1916 by Sabaton (Motorhead Cover) - Historian Reaction

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 окт 2024
  • See the original here - • SABATON - 1916 (Offici...
    Support VTH on patreon: / vth
    Follow me on instagram here - / vloggingthroughhistory
    Follow VTH on Facebook here - www.facebook.c...
    Check out the VTH Podcast
    Spotify - open.spotify.c...
    Apple - podcasts.apple...
    VTH Gaming - / thehistoryguy
    VTH Extra - / @vthextra
    VTH Originals - / @vthoriginals259

Комментарии • 367

  • @ForgottenHonor0
    @ForgottenHonor0 Год назад +516

    "The first rule of war is that young men die. The second is that nobody can change the first rule..." --Lt. Colonel Henry Blake, 4077th MASH
    RIP to all those who did not grow old...

    • @Spook_Boi
      @Spook_Boi Год назад +14

      yup. the young ones either age 20 years in 1 year, or they dont age no more

    • @fenrisulfur842
      @fenrisulfur842 Год назад +5

      god damn, I´m old enough to remeber it. Yes, wise words, and in the end...remember, what happend to Lt.Col Blake with his brand new pin stripe suite? He gave all and died on the way home, cause a fucking machine failed. FUBAR

    • @popuptarget7386
      @popuptarget7386 Год назад +2

      Henry was often portrayed as a lovable buffon...but he was a man who earned his place.

    • @logicalatheist1065
      @logicalatheist1065 Год назад +2

      @@popuptarget7386 Great Leader when he got serious, tried not to be though

    • @kingwacky184
      @kingwacky184 Год назад +3

      War is a place where young people who don't know each other and don't hate each other, kill each other, based on decisions made by old people who know each other and hate each other, but don't kill each other..." author unknown

  • @SilverSmurfen1
    @SilverSmurfen1 Год назад +301

    The timing, i'm going to a Sabaton concert in a couple of minutes.

    • @Ross-zs4zt
      @Ross-zs4zt Год назад +13

      Dude, enjoy! I saw them in Glasgow, Scotland on the 18th of this month. Best concert I've ever seen by a long way

    • @mort58
      @mort58 Год назад +4

      Lite lätt avis, ha lite kul ikväll för mig också.

    • @ziyilin2029
      @ziyilin2029 Год назад +2

      I am actually going to a Sabaton Concert soon

    • @hallqvist77
      @hallqvist77 Год назад +2

      Was there yesterday too, in avicii arena. Great show!!!

    • @Erik6706
      @Erik6706 Год назад +3

      Jag var också där. Great consert!

  • @bobburris4445
    @bobburris4445 Год назад +169

    There were also a lot of callbacks to Sabaton songs; The Hellfighters you mentioned, the ancient Greek soldiers for Sparta, the 101st airborne soldier for screaming eagles, the woman coming out of the alley while airplanes fly overhead for both night witches and Lady of the dark, etc

    • @oldcontemptible7646
      @oldcontemptible7646 Год назад +28

      Don’t forget blood of Bannockburn, the Scottish knight in yellow

    • @purpletigerfish7697
      @purpletigerfish7697 Год назад +17

      @@oldcontemptible7646 Robert the Bruce according to credits. :-)

    • @GioTummy3463
      @GioTummy3463 Год назад

      Why is it called 1916 if the video showcases wars from Ancient Greek and Rome even?

    • @bobburris4445
      @bobburris4445 Год назад +12

      @@GioTummy3463 it's a cover of the song '1916' by Motorhead

    • @GioTummy3463
      @GioTummy3463 Год назад

      @@bobburris4445 Yes I know. But why including soldiers from different periods if the song is about 1916? Just seems odd

  • @easygzus9064
    @easygzus9064 Год назад +109

    I used to LOVE this song by Motorhead, i almost forgot it existed til this... SO glad Sabaton brought it back, and great reaction

  • @clashof6d
    @clashof6d 8 месяцев назад +19

    This is not a song. This is an anthem

  • @clement7689
    @clement7689 Год назад +18

    Here in France we always make jokes about the british regarding our old rivalry. But if there is one conflict we do not dare to laugh about is WWI. Gloire à eux, ce furent des braves.

    • @jim7174
      @jim7174 2 месяца назад +1

      Us Brits make jokes about our rivalry over the last 1000 years too least we've been friends now for a long time ,but I agree you don't laugh about WW1 so many lives lost on all sides

    • @CommonSenserules1981
      @CommonSenserules1981 Месяц назад

      Red white and blue...

  • @elbrobert2377
    @elbrobert2377 Год назад +67

    I saw Sabaton this monday in Hamburg and i am still amazed by it and was soo happy that they performed "1916" just a beautiful moment to remember

    • @hummelchen6773
      @hummelchen6773 Год назад +3

      I am going to see them next Tuesday in Hannover! :-)))) Ihope they will have it on their playlist there...

