curious which of them suggested covering it! This is quite early on for them. There’s a vulnerability in the beginning, then Mitch’s part feels more confident, reassuring. Speaking of Mitch, the part you pointed out how tightly his vocals with Scott dance around, it reminds me of a lot of their Superfruit music. I look forward to whenever you to that. So do you think it aided your R/A of the song to hear the original first? Thinking of Kiiara’s Gold here, where you avoided the original until you’d done the PTX version. Hope you had a lovely Valentine’s Day, Thanks for this treat
I'd love to know which of them suggests each song they do! I'd love to know their music tastes on a personal level Yes, I've seen a number of comments about Superfruit. I mentioned in another comment reply that I'll probably incorporate Superfruit into a poll within the next weeks/months (not sure how just yet) To your question about listening to the original song first....I think it's pot luck really 😅Whilst I try to go into every reaction from a completely neutral perspective, I think there are some psychological biases that are simply unavoidable. If you think the original song is the best song you've ever heard, it's highly unlikely a cover version can top it and so you (subconsciously) may notice the "off" bits in the cover more than usual But, in general, I think listening to the original first is a good idea - especially when drawing on the comparison to make points. With 'Gold' I was still very early on in my PTX journey and decided against listening to the original as I wasn't that familiar with PTX and would probably be focussing on comparisons vs the original rather than the singers themselves So going forward, it's likely I'll listen to the originals first (at least in most cases, I imagine!)
@@SirHairless That’s a very helpful response.. I would bet you’re familiar already with most popular songs that artists cover, but then there’s the random Gold or Valentine, and your answer makes good sense. Now wouldn’t it be so great if ptx would preface or conclude each cover with how they decided to ‘make it their own’, and who brought it to the group as a suggestion to cover?! Now and then in interviews or discussions they may reference that info. And I’m sure Ben Bram has a big role in all aspects. Their own channels are a great way to learn about their individual interests and styles. And I’m sure that exploration is on your calendar for someday I hope you plan on doing this for a very long time because we’ll never get to the entire catalogs of everything… especially since they are reportedly busy working on new music now
I learn so much from your Pentatonix reactions. Thank you. I love Pentatonix version of "Valentine" and never noticed that Kirstin, Scott and Avi were singing lines, not just random words. Silly me. Great reaction!!! For your own entertainment or for a reaction, please check out Pentatonix live performances of the song. They sang it off-mic quite often so there are fan-recorded videos of their beautiful performances.
Always appreciate the analysis and breakdown from someone who understands music and music theory as much as you do, and your honest reaction to both the original and the PTX cover. I have to admit, this has never been one of my favorite PTX offerings. It's obviously a very complex arrangement, and their performance is top-notch, but I just don't think I'm a fan of the song itself - and while PTX may be able to "upgrade" many songs in their covers, this one just doesn't hit the mark for me.
The original is kind of jarring to the ear, I don’t know how I feel about it lol. But I’m glad PTX saw something in it and created this beautifully chill song. Would love to see you break down another PTX one that doesn’t get much reactor attention, Somewhere Over the Rainbow. 😊
@@SirHairlessyes sir, no video. It's one of the songs in their Classics album that includes BH, Can't help falling in love, Take on me (a killer), and Jolene, the Grammy award winning collab with Dolly Parton
Not many reactors react to this song. Which is sad to me. This is still one of my favs that PTX did. I don't mind the original either, as I had heard it before, being I'm a fan of Jessie Ware already. Oddly, I came to understand the song itself in greater depth because of their cover. Anyway, great reaction, I enjoyed it.
Yeah, when you hear "Valentine" you think "love song", but this is like a Halloween love song. Kind of scary and yet pretty. It is one of my all-time favorites because I didn't know the original and because the harmonies are so beautiful. I love learning about many unique artists through PTX. Each part here is carefully woven together, and it was one of the first videos where Mitch and Scott (aka Scomiche) sang a duet as the main part in a song, and it had to be a love song. Thanks for another great reaction.
