Amber's lawyers are pretty bad..Johnny's lawyers especially the young brunette one are running rings around them and outclassing them every step of the way. Objections on nearly every attempt to cross-examine witnesses, constant basic errors like questions lacking foundation, hearsay, witness leading.. terrible lawyers Amber has.
I don't think it started this way but, it's starting to feel like a strategy. When the defense gets objected to they become argumentative and have conversations that should normally be reserved for a private side bar. What the defense is often doing is essentially coaching the witness on how they need to answer the question.
I can’t imagine financially supporting someone and all their friends for years. Providing housing, trips and lavish lifestyles for them to turn on me and say I did these awful things. Funny how, according to Amber, that everyone from doctors, assistants, multiple police officers and people who seen her daily, are all lying except her and her friends.
This is exactly what is happening. I don't believe anything Amber or her best friend says. "Former" friend...yeah right. I believe they were in on this from the beginning and still are. I pray the jury sees through all these lies.
I don’t think her friends are lying. I think amber may have exaggerated some details but I do think it’s true that johnny hit her. I also think that she, esp at the latter end of the relationship, also hit him. This entire thing is just sad.
@@mins1668 yeah, I really don’t think Johnny is 100% innocent. I’m sure he’s pushed her or slapped her. I definitely don’t think he’s done as much as she’s claiming, though
@@randihenderson7750 I thought exactly the same, after being told what's the picture is about she says the picture describes accurately the scene, even when she didn't even know what the pic was about before... suspicious
This whole thing is ridiculous. He’s carried amber and her friends financially, provided them ALL with everything they wanted and needed, houses them together… what abuser does this. All of them took advantage of Johnny
Exactly what he did is rare. But it just goes to show how generous and wonderful he is, and how insignificant the people he let into his life and homes were.
Exactly! An abuser does everything in their power to alienate friends and family of the victim so why would he let all of them move in around them … and for FREE?
The thing that keeps bugging me is they keep showing pictures of "bruises" on the right side of Amber's face. Johnny is right handed. Her left side should have the "bruises "
They don't look like they're from a punch at all. The one shot of the lip definitely looks like a cold sore, and if that bit of hair came from the top of Amber's head, the length is all wrong (if it was pulled out by the roots it would have been longer).
So let me get this right. Johnny was paying for Amber, Her sister, her friend, and her friends boyfriend to live in penthouses in the Columbia building in LA.... Payed for their food, alcohol, and drugs. Now they are trying to ruin his life. Sounds about right.
Reminds me of OJs situation. The grifting was strong. Poor JD had enough of the neverending stream of grifting leaches living off him & his money. And ms b*tch was nagging him crazy. These mfkrs got together & staged this.
why do amber and all her friends only get “emotional” once her lawyers are asking the questions?? when johnny’s team is asking the questions they are stone cold, makes no sense
They are all fake. Real friends would have reported every incident and got her out of there. Buncha gold diggers - they just tried to milk JD for as long as they could and that obvs come to an end if AH left him. All a facade.
Because they're all just as AH, Fake and Liars..... But it also seems that they're afraid of AH because AH knows stuff about them. They know now what AH is capable of and they don't want everyone to know there dirty secrets too. When Pennington started to get emotional and cried she had the same Fake expressions on her face as AH during her fake crying parts
Soooo, Amber testifies that his finger was severed from smashing the phone to smithereens, but she tells her acting coach/friend that Johnny Cut it off while holding a broken bottle. So, which one is it Amber?
this trial truly never ceases to amaze me. it’s clear both amber & johnny we’re terrible for each other and they each brought out the worst parts of themselves, but i think it’s clear that amber was a clear instigator here. while no one will ever truly know who is telling the whole truth, amber and her witnesses seem to be very rehearsed and very in tune with each other whereas johnny’s witnesses all feel like they’re much more genuine & answering everything based on their truth and observations & that to me is very telling. no one is right here, both johnny and amber both did their fair share of hurting the other, but something johnny has done that amber hasn’t, is admit it. it truly feels like she thinks she’s telling the truth when all the evidence provided, not only by johnny’s team but hers as well, has proved incorrect several times. it’s interesting . . . if nothing else, it’s certainly interesting 🫣
In my opinion , during their marriage heard and her friends were in their late 20s , a lot younger than depp. I think they thought they could scam him out of money and use and abuse his kindness (hence they were all living In penthouses for free!!) and the whole domestic abuse thing she probably thought I’ll accuse him and he’ll pay me off, I don’t think she thought he’d take it this far. I’ve been around domestic abuse and people who drink a lot, she’s not scared of him one bit
What a coincidence that Amber and IO got in touch with Josh a couple of months before his deposition. AND Amber got in touch with her acting coach just before the deposition aswell. Even though both hadn’t spoke to her in years.
Three of those witness depositions the were suddenly contacted from a month to three months before their deposition. The make up artist conveniently "stops" contact/being Amber's friend 1 month before hee deposition.
He seems to know many of the questions before they are asked! 😂 His and Rockys delivery style is the absolute antithesis of one another. So bizarre that they were together and imagining how they conversed! 🤪🤪
If no one can see that this is a complete set up, then I don't know what world we live in ! That is an absolute bleeding cold sore and the rest is a bit of make up ! What an actress that friend
On 21st May, Raquel went over to Amber in PH3 because Amber texted her and she went straight over and heard Amber & Johnny shouting. So... when did IO phone Raquel to go over there as he testified? And why didn’t Raquel mention being called by IO?
also amber said the pic with the thumb on her her was Johnny's right and it does look mainly and thick and badly matiance (compiaired to lady's nails) but rocky said it was her finger in the photo and then the next photo was the pic of blonde hair on the floor with a finger (slim finger well matianced nail). so she lied it was about 1h 50m in and she had o yellow jacket, can anyone go back and double check. why had no lawyer catches on about both accounts on these photos .
@@lizs179 which is weird because she cried a lot but never shed a tear. She sniffed a lot but her nose always sounded dry. It's funny how things work out the opposite of the way we intend sometimes
I've watched all 3 broadcasted stations. This one is by far the better recording with clearest audio and video. Entertainment Tonight and Lan and Crime EDIT parts of the witness testimonies OUT! Also, we should not have to repeatedly turn down our volume for ADS and then keep turning it back up for the court case!