    • @elbrobert2377
      @elbrobert2377 Год назад

      @@hummelchen6773 ahh i hope you enjoy it as much as i did ! I hope it won't take too long for them to return, since the concert ended i think about it on a daily schedule 🤘🏻😁🤘🏻

    • @themanfromupover2020
      @themanfromupover2020 Год назад +1

      ​@@elbrobert2377 awesome, I saw them last week in Frankfurt!

    • @DarthAxolotl
      @DarthAxolotl Год назад +2

      I saw them in Leeds, genuinely didn't expect them to play it as it had only come out on RUclips the day before. Such a beautiful song played live.

  • @rayross997
    @rayross997 Год назад +97

    Thank you for your video about the Newfoundland Regiment at Beaumont-Hamel. Those few minutes of courage have impacted Newfoundland to this day.

  • @mighty_spirit8532
    @mighty_spirit8532 Год назад +41

    I wanted to say that just a couple of minutes before you posted this Sabaton released a behind the scenes documentary of the filming process for this song which may be worth checking out for anyone interested

    • @coletedeux
      @coletedeux Год назад +3

      The documentary is as good as it gets. Three days of filming in the Czech Republic, interviews with some of the extras as well as some of the featured actors. Good way to spend an half hour.

    • @kathnunan641
      @kathnunan641 Год назад +3

      @@coletedeux 3 days of filming in the UK for 1916 in and around Birmingham if you goto the end of the credits it tells you where it filmed Christmas truce was 3 days in Czech republic

  • @riverroth3688
    @riverroth3688 Год назад +95

    You're right on the older two being the two surviving members of Motorhead, and yeah they linked all wars, along with all the various stories they've told in this video, from the night witches and Leonidas to the soldiers at Verdun and the somme. This video really hits you in the gut and it's hard to deny the band really both put respect on the name of both motorhead for having one of the best songs about WWI, and on the soldiers they're writing about.

    • @drigerdranzer7514
      @drigerdranzer7514 Год назад +19

      And the bus in the beginning.
      Hammersmith 82.
      Heavy Motörhead reference.

    • @ThePhoenixAscendant
      @ThePhoenixAscendant Год назад +8

      They were also in the procession carrying a portrait of Ian Fraser "Lemmy" Kilmister (24 December 1945 - 28 December 2015). RIP Lemmy, you were a legend.

  • @--panda--5588
    @--panda--5588 8 месяцев назад +5

    This song... it just makes me cry every time

  • @Ishlacorrin
    @Ishlacorrin Год назад +71

    An interesting note here is that while the last lyrics are "And now no one remembers our names", Sabaton gave a name to each and every person who made an appearance in this video in the credits. A small gesture, but a meaningful one. Lest we forget.

    • @debbiescott7657
      @debbiescott7657 9 месяцев назад +1

      i think you mean lest we forget, not let we forget

  • @Dartanius100
    @Dartanius100 Год назад +54

    I saw Sabaton when they came to Leeds two weeks ago. Absolutely incredible band, they put on a hell of a show! Very grounded and down-to-earth, too.

    • @zachb7836
      @zachb7836 Год назад +4

      So jealous you got to see them at that show, looked fantastic!

    • @Dartanius100
      @Dartanius100 Год назад +2

      @@zachb7836 It really was great! Can't wait for the next one!

    • @gregstevenson8994
      @gregstevenson8994 Год назад +1

      Saw them at Glasgow, was an awesome show, best gig I’ve ever been to.

    • @eatenbyghouls1849
      @eatenbyghouls1849 Год назад +6

      Yeh I went too, it was amazing
      Admittedly that concert did get me into babymetal too and I'm seeing babymetal in wolverhampton in November now lol

    • @andrewkenny6119
      @andrewkenny6119 Год назад +1

      I also saw them in Leeds super powerful messages to all their songs.

  • @Silvercrypto-xk4zy
    @Silvercrypto-xk4zy Год назад +13

    im not crying, youre crying. why does sabaton have to make such good emotional songs. i know of at least two ancestors that barely made it to the age of 20 and died in different wars

  • @cobbler9113
    @cobbler9113 Год назад +73

    Being from the UK where WW1 is relatively high in the public conscience, this song never fails to get me emotional. Whenever I’ve listened to it, especially about the lines where they call for their mothers always gets me. I don’t have children yet, but it must have been hard for you considering your own son is probably only a few years off the age of many of these kids I’m guessing?

    • @VloggingThroughHistory
      @VloggingThroughHistory  Год назад +24

      He’s 15 1/2. Yep right at that age.

    • @svartmetall
      @svartmetall Год назад +5

      Spot on; it's actually the line '"...and we added two years to our ages" that always punches me right in the feels.

    • @cobbler9113
      @cobbler9113 Год назад +2

      @@svartmetall I don’t know what the situation was in other warring countries as they mostly had conscription, but that was one of the first things I remember learning about WW1. Hits even harder when you go to the Somme and Flanders and see the graves.