I think of this song as almost Superfruit (with PTX accompaniment), mainly because of those tight octave runs - Scott and Mitch do that a *lot* on the Superfruit album. It reminds me of a little youtube "Happy Birthday" that they put up for Jazmin Sullivan, all in crazy runs an octave apart. It goes off the rails a bit at the end, but it's pretty impressive. ruclips.net/video/f0nMsJQVBps/видео.html
This may not be your taste but it is a Kevin Olusola, Pentatonix, showing his creativity. He sings, beat box and plays the electric cello. I hope you listen and enjoy.
Thank you for your in depth analyses. There is a female vocalist that I would love to see you react to. Her name is Lucy Thomas, and she has the most pure, beautiful voice. A couple of her latest are bridge over troubled water and evergreen.
Happy Day of the Valentine to you (whatever that means 🤷🏼♀️?) I can’t say that this is one of the go back to often, never knew why until now. I like it when I hear it though so 🤷🏼♀️? Thank you 🙏! T ✌🏻
Wow wow wow. I found the original more irritated me. While Pentatonix were more confused. Like you would say "In a good way". Thanks once again foe clearly explaining that.😅
That's my favorite performance, but the original video has better sound quality. You cannot hear Avi Kaplan's overtones in the live performance because it's an amateur video from a cell or camera, but it is second level PTX for certain. Everyone asks "where's Kevin?" If one watches closely they will see Mitch move center stage while Avi is trying to blow the speaker system. And Scott move to Mitch's spot leaving room for Kevin at the end. He is there but the video focuses on Mitch mostly. You may want to consider a double reaction to both the original video and Singapore Star Vista. But no doubt the live performance is crazy good. I mentioned Aha Singapore when you first began reacting but advised that you may want to get to know the group a little better. I believe you're there. You analysis of songs makes you different from others, so I believe you have had enough exposure to react to that one. Imogene Heap should be proud. THEY SLAY IT
Here is a nice live performance that you might enjoy. I've only heard live on a phone recording but this is a live show: ruclips.net/video/DHwF54IL2Ys/видео.htmlfeature=shared
@@SirHairless We'll they have an official video of "Problem" also, you could do that one and the Live right after to compair, I just think the Live one is great also.
I agree with your confusion about this song. I don't like it. The lyrics get lost because there's not a good flow in the music so it's difficult to relate to the song. The music is choppy and disjointed and ptx do a good job of emulating that feeling. Your breakdown does make it musically more interesting than I previously thought of it but I still don't like it 😂
Check out my other Pentatonix reactions in this playlist! ruclips.net/p/PL-tAjLxAAkA9QsmC8pTH2x4La4cIws5Us
ruclips.net/video/Ogh0xKwbWj8/видео.htmlsi=DGxVkwpHjMns200p Would love to see you react to this video. PTX performed in a tribute to John Williams and sang the star wars theme a cappella at first then joined by a symphony orchestra. The costumes alone were something else.
Thanks for the recommendation!@@lizziefrances
You have become a Must Listen. I so enjoy your analyses.
Yes! Exactly
Thank you
Same. Click okay as soon as I see it in my feeds
You being a classical musician, I can’t wait til you react to Pentatonix’s version of The Prayer
This is a standard song for them to perform off mic. I actually like it a lot when it's performed in such an intimate way. When they do it on stage or in this recording, I'm less drawn to it. It's still obviously great, because it's Pentatonix. But in the future when you one day need stuff to react to, I think the private performance versions of these are worth a listen. It's just one of those songs that is really elevated by them hearing each other with their naked ears and just existing in that feeling.
I agree, it was as beautiful in private hospital room
strongly agree
ruclips.net/video/2EoOEAos_2w/видео.htmlsi=ome1w4_L152y9S6K !!
The dynamics and Kevin’s beatbox! With no mics! Crazy
I wait for your PTX reactions. Thank you for this. Your analyses of Pentatonix music is so fascinating; I look forward them them over any other reactor. (I wish you did more. 😉)
Thank you so much! I'd love to do one every day 😅 But I'm able to do 4-5 videos a week, and need to show other artists some love too - so I hope roughly 1 PTX video a week is pretty good going for now (And it means I won't run out of PTX videos as quickly )
Again, I'm appreciating your attention to your fans - and the music - wishing you a happy heart
I was so lucky! A VIP ticket to a PTX concert used to include a private concert--just 10 fans in a dressing room with Pentatonix (and a few staff), and they would sing one song--no microphones, just 5 singers, standing just inches away from us. And when I was there, they chose to sing "Valentine." My daughter had never heard that song, and she was mesmerized. It would have been so much safer for them to choose a more choral song, full of pretty harmonies and occasional scrunchy chords. But they chose this quirkly little song with intricate timing that could easily go wrong forty different ways--and of course, they nailed it. This song reminds me of the displays of Swarovski crystals at the company store in Austria. Sharp, clear, brilliant, and somehow both cold and warm at the same time. Amazing.
