As a small boy growing up in London, my WW1 veteran Grandfather would tell me "Jimmy, my boy, always have a note book and pencil-you never know when you'll need a small boy to run an errand for you.
John how does it feel knowing you talk thousands of people to sleep each night with your satisfying EDC content. Love your videos, always part of my night time routine keep it up!
And for regular folks here in Australia, Woolworths sell the Picadilly Essential Notebook, same size but with 192 pages, hard back with page marker and elastic closure for $2.99. Add the Bic classic 4 colour ball point pen (with lanyard bracket) and you're good to go!
I watched this video 2 days ago. I purchased both the pen and the notebook. They both arrived today! Very impressive! Thank you for your recommendations. Love them both.
I have been using Smythson notebooks for about 20 years now. Typically with a fountain pen (Parker or Yard-O-Lead) or the occasional Space pen. The paper is superb and wears very well even against moisture and rugged conditions. Despite it being thin paper, it is a rag paper that is quite durable.
On my third Smythson ....yes they are expensive but so is anything that is truly gorgeous, and they are certainly that. Thanks Jon for the introduction.
I genuinely think a notebook and pen kept me sane in 2020. Hmm, at some point I need to check one of those notebooks. Maybe I'll pick one up next time I'm in London. I have the exact same pen in black with timascus bolt and in the mini variety.
Jon, your channel is fantastic! Thank you for producing high quality videos and adding all of the detail. Very impressed with the level of consideration and thought you give to even the smallest items/details.
My complements...this is a message that can be applied to everyone, especially young people...showing that traditional methods can help with creativity and productivity; the computer just being the tool to further one's ideas and thoughts...thanks!
I really don't need a $60+ pocket notebook....but this notebook is super tempting! I'm curious as to how well the paper holds up to a heavy handed writer....thanks for showing the fancy side of pocket notebooks! 😊
For me it’s a ‘Rite in the Rain’ with a Fisher Space Pen in my day sack, with a mini ‘Rite’ notebook (credit card sized) and a telescoping Zebra pen in my wallet. In my hiking gear I carry a length of bendy pencil. I’ve carried one for years - all through my time in the Army and since - and I’ve never had the lead break. You can’t sharpen a biro :)
I have a Fisher Bullet space pen, but I just can't get on with the way the ink 'blobs' up as I am writing, leaving 'splodges' on the page. I do appreciate the short/long pen style though, and their toughness. When I write it tends to be with fountain or gel pens. Where the gel pens fall down is that I get through the refills really quickly, so need a spare to hand wherever I am. I am glad to hear that the FP pen is working out for you though.
I carry a similarily sized Moleskein and prefer to use a mechanical pencil when writing/sketching. I like the scritch sound of pencil lead on paper. The other recommendation is to use Evernote as an archival source. I use my iPhone camera to take an image of the page and save in the cloud. It is always with me on all my electronic devices.
The Panama is also my favorite (and now one and only) notebook. Preferred pen Kaweco sport fountain pen. Perfect match. The pair fit everywhere and go everywhere with me.
Wow I never knew about those. Those are awesome. I’m glad I watched the whole video because I’m not super into writing on paper to match but when I saw that you can fold it open and it will stay open whatever page you’re at while you write I was sold on it.
I was about to query the "legendary" in the title but having heard the pedigree of the notebook you may be right (see what I did there). Had you topped it off and told me Shackleton kept his log in one I would have been sold. Nice to see and appreciate beautiful things - thanks for the video. I think I need to cultivate the writing habit in a cheaper alternative first before investing.
I’ve been using MUJI’s A6 notebooks for years now and they really seem to work for my requirements, plus it fits in a back pocket. But the Smythson Panama may be the next purchase. 👍🏽
I've used a Pocket Flip-Top battleboard XS with a RITR pad inside since they came out. It is golden. The clear write-on wipe-off on the back makes any piece of paper a whiteboard without permanently marking the paper. My pen with it is the non-boltaction version of that pen (Ti pocket pro, i think...dont have the box anymore).
I use these notebooks each and every day. They last me about 2 months per book. Chosen specifically to enjoy the process of writing. Basically used as a journal, common place, general notes type book. Love being detached from phone and laptop, slows me down and allows me to empty my mind and enjoy ink on paper. Quality is superb. Expensive. But quality. I use a Montblanc Starwalker which was a gift from my wife many years ago. Love the ink, expensive but they last for months of daily writing. Great vids. Thanks.
I caved in a bought the notebook, pen and Pentel Energel 0.7 refills. The pen was upgraded by removing the spring and putting a softer one in there, taken from a freebie retractable ballpoint. The pen is great, as is the notebook. I prefer the Pilot G2 refills to the Pentel refills, but as I have bought ten of them they should keep me going for a while yet. Thanks again for the video.
Thanks for showing this! I understand the draw of a quality notebook-pen combo, and if it weren't for the price-point I'd already be going for your suggestions. The detail you go into with these is really appreciated; if there's someone looking for a specific quality of the products you went over your review gives them the vocabulary they need to find it; which is always appreciated in reviewers.
Great review as always Jon, I really like the notebook but a little pricey for me. I use a Leuchtturm1917 A6 softcover that seems to be a cheaper alternative with either a Kaweco pocket fountain pen or if travelling a Parker Jotter with gel refill both use blue/black ink. I find this combo works for me. But if I am in Bond street I will be sorely tempted!!!