    • @popuptarget7386
      @popuptarget7386 Год назад +3

      I am always saddened how my fellow Yanks forget the first world war. It is overshadowed here by the second but we all forget the second need not have happened but for the first..we all failed to learn the lesson paid for in blood.
      Unfortunately we seem to fly headlong into the next search for glory.

    • @1972jonboy
      @1972jonboy 5 месяцев назад

      Sydney Lewis was the youngest British soldier in ww1 and was at the battle of the Somme he was just 12 years old ( 13 years old during the Somme) he lived until 1969.
      Sidney George Lewis (24 March 1903 - 1969) enlisted in the East Surrey Regiment in August 1915 at the age of twelve. His parents had no idea where he was.
      He fought in the Battle of the Somme in 1916, then aged thirteen, in the 106th Machine Gun Company of the Machine Gun Corps. Lewis fought in the Battle of Delville Wood which saw some of the worst casualties on the Somme.
      His mother was told where her son was by a comrade home on leave, and she demanded that the War Office release him. It asked her for his birth certificate and discharged the boy. Lewis was awarded the Victory Medal and the British War Medal. He re-enlisted in 1918 and served with the army of occupation in Austria. He joined the police in Kingston upon Thames after the war and served in bomb disposal during World War II. Later, he ran a pub in Frant, East Sussex. He died in 1969.
      Although World War I army recruiters often turned a blind eye to underage recruits, another factor may have been Lewis's mature appearance. He was a tall heavily built boy, who would grow to 6 feet 2 inches (1.88 m) as an adult. The minimum height requirement of the British Army at the time was only 5 feet 3 inches (1.60 m).
      Lewis' claim has been authenticated by the Imperial War Museum after research by van Emden uncovered the evidence, including family papers and Lewis's birth certificate. The family papers have been donated to the museum by Lewis' surviving son. Lewis' story was also found to have been reported] in newspapers at the time.

  • @connorward2400
    @connorward2400 Год назад +15

    I was at that gig in Leeds. And it was a very powerful song. Very good gig as well, I had Swedish Pagans stuck in my head for two days after.

  • @copocopocopocopo
    @copocopocopocopo Год назад +39

    R.I.P. Lemmy of Motörhead. Your legacy continues on with this song. Thank you Sabaton for covering one of Lemmy's works, and thank YOU VTH for reacting to it. Some very powerful stuff right here. It almost brought a tear to my eye, thinking of the wasted lives taken by the battle.
    EDIT: 6:38 That's Lemmy in the picture he's holding.

    • @jasonuk8333
      @jasonuk8333 Год назад +6

      Every time I watch this video I swear there is someone cutting onions near me whenever it reaches the scene with Lemmy being given his rightful place on the march, alongside his bandmates. Never been able to get past it without tears. The guy holding the picture is Eddie Rocha, Sabaton's tour manager who had worked with Motorhead for years.

    • @SylviusTheMad
      @SylviusTheMad Год назад +2

      The guy holding Lemmy's picture is Motörhead's tour manager. That road crew was legendary.

  • @NorthernCoins
    @NorthernCoins Год назад +3

    Thank you for doing this, my great grandfather fought and was shot in the chest at the battle of the somme, he died in 1990 still with the round next to his heart , long live the south lancs regiment

  • @priyan605
    @priyan605 Год назад +3

    I've been waiting for this! Thank you for reacting to Sabaton after such a long time

  • @jonroberts7125
    @jonroberts7125 Год назад +1

    i was at that concert in Leeds it was so touching put a lump in your throat watching the drummer and listening to the song

  • @craighurst6102
    @craighurst6102 Год назад +9

    I was there at Leeds for the concert, the song live was just eerie and mind-blowing
    The whole concert was just unbelievable though

  • @IcemanCFB
    @IcemanCFB Год назад +3

    I was at the Leeds concert when this song had its live debut. The adrenaline of being at the concert stopped me from doing so at the time, but there have been a few times since where I have watched the music video (as well as the Motorhead original) where the tears have come through - such a powerful and emotional song with an equally powerful and emotional message.

  • @aaronwatson7609
    @aaronwatson7609 Год назад +3

    I have been waiting for your reaction ever since Sabaton released their version of 1916.
    I went to see Sabaton in Cardiff about 2 weeks ago and they were incredible. Such an amazing experience, if you have never seen then before you absolutely must!

  • @detroitpolak9904
    @detroitpolak9904 8 месяцев назад +2

    People say Sabaton “overdoes” the anthemic, epic, sound, but they ain’t singing about clerks who collated and stapled above and beyond the call of duty, here. These people DESERVE IT.

  • @argantyr5154
    @argantyr5154 Год назад +4

    I've seen this Video at least a Dozen times, and everytime I tear up. As you said toward the end, I cannot make sense of it, that is how I think most people have it.
    Yes those two are the members of Motörhead, the picture they carry later, are of Lemmy the late Vocalist of Mötorhead.
    All in all a fantastic tribute to a great Song.

