Manna Ji is an absolute legend, and one of the best singers ever. His body of work is simply awesome. Along with Rafi Saab, Kishore Ji, Mukesh Ji, he forms the top 4 quartet which dominated Hindi movie music in that era. And yes, he was the most classically gifted singer of that time, who had an exceptionally amazing range👏👏👏
Manna Da was complete singer, he had classical training from his uncle K. C. Dey and four ustaads 1. Ustaad Dabir Khan 2. Ustaad Aman Ali Khan 3. Ustad Abdul Rahman Khan and 4. Ustad Ghulam Mustafa Khan. Ustad Bade Ghulam Ali Khan had after listening to Manna Da in a program in Jaipur in 1959 had written to him asking him to sing pure classical, Manna Da almost made up his mind to quit singing filmi songs, but Rafi Sahab his close friend who translated the letter dissuaded him to do so. Manna Da sang songs which no other singer could render. Mahender Kapoor and Asha Bhonsle have confessed that they were afraid to sing with him because of his classical training and mastery. Shankar Jaikishan regretted that they did not use Manna Da fully. Manna Da didn’t get his due, he deserved much more, more songs and recognition. Only connoisseurs can appreciate his range and mastery.
Manna Dey was legend singer. He sung for almost all superstar actors of 50s, 60s and 70. Unfortunately he could not encashed his popularity like other singers of his time due to his simplicity and honesty. Salute to Manna Dey for his contribution to Indian cinema.
মান্না দে হওয়া সহজ নয় এটা অনেকেই বুঝতো বলেই তাঁকে ছোট করে দেখানোর চেষ্টা চলতো ۔۔কিন্তু ভারতীয় সংগীতে তাঁর স্থান যে কোন উচ্চতায় অধিষ্ঠিত ۔۔তা বলার প্রয়োজন পড়ে না ۔۔সংগীতের মহাগুরু মান্না দে ۔۔তাঁর বিকল্প সেকালেও কেউ ছিল না ۔۔একালেও নেই ۔۔আগামীদিনেও কোনোদিন হবে না ۔۔۔
Shweta Ji, From Holland. Manna Dey Sahab was and is my Hero. A magnificient singer and a Great human beiing. I have a collection of all his songs. Thank you M'Dey Sahab.
Manna Dey was a legendary singer's of 50's, 60's and 70's era. He made his names in music industry, but unfortunately he didn't get the recognition for his music. In the time Manna Dey was singing there were three super singer's such as Mohd Rafi, Mekash and Kishore Kumer. He could not get the fame he wad entitle for. Its sad 😥 he was a great singer's. His way of singing was unique. 🤗🤗🙏🙏🤗
Manna Dey is such a wonderful artist that Mukesh Kishore Kumar Mohammad Rafi cannot be compared to.Manna-day itself is a different kind of institution. Thanks for an informative presentation.
When you say a different kind of institution you mean classical gener and you are right but you can't take away those naughty peppy pop songs of kishore and the most versatile of them all M.Rafi....No comparison dude..
बिल्कुल सही है, मन्नाडेजी सच्चाई है कि मैं ऊनकी हर फिल्म के गाऐ हुए सभी गीत मेरे दिल के करीबी रहे हैं कयुँ की वो मेरी पसंदीदा हीरो राजकपूरजी की परफेक्ट आवाज रहे हैं/थे , फिर कभी ईस बात पर लिखेंगे, अब शुभम् मंगलमयी रात्रि😎😎😎😎😎😎 शयन रात्रि र
Ma Saraswati's blessings remained with him. Even after the immense negativity around him, the best was bestowed on him. He received the Dada Saheb Phalke award. Quality over quantity is always Ma Saraswati's preference. 🙏🙏🙏🙏. He is the best - transcendental voice. Sound arranged in perfect geometric pattern is music to transcendence 😍
Manna Dey sahab quality is unique because of this Rafi sahab, Kishore da, and Mukesh sahab has clone or other singers copy them but no one can copy manna Dey sahab even today no one dare to copy,
No doubt Mohammed Rafi himself was a great person by both professionally a legend, and a gentleman person. You rarely find a person in any profession who has such a good relationship with his all of his contemporary. He has never made any negative comment about any one. In fact he had very positive relationships with all including great singers like Manna Dey, Kishore, Mukesh, Mahender Kapoor. He is an inspiration for today's industry.
Thank you for the balanced & objective content of the video. Manna Dey's under-appreciation in our subcontinent is proof that most of us enjoy a male singer's tonal quality more than his singing prowess. This does not mean that the other greats (Mohd. Rafi, Kishore Kumar etc) were not fine singers, but Manna Dey was in a different league. To typecast him as a 'classical singer' is like feeling only the tail of an elephant and inferring that the animal is just another type of snake. He is the most genre-versatile male singer of our subcontinent. No genre of music was beyond his capability.
Manna Da has always been one of my most favorite singers. He made his own place among the famous established male singers of his times and was always very well received and accepted by the public. It was the inhibition and false notion of some producers and composers which did not give him due recognition.
Manna Dey sahab is the real Tansen of Film Music..Why only Films, let's say music The Voice, the "Lagan" and "Mehnat" with which he cultivated himself through his voice culture by intense practice, dedication and sacrifice is unmatched in the film industry He was a man for all seasons...Nobody can match him. He used to set bench marks that it was almost impossible to reach there. No wonder the singers of today who try to imitate only Rafi sahab, Kishore sahab and Mukesh sahab don't even dare to try to imitate Manna sahab or try his difficult classical based songs which were termed light classical in those days because they lack the guts, the "mehnat", the riyaaz and range. All try to shine at once which unfortunately ends up in a flash in the pan. Jaya ji has done a wonderful job in portraying the genius and calibre of a true singer Manna Dey sahab who sits on the top as the saying goes - "There is always room at the Top" R. I. P Manna Dey sahab.
