Комментарии •

  • @kathleenkaffeine8696
    @kathleenkaffeine8696 2 года назад +28

    I was waiting for someone to do a roundup like this. Thank you so much!

    • @jessbz
      @jessbz 2 года назад +2

      Me too!

  • @sarahroot3650
    @sarahroot3650 2 года назад +13

    I've been loving the new Patrick Ta palette! It's just so pretty and easy to use, I've loved every look I've done w it so far. I love how the shimmers are more like toppers so they give you that "effortless ethereal" look. Also- I've noticed this palette really lasts really well on the eyes. I wore it the other day on a 13 hour work shift and when I got home at night, I couldn't believe how good my eye makeup still looked!!

    • @amiraking6688
      @amiraking6688 2 года назад

      Would you say that second to last more reddish looking shimmer is reddish I don’t want it if it pulls browner on skin

  • @leanneharrison5750
    @leanneharrison5750 2 года назад +11

    The Patrick Ta Rose palette was actually my first ever rose toned palette, it was the first one that I literally could not stop looking at and I have no regrets!

  • @rachelapalmieri
    @rachelapalmieri 2 года назад

    Yupppp I LOVE the p. Ta rose palette 😍😍😍 I’m obsessed

  • @AmeerahMuhammad
    @AmeerahMuhammad 2 года назад +23

    Gemini II is my personal favorite. That depth works well for those with deeper skin tones. And I prefer a bit of grunge to super pink and rosey. I was underwhelmed by the Patrick Ta. It’s very samey-samey in tone to me.

    • @dariavision
      @dariavision 2 года назад +2

      I agree. The Melt is my favorite. I like my roses to be moody!

  • @sunshinemayday
    @sunshinemayday 2 года назад +7

    Love 200% of this look on you🌹

    • @zusamy20
      @zusamy20 2 года назад

      Same , she looks so pretty

  • @mus1quenonst0p
    @mus1quenonst0p 2 года назад +13

    i really like the patrick ta palette, too. i wish there was just a bit more cool tone to it like new mod, but those shimmers make it so that i don’t have to even pull in my indie multis, which is nice. although-putting a devinah moonscape shade on the inner portion of the lid for a pop of even more glitz (and the ta shimmers on the rest of the lid) with this palette is 🔥

    • @BreezyStreamy
      @BreezyStreamy 2 года назад +3

      I used my Kaleidos' Space Age Prophecy/Gifted and OMG!!!!!!!

    • @Iamyl4
      @Iamyl4 2 года назад +2

      Do you own the original? How do you compare? Same formula?

    • @mus1quenonst0p
      @mus1quenonst0p 2 года назад +1

      @@Iamyl4 i don’t have the original. i wasn’t a fan of the tones in that one. from what i hear, though, the shimmers are even better this time around, and there’s no sequin matte shade. there is one satin shimmer (the darkest red), which i like for the outer corner, and the other shimmers are all the glitzy pretty ones. the mattes are great and apparently the same as MD1, as well as the creams.

  • @zusamy20
    @zusamy20 2 года назад +8

    For me I still love my Divine Rose 1 and 2 + Ritualistic Rose. 🥰

    • @cherylb_88
      @cherylb_88 2 года назад +2

      Divine Rose 2 is one of my favorite palettes ever

  • @RaineInKS
    @RaineInKS 2 года назад +13

    I was on the fence about buying the Sigma palette and Natasha Denona's Retro palette. I went with the Retro palette. 💗

  • @ra.j7210
    @ra.j7210 2 года назад +6

    Charlotte tilbury knows how to make a woman look beautiful. I'm such a fan

  • @caseykikay8014
    @caseykikay8014 2 года назад +6

    I'm loving the new Charlotte Tilbury quad! I know the value is horrible, but I really do get a lot of use out of them. I just got my Bridgerton II palette and can't wait to play around with it.

