What's next for Scotland now Humza Yousaf has quit? | Andrew Marr's analysis
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 апр 2024
- Andrew Marr speaks to Shelagh Fogarty after the Scottish Parliament's 'biggest crisis', following Humza Yousaf's resignation.
Mr Yousaf will stay on as first minister while an SNP leadership election takes place, following in similar footsteps to his predecessor Nicola Sturgeon.
The first minister U-turned after previously saying he would not resign and instead intended to win two confidence votes.
It comes after a breakdown of the SNP's power-sharing deal with the Scottish Greens on Thursday.
The first minister said at the time that the agreement had “served its purpose" and was "no longer guaranteeing a stable arrangement in parliament".
Listen to the full show on Global Player: app.af.globalplayer.com/Br0x/...
#shelaghfogarty #andrewmarr #scotland #lbc
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup
I don’t think this is the biggest crisis. Rather, this is the biggest win for Scotland! Well done, Scots!
Bring Sangita back. Journalist should be allowed to challenge narratives
Where is Sangita???? That’s what we all want to know.
No. We "all" don't!
Where is Sangita? Have they sacked her???
Who cares. She was useless
She challenged an Israeli spokes person (propagandist)
She challenged Israel and they canned her not like this door mate Shelia that tows the lbc anti Palestine line
She's left due to mental health issues and won't be back.
@@Ibnjamal645 Are they afraid to fire James because he brings in the views? He seems to be allowed to criticise Israel.
How can presenters like Andrew and Shelagh just carry on. Just sweeping the whole Sangita issue under the carpet. Is LBC challenging freedom of speech
What happened?
@@20storiesunderit’s kicking off mate
Because they dont really care, thats the truth. Even Mr Progressive JOB is ignoring it.
Oh ffs freedom of speech doesn’t apply to a private company and until the actual presenter either takes LBC to an industrial tribunal or resigns and states her case then really your p***ing in the wind
@@20storiesunder she challenged an Israeli spokes person (propagandist). And we all know the media doesn't like the truth being told on certain subjects.
I'd argue that the UK parliament has failed too..as demonstrated by Bojo...
Well not only him but yes, abolish Parliament.
Where is Sangita? She is by far the best presenter on LBC. This is very worrying...
Bring back Sangita!
Time to vote the SNP AND GREENS OUT.
He needs to keep walking and take his family with him.
Due to his hate crime speech and his hate crime bill you’ll be very lucky to get me to vote for them ever again.
Has LBC sacked Sangita for holding Israelee propagandist accountable ? LBC has also been sold to Israel. dint expect it from LBC.
Where’s Sangita?!
If anything, perhaps Scotland needs to undergo a period of political turmoil with a non-SNP Scottish Government. Scotland has a lot more devolved powers than Wales or Northern Ireland and they are to all intents and purposes already semi-independent in perception, if not also in fact. The Scottish electorate need to be reminded what it is to be part of the union and that will mean more experiences of Scotland being trodden on and deals made that are bad for the country. Such a period would likely see a surge in support for Scottish independence that next time, will guarantee their success at the polls.
Where's Sangita? Why are you being cowards, LBC?
She's on the plane to Rwanda.
Literally nobody cares. Why are you leftists so obsessed with this?
They have knives held to them by certain interest groups
@@adamkarimian7137 utter codswallop
@@tyromenobber-fb2ls😂
His P45: WHITE
Bring back Sangita.
Why didn’t he wear his Pakistani outfit when he resigned.?
Sangita?
Where is Sangita? If LBC have caved to the Zionists then you've lost another listener here.If I wanted to hear Israeli apologists I'd listen to the Robbie Gibb Corporation.
You should stop listening to this propaganda machine for the Left anyway
We (The People) want Sangita reinstated!!!
Indeed. 👍
"Westminster has failed and we should abolish parliament"
Maybe not abolish, but the voting system needs changing! Proportional representation please 🙂
Yes please.
Be careful what you want you might not get like the version you end with. Scotlands version is terrible designed by Labour to stop the SNP and independence supporters getting what they want.
Unfortunately most people are idiots so I'm not sure that would work out any better.
Actually yes, abolish parliament.
Bring back sangita
Who?
@@TarlachOakleaf Bring back Sangita Myska.
Sangita, Sangita, Sangita. Reedy to ban LBC unless we have a favorable answer soon!!!
SNP on power = independence on the menu. NI has a legal mandate to hold one every 7 years. That's your precedent.
Where's Sangita Myska?
They must bring Sangita back.
Where is Sangita Myska?
It is very correct by Andrew,bad political leadership,but I feel a bit worried about a total majority in Holyrood.Because the Scottish people will soon be subject to some hard hitting changes, I have often thought that either the Labour and Tory parties would cut the free prescriptions and University education.Labour would then be subject to taking all instructions from Westminster chief Starmer.