How come they're not questioning the fact that ... in the first frontal picture her lips look fine ... then in the second side picture she has a big swollen bleeding lip ... there's no way that wouldn't show up on the frontal picture ... those photos were clearly doctored or faked after the fact.
So Rocky says there was glass everywhere and they didn't touch anything on the bed, and that Amber and the dogs were asleep in the bed with the glass, pocket knife and splinter of wood. No one was worried about getting cut with the glass? The dogs didn't chew up a stick at the foot of the bed? And then when "one of the dogs" pooped on the bed, no one thought to clean it up? Nope. If it were me, no dogs would be allowed in that room until everything was cleaned up and the sheets were changed because I would worry about them getting hurt during the night.
Amber also testified that her & her friends had to clean the apartment up after the cops left on the night of the “phone incident” because there was glass on the floor & they worried about dogs getting cut
It's like 2 shooting stars hurling straight towards each other so attracted that they just explode into each other until they're nothing left.... amazing yet heart breaking
We've all heard the audio recordings. She wasn't scared. We've all seen the photos of her. There was no bruising. We've all seen what women look like after being beaten up. They don't look like Amber. 1:25:42 Honestly, she just looks tired and she's actually wearing no make up for once. This doesn't resemble a woman who has been viciously attacked to me.
In the UK, to give false evidence in court and under oath is, I believe, an offence called "perverting the course of justice" which carries a substantial prison term if found guilty--- Is it the same in the US? This friend of AH is clearly lying and will be seen as lying by the jury -- she has to think far too long before answering virtually every question she is asked. There were many situations that occurred where an immediate answer would be provided if the testimony to it were true. She has to think carefully before answering too many questions. Just listen to her "laceration on AH's forehead" testimony at around 30 mins onward as just one example.
@@poohbearm.503 I'm pretty sure that a judge would be able to establish if a witness had perjured themselves and if so, possibly it would be passed to prosecution lawyers to file charges --- i.e. Maybe Police do not have to be involved? Perjury can be proven by the lawyers who have been lied to during their cross-examination so long as it is irrefutable.
God I’m sorry for Johnny that he lost Mr. Judd. I would love for him to have been on the stand. There were very few places and times he wasn’t with Johnny. He was not only an employee but a friend. He was the only one who took Johnny’s secrets and life to the grave. The rest of these people were users.
Most of the “ issues” seem to be when Johnny tried to leave and be alone because he was upset and she would just follow him and make it worse if she knew how “violent” he was why go after him !!
From Johnny's expressions it looked like he still had hopes that Amber's sister would speak the truth, but when she started, I could see his disappointment face💔
I agree. It looks to me like those two don't have a great relationship. Her sister didn't seem to be particularly hostile towards Depp either or say anything bad..overall she seemed rather neutral. She probably thinks what most are concluding, that they were both pretty much as bad as either other and were in a very toxic relationship.
Its so obvious that AH friends and sister are lying through their teeth. JD's look of betrayal when he saw WH lying. I love how AH friends & sister are literally saying the same stuff almost as if they were fed the lines, word by word. Also, isn't it a bit convenient that AH contacted all those ppl a few months before they were deposition? Hmmm. I grew up in an abusive household, none of what they are saying add up, if anything it feels like AH was manipulating him. Not that JD is a saint but at least he admitted to it. #JusticeforJohnny #Amberheardisapsycho
The cops and the staff at the eastern Columbia building say no injurys. People actually believe the pictures of her supposed injuries are legitimate? Have any of yall ever been punched in the face or nose? I have darker complexion and I've had a black eye and broken nose with black eyes. Not just on one occasion. I'm sure many people have at some point in their lives had a black eye. It is way worse, they stand out like a sore thumb and last weeks, theres no question about it. Theres not enough makup in the world to cover it within the first 3-4 days. Amber has very light complexion, those are not real bruise.. what about the blood shot eyes? No blood shot eyes after a black eye?
All they can remember is that they can't remember and Johnny is a monster, that's all they can remember. She took all sorts of photos but she doesn't remember if she took the photos of after being "sexually assaulted"
Abusers like to isolate their victims... Amber Heard was surrounded by friends and family. Johnny even let her friends live with them for free. He gave them plenty of opportunities to witness his violence and call the police... where is that evidence? If I were witness to his violence and I was Amber's friend I would have called the police multiple times, why didn't they?
Can’t believe no one noticed the pocket knife except for depps lawyer she’s awesome.. seeing the pocket knife the bed does look like it was cut instead of broken .. Amber says Johnny wouldn’t remember things that happened I wouldn’t put it past her to “add” things and make things seem worse then they were..
Man if i was JD’s lawyer id ask the question to AH acting coach: “Is it true Amber cant bring out a tear, because she is cold hearted?” Dont think ill get a objection hearsay either 🧐
Why does her friend not shed a single tear when talking to jd's attorney but heards attorneys question her the next day on the deposition and all of a sudden she brings out the water works. It's just all so weird to me. I'm sorry something is off with all of it...
Probably because there is nothing to take pictures of? She was probably wearing make up covering the cuts and bruises at the time they were taking the pictures lol
To the person who asked what's wrong with rocky ... She's weighing everything carefully and lying for amber, not sure what the attorneys doing cross know or don't know, much like people are scared to speak with cops who might bluff or play games. She Ultimately doesn't want to get caught lying . Also, it's possible they never really grew apart, they just said that so that it would appear that rocky no longer had any reason to protect or not protect amber, no reason to not be neutral and honest. When in actuality, maybe they were friends and she had a big reason to lie on amber's behalf. Just a thought. The only problem, though, is that Rocky's got a bad poker face
In the UK, to give false evidence in court and under oath is, I believe, an offence called "perverting the course of justice" which carries a substantial prison term if found guilty--- Is it the same in the US? This friend of AH is clearly lying and will no doubt be seen to be lying by the jury -- she has to think far too long before answering virtually every question she is asked. There were many situations that occurred where an immediate answer would be provided if the testimony to it were true. She has to think very carefully before answering too many questions. Just listen to her "laceration on AH's forehead" testimony at around 30 mins onward as just one example.