I really appreciate your transcriptions of the arrangements. They are a perfect accompaniment to your acute analyses. Thank you.
Wow, sounds like an amazing experience - very cool!
I don't know what I enjoy more, if it's the musical analysis or the faces you make when you listen to the song. I can see the love and fascination you have for the music, and I love that 🙌🏻
All the songs you analyze turn into brand new songs for me because I didn't hear half the music. Oh what joy! 😊
🎶🎶🎶
All these years of devoted PTX listening and this is the first time I've heard this. How did I miss it?
PTX arrangement skills are hard to beat. I believe they can see and hear the vision of the song. Masterful.
They "beautified" the original to me. In Pentaholic terms, they "upgraded" it. I had forgotten this one and I really love it! I like the sort of disjointed beginnings then the move to the beautiful melodious sections. Having not heard the original until today, I might not have even attempted to hear it from PTX. The sweet singing of Mitch is heartwarming for me. He doesn't always perform with this sweet voice. He's always in great voice, but this one feels very innocent. They were so young here. I love your open mindedness of giving it a try anyways and it was clear from your face that there were parts that really got to you. When you play it on a keyboard, I find it really lovely for my ears. I never get tired of your style of reactions. Are "Can't Hold Us (Macklemore Ryan Lewis), "Say Something", Can't Help Falling In Love" by Elvis covers and their original made about the time of Daft Punk medley called "Love Again" on your list? Thank you once again!
Yes, Mitch's voice did sound particularly sweet in this one! And yes, all 4 of those are on my list (alongside over 40 other PTX songs, not including Superfruit or anything 😅)
We'll get there....in time
only 40 other's? LOL This will be so fun! @@SirHairless
Yaaaaaaaaasssssss! I was so hoping you would react to this cover today! I love it. That intro is so clever. I love it when PTX covers an unconventional song like that and give it such a fresh approach. Another such cover is Come Along from Cosmo Sheldrake... it’s all over the place and yet catchy. It is from the Matt Sallee era so I will patiently wait. Happy Valentine Day to everyone! ❤️🤗
Oh the live off mic version of this definitely needs to be heard. They used to do this for their vip groups when there was maybe 10 people at most watching. So the cell phone videos hold up. Plus its a couple years later than this video and you know how Mitch keeps getting better and better as he ages. Ptx getting such a beautiful arrangement out of this original reminds me of their cover of the song Come Along. The original is very weird and not very melodic, but somehow ptx make it work even with the weird lyrics. I guess it will be awhile until you get to it though since its in the Matt Era. I wouldn't be opposed to you mixing the eras up. Just saying there's a lot of good stuff since Matt joined too.
People always say PTX doesn't do covers, they do upgrades
There is a live version of this that is quite excellent by PTX! Would have loved to see you react to the live one! It's off mic and glorious! This will have to do for now! Your reactions amaze me! You're the best! Thank you!
Happy Valentine's Day!
Thanks so much for analyzing this one. To me, it is so beautiful but seems quite complex to my ears. So, as always, I appreciate your breakdowns.
Your reaction is a wonderful Valentine’s Day present to all of your fans!
Thank you for reacting to some of the older and lesser known PTX songs ❤
I'm so enjoying watching you take this journey.
Thank You for another outstanding reaction/analysis of a PTX arrangement. I always feel a little smarter after your reactions.
517 views and 208 likes! I hope this shows how much we Pentaholics appreciate your fantastic analyses, even if some other artists might bring in more overall views. I'd actually never heard the original and I really enjoyed your comparison and comments. I've also never really listened to Avi, Kirstie and Scott's individual lines in that one part abd I've always been a bit confused by it, so thanks for going into detail on that!
