@@Talita2004wdym what technique? he just stopped recording in regular mode and then started again after they switched positions. the beeping part is sped up in the mv video.
12:50 I wonder if there's a chance we will see this Giselle on a performance. We got bangs Karina today after all, she really looks nice here. Actually she and Winter rock this style so much.
13:58 - 14:04 this ningning scene didn't get justice as much as the other scene :(, she looks extra gorgeous here, plus i just loveeee the makeup, the hairdo, the lip piercing, everything, my best look for Ningning as far along with the white uniform.
I know there is a lot of people would disagree to me, but I don't care, AESPA's comeback never disappoint, their mv's always scream expensive and one of the strongest threat in 4th gen
Did you like the song in 1st listen? Or maybe after few replays? Is it stuck in your head now? Or were you disappointed? Either way, if you really are a fan of Aespa. Go and show your support. They worked hard for this comeback, that alone should be appreciated.
Looks like karina’s personality is even better than her face and her body. Whenever I watch her, she bows everyone, interacts with fans, hugs and gives energy to her members. She is really doing well and I hope she will continue like that. Her future is really bright with that amazing talent, visual and personality.
12:51 seriously we've been robbed with this look of giselle in the mv, it's a crime that we only get like one shot of this the mv, its literally one of her best looks 😭
KARINA UNDENIABLE FACT: There is no group that has main dancer who also happen to be a rapper,singer,center,leader and has gen defining iconic visual as Karina. She is insanly multitalented and it's crazy that she is only getting better. A true ace of the aces,a true queen. She is my bias and she deserves it. 😻 Stan Aespa! Stan Karina!
Yeah but youre missing one important FACT: she has VOCAL POWER. An unique voice too. As all famous singers and idols should have but ofcourse thats not the industry focus.
Giselle kamu sudah berusaha, kamu sudah memberikan yg terbaik. kamu juga manusia tapi di luar sana hanya melihat kesalahanmu dan menutup mata atas usahamu , aespa selamanya 4 , love you aespa OT4 forever .❤️🌙⭐🦋
I'm new to the fandom and I'm so amazed to see how talented you are, the effort you've put in is paying off and you've accomplished so much in such a short amount of time. Please stream, our girls have worked hard!!
@@rosee_bae yep in August, they already have reality show called Sosi Tamtam, they released it before their comeback. it is already in ep 2. it airs every thursday on JTBC youtube channel 9pm kst. just convert it to your country's timezone. SNSD comeback will save Kpop. not even aespa can match them. altough I love them both❤️SM fam
I really love their outfit for this MV, especially the last one. It suits well with each member according to the outfit designed. Their stylist and makeup team really did a great job for each comeback.
I love all of aespa but I really have to say that Karina and Ningning won my heart since pre-/debut. Karina is the most talented girl group members I've ever seen, and I've been listening to kpop ever since 2nd gen
The more I get into aespa the more I realize how humble and relatable karina is...I am surprised to see how kind and friendly she is and above all of this she is obviously the most talented all rounder member too 💗 This girl deserves more love tbh
Damnnnnn, the visuals and outfits in this comeback are insane!!! They will be so hard to beat, but i said the same with Savage era so let's see. STAN aespa!!
I am soo angry we got robbed with that style of giselle. she loook so stunning yet we only get seconds in that hairstyle. hiw I wish we can get that again but I am afraid not.
As usual there’s less Winter than anyone else. Girl really doesn’t want to be in front of the camera when she doesn’t have to. Which is perfectly understandable, but I also wish we got to see more of her.
Gotta be honest, at 1st listen i was confused af but the more i listened to the song the more i got addicted to it Congratulations Aespa for this MASTERPIECE and for all your hard work. Now let's give them some wins My's.🥰
This is what I call a true My! You don't have to like the song at first listen or at all, but you can acknowledge that they worked hard and show support.