Also notice Ambers witnesses all use the same language and words? Josh and Rocky regurgitate the “strewn about”. Whitney said Johnny was “magical” and “beautiful” like the turd did. The other girl that ran out of the room with the constant smile talked about how his behavior got “dark” (also drew said it) and the acting coach. Rehearsed af.
iO used the same "magical" word in his deposition yesterday, for me it was a red flag, when everyone uses the same exact words, which are not the usual way to describe somebody... sth is fishy
@@KoNekoInverse yes! There was other things IO used as well like “dark” that I can’t remember but it definitely stood out that when they agree on a point they agree to it all with the same language 🤔
but it's flipping EVERYWHERE... so unless they're sequestered (which they're not, at least to my knowledge) they're going to see/ hear about this trial from someone/something even without actively searching it out.... he'll I can't even scroll through my news feed on my phone for what's going on in society without this being one of the first things popping up... ie.. this showed up WAY before anything about the whole Roe V. Wade being over turned, I had to ACTIVELY search that out
So false how Amber and her lawyers are trying to seem all loved up with each other suddenly. Copying the real respect Johnny and his team have for each other
She is acting disrespectful- this is why witnesses should come to court and not Zoom. Plus I feel as though I hear her lawyers whispering answers to Rocky.
I think that's because of something he said. "You'd never see my eyes again" or something. There are clips of him avoiding eye contact when Amber looks at him directly from the stand.
He said he loved Whitney in a sisterly way in the beginning days of the trial. I think he's just dumbfounded but not surprised at this 'act' whitney is putting on.
Who cares if Johnny trashed his own penthouse? He let this girl stay there rent free and obviously provided everything for his guest. This is how they repay his kindness? He just knocked inanimate objects around... not people. #Dramatic #teamjohnny
Throwing inanimate objects around is a violent act. Doesnt matter if its against a particular person or just around the person. It's still an agressive, intimidating and violent thing to do. Everyone who has a small idea about DV know this.
First off, her friends. Being questioned by camille: monotone, bored, sighing Being questioned by rottenturd: crying, shaky breathing Amazing Amber's friends are also horrible actors/actresses Second off, the look of frustration and anger on Whitney's face when an objection is sustained let alone brought up. Anger issues apparently run in the family.
An acting coach that’s blurred professional lines and going to party with them and befriend her client to where they are comfortable drinking and doing drugs and shrooms around that person is a person that has befriended her client and would cover for her…. Clearly.
EXACTLY! she's definitely covering for her. Both of them are the only two that have the same story. Why haven't AH produced any other physical evidence until/except on this day? She said "Amber went to get ready for him to arrive"... get ready to trap in so they can can finally have photos. Whyyyyyyyy didn't she go to the hospital or police to file reports, get examinations, whyyyyyyy???? She's a liar, they're both liars! #justiceforjohnnydepp
The only reason (in my opinion) why JD could and would never ever have cut his own finger with the glass and is one I think only JD can argue as own testimony to the jury is the fact that he desperately needs his fingers to play the guitar making music.
Two things I have to say to that: 1. I think the case is being made (whether true or not) that he cut his finger by accident. 2. It's honestly REALLY weird that after getting his finger cut, he proceeded to write on the walls with it until the blood ran out, then dipped in paint and continued to write with it. It's definitely got me wondering
@@wildflower0901 I don't think Amber's council claimed he did it on purpose, only that he did it. I think the idea is that his finger was severed because he was in a drunken rage and was behaving recklessly
Did Amy here Amber's friend's boyfriend say that he took Johnny's phone from amber the night that the police came to the house? I wonder how long they had his phone and what they did with it?
I'm watching wh testify and dear god am I glad JD is rid of ah, her sister and their cronie friends. They just come across to me as uncouth, bratty, users and abusers.
None of these witnesses seem to be friends with her now, after their free ride of using JD is over. Imo, they are scared or sick of her, the lies, & BS. Also, think about this... look at all the recordings & 'compromising' photos AH took of JD. If she does that to "the love of her life" imagine what she has on these 'friends.' Are they covering for her to protect themselves from any incriminating or embarrassing videos, audios, or photos AH has of them? Also, notice how AH & her friends only get emotional when being questioned by her attorneys. The Rocky lady seems to have a completely different demeanor from day 1 to day 2 of her testimony. Didn't get emotional when looking at the photos when JD attorneys showed the photos. Yet got emotional after seeing them again the next day with AH attorneys. Seems a little suspicious imo.
🤦🏼♀️wow she sounds and acts just like Heard. Partners in Crime for sure. They planned this for a while. They can only recall or "remember" what they have planned but nothing else 🙄
Exactly, can remember where photos are taken…who was there…when they are taken…but a lot of the time not who took them 😂 even when it was just her and amber present…and it doesn’t look like amber had taken it she still didn’t say she did…because it wasn’t just them doing this…
What the FU€K !!! I’ve been watching “sky news” now for 18 days. And now all of a sudden every 10 minutes we have to suffer through the SHI+TY ads, what happened to this channel it was perfect??? Time to find the trial somewhere else…
@@bellehoward1434 There were several that also said he wasn't any different. If Amber really wanted to help him, she wouldn't have been doing drugs and drinking wine while doing so. Why would any victim follow their abuser who is trying to leave??
When her life coach says "i saw ... look like freshly healing THINGS" there was a male voice correcting her saying "skins" then she proceed to correct herself. That was sus. @ 7:54:12
@@Mel79205 i have to disagree - he isn’t, by any means, perfect but i do think he is kind. he’s proven several times throughout his life that he can be kind and generous & it’s hard to continue to meet the world with kindness when it only ever returns hardship so i do have to say that, even though he isn’t innocent in his role here, he does have a kind heart, and it’s apparent many times throughout this trial alone. just sad that they both were so bad and toxic for each other it gets lost in translation
So, basically what everyone is saying is she’s an angel, he beat her up, locked her up at home and then only let her leave when she had talk shows all whilst she sported a “broken” nose? Your truth is not truthing ma’am
Whitney's testimony about the events from the 30th birthday party don't match any other testimony. And all that matters to Amber is "Honesty, integrity..." ha ha ha we're supposed to be sympathetic that she lost her mother but she gave Johnny no support when he lost his mother and millions of dollars
she is manipulating these so called friends, some only know what she told them and set them up to see the stuff they seen cuz no one ever seen johnny do anything to ah until she was taunting him or pushing his buttons to make him react
OMG, 18 days into this trial and Ambers lawyer STILL needs to be reminded to turn on her mic????