Great breakdown of a song that always confused me a bit. I remember thinking what am I listening to, and why do I like it? lol. Happy Valentine's Day! ❤
I appreciate your reaction. Thanks for showing parts of the original to help explain PTX deviation choices. For sure their arranging is stellar. ❤❤❤❤❤
I am enjoying your reactions sooo much. Thank you. It's great that you pick so many of the lesser known ones!
Yes, you've exposed me to songs I hadn't heard. So thank you! I became a super fan just this past summer. I fell madly in love with Mitchell Grassi and his angelic voice and can't get enough of the songs I found.
Very different but then this is PTX. One cannot pigeonhole their music style. I think they have such a large fanbase in all age categories because of this (imo). "Complex" is a good description. Thanks again for the reaction I've come to expect. 😊
You: ...I can't do it 😂😂😂.
Congratulations, your analysis are always on spot.
PTX are talented human beings (🦄🦄🦄🦄🦄).
Wow, almost 300 listens in just the first hour, you’re doing great! I had never had the impulse to go look up the original, now it looks like I will, so thanks. Lovely reaction, full of information that I would never be able to pick out on my own. You’re the best! Peace …
Let me know your thoughts on the original! I'm still undecided 😅
@@SirHairlessI’m not really impressed with the original, it seems disjointed and out-of-focus somehow. Now, if I heard it on repeat while cooking, it may just grow on me … but I much prefer the PTX version.
Babytonix, how young they are! I have no idea how I missed this in my Pentaholic binging times, I am kind of geeking out about the interesting time changes and crystal chime effect of their voices, I can really see them enjoying this, more challenging than a traditional song, fun like Making Christmas, which is Awesome vocally and visually, I am not a Nightmare Before Christmas person, but musically I was immediately fascinated by the complexity, Mitch had even commented that it was musically the most difficult song to date. I love the clarity of Mitch’s countertenor, so pure and pleasant. Wonderful to see a flashback with Avi too. Thank you Sir Hairless ❤
Always so informative with your reactions. Really appreciate it.
I was waiting for precisely this. Never even seen this video. Greetings from South Africa
I haven't heard this one before! They are just masterful arrangers aren't they, as well as great singers. This level of synergy is so rare. Mitch's vocals are always stellar and Scott's voice so velvet. Kirstin's distinctive timbre took the back seat here to allow Mitch to stand alone. Avi kept his line subtle and supportive, while Kevin, as always, held the whole thing together with his complex layers and qualities of rhythm.
{ Just reflecting on what Kevin might have done if he'd continued to complete his medical studies. Would he have been humming or beat boxing while conducting surgeries?! }
... Which reminds me...
A few years back I was having a nerve block in my neck, under what they called "a light anaesthetic' {ie; not as deep under as a 'general' but enough not to be fully conscious } Woke up, briefly, on the trolley being wheeled back to Recovery Unit, with the Aneathetist walking beside me, grinning. Seeing I was awake, he said; "So, you're a bit of a Blues singer!" " Jazz too..." I blurrily replied, before dropping straight back to sleep. Later, I woke up properly and went; "Whaaaaaat!?" "What happened!?" They must have had some background music going in Theatre, and I must have burst into song! I can just imagine the pandemonium as he was trying to place the needle precisely at the right nerves by my spinal chord. Were they dashing about shouting; " Hold Her STILL!" " CUT The MUSIC!! 😵
I was desperately curious to find out - but there was ONE big question that held me back - and it was this... As I went under, that Anaethetist had his back to me, bending over, and my last conscious thought was; " What a nice arse that man has! ... ... ... " Horrifying! Did I talk about his arse whilst under - as well as sing??? 😵💫🥴😰 Was too chicken to ring him and find out...
Haha thanks for the story!
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you! This song has always left me confused. You've helped to clear it up sort of.
😅 I was left a bit confused by the original version as well. There are some songs from Jesse Ware that I like but this was not one of them.
Then PTX covers it and W🤩W!! I LOVE this song now and to me it's hauntingly BEAUTIFUL!
This song was a standard for vip fans in the Avi era. There are a lot of fan clips of them singing this beautifully live, no mics.