Where's yer journalistic integrity? Still too scared to talk to listeners and too scared to defend Sangita Myska. Shame on you Mr Marr.
probably because theres more important news the majority of people want to hear which also that needs to be covered in the space of an hour. sure to core listeners of LBC it is a problem but for the average joe listening trying to catch the news and getting a sense of whats happening in the country it isnt much of an issue and this is coming from someone who signed the petition
@@domispablo7992Glad you signed the petition. I can't help feeling that Andrew Marr struggles to get under the skin of most stories. He still has problems grappling with his BBC mindset.
At least he's only on for an hour I suppose.
So getting rid of an unpopular, unelected clown is the biggest crisis Scotland has faced? In what reality?
Because right now there's no viable alternative devolved government. Whoever gets handed the poisoned chalice next will find it hard to govern effectively. Not the biggest crisis in Scotland as such, but in terms of finding stable leadership for the next few years it is.
@@carelgoodheir692 Snap election should really be called to be honest
@@mrgaudy1954 like when it happens in westminster?🤣
Someone call Mel Gibson.
Bring back Sangita Myska.
Where is Sanghita?
Bring back aangita
LBC - mouthpiece of the Israeli government….?
Can you reply?
0:25 Yes Abolish Parliament
Sawar was never voted by the Scottish people, he gain access to Scottish parliament via the back door
Truss, Sunak also were not voted in ....are you talking double standards here?
@@macred I take it you don’t understand the Scottish parliament voting system (d’Hondt)?
Sounds so familiar.😢
Where is Sangita Myska? Is Israel now running LBC?
Stuff a second referendum let's go to the international courts, the UN and court of human rights.
WHERE IS SANGITA MYSKA ?, no more listening to LBC till she is back. Shame on his fellows in the channel Please share
Get rid of Khan next
I bet you, he wins on Thursday
@@Greenpoloboy3 Well he will because of the type who will vote for him not because he is of any use.
let's hope so don't want that horrible woman to win come on Khan
Yeah down with anyone brown right?
@@Glasgow_kiss Ask yourself why a mainly white country has so many immigrant colonisers in charge
Humza a nice guy ? I guess Mr Marr is one of the luvvies, the general public have a very different view
You obviously don't live in Scotland.
You better believe i do my friend
@@user-xc8ir7ng9z I live in Scotland I can confirm Humza and his anti-white hypocrisy is widely hated. Even SNP members can't stand him.
@@blackcatdungeonmastersfami5311no it’s not.
100%
He's despised
There wasn't a "promise" to not have another election for a generation or 21 years
We were promised no brexit vote, they lied/went back on it, that should have opened the door for another referendum, but we got shafted again.
No there wasnt.
Btw, the unionists promised Scots a lot of things if we stayed in the union. Literally everyone of them never happened.
So we're owed another referendum. We voted for one, by the majority in 2021. But England took the Scottish government to court to deny us one. Proving beyond doubt that Scotland's a colony, not a respected partner.
@@OneTrueScotsman Hear, hear, well said, I keep trying to tell English people this but their not interested, most English people would prefer we just shut up and get on with being ruled, it's not happening though.
@@OneTrueScotsman and I'm sure if you lose that referendum you'll ask for another the week after
@@kityhawk2000We didn't get a second referendum on Brexit after it turned out to be based on lies and we all know how badly that turned out!
Absolutely we need another referendum especially when it can be proved the winning side lied to get their vote across the line.
What utter rot
Sangita didn't balance out her interview.
UK is going to be like Lewisham council at this rate, 100% labour 😂👍
The SNP have made a rip roaring disaster from an position of near invincibility 🤨
Where is Myska?
Andrew Marr and his like loved the authoritarian and ‘progressive’ Sturgeon. Even when the country was going down the drain. What poor judges of character
He represents the regime
"There's noone I can find across the spectrum who doesn't like Humza Yousef" - tells everything you need to know about Andrew Marr.
What drain are you talking about? Being more inclusive and understanding of marginalised groups?
A politician who answered questions instead of dodging every issue, she had the highest acceptance figures of any politician in Europe.
@@blackcatdungeonmastersfami5311 He's talking about fellow politicians of all parties in Scotland who know him personally. Among them he's quite liked apparently. But he's not really hit it off with the public. He's gone anyway.
Scottish parliament works.
Scotland will become independent. It's inevitable at this point.
until there is a clear path to it, and all the current problems in Scotland are sorted it's not of the greatest concern
How? The courts said the power of Scotland that agreed to the union vanished into the collective power of merged parliament at Westminister.