He was never underrated. I have learnt classical music and he is our source of inspiration. Pl. dont hurt somebody's feelings with your incisive comments. If you dont understand real music, it is your problem.
Since my childhood I was deeply attracted to his voice basically for the emotions he carried in the lyrics. While in comedy songs the rhythm played with tabla & dholak blended the song so fantastically that one when listens made blissful in heart. It is due to him that people were attracted to film classical songs so that the classical songs are not scary but worth listening. I owe much to him for giving me ever cheerful mind when remembering him in music.
Manna Dey was Versatile legendary Singer Who Sang immortal Melodious Songs Whoever forget his evergreen Melodious songs for Super hit movies Chori Chori,Shri 420, Ujala, Seema,Anand,Upkar,Basant Bahar, Waqt etc. Hatts of great Singer Manna Dey !!!
Great singer , my favourite velvet voice , versatile ,even lata mangeshkar use to get intimated by him . Got typecast as classical singer very famous legend in kolkata cinema . Singer Kavita Krishnamurthy use to singh under him in stage shows. All songs sung bh him r hits.
We should respect every person and every singer or actor. I'm 26 and love his voice. He had a great voice and i don't think people who disrespected him can sing a single note like him.
Manna Dey the pride of Hindustan was at his sublime best in rendering Bengali numbers. He is deeply respected in Bombay but in Calcutta he along with Hemant Kumar( Hemant Mukhopadhyay) is considered nothing less than Almighty in incarnation. My personal favorite is another great and that is Md Rafi. But I am ready to die at any time for great great Manna Dey. I am seriously against any foolish comparison between Md Rafi, Mukesh, Manna Dey, Kishore or Hemant ..as they are all blessed by none other than the Almighty. Just enjoy the musical world enriched by all these legands and the pride of our Hindustan.
@@PushpaDevi-nl8fv Kishore himself said in video interview that Music directors used to make tunes lighter so that he could sing them. So , we should believe Kishore himself , or a fan like you? We can see shor kumar was limited.
Great Manna Dey, shall remain immortal by his excellency in field of music. The only one of his kind, unmatched, unparalleled , unprecedented magic of nature.It does not matter by a group of MDs or Directors He was ignored. But in the Hearts of people he shall always be received heart to heart. His taintless, clear classical based voice was overwhelming and intoxicating shall rein over hearts of millions for the ages to come.
Never knew this much about Dada g. No doubt a great & The best versatile singer ever heard in my life. RIP sir but your songs will always live .....🧐🌠🌹🌠
Yes ......Anybody who learns Ragas needs to know about Manna Dey. When I studied music, I learnt to play the song "Tu pyaar ka saagar haii" on my harmonium.
ॐ बेजोड़ सदाबहार गायक। भारतीय सिनेमा में बहुत गायक हुवे मगर दो गायक श्री मन्ना डे साहब और किशोर कुमार साहब इन दोनो की बात ही अलग अलग थी जिसका कोई मुकाबला नही है।हार्दिक श्रधांजलि नमन।🙏🙏❤️😊
@@zunairashraf9024 ye apka ka sirf ek majhabe angle hai isse door raho. Ye insaan ko pollute kar deta. Mai Rafi saheb ko bhi manta hoon magar jo janam se hi mahan ho usko koi chu nehi sakta. Javed Akhtar ka analysis suniye detail me kaha hai. Jis gane ko Kishore da aur dusre singer ne gaya usme hamesha Kishore da hi ekkis rahe, koi bhi example dekh lo. Sara concept saaf ho jayega
Many thanks for giving such unheard exposure. He became far away from kolkata physicaly and we felt the misery in him. Today I felt the reason but it made his creation imortal.
आपने मन्ना डे साहब का बेहतरीन सत्य विश्लेषण किया है और अद्भुत जानकारी दी मैं मन्ना डे साहब को प्रथम श्रेणी का हुनर दार गायक मानता हूं बहुत पहले से और रफी साहब और मुकेश जी की बराबरी का परन्तु किशोर तो मन्ना डे साहब के सामने बिल्कुल नहीं ठहरता हेमंत कुमार और तलत महमूद की आवाज़ ज़्यादा अच्छी है सबसे फिसड्डी गायक है किशोर कुमार
@@ShwetaJayaFilmyBaatein मैडम जी ये कुंवर पाल सिंह हमारे किशोर दा का अपमान कर रहा है और आप इसके कमेंट को लाइक भी कर रही हो आपको शर्म नहीं आती ये चैनल इसीलिये बनाया है क्या ??
मन्ना डे साहब सुरीली आवाज के साथ-साथ शास्त्रीय संगीत के सरताज रहें है । गायको में प्रतिस्पर्धा की बातें बेमानी है, सबकी अपनी पहचान और कला होती है । व्यवसायिक सफलता-असफलता का महत्व नहीं होता । आपके विषय और उसके शानदार विश्लेषण के लिए बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद और हार्दिक शुभकामनाएं।
आपने Video बहोत अच्छा बनाया है Madam . मै खुद एक छोटासा Local Singer हूं . मन्नाडे साहाब महानतम Singer थे , और Classical Singing में Master और नं 1 थे इसमे कोईभी दोराह नहीं है . मगर specially रफीसाहाब और किशोरदा ये दोनों Singers की Voice , Voice of Heaven है . माना की मन्नाडे साहाब जी ने भी Classical Songs k साथ औरभी सभी तरह के बहोतसारे गाने गाए जो super-hit आजभी है , मगर रफीसाहाब की शहद जैसी मधुरतम Sweet Voice और किशोरदा का हर एक गाने का अलगही अंदाज और हर एक गाना महान-आदरणीय किशोरदा अलग-अलग आवाज और अंदाज में गाते थे , तो मेरे नजर में रफीसाहाब-किशोरदा ये सिर्फ भारत के नहीं , बल्कि पुरे विश्व में ऐसे अनमोल आवाज वाले Singers नहीं मिलेंगे . मुकेशसर भी एक महान-आदरणीय और काफी उच्च कोटी के Singer थे . मन्नाडे साहाब के गायकी को मेरा पुरा 100% Respect और दिलसे नमन है . हाँ , मन्नाडे साहाब को जितनी शोहरत मिलनी चाहिए थी , वो मिल ना सकी unfortunately ! Please Listen my Songs on my " Rupesh Gore " youtube channel dear friends , like-comments , Share it & if u Likes my Singing , Subscribe my youtube channel . Thnkuvymch .