  • @brendahernandez8920
    @brendahernandez8920 2 года назад

    Yes Patrick ta is my number 1 right now

  • @brittanyyost3094
    @brittanyyost3094 2 года назад +7

    I need all these palettes !!! I am buying a new palette this weekend and now I’m lost on which I should get. I LOVE NARS EYE SHADOWS I feel like they r not talked about as much as they should be

  • @ericabender4406
    @ericabender4406 2 года назад +4

    I love my CT Dream pallet!! It’s so beautiful on my oily hooded eyelids! I’ve been tempted to pick up Patrick Ta as well. Oh the decisions

  • @jujubeeens
    @jujubeeens 2 года назад

    Patrick Ta reigns supreme!!! 🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🔥🔥🔥❤️❤️❤️

  • @becm963
    @becm963 2 года назад +13

    I felt that.. I hear the word “sale” and I also become a monster. I bought three palettes in April after telling myself that I was not going to buy makeup. That Nars palette was one of them, as a last minute addition. I started with Patrick Ta Major Dimensions II Rose palette. The original Melt Gemini palette was the only one that was on my long time wishlist. It finally came back in stock on April 1st.

  • @biogirl1381
    @biogirl1381 2 года назад

    yesssss, i knew who the top 2 would be but the rest of the ranking was fun!!! “i am the problem”. 😂😂😂

  • @pawsitivecattitude6363
    @pawsitivecattitude6363 2 года назад +1

    Thank you, Morgan for doing this comparison! 😊

  • @angeliquemcfarland171
    @angeliquemcfarland171 2 года назад

    Girl, you are not alone.

  • @matildeosorio8257
    @matildeosorio8257 2 года назад

    I love, love, love rose palettes! I am part of the problem too! I agree with your top two. Thank you for this ranking!

  • @lavayuki
    @lavayuki 2 года назад

    The Patrick Ta one is my favourite for all the shimmers. I love shimmer shades so the more the merrier for me

  • @kaylarenebeauty5644
    @kaylarenebeauty5644 2 года назад

    Yes, I guessed your rankings perfectly! I personally love the color story of Gemini 2 but I also love my Patrick Ta palette

  • @AnnieS22
    @AnnieS22 2 года назад

    So glad you made this video! Grabbing a cup or tea now! 😊👍🙏

  • @staceyb3007
    @staceyb3007 2 года назад

    I literally just GOT ON the rose-tone eyeshadow wagon so I am stoked they keep doing more and more! ❤

  • @jeanninet.5010
    @jeanninet.5010 2 года назад +1

    I was very lucky. I ordered the Patrick Ta palette from Sephora on line and mine was perfect when it arrived!

    • @AllyKit
      @AllyKit 2 года назад

      Mine too. I think it helped that mine was a single order, with no other products in the box to bounce up against. Because god knows my grumpy UPS man just drops sh*t from 4 feet high rather than actually bend over and set down. 🤦🏻‍♀️

  • @zusamy20
    @zusamy20 2 года назад

    The look today 🥰

  • @mollyjane01
    @mollyjane01 2 года назад

    I am in love with most all of these 🌹-colored palettes you just listed in this video 🤤🤤. I know we have plenty but I fall for them every.single.TIME! I love it & can’t get enough!!! Lol. I know what looks I’ll be creating for my Spring season here in Iowa!! Thanks for doing this video, Morgan. 🥀🥀😘😘

  • @technicolortabby4239
    @technicolortabby4239 2 года назад

    I've seen a few YTers not raving about the Gemini II but I've been loving all of the looks I've made with it it and it's super easy to work with. I've really been loving it.

  • @RaquelCamilo258
    @RaquelCamilo258 2 года назад

    Appreciate how detailed you are when describing formulas and textures because we share the same taste and that helps me decide what to buy and what to skip! Thank you!

    • @cherylb_88
      @cherylb_88 2 года назад

      She is always so thorough which is what I love the most

  • @mirandaquinnn
    @mirandaquinnn 2 года назад

    The Patrick Ta palette is amazing 👏 😍 🥰🥰🥰🥰. Love it 😘😘

  • @natalie-gz5bq
    @natalie-gz5bq 2 года назад +1

    I ran to get the Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Dreams and I adore it 😍

  • @julianaaoki327
    @julianaaoki327 2 года назад

    After all these rose palette releases, I had been definitely looking forward to this video showing up on your channel!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️loved your ranking, it makes a lot of sense!

