Thanks for watching! If you enjoyed the video, don't forget to share it with others, drop a comment, and support us by hitting the like button. Your support means a lot!
WITH ALL THESE CHARLATONS THATS WHY IT IS IMPORTANT FOR EVERYONE TO FOLLOW THE SHIA TRADITION. WHICH IS WHY ALLAH WANTED MUSLIMS TO FOLLOW THE HOLY FAMILY OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD PBUH. WHO WOULD HAVE BEEN BETTER ROLE MODELS AND TEACHERS TO LEARN FROM BECAUSE WITH ALL THESE OTHERS THEY COULD BE FAKE
@@risale-inuronline2711WITH ALL THESE CHARLATONS THATS WHY IT IS IMPORTANT FOR EVERYONE TO FOLLOW THE SHIA TRADITION. WHICH IS WHY ALLAH WANTED MUSLIMS TO FOLLOW THE HOLY FAMILY OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD PBUH. WHO WOULD HAVE BEEN BETTER ROLE MODELS AND TEACHERS TO LEARN FROM BECAUSE WITH ALL THESE OTHERS THEY COULD BE FAKE
Those friends of Allah do not truly die even after the death of their temporal bodies. Many of the friends of Allah, who continue glorifying and praising their Lord in their graves, live among us spiritually today and guide us. They will continue to live in the hearts even after we die. In proportion to their closeness to Allah, their life of guidance transcends the physical boundaries of time and space.
Glad you found it fascinating! Ibn Arabi's ideas truly challenge traditional perspectives, and we're excited to explore how they can inspire new ways of thinking in Islamic philosophy.
Warning. .Deep understanding of tauhid needed so that not be misguided and blame others. Pray to Allah swt to guide the right haqqul path and indeed all the Haq and the Rightful path belongs to Allah swt.
Thank you for your thoughtful comment. We agree that a deep understanding of Tawhid is essential, and our aim is to encourage reflection and exploration while always seeking guidance from Allah SWT. May He lead us all on the straight path. We appreciate your support and prayers.
JazakAllah great work ❤need more on ibn arabi Ibn Arabi was on another level his teachings are understood by special people normal people misunderstood him. But it didn't matter to him he was not here to please humans
@AbdulRahman-vr8rw thank you very much kind comment, yes we love Ibn Arabi and we try to teach his teachings to people. We agree with you about misunderstanding his teaching. we will try our best always to speak about his books from our perspective.
Sheikh e Akber ‘s works (1000 Tassawuf related books)isn’t for everyone! Even Scholars couldn’t even understand ! Ibne Timiya wasn’t a Sufi, against of Tassawuf, therefore his comments doesn’t worth none!
To understand ibn arabi the great mystic the person should be a spiritual gifted soul through a master of who has a degree from Hzt syed Abdel Qadir r a of Baghdad he is a grade of Qutub e Rabbani no one in auwaliya Allah community has got the highest order near to the creator.
0:15 Very good effort , Remember , this a powerful spiritual state when salik is in station of Fana fillah which experienced by concentration on on Ayat .کل من علیھا فان ۔ When this state is fully in bedded in Saliks mind every creation seiz to exist. Then comes second stage of Baqa billah. With this Aya. ویبقا وجھ ربک زلجلال والاکرام۔ At this stage only Allah is every where . His noor filled in whole imaginable spaces. Words are not yet created to explain this stage experiences . Remember Iman is state. You can't explain a state to one who isn't in that state. Like hunger, pain, love one should have some common experience so that it can be explained. In Tasauaf there is no student but Salik. It's like guided tour or journey for Salik, For others his books are like travel books. Any how if you set your foot on this journey, every thing will become clear , and its a KASABI not WWAHBI. This mean open to all ,achievable for all Muslims as per Therfield efforts and Khuloos. Regards 0:15
Some claim wahdat wujud is pantheism and kufr when it is actually the total opposite . Wahdat wujud meaning is nothing exists besides Allah . All else is just shadows and illusions .
Wahdatul Shuhud is more real and true than Wahdatul Wucud. Please check Ibn Sina and Imam Rabbani. we talked on our video about Imam Rabbani`s perspective about Wahdatul Shuhud. thank you.
Ibn Araby's highest spiritual experiential conconsciousness accomplishment was his personal "Isra' & Mi'raj', in the likeness of Prophet Muhammad.saw's own - which he accomplished 1-2 years before the Hijrah to Medina. Nevertheless, he was humble enough to proclaim his ascension was not to same level as that of the Propheht, even though in his Fusus he described meeetings with 27 named prophetic entities compared to the 8 names listed in the Prophet Muhammad's Hadith. In my research on what I would label as " The Quranic Islamic Six Day Quranic Creation Process" and " The Soul Progression Process" there is one statement unique in the Prophet Muhammad's Hadith that I couldn't find in IBN Araby's account of his ascension. And that is about what Prophet Muhammad was saying his witnessing of the Four Rivers. By this the Prophet is saying, in his own way, that, by Allah.Swt's Will, he was made to witness the Creation Process of the whole Universe and of Mankind. To a certain extent there statements in his Fusus that indicate he was also made to witness the Creation process such as the ever intriguing phrase "Creation is regenerated at every instant ( tadid al-khalq)". This is a very metalicca physics statements. What IBN Araby had said is a reaffirmation of what says in the al-Quran that Allah.Swt repeats a Creation when completed. That's just like saying when a neutrino enters at the centre of the Earth, a Star disappeared at the outermost boundary of the Universe. That sounds a quantum mechanic to me. And what did Ibn Tammiya and gang knew about the content of the Earth in their time period. May be their vision of wahdat ul wujud were a little too short. Sorry for the long read and TQ for reading.
@@ReligiousStoryTV Have u studied Imam Shah Waliullah Dehlvi RA? These Arabic Scholars, their works and criticism should be taken in the regards of Arab World itself. They aren't meant for Non Arabs like us. If Islam was left to them, it certainly wouldn't have spread as it did among the Ajem ie Non Arabs. You know the reason? their thing is too simplistic and rigid. Ibn Arabi, type legends who were born in Ajem ie Andalusia, lived among the non muslims had a far more insights of different ideologies, thinkings, ideas and so on. And that's what is reflected in his works of Wahdat ul Wajood too. And its Wajood not Wucud. This was the man who inspired people like Imam Abu Hanifa, whose Fiqa Hanafi is the single largest Fiqa in the whole of ummat. 900 million followers out of a total of 1.9 billion. His wahdatul Wajood is followed in this fiqa. It explains in a deeper way how Allah's world works. The concept of 7 heavens, his throne....he himself etc etc. Gives you a lot of thought provoking insights into his Realm. But i agree with this part though that for a novice, studying his work will certainly misguide them! unless yr at a certain level spiritually, mentally and in knowledge, u will never ever get him and his concepts. I would advice you to study Imam Shah Waliullah Dehlvi (RA) to truly understand how big of a legend and master he and his concept of Wahdat ul Wajood was! BTW, only how with the knowledge of Quantum Physics, world is truly understanding the validity of the concepts of Wahdat ul Wajood. You even made a before about his time dimensional works and theories. And mind you, this work was from 12th century AD. Remarkable isnt it?? The level of his head space was soo high that a novice, or a common man will certain get himself misguided!
