IBN ARABI'S DANGEROUS Idea: WAHDATUL WUJUD Effects in Islamic World
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 окт 2024
- Ibn Arabi, the renowned Sufi mystic, left a lasting mark on Islamic thought, but why were his works considered so dangerous that they were banned?
What is the hidden mystery behind his teachings of Wahdat al-Wujud (the Unity of Being), and why did great scholars like Imam Rabbani, Ibn Taymiyyah, and Bediuzzaman express concern over his ideas?
In this video, we explore the profound spiritual insights of Ibn Arabi, delving into his famous works such as Fusus al-Hikam and Al-Futuhat al-Makkiyya. Did Ibn Arabi, in his state of spiritual intoxication, unveil truths beyond comprehension, or were his teachings open to misinterpretation, leading to controversy?
We’ll also discuss how Imam Ghazali's earlier thoughts laid the groundwork for mystical exploration, yet differed in key ways from Ibn Arabi's philosophy. Furthermore, we'll examine the caution expressed by Islamic scholars regarding Wahdat al-Wujud, comparing it with Wahdat al-Shuhud, and why this distinction remains crucial in Islamic theology.
Join us as we unravel these complex ideas and the debates surrounding one of Islam’s most enigmatic figures. What did Islamic scholars truly think about Ibn Arabi, and why did they approach his works with both awe and caution? Share your thoughts in the comments, and don't forget to subscribe for more deep dives into the rich history of Islamic philosophy and mysticism!
#IbnArabi #WahdatAlWujud #SufiPhilosophy #IslamicMysticism #IbnTaymiyyah #ImamRabbani #Bediuzzaman #IslamicScholars #FususAlHikam #AlFutuhatAlMakkiyya #SpiritualIntoxication #UnityOfBeing #WahdatAlShuhud #ImamGhazali #SufiTeachings #IslamicHistory #Mysticism #Philosophy
Thanks for watching! If you enjoyed the video, don't forget to share it with others, drop a comment, and support us by hitting the like button. Your support means a lot!
🎉🎉
Please make a video on What is the ism Azam.
Thanks for video, it's great
WITH ALL THESE CHARLATONS THATS WHY IT IS IMPORTANT FOR EVERYONE TO FOLLOW THE SHIA TRADITION. WHICH IS WHY ALLAH WANTED MUSLIMS TO FOLLOW THE HOLY FAMILY OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD PBUH. WHO WOULD HAVE BEEN BETTER ROLE MODELS AND TEACHERS TO LEARN FROM BECAUSE WITH ALL THESE OTHERS THEY COULD BE FAKE
@@risale-inuronline2711WITH ALL THESE CHARLATONS THATS WHY IT IS IMPORTANT FOR EVERYONE TO FOLLOW THE SHIA TRADITION. WHICH IS WHY ALLAH WANTED MUSLIMS TO FOLLOW THE HOLY FAMILY OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD PBUH. WHO WOULD HAVE BEEN BETTER ROLE MODELS AND TEACHERS TO LEARN FROM BECAUSE WITH ALL THESE OTHERS THEY COULD BE FAKE
Quantum physics does seem to indicate that Ibn Arabi was right
Wahdatul Shuhud is more real and true than Wahdatul Wucud. Please check Ibn Sina and Imam Rabbani. we talked on our video about Imam Rabbani`s perspective about Wahdatul Shuhud. thank you.
@@ReligiousStoryTV can you give the link
Ibn Araby's highest spiritual experiential conconsciousness accomplishment was his personal "Isra' & Mi'raj', in the likeness of Prophet Muhammad.saw's own - which he accomplished 1-2 years before the Hijrah to Medina. Nevertheless, he was humble enough to proclaim his ascension was not to same level as that of the Propheht, even though in his Fusus he described meeetings with 27 named prophetic entities compared to the 8 names listed in the Prophet Muhammad's Hadith. In my research on what I would label as " The Quranic Islamic Six Day Quranic Creation Process" and " The Soul Progression Process" there is one statement unique in the Prophet Muhammad's Hadith that I couldn't find in IBN Araby's account of his ascension. And that is about what Prophet Muhammad was saying his witnessing of the Four Rivers. By this the Prophet is saying, in his own way, that, by Allah.Swt's Will, he was made to witness the Creation Process of the whole Universe and of Mankind. To a certain extent there statements in his Fusus that indicate he was also made to witness the Creation process such as the ever intriguing phrase "Creation is regenerated at every instant ( tadid al-khalq)". This is a very metalicca physics statements. What IBN Araby had said is a reaffirmation of what says in the al-Quran that Allah.Swt repeats a Creation when completed. That's just like saying when a neutrino enters at the centre of the Earth, a Star disappeared at the outermost boundary of the Universe. That sounds a quantum mechanic to me. And what did Ibn Tammiya and gang knew about the content of the Earth in their time period. May be their vision of wahdat ul wujud were a little too short. Sorry for the long read and TQ for reading.