To be fair, we’re 2 years into working from home some days and people still need reminding to come off mute 🙈
Amber's lawyers are pretty bad..Johnny's lawyers especially the young brunette one are running rings around them and outclassing them every step of the way. Objections on nearly every attempt to cross-examine witnesses, constant basic errors like questions lacking foundation, hearsay, witness leading.. terrible lawyers Amber has.
I don't think it started this way but, it's starting to feel like a strategy. When the defense gets objected to they become argumentative and have conversations that should normally be reserved for a private side bar. What the defense is often doing is essentially coaching the witness on how they need to answer the question.
@@justsomeguywhoownsacompute9732 I didn't even think about that! That's a really good point!
Yes hahaha, their witnesses all saying lies
So she tells all her friends about the assaults including the bottle but didn’t want to tell a doc cos she was embarrassed? 🙄
She didn't want Jonny arrested and in jail. Which is exactly why in many countries the police will act even if no charges are brought.
@@relocatetoItaly cause she's a liar.
@@relocatetoItaly but she will go and write an article about all of it anyways? Makes sense.. not
Amber heard is narcissistic and a habitual liar 🤥
@@relocatetoItaly but josh supposedly showed the cops all the broken glass and what not and they did nothing?
I can’t imagine financially supporting someone and all their friends for years. Providing housing, trips and lavish lifestyles for them to turn on me and say I did these awful things. Funny how, according to Amber, that everyone from doctors, assistants, multiple police officers and people who seen her daily, are all lying except her and her friends.
It's really sad...
This is exactly what is happening. I don't believe anything Amber or her best friend says. "Former" friend...yeah right. I believe they were in on this from the beginning and still are. I pray the jury sees through all these lies.
I don’t think her friends are lying. I think amber may have exaggerated some details but I do think it’s true that johnny hit her. I also think that she, esp at the latter end of the relationship, also hit him. This entire thing is just sad.
@@mins1668 yeah, I really don’t think Johnny is 100% innocent. I’m sure he’s pushed her or slapped her. I definitely don’t think he’s done as much as she’s claiming, though
BINGO
How convenient she reaches out to Josh to “make amends” right before he had to testify lmao
He didn’t remember what he cooked but then he did. Io said they fought right away; Josh said they were fine.
Rocky: "I can't tell what this picture is". Attorney; "Does it accurately describe the scene on December 15?" Rocky: "Yes"
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
@@randihenderson7750 I thought exactly the same, after being told what's the picture is about she says the picture describes accurately the scene, even when she didn't even know what the pic was about before... suspicious
Oh I jumped when her scary face came to the screen to see the knife on the bed of the pic she took
This whole thing is ridiculous. He’s carried amber and her friends financially, provided them ALL with everything they wanted and needed, houses them together… what abuser does this. All of them took advantage of Johnny
Exactly what he did is rare. But it just goes to show how generous and wonderful he is, and how insignificant the people he let into his life and homes were.
So if Johnny is beating Amber up behind closed doors why did he give her sister and her husband keys to every door?
Good point Morag!
Exactly! An abuser does everything in their power to alienate friends and family of the victim so why would he let all of them move in around them … and for FREE?
Why did nobody call the Police with all this alleged violence over YEARS? Because the gravy train would terminate.
@@felicityksw this 100% spot on
@@felicityksw That still could be a form of manipulation. People like nice things never mind free penthouse apartment access.
I'm not sure any of these people understand "swollen".
Rocky said she doesn’t remember her wearing makeup. Amber testified that Raquel had stopped her from putting on makeup that day. 🤔
Lmao
Amber also testified that she never went out without it due to her skin condition.
@@1corinthians-138 exactly what iv been saying
@@1corinthians-138 I believe she said sunscreen
Good spot!
Plus she said she would never go out in public without make if she had "bruises"
The thing that keeps bugging me is they keep showing pictures of "bruises" on the right side of Amber's face. Johnny is right handed. Her left side should have the "bruises "
Daamn I did not think about that... excelent observation Jolene.
I always hit people with my left hand to throw people off the scent though 🤷🏽♂️
Some could be selfies which would reverse the image. Not sure on others.
They don't look like they're from a punch at all. The one shot of the lip definitely looks like a cold sore, and if that bit of hair came from the top of Amber's head, the length is all wrong (if it was pulled out by the roots it would have been longer).
Depends on how she was turning her face. Or if he backhanded her.
So let me get this right. Johnny was paying for Amber, Her sister, her friend, and her friends boyfriend to live in penthouses in the Columbia building in LA.... Payed for their food, alcohol, and drugs. Now they are trying to ruin his life. Sounds about right.
Yes, including her 500 dollar a bottle wine.
Also a typical sociopath move to overly woo friends and family of the victim.
Karma is a coming
Reminds me of OJs situation. The grifting was strong. Poor JD had enough of the neverending stream of grifting leaches living off him & his money. And ms b*tch was nagging him crazy. These mfkrs got together & staged this.
@@1corinthians-1380ver 300 bottles swell,,
why do amber and all her friends only get “emotional” once her lawyers are asking the questions??
when johnny’s team is asking the questions they are stone cold, makes no sense
My thoughts exactly!
They are all fake.
Real friends would have reported every incident and got her out of there.
Buncha gold diggers - they just tried to milk JD for as long as they could and that obvs come to an end if AH left him.
All a facade.
Exactly!! IO was getting rude with Johnny’s lawyer towards the end.
That brunette girl was just smirking when talking about supposed terrifying moments if she was reminiscing on the good times
Because they're all just as AH, Fake and Liars.....