  • @Kayd2111
    @Kayd2111 2 года назад

    I have not tried any of the others but I absolutely adore the Patrick Ta palette 😍😍😍

  • @Rosie4540
    @Rosie4540 2 года назад +8

    The NARS palette isn't getting much hype because it's "boring" but I love it. It has everything you need, no fall out, none of the colors are repetitive within the same palette (they look distinctly different on the lid), has pigment but is still really easy to use and blend. What more do you want?! I've done such a good gold, matte brown, pink, and mauvy eye! And I haven't even done all the combos yet. The best. I traveled with it and it held up well. 😍

  • @nataliebaer13
    @nataliebaer13 2 года назад +1

    Ohhh yessss I’m definitely part of the problem! 😂🤣 Patrick Ta has my vote for #1 also! 😍

  • @louisewarren6472
    @louisewarren6472 2 года назад

    Makeup looks beautiful!!!!

  • @lauralangley7240
    @lauralangley7240 2 года назад

    Morgan, I love your reviews, eye makeup looks and this Charlotte Tillbury pillow talk is just amazing on you and tutorial on this look would be awesome. . . Ty.

  • @denisesheffield481
    @denisesheffield481 2 года назад

    I can't wait to wear my new Charlotte Tilbury Luxury, Melt's Gemini 2 and PMG Bridgerton 2 palettes!! PMG has so many Rose themed palettes that I own and love. I keep eyeing Give Me Glow's new rosy palette, it looks so pretty!Nice picks.

  • @barbarabain1477
    @barbarabain1477 2 года назад

    Looks beautiful CT 🤩🤩🤩

  • @shans8635
    @shans8635 2 года назад +4

    I haven't been able to put down Gemini II! I'm honestly surprised at how much I love it. But I'm darker than you so the lighter shades in the palette work really well to use to lighten the look. And sometimes I just really love an all matte look.

  • @sparklewithmuskan3890
    @sparklewithmuskan3890 2 года назад

    Love this!! Waiting for your norvina 6 review😍

  • @amynoonan4236
    @amynoonan4236 2 года назад +1

    I have the Patrick Ta palette and I am not even envious of the other palettes in this video. If any, I would like the Charlotte Tilbury quad.

  • @iamsarahyoo
    @iamsarahyoo 2 года назад +1

    I'd love to see a comprehensive comparison or rankings of all the popular rose palettes and not just the newer ones... So including the mauve Natasha one and the pat divine rose ones... Charlotte, Etc

    • @MrsP714
      @MrsP714 2 года назад

      Great suggestion! I know I love my ND Retro, but I am intrigued to know where it would fall on her list.

  • @kittycloud6693
    @kittycloud6693 2 года назад

    Rosy tone palettes alwats get me too. Nice to have a ranking.

  • @bedazzled64
    @bedazzled64 2 года назад +1

    "the Sephora sale comes and I become a monster" HAHA no truer words said

  • @danielacastaneda2923
    @danielacastaneda2923 2 года назад +1

    I love your videos and your energy ✨️ 💕

  • @lubazak636
    @lubazak636 2 года назад +1

    I love, love, love Charlotte Tilbury dreams quad. I never liked the pillow talk original quad because it was too light, too close to my skin color and disappeared. I like the mattes in Gemini 2. I bought 1 and 2 to wear with my Adept shimmer or mostly shimmer pallets.
    Got the Patrick Ta but haven’t used it yet.
    Looks great even though I will not be using the creams because of my oily lids.