I love your videos on gear/EDC, seen them all. But this one sparked me good time. Will check out your notebook of choice. Greetings from a fan of Traveler’s Notebooks (Midori) and fountain pens.
I started carrying a notebook as a part of my EDC about 2 months ago and love it. I have been using a field notes pocket notebook mostly just because its what I had but would like to upgrade to something a little nicer. The Smythson might be one too consider. Ive been carrying a Kaweco fountain pen for a while as well but also like to use my Parker Jotter. There is something about carrying a notebook that helps my mind flow and be creative as well as express my thoughts. Thanks for another great video Jon!
I've now bought a Smythson Panorama and compared the paper with Tomoe River 52gsm (Japanese), which is loved by fountain pen enthusiasts for its minimal show-through and feathering with fountain pen inks. The Smythson paper performs virtually as well! I'm not aware of a similar notebook made from Tomoe River paper.
Great video! Another selling point on the Big Idea is the clip is similar to a knife clip. If I’m just wearing a t-shirt, I just clip it to my pants pocket. The collet at the tip also prevents tip wiggle. Ingenious! I’ll check out the notebook sometime probably!
I love that notebook, just beautiful and versatile! 👍👍👍 Here in the States some of the most popular pocket notebooks that are reasonably priced are Rhodia, Field Notes, Rite Rain, and Word. notebooks. That pen OMG that is such an awesome pen! I love bolt action pens and the fact that you can use just about any refill ink in it. 👍👍👍 I have always carried a pen or two a mechanical pencil with either a small notebook or paper since I was a teen along with a pocket knife.
you just corrected the way I pronounce Smythson, thanks! (they are indeed not cheap but paper is an expensive goods and the quality is on the higher end of the market so it is understandable.. the general finish is also is among the absolute best and the binding is, again, among the absolute best.. quality doesn't come cheap).
Bought the Smythson panama after watching this video and I can confirm this is the most unique fountain pen friendly paper I have ever! I will buy more during my next trip to London.
Have several notebooks that I keep in each of the different bags I carry depending on what I am doing that day, and a fisher space pen attached to each. Have recently purchased a Travelers Company notebook as my EDC and a Lamy Safari fountain pen, if I get on with the fountain pen I may indulge a little on a Midori Brass fountain pen :)
I made my own 'Midori' passport size size notebook for £7 and it works great, it's not that I couldn't afford £40 I just thought I'd give it a try and it's actually more practical!
Thanks for this review and your superb videos overall. I also appreciate your dry humor in this one as well…”a color nobody really wants”….and “a clicking sound to annoy those near you.” Classic. 🤣
I get it. I’ve spent a small fortune looking for the correct combo of pad and pen. I’ve settled on Rite in the Rain, which isn’t cheap either, however, I’m in the elements much of the time. This would make a great gift for someone, maybe myself, for those few times I’m able to clean up and roll like I actually have a life. 😆 Appreciate
I don't use a paper notebook much but these Edc videos make me think maybe I should start doing it again. What I do still use daily is a paper calendar, usually a smaller size, but some years I opt for a full size. As for what pen to use, for years, I used the Fisher Cap O Matic space pen, but this year I switched over to the Parker Jotter XL, with the Schmidt 900 ballpoint ink. For years, I went with the Fisher for its reliability, but I think the Schmidt ink actually flows better and looks slightly better. So for now, I mostly use the Parker Jotter at work, or working from home. I do have a bolt action pen, the Cool Hand bolt action with a Fisher refill. I did that because it sits in my car, so whether the pen has been sitting overnight in below zero weather, or baking in the sun, I know the Fisher ink will work.
I’m sure it’s a good notebook. I prefer Rocketbook. They come in different sizes and I have many of them. It does smudge using the type of pens you have to use which is it’s biggest drawback but for me it takes the best of both ways of writing, hand and you can scan it to a computer using most note apps.
I agree with the idea of having a note pad and pen but the price tags on yours made my jaw drop. My note pads get damp from sweat or unexpected rain and I lose pens either by forgetting where I put it down or loaning them to others. I suppose if I were more of a deep thinker or a creative person I could "maybe" justify that expense but I just use mine for quick lists, directions, instructions, and leaving notes for others on torn out pages. A mini composition notebook and dollar store pen serve my needs well enough. But if your notes are super important and you have the money then go with what makes you happy.
Wonderful words of wisdom about the value of handwriting, I couldn't agree more. I've handwritten notes every day at uni for years, and some of my contemporaries ask me why while they copy-paste the powerpoint into evernote and call it a day (an extreme case, but I've seen it several times). I use the Moleskine Cahier journals (XL, plain, brown), they come in a set of three, are good value for money and feel great to lay flat on a table with plenty of room to write. I have tried many alternatives to the Uni-Ball Eye Micro pen, but none have come close (though my Parker pen wins in terms of aesthetics). I used to use the classic Moleskine notebooks for journalling, but have recently switched to Leichtturm for better paper and value. I'm also writing my second novel in a larger Leichtturm that's approx. A4-sized and it's an amazing experience!