Not only do I appreciate your analysis, but you are very nice to look at. ❤️😉
😅Thank you
Great job as always. PTX is so much fun!
When you tell the story about the song and learning the education of the notes you enjoy the song so much
First time hearing this song. Love it. Love how you break things down for those of us who are not musically trained it is like a music appreciation class. I have learned so much.
Yay! Didn't expect a PTX reaction today; what an eggcellent reaction! I have actually never heard this song, (shocker) so I wasn't prepared with their parts and lyrics, but alas, the main lyrics were on screen (closed captioning doesn't always work with music.) Then, you went and slapped the lyrics and their parts on the screen.... #BRILLIANT. Oh my gosh! I have tears in my eyes. This one was so easy for never having heard it. Thank you, thank you, thank you. I'm so blessed and grateful.
I'm happy to hear the musical notation was useful! Now you can add another PTX song to your knowledge base
Please never apologize about the details you provide. For many of us that is why we subscribe. If you are interested in Mitch and Scott-you might want to listen to Superfruit.
Yes yes YES!!! A MILLION TIMES YES! As much as I love PTX, I absolutely adore Superfruit. I rewatch their channel bc they are just too funny and their music... superb. I can't pick a favorite but the Beyonce and Empire mashups are so so good and Nicki Minaj/Beyonce Feeling Myself are mesmerizing. Katy Perry's Rise with Mario Jose , Brian Justin Crumb, and Mary Lambert have brought tears to so many reactors as well as myself because it's just so overwhelming especially when you know the story behind the collaboration. When you do react, as I know you will at some point, don't forget to watch beyond the "subscribe' ....Bloopers to make us all laugh. Mitch and Scott have such a wonderful chemistry it's undeniable. They are soul mates...bff no doubt. I truly have been hoping everyday that you've chosen them for a reaction. Can't wait to see if you like them as much as their fans do. Happy Valentine's Day!!!
Very nice analysis of video. Appreciated!
Oh my God! I loved it!!! Never heard this. Didn't really get into them until Mary Did You Know came about. Didn't watch when they were on the TV Show. Thank you again for analyzing the music. I want to hear again over and over
Really enjoy your analysis - thank you
I appreciate the breakdown. This song has been a favorite of mine for a long time.
They also have this live , very impressive . You might like to look at it
I haven’t heard this before- I really love it. It’s pretty!
💖 A/R.
Happy Valentine’s Day
Everyone!💖🎵💖
Thanks for my Valentine's Day gift -- You are just wonderful -- !!
❤
thank you. I love this song
Loved the breakdown and attention to detail. That beginning, I had no idea. Just makes me appreciate again how good PTX is and how I simply am not musically talented. I didn't even pick up on that stuff and can't imagine ever being able to come up with stuff like that. Keep em coming. Thoroughly enjoy the way you break down these songs.
I'm treating myself with my national Shapsugian music today, but saw the notification and thought to at least say hello and give another 👍 for spending a holiday on it. Have a nice evening, Sir
Really appreciate your analysis - helps me think.
🙌
OMG I have been waiting for you to find this one...
I love your thorough analysis of this song, as usual. Thank you for reacting to this.
Excellent, I could listen to that all day.
Fascinating commentary as usual 💜 As others have mentioned, the live off-mic version of this is gorgeous.
this is one of my most listened tracks. im always excited when you post ptx reactions, and this one is amazing as usual
Thank you
Happy Valentine's Day, Sir Hairless! I always enjoy your breakdowns, thanks.
Avi just posted a short of My Funny Valentine. It's gorgeous! I'll leave a link, not to react to, just for your enjoyment. Cheers!
Ahh I love that song, particularly Matt Damon's cover from 'The Talented Mr Ripely'
@SirHairless the link I provided disappeared. I hope you found it and enjoyed it 😊
What a wonderful breakdown and analysis of this song. I now like it even more than I have in the past.
It’s even more amazing live. It made me cry.