Thank you for watching and commenting! In the video, I aimed to present classic Islamic responses to Ibn Arabi’s views, referencing these sources. Specifically, Imam Rabbani’s Maktubat offers a detailed critique of Ibn Arabi's concept of Wahdat al-Wujud. Said Nursi’s Risale-i Nur Collection contains significant explanations on this subject. Asa-yı Musa: Nursi reflects on divine unity and creation, focusing on perspectives distinct from Ibn Arabi’s metaphysical unity and emphasizing personal responsibility and clarity in Islamic belief. Ibn Taymiyyah: Fatawa (Majmu' al-Fatawa): In his comprehensive Fatawa, particularly Volume 2, Ibn Taymiyyah critiques the philosophical foundations of Wahdat al-Wujud, as he found Ibn Arabi’s interpretation to conflict with orthodox Islamic teachings. Kitab ar-Radd ala al-Mantiqiyyin (The Refutation of the Greek Logicians): While focusing on Greek philosophy, Ibn Taymiyyah discusses metaphysical arguments that relate to Ibn Arabi’s ideas, advocating for a more literal interpretation of Islamic texts. Al-Furqan bayna Awliya’ al-Rahman wa-Awliya’ al-Shaytan (The Criterion Between the Friends of the Merciful and the Friends of Satan): Here, he addresses spiritual excesses, which he felt led to misunderstandings in Sufism, indirectly critiquing elements found in Ibn Arabi's writings. I hope these references help deepen your understanding of the discussion!
thank you very much. there are many (like dall-e, midjourney-etc). I do not create images. our video editor creating these and its her secret amazing propmts :)
thank you very much for suggesting and comment, I did note. we have similiar content about Ayatal Kursi secrets, please check it out our channel and watch it, thanks once :)
Thank you for watching and sharing your thoughts! Sufi teachings indeed contain deep spiritual dimensions and can sometimes be misunderstood, especially with more technical concepts. However, the essence of this knowledge is to understand the dimension of ihsan in Islam, which great scholars have clarified with care. If you keep watching, you’ll see that we try to present these topics in a simpler, more understandable way.
Wow...and what spiritual insight led u to call a fellow muslim a simpleton ? There are a lot of kinds of people, physically strong, physically weak, intellectually strong, intellectually weak... The are people who invent the most sophisticated machines and those who clean the streets... We need all of them and degrading a fellow Muslim is...propably not the best thing to do, isn't it?
Thank you for your feedback. We’ll be more mindful moving forward. The visuals in these videos are symbolic, meant to convey spiritual concepts to the viewer. Each image is designed to represent the essence of unity, Tawheed, in Islam and Sufism. We appreciate your interest and understanding.
I don't see any problem with his thinking if that's how it was understood, i think those who ciritize him just understood the title of the idea, and run with it, tho i can say it's prone to misunderstanding and misinterpreation. It's true, if you believe that the material world have a real substance then you will fall into chirk, because you give matter an agency independent of God, hence i think Ibn Taymiya should reflect on his aquida because he said that the world is ancient like greek philosophers, so ibn Taymiya is the one who didn't understand Tawheed.
Ibn Arabi’s ideas are often deeply symbolic and can easily be misunderstood or superficially assessed. His perspective aligns with the belief that the material world lacks independent existence, affirming that all existence is grounded in God. his views do not contradict Tawheed. As for Ibn Taymiyya some of his interpretations may indeed show influences from the philosophers' view of an eternal world. rather than questioning his commitment to Tawheed, such views should be regarded as differing perspectives.
Exactly! and thats why Ibne Tymia's works are hardly quoted or mentioned in the world outside of those 22 Arabic countries. And there r 57/58 Muslim countries in total. And Arabs make only 13% of the ummat today. Their thinking is very rigid and traditional, no deep and out of box thinking. Something thats highly encouraged in Sufism. But good thing is that, his works did inspired people like Imam Bukhari and Imam Ibne Hanfi. And later to a master genius like Imam Shah Waliullah RA. Who explained his works in detail.
@@Blackbirdz2000 not even 22 arabic countries, the only ones who resurected him are wahabis who tried to rewrite hanbali school but ended hijacking it and creating salafism.
We explained with other islamic scholars. Please watch all video and understand the others opinions about Wahdetul Wujud. İt can make you go wrong way, cause some people thinking that's pantaizm, but it's not. Better to check imam Rabbanî, Said Nursi, ibn taymiyyah opinions as well at the video. Thanks.n
Every knowledge should be intrepreted according to 4 levelof knowledge i.e shariat, tariqat, hakikat n makrifat ... physical n spiritual. With such knowledge one will understand the idea of Ibn Arabi perfectly
Thank you very much for good explanation and reminding. I am on the first level, shearia. And avarage Muslim I am, and not good enough my praying. I do not understand God's actions and even human actions and behaviours. İt's hard to follow and understand deeply espically. insha'Allah Allah gives us good knowledge to understand and accept Him and others and Qadar. Cause I do not want to go to hell ❤️
IBN Arabi very special and very complicated for many Muslims and also me. But with other scholars can help us to understand him sometimes. Like Imam rabbani explained his some ideas very clearly, that's why I added some of sentences from different Islamic scholars for wahdetul wujud and Arabi s role.
I think jungian psychlogy shed some light about how to interpret suffi spiritual states, i think Carl Jung said that the true-self is half in the invidual unconscious and half in the collective unconscious, so the link between the collective and the invidual is the true-self while he Ego is the manifestation of consciousness, the people who interpret what suffis say with the Ego arn't understanding it, suffis basically are speaking thro the true-self, the self that doesn't have Ego, nor individualisty, so it's a self that is more ackin to the spirit that God have blown inside the creation. the Nafs wahida that God had created all inviduals from it, it's the of devine spirit, and it's the one that suffism and other spiritual practices try to reach by negating and eclipsing the Ego.
You make an insightful connection between Sufi thought and Jungian psychology. Jung’s concepts of the collective unconscious and the “true self” bear similarities to the Sufi understanding of the self. Sufis strive to connect with what is known as the Nafs al-Wahida or True Self, a state where one is purified from ego and individual desires. This state is about reaching the divine spirit breathed into humanity by God and returning to the essential unity of creation. Therefore, interpreting Sufi ideas through the lens of the Ego alone would overlook the depth of their spiritual meaning.
The book is great, of course, and very useful. However, the original, uncopied version is said to include some sections on dangerous magic. This is understandable, as the book aims to break down and address magic, which is why some spells are included.
There are many level of truth, on different degree of understanding. People that refute ibn arabi only see one face of the cube. The understanding of ibn arabi does not go against quran and sunnah. It is based on quran and sunnah, its the experiental knowledge based on it. We can’t understand this things by the mind but through tasting if the heart. Dont try to understand it if you cant. Leave it.
Sufism is unique because it focuses on inner connection with the divine rather than strictly following set rules. It’s like the waves 🌊-always flowing, adapting to time and place, and guiding people through love, compassion, and introspection. Just like the phases of the moon 🌙, Sufism is all about personal growth and spiritual renewal, shedding the ego to make room for love and understanding. In Sufism, teachings are passed down through experience and heart-to-heart connections, keeping it fresh and relatable for everyone seeking a deeper connection to God.
Ibn Arabi was far more knowledgeable and greater than his time. The islamic scholars would not understand and analyse his point of view and therefore did a great injustice to his works in the field of cosmic knowledge. Ibn Arabi was 100% correct in stating that everything belongs to Allah alone. There was nothing before the existence of Allah SWT and it is Allah alone who created the entire galaxies. In these galaxies lies stars, planets and other known and unknown things. Allah alone is most powerful and sovereign in authority. Everything exists with His knowledge. Allah is so majestic and great that we cannot even imagine His strength and power. He is so powerful that He created the entire cosmos, the entire universe in just six days and nights. It is Allah who created time and nobody can ever stop time except Allah. When Allah wishes to stop time ie, when He wishes Qayamat to occur, the time stops as the time stops the entire cosmos and the universe will crumble like soft cotton particles floating in the field at the mercy of wind. Apart from being so majestic, gigantic and powerful, Allah is most humble, most caring, most kind, most merciful, most tolerant, most beneficent, most gracious and most affectionate. It is Allah who allowed human species to benefit from his creation. The nature created by Allah never discriminates as it gives humans the food to survive. The nature is a beautiful garden which has flowers, fruits, mountains, rivers, oceans etc. Allah is most just as He decides our survival on this planet based on our actions. Allah is so loving and caring that He forgives anyone He desires. Allah is omnipotent and omnipresent. His will and wish is final. It is Allah who blessed the people of every community with His prophets so as to guide them towards straight path. Allah is most honest as he commands fair dealings in the business and Allah forbades illegal activities with appropriate punishment. Allah is great... Allahu Akbar ! We can keep describing about Allah and His supreme qualities for years. We may feel fatigue and stop describing His qualities as His presence and power is infinite.