Film industry and the music directors were unfortunate to ignore or disregard such a versatile singer. On seeing and hearing the commentary my eyes we're filled with tears, I can imagine how he must have felt after getting insulted. May his soul rest in peace. Is there any clip of Mr. K. C. Dey? If you please let me know. Thanks
Me regular listener of all filmy news and history so many host do this job very good manner but you are excellent and listen very good delivery of words from your side I have no words to present you Now you are one and only in this media Keep it up
Great Manna Dey is Manna Dey no compare with any others Singer's. He is Versatile Singer all types songs sung by Great Manna Dey . I salute legendary Singer Manna Dey .
Kasme waade pyar Wafa what a song , listen carefully you will feel the pain , without falsetto like Kishore da style of presentation of pain, there is no comparison between two manna Dey was classical singer whereas Kishore da untrained but utilizes his ability and disability beautifully ,it's my opinion don't take personal.
Superbly made video explaining full Jindagi of Mannada in short but covering full details of his life along with his Top and Popular songs he sang for and on various Actors and Music Directors. Thanks once again for your wonderful WORK. We all love you Mannada along with all other Singers.
Manna Dey is an unforgettable legendary singer. This kind of unfair treatment happens not only in Bollywood music but in every professional arena. No surprise.
मन्ना डे साहब बहुत ज़बरदस्त गायक थे, उनकी आवाज़ क्लासिक गाने के लिए बहुत अच्छी थी, क्लासिक गायकी के बादशाह थे, उनकी आवाज़ मे जवान पन नही था, मन्ना डे जी की आवाज़ मे बुढा पन था! रफी साहब अपनी आवाज़ कही भी मोड सकते थे, मुकेश जी और किशोर कुमार जी ये सब अपने आवाज़ से किसी भी अभिनेता के ऊपर जमा दिया करते थे..
Idiotic observation. In every song he sung according to the situation. If u want to listen song picturised on young hero then you should have to find bengali movies or bengali modern song which was like a chant for every bengali youths. Even today bengali youth love to memorise those legendary songs.
Wrong Idea ,Wrong comments , Please listen Yeaa dosti ham Nehi.... with Kishore Kumar in sholay flilm , Aooo twist kare in Film Bhoot Banglo , Jindegi kaysi hay pahele in Film Anand , Pyar hua ek raar hua in sree 420.,Eya Rat Bhigi Bhigi... Manna Dey could sing all type of songs like Md Rafi . Md Rafi and Manna Dey were the complete singers with classical based voices ,, Kishore Kumar was a good singer and entertainer with baritone voice . Mukesh was a good singer only.
बुड़ापन ! क्या बकवास ! मन्ना दा ने सुपर हिट रोमांटिक गाने गाये हैं । प्यार हुआ इक़रार हुआ, आजा सनम और बहुत से रोमांटिक गाने गाये हैं । उनके जितना versatile singer कोई नहीं है ।
This is not a fact. He became popular in Bengali film, when he started singing for Uttam Kumar and this opportunity he got after Hemant Mukherjee gave the passage. Obviously he was popular singer in 'Adhunik Gan'.
@@krishnagopalray8026 he is popular without Uttam kumar.there is a lot of hit non filmi song of Manna dey in Bengali.Hemant Mukherjee was the singer in most Uttam Kumar starer films
Both singers were good. We dont need to compare them. This is not Indian Idol competition where there is one winner. Singing is a form of meditation and whoever excels in that becomes a maestro.
When Manna Dey sings in classical manner, we know it is Manna Dey, but, there are so many top songs when I get confused, who sang this? Of course Rafi and Mukesh are easy because of their distinct voice. Is it Kishore Kumar? Now that gets complicated because he sounded very different in the 50s, 60s and 70s and also sang a very broad type of songs, so, if it is not Kishore kumar who is it? I look it up and it has always been Manna Dey. I think Manna Dey was the most versatile singer even more versatile than the great Kishore Kumar. He gave us the most iconic songs but never was seen as the mainstream singer for some reason. He sang Kabhi Kabhi mere dil mein...
If you learn music properly you will not care about statistical info, but the quality of his songs. It is important to learn music to understand Manna Dey.