  • @tinnuriel9972
    @tinnuriel9972 2 года назад

    Yesterday I was watching Patty Alonso doing a similar video and I am happy to see you doing one as well!!!!!!
    As for rose tones….. I finally bought Devine rose 1 yesterday as a bday present to myself 🥰

  • @annemarietimmerman7213
    @annemarietimmerman7213 2 года назад +1

    HI dear Morgan, another beautiful and very honest video again, thanks so much!!!🤩🤩🤩🤩 I bought from 2 Bridgerton releases only that 2nd eyeshadow palette you showed, loved it! Love the new CT quad as well, but more to combine with her other eyeshadows, but i always mix and match. The Patrick Ta is not yet at Cult Beauty, but i don't know yet, actually i love a colourstory like his first palette the most. Have an amazing day!!!😘😘😘😘

  • @wendywilliams4042
    @wendywilliams4042 2 года назад

    I love rose everything and I'm not ashamed!

  • @neidy8009
    @neidy8009 2 года назад

    Love your top two can't afford any of them but really love them ❤️

  • @yaffarealbeauty6089
    @yaffarealbeauty6089 2 года назад

    I am officially hooked on the Charlotte Tilbury glimmer. I use rose tones sometimes but I prefer a more concise palette. Her Dreams quad is so deep and dramatic. Love it! I also have the ND Retro so I’m good. Thanks for ranking the quality too.

  • @erica1898
    @erica1898 2 года назад

    So pretty! I have not tried any of these palettes either lol!

  • @barbarabain1477
    @barbarabain1477 2 года назад

    Yep. Mature lids is a classy way to say my lids 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

  • @kandikane5548
    @kandikane5548 2 года назад

    I love my PT pallet 🤩🤩

  • @notimportant123
    @notimportant123 2 года назад

    I've been waiting for this videoooo! I like the PT, PML Divine Rose 2, Primrose, Cor De Rosa

  • @kerriwright4593
    @kerriwright4593 2 года назад

    I really want to try the Patrick Ta formula. It's so pretty looking. I've loved everyone's looks with the first one and I love pink tones. I'm typically like a peacock with my looks but everyone needs a classy rose palette. I honestly haven't tried any of these palettes.

  • @shanerobinson4892
    @shanerobinson4892 2 года назад

    So excited for this 🤩

  • @BreezyStreamy
    @BreezyStreamy 2 года назад

    I've been loving my MDII as well! I bought mine online as soon as Sephora let people start buying it and I haven't looked back since. I'm not into mattes, but this is the first palette that I actually go for the mattes. I can't use the creams unless for liner, but I don't mind,

  • @LucisZ39
    @LucisZ39 2 года назад

    Gemini 2 is the only one I have and I love it a lot more than I thought I would. I don’t really prefer rose tones on myself. I think they make me look rather ill. Gemini’s got just the right undertones where it’s warm but not orange and those neutral olives pair really well with it. I wore those neutral olives with the olive toned smoke reflect from Auric and it was a perfect match up.

  • @Alaf_63
    @Alaf_63 2 года назад

    PMG Divine Rose is my favorite pink palette followed by ND Retro. I haven't picked up any of the new releases since I already have both.

  • @barbarabain1477
    @barbarabain1477 2 года назад

    I would like more roses 🌹 in my vases!! 🥰

  • @KK-ht6rz
    @KK-ht6rz 2 года назад

    Mam can u plz do a blush collection video with swatches..I really love your blush collection💕💕

  • @annaleander
    @annaleander 2 года назад

    Thanks Morgan! I always enjoy your videos 💖 - I picked up the CT and PMGL. I like the CT palette but have only used it once. I think I like the PMGL palette but I’m so annoyed by the customer service and delays and such with her recent launches that I just have a bad taste in my mouth about it and haven’t been inspired to even try it - it does look pretty though and I’m guessing as soon as I use it I’ll fall in love 🤷🏼‍♀️

  • @that_girl555
    @that_girl555 2 года назад

    Morgan, I’d love to see you do a bridal look with Patrick Ta products, similar to your CT one. I’m not sold on this palette yet, but I love his vibe, blush tones and the lipsticks I’ve seen. I don’t do many rose looks, and I’d like to see your Take on Ta.