Fair play to you mate for going the length you do to find out what works for YOU. I have some paper (both notebook pages and 'write in the rain' pages in my wallet and I always have a pen in my pocket. I have a couple of True Utility collapsible pens too but I always have a 'grab' pen, at the moment its a cheapish one my Missus bought me but a Bic will do. Its a handy combination for writing stuff like a round of beers, the registration plates of ne'er do wells, a round of beers, noting down the important bits of a telephone call, a round of beers..... you get the picture.
Inspiring, balanced & such a very well considered presentation Jon.. Many thanks for your effort & sharing your helpful insight as well as your accompanying helpful personal experience.. much appreciated,..
Looks like a quality item. Even with the Price, 70 USD, but who knows what you might miss out on by not having a tool like this to keep your thoughts organized everyday. Prolly something that could cost that amount of moneyb
There aren't many alternatives satisfying (1) non-paper cover, (2) tough enough for EDC, (3) around 90-by-140cm. One is the Rhodia Rhodiarama Leatherette: it weighs 140g, has 96 pages of 90g paper, and costs about a tenner.
Thank you so much for the recommendations. I bought the bolt action pen right after I saw this. Been looking for a pen like this for some time now. Thanks again. Love your channel.
Well that was more interesting than expected. Already got me my setup, Rite in the Rain notepads and a cheapo 60 pack of Bic pens. Cuz they ALWAYS get lost😁 Perfect setup for me! I make a to-do list for myself every night at work, seeing as I work outside everything has smutchz on it.
I was thrilled with your overview, Jon. I've carried the notebook for a while now. They are pricey, but well worth it to me. The feel of the leather and quality of the paper is second to none. I use it with a Mont Blanc Meisterstuck. The Big Idea pen I had not heard of until watching your video. The black DLC one is now on its way. It won't replace the Mont Blanc, which I use for formal occasions, when wearing a suit for example, but it will become my EDC instrument of choice. Great review as always.
I made a comment on one of your videos about your GMT, I now have one (pepsi, Jubilee). I've now watched this and I feel it would only be fitting to purchase the notebook as I use one daily and the pen seems like a purchase too. Thank you for the great content!
Pricey for a 50 GSM paper! Try out a 160 GSM traveler’s notebook by Archer & Olive for $31.50 with additional features in the notebook. There are other value buys like Tekukor, but size might be a constraint at A5.
I like your reviews, they indicate for me some very good research. I have been carrying an A5, A4 notebook for many years. I make up part of the book as a dairy. As for a pen, yes I have a fisher Space pen, which goes out on field trips. Day work is done with a cheaper pen. But I have been looking at the Wingback.
I enjoyed the video, and use notebooks myself. There was an interesting product by Apple that captured the creative cognitive aspect of handwriting called the Newton. I have some, and still read a forum called the Newton users group.
Jonathon I’m enjoying your channel a lot. However, while I’m not broke, my income is apparently more limited than yours is. I’m so grateful for the comments section where I’m finding great suggestions for budget priced items that serve the purpose. It would be very helpful if in some of your future reviews you would offer your favorite and first choice for the item in question (price notwithstanding) but then also offer maybe one or two budget-friendly alternatives that you have tested or used on your journey to finding the best choice.
The lost art. you’re right, despite all the electronic gadgets there’s nothing like a notebook and pen such as you described. It’s an entirely different sensory experience.
I wondered if you would do a video on the conventions you use in your note book. For example, you had one page where you are writing at a 90 angle to the other entries. Do you do this when making a list? Any other idioms that are repeated? Sketch first and write later. Or the reverse, write and then later add sketches?
I always carry at least one pocket notebook on me and at least one pen. I also have that Big I design pen, although I swapped in a Parker style gel refill. I do like the look of your notebook, much nicer than the field notes brand ones I use. But at $70 for yours versus the $15 for a three pack of mine, I'll have to check out the sale to get one.
That's an absolutely beautiful notebook but at almost $50 I gotta mull that one over a bit before I pull the trigger on that. However, fantastic video, very refined and entertaining as much as you were informative. I have no doubt when I actually decide to buy one of these notebooks I will be unable to use any other but I'm not quite there yet.
What an excellent review and one which also worked a treat. Ordered a Panama in Jade green on sale and a BID pen (almost went slim hopefully normal one not too chunky). Fantastic stuff Jon! ❤
Looks very good both in video quality and the products shown. I understand using only 256 pages a year (5 pages per week) doesn’t break the bank even with these prices but that isn’t very realistic for me. I carry a 9x14 cm notebook (that is personal size not pocket size) too for personal and work each and I use 7 pages per working day. That makes this notebook way too expensive for “normal use”. (EDC) Would like to have one though but then for something special.
Solution for pen wiggle: If your pen wiggles at the rubber rings, and the beginning of the tip ( this could be because you are using a longer refil, at least I do) I suggest you putting some basic cello tape around the rubber rings. Nothing fancy, just some tape. This fixes the pen wiggle, and it's a much more substainable solution than shoving the extra rubber rings you get down the tip...trust me. Also, it doesn't make any crinkling sound, like I though it would. Remember, the wiggle migth be the ink cartridge inside. TO SUM UP: Pen wiggles, put cello tape around the end of the barrel, migth take two layers. It's going to be difficult to screw in, but that's good. I hope I helped.
I've carried a small notebook of various makes for years. I've tried many pens but I find I prefer a mechanical pencil because I change my mind often while writing and I need to erase, also I sketch quite a bit. Lead is better than ink for drawing.