Devolution never gave it back.
😂😂😂
Nothing's inevitable till after the event. That said, there's quite a strong likelihood that the UK will break up within the next few decades.
BOYCOTT LBC FOR FIRING SANGITA
LBC is in shambles with the “truth” 😂
NO CRISIS HE,S GONE WHOOPIE DOOO
17 years of SNP government who have failed to improve Scotland or the lives of Scottish people. Independence is just a slogan for SNP an SNP MP in Westminster will not want to give up their £91k salary+expenses+backhanders.
😂👆🤡
I believe people in Scotland have a lot better than down in England. I hope one day like Ireland we get independence.
It might be that way for the SNP after Salmond, however for the Scottish people it's a very important issue.
Agreed Liz. But all the leftists who listen to this and support Jeremy Corbyn haven’t a clue about reality
Have you seen the state of Westminster, lately? Scotland's improved in lots of ways since it was controlled 100% by English parties. Sure, there's still room for improvement, but that will only happen when we have full control of our own economy, trade, taxes, migration and military.
Westminster has a COMPLETELY DIFFERENT voting system so be careful that you're not comparing apples with pears. The Scottish parliament system is designed to try and avoid any party securing a majority.
0:26 YES! YES! YES!
We non-Londoners W O U L D say Westminster should be torn down, and a truly democratic system not based in London should be created.
The SNP has been a cult of personality for more than 20 years. Before Yousless, 2 strong leaders who successfully harnessed the greavance mongering to a level that the broad church of the SNP focused all their attention on the Westminster = Bad argument and put their own opinions to the side. It's taken a weak leader and a seriously divisive topic such as trans rights to tear that all down. Humza has gone today to avoid the embarrassment of some of his own MSPs voting against him, nothing to do with any deals with Alba.
Ignorance is bliss, put down your crayons.
Yes and yr next
Bring back Sangita!!!
What has been going on in Scotland? How were they in a position where Humza and Anas Sarwar were the two options? An authoritarian identity politics provocateur vs an authoritarian identity politics provocateur.
Where is sangita myska ????
SANGITA !!!!!! LBC don’t be cowed
The main point is that the voting system at Holyrood is entirely different from the first past the post at Westminster.
" West Minster has failed, we should abolish parliament, no we should not "
*Charles II:* Yes, yes we absolutely would...
Mmmmmmm! !
Tell the truth he is not scots he Pakistan' heritage and he incompetent not a scooby
Son of Pakistani soil as he described himself 😂
Tell me robert, have you done an ancestry test? You might find your heritage comes from places you've never heard of!
@@MrBigblue40 You sneaky little toad.
Born in Rutherglen, south Lanarkshire. Lived in Scotland all his life. That makes him Scottish and British. Let your meltdown begin.
He's more Scottish than you.
He’s a nice guy?? Again showing you know nothing about what goes on up here!
The lesson is don't do it *AT ALL!!!!!*
Bring back Sangita
Not tuning into LBC until sangita is back
I can't forget his hate speech against the white white white population of Scotland
A truly low point in Scotlands history
Aye, that.
I do think Westminster has failed and needs reform.
Ha Ha Ha. His pronouns are now former, ex and past.
We don’t need two or three governments ,, we are a united kingdom with one King so why do we need more than one government 🤔 this is just individuals wanting more and more power , and have a craving for feasting at the top table ?
Under your system Scotland gets ignored by the Westminster bubble
@@Jonnyonthespot123. Yes, and he’s the king of Scotland first.
Scotland has no king, the last one died centuries ago... and we need no replacement. As for the UK, go ask the North of England how they feel about Westminster control and mismanagement. Scotland was given away in an arranged marriage. Maybe you can't comprehend what that means, but it was immoral in 1707 and is even more so now.
That’s right, can’t beat the SNP at the ballot box - shut down Holyrood! Get tae.
Bring back Marie Black. She’s exactly what Scotland needs.
Remember Nicola screamed her head of when Truss and Sunak got the PM job saying they had no mandate because they were elected from the Tory party membership. Then she resigns and the the SNP does exactly the same as the Tories to pick their new FM.
Nicola played diversion politics and bailed out as she knew she could not keep it up leaving Humza to be the patsy
I don’t remember when she did that. But I do remember her warning that if Truss governed the way she campaigned, she was going to be a disaster.
An Election.
Sangita Myska ????
What's next?......Stephen Flynn and the continued road for a federation of Kingdoms or independence. Brexit and Con party sleeze has finally shown the union is far from fit for purpose.
What great news......
Crazy comparison. Abolish Holyrood and we have Westminster, abolish Westminster and we have no Parliament! Whilst Parliament does need to be reformed with representative democracy of the kind we don’t currently have, the UK does need a Parliament!