My one the favourite singer is Manna Dey the great. I like his classical songs which are very tough and beautifully song by him. Salute his contribution to indian film industry. He will be remembered for centuries by his musical lovers👍👍👍👍👍👍
Manna dey sir hamesha sobke Dil me bosehi rahe hai aur rahega, the great singer India ki garb hain Manna Dey Sahab humare apko noman 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
মান্না দে অামাদের অন্তরে চিরদিন । গানের সংখ্যার বিচারে নয় শ্রোতাদের অন্তরে অাবেদনের দিক থেকে অন্য নামধারী শিল্পীদের চাইতে তার অাসন অমলিন।, উজ্জ্বল, ক্রমশঃ উজ্জ্বলতর।
shandar mere favourite gayek ki behtreen malumati docomentry apko salam hai apne bht bareeki se un baton ki nishan dehi ki jisy sirf music se juda hua insan hi bata skta hai shobha ji apka andaz e bayan ka jawab nhi clip lamba hony ke bawajud ese lga jese jald khatan ho gaya apka shukrya ap ne is azeem kalakaar ko man ki ankgon or dil ke kaano se mehsus kiya mn apko selute pesh krta hun sada khush rahen singer sajid ali khan karachi pakistan hum apko pakistan bulaen ge
प्रतिभा के धनी श्री मन्ना डे जी को शत-शत नमन।
लाजवाब प्रस्तुतिकरण के लिए धन्यवाद।
बहुत सुंदर प्रस्तुति
मन्ना डै साहिब उत्तम गायक थे!
श्रद्धॉंजलि !
Manna Ji is an absolute legend, and one of the best singers ever. His body of work is simply awesome. Along with Rafi Saab, Kishore Ji, Mukesh Ji, he forms the top 4 quartet which dominated Hindi movie music in that era. And yes, he was the most classically gifted singer of that time, who had an exceptionally amazing range👏👏👏
Manna Da was complete singer, he had classical training from his uncle K. C. Dey and four ustaads 1. Ustaad Dabir Khan 2. Ustaad Aman Ali Khan 3. Ustad Abdul Rahman Khan and 4. Ustad Ghulam Mustafa Khan. Ustad Bade Ghulam Ali Khan had after listening to Manna Da in a program in Jaipur in 1959 had written to him asking him to sing pure classical, Manna Da almost made up his mind to quit singing filmi songs, but Rafi Sahab his close friend who translated the letter dissuaded him to do so. Manna Da sang songs which no other singer could render. Mahender Kapoor and Asha Bhonsle have confessed that they were afraid to sing with him because of his classical training and mastery. Shankar Jaikishan regretted that they did not use Manna Da fully. Manna Da didn’t get his due, he deserved much more, more songs and recognition. Only connoisseurs can appreciate his range and mastery.
Manna Dey was legend singer. He sung for almost all superstar actors of 50s, 60s and 70. Unfortunately he could not encashed his popularity like other singers of his time due to his simplicity and honesty. Salute to Manna Dey for his contribution to Indian cinema.
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000m0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000much0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000m000000000000m000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000mm0000000000000000000mm0000000000000000000
Thanks for giving information about the great singer Manna Dey. His contribution to playback singing is memorable.
You portrait rightly reason behind manadev . .. he was great singer of all times we love ❤ him . M.zakir Rawalpindi Pakistan 🇵🇰.
মান্না দে হওয়া সহজ নয় এটা অনেকেই বুঝতো বলেই তাঁকে ছোট করে দেখানোর চেষ্টা চলতো ۔۔কিন্তু ভারতীয় সংগীতে তাঁর স্থান যে কোন উচ্চতায় অধিষ্ঠিত ۔۔তা বলার প্রয়োজন পড়ে না ۔۔সংগীতের মহাগুরু মান্না দে ۔۔তাঁর বিকল্প সেকালেও কেউ ছিল না ۔۔একালেও নেই ۔۔আগামীদিনেও কোনোদিন হবে না ۔۔۔
P
Thank you for the tribute to such a great singer … one of my all time favorites of his is Tum Gagan Ke Chandrama ❣️🎼
Shweta Ji, From Holland. Manna Dey Sahab was and is my Hero. A magnificient singer and a Great human beiing. I have a collection of all his songs. Thank you M'Dey Sahab.
So glad to meet you. I also have collection of Manna Dey songs.
Manna Dey was a legendary singer's of 50's, 60's and 70's era. He made his names in music industry, but unfortunately he didn't get the recognition for his music. In the time Manna Dey was singing there were three super singer's such as Mohd Rafi, Mekash and Kishore Kumer. He could not get the fame he wad entitle for. Its sad 😥 he was a great singer's. His way of singing was unique. 🤗🤗🙏🙏🤗
He is recognised among people who love music. people who dont love music cant be expected to love and respect a talented singer.
My favourite singer! His songs take us to another world.
Manna Dey is such a wonderful artist that Mukesh Kishore Kumar Mohammad Rafi cannot be compared to.Manna-day itself is a different kind of institution. Thanks for an informative presentation.
Absolutely right
Manna Dey Song collections are a treasure of knowledge for students of classical music.
When you say a different kind of institution you mean classical gener and you are right but you can't take away those naughty peppy pop songs of kishore and the most versatile of them all M.Rafi....No comparison dude..
Manna Dey was truly a genius singer.. He will never be forgotten.
He has been forgotten just like Mukesh
बिल्कुल सही है, मन्नाडेजी सच्चाई है कि मैं ऊनकी हर फिल्म के गाऐ हुए सभी गीत मेरे दिल के करीबी रहे हैं कयुँ की वो मेरी पसंदीदा हीरो राजकपूरजी की परफेक्ट आवाज रहे हैं/थे , फिर कभी ईस बात पर लिखेंगे, अब शुभम् मंगलमयी रात्रि😎😎😎😎😎😎 शयन रात्रि र
Ma Saraswati's blessings remained with him. Even after the immense negativity around him, the best was bestowed on him. He received the Dada Saheb Phalke award. Quality over quantity is always Ma Saraswati's preference. 🙏🙏🙏🙏. He is the best - transcendental voice. Sound arranged in perfect geometric pattern is music to transcendence 😍
Manna Dey sahab quality is unique because of this Rafi sahab, Kishore da, and Mukesh sahab has clone or other singers copy them but no one can copy manna Dey sahab even today no one dare to copy,
Please listen to Hemant Kumar group where there are 2 singers who sing great Manna Day’s songs.