I could talk about paper for ages but suffice to say I appreciate the Smythson as well. I have the Soho diary this year as well. I love fountain pens so that’s another reason for me, however I buy the notebooks on the numerous sales every year. Even so they are still stupidly expensive but like you, I enjoy them so I buy them 🙂👍🏻 EDIT: and yes Jon, I bought that ugly silver one you mentioned! 😂 Yeah, it’s not the best colour so I will go pay for another one now 😉
I really enjoy your videos. I have always struggled with pen and paper v iPhone notes. Great to here your thoughts on which to use. and when. The notes you made in your notebook look very neat and very easy to read. Would you be able to give us examples of what you write in it, what you highlight and what you don’t and what you write in the notebook versus digitally. Do you ever just simply scan the notebook with your phone to make a digital version of it? If you could do any of the above that would be fantastic.
Hi Jon, great video. I just took your advice and ordered both notebook and the pen I have been using an app on my phone and your right, it is not working. Thank you
Jon, any thoughts on the dango wallet with the built in pen/paper? I like the concept but would like to get your opinion. Love the videos, always a highlight of my day.
Thanks for the channel feedback 😊 I've not had one, but I like the Dango wallets and the pen and pad options looks really nice to me - quite bulky but to be expected
You had me right up until the price! 😅 I'm a big fan of the notebook and use one daily but I go through them pretty quickly... Any chance of pen review/guide covering some budget stuff. Cheers 🍻
Great thoughts on the advantages of writing as being creative. I usually use my smartphone (Z Fold 3 with a stylus) do jot notes/ideas; but, I do get the distractions you mentioned. I definitely got to try that notebook you recommend; pocket notebooks I've been using with fountain pends ended up being a bit heavy or with fewer pages.
I purchased the stonewashed finished and dlc coated ones. There was a discount for buying two. I was very close to getting the raw titanium, and I'm still thinking I should have gotten that one instead of the stonewash. It's not that there's anything wrong with the stonewash, I just think that raw titanium looks very nice. I did pay extra for the timascus (I think that's what they're calling it) replacement thumbstud for a little extra colour.
Look into the moleskin field note notebooks, they are much smaller than the larger version of moleskin and a bit cheaper. But smythson is unbeatable in the notebook world.
Hi, reallh enjoyed your video. How's the texture of surface of the pen? Does it have the characteristic roughness of titanium which is very useful for giving some proper friction with your fingers?
In your next review of this topic, please consider Field Notes Original Kraft Memo Book. Adam Savage of MythBusters carries it every day. Leather covers are available.
As a small boy growing up in London, my WW1 veteran Grandfather would tell me "Jimmy, my boy, always have a note book and pencil-you never know when you'll need a small boy to run an errand for you.
😊 thanks for sharing
Those were the days.
John how does it feel knowing you talk thousands of people to sleep each night with your satisfying EDC content. Love your videos, always part of my night time routine keep it up!
And for regular folks here in Australia, Woolworths sell the Picadilly Essential Notebook, same size but with 192 pages, hard back with page marker and elastic closure for $2.99. Add the Bic classic 4 colour ball point pen (with lanyard bracket) and you're good to go!
sounds ideal
Multicolor pens are the best!
Exactly
I watched this video 2 days ago. I purchased both the pen and the notebook. They both arrived today! Very impressive! Thank you for your recommendations. Love them both.
I have been using Smythson notebooks for about 20 years now. Typically with a fountain pen (Parker or Yard-O-Lead) or the occasional Space pen. The paper is superb and wears very well even against moisture and rugged conditions. Despite it being thin paper, it is a rag paper that is quite durable.
On my third Smythson ....yes they are expensive but so is anything that is truly gorgeous, and they are certainly that. Thanks Jon for the introduction.
Easily some of the best reviewing on The Tube. Your attention to detail, video work and precise description of benefits are all spot on. Bravo!
I genuinely think a notebook and pen kept me sane in 2020. Hmm, at some point I need to check one of those notebooks. Maybe I'll pick one up next time I'm in London. I have the exact same pen in black with timascus bolt and in the mini variety.
I like the mini pen option too Dom - thanks for the feedback - I'm envious of your new Crunch!
Jon, your channel is fantastic! Thank you for producing high quality videos and adding all of the detail. Very impressed with the level of consideration and thought you give to even the smallest items/details.
Really appreciate the feedback - many thanks
My complements...this is a message that can be applied to everyone, especially young people...showing that traditional methods can help with creativity and productivity; the computer just being the tool to further one's ideas and thoughts...thanks!
Thanks Edgar - totally agree
*compliments
I really don't need a $60+ pocket notebook....but this notebook is super tempting! I'm curious as to how well the paper holds up to a heavy handed writer....thanks for showing the fancy side of pocket notebooks! 😊
I agree - nobody needs this - but a few really want it! Paper seems perfect to me - almost seems to get better with use.
$.50 notebooks are the best. Don't care about em and that's a good thing
For me it’s a ‘Rite in the Rain’ with a Fisher Space Pen in my day sack, with a mini ‘Rite’ notebook (credit card sized) and a telescoping Zebra pen in my wallet.
In my hiking gear I carry a length of bendy pencil. I’ve carried one for years - all through my time in the Army and since - and I’ve never had the lead break. You can’t sharpen a biro :)
Great feedback Bob - I use bullet pen/sharpie/pencil and rite-in-the-rain in various emergency kits - but for daily use....