Wishing a day filled with love to you and all who commemorate Valentine's today! Here in Brazil Valentine's day is celebrated on June 12, and today we're actually celebrating the closure of our longer and happier national holiday: the Carnaval!🎉🎊
Thank you! I have some friends celebrating over in Rio at the moment and it looks so sunny - I'm so jealous ☀ Our sun over here at this time comes in the form of this music 🎶
I should remember that. Here, 🇵🇭 it's the national independence day
@@SirHairlessWow, that’s very cool😃Next year you should try to join your friends and come to Brazil to celebrate Carnaval with us in our tropical Summer!🏖Now I got curious to know what music style you prefer to listen during this wintery time in UK?🎶
@@BethVargas-uw6qqI hope you had a wonderful holiday in Philippines :) Greetings from Brazil!✌
It did look very fun And sunny...I've forgotten what the sun is! It doesn't exist in my land @@Maria...-mo5qm
Music style is just a wide range of things! But not my 'summer' songs which tend to be a bit more upbeat and happy. But, as you can imagine, a lot of my music listening now is through Sir Hairless as this takes up every single second of my free time 🎶
Happy Valentines! It is a gorgeous Texas morning here! Finished a painting last night and framed it this morning. Love can be terrifying…..but love never fails!
I love this song, though I've never heard the original. As always, Mitch's vocal gymnastics blow me away, and he always sticks the landing. Wait--that's real gymnastics. 🤪 I really like the part at "'cause I know about my love" where the harmonies do that smooth slide (musical terms: what are they? 🤷♀️) When I'm "enjoying" another night of insomnia and listening to the radio, I love it when PTX's versions of this and "We Are Young" come on, though I don't like the original of that song. Wow, I'm wordy today! 😆
I don't know of a term for that! The term for sliding between notes in music is glissando, so maybe chord-glissandi
Sorry to hear about the insomnia At least you're listening to some nice music
Yay! I really hoped you'd do this one on Valentine's Day! Another great reaction and analysis. I know what you mean, it is a bit confusing as a song, but I actually think it's perfect for Valentine's Day because it has so much feeling and Mitch's voice always grabs me by the heart - especially on this one and The Prayer. Honestly, he could sing the phone book to me or a shopping list and I still think he would make me feel emotional. You have done some Dimash reactions now. His voice is technically probably the best in the world but he just doesn't move me the way Mitch does.
As you say there is multi tracking on this video here, but just for your own interest (and I would love to hear what you think!) do watch this private performance of Valentine. It is just them, no mics, nothing. They all stand in a line with their eyes shut and are so in tune with each other it's unbelievable. ruclips.net/video/ARRWlFndZkA/видео.htmlsi=KS9NEdwlaf4_wKN1. Mitch and Scott's voices sound so beautiful together - it's evident on this one and The Prayer, plus all the Superfruit songs. The back and forth between them on the Prayer is one of the most beautiful things I'ver ever heard in my 54 years! On some of the Superfruit videos you can see Scott shut his eyes and just appreciate Mitch's voice - I'm thinking in particular of Hiphop goes Broadway I think either 1 or 2? Superfruit is less PG just as a warning!
For another really emotional one which really features Kirstie watch 'Say Something'. It's beautiful. She's also the lead on 'Rather be' and 'Shallow'. They really don't have egos about who features the most on songs - they always want to serve the music and use the best voice for each arrangement. If you want to see how they work with their arranger Ben Bram (the 6th member of Pentatonix!) I would watch the making of Evergreen - you will find it fascinating from a musician's perspective!
Thank you again - as always I'm sad that I have to wait another whole week before you do another PTX one! Thank you for enriching my musical life!
Thanks for the comment, Anita! I imagine I'll be polling something Superfruit-related in the weeks or months to come, not sure what yet but they are getting recommended ever so much now
All three you mentioned where Kirstie has the lead are on my list👌Watching Evergreen has also been recommended a lot, but some others mentioned it may contain musical spoilers for songs I've not yet heard, so it's a bit tricky
@@SirHairlessThat is fair enough re Evergreen and you haven't got to the 'Matt years' in your PTX reactions yet so maybe best to wait for that one till you've done some of those maybe at Christmas as Evergreen was a festive album. You have a long way to go in your PTX journey - and I for one can't wait!