Mogammad Rafi used to listen, praise and appreciate him. He was a big Fan of Manna Dey. This itself shows Greatness of Manna Dey.
No doubt Mohammed Rafi himself was a great person by both professionally a legend, and a gentleman person. You rarely find a person in any profession who has such a good relationship with his all of his contemporary. He has never made any negative comment about any one. In fact he had very positive relationships with all including great singers like Manna Dey, Kishore, Mukesh, Mahender Kapoor. He is an inspiration for today's industry.
Thank you for the balanced & objective content of the video.
Manna Dey's under-appreciation in our subcontinent is proof that most of us enjoy a male singer's tonal quality more than his singing prowess.
This does not mean that the other greats (Mohd. Rafi, Kishore Kumar etc) were not fine singers, but Manna Dey was in a different league.
To typecast him as a 'classical singer' is like feeling only the tail of an elephant and inferring that the animal is just another type of snake.
He is the most genre-versatile male singer of our subcontinent. No genre of music was beyond his capability.
मन्ना डे साहब की आवाज़ में फरिश्ते जेसी पवित्रता थी.
वे महान गायक थे.
उन्हें शत् शत् नमन
Nobody can match Manna Dey. I have loved his singing since my childhood.
Glad to meet u
Manna Da has always been one of my most favorite singers. He made his own place among the famous established male singers of his times and was always very well received and accepted by the public. It was the inhibition and false notion of some producers and composers which did not give him due recognition.
Indeed a great classical singer. His excellent renderings will remain in our hearts forever
दिल में गहरी दु:ख की लैहर उठा,,,,,,ना जाने कितने अपमान सहना पड़ा था मान्ना डे जी को ,,,हम कोटि कोटि नमन करते हैं उनकों 🙏🙏
Sahi baat kahi aapne.
Manna Dey sahab is the real Tansen of Film Music..Why only Films, let's say music The Voice, the "Lagan" and "Mehnat" with which he cultivated himself through his voice culture by intense practice, dedication and sacrifice is unmatched in the film industry He was a man for all seasons...Nobody can match him. He used to set bench marks that it was almost impossible to reach there. No wonder the singers of today who try to imitate only Rafi sahab, Kishore sahab and Mukesh sahab don't even dare to try to imitate Manna sahab or try his difficult classical based songs which were termed light classical in those days because they lack the guts, the "mehnat", the riyaaz and range. All try to shine at once which unfortunately ends up in a flash in the pan. Jaya ji has done a wonderful job in portraying the genius and calibre of a true singer Manna Dey sahab who sits on the top as the saying goes - "There is always room at the Top"
R. I. P Manna Dey sahab.
Manna Dey's songs will remain in the hearts of music lover so long the Indian music will live ....
Haji Muhammad Rafi saheb or mannadei and Kishor Kumar my favourite gayek kalakar hei thankyou God bless you
I don't know why he was under rated, he was great singer with magical voice with all said great singers of subcontinent. a pure soul of music
He was never underrated. I have learnt classical music and he is our source of inspiration. Pl. dont hurt somebody's feelings with your incisive comments. If you dont understand real music, it is your problem.
Great Great Singer. Beyond the limit. No comparison with this great soul. Highly talented. Very humble.
Manna Dey was a totally underrated singer. Thanks Shwetaji.
He was never underrated. Please be polite while writing remarks.
Since my childhood I was deeply attracted to his voice basically for the emotions he carried in the lyrics. While in comedy songs the rhythm played with tabla & dholak blended the song so fantastically that one when listens made blissful in heart. It is due to him that people were attracted to film classical songs so that the classical songs are not scary but worth listening. I owe much to him for giving me ever cheerful mind when remembering him in music.
Manna Dey was Versatile legendary Singer Who Sang immortal Melodious Songs Whoever forget his evergreen Melodious songs for Super hit movies Chori Chori,Shri 420, Ujala, Seema,Anand,Upkar,Basant Bahar, Waqt etc. Hatts of great Singer Manna Dey !!!
His songs are my favourite.
Whenever I feel down, his songs lift my mood.A legend in music.
Yes a gem🌄 in indeed.
Manna Dey and Kishore Kumar can not be replaced.
Great singer very versatile. I do enjoy listening to many of his songs. You are right didn’t get much recognition. God bless you wherever you may be 🙏
Manna Dey was not only a great singer but a great man. He always respected other singers despite the fact that he himself was a great singer.
Not only great he highly educated,highly soft thinker man, he was highly morality man ,not chacha not pair pahru
Not only great he highly educated,highly soft thinker man, he was highly morality man ,not chacha not pair pahru,they state farword talk man
Great singer , my favourite velvet voice , versatile ,even lata mangeshkar use to get intimated by him . Got typecast as classical singer very famous legend in kolkata cinema . Singer Kavita Krishnamurthy use to singh under him in stage shows. All songs sung bh him r hits.
We should respect every person and every singer or actor. I'm 26 and love his voice. He had a great voice and i don't think people who disrespected him can sing a single note like him.
Manna Dey the pride of Hindustan was at his sublime best in rendering Bengali numbers. He is deeply respected in Bombay but in Calcutta he along with Hemant Kumar( Hemant Mukhopadhyay) is considered nothing less than Almighty in incarnation. My personal favorite is another great and that is Md Rafi. But I am ready to die at any time for great great Manna Dey. I am seriously against any foolish comparison between Md Rafi, Mukesh, Manna Dey, Kishore or Hemant ..as they are all blessed by none other than the Almighty. Just enjoy the musical world enriched by all these legands and the pride of our Hindustan.
@ Amit Mazumder
Very great and valuable words !!!
You are a great soul !!!
My love and regards to you !!!