But it also seems that they're afraid of AH because AH knows stuff about them. They know now what AH is capable of and they don't want everyone to know there dirty secrets too.
When Pennington started to get emotional and cried she had the same Fake expressions on her face as AH during her fake crying parts
The ticks and leeches start dropping off their host once the blood supply has dried up...
Damn, that's a cold and twisted analogy. I like it
See now thats right on the ball!!!
Sounds like he got sick of all the free loaders
Soooo, Amber testifies that his finger was severed from smashing the phone to smithereens, but she tells her acting coach/friend that Johnny Cut it off while holding a broken bottle. So, which one is it Amber?
And I think she also claimed he used a knife.
And she saw it happen and she didn't.
this trial truly never ceases to amaze me. it’s clear both amber & johnny we’re terrible for each other and they each brought out the worst parts of themselves, but i think it’s clear that amber was a clear instigator here.
while no one will ever truly know who is telling the whole truth, amber and her witnesses seem to be very rehearsed and very in tune with each other whereas johnny’s witnesses all feel like they’re much more genuine & answering everything based on their truth and observations & that to me is very telling.
no one is right here, both johnny and amber both did their fair share of hurting the other, but something johnny has done that amber hasn’t, is admit it. it truly feels like she thinks she’s telling the truth when all the evidence provided, not only by johnny’s team but hers as well, has proved incorrect several times.
it’s interesting . . . if nothing else, it’s certainly interesting 🫣
What a bunch of odd people she is/was friends with!
In my opinion , during their marriage heard and her friends were in their late 20s , a lot younger than depp. I think they thought they could scam him out of money and use and abuse his kindness (hence they were all living In penthouses for free!!) and the whole domestic abuse thing she probably thought I’ll accuse him and he’ll pay me off, I don’t think she thought he’d take it this far. I’ve been around domestic abuse and people who drink a lot, she’s not scared of him one bit
Most heartbreaking thing here is Johnny’s look of betrayal when Whitney starts lying
That’s shame. That’s why he’s self soothing.
@@Glaiket
Really?
Please, do elaborate...
It’s like it’s all been orchestrated…
Whay a betrayal!
What a coincidence that Amber and IO got in touch with Josh a couple of months before his deposition. AND Amber got in touch with her acting coach just before the deposition aswell. Even though both hadn’t spoke to her in years.
Three of those witness depositions the were suddenly contacted from a month to three months before their deposition. The make up artist conveniently "stops" contact/being Amber's friend 1 month before hee deposition.
Yes she uses people just like she did Johnny Depp
What a coincidence Johnny pays all his witnesses
@@Glaiket Proof?
@@Glaiket amber turd party is in a different room. Bye
Makeup artist: It was years ago, I would never remember the shade!
Makeup artist: tells exactly what shade she used in the next question...
Rocky answers like she's being scolded by her mum and she's a stuck up teenager
Josh Drew has impressive diction!
If only all video depositions were this quick-fire and concise.
He seems to know many of the questions before they are asked! 😂
His and Rockys delivery style is the absolute antithesis of one another. So bizarre that they were together and imagining how they conversed! 🤪🤪
@@poohbearm.503 He lies very well
@@poohbearm.503 Tired of him saying, “speciosity.” 🤦♀️
If no one can see that this is a complete set up, then I don't know what world we live in ! That is an absolute bleeding cold sore and the rest is a bit of make up ! What an actress that friend
Exactly! She’s a way better actress than Amber!
Omg she is such a bad liar - it hurts…
Didn’t Rocky say she was alone w/Amber the day after when she had the bruises across her nose and Rocky took photos? Well, Josh was there….
On 21st May, Raquel went over to Amber in PH3 because Amber texted her and she went straight over and heard Amber & Johnny shouting. So... when did IO phone Raquel to go over there as he testified? And why didn’t Raquel mention being called by IO?
also amber said the pic with the thumb on her her was Johnny's right and it does look mainly and thick and badly matiance (compiaired to lady's nails)
but rocky said it was her finger in the photo and then the next photo was the pic of blonde hair on the floor with a finger (slim finger well matianced nail).
so she lied
it was about 1h 50m in and she had o yellow jacket, can anyone go back and double check.
why had no lawyer catches on about both accounts on these photos .
I was making me the same question
Wow, I didn't even catch this
How about that, she has a hard time crying when she’s acting. Let’s go take another look at that testimony…..😅
Acctually I think that was said as "proof" that Heard DIDN´T act in court...
@@lizs179 which is weird because she cried a lot but never shed a tear. She sniffed a lot but her nose always sounded dry.
It's funny how things work out the opposite of the way we intend sometimes
@@nataliejames1964 Exactly! And how fast she changes her face and posture! Sociopath.
It’s crazy how none of ambers witnesses remember anything but Johnny witnesses give complete stories with dates and times.
whoever keeps coughing in the courtroom needs to be kicked out. it’s obnoxious.
I heard it was a juror
I think that’s someone in the room with rocky
Same person has coughed through all the depositions as well! Must be a lawyer 🤣
I've watched all 3 broadcasted stations. This one is by far the better recording with clearest audio and video. Entertainment Tonight and Lan and Crime EDIT parts of the witness testimonies OUT! Also, we should not have to repeatedly turn down our volume for ADS and then keep turning it back up for the court case!
Acting coach just told on her...'she has a hard time crying when acting' = no tears on stand 🤔
How come they're not questioning the fact that ... in the first frontal picture her lips look fine ... then in the second side picture she has a big swollen bleeding lip ... there's no way that wouldn't show up on the frontal picture ... those photos were clearly doctored or faked after the fact.
I know I wondered that too! It is so obvious! Makes me crazy!
So Rocky says there was glass everywhere and they didn't touch anything on the bed, and that Amber and the dogs were asleep in the bed with the glass, pocket knife and splinter of wood. No one was worried about getting cut with the glass? The dogs didn't chew up a stick at the foot of the bed? And then when "one of the dogs" pooped on the bed, no one thought to clean it up? Nope. If it were me, no dogs would be allowed in that room until everything was cleaned up and the sheets were changed because I would worry about them getting hurt during the night.