One day, aespa will become one of the legendary groups their juniors are looking up to in the future. I am going to check this comment every year. Sunday, July 17, 2022, 12:00 am
4:49 Honestly i more like Giselle without bangs because her aura shine more and it fits better to concept. Because Giselle with bangs is cute, and without bangs, she is badass and more beautiful. And i also more like Winter with long hair than short hair, because she's more beautiful and show that she's the real visual along with Karina. 7:26 I love their hairstyle! Winter with two braids hair, Ningning with this hairstyle, Karina with bangs, and Giselle with hairpin. 15:22 And My favorite looks of them! I really love their hairstyle and their makeup! It's looks expensive, ikonic, badass, and they look like noble. I hope they can wear 2 looks on the MV again at music show or special performance video! Because it's so gorgeous and ikonic!
0:37 Reminds me of that one lisa and rose meme LMAO. Where lisa and rose are acting all sweet while jennie and jisoo aren’t talking 😂. No but seriously KARINA and NINGNING’s friendship is so precious 🥺❤️
10:12 Omg the way they filmed that was so amazing. So that's how 'Hold up' was filmed.
Seriously the whole MV was an art
They should’ve kept it like that tbh
What technique was that?
@@Talita2004wdym what technique? he just stopped recording in regular mode and then started again after they switched positions. the beeping part is sped up in the mv video.
12:50 I wonder if there's a chance we will see this Giselle on a performance. We got bangs Karina today after all, she really looks nice here. Actually she and Winter rock this style so much.
WOW ; You haven't See My SUPER JUNIOR Reaction Mashup video , No ? 😶💔
I hope we will because I really liked how her hair looked
Giselle skrrt skrt on what?
@@lrueuu3 you're spending too much time on every aespa's video for hate, poor u.
@@lrueuu3 ask heesung that question 💀
13:58 - 14:04 this ningning scene didn't get justice as much as the other scene :(, she looks extra gorgeous here, plus i just loveeee the makeup, the hairdo, the lip piercing, everything, my best look for Ningning as far along with the white uniform.
Yass i feel you😭😭 this scene too short for ningning 😭😭💔
hope we can see this fit again during their promo!
Yes I agree with you. On this part of the mv, she is either in the shadow or the shot is too far. They have these shots why they didn't use it 😭
True
I don’t understand why they didn’t include it more when she looks so gorgeous here
Oh, the more I look at it, the more I see how wonderful Giselle's visuals are this time around.
I know there is a lot of people would disagree to me, but I don't care, AESPA's comeback never disappoint, their mv's always scream expensive and one of the strongest threat in 4th gen
Istg y'all will eat anything even if they release mid song 😭
@@lrueuu3 you’ve been commenting a lot of hate, thanks for the views tho girly stay pressed and jealous 😘
Bruh they're the only group to sold 1M copies in their first week, they already have the title next generation leaders
@@lrueuu3 but the problem is their songs are never mid 🤷♀️
Agree
I really like their chemistry... You can see that they are enjoying and their childishness are apparent when they are not filming their scenes...
Did you like the song in 1st listen? Or maybe after few replays? Is it stuck in your head now? Or were you disappointed? Either way, if you really are a fan of Aespa. Go and show your support. They worked hard for this comeback, that alone should be appreciated.
For me, it's 2nd listen. Since 1st listen I got distracted by the whole MV
At first I was disappointed but I realized I was singing to their song now it stuck on my head 😂 I like the song now
The dance is not powerful like the song sorry👀✌🏻
First listen already like it, really catchy
1st 😆
5:55 Karina is so freaking beautiful! She's really a goddess!
Looks like karina’s personality is even better than her face and her body. Whenever I watch her, she bows everyone, interacts with fans, hugs and gives energy to her members. She is really doing well and I hope she will continue like that. Her future is really bright with that amazing talent, visual and personality.
Plastic surgery effect 😭
@@lrueuu3 plastic surgery is nothing new in kpop, get a life and stop hating
@@lrueuu3 а вы и правда хейтер.Надеюсь ни один из ваших жалких комментариев никого не заденет
@@lrueuu3 u need to get a life, i shall recommend you a song - "Life's too short" by aespa
@@lrueuu3 no amount of plastic surgery will change the true values of a person.
13:24 this winter look is superior
8:18 the eldest leader and youngest maknae 🥺💗
12:51 seriously we've been robbed with this look of giselle in the mv, it's a crime that we only get like one shot of this the mv, its literally one of her best looks 😭
so true.