May God bless you !!!
Mana Dey and Rafi are far better than kishore , kishore was limited singer .
@@russelindia Kishore is Far Better Than Barfi And Banna.
@@PushpaDevi-nl8fv Kishore himself said in video interview that Music directors used to make tunes lighter so that he could sing them. So , we should believe Kishore himself , or a fan like you?
We can see shor kumar was limited.
@@russelindia When Did he Say Mr. Crying Barfi Fan ??
Great Manna Dey, shall remain immortal by his excellency in field of music. The only one of his kind, unmatched, unparalleled , unprecedented magic of nature.It does not matter by a group of MDs or Directors He was ignored. But in the Hearts of people he shall always be received heart to heart. His taintless, clear classical based voice was overwhelming and intoxicating shall rein over hearts of millions for the ages to come.
Never knew this much about Dada g. No doubt a great & The best versatile singer ever heard in my life. RIP sir but your songs will always live .....🧐🌠🌹🌠
Manna Dey was a legend. Seen his concerts in San Francisco couple of time. Still listen to his music and enjoy it.
No comparison he was a super singer with the class of his own Indian classical singer with the knowledge of complete Raggas.
Yes ......Anybody who learns Ragas needs to know about Manna Dey.
When I studied music, I learnt to play the song "Tu pyaar ka saagar haii" on my harmonium.
Mannada was an expert classical singer It is unfortunate that he did not get what he deserved
He got lots of accolades amongst his target audience. So its wrong to say he did not get the fame he wanted.
वहुत सुन्दर, उपेक्षित को उचित सम्मान देने के लिए.. जयजयसियाराम!!! रफी, मुकेश, किशोर के अलावे मन्ना डे निसंदेह एक चौथे खम्वे थे.जयजयसियाराम!!!
Manna Dey was a great son of India & a great singer ❤❤❤❤❤& He is immortal in Heaven by virtue of his songs...
उस वक्त के सभी गायक एक एक चट्टान थे।
सभी की गायकी एक नंबर थी।
ये तो तकदिर की बात है।किसको क्या मिला।
धन्यवाद,,,,
Only Manna Dey is Padmabhushan❤
Singer of another world❤🙏🏼🙏🏼
ॐ बेजोड़ सदाबहार गायक। भारतीय सिनेमा में बहुत गायक हुवे मगर दो गायक श्री मन्ना डे साहब और किशोर कुमार साहब इन दोनो की बात ही अलग अलग थी जिसका कोई मुकाबला नही है।हार्दिक श्रधांजलि नमन।🙏🙏❤️😊
Had ho gi bhai kaha manna day or kaha kishor da
Manna day sirf rafi sahab ke sath compere ho sakte hai kishor da ko singing knowledge nhi thi
No 1 sirf aik hi sultaan he aor usse mo rafi sahab kahte he aor unka mandir bhi he aor puza bhi hoti he ye he sach saboot ke sath
Maharaja to sirf ek hi hai Kishore da. Jiske agey sab chote ho jate hai
@@thegautamdutt kahi sadak par bolna bhi mat nahi to koi hindu bhai hi maare ga aap ko
@@zunairashraf9024 ye apka ka sirf ek majhabe angle hai isse door raho. Ye insaan ko pollute kar deta. Mai Rafi saheb ko bhi manta hoon magar jo janam se hi mahan ho usko koi chu nehi sakta. Javed Akhtar ka analysis suniye detail me kaha hai. Jis gane ko Kishore da aur dusre singer ne gaya usme hamesha Kishore da hi ekkis rahe, koi bhi example dekh lo. Sara concept saaf ho jayega
Mannadey was one of our greatest playback singer....but never knew he had so many difficulties in his career.
A beautiful narration bringing out the hitherto unknown ups and downs of this great singer. Lot of thanks for this revelation.
Many thanks for giving such unheard exposure. He became far away from kolkata physicaly and we felt the misery in him. Today I felt the reason but it made his creation imortal.
Salutes from Pakistan to the pride of music Mannaday ji..... he was really baymisaal legend and nobody will ever fill the gap he left behind 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
True....Thanks for watching...
Allah taala Manna Dey Sahab ke darjo ko buland fermaye. Aamin.
I miss him.
I am a great fan of mannade, thank you so much for this information
आपने मन्ना डे साहब का बेहतरीन सत्य विश्लेषण किया है और अद्भुत जानकारी दी मैं मन्ना डे साहब को प्रथम श्रेणी का हुनर दार गायक मानता हूं बहुत पहले से और रफी साहब और मुकेश जी की बराबरी का परन्तु किशोर तो मन्ना डे साहब के सामने बिल्कुल नहीं ठहरता हेमंत कुमार और तलत महमूद की आवाज़ ज़्यादा अच्छी है सबसे फिसड्डी गायक है किशोर कुमार
Thanks for your appreciation 🙏
ऐसा क्यों लग रहा है कि तू किशोर दा की नाजायज़ औलाद है तभी ऐसा बोल रहा है।
@@ShwetaJayaFilmyBaatein मैडम जी ये कुंवर पाल सिंह हमारे किशोर दा का अपमान कर रहा है और आप इसके कमेंट को लाइक भी कर रही हो आपको शर्म नहीं आती ये चैनल इसीलिये बनाया है क्या ??
@@ghiyasuddinbalban3833 ji सबकी अपनी अपनी पसंद है, इसमें अपमान वाली कोई बात नहीं है। अन्यथा न लें 🙏🏻
Many thanks for giving such type of information about Manna Dey Saheb .