To be fair, one of the defining characteristics of psychopathy is cruelty towards animals.
*Checkmate, Mr. Depp!*
Amber also testified that her & her friends had to clean the apartment up after the cops left on the night of the “phone incident” because there was glass on the floor & they worried about dogs getting cut
It's like 2 shooting stars hurling straight towards each other so attracted that they just explode into each other until they're nothing left.... amazing yet heart breaking
We did see that Amber has difficulty crying when she is "acting"
I caught that too lol
Pennington is about as believable as Pinnochio
We've all heard the audio recordings. She wasn't scared.
We've all seen the photos of her. There was no bruising.
We've all seen what women look like after being beaten up. They don't look like Amber.
1:25:42 Honestly, she just looks tired and she's actually wearing no make up for once. This doesn't resemble a woman who has been viciously attacked to me.
Throughout this TRIAL Amber's lawyer needs to learn how to formulate a question. Not referring to this video but overall.
What, if anything, should she ask? 😄
In the UK, to give false evidence in court and under oath is, I believe, an offence called "perverting the course of justice" which carries a substantial prison term if found guilty--- Is it the same in the US?
This friend of AH is clearly lying and will be seen as lying by the jury -- she has to think far too long before answering virtually every question she is asked. There were many situations that occurred where an immediate answer would be provided if the testimony to it were true. She has to think carefully before answering too many questions.
Just listen to her "laceration on AH's forehead" testimony at around 30 mins onward as just one example.
@@poohbearm.503 I'm pretty sure that a judge would be able to establish if a witness had perjured themselves and if so, possibly it would be passed to prosecution lawyers to file charges --- i.e. Maybe Police do not have to be involved?
Perjury can be proven by the lawyers who have been lied to during their cross-examination so long as it is irrefutable.
I agree
God I’m sorry for Johnny that he lost Mr. Judd. I would love for him to have been on the stand. There were very few places and times he wasn’t with Johnny. He was not only an employee but a friend. He was the only one who took Johnny’s secrets and life to the grave. The rest of these people were users.
Most of the “ issues” seem to be when Johnny tried to leave and be alone because he was upset and she would just follow him and make it worse if she knew how “violent” he was why go after him !!
From Johnny's expressions it looked like he still had hopes that Amber's sister would speak the truth, but when she started, I could see his disappointment face💔
When she started testifying he was looking at her....then when she started to spew the bullshit he looked down from then on out.
Love how she hugged her lawyer this am after the news yesterday about how they fought
And maybe cause of how much Johnny and Camille were hugging yesterday lol
The way Amber looks at her sister while she is testifying is terrible.
Almost as if she's daring her to go off script
I agree. It looks to me like those two don't have a great relationship. Her sister didn't seem to be particularly hostile towards Depp either or say anything bad..overall she seemed rather neutral. She probably thinks what most are concluding, that they were both pretty much as bad as either other and were in a very toxic relationship.
Rocky looking up at the ceiling for majority of the answers and blinking excessively…almost like she’s lying 🤥
Gotta try and remember how to keep the story straight. 😂
A bit strange... they do not remember many things, but what they are remember exactly in same words....
Its so obvious that AH friends and sister are lying through their teeth. JD's look of betrayal when he saw WH lying. I love how AH friends & sister are literally saying the same stuff almost as if they were fed the lines, word by word. Also, isn't it a bit convenient that AH contacted all those ppl a few months before they were deposition? Hmmm.
I grew up in an abusive household, none of what they are saying add up, if anything it feels like AH was manipulating him. Not that JD is a saint but at least he admitted to it. #JusticeforJohnny #Amberheardisapsycho
The cops and the staff at the eastern Columbia building say no injurys. People actually believe the pictures of her supposed injuries are legitimate? Have any of yall ever been punched in the face or nose? I have darker complexion and I've had a black eye and broken nose with black eyes. Not just on one occasion. I'm sure many people have at some point in their lives had a black eye. It is way worse, they stand out like a sore thumb and last weeks, theres no question about it. Theres not enough makup in the world to cover it within the first 3-4 days. Amber has very light complexion, those are not real bruise.. what about the blood shot eyes? No blood shot eyes after a black eye?
The stair story continues to change. It has a story of its own now.
All they can remember is that they can't remember and Johnny is a monster, that's all they can remember. She took all sorts of photos but she doesn't remember if she took the photos of after being "sexually assaulted"
Why do all her witnesses look down as if they are reading something. All Johnny's talk directly to the camera like recolection
We've got a bit more makeup today, huh?
Abusers like to isolate their victims... Amber Heard was surrounded by friends and family. Johnny even let her friends live with them for free. He gave them plenty of opportunities to witness his violence and call the police... where is that evidence? If I were witness to his violence and I was Amber's friend I would have called the police multiple times, why didn't they?
Cause they lived rent free. Seems more important ;-)
She had more of her friends around than JD did
@@4TIMESAYEAR Exactly, his lawyers need to highlight this fact. She was never isolated, she had ppl around her all the time.
@@mellue123 Well sure, but if they saw any physical abuse would they speak out? Real friends would. So where is the evidence? They're so full of it.
Its all what she told me
Ok, please list the gotcha moments of today here, along with times 🤣🤣
Omg I wish like hell her female lawyer would learn how to ask a freakn question!! Jesus what's wrong with her?! It's so hard to watch them sink her.
“What if any…” is forever burned into my brain
Just asked same question. This woman is entertaining not defending.
I love how Raquel calls it PH instead of penthouse like they don’t have the same number of syllables haha
good try, but they do have the same number of syllables
pee-aychhh
PENT-HOUSE
@@Media_Stereotypes thanks genius, that’s exactly what I said lol
I literally had to stop and think about this, 🤣 like it’s just as easy to say penthouse
@@hannahs6457 I misread it. I will go hang myself now.
First thought that popped into my mind when I heard it 😅
Can’t believe no one noticed the pocket knife except for depps lawyer she’s awesome.. seeing the pocket knife the bed does look like it was cut instead of broken .. Amber says Johnny wouldn’t remember things that happened I wouldn’t put it past her to “add” things and make things seem worse then they were..
if it was a true event then her deposition and her testimony would have the same answer!! Why does she need think about it?!