She is pretty n Talented
Yes, i'm dissapointed because of that.
I absolutely agree
Skrrt skrrt girl deserves to get least screen and line
KARINA UNDENIABLE FACT: There is no group that has main dancer who also happen to be a rapper,singer,center,leader and has gen defining iconic visual as Karina.
She is insanly multitalented and it's crazy that she is only getting better. A true ace of the aces,a true queen.
She is my bias and she deserves it. 😻
Stan Aespa! Stan Karina!
Y’all love copying and pasting comments huh
Yeah but youre missing one important FACT: she has VOCAL POWER. An unique voice too. As all famous singers and idols should have but ofcourse thats not the industry focus.
@@ilubyou13 it's my post. I agree I commented this in another video but that's it. Why can't I make same comment twice? 🤔
There's alot of group had this y'all need to stop lying
@@lrueuu3 Irene,Taeyeon? SM dude,lol!
Giselle kamu sudah berusaha, kamu sudah memberikan yg terbaik. kamu juga manusia tapi di luar sana hanya melihat kesalahanmu dan menutup mata atas usahamu , aespa selamanya 4 , love you aespa OT4 forever .❤️🌙⭐🦋
*NINGNING IS SO PRETTY*
i've always liked karina's personality. she acts as is. she looks shy but sometimes acts random which always makes me laugh
She's unreal also i was offended because her bangs weren't real
@@lly.l0d555 😭😭
True
Giselle in that black outfit with two colored hair rocks!
Ikr she looks so freaking beautiful
RIGHTTR IT DESERVED MORE SCREEN TIME
YASSSS!!!
Yes but sm give her screentime at mv less 1 second 😭
the fact that karina likes her outfit which is all white, i also like that outfit too. karina in white is like a goddess
Aespa is the Best gg in 4th gen I think their themes, songs, outfits, voices,are the best in 4th gen gg's
Their
Yes true💙
Itzy #1
ningning so gorgeous, i think "girls" is her era
12:51, this giselle, deserve a lot of screen time
if only SM would let her
@@Mr_Jingles111 The same thing I was praying for
지젤, 너무 귀엽지만… MV 부분이 매우 적은 것이 팬으로서 충격입니다.
Omg 😭 yes aggree so small her screentime
13:00 이 스타일 지젤에게 아주 잘 어울렸고 지젤도 마음에 들었던거 같은데,
뮤비보면 잠깐만 클로즈업 되어서 좀 아쉬움
Why winter pouting like that!?Soo Cuteeee. Winter my heart is beating so fast. Really Cute
True😭😭same feeling as you
If she pouted at me like that😭gosh, she gonna have whatever she want this little baby🐶😂🥹
8:26
So much Ningrina moments happened this era, loving it🫶🏻
04:49 We love you not only with bangs, but in every way, Giselle. This hair suits you very well.
❤️
I like giselle with bangs and this hairstyle! I cant decide which I like more.
Skrrt skrrt girl
@@lrueuu3 enehyflops
1:02 and 8:18 aw i love these ningrina moments.
my bias (karina) and bias wrecker (ningning) atm
I'm new to the fandom and I'm so amazed to see how talented you are, the effort you've put in is paying off and you've accomplished so much in such a short amount of time. Please stream, our girls have worked hard!!
welcome baby MYs!!
Welcome to the fandom😊 And yes our æspa is awesome and hard working!!
Welcome 🙏
Talented where? 😭 They can't even sing live
@@lrueuu3 you're taking your time to reply to a lot of people negatively, it's kinda weird :/
13:58 this look of ningning deserve more screentime
Ningning so cute and talented 🌺
Ningning and Karina are so cute, Karina's face made me forget how to breathe wow
Me too😂💙💙
10:35 The set is so incredible, I can't wait for Girl's Generation comeback !!
Wait, girls Generation is going to make a comeback? When 😮
@@rosee_bae August
@@rosee_bae august, as 8 btw ✌️
@@rosee_bae yep in August, they already have reality show called Sosi Tamtam, they released it before their comeback. it is already in ep 2. it airs every thursday on JTBC youtube channel 9pm kst. just convert it to your country's timezone.