मन्ना डे साहब सुरीली आवाज के साथ-साथ शास्त्रीय संगीत के सरताज रहें है । गायको में प्रतिस्पर्धा की बातें बेमानी है, सबकी अपनी पहचान और कला होती है । व्यवसायिक सफलता-असफलता का महत्व नहीं होता ।
आपके विषय और उसके शानदार विश्लेषण के लिए बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद और हार्दिक शुभकामनाएं।
Love his songs,I saw his show in Auckland New Zealand once , it'll stay in my mind for as long as I live.
Manna Da’s many classical songs could be sung by anyone.
Great personality & great singer Manna dey
Manna Dey was one of the greatest singer of the Hindi film industry
अतुलनीय गायक - नमन वंदन पूजन - सुन्दर वीडियो के लिए आभार
Bahot bahot e accha laga.Well done .Manna Dey is Manna Dey. No substitute.
Fantastic singer Mannadey saab 🙏 .. only Rafisaab was his challenge , as Mannadey himself used to say .
Manna Dey never cared about making status.
In every song he tried to sing efficiently and perform his best.
आपने Video बहोत अच्छा बनाया है Madam . मै खुद एक छोटासा Local Singer हूं . मन्नाडे साहाब महानतम Singer थे , और Classical Singing में Master और नं 1 थे इसमे कोईभी दोराह नहीं है . मगर specially रफीसाहाब और किशोरदा ये दोनों Singers की Voice , Voice of Heaven है . माना की मन्नाडे साहाब जी ने भी Classical Songs k साथ औरभी सभी तरह के बहोतसारे गाने गाए जो super-hit आजभी है , मगर रफीसाहाब की शहद जैसी मधुरतम Sweet Voice और किशोरदा का हर एक गाने का अलगही अंदाज और हर एक गाना महान-आदरणीय किशोरदा अलग-अलग आवाज और अंदाज में गाते थे , तो मेरे नजर में रफीसाहाब-किशोरदा ये सिर्फ भारत के नहीं , बल्कि पुरे विश्व में ऐसे अनमोल आवाज वाले Singers नहीं मिलेंगे . मुकेशसर भी एक महान-आदरणीय और काफी उच्च कोटी के Singer थे . मन्नाडे साहाब के गायकी को मेरा पुरा 100% Respect और दिलसे नमन है . हाँ , मन्नाडे साहाब को जितनी शोहरत मिलनी चाहिए थी , वो मिल ना सकी unfortunately ! Please Listen my Songs on my " Rupesh Gore " youtube channel dear friends , like-comments , Share it & if u Likes my Singing , Subscribe my youtube channel . Thnkuvymch .
Nicely explained 👍 all the best for your valuable work 🙏
He is my father's and mine all time favorite singer
While I have my utmost respect to Mukesh, "ye raat bheegi bheegi" cannot be sung by him or any other singer.
Great Singar mannadey Sahab
Lajawab my favourit Singar
So Fantastic Classic Singar
Lekin Padma Bhushan award to Manna ko hi Mila Jo na Mukesh na Rafi na Kishore Kumar ko mila
Super glowing tributes to Manna dey..classical songs specialist in Bollywood field.I like very much melody of great singer.
Film industry and the music directors were unfortunate to ignore or disregard such a versatile singer. On seeing and hearing the commentary my eyes we're filled with tears, I can imagine how he must have felt after getting insulted. May his soul rest in peace. Is there any clip of Mr. K. C. Dey? If you please let me know. Thanks
Zabardast video banaayi hai 👌jo bhi rahe, Manna De ki awaaz bahut sureeli aur madhur bhi thi ❗❤️🙏
Even if he had sung only one song "tu pyar Kay sagar hai,," he would have been immortal.
Sahi kaha...👏👏
Me regular listener of all filmy news and history so many host do this job very good manner but you are excellent and listen very good delivery of words from your side
I have no words to present you
Now you are one and only in this media
Keep it up
Heartiest thanks sir 🙏 Stay connected 🙏
Great Manna Dey is Manna Dey no compare with any others Singer's. He is Versatile Singer all types songs sung by Great Manna Dey . I salute legendary Singer Manna Dey .
Bahut accha. Salute to great singer Manna dey ji. Saath hi saath aapko bhi. Aapki awaz bhi bahut acchi hai.
Well done dear Shweta,very great ,very onest,and very pure collection you provide us manny manny thanks to you, love you mam
Thankyou Shweta ji Aise legend ke zikr karne ke liye.
Versetile fantastice posting of great extraoradnery manna dey sheab
Legendary singer. All his songs were hits
Kasme waade pyar Wafa what a song , listen carefully you will feel the pain , without falsetto like Kishore da style of presentation of pain, there is no comparison between two manna Dey was classical singer whereas Kishore da untrained but utilizes his ability and disability beautifully ,it's my opinion don't take personal.
Wah superb video very good information thanks for sharing lovely posts.. 👍😍🌹
मन्नाडे पर मेरी किताब संगीत मन को पंख लगाए जरूर पढे महान गायक और महामानव को शतशत नमन
Very mean full video about great play back Indian Film singer Manna Dey, thanks!
Superbly made video explaining full Jindagi of Mannada in short but covering full details of his life along with his Top and Popular songs he sang for and on various Actors and Music Directors. Thanks once again for your wonderful WORK. We all love you Mannada along with all other Singers.
Thanks for your appreciation and valuable comment 🙏 regards
Good video about a great singer.👍 Inspite of mistakes at couple of places.
My favorite only rafi saab
Manna Dey is an unforgettable legendary singer. This kind of unfair treatment happens not only in Bollywood music but in every professional arena. No surprise.