I have a Fisher Bullet space pen, but I just can't get on with the way the ink 'blobs' up as I am writing, leaving 'splodges' on the page. I do appreciate the short/long pen style though, and their toughness. When I write it tends to be with fountain or gel pens. Where the gel pens fall down is that I get through the refills really quickly, so need a spare to hand wherever I am. I am glad to hear that the FP pen is working out for you though.
I carry a similarily sized Moleskein and prefer to use a mechanical pencil when writing/sketching. I like the scritch sound of pencil lead on paper. The other recommendation is to use Evernote as an archival source. I use my iPhone camera to take an image of the page and save in the cloud. It is always with me on all my electronic devices.
The Panama is also my favorite (and now one and only) notebook. Preferred pen Kaweco sport fountain pen. Perfect match. The pair fit everywhere and go everywhere with me.
Thank you for the notebook recommendation, Jonathan! I stopped at Smythson’s while on holiday. It’s such a lovely notebook, I purchased two!
Wow I never knew about those. Those are awesome. I’m glad I watched the whole video because I’m not super into writing on paper to match but when I saw that you can fold it open and it will stay open whatever page you’re at while you write I was sold on it.
I was about to query the "legendary" in the title but having heard the pedigree of the notebook you may be right (see what I did there). Had you topped it off and told me Shackleton kept his log in one I would have been sold. Nice to see and appreciate beautiful things - thanks for the video. I think I need to cultivate the writing habit in a cheaper alternative first before investing.
🤣 thanks for the feedback - I bet Shackleton did!
It’s great seeing the level of success your channel has had the past year, cheers!
Thanks to people like you who watch it 😊
I’ve been using MUJI’s A6 notebooks for years now and they really seem to work for my requirements, plus it fits in a back pocket. But the Smythson Panama may be the next purchase. 👍🏽
Muji notebooks are fantastic, especially for the price!!
I've used a Pocket Flip-Top battleboard XS with a RITR pad inside since they came out. It is golden. The clear write-on wipe-off on the back makes any piece of paper a whiteboard without permanently marking the paper. My pen with it is the non-boltaction version of that pen (Ti pocket pro, i think...dont have the box anymore).
I have started using the Paper Republic set up and very pleased with it
great to hear
Hello, your videos are very informative. The production quality, editing, lighting, and sound are top notch. Thanks again.
I use these notebooks each and every day. They last me about 2 months per book. Chosen specifically to enjoy the process of writing. Basically used as a journal, common place, general notes type book. Love being detached from phone and laptop, slows me down and allows me to empty my mind and enjoy ink on paper. Quality is superb. Expensive. But quality. I use a Montblanc Starwalker which was a gift from my wife many years ago. Love the ink, expensive but they last for months of daily writing. Great vids. Thanks.
I caved in a bought the notebook, pen and Pentel Energel 0.7 refills. The pen was upgraded by removing the spring and putting a softer one in there, taken from a freebie retractable ballpoint. The pen is great, as is the notebook. I prefer the Pilot G2 refills to the Pentel refills, but as I have bought ten of them they should keep me going for a while yet. Thanks again for the video.
Thanks for showing this! I understand the draw of a quality notebook-pen combo, and if it weren't for the price-point I'd already be going for your suggestions. The detail you go into with these is really appreciated; if there's someone looking for a specific quality of the products you went over your review gives them the vocabulary they need to find it; which is always appreciated in reviewers.
thank you
Great review as always Jon, I really like the notebook but a little pricey for me. I use a Leuchtturm1917 A6 softcover that seems to be a cheaper alternative with either a Kaweco pocket fountain pen or if travelling a Parker Jotter with gel refill both use blue/black ink. I find this combo works for me. But if I am in Bond street I will be sorely tempted!!!
I love your videos on gear/EDC, seen them all. But this one sparked me good time. Will check out your notebook of choice. Greetings from a fan of Traveler’s Notebooks (Midori) and fountain pens.
Thanks for the feedback Robbie, much appreciated.
I started carrying a notebook as a part of my EDC about 2 months ago and love it. I have been using a field notes pocket notebook mostly just because its what I had but would like to upgrade to something a little nicer. The Smythson might be one too consider. Ive been carrying a Kaweco fountain pen for a while as well but also like to use my Parker Jotter.
There is something about carrying a notebook that helps my mind flow and be creative as well as express my thoughts.
Thanks for another great video Jon!
Thanks for the feedback - mirrors my experience 👍
I've now bought a Smythson Panorama and compared the paper with Tomoe River 52gsm (Japanese), which is loved by fountain pen enthusiasts for its minimal show-through and feathering with fountain pen inks. The Smythson paper performs virtually as well! I'm not aware of a similar notebook made from Tomoe River paper.
Thank you Jon, My pen is on the way. Discount is perfect! I went for smaller EDC Arto version at the end.
perfect 👍
Great video! Another selling point on the Big Idea is the clip is similar to a knife clip. If I’m just wearing a t-shirt, I just clip it to my pants pocket. The collet at the tip also prevents tip wiggle. Ingenious! I’ll check out the notebook sometime probably!
I love that notebook, just beautiful and versatile! 👍👍👍
Here in the States some of the most popular pocket notebooks that are reasonably priced are Rhodia, Field Notes, Rite Rain, and Word. notebooks.