Your preference for Imam Al-Ghazali is very natural; he holds a prominent place in Islamic thought and emphasized sound knowledge and devotion for spiritual growth. Thank you for your comment!
Ibn Taymia was a gem in his earliest life, however, he was misguided later and started questioning credibility on Taqlid on 4 imams. Do not follow him!
Thank you for your comments! I wasn’t aware of what happened to Ibn Taymiyya later on, but we also included thoughts from scholars like Imam Rabbani, Said Nursi and Ghazali in the video. Did you have a chance to listen to those sections? Thanks for engaging with the content!
What ibn Arabi is trying to say is? Only existed in beginning is Noor of Allah, Allah is Noor, consider a room fill with Noor, and nothing else exist, then Allah decided to create makhlooks, he shrink his size which occupied whole room, darkness we see is absent of Noor, otherwise darkness doesn't exist initially, he created water, arsh, kursi from Noor, shrinking his size he than sat on arsh, later he created universes and makhlooks inside universes from water, water is made of Allah's Noor, so indirectly Allah is present everywhere, we are part of water through which we are created and water was created by Allah's Noor, please don't consider water as our regular water, this water is made of Noor and different from regular water.
Allah is not an Noor; Allah has His own light (Noor). However, Allah is not something we can see with our eyes and does not resemble any of His creations. He is not matter or light; His nature is very different. Speaking on this matter is not correct, as it is beyond our understanding in this world. Therefore, Islamic scholars have found it inappropriate to discuss what Allah is made of. Allah created the human soul with His light and breathed from His own soul. Allah has placed immense value on humans, creating them in the most special and superior way, with great artistry and love. He desires no attention other than love and affection and seeks the love of His servants. Those who show this love are the most esteemed in the sight of Allah. May Allah make all of us among those who reach such levels and attain closeness to Him. ❤️
We believe there is only God and we were created by God. We are not God or part of God. Sunni Islam or any part of different islam, we believe only one God. We do not accept panteism or something similar. ibn Arabi did not say directly, we already explained on our video. İmam rabbani is correct about this subject, WAHDATUL shuhud. Please check it. Thank you for your comment and watching.
Thank you for watching! The claim of Ibn Arabi predicting major global events, such as a potential World War III, is complex and debated. In works like Al-Futuhat al-Makkiyya (The Meccan Revelations), he explores themes of societal turmoil, spiritual challenges, and a symbolic battle between material and spiritual values. However, these are generally symbolic and open to interpretation rather than direct prophecies. While some scholars or enthusiasts interpret his writings as alluding to major future conflicts, they typically reference spiritual or esoteric struggles rather than specific events like world wars.
Do not be misguided by these people. Please follow Allah’s book The Quran, the Hadiths and Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad and try be like the Sahaba. Just read all other books like story books and move on and Don’t get stuck. You will need to face Allah on judgement day.
We published Imam Rabbani, Said Nursi, İmam Ghazali and Ibn Taymiyyah and Ibn Arabi opinions together. We do not misguide anybody with these great Islamic scholars. Thank you for suggesting ❤️
Figures like Ibn Arabi didn’t aim to create divisions but sought to deepen spiritual understanding within Islam. His works focus on divine love, unity, and personal connection to God, which align with core Islamic values. Divisions in the ummah often stem from complex historical and political factors, not the ideas of scholars who contributed to Islamic spirituality.
The word "intoxication" could easily be perceived as harmful. I would personally classify it as "cainian" in English/ Hebrew or "qabilian" in Arabic. Jealousy, I suppose must be the first human defilement ythat Allah.Swt had created and still is recreated at every instant, as beasts are.😊
The term 'spiritual intoxication' is indeed appropriate here. Ibn Arabi experienced an advanced state of divine love, where he was so immersed in God that he couldn’t see anything else, ultimately developing his philosophy of wahdat al-wujud (oneness of being). However, his inability to perceive anything outside of God doesn’t imply that nothing else exists. Just because one can’t see beyond their beloved doesn’t mean everything else is non-existent. Many Islamic scholars, such as Imam Rabbani (explained in the video), surpassed his level and critically examined Arabi's perspective, providing persuasive reasons as to why it may not be entirely accurate. Did you happen to watch the video to the end? Thank you so much for your comment; please stay tuned for more!
There is kudthi hadith type which is Allah almight speaks and than prophet Mohammad (saw) says. There are many Turkish books also mention kutsu hadis in Turkish. Please research and learn ❤️
Thank you for your comment. It’s important to clarify that Ibn Arabi’s teachings have historically been understood and interpreted in various ways by scholars and students of Islamic thought. While some groups may refer to him in ways that may differ from mainstream or orthodox Islamic teachings, Ibn Arabi himself was focused on advancing knowledge of the inner, spiritual dimensions of faith and unity with God, rather than endorsing practices like grave worship, which are outside traditional Islamic beliefs.
God And His Creation is ONE: a drop of water falls in an Ocean GOD and Creation are separate : A Drop of water Leaks from the Ocean. Those who perceive beyond the Body Mind Thought are ENLIGHTENED BEINGS . They see themselves in EVERYTHING and EVERYTHING in THEM, They are One with GOD : DIVINE CHILDREN OF GOD Separate from GOD: Servants of GOD. That’s the Difference.
There is no children of God, no doubt. Sural Kafh, Allah almight says very clearly. And also no similarities human and God body or existence. Human and all other things has begining, God not. The ocean and drop water example, you need to change the names. Normal people can be drop, ocean can be Mohammad Saw, cause same material of our bodies. Not God is ocean. İt's wrong analogy. Thanks
If Ibn Tamiyya is alive today, I would adk him to deliberate on two Quranic verses. One that says Allah is closer to you that your jugular vein. The other one is Allah.swt surrounds everything. Mind you it is by Allah.Swt's Will that mankind tiday have been up skilled in their critical thinking and enriched scientific vocabulary , it is not the objective jugular vein that we have to focus on, in our contemplation, but what flows thru it. And ....everything means all inclusive, the macros and the micros, the atomic snd the nuclear.😅
No there is a verse in Quran. Ar rahman alal arsh is tawa. Allah SWT is on his arsh. Again too much deviation. How sahabah viewed the things is best way forward.
According to Sunni Islam, Allah and created beings are distinct and independent entities. Allah is the absolute, eternal Creator, while we are contingent and limited beings. Ibn Sina explains that Allah is the necessary being , meaning His existence is independent and inherent, while our existence is entirely dependent on His will. In this context, the concept of Wahdat al-Shuhud is also relevant. This perspective holds that everything bears witness to Allah’s oneness and majesty, but it does not imply that created beings are themselves Allah. As His creation, we seek to "witness" Him in existence, not become Him.
No, not silence. We love İbn Arabi. You can check our channel, we have many videos of Arabi. But in this case, we publish also many Islamic scholars discussing about WAHDATUL WUJUD. Nobody said wrong about Arabi, they respect but not respect to wahdetul wujud. We just publish this.
Allah is not god. There are no god. God are idols that are worshipped and is forbidden. 5 x prayers a day is not act of worship. Im not going to tell what prayers are about. Not yet. But, I tell you this. Every creations comes out of Allah. Allah is not god. It's something else. Its essential to note that creations become when atoms and its contents vibrate at speed more than speed of light.