  • @edwardleecaliforniausa
    @edwardleecaliforniausa 2 года назад

    Good morning happy Friday morning and I just wanted to say that your vlogs makes me feel happy and you are sweetheart and I loved your vlogs and you are amazing Supporter

  • @brendatompeterson8401
    @brendatompeterson8401 2 года назад +1

    I'm loving the Patrick Ta palette and Bridgerton 2 palettes. You need to try give me glow Cosmetics. She just released a rose toned palette, two moods. The formula is amazing

  • @kristenc.5468
    @kristenc.5468 2 года назад

    I just got the Charlotte Tilbury palette in the mail today. It’s the only one of these palettes that I own. I don’t really own any other rosy palettes that I can think of. The Sigma palette has been on my wishlist, and the Nars palette is really appealing to me, but not sure if I’ll buy either of them. I think the ND Retro palette is probably the rose colored palette that I would choose next.

  • @lornahamm3193
    @lornahamm3193 2 года назад

    I love your rankings videos and you're just amazing 👏 😍 🥰🥰💜💜💜💜💜💜🔥👍💋

  • @kellycastillo241
    @kellycastillo241 2 года назад

    The ones on the lower half of your list are the ones on my wish list. I just think the nars, supreme mauves, and new mod are so beautiful. Nars is the one I think I’ll end up picking up eventually though.

  • @gabrielsworld6331
    @gabrielsworld6331 2 года назад

    Pat McGrath is the best and has amazing quality. Enjoyed this video.❤️

  •  2 года назад

    love!

  • @samanthamagnus3741
    @samanthamagnus3741 2 года назад

    Thanks for this tutorial, so helpful to choose a rose palette when you do vids like this :) I am waiting for the Patrick Ta palette to come to Cultbeauty as our Sephora doesn't stock it :( I am also thinking of getting the Sigma palette :) And now I am really looking at the NARS palette...I am such a sucker for baby pink glittery shades! Thanks again for this awesome vid, love your content

  • @kerriwright4593
    @kerriwright4593 2 года назад

    I've been debating about getting the nars palette but I do have 2 nars palettes and they're almost the same as each other and this new one. I haven't had any issues with their formulas though. It's really pretty though.

  • @Marina-vd
    @Marina-vd 2 года назад

    I don’t like rosy palettes but man the look is so stunning I’m thinking about checking up the Charlotte Tilbury palette hahha ok you convinced me it does look good and sophisticated

  • @makeupdatewithjacki8959
    @makeupdatewithjacki8959 2 года назад +3

    The top rose palette on my list right now is the Two Moods by Give Me Glow! Next would be the Sigma New Mod and then I think Patrick Ta@

  • @julianapurvis3461
    @julianapurvis3461 2 года назад

    This video sparked my memory…who remembers the old Milani 12 pan palette called Pure Passion? I just got mine out, dusted it off, and holy cow is it an amazing rose palette! The quality is sooooo good (they have completely different formulas now sadly). If you still have it, I recommend It highly. It even has 2 duochromes and beautiful mattes/shimmers. I have no idea how Milani was making things this good from so long ago.

  • @ViDaoNoww
    @ViDaoNoww 2 года назад

    I’m proud to say that the only rose toned palette I bought was the new CT pillow talk dreams palette just bc I collect her quads. I honestly am sick of rose and don’t really like rose tones on me so I haven’t bought a pml palette in a hot minute since all her palettes have been pink and rose tones. I’m a neutral gal all the way unfortunately..

  • @zusamy20
    @zusamy20 2 года назад

    The Rose overdose!

  • @myrnaaguilar4034
    @myrnaaguilar4034 2 года назад

    I swear your so cute! 🥰 I have 2 out of the list but now I have to buy the Charlette Tilbury one lol like if I need it

  • @Tseana1
    @Tseana1 2 года назад

    I wasn’t going to buy the Patrick Ta but I bought it yesterday with my Sephora points and got $15 off.
    I just got the Bridgeton one and haven’t used it yet.
    I also have the Nars I’ve used it once so my opinion is still out with that one. Love eyeshadow it’s my fave.