That pen OMG that is such an awesome pen! I love bolt action pens and the fact that you can use just about any refill ink in it. 👍👍👍
I have always carried a pen or two a mechanical pencil with either a small notebook or paper since I was a teen along with a pocket knife.
great feedback - thank you
you just corrected the way I pronounce Smythson, thanks! (they are indeed not cheap but paper is an expensive goods and the quality is on the higher end of the market so it is understandable.. the general finish is also is among the absolute best and the binding is, again, among the absolute best.. quality doesn't come cheap).
I agree!
Bought the Smythson panama after watching this video and I can confirm this is the most unique fountain pen friendly paper I have ever! I will buy more during my next trip to London.
Have several notebooks that I keep in each of the different bags I carry depending on what I am doing that day, and a fisher space pen attached to each.
Have recently purchased a Travelers Company notebook as my EDC and a Lamy Safari fountain pen, if I get on with the fountain pen I may indulge a little on a Midori Brass fountain pen :)
I made my own 'Midori' passport size size notebook for £7 and it works great, it's not that I couldn't afford £40 I just thought I'd give it a try and it's actually more practical!
Thanks for this review and your superb videos overall. I also appreciate your dry humor in this one as well…”a color nobody really wants”….and “a clicking sound to annoy those near you.” Classic. 🤣
Thanks for the feedback - great to hear - helps me double down on what people want to see.
I get it. I’ve spent a small fortune looking for the correct combo of pad and pen.
I’ve settled on Rite in the Rain, which isn’t cheap either, however, I’m in the elements much of the time.
This would make a great gift for someone, maybe myself, for those few times I’m able to clean up and roll like I actually have a life. 😆 Appreciate
I don't use a paper notebook much but these Edc videos make me think maybe I should start doing it again.
What I do still use daily is a paper calendar, usually a smaller size, but some years I opt for a full size.
As for what pen to use, for years, I used the Fisher Cap O Matic space pen, but this year I switched over to the Parker Jotter XL, with the Schmidt 900 ballpoint ink. For years, I went with the Fisher for its reliability, but I think the Schmidt ink actually flows better and looks slightly better. So for now, I mostly use the Parker Jotter at work, or working from home.
I do have a bolt action pen, the Cool Hand bolt action with a Fisher refill. I did that because it sits in my car, so whether the pen has been sitting overnight in below zero weather, or baking in the sun, I know the Fisher ink will work.
Thanks for sharing Martin 👍
I make my own notebook using thicker paper but I appreciate the craftsmanship undertaken on the Smythson Panama.
Outstanding notebook worth every penny!!!! It improves with each use. Should be in everyone’s edc…
sounds like you have one!
I’m sure it’s a good notebook. I prefer Rocketbook. They come in different sizes and I have many of them. It does smudge using the type of pens you have to use which is it’s biggest drawback but for me it takes the best of both ways of writing, hand and you can scan it to a computer using most note apps.
great option Tim
I agree with the idea of having a note pad and pen but the price tags on yours made my jaw drop. My note pads get damp from sweat or unexpected rain and I lose pens either by forgetting where I put it down or loaning them to others. I suppose if I were more of a deep thinker or a creative person I could "maybe" justify that expense but I just use mine for quick lists, directions, instructions, and leaving notes for others on torn out pages. A mini composition notebook and dollar store pen serve my needs well enough. But if your notes are super important and you have the money then go with what makes you happy.
Wonderful words of wisdom about the value of handwriting, I couldn't agree more. I've handwritten notes every day at uni for years, and some of my contemporaries ask me why while they copy-paste the powerpoint into evernote and call it a day (an extreme case, but I've seen it several times).
I use the Moleskine Cahier journals (XL, plain, brown), they come in a set of three, are good value for money and feel great to lay flat on a table with plenty of room to write. I have tried many alternatives to the Uni-Ball Eye Micro pen, but none have come close (though my Parker pen wins in terms of aesthetics).
I used to use the classic Moleskine notebooks for journalling, but have recently switched to Leichtturm for better paper and value. I'm also writing my second novel in a larger Leichtturm that's approx. A4-sized and it's an amazing experience!
Fantastic feedback Christian - thanks for sharing
Fair play to you mate for going the length you do to find out what works for YOU. I have some paper (both notebook pages and 'write in the rain' pages in my wallet and I always have a pen in my pocket. I have a couple of True Utility collapsible pens too but I always have a 'grab' pen, at the moment its a cheapish one my Missus bought me but a Bic will do. Its a handy combination for writing stuff like a round of beers, the registration plates of ne'er do wells, a round of beers, noting down the important bits of a telephone call, a round of beers..... you get the picture.
Inspiring, balanced & such a very well considered presentation Jon..
Many thanks for your effort & sharing your helpful insight as well as your accompanying helpful personal experience.. much appreciated,..
Thanks Sunjay for the kind comments.
Looks like a quality item. Even with the Price, 70 USD, but who knows what you might miss out on by not having a tool like this to keep your thoughts organized everyday. Prolly something that could cost that amount of moneyb
There aren't many alternatives satisfying (1) non-paper cover, (2) tough enough for EDC, (3) around 90-by-140cm. One is the Rhodia Rhodiarama Leatherette: it weighs 140g, has 96 pages of 90g paper, and costs about a tenner.
thanks Nick - great suggestion
You are my pen bestie. My EDC is a pentel engergel refill in a big idea screw cap titanium body. And the bolt action is at the top of my to buy list😊
I think I will order one for my sister for Christmas . She loves special, well made things like this . Thanks for sharing Jon .