Empire Medley. @@SirHairless
Maravillosas armonías. Felíz día de los enamorados de la música. un abrazo de madre, como siempre
Ahh yes! I’d hoped you might do this song… and after thinking about your deep dive into it, I think I’m glad I hadn’t heard the original, although it was interesting (&jarring) to see the clips. I’m really curious which of them suggested covering it! This is quite early on for them. There’s a vulnerability in the beginning, then Mitch’s part feels more confident, reassuring. Speaking of Mitch, the part you pointed out how tightly his vocals with Scott dance around, it reminds me of a lot of their Superfruit music. I look forward to whenever you to that. So do you think it aided your R/A of the song to hear the original first? Thinking of Kiiara’s Gold here, where you avoided the original until you’d done the PTX version. Hope you had a lovely Valentine’s Day, Thanks for this treat
I'd love to know which of them suggests each song they do! I'd love to know their music tastes on a personal level Yes, I've seen a number of comments about Superfruit. I mentioned in another comment reply that I'll probably incorporate Superfruit into a poll within the next weeks/months (not sure how just yet)
To your question about listening to the original song first....I think it's pot luck really 😅Whilst I try to go into every reaction from a completely neutral perspective, I think there are some psychological biases that are simply unavoidable. If you think the original song is the best song you've ever heard, it's highly unlikely a cover version can top it and so you (subconsciously) may notice the "off" bits in the cover more than usual
But, in general, I think listening to the original first is a good idea - especially when drawing on the comparison to make points. With 'Gold' I was still very early on in my PTX journey and decided against listening to the original as I wasn't that familiar with PTX and would probably be focussing on comparisons vs the original rather than the singers themselves
So going forward, it's likely I'll listen to the originals first (at least in most cases, I imagine!)
@@SirHairless That’s a very helpful response.. I would bet you’re familiar already with most popular songs that artists cover, but then there’s the random Gold or Valentine, and your answer makes good sense. Now wouldn’t it be so great if ptx would preface or conclude each cover with how they decided to ‘make it their own’, and who brought it to the group as a suggestion to cover?! Now and then in interviews or discussions they may reference that info. And I’m sure Ben Bram has a big role in all aspects. Their own channels are a great way to learn about their individual interests and styles. And I’m sure that exploration is on your calendar for someday I hope you plan on doing this for a very long time because we’ll never get to the entire catalogs of everything… especially since they are reportedly busy working on new music now
I love your explanations. Brings a new view for me.❤
I learn so much from your Pentatonix reactions. Thank you. I love Pentatonix version of "Valentine" and never noticed that Kirstin, Scott and Avi were singing lines, not just random words. Silly me. Great reaction!!! For your own entertainment or for a reaction, please check out Pentatonix live performances of the song. They sang it off-mic quite often so there are fan-recorded videos of their beautiful performances.
Always appreciate the analysis and breakdown from someone who understands music and music theory as much as you do, and your honest reaction to both the original and the PTX cover. I have to admit, this has never been one of my favorite PTX offerings. It's obviously a very complex arrangement, and their performance is top-notch, but I just don't think I'm a fan of the song itself - and while PTX may be able to "upgrade" many songs in their covers, this one just doesn't hit the mark for me.
Never heard this before .What a strange song, but i like it. Love Kevins beat boxing.
The original is kind of jarring to the ear, I don’t know how I feel about it lol. But I’m glad PTX saw something in it and created this beautifully chill song. Would love to see you break down another PTX one that doesn’t get much reactor attention, Somewhere Over the Rainbow. 😊
Thanks! This is on my list - it doesn't have a video, right?
@@SirHairlessyes sir, no video. It's one of the songs in their Classics album that includes BH, Can't help falling in love, Take on me (a killer), and Jolene, the Grammy award winning collab with Dolly Parton
@@SirHairlesscorrect, no video. So it’s really a fun guessing game of who the heck is singing what part 😂
Not many reactors react to this song. Which is sad to me. This is still one of my favs that PTX did. I don't mind the original either, as I had heard it before, being I'm a fan of Jessie Ware already. Oddly, I came to understand the song itself in greater depth because of their cover. Anyway, great reaction, I enjoyed it.