  • @sylviannepoitras9405
    @sylviannepoitras9405 2 года назад

    Wow! Thanks for this rose dreamers review! I’m crazy about the sigma rose mod new palette but I enjoy the Huda beauty nude light and the rose quartz palette as well! I would like to know your thoughts about these 2? Continue the good work! I just discovered you! 🌸🌼🌺💕 hope for more videos!

  • @KBellaBeauty1
    @KBellaBeauty1 2 года назад

    I definitely guessed your #1!

  • @rabbiroz3806
    @rabbiroz3806 2 года назад +1

    Interesting ranking. Where would you put Natasha Denona Retro and Huda Naughty, New Nudes, or Rose Quartz? Of the ones you ranked, my favorite is the Sigma New Mod, but I haven't tried the Charlotte Tilbury Quad yet. I was underwhelmed by the Genesis II and I think I'm going to return the Artist Couture one.

  • @kat1701
    @kat1701 2 года назад

    I focus on Jewel tones but I got the Patrick Ta palette and it’s soooo yummyyy (it did arrived shattered 😭 hurt my heart for a moment until they sent me a new one)

  • @barbarabain1477
    @barbarabain1477 2 года назад

    You’re awesome 🤩

  • @susieramirez223
    @susieramirez223 2 года назад

    I like lorac unzipped palette. Not exactly rose but a rose gold toned. Oldie but a goodie

  • @veronicamcminn7775
    @veronicamcminn7775 2 года назад

    I can’t get enough of the cream shadows. I would buy an all cream palette. Edit Patrick Ta cream shadows

  • @barbarabain1477
    @barbarabain1477 2 года назад

    NARS is awesome!!!

  • @kerriwright4593
    @kerriwright4593 2 года назад

    I'd probably use lighter shimmers with the melt palette.

  • @venessacandelaria9385
    @venessacandelaria9385 2 года назад

    I was super excited for the Artist Couture eye palette but unfortunately it was not good. I returned mine. So sad because the colors were very pretty.

  • @maryfletcher3906
    @maryfletcher3906 2 года назад

    Bought the artist couture supreme mauves from Sephora during the sale then remembered I have similar shades from Sydney grace and Pat Mcgrath, so did not need it. Luckily i was able to cancel.

  • @AllyKit
    @AllyKit 2 года назад

    Yes girl! I am the problem 😬

  • @oomma5
    @oomma5 Год назад

    What about the ND retro?

  • @sherryfreer5562
    @sherryfreer5562 2 года назад

    I am definitely the problem too 🤣

  • @annagorbenko5923
    @annagorbenko5923 2 года назад +6

    I personally returned Patrick Ta rose palette, it's way too warm toned on my eyes, made me look sick. I stick to mothership 7&8 instead whenever I want rosy look. The light cream shadow is very close to CT pillow talk cream shadow and pink gliter shade to Hourglass Aura, as I already thave those, Patrick Ta palette wasn't adding to my collection

  • @jillrenaebeauty3077
    @jillrenaebeauty3077 2 года назад

    I also become a monster during the Sephora sale and then after it over I feel terrible for how much I spent but I do love makeup so...

  • @ChristineMaz
    @ChristineMaz 2 года назад

    Would you recommend the CT quad over the stoned rose face palette?

  • @chrissymoss514
    @chrissymoss514 2 года назад

    I have none of these .... I'm literally full to the brim with rose/pink toned palettes and I don't even like these tones on my eyes!!!
    Obviously, I got caught up in the hype and suffered the dreaded FOMO 😂😂
    I believe I could've chose the order of these palettes, especially the last 4 or 5. When you love a palette, you really do love it 💗🌹🌹💗
    Love ya 🤍💛🤍

  • @donnareed73
    @donnareed73 2 года назад

    I wasn’t going to get the Nars palette my first thought was it’s cute but boring. But for some reason it kept calling me lol every time I saw it so I bought it and I really like it