Allah sent the religion of Islam 1400 years ago and said, "I do not resemble any being, and I am not made of matter. I am beyond space and time, I have no beginning or end, meaning I am not within time. Additionally, the flow of time for you and its flow elsewhere are different. What is five thousand years for you could be like five years somewhere else." In the last century, we scientifically learned that time is created and relative. Furthermore, the entire universe is created, it has a beginning and an end. The power that creates the universe must not be bound by time or space. If time and space are created, how could it be contained within them? It must exist beyond them. He just says “Be,” and it is. There is no difficulty for Him. He did not create in six days and then rest, as in the Christian and Jewish beliefs; Israel did not wrestle with Him and win, and He did not have a son to send. Such nonsensical views do not exist in Islam. In Islam, Allah is not human, He does not resemble humans in form. Some of the human attributes resemble Allah's, but the difference in quantity is like that between a tiny drop and the ocean. It is like comparing infinity to a finite number. We have faith in Allah, and may He keep us on the right path, and guide you to the right path as well. The self is dangerous, do not trust your own thoughts. Always consult reliable sources. Humans are prone to mistakes.
@@ReligiousStoryTV the Qur’an was revealed 1400 years ago not Islam. Islam is the religion of Adam and all prophets, of course people thousands of years ago might have not called it "Islam" literally, they might have a different name for it in their language but it's still the same religion. Noe the guy above you is completely lost. This is why going philosophy and ignoring the words of God, can lead you astray. ALLAH knows best.
Yes I did make mistake. Islam is only one religion from Adam, noah, moses, Jesus and 124k prophets and also last prophet Mostofa Mohammad (saw). I should have said Mohammadi shariat of Islam. Thank you for e Warn me brother
Have you even read what you are talking about? In the original language - because that is what every writer of genius - which Ibn ‘Arabī is - deserves? I doubt it - your pronunciation of his name is just so far from what it should be that the rest will have not obtained more respect from you than that. Now, you or others in your defense may reply: leave the pronouncer alone - “they” is after all only an AI tool. Aha! If you are an AI tool, why would I even bother to listen to the first letter you pronounce. You are not, as Ibn ‘Arabī would see, a letter from one of the infinite number of letters of one of the infinite number of Names of God. Stop whispering. Into my ears or any other’s.
I wish I were an AI, without emotions, without accountability, without the grave, judgment, and hell awaiting me. After all the effort, I wouldn’t still be blamed, and my heart wouldn’t skip a beat. But unfortunately, here I am, human, once again answering accusations. So, where were we? I am Turkish; I don’t know how to pronounce Ibn Arabi’s name, but if he were alive and I called out to him, he wouldn’t mind. I wish you didn’t either. I listen to Ibn Arabi audiobooks. There are no books in my language where I live. Besides, even if there were, I couldn’t afford them right now. That’s why free audiobooks are great. Before preparing a video, I watch at least a few others. I look at what other scholars have said. I am not a scholar; I certainly have mistakes, I have gaps. But I will keep doing my best. I don’t want to sit idle at home; I want to work a bit and learn. And if I can make money along the way, that’s even better. Hopefully, you are also using your free time productively. Thank you for your feedback and your comment. Next time, if you specify where I went wrong, you’d be more helpful to me. For now, goodbye, and may God protect you.
The sun does not shine to illuminate its own path. Fruit trees do not consume their own fruits. The wind does not blow for its own pleasure, and the earth does not rotate to reach its own goal. Likewise, our eyes were not created to see their own way, nor do our ears hear for their own enjoyment. Allah created the universe to be known. This is mentioned in a Qudsi Hadith (Acluni, Kashf al-Khafa, II, 132): "I created the jinn and humankind only so that they may know and worship Me." (Adh-Dhariyat, 51:56) This is not about compulsory worship, but about worship filled with love, performed with understanding and affection. As they worship, they grow in love and comprehension of Allah. The purpose is this: Allah wished to love and be loved. Why does a hidden treasure want to be known? For love, for passion, for those who seek and strive to find it, for those who put in effort to reach it, and for those who love and yearn to meet it. Allah placed love and mercy in our hearts; He gave it from Himself. He gave it to animals and plants too. We see this mercy everywhere in the universe, but there is much more of it in Allah. Inshallah, we can find Him, my brother.
Also No scholar was perfect. We should respect every scholar for their service to Islam. They may have made mistakes. So no need of picking one thing or one opinion to malign any scholar. But yes things should be viewed in perspective of Quran and Sunnah.
yes %100 agree, we tried to prepare with 5 different islamic scholars in this video for discussing Wahdatul Wujud and Shuhud. so people can agree any of them and its the most important Quran and Sunnah of course like you said. Thank you very much.
WITH ALL THESE CHARLATONS THATS WHY IT IS IMPORTANT FOR EVERYONE TO FOLLOW THE SHIA TRADITION. WHICH IS WHY ALLAH WANTED MUSLIMS TO FOLLOW THE HOLY FAMILY OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD PBUH. WHO WOULD HAVE BEEN BETTER ROLE MODELS AND TEACHERS TO LEARN FROM BECAUSE WITH ALL THESE OTHERS THEY COULD BE FAKE
Shia was created by Jews; everyone knows this history well. They did not change the Qur'an, but they divided Muslims. Shia uses only the names of Ali and the Ahlul Bayt. Your Shia books begin with cursing Abu Bakr, Omar, and Aisha. Even hypocrites don’t curse publicly. You should reflect on your own path. Sunni Islam is the main truth and the only one.
Thanks for watching! If you enjoyed the video, don't forget to share it with others, drop a comment, and support us by hitting the like button. Your support means a lot!
🎉🎉
Please make a video on What is the ism Azam.
Thanks for video, it's great
WITH ALL THESE CHARLATONS THATS WHY IT IS IMPORTANT FOR EVERYONE TO FOLLOW THE SHIA TRADITION. WHICH IS WHY ALLAH WANTED MUSLIMS TO FOLLOW THE HOLY FAMILY OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD PBUH. WHO WOULD HAVE BEEN BETTER ROLE MODELS AND TEACHERS TO LEARN FROM BECAUSE WITH ALL THESE OTHERS THEY COULD BE FAKE
@@risale-inuronline2711WITH ALL THESE CHARLATONS THATS WHY IT IS IMPORTANT FOR EVERYONE TO FOLLOW THE SHIA TRADITION. WHICH IS WHY ALLAH WANTED MUSLIMS TO FOLLOW THE HOLY FAMILY OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD PBUH. WHO WOULD HAVE BEEN BETTER ROLE MODELS AND TEACHERS TO LEARN FROM BECAUSE WITH ALL THESE OTHERS THEY COULD BE FAKE
Those friends of Allah do not truly die even after the death of their temporal bodies. Many of the friends of Allah, who continue glorifying and praising their Lord in their graves, live among us spiritually today and guide us. They will continue to live in the hearts even after we die. In proportion to their closeness to Allah, their life of guidance transcends the physical boundaries of time and space.
His ideas really push the boundaries of traditional thought, and it’s fascinating to see how they could impact Islamic philosophy moving forward.
Glad you found it fascinating! Ibn Arabi's ideas truly challenge traditional perspectives, and we're excited to explore how they can inspire new ways of thinking in Islamic philosophy.
@@ReligiousStoryTVonly idiots follow kafir ibn arabi even hamza yusuf the deviant sufi admits his on pure kufr
Warning. .Deep understanding of tauhid needed so that not be misguided and blame others. Pray to Allah swt to guide the right haqqul path and indeed all the Haq and the Rightful path belongs to Allah swt.
Thank you for your thoughtful comment.
We agree that a deep understanding of Tawhid is essential, and our aim is to encourage reflection and exploration while always seeking guidance from Allah SWT. May He lead us all on the straight path. We appreciate your support and prayers.
A big truth.....
What does it mean to "have a deep understanding of Tawheed"?
@@junrad1 it's means that only Allah SWT exist no even you or any others of His creations.
JazakAllah great work ❤need more on ibn arabi Ibn Arabi was on another level his teachings are understood by special people normal people misunderstood him. But it didn't matter to him he was not here to please humans
@AbdulRahman-vr8rw thank you very much kind comment, yes we love Ibn Arabi and we try to teach his teachings to people. We agree with you about misunderstanding his teaching. we will try our best always to speak about his books from our perspective.
Ibn Arabi is one of the great Islamic scholars but many people think wrong about his teachings.
Thanks for your comment! Ibn Arabi’s teachings are deep, and we aim to clarify some common misunderstandings. Appreciate your support!