There are several live versions of this where they are just standing in an office break room and the performances are perfect
Yeah, when you hear "Valentine" you think "love song", but this is like a Halloween love song. Kind of scary and yet pretty. It is one of my all-time favorites because I didn't know the original and because the harmonies are so beautiful. I love learning about many unique artists through PTX. Each part here is carefully woven together, and it was one of the first videos where Mitch and Scott (aka Scomiche) sang a duet as the main part in a song, and it had to be a love song. Thanks for another great reaction.
I think of this song as almost Superfruit (with PTX accompaniment), mainly because of those tight octave runs - Scott and Mitch do that a *lot* on the Superfruit album. It reminds me of a little youtube "Happy Birthday" that they put up for Jazmin Sullivan, all in crazy runs an octave apart. It goes off the rails a bit at the end, but it's pretty impressive. ruclips.net/video/f0nMsJQVBps/видео.html
Again A MILLION TIMES YES FOR SUPERFRUIT
Time to check out Superfruit!
This may not be your taste but it is a Kevin Olusola, Pentatonix, showing his creativity. He sings, beat box and plays the electric cello. I hope you listen and enjoy.
Hi Sandra, I think you didn't include the link or song name you were referring to
I’ll bet you wish it was PTX’s version that was repeating over and over while you were cooking! 😉❤️
You're not wrong there
PTX🔥🤘
Thank you for your in depth analyses. There is a female vocalist that I would love to see you react to. Her name is Lucy Thomas, and she has the most pure, beautiful voice. A couple of her latest are bridge over troubled water and evergreen.
Thank you for the recommendation!
Happy Day of the Valentine to you (whatever that means 🤷🏼♀️?) I can’t say that this is one of the go back to often, never knew why until now. I like it when I hear it though so 🤷🏼♀️? Thank you 🙏! T ✌🏻
Haha a day we celebrate the patron saint of epilepsy!
Wow wow wow. I found the original more irritated me. While Pentatonix were more confused. Like you would say "In a good way". Thanks once again foe clearly explaining that.😅
One of my favorites❤ did you react to "Aha" perfomed in Starvista at Singapore?
That's my favorite performance, but the original video has better sound quality. You cannot hear Avi Kaplan's overtones in the live performance because it's an amateur video from a cell or camera, but it is second level PTX for certain. Everyone asks "where's Kevin?" If one watches closely they will see Mitch move center stage while Avi is trying to blow the speaker system. And Scott move to Mitch's spot leaving room for Kevin at the end. He is there but the video focuses on Mitch mostly. You may want to consider a double reaction to both the original video and Singapore Star Vista. But no doubt the live performance is crazy good. I mentioned Aha Singapore when you first began reacting but advised that you may want to get to know the group a little better. I believe you're there. You analysis of songs makes you different from others, so I believe you have had enough exposure to react to that one. Imogene Heap should be proud. THEY SLAY IT
⚡⚡🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥⚡⚡
You should check out "What We Need Is Love" by Home Free. It is a 5 part harmony with no vocal percussion. Amazing!
Another song is In The Blood by Home Free. Amazing 5 part harmony!
Here is a nice live performance that you might enjoy. I've only heard live on a phone recording but this is a live show:
ruclips.net/video/DHwF54IL2Ys/видео.htmlfeature=shared
Another great reaction. Could you react to PENTATONIX - Problem (Ariana Grande ft. Iggy Azalea cover) | 3FM Live. just a fun live performance.
Thanks for the recommendation - I haven't received that one before!
@@SirHairless We'll they have an official video of "Problem" also, you could do that one and the Live right after to compair, I just think the Live one is great also.
I just found this video of them singing Valentine live in dressing room. Just amazing…. ruclips.net/video/2EoOEAos_2w/видео.htmlfeature=shared
🀄🀄 .. I am sorry , Sir Hairless , but I do not speak Japanese....
😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳
I agree with your confusion about this song. I don't like it. The lyrics get lost because there's not a good flow in the music so it's difficult to relate to the song. The music is choppy and disjointed and ptx do a good job of emulating that feeling. Your breakdown does make it musically more interesting than I previously thought of it but I still don't like it 😂
How do you always pick out something CRAZY which I never knew as a 10 year pentaholic fan🫨🫨 Love your analysis so much
Guess you need to keep watching all my Pentatonix reactions
Happy Valentine's Day!
PTX🔥🤘