Thank you so much for the recommendations. I bought the bolt action pen right after I saw this. Been looking for a pen like this for some time now. Thanks again. Love your channel.
Thank you for introducing me to this brand of notebook. Ordered one and I am expecting to commit very strongly.
They are great pens, I have both a titanium and a copper one and I like them both.
great to hear
Well that was more interesting than expected. Already got me my setup, Rite in the Rain notepads and a cheapo 60 pack of Bic pens. Cuz they ALWAYS get lost😁 Perfect setup for me! I make a to-do list for myself every night at work, seeing as I work outside everything has smutchz on it.
I was thrilled with your overview, Jon. I've carried the notebook for a while now. They are pricey, but well worth it to me. The feel of the leather and quality of the paper is second to none. I use it with a Mont Blanc Meisterstuck. The Big Idea pen I had not heard of until watching your video. The black DLC one is now on its way. It won't replace the Mont Blanc, which I use for formal occasions, when wearing a suit for example, but it will become my EDC instrument of choice. Great review as always.
Thanks for the great feedback James - great to hear.
I made a comment on one of your videos about your GMT, I now have one (pepsi, Jubilee). I've now watched this and I feel it would only be fitting to purchase the notebook as I use one daily and the pen seems like a purchase too. Thank you for the great content!
Congrats on your Pepsi - that is a lovely watch and hard to get hold of as you will know. Yes, I love my Root Beer - huge fan of the GMT here.
I love this thought method
Pricey for a 50 GSM paper! Try out a 160 GSM traveler’s notebook by Archer & Olive for $31.50 with additional features in the notebook. There are other value buys like Tekukor, but size might be a constraint at A5.
thanks for the suggestions
I like your reviews, they indicate for me some very good research. I have been carrying an A5, A4 notebook for many years. I make up part of the book as a dairy. As for a pen, yes I have a fisher Space pen, which goes out on field trips. Day work is done with a cheaper pen. But I have been looking at the Wingback.
I enjoyed the video, and use notebooks myself. There was an interesting product by Apple that captured the creative cognitive aspect of handwriting called the Newton. I have some, and still read a forum called the Newton users group.
I remember it!
great edc reviews always Jon!!
Another excellent review, well researched and beautifully presented. You should have 350k subscribers soon!
I wish! Thanks Jacques 😊
Jonathon I’m enjoying your channel a lot. However, while I’m not broke, my income is apparently more limited than yours is. I’m so grateful for the comments section where I’m finding great suggestions for budget priced items that serve the purpose. It would be very helpful if in some of your future reviews you would offer your favorite and first choice for the item in question (price notwithstanding) but then also offer maybe one or two budget-friendly alternatives that you have tested or used on your journey to finding the best choice.
great feedback - thanks Carmen
10mm isn’t 3/4” Jon. It is less than 1/2”. Sorry for the correction. Love the channel, keep up the good work.
Hi Jason, my bad! I don't know what I was thinking! Thanks for pointing it out and for kind comments on the channel.
If I spend that much on a notebook, I'll never use it because I'll want anything in it to be special. I guess I'm sticking with my Leuchtturms
I enjoyed this video!!
Really shows how pocket notebooks can come in handy, thanks!
The lost art. you’re right, despite all the electronic gadgets there’s nothing like a notebook and pen such as you described. It’s an entirely different sensory experience.
I wondered if you would do a video on the conventions you use in your note book. For example, you had one page where you are writing at a 90 angle to the other entries. Do you do this when making a list? Any other idioms that are repeated? Sketch first and write later. Or the reverse, write and then later add sketches?
I always carry at least one pocket notebook on me and at least one pen. I also have that Big I design pen, although I swapped in a Parker style gel refill. I do like the look of your notebook, much nicer than the field notes brand ones I use. But at $70 for yours versus the $15 for a three pack of mine, I'll have to check out the sale to get one.
thanks for the feedback Todd
Really enjoyed this clip!
Glad you enjoyed it!
Love the note book but too expensive for me
any notebook will do 👍
That's an absolutely beautiful notebook but at almost $50 I gotta mull that one over a bit before I pull the trigger on that. However, fantastic video, very refined and entertaining as much as you were informative. I have no doubt when I actually decide to buy one of these notebooks I will be unable to use any other but I'm not quite there yet.
Thanks for the feedback - yes, big ask this one - nice though!
What an excellent review and one which also worked a treat. Ordered a Panama in Jade green on sale and a BID pen (almost went slim hopefully normal one not too chunky). Fantastic stuff Jon! ❤
Enjoying both immensely from the outset. Bringing even more joy to my daily noting. Cheers Jon! @JonGadget
Looks very good both in video quality and the products shown. I understand using only 256 pages a year (5 pages per week) doesn’t break the bank even with these prices but that isn’t very realistic for me.
I carry a 9x14 cm notebook (that is personal size not pocket size) too for personal and work each and I use 7 pages per working day.
That makes this notebook way too expensive for “normal use”. (EDC)
Would like to have one though but then for something special.