  • @tonk82
    @tonk82 7 месяцев назад +1

    As a motorhead fan, i know Lemmy would have loved this video. Not only because its a great rendition, but also because of all the details portraying soldiers from different times, clothing included. He was a huge fan of war memorabilia.

  • @TheMelody911
    @TheMelody911 Год назад +1

    Thank you for your deep reaction! Greetings from lower Saxony Germany!

  • @raderadumilo7899
    @raderadumilo7899 Год назад +1

    Monument to the "Unknown Hero" on mount Avala just south of Belgrade was built after WWI. It was built, however, at the spot where Austrians had built a small monument to a hero they encountered. Their advance was halted by very precise gunfire, and they had to wait for the heavy artillery to deal with the shooter. When they got there, they found out that it was a 15 year old boy that was holding up the entire regiment. They buried him together with the artillery shell casing that killed him, and built a small monument.
    Later in the 1930s a huge mausoleum was built as a monument to all the heroes of the Great War.

  • @ThePhoenixAscendant
    @ThePhoenixAscendant Год назад +1

    Good sir, you got my subscription when you named the young fallen with such loss. Your heart is a deep well and I feel I will come to learn much about The Great War.
    In regards to this song, Good Gods above... I'm gonna need to grab a box of tissues to watch this...

  • @No-nonsense-lady
    @No-nonsense-lady Год назад +1

    Thoroughly enjoyed your commentary. Thank you

  • @matthewarsenault463
    @matthewarsenault463 4 месяца назад +3

    I know you love history when you can feel for the people you never met they're not just characters in a movie they had real dreams they wanted a future that was stolen from them

  • @seansteele1335
    @seansteele1335 Год назад

    Very powerful. I only just recently found your reactions to Sabaton. A band I loved in College what feels like so many years ago now. As a History major myself their music often resonated with me. It is a great joy to be suddenly reintroduced to them again as I make my slow way through all your old videos. Keep doing what your doing. I enjoy very nearly every video you do, for those I don't, that is more a mater of the gravity of the topic than your presenation of it. Just hard to enjoy learning some of the story you tell. Though it is important for us all to hear and remember them.

  • @Buzzed720
    @Buzzed720 Год назад +1

    I live in Accrington, and we have huge artwork on buildings. There is also a still picture of the Accrington Pal on one of the buildings showing all the soldiers dated 1916 before they went to the Somme.

  • @saintbutters
    @saintbutters Год назад +3

    I love this tribute so much because it does right by the song and there are so many references to others songs and stories that sabaton has told its truly amazing. I also cried my eyes out when I watched this video for the first time.

  • @Skykilla21
    @Skykilla21 Год назад +1

    Absolutely love the reaction, and love the song. As a history buff and someone serving, with family in the services, it hits home. I plan to visit many of the sites from Normandy to the Argonne during my time in Europe to try and encapsulate the memory of the fallen. Love your videos.

  • @rudolphaswad8723
    @rudolphaswad8723 9 месяцев назад +1

    probably watched the music video 10 times and it still gets me

  • @67Spectre
    @67Spectre 9 месяцев назад +1

    I really enjoy seeing a reaction video done by someone who has historical knowledge about The Great War. Another singer who wrote some very deep songs about World War I is Eric Bogle. I would love to see a reaction video to “And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda”, “As if He Knows”, or “No Man’s Land”(also covered very well by Dropkick Murphys

  • @TheLibermania
    @TheLibermania Год назад +3

    I went to a Sabaton concert this monday. They did that again. It's so atmospheric.

  • @brendanhart517
    @brendanhart517 Год назад +3

    The detail in this video is incredible, the motorhead tribute, the different uniforms that are still recognisable, i managed to pick an australian uniform, the woman who steps out of the alley is in a russian uniform and looks up at the planes is a reference to night witches. This video is powerful and Sabaton is so good at this stuff, the history, the rtespect the emotion

    • @1972jonboy
      @1972jonboy 5 месяцев назад

      The woman from the alley is not in a Russian uniform but a British uniform of the Women's auxiliary territorial service ATS (( Princess Elizabeth was one of many women who were part of this vital service) she is named in the credits at end as ATS Ivy Valentine

  • @Templarofsteel88
    @Templarofsteel88 Год назад +1

    The two guys at 6:24 are Mikkey Dee and Phil Campbell, the drummer and the guitarist of Motörhead. The picture is of Lemmy Kilmister, the bassist and singer of Motörhead.

  • @christiancleofas7451
    @christiancleofas7451 Год назад +1

    Regardless of how tough or how resistant you are to tearjerkers. There would be something to tug your heartstrings. And this does it for some. Imagine the lives lost, futures ruined, and memories forgotten by the senseless act that happened.

  • @nashtheneet
    @nashtheneet Год назад +1

    Yes those are 2 members of Motorhead, and the picture they were holding was of Lemmy Kilmister, who passed away in 2015 and he wrote this song back in the 90s

  • @music2seeconcertphotograph457
    @music2seeconcertphotograph457 Год назад +2

    I was accredited as photographer at the Sabaton concert in Hannover last week. I am just having a break from selecting the photos and what could be better, than a reaction video to Sabaton?
    1916 was live also extremely powerful. It gave me goosebumps and also wet eyes within the pit.
    Just like Christmas Truce, where they had a burning piano on stage, Tommy standing on it. It gave me an already now favorite shot of mine.