His ideas really push the boundaries of traditional thought, and it’s fascinating to see how they could impact Islamic philosophy moving forward.
Glad you found it fascinating! Ibn Arabi's ideas truly challenge traditional perspectives, and we're excited to explore how they can inspire new ways of thinking in Islamic philosophy.
@@ReligiousStoryTVonly idiots follow kafir ibn arabi even hamza yusuf the deviant sufi admits his on pure kufr
JazakAllah great work ❤need more on ibn arabi Ibn Arabi was on another level his teachings are understood by special people normal people misunderstood him. But it didn't matter to him he was not here to please humans
@AbdulRahman-vr8rw thank you very much kind comment, yes we love Ibn Arabi and we try to teach his teachings to people. We agree with you about misunderstanding his teaching. we will try our best always to speak about his books from our perspective.
Warning. .Deep understanding of tauhid needed so that not be misguided and blame others. Pray to Allah swt to guide the right haqqul path and indeed all the Haq and the Rightful path belongs to Allah swt.
Thank you for your thoughtful comment.
We agree that a deep understanding of Tawhid is essential, and our aim is to encourage reflection and exploration while always seeking guidance from Allah SWT. May He lead us all on the straight path. We appreciate your support and prayers.
Ibn Arabi is one of the great Islamic scholars but many people think wrong about his teachings.
Thanks for your comment! Ibn Arabi’s teachings are deep, and we aim to clarify some common misunderstandings. Appreciate your support!
Sheikh e Akber ‘s works (1000 Tassawuf related books)isn’t for everyone! Even Scholars couldn’t even understand ! Ibne Timiya wasn’t a Sufi, against of Tassawuf, therefore his comments doesn’t worth none!
Are you a grave worshipper
@@shahidsyed3226ibn arabi the king of kafir and shirk
I understand what ibn arabi means as we Māori people have these understandings through our stories also.
I'd love to hear about the Maoris conception of the Supreme Being.
How does the metaphysics of Maori religious tradition view God?
That's were closer to reality and fantasies, imagination and illusion, dreaming and out of dreams... Wallahualam...
yes, its better to far away from materialist world, isnt it? :)
Thank you, I understand more about wahdat al wudjud now...
MashAllah, very good part of book of Ibn Arabi, thanks a lot ❤
Please make a video on what is ism azam
Thanks for this video❤
My pleasure, welcome 🤗 😊
لا اله إلا الله- وحدت الوجود
محمد الرسول الله صلى الله عليه وآله و الصحابه آجمعين - وحدت الشهود
Not justification, from these people like ibne arabi created so many sects, Muslims umma divided, but Islam is pure and clear,
If its possible to give references of the books you are quoting from that will be sooooo beneficial
Ibn Taymia was a gem in his earliest life, however, he was misguided later and started questioning credibility on Taqlid on 4 imams. Do not follow him!
Can you please give the proof of Ibn Araby's prophecy about the WW III? In which of his writings he had said that?
Wahdatul Wujud aka Manunggaling Kawula Gusti? It's very popular in Indonesia especially on Java island...
I don't see any problem with his thinking if that's how it was understood, i think those who ciritize him just understood the title of the idea, and run with it, tho i can say it's prone to misunderstanding and misinterpreation.
It's true, if you believe that the material world have a real substance then you will fall into chirk, because you give matter an agency independent of God, hence i think Ibn Taymiya should reflect on his aquida because he said that the world is ancient like greek philosophers, so ibn Taymiya is the one who didn't understand Tawheed.
I think jungian psychlogy shed some light about how to interpret suffi spiritual states, i think Carl Jung said that the true-self is half in the invidual unconscious and half in the collective unconscious, so the link between the collective and the invidual is the true-self
while he Ego is the manifestation of consciousness,
the people who interpret what suffis say with the Ego arn't understanding it, suffis basically are speaking thro the true-self, the self that doesn't have Ego, nor individualisty, so it's a self that is more ackin to the spirit that God have blown inside the creation.
the Nafs wahida that God had created all inviduals from it, it's the of devine spirit, and it's the one that suffism and other spiritual practices try to reach by negating and eclipsing the Ego.
