Edward Teller - Discussing the atomic bomb with Leó Szilárd (63/147)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 64

  • @MikeBenko
    @MikeBenko 6 лет назад +96

    That generation of scientists was some sort of miracle into itself. Einstein, Teller, Szilard, Fermi, Neumann, Ulam etc.

    • @willthacker5182
      @willthacker5182 5 лет назад +21

      Ive often thought about that myself. What makes it even more astonishing is how many of the brilliant ppl all came from the same general region of Austria-Hungary, and regions near germany, during the first world war era. What was in the water over there for the 25yrs of the 1900's?!? Having so many revolutionary minds from the same generation is amazing, but having all them born in the same geographical region is a true miracle!! Makes me wonder what discoveries were lost to mankind as a result of all the ppl killed during ww1, who also shared the gift of a brilliant mind!

    • @gabrielgonzalez1993
      @gabrielgonzalez1993 5 лет назад +1

      Will Thacker yes you are very right. It’s so sad to think of all the wasted human potential. But it is up to us to push science forward.

    • @agnezabarutanski1963
      @agnezabarutanski1963 3 года назад

      @@willthacker5182 Tesla smokes them all. Not a single destructive invention, only brilliant stuff that gave the entire human race a gigantic push forward. Tesla was also born in the Austria-Hungary, by the way, only some 50 years before the 'nuclear' generation.

    • @kurtvonfricken6829
      @kurtvonfricken6829 2 года назад

      @@agnezabarutanski1963
      What is a “ destructive invention”?

    • @cylersmiley5259
      @cylersmiley5259 2 года назад

      @@agnezabarutanski1963 I completely 100% agree with you. Someone asked Einstein what’s it like to be the smartest man in the world and he said I don’t know ask Tesla.

  • @harryh4398
    @harryh4398 5 лет назад +20

    He places Szilárd even above Von Neumann? Wow!

    • @g.l.5072
      @g.l.5072 Год назад

      *cringe*

    • @attilaosztopanyi9468
      @attilaosztopanyi9468 8 месяцев назад

      Neumann made the digital computer and binar language.
      Szilárd made research in fission reactions, the nuclear power plant, particle accelerator and the electro microscope.

  • @deeprollingriver5820
    @deeprollingriver5820 5 лет назад +4

    I can’t remember what I ate yesterday much less remember every day of my life

    • @BizarreIoveTriangle
      @BizarreIoveTriangle 2 года назад +1

      Teller surely forgot more amazing stories than most people will ever experience, his life was just that dense

  • @rotfogel
    @rotfogel Год назад +13

    As more time goes on, and the more research I do, it was, indeed, Leo Szilard's idea to create a Nuclear bomb. It was his and his alone initially, perhaps for the first 3 or 4 years after he thought about an atom splitting. I researched and found Szilard would talk his mouth off at conferences he wasn't invited to and all he talked about was how a split atom could produce a weapon. It truly is Leo Szilard's 'invention'. God Bless Fermi, Oppenheim et all, they each got WAY WAY WAY too much credit when compared with Szilard with regard to the creation of the nuclear bomb. It's almost all Szilard. He has been forgotten by history while they have not, but it was all Szilard's idea initially.

  • @anakarinatanabe
    @anakarinatanabe 3 года назад +1

    Everything happens for a reason, and we still need to applause them, though we need to think many times about what this reason is for our Planet's sake; for the future, now is the time to heal.

  • @kurtvonfricken6829
    @kurtvonfricken6829 2 года назад +2

    Does he call John von Neumann “Johnny” von Neumann???

    • @buckhorncortez
      @buckhorncortez 2 года назад +8

      Everyone who was a contemporary of Von Neumann and knew him called him "Johnny." That was his "nickname" used by people who were friends of his.

    • @domonkosg562
      @domonkosg562 Год назад +3

      He was only Jancsi in Hungary. Neumann János from Budapest.

  • @aigerimzhaksylyk6217
    @aigerimzhaksylyk6217 5 лет назад +3

    Is Leo developer of first nuclear fission?

    • @freexky
      @freexky 4 года назад +1

      No, he took the idea from H.G. Wells - The world set free

    • @buckhorncortez
      @buckhorncortez 2 года назад +5

      Szilard was crossing a street and in his own description said that between the time the light turned green and he began to cross the street and the light turned red when he reached the other side, he had worked out the idea of nuclear fission. That is, neutrons doubling each time they hit another atom and releasing more neutrons, each time releasing huge amounts of energy. The idea of a nuclear bomb was obvious to every physicist who understood the fission process. Szilard read the H.G. Wells story and the idea of a bomb and its possible consequences became part of his life to the point he spent most of his efforts towards nuclear arms reduction and elimination of nuclear weapons. Szilard wrote, "Voice of the Dolphins: and Other Stories" which was an allegory for the elimination of nuclear weapons.

    • @rotfogel
      @rotfogel Год назад

      Well, kind of, he certainly is the first to think of the use of a weapon WAY before anyone even dreamt about it, probably by like 5 years or so.

    • @hcronos
      @hcronos Год назад +1

      Fermi created the first chain reaction in nuclear fission

    • @attilaosztopanyi9468
      @attilaosztopanyi9468 8 месяцев назад

      ​@@hcronoswith Leo Szilárd.