SNSD comeback will save Kpop. not even aespa can match them. altough I love them both❤️SM fam
I bet Karina, a hardcore SONE the reason why she wants to be an idol bet she will be soooo excited for Soshi comeback
Obsessed with Giselle half blonde hair 😭❤️ She looks amazing in the 3rd costume and look
8:15 I miss this Ningrina habit. Karina always let NN sit on her, and NN sits on Karina too. 😭❤️
why is winter so beautiful. Im here for her
omg ang ganda talaga nila i love you karina winter giselle and ningning
Karina is ACE and best leader. Her personality is very commendable.
aespa見てると本当元気出る..!可愛い🥲🤍
I really love their outfit for this MV, especially the last one. It suits well with each member according to the outfit designed. Their stylist and makeup team really did a great job for each comeback.
Karina is looking like a doll 😍
Ikr💛
12:51 Giselle should have kept this hairstyle 🥺and I love the makeup
Ningnings aura js makes me smile omg 🙁🦋
Jatuh cinta sama dandanan Giselle disini 12:50, sayangnya di MV ngga banyak masukkin pas Giselle tampilannya gitu☹️ 14:44
Aespa and the staffs behind this song is working so hard. Kudos!
Honestly, this is the best 4th gen comeback this year.
I love all of aespa but I really have to say that Karina and Ningning won my heart since pre-/debut. Karina is the most talented girl group members I've ever seen, and I've been listening to kpop ever since 2nd gen
The more I get into aespa the more I realize how humble and relatable karina is...I am surprised to see how kind and friendly she is and above all of this she is obviously the most talented all rounder member too 💗
This girl deserves more love tbh
So true i agree💙💙
Finally more screen time for Giselle iconic look that got less than a second in the MV. Hope to see more
YOOOOO I LOVED AT 10:19. That small pause after hold up, makes it sooo sastifying mmmmmmmh
12:51 このめちゃくちゃ可愛いジゼルちゃんMVだと全然無かったからここで見れて嬉しい
Karina and ningning í so pretty, i like them❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
진짜 에스파 비주얼 미쳤다 다들 너무 이뻐 ㅠㅠ 사랑해💗💗
最後のカット終わったあとの「やったー!帰れる!」みたいなテンション上がってるのめちゃかわいい
6:54 Karina is soooo cute!!
They should’ve showed ning ning snd Giselle in their last outfits moreee omg
seeing ningning sitting on karina's lap
but do you see the couple behind them doing the same!!😭😍8:42
Thats cute💜
Karina really ate this era up. No wonder why she's called the ace and all rounder. ❤️😭
8:32 MY *KARINING* IS SO CUTE
9:58 WINTER’S POPPING MOVES ARE ALWAYS SO ADDICTING
My girls 카리나 윈터 지젤 닝닝이 뮤비 찍느라 너무 고생했어😉❤️❤️
와 ; 내 NiziU 매시업 비디오를 시청했습니까? 아니요? 💟
I really like watching these behind the scene videos, it makes me feel connected to them even more...
Aespa is so incredible
Gisslle .... my fav .. omg she looks AWESOME 👌.
winter changing her expression from 3:24 to 3:26 is insane. from baby to a complete tease!
Damnnnnn, the visuals and outfits in this comeback are insane!!! They will be so hard to beat, but i said the same with Savage era so let's see. STAN aespa!!
8:15 ningning so cute
Omg karina’s visual is unreal 0_0
Karinas visual is out of this world
done and dusted
@@sleepyjoe4529 haters gonna hate eww 🙄🙄🙄
@@sleepyjoe4529 get lostttt dear😉
Plastic surgery really change her
I am soo angry we got robbed with that style of giselle. she loook so stunning yet we only get seconds in that hairstyle. hiw I wish we can get that again but I am afraid not.
12:42 WANTED MORE NINGNING SCREEN TIME WITH THIS LOOK!!
Ningning on Karina's lap is my favorite thing.
Aespa are the queens of K-Pop and no one can stop them
I agree. The group of aespa is best in K-Pop and no one can stop them. As you said they are queens.