Man if i was JD’s lawyer id ask the question to AH acting coach:
“Is it true Amber cant bring out a tear, because she is cold hearted?”
Dont think ill get a objection hearsay either 🧐
It would have been great if they could somehow comment that Amber didn’t appear to actually shed tears
Why does her friend not shed a single tear when talking to jd's attorney but heards attorneys question her the next day on the deposition and all of a sudden she brings out the water works. It's just all so weird to me. I'm sorry something is off with all of it...
It’s very strange!
It’s because she had to recount the full story of each incident on the defense side. With Camille she was just answering questions about the pictures.
Her story about the sofa changed between the 2 attorneys changed as well
I think Amber called her and offered money for a better performance.
Why did Josh Drew say if they had tampered with the photographs, his testimony would be much different. Why not just the truth?? That really hit me.
He was saying that, if he was aware they scenes had been faked, he would be testifying to expose the women for setting Johnny Depp up.
I noticed this too!.
I noticed that
Why would they not take picture of Amber's face but took pictures of everything else
Or videos? 🤔
Because they are lying.
Amber prolly promised them some of the 100 million counter. Clearly, her sister needs it for her addiction that she is still battling.
Probably because there is nothing to take pictures of? She was probably wearing make up covering the cuts and bruises at the time they were taking the pictures lol
@@michellejansevanrensburg5525 but she’s got all these pictures of the damage in the houses, why not take photos of her face as well?
To the person who asked what's wrong with rocky ... She's weighing everything carefully and lying for amber, not sure what the attorneys doing cross know or don't know, much like people are scared to speak with cops who might bluff or play games. She Ultimately doesn't want to get caught lying . Also, it's possible they never really grew apart, they just said that so that it would appear that rocky no longer had any reason to protect or not protect amber, no reason to not be neutral and honest. When in actuality, maybe they were friends and she had a big reason to lie on amber's behalf. Just a thought. The only problem, though, is that Rocky's got a bad poker face
Yeah I don’t know who is worse at lying rocky or Amber but they both are easier to read tusk s kindergarten book
I thought that! Day 1 I’m thinking yes! She hates amber! Day 2 she’s crying. Totally planned
So if that's the case....then she's lying about her feelings for JD too, huh?
if those are black eyes, my anemia is someone punching me
In the UK, to give false evidence in court and under oath is, I believe, an offence called "perverting the course of justice" which carries a substantial prison term if found guilty--- Is it the same in the US?
This friend of AH is clearly lying and will no doubt be seen to be lying by the jury -- she has to think far too long before answering virtually every question she is asked. There were many situations that occurred where an immediate answer would be provided if the testimony to it were true. She has to think very carefully before answering too many questions.
Just listen to her "laceration on AH's forehead" testimony at around 30 mins onward as just one example.
Also notice Ambers witnesses all use the same language and words? Josh and Rocky regurgitate the “strewn about”. Whitney said Johnny was “magical” and “beautiful” like the turd did. The other girl that ran out of the room with the constant smile talked about how his behavior got “dark” (also drew said it) and the acting coach. Rehearsed af.
iO used the same "magical" word in his deposition yesterday, for me it was a red flag, when everyone uses the same exact words, which are not the usual way to describe somebody... sth is fishy
@@KoNekoInverse yes! There was other things IO used as well like “dark” that I can’t remember but it definitely stood out that when they agree on a point they agree to it all with the same language 🤔
And why do all ah witnesses say ‘wacking’ and not ‘beating’ or ‘punching’ or something someone would actually say about their friend being abused?
Looks like she's into self harm and uses it against JD.
Judge says do not discuss the case outside to anyone. Whole world is watching case live 😃
It’s more so the jury etc are not biased by information. Not so that the public doesn’t know.
but it's flipping EVERYWHERE... so unless they're sequestered (which they're not, at least to my knowledge) they're going to see/ hear about this trial from someone/something even without actively searching it out.... he'll I can't even scroll through my news feed on my phone for what's going on in society without this being one of the first things popping up...
ie.. this showed up WAY before anything about the whole Roe V. Wade being over turned, I had to ACTIVELY search that out
Doing her duty
@@felinemocha1995 Yep. Yet we know Amber has been watching coverage as she was wearing a 🐝 earring after the “stepped on a bee” memes went viral 😆
@@stevegray934 yess! She definitely is watching online stuff and she said clearly, 'go online and see who is being abused.' To Camille
So false how Amber and her lawyers are trying to seem all loved up with each other suddenly. Copying the real respect Johnny and his team have for each other
Rocky is a better actress than Amber.
She is acting disrespectful- this is why witnesses should come to court and not Zoom.
Plus I feel as though I hear her lawyers whispering answers to Rocky.
I love how he does look at Whitney, but not the sister 😂
I think that's because of something he said. "You'd never see my eyes again" or something. There are clips of him avoiding eye contact when Amber looks at him directly from the stand.
@@thewhisperchannel4684 i dont blame him. She gives full on crazy eyes
He said he loved Whitney in a sisterly way in the beginning days of the trial. I think he's just dumbfounded but not surprised at this 'act' whitney is putting on.
Who cares if Johnny trashed his own penthouse? He let this girl stay there rent free and obviously provided everything for his guest. This is how they repay his kindness? He just knocked inanimate objects around... not people.
#Dramatic #teamjohnny
Throwing inanimate objects around is a violent act. Doesnt matter if its against a particular person or just around the person. It's still an agressive, intimidating and violent thing to do. Everyone who has a small idea about DV know this.
First off, her friends. Being questioned by camille: monotone, bored, sighing
Being questioned by rottenturd: crying, shaky breathing
Amazing Amber's friends are also horrible actors/actresses
Second off, the look of frustration and anger on Whitney's face when an objection is sustained let alone brought up. Anger issues apparently run in the family.
This is getting as bad as the
OJ Simpson trial.
Cameras should not be allowed in the courtroom, it turns into a media circus.
That and the Casey Anthony trial I agree.
I have so much more respect for lawyers.