  • @richardthompson5892
    @richardthompson5892 2 года назад +5

    I do not believe Fermi was Jewish. His wife however. was Jewish.

  • @balintkovacs8045
    @balintkovacs8045 2 года назад +10

    hajrá magyarok

  • @sjm8510
    @sjm8510 Год назад +5

    Hungarian is not just a language, it is the ultimate tool to truly open your mind and take it miles beyond your believed maximum potential. It has to be the language of Gods. I know a few languages, even speak some fluent, but none of them open my mind as the Hungarian.

    • @hhgygy
      @hhgygy Год назад +8

      It's bullshit, man. And I'm a native Hungarian speaker.

    • @Rubenso976
      @Rubenso976 6 месяцев назад

      I’m Hungarian, and this is nonsense

  • @markusweissenbock6337
    @markusweissenbock6337 6 лет назад +3

    They changed the world probably more like Jesus did...

    • @robertoppenheimer8976
      @robertoppenheimer8976 5 лет назад +1

      Jews always changed the world.
      Jesus,
      These scientists
      ISRAEL herself is blooming the deserts

  • @robertoppenheimer8976
    @robertoppenheimer8976 5 лет назад +6

    All Jews. And am not anti-Semitic here

    • @balintkovacs8045
      @balintkovacs8045 2 года назад +10

      all Hungarians brother

    • @VideoNOLA
      @VideoNOLA Год назад +2

      Both the Jewish and the Hungarian traditions include a deep and abiding respect for lifelong education, moral inquiry, and furtherance of the communal good.

    • @tomaspabon2484
      @tomaspabon2484 5 месяцев назад

      Fermi wasnt jewish, heck most of the manhattan project wasnt

    • @robertoppenheimer8976
      @robertoppenheimer8976 5 месяцев назад

      @@tomaspabon2484 search for " Jewish bomb" and you will be shown nuclear weapons. What does that mean?

    • @janoycresva276
      @janoycresva276 4 месяца назад

      @@tomaspabon2484 most of the MP WAS Jewish actually

  • @Kacee70
    @Kacee70 3 года назад +5

    Incredible, the comments here. This guy was reprehensible: pushed the creation of something that can obliterate humanity in a blink (and did, twice), even lying when he needed to push his own agenda. Even nature tried to stop him in his tracks...unfortunately he only lost a foot. Sobering to note that the focus is oh, how brilliant he was. His work created death. As for the wonder that so many scientists came from one region, there was nothing better to do - no distraction of Internet and TV, unfortunately just ego. If you're brilliant but can't see beyond promoting your own imagined grandeur, your brilliance is nothing. The other cursed one was Szilard who took the imaginings of a novelist to bring into being that which could annihilate us in a blink. What skewed focus is revealed here! Someone wrote: "But a 1949 committee of scientists, led by Oppenheimer, declared the Super both unnecessary and immoral. To Teller, this was dangerous advice. With the Cold War pulsing about them, Truman, at Teller's urging, overruled the scientific committee and went ahead with development of the fusion bomb. Teller contributed still-secret work on the design." They're still trying today to stop nuclear development, with good reason. Only a matter of time before another ego-maniac is in control of it.

    • @kurtvonfricken6829
      @kurtvonfricken6829 3 года назад

      You live in a fantasy world. The atom bomb saved millions of lives. There was no internet in the 1940s so of course it was not a distraction.

    • @VishaalKapoor
      @VishaalKapoor 2 года назад +15

      It seems your comments on Szilard's personality are misguided by an inaccurate account of history. Szilard ideated the bomb but didn't publish it until the German scientists were successfully bombarding U-235 albeit unsuccessfully (using contaminated graphite as housing). Szilard wrote his beliefs in a 10 commandments list - read them to understand why he didn't care about feelings. You should dig deeper on history as well as what Szilard did. On why he and Fermi were motivated to prove the bomb could be built as it seemed tragically inevitable that it would be needed as the German scientists discovered how to split the atom. How when Germany was beaten, how he pushed that the US not use the bomb on Japan, proposing if it must be used to demonstrate power, to let Japan know they would bomb one of ten or so cities ahead of time, but not which one, so that those cities could be evacuated of people. Roosevelt died, and Truman took over. Leo petitioned Truman but he was not heard. Szilard was pushed out of the Manhatten Project by General Groves and wasn't involved in the science lead by Oppenheimer ("I am destroyer of worlds"). Oppenheimer convinced Teller to ignore Szilard's petitions as well, thinking civilians didn't have enough information to make such decisions and that Szilard was abusing his fame as a scientist by trying to change history. Cheers

    • @stratovation1474
      @stratovation1474 Год назад +10

      The Einstein letter was written by Szilard who was a founder of the Union of Concerned Scientists and had turned against nukes as had most of the scientists at the end of the war. Szilard was ahead of everyone almost always. Groves hated Szilard. Nuff said.

    • @rajuaditya1914
      @rajuaditya1914 Год назад

      You are an illiterate idiot.

    • @tomaspabon2484
      @tomaspabon2484 5 месяцев назад

      This is a stunningly ignorant take. Szilard didnt invent anything, he diacovered a basic fucking fact about nuclear physics. He then extrapolated from that than huge ammounts of energy might be created. Any form of power generation can be a weapon its not his fault that nuclear chain reactions are a thing