Aye meri zohrajabeen what a masterpiece
A real legend who was not easy to understand until he proved him self with his talent no comparison
मन्ना डे साहब बहुत ज़बरदस्त गायक थे, उनकी आवाज़ क्लासिक गाने के लिए बहुत अच्छी थी, क्लासिक गायकी के बादशाह थे, उनकी आवाज़ मे जवान पन नही था, मन्ना डे जी की आवाज़ मे बुढा पन था! रफी साहब अपनी आवाज़ कही भी मोड सकते थे, मुकेश जी और किशोर कुमार जी ये सब अपने आवाज़ से किसी भी अभिनेता के ऊपर जमा दिया करते थे..
100%true opinion diya h aap ne
Idiotic observation. In every song he sung according to the situation. If u want to listen song picturised on young hero then you should have to find bengali movies or bengali modern song which was like a chant for every bengali youths. Even today bengali youth love to memorise those legendary songs.
Wrong Idea ,Wrong comments , Please listen Yeaa dosti ham Nehi.... with Kishore Kumar in sholay flilm , Aooo twist kare in Film Bhoot Banglo , Jindegi kaysi hay pahele in Film Anand , Pyar hua ek raar hua in sree 420.,Eya Rat Bhigi Bhigi... Manna Dey could sing all type of songs like Md Rafi . Md Rafi and Manna Dey were the complete singers with classical based voices ,, Kishore Kumar was a good singer and entertainer with baritone voice . Mukesh was a good singer only.
बुड़ापन ! क्या बकवास ! मन्ना दा ने सुपर हिट रोमांटिक गाने गाये हैं । प्यार हुआ इक़रार हुआ, आजा सनम और बहुत से रोमांटिक गाने गाये हैं । उनके जितना versatile singer कोई नहीं है ।
@@umasankarchakraborty1516 मुकेश चंद्र माथुर और किशोर कुमार ने भी बहुत सारे शास्त्रीय संगीत से सजे गीतों को गाया है कृपया जानकारी पूरी रखा करें।
रफी मुकेश किशोर कोई भी मन्ना दा का मुकाबला नहीं कर सकता था महानतम शाश्त्रीय फ़िल्मी गायक को नमन....
rafi was the complete singer..rafi is above all the singers till today...
@@sarojlamichhane5967not all time
बांगला फिल्म जगत मान्ना दे का पहला पसंद था|वह पहले टलिवुड को टाईम देते थे-बाद में बलिवुड को!इसलिए भी मान्ना दे बलिवुड में पिछे रह गए थे!
This is not a fact. He became popular in Bengali film, when he started singing for Uttam Kumar and this opportunity he got after Hemant Mukherjee gave the passage. Obviously he was popular singer in 'Adhunik Gan'.
@@krishnagopalray8026 he is popular without Uttam kumar.there is a lot of hit non filmi song of Manna dey in Bengali.Hemant Mukherjee was the singer in most Uttam Kumar starer films
No one can replace Manna Dey ji.All songs.sung by him are AMAR.
Hame apka episode bahut achha laga unke jivan ki kirti 20 minat me bataya dhanyabad 🙏🙏🙏
Manna Dey a great singer and one of my favorites. It was fate that he was a singer during Rafi Saab's time otherwise he would have been on top.
Both singers were good. We dont need to compare them.
This is not Indian Idol competition where there is one winner. Singing is a form of meditation and whoever excels in that becomes a maestro.
When Manna Dey sings in classical manner, we know it is Manna Dey, but, there are so many top songs when I get confused, who sang this? Of course Rafi and Mukesh are easy because of their distinct voice. Is it Kishore Kumar? Now that gets complicated because he sounded very different in the 50s, 60s and 70s and also sang a very broad type of songs, so, if it is not Kishore kumar who is it? I look it up and it has always been Manna Dey. I think Manna Dey was the most versatile singer even more versatile than the great Kishore Kumar. He gave us the most iconic songs but never was seen as the mainstream singer for some reason. He sang Kabhi Kabhi mere dil mein...
If you learn music properly you will not care about statistical info, but the quality of his songs. It is important to learn music to understand Manna Dey.
Kishore da apko apko Rafi sahab je jyada versatile lage???
Improve ur music knowledge
@@ammyvideos2215 सच को स्वीकार करो।
My one the favourite singer is Manna Dey the great. I like his classical songs which are very tough and beautifully song by him. Salute his contribution to indian film industry. He will be remembered for centuries by his musical lovers👍👍👍👍👍👍
Sweta g apne to mujhe rula hi diya..Manna Dey saab ki yaad aa gyi..wo karoro logon ke dilon pe aaj bhi raj karte hai
Most knowledgeable display of events of a great singer. How to remain composed at the time of insults it self shows greatness of a singer.
Manna dey sir hamesha sobke Dil me bosehi rahe hai aur rahega, the great singer India ki garb hain Manna Dey Sahab humare apko noman 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
মান্না দে অামাদের অন্তরে চিরদিন । গানের সংখ্যার বিচারে নয় শ্রোতাদের অন্তরে অাবেদনের দিক থেকে অন্য নামধারী শিল্পীদের চাইতে তার অাসন অমলিন।, উজ্জ্বল, ক্রমশঃ উজ্জ্বলতর।
shandar mere favourite gayek ki behtreen malumati docomentry
apko salam hai apne bht bareeki se un baton ki nishan dehi ki jisy sirf music se juda hua insan hi bata skta hai
shobha ji apka andaz e bayan ka jawab nhi
clip lamba hony ke bawajud ese lga jese jald khatan ho gaya
apka shukrya ap ne is azeem kalakaar ko man ki ankgon or dil ke kaano se mehsus kiya
mn apko selute pesh krta hun
sada khush rahen
singer
sajid ali khan
karachi
pakistan
hum apko pakistan bulaen ge
Itna pyar dene ke liye shukriya Sajid Sahab 🙏 namaskar 🙏
You are my “Host and Ghost”.
Good information. Keep up your good work.
Thanks 🙏😇