Sheikh e Akber ‘s works (1000 Tassawuf related books)isn’t for everyone! Even Scholars couldn’t even understand ! Ibne Timiya wasn’t a Sufi, against of Tassawuf, therefore his comments doesn’t worth none!
Are you a grave worshipper
@@shahidsyed3226ibn arabi the king of kafir and shirk
To understand ibn arabi the great mystic the person should be a spiritual gifted soul through a master of who has a degree from Hzt syed Abdel Qadir r a of Baghdad he is a grade of Qutub e Rabbani no one in auwaliya Allah community has got the highest order near to the creator.
0:15 Very good effort ,
Remember , this a powerful spiritual state when salik is in station of Fana fillah which experienced by concentration on on Ayat .کل من علیھا فان ۔
When this state is fully in bedded in Saliks mind every creation seiz to exist.
Then comes second stage of Baqa billah. With this Aya.
ویبقا وجھ ربک زلجلال والاکرام۔
At this stage only Allah is every where . His noor filled in whole imaginable spaces.
Words are not yet created to explain this stage experiences .
Remember Iman is state. You can't explain a state to one who isn't in that state.
Like hunger, pain, love one should have some common experience so that it can be explained.
In Tasauaf there is no student but Salik.
It's like guided tour or journey for Salik,
For others his books are like travel books.
Any how if you set your foot on this journey, every thing will become clear , and its a KASABI not WWAHBI. This mean open to all ,achievable for all Muslims as per Therfield efforts and Khuloos.
Regards 0:15
I understand what ibn arabi means as we Māori people have these understandings through our stories also.
I'd love to hear about the Maoris conception of the Supreme Being.
How does the metaphysics of Maori religious tradition view God?
Some claim wahdat wujud is pantheism and kufr when it is actually the total opposite . Wahdat wujud meaning is nothing exists besides Allah . All else is just shadows and illusions .
Muslims are so knowledged especially Arabs .
Quantum physics does seem to indicate that Ibn Arabi was right
Wahdatul Shuhud is more real and true than Wahdatul Wucud. Please check Ibn Sina and Imam Rabbani. we talked on our video about Imam Rabbani`s perspective about Wahdatul Shuhud. thank you.
@@ReligiousStoryTV can you give the link
Ibn Araby's highest spiritual experiential conconsciousness accomplishment was his personal "Isra' & Mi'raj', in the likeness of Prophet Muhammad.saw's own - which he accomplished 1-2 years before the Hijrah to Medina. Nevertheless, he was humble enough to proclaim his ascension was not to same level as that of the Propheht, even though in his Fusus he described meeetings with 27 named prophetic entities compared to the 8 names listed in the Prophet Muhammad's Hadith. In my research on what I would label as " The Quranic Islamic Six Day Quranic Creation Process" and " The Soul Progression Process" there is one statement unique in the Prophet Muhammad's Hadith that I couldn't find in IBN Araby's account of his ascension. And that is about what Prophet Muhammad was saying his witnessing of the Four Rivers. By this the Prophet is saying, in his own way, that, by Allah.Swt's Will, he was made to witness the Creation Process of the whole Universe and of Mankind. To a certain extent there statements in his Fusus that indicate he was also made to witness the Creation process such as the ever intriguing phrase "Creation is regenerated at every instant ( tadid al-khalq)". This is a very metalicca physics statements. What IBN Araby had said is a reaffirmation of what says in the al-Quran that Allah.Swt repeats a Creation when completed. That's just like saying when a neutrino enters at the centre of the Earth, a Star disappeared at the outermost boundary of the Universe. That sounds a quantum mechanic to me. And what did Ibn Tammiya and gang knew about the content of the Earth in their time period. May be their vision of wahdat ul wujud were a little too short. Sorry for the long read and TQ for reading.
Wahdatul Shuhud is just a misunderstanding of wahdat al Wujud. Its essentially in its core the same thing
@@ReligiousStoryTV Have u studied Imam Shah Waliullah Dehlvi RA?
These Arabic Scholars, their works and criticism should be taken in the regards of Arab World itself. They aren't meant for Non Arabs like us. If Islam was left to them, it certainly wouldn't have spread as it did among the Ajem ie Non Arabs.
You know the reason? their thing is too simplistic and rigid. Ibn Arabi, type legends who were born in Ajem ie Andalusia, lived among the non muslims had a far more insights of different ideologies, thinkings, ideas and so on. And that's what is reflected in his works of Wahdat ul Wajood too. And its Wajood not Wucud.
This was the man who inspired people like Imam Abu Hanifa, whose Fiqa Hanafi is the single largest Fiqa in the whole of ummat. 900 million followers out of a total of 1.9 billion. His wahdatul Wajood is followed in this fiqa. It explains in a deeper way how Allah's world works. The concept of 7 heavens, his throne....he himself etc etc.
Gives you a lot of thought provoking insights into his Realm. But i agree with this part though that for a novice, studying his work will certainly misguide them! unless yr at a certain level spiritually, mentally and in knowledge, u will never ever get him and his concepts.
I would advice you to study Imam Shah Waliullah Dehlvi (RA) to truly understand how big of a legend and master he and his concept of Wahdat ul Wajood was!
BTW, only how with the knowledge of Quantum Physics, world is truly understanding the validity of the concepts of Wahdat ul Wajood. You even made a before about his time dimensional works and theories. And mind you, this work was from 12th century AD. Remarkable isnt it??
The level of his head space was soo high that a novice, or a common man will certain get himself misguided!
If its possible to give references of the books you are quoting from that will be sooooo beneficial
Thank you for watching and commenting! In the video, I aimed to present classic Islamic responses to Ibn Arabi’s views, referencing these sources. Specifically, Imam Rabbani’s Maktubat offers a detailed critique of Ibn Arabi's concept of Wahdat al-Wujud.
Said Nursi’s Risale-i Nur Collection contains significant explanations on this subject. Asa-yı Musa: Nursi reflects on divine unity and creation, focusing on perspectives distinct from Ibn Arabi’s metaphysical unity and emphasizing personal responsibility and clarity in Islamic belief.
Ibn Taymiyyah:
Fatawa (Majmu' al-Fatawa): In his comprehensive Fatawa, particularly Volume 2, Ibn Taymiyyah critiques the philosophical foundations of Wahdat al-Wujud, as he found Ibn Arabi’s interpretation to conflict with orthodox Islamic teachings.
Kitab ar-Radd ala al-Mantiqiyyin (The Refutation of the Greek Logicians): While focusing on Greek philosophy, Ibn Taymiyyah discusses metaphysical arguments that relate to Ibn Arabi’s ideas, advocating for a more literal interpretation of Islamic texts.
Al-Furqan bayna Awliya’ al-Rahman wa-Awliya’ al-Shaytan (The Criterion Between the Friends of the Merciful and the Friends of Satan): Here, he addresses spiritual excesses, which he felt led to misunderstandings in Sufism, indirectly critiquing elements found in Ibn Arabi's writings.
I hope these references help deepen your understanding of the discussion!
Thanks for this video❤
My pleasure, welcome 🤗 😊
Ibn Arabi is incomparable in the history of mankind, in certain sense.
Yes very true, thank you for watching and comment 😊
Thank you, I understand more about wahdat al wudjud now...
MashAllah, very good part of book of Ibn Arabi, thanks a lot ❤
That's were closer to reality and fantasies, imagination and illusion, dreaming and out of dreams... Wallahualam...
yes, its better to far away from materialist world, isnt it? :)
Images used in this video are awesome, from which site you get these. Regards
thank you very much. there are many (like dall-e, midjourney-etc). I do not create images. our video editor creating these and its her secret amazing propmts :)
Please make a video on what is ism azam
thank you very much for suggesting and comment, I did note. we have similiar content about Ayatal Kursi secrets, please check it out our channel and watch it, thanks once :)
There is no true God but Allah and prophet Mohammad s.w is his last messenger. ❤❤❤
لا اله إلا الله- وحدت الوجود
محمد الرسول الله صلى الله عليه وآله و الصحابه آجمعين - وحدت الشهود
These teachings sre sufism. Normal simpleton muslims cnt grasp the idea n maybconfuse them. So those who don't understand, just dont try to. Thx
Thank you for watching and sharing your thoughts! Sufi teachings indeed contain deep spiritual dimensions and can sometimes be misunderstood, especially with more technical concepts. However, the essence of this knowledge is to understand the dimension of ihsan in Islam, which great scholars have clarified with care. If you keep watching, you’ll see that we try to present these topics in a simpler, more understandable way.