  • @kaisersoze3604
    @kaisersoze3604 Год назад

    Just found you and I like your stuff cause this really hits, especially what the young people back then had to go thru to fight for what they believed in....it's sad how many young lives were lost

  • @mikepenny8940
    @mikepenny8940 Год назад

    Thank you so much for doing a react to this. Im a huge Sabaton fan and I enjoy your videos. Im looking to start pursuing my history studies in a few month. Keep up the great work.

  • @JuleyC
    @JuleyC 5 месяцев назад +1

    I really like how they included representations of people from all different culture groups ie punks, rockers, hippies, the general folk of a city most in period clothing from the early 1910's. To think many of the wives who lost their husbands in WW1 lost their sons in WW2, and then the next generation repeated with Vietnam and it's continued to this day :(

  • @kitsune303
    @kitsune303 Год назад +1

    3:53 Notice the snake shoulder patch of the Harlem Hellfighters

  • @thekeenmoron1900
    @thekeenmoron1900 Год назад +1

    I was at the Leeds gig and it was frigging awesome.

  • @MrSapperb3
    @MrSapperb3 10 месяцев назад

    I live in Burnley, a town next to Accrington. The Burnley Pals are still very much remembered here, they’ve even got a separate memorial behind our cenotaph, and every time I go through Accrington on the train I give a nod to the huge mural they’ve got in the town centre. Such an insane thought that my town and others had an entire generation of men gone in an instant, it’s impossible to imagine. But it’s part of our local and indeed world history that we are enormously proud of.

  • @nigelmullen9546
    @nigelmullen9546 Год назад +1

    I was at the Sabaton concert in Leeds and heard them sing it for the first time, being a massive motorhead fan I knew it word for word.

  • @CosmosJack
    @CosmosJack Год назад +1

    I've seen comments elsewhere about WW1 veterans who lived long enough to hear this song themselves.
    Lemmy (from Motorhead) was a phenomenal songwriter and very well-read in history; he would often talk about how "a whole generation died" on that first day at the Somme.
    "Death or Glory" is another Motorhead song that captures the universality of a soldier's experience, listing many pivotal battles (though the song is less somber).
    Great reaction Chris!!

  • @johnhavardvalebrokk6151
    @johnhavardvalebrokk6151 Год назад +1

    6:28 Yes, my friend. Those are the last 2 remaining living Motörhead members. Mickey Dee (drummer) and Phil Campbell (guitarist) who aren't original members, but remained in Motörhead until Lemmy died.

  • @matthewhawkins1990
    @matthewhawkins1990 Год назад +1

    I was there when the music video was shot, it was shot partly on the Tipton Road Dudley, Black Country Living Museum. And they met Mickey Dee and Phil Cambell the last members of Motörhead in Birmingham.
    Sabaton were all gentleman! And we saw them play in Cardiff.

  • @woogieonaboogie928
    @woogieonaboogie928 Год назад +1

    I had the honor of seeing Sabaton live just yesterday evening, and this was one of the songs they performed.. It is truly emotional as it is, listening to it digitally, but the impact it had in person was just.. I can’t even describe it.

  • @undertakernumberone1
    @undertakernumberone1 Год назад +5

    1) maybe try the original as well at some point. Lemmy's voice just hits different.
    2) Try Running Wild's Songs "Little Big Horn" and "Waterloo" at some point, please. Basically Proto-Sabaton

  • @CrafoordV
    @CrafoordV Год назад +1

    I think this is what i find so beautiful with Sabaton. With songs like these, they remember all these people. All the sacrifices, even the more obscure battles that many might not have heard about. They give a space for that to be remembered and talked about. Not to mention all the people who learned things they didn't know before, thanks to songs (and reaction videos) like these.
    As a European myself, what i learned in school were the most basic in coverage of the First and Second WW. The rest, i can confidently say i learned from Sabaton

  • @Franzen90
    @Franzen90 Год назад +1

    The two guys that walk out from the bar are the guys from Motörhead. Drummer Mikky Dee and guitarist Phil Campbell.

  • @elvwood
    @elvwood Год назад +2

    I was at that Leeds concert, the first night of the tour, and it was so emotional. So let's raise a few glasses: to Birmingham, birthplace of metal; to Lemmy (RIP); to Sabaton; and to those who sacrificed so much. My wife's grandfather was one of those who lied about his age - he was only _14_ when he went to the Front! He got out alive, thanks to some amazing luck: he was wounded and taken to a field hospital, and his own father was there at the same time. He swore a lot when he saw his son, then wrote to his wife back home explaining the situation. She in turn sent evidence of their boy's age to the War Office and they pulled him out (one of my wife's relatives still has the letters). After he came home he never spoke to anyone in the family about his experiences. Greetings from South Yorkshire - Lest We Forget.