The word "intoxication" could easily be perceived as harmful. I would personally classify it as "cainian" in English/ Hebrew or "qabilian" in Arabic. Jealousy, I suppose must be the first human defilement ythat Allah.Swt had created and still is recreated at every instant, as beasts are.😊
❤❤
These teachings sre sufism. Normal simpleton muslims cnt grasp the idea n maybconfuse them. So those who don't understand, just dont try to. Thx
If Ibn Tamiyya is alive today, I would adk him to deliberate on two Quranic verses. One that says Allah is closer to you that your jugular vein. The other one is Allah.swt surrounds everything. Mind you it is by Allah.Swt's Will that mankind tiday have been up skilled in their critical thinking and enriched scientific vocabulary , it is not the objective jugular vein that we have to focus on, in our contemplation, but what flows thru it. And ....everything means all inclusive, the macros and the micros, the atomic snd the nuclear.😅
But modern days grave worshippers portray him as their leader
Why you put a dot like the hindus on the portrayal of Ibn Arabi....we are muslims and do not follow hindu traditions
Should the title be Wahdatul Wujud?
Thank you very much, we will edit it very soon. ❤️
billy carson channel there some slight similarity about this idea but more to sciencetific and ancient text, research about the entity (god) or being
Only shia islam is the true path
God And His Creation is ONE: a drop of water falls in an Ocean
GOD and Creation are separate : A Drop of water Leaks from the Ocean.
Those who perceive beyond the Body Mind Thought are ENLIGHTENED BEINGS . They see themselves in EVERYTHING and EVERYTHING in THEM, They are One with GOD : DIVINE CHILDREN OF GOD
Separate from GOD: Servants of GOD.
That’s the Difference.
There is no children of God, no doubt. Sural Kafh, Allah almight says very clearly. And also no similarities human and God body or existence. Human and all other things has begining, God not. The ocean and drop water example, you need to change the names. Normal people can be drop, ocean can be Mohammad Saw, cause same material of our bodies. Not God is ocean. İt's wrong analogy. Thanks
Some one try to silence My guy IBn
No, not silence. We love İbn Arabi. You can check our channel, we have many videos of Arabi. But in this case, we publish also many Islamic scholars discussing about WAHDATUL WUJUD. Nobody said wrong about Arabi, they respect but not respect to wahdetul wujud. We just publish this.
im more inclined to believe imam al ghazali
This is AI generated. Please be careful deciphering the concepts here.
No, we are not AI and we have references from ibn Arabi, İmam Rabbani, Said Nursi, ibn tayymiyah and Ghazali.
Allah is not god. There are no god. God are idols that are worshipped and is forbidden. 5 x prayers a day is not act of worship. Im not going to tell what prayers are about. Not yet.
But, I tell you this. Every creations comes out of Allah. Allah is not god. It's something else.
Its essential to note that creations become when atoms and its contents vibrate at speed more than speed of light.
Allah sent the religion of Islam 1400 years ago and said, "I do not resemble any being, and I am not made of matter. I am beyond space and time, I have no beginning or end, meaning I am not within time. Additionally, the flow of time for you and its flow elsewhere are different. What is five thousand years for you could be like five years somewhere else."
In the last century, we scientifically learned that time is created and relative. Furthermore, the entire universe is created, it has a beginning and an end. The power that creates the universe must not be bound by time or space. If time and space are created, how could it be contained within them? It must exist beyond them. He just says “Be,” and it is. There is no difficulty for Him. He did not create in six days and then rest, as in the Christian and Jewish beliefs; Israel did not wrestle with Him and win, and He did not have a son to send. Such nonsensical views do not exist in Islam. In Islam, Allah is not human, He does not resemble humans in form. Some of the human attributes resemble Allah's, but the difference in quantity is like that between a tiny drop and the ocean. It is like comparing infinity to a finite number.
We have faith in Allah, and may He keep us on the right path, and guide you to the right path as well. The self is dangerous, do not trust your own thoughts. Always consult reliable sources. Humans are prone to mistakes.
You mean ☯.
Tao-heed?
so deep '-'
Yes.
You mean ☯ ?
@@ZainalAbidinBinJalil yes, the subtitles were saying "taoheed" instead of "twahid" xd
THIS IS BIDAH...
what is bidah?
He means بدعة.. Innovation
@@shimoesmat1898 So it's like bringing something new to religion.
Exactly 🙂@@LucyPennywise
Dirilis Ertugrul
Yes, Turkish TV series. I am Turkish as well :)
@@ReligiousStoryTV Look Ibn Arabi Was Shown In Dirilis Ertugrul