Wow...and what spiritual insight led u to call a fellow muslim a simpleton ?
There are a lot of kinds of people, physically strong, physically weak, intellectually strong, intellectually weak...
The are people who invent the most sophisticated machines and those who clean the streets...
We need all of them and degrading a fellow Muslim is...propably not the best thing to do, isn't it?
@@majdishaladi7854 nth wrong being a simpleton.
Why you put a dot like the hindus on the portrayal of Ibn Arabi....we are muslims and do not follow hindu traditions
Thank you for your feedback. We’ll be more mindful moving forward. The visuals in these videos are symbolic, meant to convey spiritual concepts to the viewer. Each image is designed to represent the essence of unity, Tawheed, in Islam and Sufism. We appreciate your interest and understanding.
@@ReligiousStoryTV 🙏💚
He is one of the greatest Sufis and one of the greatest men of Allah of all times.
yes he is. we love him. thank you very much for comment and watching.
MAŞAALLH SÜBHANALLAH❤ALLAHU EKBER SELAMETLE EMEGİNE YÜREGİNE SAĞLIK 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
I don't see any problem with his thinking if that's how it was understood, i think those who ciritize him just understood the title of the idea, and run with it, tho i can say it's prone to misunderstanding and misinterpreation.
It's true, if you believe that the material world have a real substance then you will fall into chirk, because you give matter an agency independent of God, hence i think Ibn Taymiya should reflect on his aquida because he said that the world is ancient like greek philosophers, so ibn Taymiya is the one who didn't understand Tawheed.
Ibn Arabi’s ideas are often deeply symbolic and can easily be misunderstood or superficially assessed. His perspective aligns with the belief that the material world lacks independent existence, affirming that all existence is grounded in God.
his views do not contradict Tawheed. As for Ibn Taymiyya some of his interpretations may indeed show influences from the philosophers' view of an eternal world. rather than questioning his commitment to Tawheed, such views should be regarded as differing perspectives.
Exactly! and thats why Ibne Tymia's works are hardly quoted or mentioned in the world outside of those 22 Arabic countries. And there r 57/58 Muslim countries in total. And Arabs make only 13% of the ummat today. Their thinking is very rigid and traditional, no deep and out of box thinking. Something thats highly encouraged in Sufism.
But good thing is that, his works did inspired people like Imam Bukhari and Imam Ibne Hanfi. And later to a master genius like Imam Shah Waliullah RA. Who explained his works in detail.
@@Blackbirdz2000 not even 22 arabic countries, the only ones who resurected him are wahabis who tried to rewrite hanbali school but ended hijacking it and creating salafism.
Wahdatul Wujud aka Manunggaling Kawula Gusti? It's very popular in Indonesia especially on Java island...
We explained with other islamic scholars. Please watch all video and understand the others opinions about Wahdetul Wujud. İt can make you go wrong way, cause some people thinking that's pantaizm, but it's not. Better to check imam Rabbanî, Said Nursi, ibn taymiyyah opinions as well at the video. Thanks.n
Ibn Arabi ra. People of his time could not understand him. Only through truth sight you will understand
Every knowledge should be intrepreted according to 4 levelof knowledge i.e shariat, tariqat, hakikat n makrifat ... physical n spiritual. With such knowledge one will understand the idea of Ibn Arabi perfectly
Thank you very much for good explanation and reminding. I am on the first level, shearia. And avarage Muslim I am, and not good enough my praying. I do not understand God's actions and even human actions and behaviours. İt's hard to follow and understand deeply espically. insha'Allah Allah gives us good knowledge to understand and accept Him and others and Qadar. Cause I do not want to go to hell ❤️
IBN Arabi very special and very complicated for many Muslims and also me. But with other scholars can help us to understand him sometimes. Like Imam rabbani explained his some ideas very clearly, that's why I added some of sentences from different Islamic scholars for wahdetul wujud and Arabi s role.
Asalamo alaikum, Qur'an is book of Guidance and Muslims are instructed by ALLAH to follow Basic and Fundamental Verses of Qur'an i.e Monotheism.
alaykumsalam brother. thank you for watching and comment.
I think jungian psychlogy shed some light about how to interpret suffi spiritual states, i think Carl Jung said that the true-self is half in the invidual unconscious and half in the collective unconscious, so the link between the collective and the invidual is the true-self
while he Ego is the manifestation of consciousness,
the people who interpret what suffis say with the Ego arn't understanding it, suffis basically are speaking thro the true-self, the self that doesn't have Ego, nor individualisty, so it's a self that is more ackin to the spirit that God have blown inside the creation.
the Nafs wahida that God had created all inviduals from it, it's the of devine spirit, and it's the one that suffism and other spiritual practices try to reach by negating and eclipsing the Ego.
You make an insightful connection between Sufi thought and Jungian psychology. Jung’s concepts of the collective unconscious and the “true self” bear similarities to the Sufi understanding of the self. Sufis strive to connect with what is known as the Nafs al-Wahida or True Self, a state where one is purified from ego and individual desires. This state is about reaching the divine spirit breathed into humanity by God and returning to the essential unity of creation. Therefore, interpreting Sufi ideas through the lens of the Ego alone would overlook the depth of their spiritual meaning.
Asalamu alykum.IBN ARABI
Thank you for watching and comment. Yes you are absolutely right. These books for not every Muslims. ❤️
Why do you say his book is dangerous? It's not dangerous. It's the most knowledgeable book of spirituality!
The book is great, of course, and very useful. However, the original, uncopied version is said to include some sections on dangerous magic. This is understandable, as the book aims to break down and address magic, which is why some spells are included.
There are many level of truth, on different degree of understanding. People that refute ibn arabi only see one face of the cube. The understanding of ibn arabi does not go against quran and sunnah. It is based on quran and sunnah, its the experiental knowledge based on it. We can’t understand this things by the mind but through tasting if the heart. Dont try to understand it if you cant. Leave it.
I think Imam Rabbani already answered IbnArabi`s idea. please watch it on the video. thank you for watching and your comment.
What made sufism unique, it is like 🌊 not bound by fixable dogma and regenerative like 🌙🌚♀️
Sufism is unique because it focuses on inner connection with the divine rather than strictly following set rules. It’s like the waves 🌊-always flowing, adapting to time and place, and guiding people through love, compassion, and introspection. Just like the phases of the moon 🌙, Sufism is all about personal growth and spiritual renewal, shedding the ego to make room for love and understanding.
In Sufism, teachings are passed down through experience and heart-to-heart connections, keeping it fresh and relatable for everyone seeking a deeper connection to God.
Ibn Arabi was far more knowledgeable and greater than his time. The islamic scholars would not understand and analyse his point of view and therefore did a great injustice to his works in the field of cosmic knowledge. Ibn Arabi was 100% correct in stating that everything belongs to Allah alone. There was nothing before the existence of Allah SWT and it is Allah alone who created the entire galaxies. In these galaxies lies stars, planets and other known and unknown things. Allah alone is most powerful and sovereign in authority. Everything exists with His knowledge. Allah is so majestic and great that we cannot even imagine His strength and power. He is so powerful that He created the entire cosmos, the entire universe in just six days and nights. It is Allah who created time and nobody can ever stop time except Allah. When Allah wishes to stop time ie, when He wishes Qayamat to occur, the time stops as the time stops the entire cosmos and the universe will crumble like soft cotton particles floating in the field at the mercy of wind. Apart from being so majestic, gigantic and powerful, Allah is most humble, most caring, most kind, most merciful, most tolerant, most beneficent, most gracious and most affectionate. It is Allah who allowed human species to benefit from his creation. The nature created by Allah never discriminates as it gives humans the food to survive. The nature is a beautiful garden which has flowers, fruits, mountains, rivers, oceans etc. Allah is most just as He decides our survival on this planet based on our actions. Allah is so loving and caring that He forgives anyone He desires. Allah is omnipotent and omnipresent. His will and wish is final. It is Allah who blessed the people of every community with His prophets so as to guide them towards straight path. Allah is most honest as he commands fair dealings in the business and Allah forbades illegal activities with appropriate punishment. Allah is great... Allahu Akbar !