Yes they r so talented💛
I love Karina's personality 🥺
And she's so talented an all rounder for sure
Our main dancer, rapper, vocalist, center, fotg OUR ACE KARINA
As usual there’s less Winter than anyone else. Girl really doesn’t want to be in front of the camera when she doesn’t have to. Which is perfectly understandable, but I also wish we got to see more of her.
Our introvert
she's an introvert so I think that's why, but the members also said that she's really energetic.
14:42 かっこよすぎるよ〜😭🫶🏻💓
12:28 ここからの皆のスタイリング、めちゃくちゃ可愛いのにMVではあんまり出てなくて悲しい😭
aespa never disappoint. their music is so diverse and amazing. i hope their music reaches bigger audiences in the future
Karina you are stunning with an amazing personality to match❤️🔥
aespa is one of the best girl groups out there. Period.
IKR
윈터 너무 귀엽다 사랑해요♥️
12:52 THIS ICONIC LOOK
Omggggg ningning ニンニンあなたはとても美しいです🤩🥳🎉🥰
Karina is the prettiest idol i’ve ever seen
Gotta be honest, at 1st listen i was confused af but the more i listened to the song the more i got addicted to it
Congratulations Aespa for this MASTERPIECE and for all your hard work. Now let's give them some wins My's.🥰
This is what I call a true My! You don't have to like the song at first listen or at all, but you can acknowledge that they worked hard and show support.
WOW ; You haven't See My SUPER JUNIOR Reaction Mashup video , No ? 😶💔
its supposed to be like that!
10:12 i love how it came out in the mv
KARINA SO TALENTED AND FUNNY
i know karina's visuals are unreal. but karina with bangs really looks like a manhwa character. she looks like she came out of a webtoon
One day, aespa will become one of the legendary groups their juniors are looking up to in the future.
I am going to check this comment every year.
Sunday, July 17, 2022, 12:00 am
Winter’s beauty is something else ❤️
7:44 that aeoww so cute
Omg ningning , she is so adorable ❤️
유지민 진짜 천상 아이돌이다... 난 니가 구석기 시대에 태어났어도 곁에서 뗀석기 들고 응원 했을거임
Karina with full Bangs = Definition of BOP! 🤩✌️
지젤아 앞머리 안냈다고 미안해 하지마. 넌 그 자체로 예쁘고 쏘핫걸이야. 팬들은 지젤이 얼마나 따뜻한 사람인지 알아. 심지어 대머리가 되어도 사랑받을 사람이라고.. 지젤 사랑해 우리 애기 절대 기죽지마. 네가 최고야!!!!!
Awww💕
4:49 Honestly i more like Giselle without bangs because her aura shine more and it fits better to concept. Because Giselle with bangs is cute, and without bangs, she is badass and more beautiful.
And i also more like Winter with long hair than short hair, because she's more beautiful and show that she's the real visual along with Karina.
7:26 I love their hairstyle! Winter with two braids hair, Ningning with this hairstyle, Karina with bangs, and Giselle with hairpin.
15:22 And My favorite looks of them! I really love their hairstyle and their makeup! It's looks expensive, ikonic, badass, and they look like noble.
I hope they can wear 2 looks on the MV again at music show or special performance video! Because it's so gorgeous and ikonic!
waiting for jacket behind the scene, recording behind the scene, dance practice, dance practice behind and many more~
Jacket behind the scene is already uploaded :)
ahh.. sorry, I forgot :'
i really want recording behind the scene. it will be amazing
3:21 Cuteness overload. Ahhh i can't stand. It's shaking my heart
0:37 Reminds me of that one lisa and rose meme LMAO. Where lisa and rose are acting all sweet while jennie and jisoo aren’t talking 😂. No but seriously KARINA and NINGNING’s friendship is so precious 🥺❤️
Oh wow, I just realised Karina had two tone eye lens 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Her beauty overcoming her lens 🤷🏻♂️
11:24 laughing so hard with winter’s reaction when karina and giselle making heart sign 🤣🤣🤣
Lmfao it's cute and funny at the same time
4:34 woah aeri is soooo pretty