  • @CosmosJack
    @CosmosJack Год назад +1

    From Lemmy's autobiography:
    "I wrote the words [to '1916'] before I wrote the music. It's about the Battle of the Somme in World War I . . . it happened that I was in England, watching a programme about World War I and I had a brainstorm when they got to the Battle of the Somme. Nineteen thousand Englishmen were killed before noon, a whole generation destroyed, in *three hours* -- think about that! It was just terrible -- there were three or four towns in northern Lancashire and south Yorkshire where that whole generation of men were completely wiped out. And those towns are still suffering from it because they were never able to build their population up again. Places like Accrington, in Lancashire, were fucking destroyed. They brought five old guys back to the battlefield in this TV special. One guy, who was about ninety, said 'They told us to walk, not run, and we walked across and all the lads around me laid down. I thought there might have been an order from the rear that I hadn't heard. And then I realized they were all dead.' It's a case of the English killing more Englishmen than the Germans. Hindenberg, who later became president of Germany, said, 'They were lions lead by donkeys.' So I wrote a song about it. But I do have a lot of ambivalence about that tune. This kid wrote to me and said he played it for his grandfather, who was there, and the old man cried all the way through it. That's a very great compliment, but I'm not sure I like the guy feeling that bad for my gratification. It's an amazing thing to have happen, though, to reach back over all those years and touch somebody like that."
    -Lemmy Kilmister (with Janiss Garza)
    White Line Fever
    2002

  • @RedLogicYT
    @RedLogicYT Год назад +1

    What a beautiful and sad cover. Thanks for reacting to this! Rest in peace all those who fought in the great war.

  • @MRKBDY
    @MRKBDY Год назад +2

    Thank you for a reaction that adds context & respect to this heartbreaking song. I prefer the bleakness in Lemmy's voice, but also appreciate the important information that Sabaton include in their video.
    One vital part of the lyrics that I think people skip over & miss is "though it wasn't my fault and i wasn't to blame". The kind of thing a kid gets upset over when getting told off, but also the real truth of war. The young die & the people to blame are the kings, queens, politicians & dictators who start & maintain conflict for their own ends. Tragic.

  • @lucretialee3691
    @lucretialee3691 Год назад +1

    I remember as a child my Grandmother and Mother showing me this large and very thick book kept in a glass case in our local library, in it was all the names of the local men who had died in WW2. It became a game to a small child to see on each visit if the page with my Grandfather's name was the one showing.
    I had to become an adult to understand that name was all they had of him, no grave, no body, no proper idea of where his ship had actually sunk.

  • @Spook_Boi
    @Spook_Boi Год назад +2

    2:35 in a recent documentary, the actor of the first soldier you see in the brody helmet said that his character Private Sydney Lewis was 12 years old. also i feel like Joakim was meant for this song. he sung it beautifully and with enough heart to pull the air outta my lungs

  • @markbro4427
    @markbro4427 Год назад

    That was Motorhead drummer Mikkey Dee (now in The Scorpions) and Motorhead guitarist Phil Campbell in the video carrying Lemmy's picture.

  • @tylerlucas3752
    @tylerlucas3752 Год назад +8

    I got choked up listening to these lyrics and listening to your commentary. It’s very emotional and that’s one of the things I have always loved about history is that it makes you want to remember and never forget not just the important dates or the important events… but all those who time may have forgotten, but you never will.

  • @MulleDullen
    @MulleDullen Год назад +1

    I just saw them live in Copenhagen, amazing experience. Sabaton does a great job at telling these stories. Lest we forget.

  • @arturfilipecastanha580
    @arturfilipecastanha580 Год назад +1

    Hey yeah they were mickey dee and phil cambell they were the last members of motorhead to play with lemmy, a moving tribute

  • @DocStrange0123
    @DocStrange0123 Год назад

    No matter how many times I listen to this song and/or watch that video, that my eyes get, at the very least, bright with unshed tears, and my throat full of emotion. It happens every single time.

  • @pinkpolo97
    @pinkpolo97 Год назад

    I love the call back to all the songs they've done. Being English and from the North. I can help but 😢 up every time I hear this song. Some of the towns around where I live lost full generations in both wars.

  • @JorgentheBraggart
    @JorgentheBraggart Год назад

    Welcome back to the rabbit hole, Chris. It's been a long time since u react to them.

  • @ATFaris
    @ATFaris Год назад

    I usually listen to Sabaton with the videos in the background. I always watch your reaction and your heart breaking did the same for me. Thank you!

  • @zacharycardenas353
    @zacharycardenas353 8 месяцев назад

    Phi Campbell and Mikke Dee were in the video of the two Surviving members of Motorhead and their tour Manager.