We can keep describing about Allah and His supreme qualities for years. We may feel fatigue and stop describing His qualities as His presence and power is infinite.
im more inclined to believe imam al ghazali
Your preference for Imam Al-Ghazali is very natural; he holds a prominent place in Islamic thought and emphasized sound knowledge and devotion for spiritual growth. Thank you for your comment!
Ibn Taymia was a gem in his earliest life, however, he was misguided later and started questioning credibility on Taqlid on 4 imams. Do not follow him!
Taqlid is not fard.
If anyone opposes blind taqlid then it's absolutely correct.
Thank you for your comments! I wasn’t aware of what happened to Ibn Taymiyya later on, but we also included thoughts from scholars like Imam Rabbani, Said Nursi and Ghazali in the video. Did you have a chance to listen to those sections? Thanks for engaging with the content!
What ibn Arabi is trying to say is? Only existed in beginning is Noor of Allah, Allah is Noor, consider a room fill with Noor, and nothing else exist, then Allah decided to create makhlooks, he shrink his size which occupied whole room, darkness we see is absent of Noor, otherwise darkness doesn't exist initially, he created water, arsh, kursi from Noor, shrinking his size he than sat on arsh, later he created universes and makhlooks inside universes from water, water is made of Allah's Noor, so indirectly Allah is present everywhere, we are part of water through which we are created and water was created by Allah's Noor, please don't consider water as our regular water, this water is made of Noor and different from regular water.
Allah is not an Noor; Allah has His own light (Noor). However, Allah is not something we can see with our eyes and does not resemble any of His creations. He is not matter or light; His nature is very different. Speaking on this matter is not correct, as it is beyond our understanding in this world. Therefore, Islamic scholars have found it inappropriate to discuss what Allah is made of.
Allah created the human soul with His light and breathed from His own soul. Allah has placed immense value on humans, creating them in the most special and superior way, with great artistry and love. He desires no attention other than love and affection and seeks the love of His servants. Those who show this love are the most esteemed in the sight of Allah. May Allah make all of us among those who reach such levels and attain closeness to Him. ❤️
billy carson channel there some slight similarity about this idea but more to sciencetific and ancient text, research about the entity (god) or being
Only shia islam is the true path
We believe there is only God and we were created by God. We are not God or part of God. Sunni Islam or any part of different islam, we believe only one God. We do not accept panteism or something similar. ibn Arabi did not say directly, we already explained on our video. İmam rabbani is correct about this subject, WAHDATUL shuhud. Please check it. Thank you for your comment and watching.
Can you please give the proof of Ibn Araby's prophecy about the WW III? In which of his writings he had said that?
Thank you for watching!
The claim of Ibn Arabi predicting major global events, such as a potential World War III, is complex and debated. In works like Al-Futuhat al-Makkiyya (The Meccan Revelations), he explores themes of societal turmoil, spiritual challenges, and a symbolic battle between material and spiritual values. However, these are generally symbolic and open to interpretation rather than direct prophecies.
While some scholars or enthusiasts interpret his writings as alluding to major future conflicts, they typically reference spiritual or esoteric struggles rather than specific events like world wars.
❤❤
Should the title be Wahdatul Wujud?
Thank you very much, we will edit it very soon. ❤️
Do not be misguided by these people. Please follow Allah’s book The Quran, the Hadiths and Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad and try be like the Sahaba.
Just read all other books like story books and move on and Don’t get stuck.
You will need to face Allah on judgement day.
We published Imam Rabbani, Said Nursi, İmam Ghazali and Ibn Taymiyyah and Ibn Arabi opinions together. We do not misguide anybody with these great Islamic scholars. Thank you for suggesting ❤️
Not justification, from these people like ibne arabi created so many sects, Muslims umma divided, but Islam is pure and clear,
Figures like Ibn Arabi didn’t aim to create divisions but sought to deepen spiritual understanding within Islam. His works focus on divine love, unity, and personal connection to God, which align with core Islamic values. Divisions in the ummah often stem from complex historical and political factors, not the ideas of scholars who contributed to Islamic spirituality.
Stupid muslims who did not have the courage and tenacity to study Ibn Arabi, got divided among themselves on the pretext of Ibn Arabi.
The word "intoxication" could easily be perceived as harmful. I would personally classify it as "cainian" in English/ Hebrew or "qabilian" in Arabic. Jealousy, I suppose must be the first human defilement ythat Allah.Swt had created and still is recreated at every instant, as beasts are.😊
The term 'spiritual intoxication' is indeed appropriate here. Ibn Arabi experienced an advanced state of divine love, where he was so immersed in God that he couldn’t see anything else, ultimately developing his philosophy of wahdat al-wujud (oneness of being). However, his inability to perceive anything outside of God doesn’t imply that nothing else exists. Just because one can’t see beyond their beloved doesn’t mean everything else is non-existent. Many Islamic scholars, such as Imam Rabbani (explained in the video), surpassed his level and critically examined Arabi's perspective, providing persuasive reasons as to why it may not be entirely accurate.
Did you happen to watch the video to the end? Thank you so much for your comment; please stay tuned for more!
dangerous 😂😂😂😂😂.Allah is One.. that's All. None equals the multi faceted God Our Only Creator
Allah does NOT say anything in a Hadith. Bruh, come on.
but this is probably AI so no fuss
There is kudthi hadith type which is Allah almight speaks and than prophet Mohammad (saw) says. There are many Turkish books also mention kutsu hadis in Turkish. Please research and learn ❤️
But modern days grave worshippers portray him as their leader
Thank you for your comment. It’s important to clarify that Ibn Arabi’s teachings have historically been understood and interpreted in various ways by scholars and students of Islamic thought. While some groups may refer to him in ways that may differ from mainstream or orthodox Islamic teachings, Ibn Arabi himself was focused on advancing knowledge of the inner, spiritual dimensions of faith and unity with God, rather than endorsing practices like grave worship, which are outside traditional Islamic beliefs.
God And His Creation is ONE: a drop of water falls in an Ocean
GOD and Creation are separate : A Drop of water Leaks from the Ocean.
Those who perceive beyond the Body Mind Thought are ENLIGHTENED BEINGS . They see themselves in EVERYTHING and EVERYTHING in THEM, They are One with GOD : DIVINE CHILDREN OF GOD
Separate from GOD: Servants of GOD.
That’s the Difference.
There is no children of God, no doubt. Sural Kafh, Allah almight says very clearly. And also no similarities human and God body or existence. Human and all other things has begining, God not. The ocean and drop water example, you need to change the names. Normal people can be drop, ocean can be Mohammad Saw, cause same material of our bodies. Not God is ocean. İt's wrong analogy. Thanks
If Ibn Tamiyya is alive today, I would adk him to deliberate on two Quranic verses. One that says Allah is closer to you that your jugular vein. The other one is Allah.swt surrounds everything. Mind you it is by Allah.Swt's Will that mankind tiday have been up skilled in their critical thinking and enriched scientific vocabulary , it is not the objective jugular vein that we have to focus on, in our contemplation, but what flows thru it. And ....everything means all inclusive, the macros and the micros, the atomic snd the nuclear.😅
No there is a verse in Quran.
Ar rahman alal arsh is tawa.
Allah SWT is on his arsh.
Again too much deviation.
How sahabah viewed the things is best way forward.