Ok I’m sold on the notepad. Can’t seem to get the popular EDC pens that easily the UK though….
Solution for pen wiggle: If your pen wiggles at the rubber rings, and the beginning of the tip ( this could be because you are using a longer refil, at least I do) I suggest you putting some basic cello tape around the rubber rings. Nothing fancy, just some tape. This fixes the pen wiggle, and it's a much more substainable solution than shoving the extra rubber rings you get down the tip...trust me. Also, it doesn't make any crinkling sound, like I though it would. Remember, the wiggle migth be the ink cartridge inside.
TO SUM UP: Pen wiggles, put cello tape around the end of the barrel, migth take two layers. It's going to be difficult to screw in, but that's good. I hope I helped.
I've carried a small notebook of various makes for years. I've tried many pens but I find I prefer a mechanical pencil because I change my mind often while writing and I need to erase, also I sketch quite a bit. Lead is better than ink for drawing.
I could talk about paper for ages but suffice to say I appreciate the Smythson as well. I have the Soho diary this year as well. I love fountain pens so that’s another reason for me, however I buy the notebooks on the numerous sales every year. Even so they are still stupidly expensive but like you, I enjoy them so I buy them 🙂👍🏻 EDIT: and yes Jon, I bought that ugly silver one you mentioned! 😂 Yeah, it’s not the best colour so I will go pay for another one now 😉
I really enjoy your videos. I have always struggled with pen and paper v iPhone notes. Great to here your thoughts on which to use. and when. The notes you made in your notebook look very neat and very easy to read. Would you be able to give us examples of what you write in it, what you highlight and what you don’t and what you write in the notebook versus digitally. Do you ever just simply scan the notebook with your phone to make a digital version of it? If you could do any of the above that would be fantastic.
Looks attractive and definitely worth the price!
I miss my three ring reporters 3x5 top bound shirt pocket notepad. Moneverde tool for the writing stick.
I make my own passport sized notebooks. It allows me to pick and choose my covers and paper.
Great points about analogue notebooks versus computers. For more, see David Sax's excellent 2016 book "The Revenge of Analog".
Oooh! I'll check it out - thanks!
David who? that caught my eye ! 😉
Almost a namesake and a subject that interests me, how spooky.
Give zequenz or dingbats a try. I think you’ll be pleasantly surprised
I reckon the bic Cristal is almost the perfect pen, ultra cheap, compact and writes well. You can lose the lid though.
Hi Jon, great video. I just took your advice and ordered both notebook and the pen I have been using an app on my phone and your right, it is not working. Thank you
Jon, any thoughts on the dango wallet with the built in pen/paper? I like the concept but would like to get your opinion. Love the videos, always a highlight of my day.
Thanks for the channel feedback 😊 I've not had one, but I like the Dango wallets and the pen and pad options looks really nice to me - quite bulky but to be expected
You had me right up until the price! 😅
I'm a big fan of the notebook and use one daily but I go through them pretty quickly...
Any chance of pen review/guide covering some budget stuff.
Cheers 🍻
thanks for the feedback - will put it on the list
Great thoughts on the advantages of writing as being creative. I usually use my smartphone (Z Fold 3 with a stylus) do jot notes/ideas; but, I do get the distractions you mentioned. I definitely got to try that notebook you recommend; pocket notebooks I've been using with fountain pends ended up being a bit heavy or with fewer pages.
great feedback Marcos
I purchased the stonewashed finished and dlc coated ones. There was a discount for buying two. I was very close to getting the raw titanium, and I'm still thinking I should have gotten that one instead of the stonewash. It's not that there's anything wrong with the stonewash, I just think that raw titanium looks very nice. I did pay extra for the timascus (I think that's what they're calling it) replacement thumbstud for a little extra colour.
I do like the raw but stonewash nice too
Look into the moleskin field note notebooks, they are much smaller than the larger version of moleskin and a bit cheaper. But smythson is unbeatable in the notebook world.
Hi Roman, I have used Moleskin for years including pocket size and they are great - Smythson is special though, although you pay for it.
@@JonGadget smythson has such great quality, especially with the cross grain leather cover. Do they carry any other styles or sizes at smythson?
damn I just was on bond street and now I am across the world. bet your bottom dollar I am loading up on those next time I am in town 😮
Thank you
you're welcome
Maybe if the legendary IBM "Think Book" had been made like the Panama notebook, IBM would be a world economic power still.
good point (I think they're doing quite well still!)
Was looking for this video to see that pen, i ended up getting an olight mini pen just for the bolt action fidget-ness
Very good speech to advocate handwriting. I find it very satisfying to do sudokus with a good gel pen. ..so this has to be number FIIIIVVVE here
I enjoyed this excellent video and that pocket pad notebook looks sweet as heck but a little too expensive for this old boy.
Hi, reallh enjoyed your video. How's the texture of surface of the pen? Does it have the characteristic roughness of titanium which is very useful for giving some proper friction with your fingers?
I really enjoy your videos and superb videography.
Thank you!
In your next review of this topic, please consider Field Notes Original Kraft Memo Book. Adam Savage of MythBusters carries it every day. Leather covers are available.
Thanks Darius - Field notes are a great option (not use Kraft Memo Book)
I love Field Notes, but their paper is not very fountain pen friendly.
I always carry a notebook with me everywheres i go.