Not a crazy comparison when taken in context of what he actually said.
@@MrBigblue40 I disagree. All things being equal, abolish both. All things are not equal in this case and Scotland has legislators at Westminster. Oops, maybe I should have listened longer. My bad!
You wrongly assume there is a UK.
@@user-st7wb3yf3d I wrongly assume there is a a UK! If we had Independence now I would be in favour of returning to the UK. While I am in favour of abolishing the Scottish Parliament, I would not be in favour of immediate abolition in an independent Scotland. As I said, all things with regards to Parliaments are not equal.
@@christrance777 The mess Westminster is in? You do realize that Holyrood is not representative of an Independent Scotland. It was shaped by Westminster so that no Party could get a majority, and thus, do what they actually have to do to be successful.
Only Independence gets us out of the endless chaos that Westminster has created for Scotland since 1707. The History is there, right up to the present.
Give me one rational reason for sticking in this arranged marriage? Just one.
People need to quit with the "wheres Sangita" stuff.
They are not going to tell you anything, and no one knows why she's not on the air.
Presenters obviously have NDAs in their contracts that prohibit discussing programming decisions. Sangita herself limited her social media remarks to "I miss you too."
@@danmayberry1185 Talk about stating the obvious.
She is on a plane to Rwanda, no signal.
@@Glasgow_kiss No loss.
Where's Sangita adolf?
"There's noone I can find across the spectrum who doesn't like Humza Yousef" FFS man 90% of Scotland hates him! Even most SNP members can't stand him.
90% that’s a strong claim. Luckily you can’t and won’t back it up because it’s bs
You're everywhere sticking up for Lord Humza...
How can you prove its not 90% ?
I'd say it was higher...96% maybe...
@@monkeyface6139 It was obvious that Marr was talking sabout people who know Humza personally, as a fellow MSP in Holyrood. The general population in Scotland is unimpressed by him but that's a different story.
A bit like Michael Foot - all who knew him liked him but he was a lead balloon with the electorate.
The exact opposite of Boris. Everyone that knew him well knew he was disgusting but the electorate loved him - for a while.
Hmmm," he speaks quite well" really? maybe that's part of the problem eh?🤔🤨
Humza was an ignorant private school bully boy. Maybe that’s why Andrew likes him
now we have the band wagon rolling
Now just Sadiq and rishi
why stop there? surely there are other coloured people you want out?
Humza is "nice"? He judges others by the hate he has. Others don't like his skin colour while he got to the highest position in the govt? He brought in one of the most repressive and anti-Scottish Acts in my lifetime.
Sounds like you only get your viewpoints from some proper biased rags
Which act?
@@Glasgow_kiss The Scottish Hate Crimes..
@@20storiesunder You think it's OK to have a police file against yourself for something that you said in your own home, that you weren't convicted of, and that you were not given the right to answer?
@@jwsuicides8095 So you peruse the same rags if that's your understanding of the act.
Scotland should go FPTP and get the majority Westminster want...for pro independence
Theres only one man Scotland wants: Rishi Sunak. x
Literally nobody wants Rishi Sunak. That's why he refuses to call a general election!
Tories haven’t won an election in Scotland since 1955.
What else don’t you know about Scotland?
Devolution was a matter of principle. It was not about things being better.
Isn’t that one argumrnt for Brexit?
*Humza was a typical diversity hire* 😂👍
This disastrous tory clownshow means we should cancel separation from the EU. 👍
Everything falls into Starmers lap
The real problem is the Greens. They should concentrate on the climate issue and not get distracted by all their culture war stuff. The SNP should have made them choose.
Get over this personality politics, he's one man not the whole independence movement.
Useless is a utter incompetent and the one who follows will be the same as the skill,experience and quality of the snats' is minimal---Scotland deserves SO much better.
The SNP didn't lose the referendum narrowly. The gap was 10.6%. In a two way race, anything over a 10% victory margin is a landslide.
45/55 is a slight margin like it or not.
The polling average in the last 12 months, puts support for staying in the UK at 47%. Down from, as you say, 55% in 2014.
This despite the SNP fiasco. Support for the union has never been lower.
The majority of every age group under 55 support independence. Those under 35, by three to one.
Only 18% of Scots identify as British, according to the last census. A few years of Starmer will help push up support for indy even futher.
@@OneTrueScotsman Dream on.
The referendum result was bought with fools gold.
@@OneTrueScotsmanlol is that why the SNP attack Labour twice as hard as the Tories. Face it. The SNP know having a Tory government in Westminster is far better to get independence than having a Labour government
BBS BBS BBS BBS BBS BBS BBS
Sangita taking a job with the daily mail