According to Sunni Islam, Allah and created beings are distinct and independent entities. Allah is the absolute, eternal Creator, while we are contingent and limited beings. Ibn Sina explains that Allah is the necessary being , meaning His existence is independent and inherent, while our existence is entirely dependent on His will.
In this context, the concept of Wahdat al-Shuhud is also relevant. This perspective holds that everything bears witness to Allah’s oneness and majesty, but it does not imply that created beings are themselves Allah. As His creation, we seek to "witness" Him in existence, not become Him.
Some one try to silence My guy IBn
No, not silence. We love İbn Arabi. You can check our channel, we have many videos of Arabi. But in this case, we publish also many Islamic scholars discussing about WAHDATUL WUJUD. Nobody said wrong about Arabi, they respect but not respect to wahdetul wujud. We just publish this.
This is AI generated. Please be careful deciphering the concepts here.
No, we are not AI and we have references from ibn Arabi, İmam Rabbani, Said Nursi, ibn tayymiyah and Ghazali.
THIS IS BIDAH...
what is bidah?
He means بدعة.. Innovation
@@shimoesmat1898 So it's like bringing something new to religion.
Exactly 🙂@@LucyPennywise
You mean ☯.
every thougts effect each other, of course ying yang can be effected also.
Allah is not god. There are no god. God are idols that are worshipped and is forbidden. 5 x prayers a day is not act of worship. Im not going to tell what prayers are about. Not yet.
But, I tell you this. Every creations comes out of Allah. Allah is not god. It's something else.
Its essential to note that creations become when atoms and its contents vibrate at speed more than speed of light.
Allah sent the religion of Islam 1400 years ago and said, "I do not resemble any being, and I am not made of matter. I am beyond space and time, I have no beginning or end, meaning I am not within time. Additionally, the flow of time for you and its flow elsewhere are different. What is five thousand years for you could be like five years somewhere else."
In the last century, we scientifically learned that time is created and relative. Furthermore, the entire universe is created, it has a beginning and an end. The power that creates the universe must not be bound by time or space. If time and space are created, how could it be contained within them? It must exist beyond them. He just says “Be,” and it is. There is no difficulty for Him. He did not create in six days and then rest, as in the Christian and Jewish beliefs; Israel did not wrestle with Him and win, and He did not have a son to send. Such nonsensical views do not exist in Islam. In Islam, Allah is not human, He does not resemble humans in form. Some of the human attributes resemble Allah's, but the difference in quantity is like that between a tiny drop and the ocean. It is like comparing infinity to a finite number.
We have faith in Allah, and may He keep us on the right path, and guide you to the right path as well. The self is dangerous, do not trust your own thoughts. Always consult reliable sources. Humans are prone to mistakes.
@@ReligiousStoryTV the Qur’an was revealed 1400 years ago not Islam. Islam is the religion of Adam and all prophets, of course people thousands of years ago might have not called it "Islam" literally, they might have a different name for it in their language but it's still the same religion. Noe the guy above you is completely lost. This is why going philosophy and ignoring the words of God, can lead you astray. ALLAH knows best.
Yes I did make mistake. Islam is only one religion from Adam, noah, moses, Jesus and 124k prophets and also last prophet Mostofa Mohammad (saw). I should have said Mohammadi shariat of Islam. Thank you for e
Warn me brother
Tao-heed?
so deep '-'
Yes.
You mean ☯ ?
@@ZainalAbidinBinJalil yes, the subtitles were saying "taoheed" instead of "twahid" xd
But in english, they suggest tawhid. I am also confusing about writing of English. I used Google translate and chatgpt pro version.
Have you even read what you are talking about? In the original language - because that is what every writer of genius - which Ibn ‘Arabī is - deserves? I doubt it - your pronunciation of his name is just so far from what it should be that the rest will have not obtained more respect from you than that. Now, you or others in your defense may reply: leave the pronouncer alone - “they” is after all only an AI tool. Aha! If you are an AI tool, why would I even bother to listen to the first letter you pronounce. You are not, as Ibn ‘Arabī would see, a letter from one of the infinite number of letters of one of the infinite number of Names of God. Stop whispering. Into my ears or any other’s.
I wish I were an AI, without emotions, without accountability, without the grave, judgment, and hell awaiting me. After all the effort, I wouldn’t still be blamed, and my heart wouldn’t skip a beat. But unfortunately, here I am, human, once again answering accusations.
So, where were we? I am Turkish; I don’t know how to pronounce Ibn Arabi’s name, but if he were alive and I called out to him, he wouldn’t mind. I wish you didn’t either.
I listen to Ibn Arabi audiobooks. There are no books in my language where I live. Besides, even if there were, I couldn’t afford them right now. That’s why free audiobooks are great. Before preparing a video, I watch at least a few others. I look at what other scholars have said. I am not a scholar; I certainly have mistakes, I have gaps. But I will keep doing my best. I don’t want to sit idle at home; I want to work a bit and learn. And if I can make money along the way, that’s even better. Hopefully, you are also using your free time productively. Thank you for your feedback and your comment. Next time, if you specify where I went wrong, you’d be more helpful to me. For now, goodbye, and may God protect you.
My religion is the religion of love.....he is misguided for sure.
The sun does not shine to illuminate its own path.
Fruit trees do not consume their own fruits.
The wind does not blow for its own pleasure, and the earth does not rotate to reach its own goal.
Likewise, our eyes were not created to see their own way, nor do our ears hear for their own enjoyment.
Allah created the universe to be known. This is mentioned in a Qudsi Hadith (Acluni, Kashf al-Khafa, II, 132):
"I created the jinn and humankind only so that they may know and worship Me." (Adh-Dhariyat, 51:56)
This is not about compulsory worship, but about worship filled with love, performed with understanding and affection. As they worship, they grow in love and comprehension of Allah. The purpose is this: Allah wished to love and be loved. Why does a hidden treasure want to be known? For love, for passion, for those who seek and strive to find it, for those who put in effort to reach it, and for those who love and yearn to meet it.
Allah placed love and mercy in our hearts; He gave it from Himself. He gave it to animals and plants too. We see this mercy everywhere in the universe, but there is much more of it in Allah. Inshallah, we can find Him, my brother.
Also No scholar was perfect.
We should respect every scholar for their service to Islam.
They may have made mistakes.
So no need of picking one thing or one opinion to malign any scholar.
But yes things should be viewed in perspective of Quran and Sunnah.
yes %100 agree, we tried to prepare with 5 different islamic scholars in this video for discussing Wahdatul Wujud and Shuhud. so people can agree any of them and its the most important Quran and Sunnah of course like you said. Thank you very much.
WITH ALL THESE CHARLATONS THATS WHY IT IS IMPORTANT FOR EVERYONE TO FOLLOW THE SHIA TRADITION. WHICH IS WHY ALLAH WANTED MUSLIMS TO FOLLOW THE HOLY FAMILY OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD PBUH. WHO WOULD HAVE BEEN BETTER ROLE MODELS AND TEACHERS TO LEARN FROM BECAUSE WITH ALL THESE OTHERS THEY COULD BE FAKE
Shia was created by Jews; everyone knows this history well. They did not change the Qur'an, but they divided Muslims. Shia uses only the names of Ali and the Ahlul Bayt. Your Shia books begin with cursing Abu Bakr, Omar, and Aisha. Even hypocrites don’t curse publicly. You should reflect on your own path. Sunni Islam is the main truth and the only one.
Dirilis Ertugrul
Yes, Turkish TV series. I am Turkish as well :)
@@ReligiousStoryTV Look Ibn Arabi Was Shown In Dirilis Ertugrul
There is no true God but Allah and prophet Mohammad s.w is his last messenger. ❤❤❤
My religion is the religion of love.....he is misguided for sure.
Allah created this world for the muhabbetullah (Love of God).
There is no true God but Allah and prophet Mohammad s.w is his last messenger. ❤❤❤
My religion is the religion of love.....he is misguided for sure.
Allah kept him be special always. Allah create universe for love (muhabbatullah)