  • @AronLeonard
    @AronLeonard Год назад +1

    I was at the show in Leeds and it was a powerful song with Joakim singing and the lone drummer. I've not heard the moterhead song however so I must check that out at some point

  • @isaacbobjork7053
    @isaacbobjork7053 Год назад +1

    Yeah we saw Mickey Dee there, drummer of Motörhead and fellow Swede as well

  • @brianhuss9184
    @brianhuss9184 Год назад +1

    I was hoping that you'd do a reaction to this video. Well done as always. But I expect nothing less from a fellow Buckeye!
    I thought it was very cool of Sabaton to include a Gurkha. Those guys are likely the finest soldiers in the world.
    They show SGT Henry Johnson of the Harlem Hellfighters at 3:53 in your video. You can see their rattlesnake patch and he's identified in the credits.

  • @gryphonosiris2577
    @gryphonosiris2577 Год назад +9

    All of the soldiers they highlight on in the video are based on real people. Not counting the Knights and the Spartans, so far I've come up with:
    The soldier pulling himself out of the mud, at first I thought he was a member of "The Smoking Snakes" (Força Expedicionária Brasileira, FEB, nicknamed Cobras Fumantes), but doing some more research with the patch on his shoulder as well as his helmet, that's Sgt Henry Johnson of the 15th New York National Guard Regiment, aka "The Harlem Hellfighters". Medal of Honor recipient and recipient of French Croix de Guerre avec Palme, France's highest award for valor. The Medal of Honor was awarded to him in 2015.
    Sgt. Henry Johnson is "one of the five bravest American soldiers in the war."
    Theodore Roosevelt Jr. in his book "Rank and File: True Stories of the Great War"
    The Asian soldier with the cocked-hat, that's a Nepalese Gurka named Havildar Gurung (per the credits) who earn the Victoria Cross in the Burma campaign off WWII.
    Sgt Awal Nur, belonged to the most famous Indian Army regiment of 1914-18, Queen Victoria's Own Corps of Guides. He served in Belgium, France and East Africa from 1914 to 1917, and he was wounded three times. But his most extraordinary exploit was on His Majesty's secret service. Nur was one of 16 Indian soldiers specially chosen to join British officers on a secret Indian Army mission into Soviet Central Asia in early 1918. On the direct orders of London, the mission's goal was to stop Soviet resources in Central Asia from reaching the Germans by railway and the Caspian Sea.
    Lt. Audie Murphy the highest decorated soldier in US history who served in WWII.
    Sgt. Alvin York a humble man from Tennesse who was awarded the Medal of Honor in WWI for exceptional bravery under fire.
    Private McNamara was 101st Airborne, Silver star awarded due to actions during the Battle of the Bulge.
    I also notice a soldier with the Croix Lorraine on what looks like a French flag arm band, meaning he was a member of the 'Forces françaises libres' forces in WWII. Doing some reading I found out that a large number of French colonial troops from territories such as Chad and Senegal had joined with the 'Forces françaises libres'. Damn, Sabaton REALLY does their research! I suspect that soldier is Lt Comba, but I can't find anything on him.
    ATS Ivy Valentine is coming up on a dead end, I found that the ATS (Auxiliary Territorial Service) was the British version of the American WAC's, but I cannot find anything about her name.
    As I've been working my way through the names listed in the credits and found another one: Private George Stringer, Manchester, Awarded the Victoria Cross at the Battle of Es Sinn in Mesopotamia.
    Capt. Dobson, 1st Canadian Infantry Battalion, Killed on 9 July 1916 in Flanders.

  • @perhaps_a_pikmin
    @perhaps_a_pikmin Год назад +13

    Someone please give Chris a tissue. The song was moving enough, but seeing Chris tearing up moved me alot more.

  • @neoburst1
    @neoburst1 Год назад +1

    recently seen them play live in Glasgow they played this at that concert, as you say its just such a powerful song and lyrics

  • @richardmardis2492
    @richardmardis2492 Год назад

    You such a good man- I was getting choked up to❤️🫡

  • @nickshaffer9961
    @nickshaffer9961 Год назад +2

    Wow this song and video hit hard. Completely agree with you. WWI was such a waste of life for nothing. Thank you for continuing to bring these men’s stories to light as we try to never forget them

  • @Thandar324
    @Thandar324 Год назад +1

    Yes, they were from Motorhead (Those guys in the door)

  • @RichardAndewSwayne
    @RichardAndewSwayne Год назад +1

    I saw them two weeks ago at Wembley. They were awesome.
    Is it weird that I took my friend to the Imperial War Museum before the show?

  • @Zeraphim
    @Zeraphim Год назад +5

    I'm from Sweden like they are and there are so many of their songs that just make me choke up and actually cry when i see their videos. They do the horrors of war so much justice in how they present the story and the amount of detail and emotion they put in. Sabaton is a band that is needed so people continue to remember the horrors of the past. Lest We Forget.