Those cuts on her arm are far too precise and in one area to be from glass
Out of all of AH witnesses, why is it that only her sister is there in person?
Because she’s fallen out with them all
Oh, Amber has a hard time crying while acting 🤔🤔🤔 - info straight from the acting coach
An acting coach that’s blurred professional lines and going to party with them and befriend her client to where they are comfortable drinking and doing drugs and shrooms around that person is a person that has befriended her client and would cover for her…. Clearly.
EXACTLY! she's definitely covering for her. Both of them are the only two that have the same story. Why haven't AH produced any other physical evidence until/except on this day? She said "Amber went to get ready for him to arrive"... get ready to trap in so they can can finally have photos. Whyyyyyyyy didn't she go to the hospital or police to file reports, get examinations, whyyyyyyy???? She's a liar, they're both liars! #justiceforjohnnydepp
The only reason (in my opinion) why JD could and would never ever have cut his own finger with the glass and is one I think only JD can argue as own testimony to the jury is the fact that he desperately needs his fingers to play the guitar making music.
😂
Two things I have to say to that:
1. I think the case is being made (whether true or not) that he cut his finger by accident.
2. It's honestly REALLY weird that after getting his finger cut, he proceeded to write on the walls with it until the blood ran out, then dipped in paint and continued to write with it. It's definitely got me wondering
@@nataliejames1964 there are a lot of things that make it hard to believe one or the other
@@wildflower0901 I don't think Amber's council claimed he did it on purpose, only that he did it. I think the idea is that his finger was severed because he was in a drunken rage and was behaving recklessly
Did Amy here Amber's friend's boyfriend say that he took Johnny's phone from amber the night that the police came to the house? I wonder how long they had his phone and what they did with it?
Bitter because the gravy train stopped
Amber is smiling like crazy now. She's like "THANK GOD THEY ARE LYING FOR ME!!"
I'm watching wh testify and dear god am I glad JD is rid of ah, her sister and their cronie friends. They just come across to me as uncouth, bratty, users and abusers.
None of these witnesses seem to be friends with her now, after their free ride of using JD is over. Imo, they are scared or sick of her, the lies, & BS.
Also, think about this... look at all the recordings & 'compromising' photos AH took of JD. If she does that to "the love of her life" imagine what she has on these 'friends.' Are they covering for her to protect themselves from any incriminating or embarrassing videos, audios, or photos AH has of them?
Also, notice how AH & her friends only get emotional when being questioned by her attorneys. The Rocky lady seems to have a completely different demeanor from day 1 to day 2 of her testimony. Didn't get emotional when looking at the photos when JD attorneys showed the photos. Yet got emotional after seeing them again the next day with AH attorneys. Seems a little suspicious imo.
The showed the same photos to Rocky 100 times!!!! I was falling asleep!!
how her demeaner changes from being questioned by Amber's team.... where are the tears at the thought of the trauma he friend endured now??
Why didn't Camille get to ask questions again to Rocky? That's how it was done with all of Johnny's video depositions.
yes can someone tell me that too...Camille would have eat her alive with her discrepancies
Rocky is giving me moody teenager vibes
I think I’d also be a bit tired of being involved in a case that’s been going on since 2016
@@bingowashisname2345 absolutely but she has quite a different demeanour when Heards team were asking questions in my opinion
🤦🏼♀️wow she sounds and acts just like Heard. Partners in Crime for sure. They planned this for a while. They can only recall or "remember" what they have planned but nothing else 🙄
Exactly, can remember where photos are taken…who was there…when they are taken…but a lot of the time not who took them 😂 even when it was just her and amber present…and it doesn’t look like amber had taken it she still didn’t say she did…because it wasn’t just them doing this…
What the FU€K !!! I’ve been watching “sky news” now for 18 days. And now all of a sudden every 10 minutes we have to suffer through the SHI+TY ads, what happened to this channel it was perfect??? Time to find the trial somewhere else…
Another day of what if anything.....
Several people saying Johnny was amazing and awesome when he was sober but a nightmare when he was using drugs or alcohol. That's the best I can gauge
@@bellehoward1434 There were several that also said he wasn't any different. If Amber really wanted to help him, she wouldn't have been doing drugs and drinking wine while doing so. Why would any victim follow their abuser who is trying to leave??
The PR team having Whitney and Amber to wear matching necklaces and so openly…hmmmm
When her life coach says "i saw ... look like freshly healing THINGS" there was a male voice correcting her saying "skins" then she proceed to correct herself. That was sus. @ 7:54:12
Timing?
@@SonicaTheMoon 7:54:12 listen carefully from this point
Eerie
I'm listening again, this lady creeps me out! All of her so called friends do actually!.
@@krisgomez4919 I didn'tike any of them. They'd ideally not come across as nice people... just like her
We're supposed to believe Josh Drew over four police officers? I don't think so!
she took his kindness for weakness and played on it to the max !!
He's not kind
And sadly she truly hurt him. He loved dearly someone who doesn’t exist. She betrayed him in the worst way a person can betray another person.
@@Mel79205 i have to disagree - he isn’t, by any means, perfect but i do think he is kind. he’s proven several times throughout his life that he can be kind and generous & it’s hard to continue to meet the world with kindness when it only ever returns hardship so i do have to say that, even though he isn’t innocent in his role here, he does have a kind heart, and it’s apparent many times throughout this trial alone. just sad that they both were so bad and toxic for each other it gets lost in translation
Is it me or does the sister looks like the dollar store of Amber Heard? 🤣😂
So, basically what everyone is saying is she’s an angel, he beat her up, locked her up at home and then only let her leave when she had talk shows all whilst she sported a “broken” nose?
Your truth is not truthing ma’am
Whitney's testimony about the events from the 30th birthday party don't match any other testimony. And all that matters to Amber is "Honesty, integrity..." ha ha ha we're supposed to be sympathetic that she lost her mother but she gave Johnny no support when he lost his mother and millions of dollars
she is manipulating these so called friends, some only know what she told them and set them up to see the stuff they seen cuz no one ever seen johnny do anything to ah until she was taunting him or pushing his buttons to make him react