  • @ghostdestiny1
    @ghostdestiny1 Год назад +1

    Chris,just discovered your channel,your deep respect you show to the fallen touches me immensely, I have on my mantle piece a photograph of my great uncle Edward mark, he looks no more the a school boy in uniform,no wonder for his determination to join his 4:brothers in the East Kent buffs meant he lied about his age,he was in truth just 16 years old,he was gassed in the battle of mons , returning home where he died shortly after, as his mother,my great great mother wept by his bedside he told her ,do not grieve mother ,I'm lucky to die here at home unlike my pals. This was related to my by his sister ,my great gran.on my birth she asked my mum would she name me after him,we already had 3 Edwards in the family so I was given his middle name,of the of the 7 great uncles that went of to war only 3 returned, Harry died along side his brother Frank at Ypres, Great uncle Arthur lost his life at the Somme Aged only 19, I have a letter given to my mother,it is from Arthurs best pal informing Arthurs mother how he was always the life and soul of the regiment,and describes the moment he lost his life, it was quick and he did not suffer,he describes how they went over the top together he says how one moment Arthur was by his side," I looked to the left for but a moment, but when I looked back to where Arthur had been,he was gone, every November I attend remembrance Day service, standing before the war memorial, their names engraved on the monument I reflect on what lives they may have led .

  • @micke20
    @micke20 Год назад

    6:25 is Mikkey Dee. A swedish formerna drummer for motörhead from 1992 to 2015 on the left. The other guy on the right I have no who he is

  • @autumnwolfe9105
    @autumnwolfe9105 Год назад +1

    I was at that concert, everyone felt this song on some level ❤

  • @kingwacky184
    @kingwacky184 Год назад

    8:42 I have researched names and written down the names of those you mentioned that you visited the grave of Horace Iles and Valentine Strudwick. I wrote down those names and I will keep doing my research to get as many names as I can. To me they will NEVER be forgotten.

  • @joacimfrobom7057
    @joacimfrobom7057 Год назад

    Loved your reaction❤️. Many boys/ men did’nt die from their wounds but drowned in the mud at the Battlefield, what a horrific way to die😢. Please react to Sabaton” no bullets fly” and ” uprising live in Poland ” so amazing!!

  • @MultiLeonard1000
    @MultiLeonard1000 Год назад

    Thank you for doing videos like these. I feel like ww1 is one of our least talked about wars and the care and attention you put into really resonates with me. I know all wars are full of tragedy, but this one really does feel the most tragic the more I learn about it

  • @pleasehelp2446
    @pleasehelp2446 Год назад +1

    The men around the photo of Lemmy were his band mate's, the young woman was Lemmy's daughter.

  • @alancarter41
    @alancarter41 Год назад

    A phenomenal tribute to both Lemmy and all the soldiers throughout history who marched off to fight, and maybe die, for their homeland. RIP, you are missed and appreciated.

  • @Jonno_B251
    @Jonno_B251 Год назад

    I hadn’t heard this song for ages, it popped into my head today and I find out sabaton released a cover and VTH reacted to it all around winning.
    And yes you’re right that is Mikkey Dee and Phil Taylor of Motörhead fame

  • @YourAverageKriegsman
    @YourAverageKriegsman Год назад

    Another song they released was 'the price of a mile,' which goes more into what you said about 300k men and boys dying for six miles of mud. So much carnage and bloodshed, just to move six miles

  • @foxalpha09
    @foxalpha09 Год назад +1

    With 1916, no one can say Sabaton glorifies war anymore.
    War will not change, but let's hope we do for the better.
    After all, all the fighting leaves us with Ash, empty seats at the dinner table and rooms never to be used or entered ever again.

  • @johnrust592
    @johnrust592 Год назад

    Trying to put that first day of the Somme into perspective, I think about the town next door to where I live, population around 11,000. So it's basically think of everyone in that town suddenly killed, and tack on an extra 8,000 lives, and that's the first day of the Somme. Almost inconceivable.

  • @NBM3
    @NBM3 Год назад

    Yes ,that is Phil and Mikky the remaining members of the last lineup of MOTORHEAD.

  • @swenartmann1670
    @swenartmann1670 Год назад

    Great reaction. Greetings from Germany

  • @Mr.Korzack
    @Mr.Korzack Год назад +1

    I love how authentic this version is compared to Motorhead's original, I remember seeing them playing this on tour & it made me an emotional wreck... Only thing I'd slight the Sabaton version for is the final line feels more triumphant Vs. Lemmy's line. Nit-picks aside, this was so well done and credit to Sabaton for doing this song right

  • @hellhoundactual8201
    @hellhoundactual8201 11 месяцев назад

    The Night of July 1st 1916 is a date of Infamy for my Family.
    My Great Great Grandfather was a Lieutenant in the 1st Newfoundland Regiment "Blue Puttees"
    On the Night of July 1st 1916, after a harsh day of fighting, They went over the Top at Beaumont Hamel with 1070 men.
    By 8am the next day, He and 64 came back. 1000 men Slaughtered by Hun Machine Guns, Veteran Riflemen, And Grenadiers.

  • @Hyper_Blue358
    @Hyper_Blue358 Год назад

    In finland we have almosti in every church and cemetary a headstone for those buried elsewhere